Graphes parfaits : structure et algorithmes
Nicolas Trotignon
To cite this version:
Nicolas Trotignon. Graphes parfaits : structure et algorithmes. Autre [cs.OH]. Université JosephFourier - Grenoble I, 2004. Français. �tel-00008558�
HAL Id: tel-00008558
https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00008558
Submitted on 23 Feb 2005
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
!#"%$'&)(*+!-, /.102!10
35G8<+468AK79J 684=8:[email protected]; <><>7=8N/[email protected][email protected]; OQAC<+P+D7 7F<>E=G84<:8G8AC<<RTG8S84IUVH>4; N <><>68387 WYX4687/?C<>7
Z 35O[H>?\E [email protected][email protected]; O^]8_`E ;/WO>a^E ;/?Cbc6<[NBRd=feg47/a^E ;/?CbV6<
Xl 447/ama^:8E [email protected];/=?CE4;[email protected] 4I<QH><>; ;B47FjBE AC38<';/[email protected]]8a-iB?CNF<[E H ;/W?C<>47 = H W<-jB3kO>7FE ;/?C4=8=<>[email protected]<S
n o prqtsvu`w xq pyo+z{py|I}^w ~
€}#oQt‚ƒ}#to2u u„} rp 8†)‡ˆoQ|c}1st‰ u`w
Š%‹Œ Œ KyŽ‘’”“r• –Ž˜——™
š›/mœQB"Ÿž¡ *Q"¢£,¥¤F¦ ‹˜§[¨© ¦8 Œ ¨ ªM«’¬­
®‘¯ *°$^*2±³²´!#*Q0 ¯Bµ !1"¢&¶¤F˜ ‹ · Œ V­
¸’£$^0º¹ !#0 "’Q»£,¥¤ f¼“ © {k Œ V­
¸’£$^0+½I¾-Q¿¹ !1QÀ#Q{,Á¤ f¼˜“ © {k Œ M­
¹#* ¯ ± ¯ *2 šŸ$#££*°$ÄÃŤ ¨Ä© Ɣ¦f Œ ¨ ªM«Ä¬k­
ž¡*°Q›ÇBÈ±Å¤F˜ ‹ Æ Œ M­
!!"$#&%
'
()"$#&*,+-./#0 *$"
1
=
2 3 *4#0 *5"6%7+8:98;<%&
>/[email protected]> A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[N ?B?C?D?D?C?D?C?D?C?B?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B? E
>/[email protected]>/[email protected]> l WEGCF =<[N S”H W<>[email protected]=N SH)fH H>AC<[N Sf;/7 46NB<>;ÈE =V;/[email protected];/7 46N ?D?C?D?C?B?I>/>
>/[email protected]>/?KJ L IH 7FE a-?CG8<[N S387/?CN a'<[N9<>;Èbc6EN/?NKM 387/?CN/a'<[N ?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?I>&O
>/[email protected]>/?KO P
?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?I>&Q
>/?KJ A <[N E [email protected]/[email protected];/<>W8ACa'bc6<[<[N N9?DD7F?DE 38?CW?D<[N9?C3?DE ?C7/;/?B?CH>[email protected]?C?C<>?D7 N ?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?I>&R
>/[email protected]> L 7 4:8AU>T a'<[N S5E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<[N SH[4a-38AC<WfV [email protected]; O ?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?I>&E
>/?KJS?KJ A <[NÈ387 4:8AU>T a'<[N L S4X L S l 4/X L <>;YX L M H[4a-38AC<>; N ?D?C?D?C?B?ZJ/[
>/?KO iBO[N/68a'O°G8<[NÈG8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=NÈAC<[N£[email protected]£[email protected]/;FE =V; <[N ?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZJ/J
] ^ ;<_8`6%a_8;<Gbc;4d#&%
]1
[email protected]> A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[N9:EN/?Cbc6<[N ?D?C?D?C?B?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZJfe
JS?KJ A <[NÈ;/7FE[LE 6SV G8< A 4 L/g Nih ?C?D?C?B?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZJ/R
JS?KO A <[NÈ;/WO[47j>T a'<[NÈG8<G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4= ?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZJ/E
JS? k A <;/WO[47j>T a'<°eg47/;9G8<[N£D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; N ?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZO/O
JS?KQ L 7 4:8AU>T a'<[N 468LM<>7/; NÈ<>;9bc6<[N/;/?C4=N ?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZOfe
' lm;4 %[email protected];4 %
'p=
[email protected]> P 7FE 38W<[NBG8<°bV6EN ?NKM 3E 7/[email protected]; O ?D?C?B?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?qk[
[email protected]>/[email protected]> A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[NÈNFE =N£;FE 687 < E 6 ?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?qk4>
[email protected]>/?KJ A <[NBH[4=sr <[H>;/687 <[NBG8<CBt 468DVE 7 GSH ?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?qk4>
[email protected]>/?KO A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[N9:[email protected] 7/;/?CNFE =N ?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?qkJ
[email protected]>/? k u
?C?B?qkJ
OS?KJ A <[NÈD7FE 38WO><[; N9<[H>3;/E?C47 =heKE [email protected]; <[<>N£a'3<>[email protected]; 7 <[H[NB4=VG;/J 7FE Ea-H>?C;/NÈ[email protected]<[GN E =?DN£?DAC<[[email protected][email protected]=?C<W?DKM D?C7FE ?D38?DW<[?CN ?D?C?B?qk/k
[email protected]> A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[NÈG8<°_`<)cH =8?C<>A ?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?qkR
OS?KJS?KJ A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[N£eKE [email protected]:8AC<>a'<>=V;È;/7/?\E =8D68ACO[N ?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZQS>
OS?KJS?KO A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; <>a'<>=V;B47 G84=8=E :8AC<[N ?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZQ/J
OS?KJS? k A <[NÈD7FE 38W<[NBE[LM<[Ha'[email protected]=NÈG8< >&[ N 4a-a'<>; N ?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?ZQ/O
>
J
OS?KO +P O>=O>7FE [email protected]?CNFE ;/?C4=NBG8<°A\EQ=4;/?C4=YG8<°3E [email protected] <mGJ E a-?CN ?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? Qk
OSK? [email protected]> L E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=NB3E [email protected] <[N ?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? Q/Q
OS?KOS?KJ l [email protected]?CbV6<[NÈ<>=8=<>a-?C<[N ?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? Q
! +6 *$-.%&%0of#7 -.9 *
$1
[email protected]> u ?!kO>7 <>=c; <[N9387 <>68LM<[N ?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C"
? /Q
k4?KJ iÈ<[N ;/7/?CH>;/?C4=$#-G8<[N9H>A\EN N <[NÈG8<+D7FE 38W<[N93E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 N ?B?C?D?D?C?D?C?esJ
k4?KO l 47 [email protected]\E [email protected] <[NÈ<>;ÈLE 7/?\E =c; <[N968;/[email protected]<[N ?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C?esO
1 ^ G;<_`6%a+o&n %G#&! %
'<=
[email protected]> L E [email protected] <[NÈGJ E a-?CNÈN 35O[H>?\E AC<[N ?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? R/[
QS?KJ L 7 <>68LM<Gf6Y;/WO[47j>T a'< QS?KJ ?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? RS>
QS?KO l 4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[NBE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a-?Cbc6<[N ?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? E/J
QS? k l 4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[N93k46879G8<[N9N 46N M H>A\ENFN <[N9GJ)(B7/; O>a-?CN ?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? Efe
QS?KQ * WO[47jT>a'<[NÈG8<mG8O[H[4a-354N/[email protected];/?C4=h<>;93E [email protected] <[N9GJ E a-?CN ?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? E/R
lBG*5
9 ,+!%a+8:f*$"6"6;4 %&%&;4"6f
.2 - '
[email protected]> / ;FE ;ÈG8<+AKJ E 7/; ?C?D?B?C?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&[k
[email protected]>/[email protected]> P 7FE 38W<[N£eKE [email protected]:8AC<>a'<>=V;B;/7/?\E =8D68ACO[N ?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&[k
[email protected]>/?KJ iÈ<[H[4=8=E ?CN NTE =H[<G8<[N£D7FE 38W<[NÈG8<10<>7/DM< ?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&[/Q
S?KJ u O>; <[H>;/?C4=YG8<N 46NiKM D7FE 38W<[N ?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&[ [email protected]> L 7/?CN/a'<46 L cH 7FE a-?CG8< ?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&[ S?KJS?KJ L 7/?CN/a'<[NÈ3E [email protected] N ?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >/>&O
?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >/>&Q
S?KJS?KO A [email protected]=<WKM D7FE 38W<[N G8<N/68:[email protected]?CN/?C4=N£G8<
K
S?KJS? k L 7/?CN/a'<[NÈ[email protected] [email protected] N ?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&Jk
S?KO u <[N£387 4:8AU>T a'<[NYX L M H[4a-38AC<>; N ?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&Jfe
S? k iÈ<[H[4=8=E ?CNFNFE =H[<<>;9H[4AC47FE ;/?C4= ?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&O/O
S?KQ P 6<[N/;/?C4=N9468LM<>7/; <[N ?D?C?D?C?D?D?C?B?C?D?C?D?D?C?D?C?B?C?D?D?C?D?C? >&O/Q
% "6"63 2 !%
2 4' '
% 5a 6
9 8* 7p;<_8`8 2 4' '
5 ( "6+69 2
2 1
4
U
M
<
/
;
C
?
>
<
=
N
;
4
8
6
;

G
J
E
k
:
4
7
1#{7 <>a'<>7 H>?C<>7¢P+O>7FE 7 G l 47/=V6O r/4ACN<>; 07/6H[<’iÈ<[<[GmGJ E[[email protected]
G
E;<>H[68H[7<>N38S8; OUM< G8E <°=Y7FXE [email protected]/38; ; <>7B<>;ÈH[<>UM;/< ; E<°=S;/M W4A T[6N H2< ? XUM4<°67bc<>6a'<>; <>? 7 H>?C<mO>DVE AC<>a'<>=c;Ba'<[NBG8<>6SVƒ<WVE [email protected]=EGM
M
U
<
/
;
C
?
>
<
=
N
#£7 <>a'<>7 H>?C<>7a'4=m<>a-38AC40HM<>687 S·[email protected]<>7 N/[email protected]; O L ?C<>7/7 <Ä_h<>=G<T[NiM X87FE =H[<S·<>;
[email protected]<+6a'NÄ3<[N9E 7/<>;/=?CH>N 68<>[email protected]@D?UT>=7 <><>a'a'<><>=V=c; ;ÈN N 3k4=468l 7£4a'=<°N <>[email protected] <>Z7/a'H>?C<><>=V;/;/;/7 ?N\<bcG86<°<°a'bV68<>=?k<>a 7 J #QE2:8G8?CO[<>H =YWE H[7/<+DMO°;/7FGE LJ 68E [email protected] < ? 3E 7/;/?C<
M
U
<
7
>
<
'
a
>
<
7
>
H
C
?
Q
<
C
A
[
<
B
N
@
?
=
/
N
/
;
@
?
/
;
8
6
/
;
C
?
4
=
+
N
/
N
8
6
@
?
L
E
V
=
;
[
<
N
V
b
8
6
?
a
J
4
V
=
;
5
3
>
<
/
7
a
C
?
N
”
S
3
E
È
7
C
A
>
<
8
6
+
7
N
4
8
6
/
;
C
?
>
<
=
\=E =H>?C<>7 SGJ EN N/?CN/; <>7 # G8<[N9H[4=fe O>7 <>=H[<[NÈ[email protected]=V; <>7/=E ;/?C4=E AC<[N ]
`a'_ <>E ;/;/7/W?CH<>a^l E 4;/=c?CNFLMH <WWV <[N+l X44am7 N:[email protected]=68E =8; 4DM7/N/[email protected][=N N/14;/[email protected];/687/DV; E #^=8?CjBN O[:k<#<>73ÄE 74A eK0 E?H WP°<>] 7Fl E 47 G8=fNegO>S 7 ( <>=? H[Z < <>:P+Y<<[>4;M
i(Èa'? <>7/<>?CH?CN/E a^= E Rd=c=; N/<>;/A [email protected];/<>68=a; r<´[email protected] = e'J/_ [/[/E JS;/W? <>a^E ;/?CH[N S # L E AC4 (È[email protected]; 4 ] L <>7 e <[H>;P 7FE 38WN
l E4<[7 NFIE N 7 W< 4E 3+4¢Gfa'7/DV4E ==8G?CN O+0{3<>Es= 7 r E L8a-? [email protected] =r<)HIG8a'<Y4iB68l 47È;/<>W;£N H i [email protected]* GrWXZ 44a^68E=N9G<>E =„;/?C4== 4 LMR <>=a2N/;/:[email protected];/<68; J/<„[/[/e 4JS7 ?
RÄ=c4; 7 <>f7 GfN/W?CN 4H>3ƒ[email protected]@[email protected]=^=EDi77FHE 38(ÈWƒ38H>38A\[email protected]?CN H N E <[;/NÄ?C4E ==NƒGƒ4E [email protected]/[email protected];/W838a'68N; È4<>7 7/DVH>E ?C=8<>?C=N H[OB<3S E t 7ÄE _ ? eKE–? P°] [email protected]:8<>?C7/H; S
( ? 0{<>7/i7 H„<>;9X ? _ E 57F&E H1<>=hE Lc7/[email protected] J/[/[k4?
A <>[email protected]:[email protected]? hMSI<>;Ä; 468;ÄGJ E :k47 G Z [email protected] [email protected]=ƒP 7FGE M
M
U
9
<
7
>
<
'
a
>
<
7
>
H
C
?
B
<
K
A
J
[
O
c
b
8
6
@
?
5
3
<
f
G
^
6
\
A
E
k
:
4
F
7
E
;
4
@
?
7
<
LcN/;F?CE<>7-DM<9bcG868< ?ua J Eh( eK? E [email protected]; J E eK?”E [email protected]'<#:5a'O>=<[WON'\38H>?C7 <><>7a-Gf?C6^<>7 N-N 4368E;/?CN'<>=1E 6<>;’A\EG8:5<[N’47FH[E 4; =4N [email protected]<><[email protected]Ä<>G=J E <>68=;/H 7 E<[GfN’7Fa'E =c<>;^a2a':87 4<[= N
G8G8<Q<[N+NFa'4= <>amO[bc:8687 [email protected]<[3kNQ<G8S< _YAK?CJ HFO[WbV<>68A¢[email protected]_h<[email protected]ÈA\E <[7 HFGWS <>l7 H WWE <17/ACjB<[N 3kO>L 7FE E HV;/E?C4==8=<>; <>[email protected]<FS6.4X+=8D EGfXB?\ED<6 0HM7F<>E =˜68S˜=E <>[email protected] =S N/?P+bV<>67 G <
X [email protected]= MA <°J O[<>bc;B68_`[email protected]<E 687/D?C7FH[E< 38P W<[6N2)< HI<>7F;QE =8438=;/< [email protected]? a-?CNFE ;/?C4=ªH[4a2:[email protected]=E ; [email protected] < #a J EhEH[H>6<>[email protected]@[email protected]? ] (B=Gf7 gN
Z <>:h<>;2N 4=ª<>=V;/W46N/?\EN/a'<ƒH[4=N/;FE =c;Q<>;QH[4a-am68=8?CH E ;/? e _:HI7/?\E a L 7 <>?CN N/a^E =8=˜S
DLME[LM7F<>E7<[N£38H^WACbc<[<[68N£N{? D3r[7FE JE E 7 38eg?¢[email protected]<[; EN9N N 38N O'_hE 7 G8eK?CHE<'[email protected]; AC<>N4A ?=80D6867/<[ACNm<>; WS8<>bc68687 ?˜<[N E2#ƒH[4 [email protected] [email protected]<>7 <-=H A\EEƒGf387 Om7 <>H[68<>LM;/<#; <+Gf;/64W T[;/N W<O[S84<>j7 ;{T>a'a <'J E eg447/7/;?C<>G8=V;<[ON
A EQ:k4=8=<E am:8?\E =H[<mGf6ƒA\E :k47FE ; [email protected] <°=<+AC<°N <>7FE [email protected];£3EN9NTE =N{a'<[N£H[4=Gf?CN H>[email protected]<[N
;/WO[NFE 7 G8N Sc387 O[N <>=V; N{<>;3EN N O[N ] L 7FE EN/W l 468=V; HFWE a S u E[LI?CG u < eg4N N )< hMS / 7/?CH u S6 M
O
k
HF_ W4ET>=7/?C<< S A t+E E [email protected][email protected]/7 ?C<N„S P L 7F?CE[<>L7/7E < =4 A LI<>?CHa^SE [email protected] @<=S H[<>0{=c<>;ƒ=sr UVE 4a-N/; [email protected]=SÄA E O>=8L=[bV+6<?C<S{<_`>7 <[SÄGf_`W8? 4_WE E a'[email protected]\<[E GW˜SÄBX47 :5O[G8<>?CO>NF7/N/?C?KH S
_`<>=8<>7/68?CHF=8W8?C?C<>N 7 NFSE =VU;68N [email protected]?CE <>LM=ª<[HÄ_hG84<[=NH[Lc<>?CAKN/S [email protected]; Z <>[email protected]'7 N4= &] XBL ?C<>H[74GfA\E 7/N? (BVkS 35/ [email protected]/AC?C4H =8*?C48E S =8t =8<>[email protected]<>= 7 ? ’EUJ =2E ?G8<><>6´87 tBG84<[NmACN/; H[S 4l =c;F<>[email protected][email protected]>=; E N
G8<[email protected]<>[email protected] <[G848S l A g 6Gf?\E A [email protected]=8WE 7 <[N Z E AC<[N·S”P ?\EH[4a'4 kE a2:5<>[email protected]@? =4;FE a-a'<>=V; ?
83kG <<>==UVG4<E 68=VLM7 ;B<><>a'A\[email protected]<[<>NGf7 H>68O>?C7=8<O[[email protected]<DE a'6G8N<<[N/N·?H[S<>a'<>;/;; 4<°N=¶4;/W468E T[LMa-N <><+=V?+; a UV##O>J E-7 aAC<[:5'N+< <¡E7 O[6iÈN H[44<>6=68Gf3hE 7 68< E [email protected]?.;?CG8S{A O ;<Q? 4;/6s7Fr/E[4L68E 7 [email protected]ƒA’< 38k<7 [>H>; ;/6#O'E E ;/LM;FE<[[email protected]<>7 ?
V
U
m
<
7
>
<
'
a
>
<
7
>
H
C
?
Q
<
;
4
6
B
N
'
a
[
<
È
N
7
>
<
C
A
[
<
>
H
;
>
<
8
6
7
N
5
]
>
<
Y
=
8
3
7
>
<
a
C
?
>
<
+
7
@
A
C
?
>
<
h
6
8
X
7
[
O
8
G
>
O
/
7
C
?
H
_
E
57
F
&HYbc68?E
E
?
37FE E ;/7/?C;/4?C=H>[email protected]Ä3kG8O <{#me 4; 4=6G^NÄbVAC68<[N’?47 O[=cN/;¢[email protected];F<>E 7/;a-N?C38N’7 G8O[<£N <>7F=cE; H[O[H[N4?C68H>7 ? H>[email protected]/G86<[H[N’< G8iÈO>a'<[<[4G#=EN/;/387FE 7 ;/4?C3544=NFN’OÈegEG8N <[;/N£?CGfE ?Ca'<>6O>N [email protected]?C<[4N M S
<:8>; 7 <>G6J EN <[H[N-H[O>E ACO>a'7 <>O>7’[email protected]?C4H[7F<>E7/;F;/[email protected]==N’N ? E [email protected]_ DM4Hc7/7/[email protected]?\;/E W8a a'<[L N 7 ? <>_Y?CN ?CN/HFa^WE<>A=80=˜S6687/0{AC<><>;=sr EBE [email protected][email protected]= E 6A N O>N L?I[38bc7 64<3kS 4Nu O{E[G8LI<?CG =4u a <WMM
egG84<1N N G8)< OhMegS E Ä68; E N =8? = _`+<[N2?C< <Gf>?CN 7 H>S6RdNFNFN/E ?C4:k=<>[email protected]<^E[LMi <[E[H LML<1?C<><>;Q7/7 UV< O>A7 a<>'a^<1E [email protected] <ƒ<>=N/68E [email protected];Q * 4=cQ;QSH[407/[email protected]/:[email protected]; O1W< V´3<>E;QN2_`a^EW< MA
;F:kE < 3kE 46N/H[; 468 <W3 VfH[# <>A\[email protected]<>=c38;£7 O[A\NE <>=8=cDV;FE E DM;/<+?C4D= 7F? E ;/[email protected];£354687{G8<[N N/[email protected]=<>7£G8<[N{D7FE 38W8?C bc6<[N S84=V;9E 383k47/; O
¢S= \=˜Sfa'4=ƒO>3k46N < l W87/?CN/; <>[email protected]< L <>;/[email protected]; Sf=4=„a^E ;/WO>a^E ;/?CH>?C<>=8=<°a^E ?CN{AC<>;/;/7 O[<SE
<>G86<BACeK<’E 68H[4; <[68N£7FE GDMJ <Ä47/G8;/<W47 <>[email protected][email protected] <¢38WAKJ <m<>=<>N ;£<>amG8< :8a^AC<E GfA\6mEGfG87 4I<[H>N 68N <[a'N9<>G=VJ ;W< Vf353847 68<[7˜N N/AK?CJ <W4Vf= 38? 68UM7/<+DM<>LM7<>S6 GV1J [email protected]=68<Ä[email protected] E <°=cbc;/[email protected]; O<
r/< =˜J E 687FE/ ?CN r E a^E ?CN386¡a'l <>=<>7 #1? :8?C<>=´H[<-;/7FE[LE [email protected]’NFE =NmN 4=N 468;/?C<>=˜S=8?’NTE =N°=4N
<>=feKE =V; N [email protected]<S ([email protected]?CH[<°<>; [email protected][email protected]=<
U
V
°
<
;
>
<
=
E
C
?
# G8O[Gf?C<>7ÈH[<+;/7FE LE [email protected] E 6SVƒ=4am:87 <>6SV <WV8H[<>[email protected]<>=V; NÈ387 4 e <[N NF<>687 N9G8<+a^EGM
N
;/=W4O>a2a^:8E 7 ;/<?CbcG86<[<[N N bc6bV<>6AC<N`r[]{J E _h?ma'7 <>< =H[_`4=cE;/7 <>O[; N`L ; <>[email protected]?CN;`NF4E 6˜6¶S£AC_h4=8_ D‘G8_h<4Na'H[4·<[LcNY?CH>AC4?KS =8Du 6E <[=NhN <>O>; ;/S 6G8l <[4N 7/S+?E <>6 ;
0687/AC<>; ?
u <>7/=8?C<>7-GJ <>=V;/7 <ƒ<>6SV´<>=GE ; <S X7 O[G8O>7/?CH1_ E k7FE HMSa'4=ª[email protected] <[H>; <>687-G8<^;/W4T[N <S
=;/7F<-E LNFEE [email protected]£BE NFE´r E a^3E E ;/?C?CN<>=EH[N < N )< <>h ;„a^NFE1E´DGf7F?CEN 35;/[email protected];/[email protected]:8<[email protected]@[email protected]; 4O 68? 7+UA\J EE^?°a^<>6E =8A\?UE´T>7 <^HFWG8E 4==VH[;°<¡[email protected]’G8<YE1:k<>=O>H=EOWGf\7H>O ?C<>a'7 4G8= <
NF Eƒ=c;/H[7 4<^=8=a-E [email protected][email protected]<'NFE :8=?CH[<><-=feg38E 7 [email protected]; Neg4<S =r <-G8<';/?CG8<>=<[N°N D#ƒ7FE AC<-38W7 <[<>Na'3<>7 E H>7 ?CeK<>E [email protected]; GNE Gf=68N7FEAC<'=c;G8O>68;F=E <[email protected]O>J 7/68?C=4cG8O><-38?CH>N 7/[email protected];/G8?C<'bc6G8< < ?
=38A\4E ;/?C7 N <ƒ< ;/7F]fE N L4E =„[email protected][email protected]=H[4N ?Ca-N/;Fa2E =68H[=˜< S #Q354H[<°687-bV6˜NFEhJ E LML<[E H°AC<>_:687'HI7/W< ?\VfE <>a a-38L A\7 E <>[email protected]?C7 N <„N/a^<>; E =8a'=„4=7FE4AC6< N9 [email protected]=?CN/<ƒ[email protected]=68N{?£AC<><[=N >)G8kWO R M
3a^E E DM?C<[NÈNBWG8E <+68; A\<>EQa'38<>7 =V<>68;ÈLM:k<O>=GfWO6 \;/bcW6O[< 4? j7 T>a'<+eg47/;9G8<[N£D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; Nm]f;/7FE LE [email protected]˜egEN/;/?CGf?C<>S6 V
l 4=N/?CG8O>7 4=NB68= 3E HfNÈG84=c;ÈA\E'N ;FE ;/?C4= =E ;/?C4=E AC<2G8<7FEGf?C4cGf?!k6N/?C4=YLM<>68; EÆedM
eG8<[< H>; Q/<>[ 7 c68a=<¢Sce [email protected]”O[egbVE 668<>;=ACH[<><6879#BE H ;/W;/E7/[email protected]:866<’<>LI7{[email protected]@G8AC<<[NÄ?sP e 7 6O[EbV=6GQ<>=G8H[<><[6SN£VmGfLI?![email protected]@>AC<[7 <>N =VNF; 4<[=VN9;%EGO>\AC4=ƒ[email protected]=J O>O[LI<[[email protected]; G8<>7<ÄACa'<[[email protected][email protected]==SNM
;H <>W7 Ee bcO>76<><^=H[LI<[[email protected]@N AC? <^jB3=E 7Q3k68<>=ª68;-35a'[email protected]=cG8; O> [email protected]<>?CNF=ª<>7-;/WAC<#O[4387/?C7 <ƒ4:8G8AU<[T>N2a'D< 7FE338E W7-<[68N·=S 4 = [email protected];[email protected]]684; =;7 <>387 O[NF<>=V ; < S
<>G8;#<>6S4V^=yLc7 [email protected]@<>[email protected]<[?C<hN{H[G84<>7/S6 7 <[VyN/3kN 44a-=Ga'E =V<>;; N#<[N£3NFE 47^=V;£68=O>AC<[email protected]@[email protected]=D=O[<[< N£ G84<È=ra'[email protected];#[email protected]=38N{[email protected]< ; ;Q/[ ca ? l^<><G A\T[E2N#35bc4668<„7/7FEAC<[[email protected];N
G84=8=<>79AKJ 68=YG8<[N£D7FE 38W<[NÈ7 <>387 O[N <>=V; O[N H>N? M G8<[N N 46N]
"!$#&% > u <>6SV„D7FE 38W<[N
68H[4=ªa-NR 38A4; a-eK< E a'68AC<„; <>;-:8eKE ?C<><>[email protected]; ;^= A\bc=EY64e< ; 4<>7/G87a'<>bc6S<16yV << <N N/4[68a-H>7B;/a'[email protected]\LME <„<>;\N#G8D<[68N N 47 <-=VE ;#7 H>>?N7;M <>G8<[[email protected] <[?CO[N =˜NN#6J 44N =c6–S5;'AKJ=<>E 4=6=rGfH>687 74=<>[email protected]<ƒ;[email protected]?CO[[email protected]^a-' 335[< E4N 7#7/; ;FE687 <>==38H[<Y7< O[?E NF7 Z<>>=V>< ; ;68< O A?
XB4;/7 <„387 4:8AUT>a'<`GJ E <[H>;FE ;/?C4=‘G8<[N^e 7 O[bc6<>=H[<[N#7FEGf?C47 <>LI?C<>=V;1E AC47 N#´ENFN 4cH>?C<>7
#„H WEbc6<^N 4a-a'<>;2GJ 68=´D7FE 38W<'68=´=4am:87 <1<>=V;/?C<>7 H[47/7 <[N 354=GE =c; #ƒ68=<-e 7 OWM
a68bV6=y><>a'==H[<£4<am= 4:8G8am7 <<`:8N 74Gf< 7/?!O?; <{R>A7 bV<><[6=VN <;¢; SÄG8; 4<>a^6s6SrE QV 4?CN#68N 47 4a-N’=‘35a'4N <>4NF; N/[email protected]:87 EAC<><£[email protected]@; ?CG<O[N%J E DM3k<O>E [=7%H>O>; 687F<>E =7AC<£<>#°a'E H 7 <>W>=cE; ;1<bc6=a-<È<’[email protected]=8NF7 4<[email protected]([a-4?Ca'[email protected]<><><>7#;’=c;,ACGf<Y/r6'E =a^D47FamE E ?C38:8NW7 AC<<<
GJ <>=V;/?C<>7 N968;/[email protected]@?CNFO[N&) AC<[N{e 7 O[bV6<>=H[<[NÈ7FEGf?C4'N 4=c;9387 O[H>?C<>6N <[N ?
=`;/WO[47/?C<2G8<[N D7FE 38W<[N S”[email protected]; ; bc6<QGJ EN N 4IH>?C<>7È68=`=4am:87 < #^HFWEbV6<QN 4a M
a'68=1<>; 3kSc<>[email protected]„A<[H>N/68;{7/H[?C<>4668N ;/<+68a-387 ?C4 <>LI79?CG<>=VJ E;BN NFN E4I=H>?CN{<>7{G846868=; <+<°*,G8<B-/.0A\1E2-/38„7 <>]Ia-7 4?U68>T 7DM<m<ScE :838AC3<>E6 7/[email protected]? ;/? ?C4? =„l <>W8;/?C; N <+; 4W7/E?CbV:[email protected];/<°6GfG86 <
38a^7 E 4=:8G8AU>T O°a'H[<h4am] :8<>?C= <>=h>&R/G8Q/<°J H[46868=´AC<>a^687E NB;/WO>O>;Fa^E ?C<>E =V;/?C;9H>?C=<>O[=–H[<[E NFa^NFE E [email protected]; <[<>68N£7 3kS%4X8687F79E H[=4H>AC?C4N'7/?CP <>7968;/ACW8<[N{7/?C3<S%E fH E[N9LE N/[email protected];Q7£G868<W= M
Ee 7 ;/4A\E=cN{;/?UEGT>7\ < =ƒH[bc46a-<Èa2AC<[68N{=H < E =7/; <B<[NN 4e ?C6<>N=cN ;{<>=V3;ENÄ[email protected]?CN/[email protected]<B:8ACA\<[EN aSIH>J <[a'N/;<+M #GH[[email protected] <><°687bc? 6l <B<>G8;/<>; 6S< #V bV63<[E N/fH ;/N{?C4E&=ƒVH E Gf=V?32^;£68H>[email protected]=AC<<
Q
=˜;/7 J OEbV7 6<(><61GNFE E°=N%7 O>H[35<Ä4H =EN N<B3G8E OW7/\;/?C=8H>[email protected];/[email protected]@LM?C<><B7¢bcG86˜<[JN <>D= 7FE>&Ef38e/We <[ScN%bV386A\E E ==EG [email protected] (B<[N 38S35bV<>6AE <>;/; 7 <t H[E 4M68<>AC=1<>6847 =VN ;{N/G86O>2^a'N 4<>=c=S;M
;A\E 4s6 \r/D468687 7 < N ? > Z E[68LM7+<[A\H°E 68\= D68=74<-a2H>:8N? 7M G8<<[a-N N [email protected][email protected]^N SkE 4A=¡G8<ma'H[44=c68;/AC7 <>< 68687 Nm=<-] H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=´G8<[N+D7FE 38W<[NG8<
l <°D7FE 38W<°=O[H[<[NFN/[email protected]; < Q
l <°D7FE 38W<=O[H[<[N N/[email protected]; < O
H[468AC<>687 N
H[468AC<>687 N
&! #&% J V8<>a-38AC<[NÈG8<°D7FE 38W<[NBH[4AC47/?CO[NÈ438;/[email protected]^E AC<>a'<>=c;
A <-387 4:8UA T>a'<^DMO>=O>7FE AÄG8<-A\E„H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=G8<[N°D7FE 38W<[N2H[4=N ?CN/; <-G84=H^<>=AKJ EÆe M
eg3<[E H>7¢;FE 68;/=?C4<9= E 7 #^>; H <9WE=bc<£67 <m<([N [email protected]<>a'=V;.<>;r/E Ga^J 68E =?CN <mA\H[E°4a 68AC><>a'687 <9SH[G84<268ACN <>4687/7; <SM<>bc;’6<><m=-G868<>;/S6 [email protected]@V ?CNFNE 4=ca-;’68a'=-<>; =NB47a2<>:[email protected]?C7O[<N
a-H[[email protected]==8H[[email protected]^<>38E ;/A%?C4G8=–<GH[4J <>68a-AC<>3868AC74N ?CN'? l Gf<°6ª38; 7<>4a-:83UA T>N a'S <QE <E'[H>G8;F<°E ;/=?C44=–am:8G87 <'<>6e 7N O[<[bVN°6E <>38=38H[[email protected]<[?CHN E 7F;/E?C4Gf=?C4 NB38? 7F? E?;/u ?CbV<>638<[68NQ?CN ]
68AC<2=7< O[bVN 466E Gf7FE7 <Q=c;F1< E 2^[email protected]=H <+EGH[<>J Ea'=8<>==VO[;<[N <>Sc;+4<>=1=hN ;4468683 ; ([<24=8DMO>==<BO>bc7FE6˜[email protected] [email protected][email protected]; AO=˜S5J a<WVf>?Ca'N/; <+< E #^6AKH>J 68E ?C=G8<È<2a'GO>J 4;/[email protected]=<ÈE ; 3k<>468687 N7
;/<[j7N T[NTN1E HM7FO[E <[38N ?CG8]’<[7 N O[? NF4L [email protected];/7„?C4=‘H[4=cGf;6‘468387/7 =4<>:87ƒAUT>H[a'<>;/< ; < G8<YGf3? a^2^E H>[email protected]>; 7O<`[email protected]/?C?CG8<><`687 a^N„E E ?C38N138E 7 384I38H W7 4&<[VINƒ[email protected]^4=VE ;ƒ;/[email protected]>LM; <O S
DG8E=H[<>H[7/E =8O>=cAC?U;O>T>7 7 #°<><Q7FG8E E <[;/38N’?C384D=`7 7F4cE G8HF38W<[W<N£<[? a'N’3O>;/E W7/4c;/?CG8H><[68NÈ[email protected]?C<>AC<>7 =VN ;? <[XBN S4;/47 6 <9<>;/S=7FE[\L= E [email protected] A”O[N N <£[email protected]\;/E?CH[4<È=YG1< E 2^=HN¢EACH[<9<H <>E=Gf7 NF<B<+G87 <9<[N/H[;/<>7 ;/<>; N? < M
>&E/[ S l A\E 6G8< 0{<>7/DM<#EYG8OW\=8?’A\E H>A\ENFN <^G8<[N 1 B
6
8
G
>
O
8
:
8
6
Q
;
8
G
[
<
Q
N
E
8
=
=
[
O
[
<
N
$-bc68? <[N/;E 383E 7/6< 3E 7°A\EƒN/[email protected]; < H[4a-a'< 68=<-H>A\EN N <-EN N <)h DMO>=O>7FE AC<-3k4687
A\=E4bca26:8<>[email protected] AC<><Y6SACV <Y;/387FE[7 4L:8E 6SAUT>Vƒa'4<h=c;ÈG8<YO>; A\OE´H[4H[4=ACNF4E7FH>E 7 ;/O[?CNÈ4=‘E 6S3kVƒ4D687FLE E [email protected]; W<[>N9;/7 3<YE 7 7 eKO[E N [email protected]; [email protected]‘]<142^=„H 7 E<>H[=<>H[a'<>=<>NF=V<°; ? [email protected] 6<N
G8A <4·sL Q/g[/jN [hm<>E ;7/;/(È?CH>ACACW< <[VN°E N =H>G8?C<><>=V7 ;/?NZ \HFbcW867/?<[r NLM<>N/7È6874=cAC<;ÈG8N/6sO>r/a'<>; 4? =V¢;/7 = O2bV>&E/6˜RJ [email protected] A˜Sk<[_N ;£E 357/4;/[email protected] =´N [email protected]:8P AC7<°G8; N<°H WH[4<>ACAK4S 7/A ?C<>g79Nih[AC<[A N
[email protected];E <+38WG8<[<[N^N<>[email protected]@[email protected] 3egNE [email protected]; KGN'8<[<>N =ySfGf; ?3<>2^a-H>[email protected]< 35#[email protected]@A a-HI=384ACO>a-a'?\E<>A=c? ; <>Rd79ACN-<>68=#;/[email protected]@7F?CNE <>;/=c?Cbc; 6# < #mH[<>H ;/E; <6N \< =–G8<BA\E`387 a'4:8O>;/AUT>Wa'4IG8<[<N
GJ [email protected]=¢N/;F=#E :8a [email protected]@>[email protected];a'Om<B=V;68<>a'a-O>37/N{?CbcbV66< < ? l A\E 6G8< 0{<>7/DM< G8WO \=8?CN NFE [email protected];AC<[N’D7FE 38W<[N3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N [email protected]”387 4 M
[email protected]; E [email protected];]568A\E1=<'H[4H[s= 4r =s<[r/H><[;/H>68;/7 68<27 <-eg4AC7/<[; N2< H G8E <[7FN+EH>D; 7FO>E 7/38?CNFWE <[=VN+;Q33E E 7 7egE [email protected][email protected]=V; ;N <>? 7 l Gf?C<>H>[email protected];/W< ?C4M H>=?¢G8N J <-<[N N ;°46E LMN MKO>D7 7FO[E< 387 WO[<[H NmE [email protected]>=SN? MM
;/7FE =c; < ##A\E^387 <>68LM<„]53k<>=GE =V; k[ E =N S5AC<[NE 38387 4IH W<[N°AC<[[email protected]°[email protected]<>7 N <[N°4=c;O>; O
(
e
;;/7<><>=V72; O[A\<[E N 35NFE <>=7 egN%<[H>N/6;/?CH[4H =ªT[N G8?s<1A J H[68<>=7/<{;FE G[email protected]=J <>[email protected]<; HIe 3568<[; NQ38G87 4<'a2D67F<{E 383WE <[7 N·’ES [email protected]Ä< 38 7 4l 35WV4L/NTg E ;[email protected];QA˜G8] <^354AC<[68N 7%dHG8O>Ea'NFN 4<>=S7M
3<>G8=1<E 7F38EG7 [email protected]<[;/7H[N <-4?C<>[email protected]<>7E 7^N9=ACN°N <[4N^G86<[Na'N+MKD4D7F7 7FE H[E 38< 38EWW6S<[<[NÈV N+„[email protected]@a-6E N£37#E N/[email protected]<[E N^[email protected]; ACN°a'<[N£a-4&[email protected]<>[email protected]^N#G8E<[38N£6S7 VO[N/N;/Sk7/<>LM67/4LH>[email protected] =V7< ;^<[bVN£A\6E¡=E <+=353kG <>74egH68<[J L<[H>EN/;/;+?C=V4;£3k= 34? NEl N/NÈ[email protected]<>:8E ;/AC3S; << M S
Ga^E 38J EE 3868?C7N°;/4c7 H[HF<[<2WN <=˜4JEm=c<[;°N 3k; N/<>68bc7/a-6˜[email protected] ?C?##N 9A\#QG8E7<mG8\ <38=¡7 =4G8468<[amLMN<>:87+E 7 =8<>A\6S=E^YV O[35<[EN<>687 eg>&; <[E/<>H>E/68;/[7?C4NS=¡Sbc 6˜G8_hJ <268?CH= H[W<>D<>7/A;F7 [email protected]=6835<[7/< N+AC<>G8H>; A\S8<QEUMN ;/<NF7 E<[4NB= ?CN°G8XH <24W=8D<>[email protected] 38W38;<>WS868<[<>7 N N; S
_Y?CHFW<>AC< l 4=feg47/;/?KSP+O>7FE 7 G l 47/=V6O /r 4ACNƒ<>; +7/?CN/;/[email protected]=E 6 M4 LI?#E¡387 43k4N O 68=
3835A\O>E 7F=YE =c38;ƒ7 O[E H>[email protected]?C=NÈN/?<>;BG87O>O a'E [email protected]?C=VN/;;/<7 <>3k7ƒ4A\68E7BH[E 438=s38r/[email protected]<[?CH>bc;/668<>7 7 <hH[e <>4;/7/; ; <m<ha'G8O><[;/N^W4cD7FG8E <238<>W= <[N1; 4368E ; 7 <eKE [email protected]>; N=? O>7Fl E <[[email protected][email protected]#; O;/S57 <[4N?CNM
HG8W<’<>=7 H4Wa2<>:8687 7 <>NB6S=QV <°7 NO[4N/[email protected];£;FE; 4; N68?G; A < e 447 ?CNFN£bV36E<6N9[r J3E E ?I7/H[LM4<>a-=V6a'N<>#2=H[eKOE [email protected]^7 <EBE ;/:kW44[T 68N <;/[email protected]Æ7£AC<[ACN<>68HF7WN£4N?CG8<[N%O[<[<>N =-SfO>a^;FEE [email protected]<>D=V7 O;
A4#Y68LM]<>A\7/E^; NÈH[4G8=s<+/r <[A\EH>;/;/68W7 O[<24e 7/4?C<7/; G8<Q<[G8N9<[DN 7FDE 7F38E W38<[WN <[? NB3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N+O>;FE [email protected];+AKJ 68=`G8<[N D7FE =G8N 387 4:8AU>T a'<[N
=1a^E ? J/[/[/J Sc68=ƒD7 46835< G8< H W<>7 H W<>687 N _`E 7/?\E l WV6Gf=4·LIN !HMSSX <>[email protected]:5<>7/; M
ND47F=˜E 38S WL <[E NÄ683A E Z7 eK<)E IH [email protected]'; N{4<>68=17^N <>68;^[email protected]ÈE =c4;Ä:[email protected]\=Ema'* O>W;/4Wa^4cG8EN<B-38E¡7 4G83kO>4a'N O[4<È=c3;/7E OY7 lA\E¡47/H[=V46=sO/r /r<[4H>AC;/N 687 <ƒ .eg4 7/? ; l < <>G8;/;<[<N
35;/?C<>47 =hH[O[G8<£<[;/NBWDO[7F4E 7/38?CbcW6<[<9NÈ=˜3JE E°7 eK3E [email protected];N’N <>? 6#¢G8=Y<9=7 4 <>LM; <>4a2am:8:k7 O[< <ÈJ/Gf[/[email protected] [/<[J H>S ; <Èl NWc6867¢GfAC=<£4 38Lf7N 4!:8MH AUS >T l a'4< 7/=VG86<£O A\/r E°4ACH[N 4S AC4A [email protected]˜EGM S
Z <)cH a'4687Q<>; 6 M4 LI?^4=c;m7 O[N [email protected]´68=<^E 68;/7 <^bc6<[N/;/?C4=468LM<>7/; <h][email protected]=c;2G8O[H>7/[email protected];
68=YE l [email protected] <[4N/7/;'[email protected];/68W8=a'<h<mH <>W= E =; <>H[a-<`3<WN£fV H[3k<>[email protected];/IH ?C=44=8a-=<>?\[email protected] ACA<`bVG68J ? E[LMG84O[[email protected]>71?CG838<6yN/?7 O68E =„[email protected]?CDN <>7F7#E 3868W=<m< <[;/N W4;£[T 3N E <Y7 egGE E [email protected]; =? N^68=
H>[email protected]'ª[email protected]^G8E <[;9NQG8bV<+6<[7 <[N ;/H ?CW4<>=7 NQH WGf<Q?32^E 6H>[email protected]/<[?˜N-E<>H>;-;/? e E =<>;H>?C7/<>?C=8HFW=<<[N <>=„;/7 4?CG868O[L<[E N{?C<>==V4; 68ACLM<><>[email protected] <[NQN S7 O>E 356„4a'=N 4<[a'N ?6<>A=c;9<[NQ387=O[4H>6S?CNM
LM38<>7 [email protected][ACH[<[O[N£G8?C<>G8=VO[; <[<[N£N£G8G8O><9DVEa'DM4O[=ƒ<[[email protected] E <[7£H>;AK<>J O[68bc7£[email protected]<È<°;/W4G8<[T NFL<SVE X8687A O[Z G8<)O>HI7/a'?CH+4_ 687 E S57EFN E&N MH 4ISVH>=?CO[4<[6N9N{E 46S=VV1;;3k<><>=c7/;Fa-E ;/?CNÄ[email protected]<[<N
77 O[<>;/N ;B46<>Gf;7 0<m7/686=H[<2<QH[iÈ4<[=s<[r G<[H>? ;/l 687<><2;/; 38<Q7 H[443k=s4r N <[O[H><Q;/68E 7 6`<QG8E 2'O>:87/68a'; <2G8<[bcN+6˜JE 68=8==<mO[<[NF4N 6>&N E/M H>E/A\[ EN 3N E <7 G8t <[NBEh D<>7FA E 38WLM<[<WNM
3=4E ;/7 eg?C4E [email protected]; N G8SI<2AC<[3N{E [email protected] <-E 38GWJ <[E N9a-G?CN°J)(BG7/J ; 68O>=¡a-D?CN 7FSfE 3k38<>W68< ; ? X>;/47 <°6NH[4E[ACLM447/=?CO[Nm<+O>7FDVE E 38AC?C<>G8a'<>a'<>=V<>;=V;;/7 <>4=168LM68O ;/[email protected]@?C=´NTE [email protected];9DM4A\E M
7/H>[email protected]\;/EW8N a'N <[<°N£N/[email protected]<Ba-7 [email protected]<[A\E H[[email protected] =8<[N=? E jB?CNFNF= E =;/7 H[4<°683kLM4<>7F68E'7H>AC<[?NdM N{E D387F7jE [T 38NÈW68<[=„NÈ7GO[J)N/(È687/a'; O>Oa-G8?C<N S8H[<><>;9;/; E <°6N;/W4N ?5[T 3kNF< 4? 6879GJ E 68;/7 <[N
A J <>=N <>a2:8AC<°G8<BH[<B;/7FE[LE [email protected]˜EmO>; OB7 O E [email protected]?CN O+<>=1H[[email protected]\E :k47FE ;/?C4= E[LM<[H+X87 O[G8O>7/?CH°_ EÆedM
e 7FE&H ?
`.;<_d#&G 2 3 *4#0 *5"6%7+8:98;<%&
X 46N 7FE ? 3835<>AC4=N¢; 468; <[N¢AC<[N¢G8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=NÄG8<{;/WO[47/?C<9G8<[N D7FE 38W<[N¢68;/[email protected]<[N¢354687
A\H[E4a-N [email protected];AC<W< fV [email protected] ; O{[email protected]ÄDM4G87/[email protected]=8;/W8=a-4=?CbcN668< =ƒ?sAE 35<Ä<>AC7,<[(>H>61; <>7F68E 7%38H[?C4G8=8<B=<>E ;[email protected]=fNFE eg4=V7/;a':8<>?C<>A5=-G8<ÈH[<[A\N E°N/;/6sW/r O[<>4; N7/?C35<+4G868<97/7FA\EE
H68[4;/[email protected]=AC<[N/[email protected]#; <>=7B4A\;/E-7 <BG8<>;/7/7F=8E[L?U>T E 7 [email protected]<mA”=N <[< H>\ ;/?CD468=`7FE 4=V'Y;{N 34E=cN;9G7FE E =38NÄ35AC<><[ACO[N<[4NB68ACLI<[7FN9E bcDM6<[NÄ<>ACH>bVA\6E<[N NBN ?CbVG86OW\<[N [email protected];/A ?C4J [email protected]==SNM
G;84<W6ªV N£<>AC=<[N£\ ; =–<>7/a'G8<„<[NBG8<>4Ia-H>6838a'AC4&<>MH =VO[;^N ? 35<>7/a'<>;#E 6NFN/?£G8<ƒ7 <>;/7 468LM<>7'AC<[N-G8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=N^G8<
R
`6;<_8d#& ] ^ G;<_`.!%a_6;<b ;4d#&%
D38XB7F7 4E<>63868N1WLM<¡<[G8N 4G8=83<h=E 4A\7 Eªeg=E N^[email protected][; 468N =sS=r/r <[G8W8H><[;/?CN`N/68; 7 384<`7/7 ?C<>ebca-467/?C<h; <><`7 G8N G8<[N^<[;/7FNƒ38E[LD7/[email protected]=E6SH>38V [email protected]<[EG8Nƒ6S< Vy3l E 7 A\7 O[E eKN/6E [email protected];[email protected];F<NƒE ; 30N1E <>7 H[7/DM4l <:=WcH[r <>667/Gf=N =bVE 46˜=VLfJ;ƒ#yN AC<[A\MH E N S
iÈ4:k<>7/; N 4=˜S Z <)HIa'4687È<>; * W4a^EN ?
`6;<_8d#& ' l ;4 G!%7+ [email protected];4d%
B=X 44;/6?C4N+=h7FE [email protected]<>4AC7/4;F=E N°=V;AC<[<2N°35G84OW68\ 7È[email protected]<[;/[email protected]<>7/;°[email protected];/7 W8O[a'N/68<[[email protected]+;FE <1; 2^N+H38E7/H[[email protected]=<[H>[email protected]<26SH[V 4ACH[447F=E ;/H[?C<>47/=ª=E ]=cA\;E 68==4< M
;/G8?C<'4=^G8O>G8; <£<[H>3;/E [email protected] =<9GG8J<[E N°a-3?CENÄ[email protected]7 <[J 68Nm='GDJ E 7Fa-E 38?CNmW< G? E X =4N6ACN¢<[[email protected][email protected]=8==<WMK4D=7FN¢E 3868W=#<[E N [email protected]? DMA47/E„[email protected];/G8W8<>a'7/=8<B?UT>47 7/<#[email protected][email protected] =<[HWE MA
;/G8?C<°4=A\EQ38=7 4O[;/N ?C<>4=V=h; <^G8G8<+<[3N°E [email protected][<N/68G[email protected];FJ E E a-; N?CN 4? 7/[email protected][email protected]=E 6SV N/687°G8<[N°DMO>=O>7FE [email protected]?CNFE ;/?C4=Nm354NFN/[email protected]:8AC<[N
`6;<_8d#& !:+8: *5-6%&%&. #7 -69d*
BXBX 4466N{N17F<>E =r383kG8<>4AC=84==4N=68N1=1687 =O[N< [email protected];F7 E <>;[email protected]<`3k447/7/[email protected];FDE [email protected]==V;E AC<]ISÄAC<B38AC68<>?Ca-N^a'=<°46G8N1<BG8iB44=86=N 4N =<>AkNƒ<>bV;£6i9<>AC68bc:86?C<[4 N ?
H[47 [email protected]\E [email protected] <[NB<>;£LE 7/?\E =V; <[N bV68?=46NÈN <>7/[email protected] 4=c;93E 79A\E-N [email protected]; < ?
`6;<_8d#& 1 ^ G;<_`.!%a+ n %0#& %
BXH[<>47/6;FE [email protected]=38<£7 4H>68A\ELMN 4N =<N^G8<’68=D<„7FE H[384W=s<[r N%<[3H>;/E 687 7eKE<[email protected]; G8N <„ ACiÈ<[N <[<[DG7FE 38<>;W<[ N LMG<>J)7 (B<>;/7/;; O>S’a-E 2'?CN7/a^3k<>E 68=c;;#>bc;/6˜7 <J 68H[=4< M
AC47/?CO[< <12^ H? EXBH[<>4a'6N-<>=cG8;£4<>=8=#=468=;/[email protected]@?C68NFE ==c;Ä;/WA\EmO[4=7j4T>a';/?C4<Y=ƒG8G8<1<ÈG83O[E H[[email protected] <[a-N3kG4J N/E [email protected];/?C4?CN =y H[G84<[a-N 38DAC7F<WE IV [email protected];WO <[N ]
O(mn )
GO>=J)(È4=7/; H[O>[email protected]?CN 38 [email protected]=?CH>[email protected]; <>N9a'=˜<>J E[=VLM;4<>=;’N£G83O>Ea'N£4G8=VO>;/a'7 OB4G=cE;/7=O°N =A\E 4638N 7 KM <>a 68LM>a'<ÈG8<<{H[A\< E+;/H[W4O[=s4/r 7j<[>T H>a';/68<'7 <£][email protected]47/<[;N/<;
G8A <[<[NN D7 7FO[E N/[email protected];F<[E N; 3N E G87 <#eKE H[[email protected]; <1N3H WE E 7 38l [email protected];/WV7 6<„GfNF=44 =VLf;-N <>MH =SÆiB7 O>4LI:5?CN/<>?C7/4; =NF4eg=˜E S LMZ 4<)7FIHE a':8AC4< 68E 76 <>; * -/W4a^E.&N ?
. 1 R/J ?
`6;<_8d#& lD*p69 ,+!%a+8:f*$"6"6;4 %&%&;4"6f
P7 <[7H[4H[=8< =E#1?CN G8NF<[E N°=H[; <-<[H G8W8<[=8NB?CbcD67F<[E N38W68<[;/N°[email protected]@?CG8NFO[< <[0{N°<>37/E DM7 <S”l =WV466GfN =G84·LI4N=8=H 4=<>N+; 68Z =¡<)cH E a'[email protected]/[email protected];/W83ka'468<-7°<>A\=E
;=<>4a-=N’3N¢O>DV3kE [email protected]<>cH a'=<>4=Va-;?\G8E A<[N’G8<9E [email protected]<[4H[7/[email protected];/=8W8=a'E ?C<[N N¢NFE 3k=4H[68<È7 G8AC<[<[N’N¢ED687FE ;/387 <[WN¢<[H>N’A\GENFJ)(BN <[7/N¢; O>G8a-<{?CDN 7F? E X 384W6<[N¢N¢[email protected]=c4; =SOWMM
7bV<[6N <2NFE ==V4; N <[N{E [email protected]/[email protected];/[email protected]=ca';<[G8N°<BG8LI<267 <È<[H[G84<B=8A\=EE =?CN 4NF;/E ?C=4=ƒH[<QG83k<È<>368E [email protected]<>7 =V< ; G>J E ;/7a-<2?CN 68? ;/[email protected]@?C4N 6O[N NÄ#'a'G84=V<[Nm;/7 \4==NN
G;/8?C<°4=1H[4G8AC4< 7FN E 4;/6?C4N =KM D? 7FBX E 384WN£<[E [email protected][email protected]=47/[email protected];/[email protected]; a'N<[3NÈE 7ÄNF4H =VE ;ACH>e 684Ak=G8G8<ÈO[N£[email protected]{H[G84<[68N7/a'; N{O>H;/WW<>4Ia-G8<[[email protected]=N9N£G8G<+E G8=O>NÄ; <[AC<[HWNM
DG87FO>E ; 38<[H>W;/<[?CN4='NTE N =4N’=V; ;/7 X 46#L M [email protected][a-43a-E [email protected]<>? ; X N 4G6E N¢=Na'AC4<[=cN ;/D7 7F4E =38N£WbV<[6N%<BDMO>H[=<[O>N’7Fa E 6S>V a'?s<[A NÄ<[38N7 7 4O[:8N/68AU>T [email protected]';FE <[; N£N G8G8<<
H[<HFWE [email protected];/7 <£N 4=V; N 468a-?CN E 6
-/ . * $1 *1 R/O ?
2
! "
DG87F<#E [email protected][email protected] 4<ƒ<[6N1H[N2<ƒ<>38;#H 7 WACO[<[EN N„<>[email protected] ;/; [email protected] 4DM<=4S¢N27/a^[email protected];/?CH>W8E ?a'?CN-AC<[<[G8N2N <>? =LcA 47F<YE;/[email protected];-AC<[=H[H>NQ4; <>=G868N/<^7168:[email protected]; E<>E N 7':8<[[email protected];/Eh668O¡;/[email protected]<>[email protected] ?C7/N 6r=8O[?U<[T>N/NQ76s<„r/G<>E N;1=<[H>35NQ;/<>?CH[684<>=–;1;/; N<#bc<Y68;/?{4WGf?CT[7FN/EN 3k<h38<>35=]˜<>N [email protected]<[<>AC<7N
AC38<[[email protected]°;/7 7F<{E =˜7 <[J E°NE3k64H>[email protected]=V68; =NQ<£4 38'7 O>=; <>4=VN;/?CH[44=#=cLM35<>O[=VG;/E ?C4DM=4NQD?C35bc6<>68<LMSM<><>=c; ;2:8?C3<>E='7FGEbcFC6;/<Ä7 <^; [email protected]=868W; <[E N’:[email protected]<[;/6N <>[email protected]<[\N =8? [email protected];/l ?C4<^=H N’WG8GE < M
;/7/[email protected][44687/7?C<2<>6G8N <[<>N a'D<>7F=VE ; 38S5WAC<°<[N AC<[68H>;/; [email protected]<>AC<[68N 7 #-=4 A\LIE#?CH[H[<4a-38738O 7 e O>T>W7 <><>=7FE^N/?C4NTE=¡=G8NÈ<2G84H[<>68;/; ; <m<2H[;/4W4=T[N N 68<[email protected]; N <>47B?C<>68=V=`;°G84684=8Lc=7FE O[DM<[<N
H35>A\4EN N OÄN/?C7/[email protected]< 687R <>S 6SkVJ S?Sa^L E 4?CN%687968= H[< N [email protected]?kAC<[<{N/;£E 3kG8<><[7,N9(>6'E [email protected]<[7/N [email protected];/G8W8OWa'\=8<[[email protected] ;/Sf?C4==4N¢6<>N{; =G8<+<[G8N47 =8O[N/[email protected]=;FE N{; 3N EAC<[N£NG38J W<[email protected]!NM
H>A\EN N/?Cbc6<[N ?
"
Z ? <[N/; 68=-<>=N <>a2:8AC<£bV6<>ACH[4=bc6<£<>;%N/? <[N/;68=-<>=V;/?C<>7 3k4N/[email protected];/? e/S E AC47 N 4= =4; <
AKJ <>=N <>a2:8AC< G8<[NB3E 7/;/?C<[N°G8< bc68?4=c;+<WVEH>; <>a'<>=V? ; A O>ACO>a'<>=V; N ? È= <[E N/38;+3568<>AC= O[NmH[4AC<[68N+38AC<^ GJ <>=N $<>1amG8:8< AC<[N S<>;AC<[N2; O><>ACAO>a'bV6<>=V< ; N G8< N 4=c;Q<[N°E 38O>3kACO><>a'ACO[<>N=c;AC<[NmN G8< 11NF4G8=V<;
? ( \=GJ E [email protected]>DM<>72AC<[N°=4;FE ;/?C4=N S 4==4; <>7FE A\Eƒ3E [email protected] <'H[4=c; <>=E =V; <>; gE 6
[email protected] ?C4<>a-6 a'G8< <>; N9<>; ? Z ? AKJ <>=<[N N/<>;+am68:8=¡AC<2DG87FE <38N W<[<NÈS˜E E 7 AC>4; 7 <[N N ? G8O[N/[email protected]=<>7FE1AKJ <>=N <>a2:8AC<'G8< N <[N
Z [email protected]; 68=1D7FE 38W< ? Z 4?C<>=V; <>; G8<>S6 VƒN 4a-a'<>; N9G8< ? Z ?
[email protected]; < bV6< <[N ;9<>68; = N 4 =V ; G8< * 4=h$MGfS%[email protected];B6E < 6N N/?˜<>bc; 6< N 4=c ;2$AC <[N ? Z ? 1$1ƒG8<^AKS”J E EE 7 ACAC44>;77 <NN
4E 6=`N GfN/?%[email protected];°bV6bc6< < <>; !- N 4=c; ? Z ? <[N/; 68* =¡$N 4Sa-bca'6< <>;<><[; N ;B6868= =<'E 7 >; <Sk 4 = [email protected]<;°bc65< 4=¡<[GfN [email protected];;
? Z 4?C<>=V; <>; G8<>6SV¡E 7 >; <[NG8< ? jB=
*" # N ?%<>;NF<>68AC<>a'<>=V;mN/?
GfH[[email protected];Qa-bcam668< =<S”<>E ; 68;/7 <>N a'4=c<>; =c;B Gf* [email protected]#;È N ? 1ƒN/?<>;QNF? <>68AC<>a'<>=V;-N/? <>; 4=c;Q68=<1W< Vf;/7 O>[email protected]; O
XB4; 4=NYbV6<S£3E 7hG8WO \[email protected];/?C4=˜S9=4N„D7FE 38W<[NhN 4=V; - *. MS HJ <[N/; M #GM [email protected] <
bV6˜J 68=`N 4a-a'<>; =<m3k<>68; r E a^E ?CN >;/7 <QN 4=h387 4387 <LM4?CN/[email protected]= H E 7 =<m354NFN WO M
V
k
V
V
(V, E)
k
k
E ⊂
G
uv
u
v
u
v
u
u
u∈e
e
e
v
uv ∈
/ E(G)
v
e
G
f
e
f
E
v
uv ∈ E(G)
G
u
u
v
e ∩ f 6= ∅
v
V
E
uv
V (G)
G
{u, v}
G
E(G)
G
u
v
u
u
v
u
v
u
e
f
V
2
{v, v}
>&[
.
=G 4E =cN2;%Dbc7F6˜E 38J 68W=-<[NmN <>=68<^AfO>N AC4O>=Va';2<>3=VE; [email protected]=˜ J E 383 E M7/S;/H?C<>J <[=VN ;¢; 3M #GEM N Gf#[email protected] <#bc6 <-? X 3k44; 6847m=N; 4bV66Nm<ÄNF34E a-7%a'G8OW<>\; [email protected];/?C4<>= ;
SG8<>6SV¡N 4a-a'? <>X ; N 4; 4=<>N£; <>=SS\[email protected]=A¢<WbVVf6?C<+N/; =< 4[ N{4D67FE 38> WE <[7 NB>;N <4S˜=V;<>;° = 4.=´ 68M=¡S8H=J <[4N/am; M :8#G7 M <^[email protected] <6<>bcAC6˜H[4J <>==Vbc;/67 <<
GJ EM7 SÆ>H; J <[<[NN ?; M X #GM 4Gf; [email protected] =<£N£bV<>6=S<\==„46bV6N <BN/68; 3843k64NN AC<><[7 NÄ4D=7FNE ; 384Ws6 <[r N£468bc7 6N < bc=64< 6N{H[3544=NFN/jN ?CT[G8G8O><’7 <>687 = 4==N94Na2<>:87 47 =c< ;\ =8?
GN 4J O>=1ACO>=a'4am<>=c:8; 7N <+? jBG=^J E 7 =>4; ;<[<>N 7F? EjB<>=„=^E DM38O>35=<>O>[email protected] <A $AC.$<9.0 =G4amJ 68=ƒ:87 D<B7FG8E 38<ÈWN <+4a-N 4a'=1<>=; NÄ4amGJ:8687 =^<+DG87F<BE 38NF4Wa-<Sca'<>;<>; N ?
Z [email protected]; 68='D7FE 38W< ? Z ?
G8< ? X ? Z4;? 4=NQbV6< SME AC47 N ? jB=´G8=SVO[4E N/; [email protected]< 7=N’<4AK=#J <>==ACN< 4<>; a2< :8 AC<9YG8G8<[<NAKJ <>N 4=a-N G8<>WOa'a2\<>:8=8; AC?N<È3G8G8E < <[7 N¢LM4E HV?CN E [email protected]==c;N
EGf62?CN r/a'[email protected][email protected];=N N ? 68=2LM4?CN/[email protected]= GE =N ? X 4; 4=N bc6< <>; =<’NF4=V;3EN=O[H[<[N NTE [email protected] <>a'<>=V;
Z [email protected]; 68=D7FE 38W< ? jB=yE 3835<>[email protected]< * . $hG8< AC<ƒD7FE 38W<„=4; O
G8WO \=8?£3? E Z 7 4?C<>=c; <>; G8<>S6 V^<>; D7FE 38W<[N ? jB= E 3835<>[email protected]< <>; +<>=c;/7 < <>; <>;
; 468<>; ;È<Q; eg<>[email protected]=<2H>;/bV?C64<= :8? r/<[H>;/[email protected]<S˜EN N 4IH>?\E =V;1#ƒHFWEbV6<-?NF4Z a-J [email protected]'W< <>Vf;?CN/G8; <<68=`68?C=N 4a'N 44a-7/38a'W8<>?C;N/a'G8<<
<>-=c;/ 7 < *, <>.; 1 SE AC47 ,N°Q4; =468Gf;[email protected];°D7FbcE 638< W<?CN <>4; a'47/N384W=c< ; # N 4+= H[ 4a- 38 AC? O>a'jB=<>=cE;[email protected] <<>[email protected]? AC< D7FE 38W<
Z 4?C<>=c; 68=„D7FE 38W<°<>; 68=„<>=N <>a2:8AC<G8<+N 4a-a'<>; N£G8< ? jB=„=4; <
AC<[<mN/; D7FE 38W<2G84=c;BAKJ? <>=jBN =<>a2Gf:[email protected];-AC<2bcG86<[< N N 4a-a'<><[; N/N ;Q<[ACN/< ; - <>$; G84=V; AKJ <> =N <>am :8!AC< - G8$ <[NB E 7 >; <[N ?
L 4687-=<^3ENQ;/7 43–E AC4687 [email protected] AC<[NQ=4;FE ;/?C4=N S 4=ªN·J E 68; 47/?CN <ƒH[<>7/;FE [email protected]=N'E :86N1]N/?
<[N/;{68=ƒN 46N MKD7FE 38W? <+Z ? [email protected]=Gf68<[[email protected]/;£; G868< = <>Sf=4N =1<>am=:84AC; < < G8<QN 4a-ACa'<B<>D; 7FN°E 38G8W< <°bVS56˜4J 4=`=„=G84<>; LI< 7FE [email protected];=4; <>AC<7
D7FE 38jBW= <E bc386˜35J 4<>[email protected]< G8*<>.LI"-7FE [email protected]{;94=6 4;<> 7 1 * .0; ?468;D7FE 38W<ÄLMO>7/N? \”E =V;
?
?
=H[jB44=ya-; <>38E 7 38ACO>3ka'<>[email protected]<>AC=c68< ;F=E <[email protected] H><[email protected]?C<[bV N/6.0;’ <268;E[=4LM<£68<[H>H; [email protected]<„?CbVH>[email protected]?C<4bV?a-6jB<a'=1E&<>E;HVN38E ? 35=VjB;#<>[email protected]=`AC;/< 7 E4*38?C. N'#3k-<>N [email protected]< a'1 <>;1N .0; m4Rd68; A£4;¢68<[D;BN/7F;-ED38H[7FE4W3868< W;/68<ma-G8bc?C468<>=V7#?;B<[G8N/AC<<;
6eg84=?CNm<+H>[email protected]˜?CbcJ 46=´<BG8<>;{WO \[email protected]?k7FE„<[N/;68=´68=„; HIN 354<'6N G8MKD<'7FED387FE W38< [email protected]< =Gf:[email protected];£68G8AC<< ?SH>[email protected][email protected]<S˜DMO>N/=;FE O>:87FE AC<AC<>S˜a';/7 <>4=V6 ; S? H ? W? ESbc46= <
E 383k<>[email protected]<>7FE "-/. ; 468; D7FE 38W<9bV68?<[N ; 68= :8?CGf68AC< 46#bV68?<[N/; ?CNF4* a' 4 7/ 38 W<
#68= :8?CGf68AC< Ä<>;Äbc68?”<[N/;Ä68=#N 46NiMKD7FE 38W<È[email protected][email protected];{G8< ? jB=#[email protected]<
68:8= ?CGf68:8AC?C<Gf'G68AC8< <N/?˜? <>;9jBNF=<>[email protected]<>7Fa'E„<>bc=V6;B< N·J [email protected]<[W< N/VI; ?CN ; <+68 = N 4#6-/N MK.0D£7FE N/38?¢W<><;[email protected] =<>Gf6868AC<>[email protected];Ba'G8<><=V;QN J [email protected] 68=˜?˜J<[W< N Vf;9?CN/68; = <
E 6H>68Z [email protected]; :8?CGf6868=QAC<N b4a-c68a'?<>N ;%[email protected];£< 68= ? N [email protected];7FE bc386W< <[email protected]<[=N/Gf; 68 [email protected];È G8.< * ? .fN ?c<>; NF<>68AC<>a'<>=V; N/?
[email protected]<[=N/Gf;[email protected];N 68N/[email protected]:8<9AC< H>[email protected]?Cbc<Q63<ÈE G87/< ;/[email protected];/?C4? =8jB==#<>7 [email protected];bV6˜J 68<>=#=¡DG87FE<>6S38VW< <>=N <><[amN/; :8AC<[ N <>N/; ?<>;Ä;NF<><>AC68N°AC<>bca'6<<>=V;{N J [email protected]
<>; <>;°; 468N ;4=VN 4;9a-G8a'<[N£<>N/;m;FEG8:8< AC<[N ? SZ E ?kAC4G87 <[email protected]=6N{[email protected][email protected];W< bVVf6?CN/< ; <+68<[=N <°; E 687 =¡>; D<°7F<>E =V38;/W7 <<°; 4 68;91NF 4a-* a' <>.;90G8 < ?
u E =NmH[<#H EN SA\Eƒ:[email protected] 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=<[N/;68=8?Cbc6< ? Z ? <[N/;68=´D7FE 38W<':[email protected] 7/;/?{H[4a-38AC<>;
V
2
u
v uv = vu
u
v
V
n
G
v
|N (v)|
v ∈ V (G)
v ∈
/ N (v)
A ⊂ V (G)
N (A)
A
G
F
N (v)
d(v)
A
v
N (A)
G
E(G) = {uv; u ∈ V (G)
v ∈ V (G)
V (G) = V (G)
F
G
ϕ
uv ∈ E(F ) ⇔ ϕ(u)ϕ(v) ∈ E(G)
G
F
G
F
G
G
G
uv ∈
/
F
G
W
W
W
2
d(v) =
G
G
E(G)}
m
∩ E(G)
G G[W ]
W
F
G\F
G
G[V (G) \ V (F )]
G[W ]
F
G\F
G
G[V (G) \ F ]
V (G)
2
E(G) =
Kn
n
G
K
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
v
G
v
G
G
V (G)
A
G[B]
A
B
N (v)
G
G
B
G[A]
>/>
[E LM<[H Z
<>; ? SE AC47 NÈ4=„AC<°=4; <+WE :[email protected];/6<>[email protected]<>a'<>=c; ?
<>N/;F= E :8AC4< <>[email protected]? ; =X NF<>4am;684=¡:8=ACN<[<>N=VbV;/6?C<><^7 ; 4jB68=; ED387FE3k38;<>W<>[email protected]<1< N E bVLMM 6*<[< H .3 3k 4N68 47„a-; a'468G8<>;< ; NQ354; 4N N68T[; G8<Q<^368E =7/;/S< [email protected];/?C4M =H[4G8AC4< 7F<[E N/;/;„?C468= = ?
A <[N <>=N <>am:8AC<[N NF4=V;’E 383k<>ACO[NG8<[N * - . 1-/ ? Z ? [email protected]; bV6˜J 4='E .0 * - . 1-/ ?<L E 7 eg4?CN S4= G8O[N/[email protected]=<+AC<[N{=c68a'O>7 4NÈG8<[N9H[468AC<>687 NÈ3E 79G8<[N9EGr <[H>;/? egN
:[email protected]? h· E 7/17 ,<[ N„*1H[ 4a-a'< #-7 4Y68DMG8< < FS :8ACAC<#<>6 [email protected]? NQ? ? 3k4<>;/6 [email protected];-a <>>=Va';/?C<>< 7 7 4NF; <<>`4A{bc66 < LM<>7/3k;4? N NjjBT[G8=)<#E 6838=35< <>[email protected]< M
H[4ACE 4LM7F<[E H ;/?C4= ? jB=N 4a-=4a'; < <>; N9<[N ;GfAC<#[email protected]; < =4 am :8 7 <ƒ.H W8? 7 4jBa^=ƒE =;/?C4bc; 6< <ƒG8< A\?E2È;FE [email protected]<#[email protected]<°H[4GACJ 4687F=E <°;/?CH>[email protected]=?CbV6G8<<
Ga^8< GE [email protected]^G8E < AC< ;F?4E [email protected]@AC<°<-AC<>a^a-EGa'[email protected]<a^N/E 68AC< [email protected]? E jB=V;È=<[=N 4;£; ;/< 7/[email protected]?\E A’] A\E1;FE [email protected]@AC<'GJ 68=N/;FE :8AC<'G8< G8<';FE [email protected]@AC<
|A| = a
k
|B| = b
k
k
A1 , . . . , A k
n
Ai
v
G
V (G)
1 ≤ i ≤ k G[Ai ]
n
v ∈ Ai
i
G
χ(G)
G
k
G
k
G
ω(G)
χ(G)
G
Ka,b
α(G)
G
! 2 2 G - G 1
G 1
G 1
G 1
G 1
- 1 1.0 1-/.01 χ(G) = 1 - 1 1.0 1-/.01 ω(G) = 1 - *. #- 1-/.0 χ(G) = n - *. #- 1-/.0 ω(G) = n 1-/. 1 χ(G) ≤ 2 Z [email protected]; 68=D7FE 38W< ? jB=rE 3835<>[email protected]< . 1 G8< AC<„D7FE 38W<„=4; O
G8H[<>4=V=V; ;'N’AKN J ?<>=<>;’N <>N a2<>68:8ACAC<><Ya'G8<><[=cN';ÄN/NF?4a-AC<[N’a'G8<><>; 6SN'V'<[N/E ; 7 >; <[NÄG8< SÄ<>;'bcG8684?8=VAC<>;#68G87Ä<>H[6S4V7/7 N<[4N 35a-4a'=G8<>;<>N'=c;ÄNF4N 4=V=c;#;’[email protected]=r H>EG?NMM
G8<>=V; <[N <>? ; X47/a'<>[email protected]<>a'<>=V? ; S
<>;
<>;
Z ? <[N ; 68=¡D7FE 38W<-<>;°N/? <[N ; 68=¡N 4a-a'<>;G8< E HVE =c;m<WVEH>; <>a'<>=V;mG8<>6SV
LMN 44a-?CN/[email protected]'=N˜<>; =N 4<[= N ; EGr/EH[<>=c; N S<><>; ;G84S·=VE ;AC4AKJ7 <>N=4N =<>am=:84AC; << G8<[N E 7AC<¢>; D<[7FNE <[38N/W; <ÄG84=V;AKJ <>=NF<>am:8AC<G8<[N
? Rd=V;/[email protected];/[email protected]<>a'<>=c; S£AC<YD7FE 38W< <[N/;^AC<`D7FE 38W< 4:8; <>=V6ˆ<>= [email protected]?CN NFE =c; YAC<
NG84< a-a'N <>?; <>;¢? N <>Z 68? AC<>a'<><>; =V;’N·N J [email protected]=VW< ;’VIG8?CN/<[; N’<{D687F=E 38<£WN <[68N [email protected];Sc<£E ACG84<{7 NÄD7F4E =^[email protected]<[;ÄN bc6< <[N/S;¢68=S< ? 1? - ? S <>G8; < 68=< G8N/<[email protected]; <>< D7 O J <>; ; <>A bc6<Q354? 687°; 468;
S <[N/; 68=N 4a-a'<>;
6838=r68?CNBR3kAÄ<>4=`<[[email protected]=VN/;2;„7 <>H[[email protected]?\46E 68=V;/;+3868A\3a-E E=ˆ?C7È<>7-bV686=G8<h<2<^[email protected][email protected] 4D<[=ˆ=NFN/<[email protected] =;Hc<>4a27m68:5; AC<[<[[email protected]?CNFACD<[<h7FNBE 3383E WE 7ƒ<[[email protected] N 68<[N+=‘<>=ªG835<mE<>N3k;/N [email protected];„[email protected]>=VH[?\; E<>N =V7 H>;bcAC68< # ? HFN LIW4?C=cEG8;bV<`6G84<1<[6‘N+N 4E38a-7 AC><>a';[email protected]= <[<>N ; S?
L 4687B7 <>387 O[N <>=V; <>7 68=YD7FE 38W<m:[email protected] 7/;/?KS”4= 7 <>387 O[NF<>=V; <23E 7 e 4?CNBAC<[NÈN 4a-a'<>; N G8<°A\E
387 <>a-U? T>7 <°3E 7/;/?C<G8<°A\EQ3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=`<>= 38AC<>[email protected]= +<>;ÈAC<[NÈE 68;/7 <[NÈ<>= dH>7 <>S6 V ?
G
G
L(G)
E(G)
G
V (L(G)) = E(G) E(L(G)) = {ef ; e ∈ E(G)
G
v
v0
V (G)\{v}
G/v
(E(G)\{vv 0 , vv 00 })∪
G/v
v
G
F
F
G
v 00
{v 0 v 00 }
Gi
f∈
e ∩ f 6= ∅}
E(G)
v0 , . . . vk−1
Gi+1 = Gi /vi
G
G = G 0 G1
0 ≤ i ≤ k − 1 vi
Gk = F
!"$#%&(')+*,-&. +&/%&(')+*
u E =N{; 468;{H[< ;/7FE LE [email protected][email protected]N <>7FE2:k< E 6H[4683 bV6<[N/;/?C4=„G8< dHFW<>[email protected]=N ? jB7{[email protected]<WVf?CN/; <
?
<>=';/WO[47/?C<9G8<[N¢D7FE 38W<[N’[email protected]/?C<>687 N¢=4;/?C4=NÄG8<9H W<>[email protected]=N·SMLE 7/?\E =V;ÄNF<>AC4='AC<[N’E 68; <>687
>&J
.
d?CR H>A?==446N¢N¢38N 7<>4a238:87 AC<[<ÈN’bc=6˜4J;FE E 6;/H>?C468==N <9SV=bV64;F<£E =;/?C446=#NÄ=˜<[JN/<[3kN/O>;¢7 LI47F=E N¢[email protected]'H>A\<>E [email protected] ;Ä<[NN ;FSE [email protected]=c=;/G68E [email protected];/[email protected]? <[X NÄ4<>6;¢N¢7/[email protected] 4O[68N 7 <><>=c6; NF4<[=N N ?
Z [email protected]; 68= D7FE 38W< ? jB=-E 383k<>[email protected]< *1/ {G8< ; 468; <{N/[email protected]; <
G8<QN 4a-a'<>; N°G8<>?56SA V <[N+##E G87 <>>6S; Vh<[N GfG8?CN/< ;/[email protected]=H>G8; N+<2G8A\E < eg47/a'LMO>< 7/?N\”E =c;°354E 68LM<[7 H ; 468;
]
E AC47 N E 3835<>ACO[N <[4NB=V;°AC<[EN 3835,<>ACO[ <[ NB AC<[ N .3 *,*1 ?4A .3 <[NB*1E 7 >; <[ N ?5G8A < <[NBNF4G8a-<°a'A\E-<>;e 4N 7/a'< <>; SENFN 44LM=V=c<[H;;
E=3843ka2<>:8ACO[7 <mN£ACG<[JN E 7 > ; <[N 1? .0 *1 ?<A E-AC4=8D6<>687ÈG8<+A\E H WEGFC=<2<[N/;£O>DVE AC<1# N 4=
8
G
m
<
F
N
4
a
'
a
>
<
;
B
N
8
G
>
<
S6 V
B
j
=
E
8
3
5
3
>
<
@
A
C
A
< * *. QG8< ; 468; <2N/[email protected]; <
AK#`J EG8G8<>[email protected];/Vª?CE[4LMGf=<[?CN H G8;/[email protected]<[=NH>;[email protected]=N-GfG8?CH[< <[NQS5<[N N/LM4;mO>=V7/<>;°?N=c\”E;E <>AC=c4=;-7 GfN°356E 4<#3868a'357 <>4I; ACO[Gf4<[6868N ;AC4 AC<[N ? A ,<[N2 E 7 >-; ]<[*NQG8*.0< ? A <[G8N°<^E A\7E1>; eg<[4NS¢7/a'4G8' <<
G8jB<+=1A\E E e 384357/a'<>[email protected]< < *1E[LM1<[H ; 468;¢D7FE 38W< NF4=VG8;B4=VE ;¢383kAKJ <><>AC=O[N <[<>N9a2AC<[:8N AC<È* G8<[ N¢ NF 4a-- a'* <>; *N¢.03k? <>68; >;/7 <
;44477 68G8G8;¢44=8=8D==7FEO°O[38NBG8WG8< < <+a^a^E E=8E[=8LMU? T>U?<[T>7 HB<7 1< E #m6-#2e a'4e 47/4a'7/[email protected]'=<>N’7{<>7£bc68686==E<+;/H)H7 W<£HfGEH>N ACFC4<°=a-<°NFa'E NT=E <>N£=; NN’H[4G8H[744G87 =c<G8;¢<°G8AC<[<G8N¢< N 4? a-SfXB<>a'4;£;<>44; =„N=N93kE <>38bc686˜3kLM<>J [email protected]<>[email protected]˜AC=V< W< ; Vf >?C ;/N/ 7; - <<
egEE 46387/3ka'38<>[email protected]<>[email protected]È<^N-68ACG8=<[N<><2S6 H VW EGa^FC1=E < =8?p U? T>L 7 4<[68N^ 7+-GH[J 4<[*17NÈ G81447 =8Gf =7 <><[˜7-N SACAC<[AC<[N-<[N-NÈE N <W684Vf;/a-;/7 7 <[a'O>N a-<>N ; [email protected]; a-O[GNBa'J N68<>4=;=cN ;ÈH WGfAC<[<>6ªNÈa-HFa [email protected]=y><>a'a-G8<1<[[email protected]=N a^SN <>E 4;È=8=V4U?; T>=h7 Gf< [email protected]<[; # NN
1 - ? jB=-=4; < AC<£N 46N M H W<>[email protected]=#G8< [email protected][email protected]; 3E 7 AC<[N NF4a-a'<>; N [email protected]=V; O>7/?C<>687 N
G8E 38< 3k<>[email protected]? AC< jB=„= 4 *1; < 1 ; 4A\E68;m.0 D7F E - 381W-/<#-bVG868< ?Ä<[N/Sf;HACJ <[<'N/;H[M 4#Ga-M [email protected] O><a'N <>4=c=„;[email protected] a2<„:8G7 J <68=GJ H E W7 <>>a-; <[[email protected] =˜? SjB<>= ;
$ -1; 468;ÄD7FE 38W<+bc68?5<[N/;ÄAC<BH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=c;FE [email protected] <GJ 68=1;/7 46 ? jB=ƒ[email protected];{bV6˜J 68=1;/7 46
46168=1E =c;/[email protected];/7 46 ’<[N ; $ 7 <[N/3 ? N J [email protected][4=V;/?C<>=c;68=1=4am:87 <B3E [email protected]{GJ E 7 >; <[N
7 <[N/3 ? [email protected] [email protected] ? jB=–[email protected];'bV6˜J 68=;/7 46–4668=yE =c;/[email protected];/7 46y<[N/; .3 ªN J [email protected][4=V;/?C<>=c;1E 6
a'[email protected]=?N Q N 4a-a'<[<>N/;; N 68? =´<>=c;/?C<>7Q<>;2N/?
bc? ?6? <>S ACH[4=<>bV;°6<[G8N·4SI=V4;+=1AKJ =<>=4;N <<>am:8AC<-G8<[N°E 7 >; <[N°AC<[< N/;D7FE 38WNF< 4=VG8;24=cG8;{<[N2AC<[4N:SNFr 4<>a-; Nma'a^<>; E N£;/?WN 4AO>a^=V<Q; E D;/7F?CE bVS 386W<[<N S
?
[
<
N
;
8
G
4
=
H
8
6
„
=
H
W
>
<
a
@
?
=

G
J
W
<
f
V
/
;
7
>
O
a
@
?
;
[
O
N
S
>
<
{
;
8
G
B
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
Z ? <[N/;Ä68=„HFW<>[email protected]= <>;N/? S N 4=c;{G8<[N{N 4a-a'<>; N£G8< S8E AC47 N SI4=ƒ=4; <
[email protected]=< [email protected]=;9 G8H *1<W<>[email protected]= 68r?E[G8LM<[N/<<[;H 68= GN H J4WW< a-Vf<>;/a-a'7 O>[email protected]<>= a-; N G[email protected]; J O[<WN Vf;/7 68O><>a-=; [email protected] ; =VO[S%N;/?CHH J W<[<>N/<>;;a-M #[email protected]=–M ? [email protected]7 LM<1<[<[N/HAK;J 68H[=8468?CN bV;/4668a-<ƒa-a'N?C<>4<>7B6; N·N G8S MK<BD7F=E 438; 68W<>= <7
;/;/77 4466hE[E LMLM<[<[HHbc6N E 4;/a-7 <a'N <>4; a-N£a'<>; <>; N S8=684=„; O E =c;/[email protected];/? 7 46YE[LM<[H NF4a-a'<>; N ? jB= E 383k<>[email protected]+< *,1AC<
N/bc?£6<<>;-jB=„N <><[68G8N/ACWO ;°<>\a'[email protected]<>;{=c< ;^687 =<>N <A\J [email protected]£7;/<>?CW< 4A\VIE =´?C;/N ?CG;4<#=J O[bc68<>[email protected];/L7HFE <WAC<><>AC<[a-=N£H[[email protected]<=yN 4? a-G8jB< a'=´<>E ; 38N{G35GJ <>W< J [email protected]<;/=ƒ7 O>*,Da-7FE [email protected]; O[WN < <>]f; 4=1*,? =jB4=; < LM O>ƒ7/N? \G8<<
AN <>68CAC<[<+NH[D47Fa-E 383kW4<[NFNE [email protected]=; <°Gf68H[[email protected]; =8N=3W< V8E 7m<°ACE <[ACN47 H>N£A\E4N =„N <[[email protected];{GbcJ O[6bc< [email protected] <[AC<>N/=; H[* <' G8< ? ? Z Z ? ? <[3kN/4;£N jNH[T[4G8=8< =W< 68V8=<< S
E AC47 N'4=–[email protected];-bc6< <[N/; *, ? jB=yE 3835<>[email protected]< * *, G
G
C = (v1 , v2 , . . . , vk )
1 ≤ i ≤ k−1
1 ≤i ≤ k−1
v i vj
v1
vk
G
vi vi+1 ∈ E(G)
G
|i − j| > 1
vi vi+1
G
C = (v1 , v2 , . . . , vk )
1 ≤ i ≤ k vi vi+1 ∈ E(G)
n
G
G
1≤i≤k
v i vj
vi vi+1
G
G
|i − j| > 1
P
P
H
H
P∗
P
lg(P )
P
P
n≥1
vn
v1 −v2 −· · ·−vn
P
P
Pn
n
v 1 , v2 . . . v n
v1 −v2 −· · ·−vn
{vi vi+1 ; 1 ≤ i ≤ n − 1}
v1 vn
u v
P
P
u
v
u v
n
Pn
n
Cn
n
C4
G
G
u
v
v1 v2
n−1
u−P −v
Cn
u∼v
∼
G
G
G
∼
G
G
>&O
8;G 4< 68;'DAC<[7FN{E 38H[W4<a-38ACO>S a'AKJ <>68=V=r;FE E [email protected] <[NBa'G84<[[email protected]=NN^H[4G8a-< 3k4NFS E =c; <[<[N£N/;^H[4H[=84==8<W=Vf<W<[V8N£< G8? < jB=r? E XB3843k; <>[email protected]=AC< N{bc 6<È13k 4168.07
H[<[4N/;9=81=H[ 4<W *Vf=8-/<=.3? <WVfZ <? S”3k‘E 4AC68G847È7< N9; 44=Y68; ;B4Gf<>[email protected];È=;'NFbc<><>6am=< NF:8<>ACam< :8<[N/AC<; G8G8< <ƒ*, N 4a-a' N <>4? ;a-N a'<>; ; N <>A9G8< bc6< SAC<D7FE 38=˜W<J <[N ;Q3EN
Z [email protected]; 68=#D7FE 38W<SV<>; S G8<>S6 V'N 4a-a'<>; NÄG8< ?A E 1 * ÈG8< # <[N/;’A\E
AC*14=81D6 <>68 79S8GGJ J 68<WVf=ƒ;/HF7 WO>a-<>[email protected]; [email protected][= N G8< <>; G8? <BZ AC? 4=8D6<[<>N/;£687£[email protected][email protected]<>a^a-E [email protected]=h< G8 4< =„[email protected] ;£HVN E 4=V68;BLM68<>=V=;"<.<WVf- ;/ 7 O>*,a- - [email protected]; O S387 %4N/38?£7/?C4O>=ª; O3S”E E 7/ACAC4<Y7 [email protected] N NFJ 4E [email protected]'7FE-<>;Gf6YN 4G8a-< a'<>; . a-. - [email protected] [email protected] ?CNF*E=Vh; G8A\E-< Gf?CN/E ;FHVE E==cH[;'<m<>68=V=;/<„7 < H[<>7/;F<>E ; [email protected]=<
H E ACH>XB68AC4O[6<N9G; E <>=7/[email protected]<°=4HF=WN9<>[email protected]= 7968=„<>;/;£W=O[44j7= T>a'3E<mN9:8G?CE<>==YNÈH[AC4<+=8D=V7F6ªE 38] W< ?
G
G
G
G G
G
G
G
u v
G
u v
u0
u
G\F
F
k−1
F
G\F
G
k
G
P
P
u
P
` *p +! 2 U] b $]
* *.0 $ $ v
G
u
u0
u
u0
G
& 1-/.01 $.
" '/ ' ( $& * ' ( È=„387/?CN a'<°[email protected] [email protected]]
È=„387/?CN a'<°3E [email protected]]
A <[email protected]<>;/[email protected];£387/?CN/a'<']
&!$#"%
>/[email protected]> u <[N£387/?CN/a'<[N
;/7 4?C<[NmjBN/; =<>=G8EN <m<>38a2AC354<>:[email protected]<[< 6N2<>[email protected]=7° Gf1E686`?CQNTE a'; =V44; [email protected]=G8;+N <[DNm>7FE S”H 38WGW<>J <Wa-< [email protected];/=7 NO>[email protected]=c; ;°SO[N AC<[N S NF<>4; a-; a'<>SAC<>Nm; ; <>N°bcACN+6N <m<'bc633k< E 47/68;/7 [email protected];/?C4=8=<>=c;m<><>= ; S
NN 446a-N a'MKD<>7F; E NÈ38WG8<+< [email protected][email protected]=68Gf?C<>68N ; [email protected]<>;È=c;GJG868 <[=„NÄD;/7/7F?\E E 38=8WD< AC<[N SfS<>E ;’9AC4; E 7<>68NÈACN;/47 bc<m=ƒ6˜bVGfJ [email protected][email protected];9<=˜bcH[J H^6<>[email protected]<+E AC<[[email protected];£NB<[N{E G86;/<[7 H>N9468;/?C=N97/?\< HFE WE=8<>7 D>a-AC;<[<[email protected] =? <>N Z=V?;/7 < S G8<[<[N/;N S
F
P1 P2 P3
ai
bi
Pi
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
Pi
Pj 1 ≤ i < j ≤ 3
G
i = 1, 2, 3
{a1 , a2 , a3 }
F
P 1 P2
>)k
.
>AC< <[; N *, 1Gf61 38 7/?C68N/=ƒa'38< 7/? ?CjBN/a'=#<[email protected];{< bV6<? jB=„<[GfN/; [email protected];£bV6$ <BAC7<[<[N{N/N3 4? a- a'<>; $N N/?”AC<[S N’;/7 4?CN{H W<>[email protected]==V;N
N
4
V
=
;
8
G
#
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
3
E
@
?
7
<
7 <[N 3 ? [email protected] [email protected] < ? [email protected];-bV6˜J 68=ª387/?CN/a'<ƒ<[N/;
.0 1N J [email protected] NjT[G8<°E 6„a'[email protected]=N£N <>38;9N 4a-a'<>; N S8HJ <[N ; M #GM [email protected] <°N/?AKJ 68= E 6„a'[email protected]=N9G8<+N <[N
HFW<>[email protected]=NB<[N/;9G8<+AC4=8D6<>687 N/683kO>7/?C<>687 <46 O>DVE AC<1# JS?
P3
G
ai , bi i = 1, 2, 3
F
P1 , P 2 , P 3
c0
S3
c
a0
b0
S1
S2
0
S4
d
d
a
b
&! #&% >/?KJ È = bc6EN/?NMK387/?CN/a'<
B
j
'
=
E
8
3
k
3
>
<
@
A
C
A
<
- 0 1 {; 468; D7FE 38W< S G84=V;%AC<[N N 4a-a'<>; N N <Ä3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=<>=V;
<>=Ybc6E ;/7 <°<>=N <>a2<>; :8AC<[NÈ[email protected]=Gf68?CNFE =c;ÈG8S<[4NÈ' HFW<>a-<>; [email protected]=N S35<>68=LM<>a−·
· ·−a S S = b−· · ·−b S
c
=
;
>
/
;
7
9
<
8
G
£
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
S = c−· · ·−c
S = d−· · ·−d
S
S
0 a^E ?CN
4' S , S N 4=V;ÈG8<AC4=8D6<>687 E 6 a'[email protected]=N 1 S<>;9? ; X <>AC4N9; bc46=<N’bcE(S)
= E(S ) ∪ E(S ) ∪
6
<
E(S ) ∪ E(S ) ∪ {a c, a d, cd, b c , b d , c d }
{a , c, d} <>; {b , c , d }
Nbc46=cE;£N/?NG8MK38<[N{7/?CN/;/a'7/?\E <'=8<[DN AC;<[[email protected];+< 1S ? jB* B = N/E ? 38AK3kJ 68<>=ª[email protected]< E 6¡a <>a'; [email protected]=AC<[NmN G8 < 1 <>$; 1m Gf<[6ƒN/;bc6G8<'EN/AC?N4MK38=87/D?C6N/a'<>68< 7Q?SAE 6 <
S
S
0
3
3
4
3
4
4
0
0
0 0
0
1
0
1
0 0
0
2
2
0 0
0
a'[email protected]=N ?
B=<+3HI7FE a-?CG8<^]
1
1
0
0
2
0
2
1
A E [email protected]£3k<>;/[email protected]; <°3HI7FE a-?CG8<^]
&!$#&%
>/?KO u <[N£3!Hc7FE a-?CG8<[N
KA J 68=8jB?C4=ˆ=EG838<1S 3k;/<>7 [email protected]< ?C<[N N ;m<>=G8N <-<>amAC4":8 =8AChD<[N6; <>[email protected]=687QGf;168E D?C6´NF7FEE a'=c38;-W4< [email protected]=<[N NQ> HFG8S˜W4G<>=Va-J <W;[email protected]=AK;/J 7N<>O>=a-N <>[email protected];S O[:8N AC< S G8<>; <[N1; <>N S˜4ACN <>a-;bca'6; <><><^AC; NmN13kbc4<[668N/<;7
;/7 4?CN°HFW<>[email protected][email protected]=N GfS68<>[email protected];+;2; 68<>+=¡ACN E ;/68bc7/;/6˜?\7E J <^[email protected]=8A%DbV=˜AC6<J H`<-S˜; H[E <><>[email protected];°[email protected]<[E bVN66H>Gf< 686¡=<';/7/<[?\EN/E ;°7 =8>AKD; J <AC68<^=8<>?C<>=Vbc;;/67 H[<^<-<>[email protected] AC4<[<[a-NmN°Ga'N 4J <W<>a-Vf;ma';/H[7 4O><>a-a-; N°[email protected]; G8O 68< =ª?,E u 6S<>V <;
[email protected]<>6S6 N V^SkE6868=¡;/7 N <[<>N’68A¢[email protected]<><>a-=c; [email protected]=>;/37 E<È7/G8a-<£? AC4=8D6<>687E 6'<[N/a';m4E [email protected]=;N 47/?C? N Z O ? # ><[;/N/7 ;¢<-N G84< 6N ACMK4D=87FDE 638<>W68<È7 [email protected]=> GfSk68AC<[[email protected];N
F
P1 P2 P3
a
bi
i = 1, 2, 3 Pi
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
a
Pi
a
Pj 1 ≤ i < j ≤ 3
P1 , P 2 , P 3
2
F
>&Q
GJ 68= D7FE 38W< SE AC47 [email protected];9bV6<°AC<[N9;/7 4?CN9H W<>[email protected]=N S S8<>; 68=<
3 HI7FE A a-?CG8<G8< ? jB= [email protected];Èbc6<+AC<N 4a-a'<>; <[N/;£AC<* ¡G8<+A\E 3!Hc7FE a-?CG8< ?
H[4=V;/?C<><-=VAC;B<>a-68= a';/<'7 4N 6 [email protected][email protected] =c3;mE [email protected]<[7mN/;m] N 468LM<>=c;;/7jT[N387FE ;/?Cbc6<-3k4687387 468LM<>7mbc6˜J 68=D7FE 38W<
G
G
P 1 P2
a
P3
! 2 ' $ F - # .0 F *, - - $ d
R
”
A
WVf?CN/; <ÈG8<>?46SL V#HFW<>[email protected]=N{G8< F bV68?5N 4=V;{G8<Èa >a'<B3E 7/[email protected]; OSINFE =N’3k<>7/; <>
<
G8<>; <°DMO>=O>7FE [email protected][email protected]; OS P <>[email protected]; [email protected];È68E = 7/a-;/7 ?4<>6„6S[email protected][email protected] E H„[email protected] ?<>=hE'E 6ha^[email protected]=`G8<°AC4=8D6<>687
V (P ) ∪ V (P )
2
A <¡AC<>a-a'<N [email protected] =c; a'4=V;/7 <bV6<¡GE =NYAC<[N„D7FE 38W<[NYNFE =N ;/7 46)[email protected] [email protected] S£AC<[N
387/?CN/a'<[N9N 4=c;9; 46N£3E [email protected] NÈ46„[email protected] [email protected] N2]
! 2 & $ F - $ $ .0 F *, &- $ Z [email protected]; F 68=h387/?CN a'< ? Z ?AKJ 68= G8<[N H W<>[email protected]=N P G8< F <[N/;BG8<mAC4=8D6<>687
368=„E [email protected] ;/<È7 4<>6 ;’[email protected]=13E E [email protected];/7 7? <BHFW<>[email protected]= P G8<9AC4=8D6<>687Ä[email protected] [email protected] <SIE AC47 N V (P ) ∪ V (P ) [email protected][email protected];
2
1
1
2
2
1
2
.*# 1
2
* '/ '/& $*# %-'
XB46N9387 O[N <>=V; 4=NÈ?CH>?˜bV6<>ACbc6<[N9? uD7FE 38W<[N£3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 N bc68?LM4=V;9; 46N r 46<>7£68=
[email protected];C<#O[<G SE =:kN < E A\6EhH[N/[email protected]`; <ƒG8G8<2<ƒH[<[H[NÈ<^D;/7F7FE E 38LWE [email protected]<[A N N 4<#=c;+a^E E 68=8; ?U4I>T H[7 4< a-E38N ACN O><)a'ƒh <>H>=V68;F7/E ?C<>[email protected] 6<[N N < ?,L <>4;2687=468==<m387O>O>;/a'6G8OW< M
G8H[4<[a-N£D387FAUT>E ;38<W<[G8N < E (B68A\; E4IN/H[;F4E [email protected]>7/a'7/68<>=VD;F?\EE [email protected] k!<[eN·S? =46NÈ7 <>=VLM4&MH 4=N # A\E-;/W4[T N <G8<_ EN/; <>7£;/7jT[N
"
A <°;FE 687 < E 6
&!$#"% >/? k A <[NÈ;/7 4?CN£D7FE 38W<[NBE 68; 4IH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=V;FE [email protected] <[N°E LM<[H k 46 Q N 4a-a'<>; N
A <BD7FE 38W< a−b−c−d <[N/;NF468LM<>=V;£E 3835<>ACO P [email protected] \ D687 < >/? k ? l J <[N/;’AC<[email protected]
35D7F<>E ;/[email protected];£WD<Ä7F7 E O[38GfW68<[email protected];E #È68; 684I=QH[4NF4a-a-38a'ACO>a'<>;<> =V? ;Fl E J [email protected]<[7 N < ;%E # 6N3N E ?K7/S ;£E LMAC<<[HÄH ACE<N9H ;/E 7/7/[email protected] O{?\E <>A˜;GfNF6„4=QD7FH[E 438a-W38<mACO>Lca'?CG8<><°=c;F<>E;[email protected]<6 S
ACXB<438; [email protected]=NBN DbV7F6˜E J [email protected]<[N/D;7FEE 386WN N <2?MACbV<¢[email protected][email protected]=N <W4KM [email protected]; 7F#'E 38A\WE <{eg4G?CJ NÈ68=m:[email protected] E 7/38;/?%W<Ä<>;B:[email protected][34E a-7/;/38?KACS·O><>a'; <>AC<’=c;FH[E [email protected] <-38G8ACO><a':8<>[email protected]=c3;FE E 7/[email protected];/7 ? < ?
G35f6<>;/[email protected]@;£[email protected]=D<W7FKM ED387FE W38<Wbc<268G?˜J =68<°=hN [email protected];£383WE<NÈ:[email protected]=„3E [email protected]/[email protected]=;/? <W?5KM DA 7FE E 38W <^ ][email protected] 7 7 eg\ 4D?C68NB7 =< 4>/; O[?KQS< ? K S<[N ;9AC<°[email protected]
P4
C5
4
1,3
>
&! #&%
.
>/?KQ A EQD7/?!<
>/? k4? l J <[N/;168=‘D7FE 38W<`E 68; 4IH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=V;FE [email protected] < ?
<
[
/
N
#
;
7
>
<
8
3
7
[
O
F
N
>
<
V
=
;
O
\
D
8
6
7
<
l J <[N/;%AC<Ä[email protected]%35<>;/[email protected];;/7 46l [email protected] [email protected] ?/A < -/ -'<[N/; AC<D7FE 38W<{H[4=V; <>=E =c;¢68= ;/7/?\E =8DAC<
7<><>;Ä38AC7< O[N <>=c;NFO4=V\;D68AC<[7 NÄ< N >/<>? 68k4AC? N’DJ 7F<[E N/38;W<><[=N£H[4E 7 68<’; 684cH[=4Da-7FE3838ACO>Wa'<Ä<>E =c68;F; E [email protected][7 <[4NÈa-E[38LMAC<[O>H+a'H><>[email protected]=V=;Fb-E [email protected] 7 4< a-?sA a'<’<>;F; E N 68 7 LM< 4E [email protected] 7
k!e ?
A<
C5
C5
>/? * 7 4?CN97 <>387 O[N <>=c;FE ;/?C4=NBG8< C
A <ƒD7FE 38W< C <[N ;Q7 <>387 O[NF<>=V; O G8<„[email protected]<>7 N <[N a^E =8?U>T 7 <[N#N/687 A\E:\D687 < >/? S? A E
38A\E7 <>G8a-<>?U6ST>Vf7 <#?UT>a'7 <>< 387 7 O[<>N 38<>7=VO[;FN E <>;/=V?C4;F=E ;/?CAC4<'=˜egSBE [email protected]; =ˆE 38AC<`3E [email protected]; ;/7 H[<#4a-H[4a'a-< a'AC<#< AC<#[email protected]@Nƒ6Nm35<>3k;/<>[email protected];Y;/[email protected];mE =c38;/7/[email protected]?C;/N/7 a'46)< ? 3Z E [email protected]
H[HFW4=8<>a-=<[email protected]=y< ?G8<ƒZ 68AC47'=8A\DE¡6<>;/76847 ?CN/O ?U>T a' <><=7 W<>E 38687 ;O[N <>G8=c4;FE=V;/;-?C4AC=˜<[N^SÄ4<WVI=y;/7 ACO><„[email protected]; [email protected][;#N-E LM3843?C<>E =c7F;^EGCF ;/G87 <><`6SVªH[4NFa-4a-a'a'< <>68; = N
=G4J E =h7 >E; G<2r EG8H[4<>=V=V;9; NAC<[N9 <><W= fV :;/7 EO>Na- [email protected]; <>O[;9N9H[LM<>4A\E-?C<>NF=cE ;È=ACN£<[N9bc6G8<+<>6SAC„V<°HN W4a-<>a-a'[email protected]=`<>; G8NB<+<>=„AC4:=8DE6N ? <>687 O =<+3k4N Nj[T G8<
A < <[N/;°AC< D7FE 38W< #ƒbc6E ;/7 <'N 4a-a'<>; NG84=c;AC<-H[4a-38ACO>a'<>=V;FE [email protected] <1=<
Ha'[4<>=c; ;/NÈ?C<>7 =V<>;+387bVO[6˜N J<>68=V=; <ODNF\ <>D6868AC7<m< E >/7 >?KRS; <? ?pl A J <[< N/;9 68- = 1.0D 7F E 38 W<2E 689; 4c<[H[N 4;£a-AC<°38ACDO>7Fa'E 38<>W=c;F<2E [email protected] LM< <[? [email protected]; N 4a M
&! #&%
6
6
&! #&%
>/?KE Sm4=vEˆ7 <>387 O[N <>=c; O
X
@
?
D
8
6
7
<
/
>
@
?
&
>
[
D687 < S4=hEQ7 <>387 O[N <>=V; O ?
K3,3
>/? e A < Gf?\E a^E =c;
K4
<>;N 4= [email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<Sm=4; O
L(K4 )
? X?NM
>0e
&!$#"%
>/?KR A m< G8468:8AC<WM Gf?\E a^E =V;
&!$#"%
>/?KE &! #&%
K4
>/[email protected]>&[ <>;
L(K4 )
K3,3
>/[email protected]>/> S4=^E 7 <>387 O[N <>=V; O£AC<{[email protected][email protected]=<{D7FE 38W<ÈG8< E[LM<[H£68=<{=c68a'O>7 4;FE ;/?C4=
X
@
?
D
8
6
7
<
==8?UE T>;/7 68< 7 <>#[email protected]<QE [email protected] <<[N+E 38N 43a-E 7Fa'EGFC<>;/; 7 N <È?68=1H ?CN;4a'OSk447/=¡38W8E#?CN/7 a'<>38<+7 E[O[LMN <><[=VHB; ACO <9ND47F=E 38H[W4< a-G838<BACO>G8a'O>3<>=VE ;F7/;E [email protected] a'<'4G8=V<Q;/7Fa^E =cEG;M
[email protected]=E N/38?Wbc<[NÈ6< 7 <>387 O[N <>=c; O[N+<[N/H ;Q;E < 68; #-4IH[H 4;a-<238N AC4O>a'=V; <>=V;F E [email protected] < ? R $A’ S5egEbV686;Q<:8HFW?C<>E=bV6=< 4; E <>7 7Q>; bc<m6G8<#<AC<[AKJNQ68=hG8<><[6SN/V ;
68G8=<[N¢<£N =44a-S= a'MdE <>7 ;>N¢; <ÈGfG86'<{H[AK4J a-E 6838;/AC7 O>< a'? jB<>=c=';FE 7 [email protected]<>7 a^<9Eeg47 7/bVa'6<><>7F=VE ;Ä E egACE [email protected];ÄN¢E 68== <[H[*,G841;/?C bc6< "bc-6V<£SMACH<[NJ <[=cN/; 68M a'#GM O>Gf7 [email protected] <N
bVGf6?\E <QDM4N/?=EAKJ AC4<„=¡GfE6G8GfH [email protected] ;/7/?C74O=8S =4< =AC<[4N :8;/;/7 ?C4<>=c?CN+;-H ; W84?!s6 k7r 4<[68N°7 GN J 68A\E`=< H[4H[=4N/AC;F4E =8=c=; << SGa^J 68E =D<[email protected][email protected]< =¡]<S54>&6QS?8GL J 684=68<7
K3,3
L(K3,3 )
>&R
.
83 [email protected]ÄGJ [email protected]=fAC<£e 4D7/a^7FE E38;/W?C4<È=:8N{[email protected]/68E 7/7¢;/AC?”<[7 NÄ<>H38E 7 7/O[7 N O[<>N¢=c;a^O E \DD?Cbc6867 < <[N >/[email protected]>&[email protected]? 7 l k4J <[> N/;’? ACRd<£A<[38N/[email protected];6N’WE3k:8<>[email protected];/;/[email protected];¢<>DAk7FG8E 38<£W=<È4;:8<>?N7M
3\DE 7/68;/7 ?5<-bV<[68N/?;[email protected]= ;’68D7F=E <938N/W68<':[email protected]; ?C4IN/H[?C44=^a-G838<ACO>a'<>=V? ;FZ E [email protected]='7 <[email protected][email protected]=bc<W6MK<QD7FAKE J 438=¡W< G87O[<>N/[email protected] =O[<QN <>3=c;E OÈ7 N/687ÄA\E+a >a'< ?
0{<>[email protected]=< M< k EB387 468LMO9bV6<AC<[N%N <>68ACN%[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<[NE 68; 4cH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=c;FE [email protected] <[NÄN 4=c;
S
?
S SfAC<+;FE 687 < E 6˜S
<>;
K3,3 \ e
K4
L(K3,3 \ e)
K1
L(K3,3 \ e)
P4 C5
>/[email protected]>/> L(K3,3 )
>/[email protected]>&J &! #&%
&!$#&%
L(K3,3 )
<>;9N 4=hH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=V;FE [email protected] <
K3,3 \ e
<>;
L(K3,3 \ e)
A Em=4;/?C4=„GJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<°<[N/;Äa^E A\E ?CN O[< #mG8OW\[email protected]/a'<>[email protected]<>a'<>=V; Sfa^E ?CN{H[<>A\EQ<[N/;
;E 4668N ;N ?k# H>A\egEE [email protected][email protected]£;’bc356˜4NJ 68N [email protected]=ƒ:8AC=< 4amH e:8? 7 <ES> <>=c{;/?C]<>6879=ƒ461E [email protected]=ƒ7/[email protected];/7FW8E a'38<ÈW< <[?<N/;¢A 68E2=1=44;/:S?Cr 4<>= ;’G8a^< E 7F;/EW38O>a^[email protected]; ;/O°?CbVG6J <B68= ; 4E 68AN;M
[email protected]/[email protected] ;/S W8G8a'<><Q3868<[?CN/N ;9G8;/7j<[[T NmNB; [email protected]<>a-a-3534N27/;F;/E 7j=c[T Nm; <27 <[N H>?˜68AKJAC4O[=hN·S <>4=c=ªLc?CNFNFE E [email protected];2<2bcG86<[<'NBA\E EY38387 <[[email protected]?CH H WE <>;/7 ?CHF4W=<1N G387FJ E E [email protected];/DM?C4bc7/[email protected]<[;/W8N ?pa'u <[<N
7F?CH>E ? 3838?CG868<[7 N°<[N <>=8G7/J ?CE [email protected][email protected];7/[email protected];/ACW84a':E<[ACN <>? a'l <>[email protected]=V; 4;=ACN+<[N H[4a^a-E a';/W<QO>a^<WVfE <>;/a-?Cbc386AC<[<mN°AK38J E [email protected] <[4N 7/[email protected]);/W8a'=<Q46GN+J¢LM64H>[email protected]?C4G8=<2N°[email protected] <7
ACG8<{<ÈH 38E 7ACH>46868ALMGf<>76 G8L <[P NÄl;/Wu O[4G87j<{>T a'G8<><[6SNQV [email protected]<>=V35;/4?C7/<>;F7 E N =cbc; 68N ?8 <>0{= <)[email protected]; ScG8;/<WNFO[44=27j>T [email protected]'=c; <+O>7 G8>< ;¢P°387FE E 6;/N ?CbVN 6? <? ? 3k ?<>7/* a'46S<>;M
;O><;FegE [email protected];-?CN SLrE 6DN 6bc<ƒ6˜<>J E ;Q6`=a-<#[email protected]@E?C<>?C6NFE [email protected]; 6 3EN AK+J 4N/:S?U[T r H><>AC;'<S”G8A\<1E#7 =<[4HFW;/?C<>47 = H WG8<[<2N'7F3kE [email protected]; <>O [email protected]<WGKM Ja 68=>a'E <[email protected]? 4X7/[email protected][email protected];/=W8E a'AC<W< M
a'AC<-<>a-=c; [email protected]@?CAC<><Q6G8G8O>LM<[<>NmAC4E 38=83k=<>O[a'<[N <>=V>&;E /G8[ <E1A\E^38;/A\EWH[O[O'47/A\?CE1< =G84<m;/A\?CE^4=H[4G8a-< 387FACE <W38IV [email protected]; [email protected]; O^E [email protected]DM4J 687/=ª[email protected];/W8E [email protected]?C4bc7/[email protected];/< W8G8a'<><#3868E ?C6 N
H +687ÈG8<mbV6<[N/;/?C4=N9;/7jT[N9Gf?32^H>[email protected]<[NÈ<>;9387 4 eg4=G8<[N ?
>&E
') # # )+' &/ ! )+ #% %&
3G84E 7-=VÈ;’68A\= =E7 =O>4 35am14. =:81 NF7 <È< £G8\<[O>=8N/3k;%?9<>G8G8=WO <„G'\=868NjHc?f=8a23?CbcE :567 4<>A\ACa'EB<[N <>G8=V4 ;£=8. =G8O[<£<{AKJG[email protected]=J 68N/* =-;FYE 4=4S: 6H[r< <>? . ;Z a^?A\E E;/,W7 O>O> 35a^<>4E;'=;/N ?CG<bVJ 668#+<{=A\< 7E<>bc38-67 O[<[NFN/<>;/=V?C4; = O
=a'<^<>=V3k; <>S56868; =>;/E 7 [email protected]<ƒDM4bc7/[email protected];/< W8a'd4<-68? <[14N/;B6 68=< =4G8= <[FSN %H>7/[email protected]=38;/3?C4E =¡7/AC<ƒG8<QG8AC+< 4=8D6 1<>.6817 \ =8?C< SkG E * = NB 68 = ? .0X E gLM W< M
G8 O> 35 <>?=* ,G4E6=cN;=bc+46N{<È E [email protected] DM<B”4S5AK7/J [email protected][email protected];/=W8J 68N/a';F=E <Q<[=N9H[N/68<E [email protected]<>; 7 ;¢<B4eg=c\4;£=868?C357/<2=84?CG68N 7JNF4E [email protected]=V=O>;N/7F;F68E E ;/==?C<94H[=< 7 N+O>G83k<[O>4ACNO>=Da'N 7F< <>E =V#°38;FWA\E Em<[[email protected] bV<[Sf6N 4<[61 N/. ;/G8+?C4<[*,N= .D0*7F.3-/E . 38BW=<[ <N E[LM<[Hbc6<>ACbV6<[NÈ4:Sr <>; N9N 683838ACO>a'<>=V;FE [email protected] <[N N 4a-a'<>; N SHFW<>[email protected]=NÈGf6 D7FE 38W< ? ? ? ?
B
j
–
=
E
8
3
5
3
>
<
@
A
C
A
<
$.$.0 G8<#AKJ [email protected]=N ;FE =H[<ƒAC<ƒ=4am:87 < G8<ƒiN HIam:k4AC<[N =O[H[<[N NFE [email protected] <[N # NFE
4
?
L
7H <>W38<>77 O[4N=<>N =V#;FE O>;/L?C4E = [email protected]<>7’4A\68E 79*,H W Ebc.06<$E [email protected]<È7/[email protected];/JW8E a'[email protected]<4S7/[email protected]<>;/;{W8a'3k4<68Sf7{HJHF<[WN/E; MbV#G6M <°[email protected]<>7 =c<9;/AC?C<È<>7 =4amSV=:847 <6N£GHFJ 4W35<>WO7 MM
7F;FEE ;/=?CH[4<2=NG8<mO>AC;FO>E a'[email protected]@<>AC<=V;FE [email protected]<[E N2=NB=O[ACH[<2<[38N [email protected] <[email protected] G8<[1N <[N #1H AKEJ W<N V8? O[X H>468NÈ;/?C<[4N=;/[email protected]^< E ;/AKJ?CE [email protected]=DMN 47/[email protected];/<QW8H[a'4<'a-383kAC4<W68Vf7°[email protected]; 68O2=N < <>7 [email protected]==cN ;M
;G84< s6 rA 4E 68=7 GNBE G86 4=8] =O[<[N #'68? =u <[email protected][7 4<Y=bVN/;F6˜E J 68=V;=r<2E [email protected]@7/;/[email protected][email protected];/[email protected]?Ca'H E <h;/[email protected]<[LMN/<Q;'38G8j7 < T[N H[#4a-AKJ 38E ?CACG8W< Vf<[email protected];G8O <mA\E =4;FE ;/3?C4E = 7
<7FWEVf;/<>?Ca-4=38N+AC<35S4LM68<>7°68;'W< V8GfO[[email protected]>7 68<ƒ; <>bV7 6˜AKJ [email protected] A£E [email protected]<WDMVf4?C7/N/[email protected]; ;/<1W8a'68=<^<ƒN/68H[7B4=68N/=;FE<[email protected]; =< N/;FE =; H[<><[email protected]<ƒG8<QbV6;F<1E [email protected]@ACAC<1< =4am<[N :8;B7 [email protected]< =fegGO>J7/4?C<>3k68OW7M
?
#
XB46N H[4=N/?CG8O>7 4=N+bc6˜J 68= E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<-<[N/+; *, * 'N J [email protected]<[N/;+<>= 1 . . SHJ <[N/; M #GM [email protected] <9N/?NFE+H[4a-38AC<[email protected]; O9<[N/; a^EGr/47 O[<£3E 7¢[email protected]= a'<9GE =N A\E+;FE [email protected]@AC<
[email protected]<{;/?CAK4J [email protected]='=N/=;F4E S==MH[1< < 2^? BH E=^H[< E [email protected] 4<{7/[email protected];/7W8<>a'a-<È?C<>G87 4#°=V;’E[LMA\[email protected][7¢47 a-<>a^38ACE W< [email protected];6OBO9<[bcN/6; <{:5< E 6H[NF4<>687F31E+G8G4J E [email protected]£DM437/E [email protected];/7’W8G8a'WO \<<[NM
H7F>EA\E?CNN 4N/?C=8bc=6E <[:8N9AC<#N J <WG8V8<#O[H>7 68<>38; <>7 =VO[;ÈN <><>=c= ;FE ; ;/<>?Ca-4=3NÈG8<[35N [email protected]==84=a-O[?\<[E N AKSS8N [email protected]=<>a2G8O>:83kAC<<>=>G;/E7 <a-a'l 4<>:8=VW;+E G8a <°; 4Jf68e ;ÈS˜HFa^W4E ?N?CV N
AKG8J ?C<>G87/=8O[<?C<>G7QJ <>EY=ƒE eg6E [email protected]/7 ?¢<AC68<'= 38H>7 7/<>[email protected]; T>?C7 <><72G8eg4<7/H>amA\E68N ACN/O'N? \AKHJ ?CEG8;/O[?C<14=hN 4<[68N/LM;9<>Gf=c6;21< LM# O>7/UV?N\EO[H <# bV’6Gf<^a'A\4E =G8G8O[N H[4k68Q LM?<>7/l ; <<
3GEJ [email protected]È=„L E[E [email protected]<[DMH47/[email protected];/=W8<a'a'<°<><>[email protected]=ƒ[email protected]<>; 68<>7 a-<3H[N{[email protected] 7 HcO>=W4<>a-=N/?\?CE 4Ak= 3kG8468<°7{H[68<>[email protected]=168N? 38M H>7 ?4? :8UA T>a'<+LEmDMO>=O>7FE AC<>a'<>=V;ÈG8<
E;/[email protected][4N 7/<[email protected];/68W8AKJ7-a'<WVIH[< ?C<>N? 7/; ;F_`<>E [email protected][=?C<°NN1G383kJ 76844=h68:87#UAE T>[email protected]; a'DM446<[7/NNƒ[email protected];/W8ACAC<[a'<[N1N2<°3838=7 7 444:8=S:8UA M UAT><1T>a'2^a'<[H<[N„EN H[bc<m6NF<Y <>7F=* EQ#4 6;/7/Nƒ[email protected] ;/ ?\7FE E AC<[email protected]%; ? <>[email protected] 7 4=˜4=;/J W<N„7 VI<°G?CN/N E ;4=<ƒ6N„H>E ?˜6H[N<>H><>;/687F; = E<
G84=HG8<+7 <[H W<>7 HFW<>7 G8<[NÈE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<[N 1< 2^H EH[<[N ?
GGJJ 68E 7=„jB>; E=1<[[email protected]°DMH[44] 7/[email protected];/N W8?C<G a'T>7 <<ÈS? DMZ<[N/O>?k;{=AKJO>A\4E27F=„E NFAC4E<>a'a-Gfa'<>a'=c<>< ;È;£G8bVbc<°66˜<ÈJNF684A\=ƒE=#E;[email protected][email protected]@4AC7/<+:[email protected];/G7 W8<J a'68G8=1<°<+DG8N 7F44E a-=c38;£Wa'AK<J<>Sf<>; =V<>N£;/=#7<>O[;9;F<°E G8=c<[<+;N/;N bc46˜68=ƒ=1J [email protected]==DN/47F;FamE E 38=:8WH[7 <<<
[email protected]?;’:8ÈUAE T>6-=´a'a'<’E [email protected][email protected]=S= 7/N¢[email protected];/38;/W87/7 [email protected]'<>LI=?\<ƒEGfAK7E S <[email protected] H[<[=c4N/;m=8;=68LE =E [email protected]<-N =mNTE; G<>[email protected][<[AC<#<9N/3kG8H[O>4<{7 a-<>AK7J [email protected]=68AC<WN/=;FVI<ÄE [email protected];=H[O#4H[a-<<[SMN/384;AC=-W< [email protected][email protected]; 4; OÄ[email protected];’a'bc6<>[email protected]<{[email protected] AC3k<>6847 68<Ä7 . bc3564< 68$7 #; 44686 ;
3G84E 7=8e =4O[?CN <[N 1?pA <[NB.7 <>?38XB7 O[4N 6<>=cN9;F=E 4;/?C64NÈ=NN 4H>6A\H>E?CNF<>N/7 ?C4bV=6N<[NBENG8N <[)< NÈh°D3k7F<>E 6 38WG8<[<°NBA\3EQE 7 7È<>38a^7 EO[;/N 7/<>?C=VH[;F<2E ;/G[email protected]== H>G8?CG8<+<>==H[4<N
46^[email protected]?CN/; < GJ EGr/EH[<>=H[<[N£NF4=V;{<[N N <>=V;/?C<>[email protected]<>a'<>=c;9O[[email protected] AC<>=V; <[N3k4687ÄA\EmH[4a-38AC<[email protected]; O+G8<
n
n
O(n23 )
O(. . . )
c
n
c × n23
"
O(2n )
"
"
n+m
m)
O(n+
J/[
.
=; <>4a-NÈ3E NÈ[email protected]@[email protected]=7/[email protected] ;/[email protected]'7 < <[? N·SGE =N£A\EQa'<[N/687 <m4'„=46N£=<G84=8=<>7 4=NBE 6H>68=`E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<m<>=
DM<[N/4; 7/[email protected] ;/3W8E 4a'7'6N<[H[N <>; SÄ7/<>;F=bVE [email protected]==?BN^N <[N/#'E;^N 3835G7 <[JO[H>E H>; [email protected][email protected] AC<><>H>687+7/7 [email protected];/N#6?CbcAC<m<„6=E 35:844;/AC<[email protected] =c<Q?;#* 3kG844<„[email protected]=V;'LI;+6GG8<J <mE :kH[LI446=c7 <2GLM<>S%N =V6868;/7B=y?C4A\E#=8E [email protected][DM<>44A°a-7/[email protected]<>;/38;'W8ACW<a'a^VI<„[email protected] ; r/O a^47/G8E [email protected]<[;[email protected] <?CNA NM S
G<>= E =a'Nm&4 ACHM< <>[email protected]=7 <<'?,G8u <[N<[email protected]°N 3kS5<>a 68;>a'>;/< 7 <-N/?%[email protected]=VH W; O>E7 H><[68NF=NFE H[=V4;2=V35LI4?C<>68=V7;2:kbV< 6˜E J 668H[=¡468E [email protected]´DM4G7/J [email protected][email protected];/=W8N/a';FE <'=H[<><[=`N·S; <>[email protected] <N
<WVf354=<>=c;/?C<>AN <>7FEQ; 46sr/4687 N{[email protected]£AC<>=V;BbV6˜J 68=YE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<<>=„; <>[email protected]=4a-?\E A
1 $ - * 1 $. . . 1 * >[email protected]˜N < 3k<>68;9bV6< N [email protected];£N/6 2^NFE a-a'<>=V;
D<>=¡7FE =387FGmE 35;/?C4bc6867<-bV36E <¢7°NF<>AKJ6868AC=<[N˜<'AC4<[N˜6¡[email protected]=AKJ NE ;F68E ;/=7 H[<'<[G8N <[G8N<’a';FE O>[email protected]@;/ACW<¢4c;/G8j7 T[<[N˜N ? [email protected]=f eg=¡O>7/?C38<>7F68E 7 ;/< ?CbV# 6<NFS˜468?C<>=´=V;E [email protected];/DM7F4E 7/[email protected];[email protected];/E W8:8a'AC<[<N
<W<>V8=<>a-; <>38a-AC<3?N ¢=h468;/7 35<S”<>6835;-468G87B4=AC<[H N >E ;/387 38<[email protected]?C38H 7 E O ;/e ?CO>47F=E N :8AC38< 7FE #h;/?C68bc=–6<[EN [email protected]\4E^7/[email protected][;/4W8=a'N/;F<„E =V<>;= <[email protected];/[email protected]@?C3H EGE 7M
;/[email protected]<Q<9<[=N 4;¢[email protected]\=^EƒGG8J 4>=8;/7 =<94==O>N°D=˜[email protected][email protected]<[< N/E;°:8bVAC6˜< ? J [email protected]<Q=E [email protected]=<>Gfa'?CH <>E =V;/; ?CSc4A\=´E°G8H[4<Qa-A\E138AC3k<WVI<>7 [email protected];e 4O 7/Ea^[email protected] 4=7/H[[email protected]<-;/W8< a-<?C[bVH>6;/[email protected]<ÈLM;<-<>[email protected]<<
AKN J4E [email protected]; 4#m7/[email protected]';/W84a'=„< E[]cLIAK?CN{J [email protected][email protected]=38GfAC?CO>N/a'3k<><>==VNF;FEE :8;/?CAC4<[=N£N/\?5=AKE J 4AC<=„G8N <È<ÈAK38J 7E O[[email protected][7/H>[email protected];/3kW8a'< G<+J <>E ;{[email protected]<[?CN’H E ; ;/<[?CN/4; =NNÈ<>H[[email protected]>7/7j?CT>bc; 6<[<[N N ?
77 <[<>=#38N/; 7 G8<mO[O>N 6838<>[email protected];’;F4EG868;/<£?C;/4H[[email protected]=<[N¢NBN [email protected]>a-G87/<[email protected];/ACG8?C<mbc46=8<><[;È=N O[38S<[68A\NÈE+?CNF<>H>NF;9A\E E=VG8N ;<[N/N?S”N9\bVA\H E68E =8? ;/DV?CE'4E =1DMAKJ <[E[G8NBL<[E N’G8=V<+E ;[email protected]<Q47/[email protected];/7FW8JE >a'a-;/7 <[a^<mN¢E3k38;/<>7 ?C6YO[4NF= <>G8? =VO>;3kO[<><È=H>GN? EM G8=V<[;+NFG8N/6<[NN
X 46N68;/[email protected]@?CN <>7 4=N%N 468LM<>=V;AKJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<eg4=GE a'<>=V;FE A8H>N? M G8<[N N 46N ? X 4; 4=Nbc6<
H;/[7/<>[email protected];:86E [email protected] DM4# 7/[email protected] ;/W8? ra'IN <-;/7F3EfE S”7 3eg4E ?C7 NH[<^E 38bV356˜<>J [email protected] A¢Eƒ3O>E ; 7 O H[4AC68< 7 38N7 <><>= a-?CA\<>E 77/DM#1<>687 7O[N G4J6E Gf:k7 4<'7 G 68=¡<[38N ;7 4N :84AU68T>LMa'<><-=c;[email protected] 6; NM
DMZ O>HF=W8O>7/?7Fr E LMA <>7 AC< H >&W[<>k [email protected]=-E G8DM<’< 3kRf4e [email protected][email protected]<[68N9a O[H> A\? E X [email protected] 4H>?C6N N N <>7 a'<>=c<>LM=c&4 ; HMNÈ4W8=?CN’N ; E 4627/[email protected][email protected] <[<N ?G8< (ÈACW< VE =G8<>7
% ,7p*psd#0`6 2 1 5 ! 75 U1
*,*5G B=„D7FE 38W< <>;ÈG8<>S6 V„N 4a-a'<>; N <>; G8< ?
!
È=„[email protected][4687/;ÈH W<>[email protected]=`G8< GJ <WVf;/7 O>[email protected]; O[N <>; ?
t
t
t
O(n23 )
O(2n )
G
!
O(n + m)
?
s
t
G
G
s t
'/) # ) $& )+ # $&/
>3k< =468; jB7È<>a-=68=`[email protected];9357 bc44:86˜[email protected] 68T>=a'=ƒ4a-<2387?\G8E4<2A¢:8UAG83kT>O[4a'H>68?C<m7°N/?CE4AC<-38= 37 <[EO[N/7/N ;È;/4?C668<>Gf=V=`7; <4#2?:SrBA\<>E =; *7 .3* <>1387 O[ N <>*,=V;FN E J [email protected]:8A-ACW< <QVI3?C-N E ; 7B<B 68687 <[==YN/<23 E N/[email protected][email protected]; 7/<[email protected];/W8\ a'=8?C<< G8N/?{< A\NiEhHIam7 O>:k3k44AC=<[NN <„ScG8E O>6ª3k<>38=7 G4E:8=VAUT>;9a'NF<„<>68<[AC<>N a'; d4<>=V68;£? G8< 7 AK<[J [email protected]/=3 N/?;FE ==H[4<+= <> ;? bcÈ68= ?5<WVf ?CN/; <B* 1N/?5 <> ;{*,N <> 68AC<[<>N/a'; <>68=c= ;
H[<>;<>7/bV;/?N68\?H E <[;9N/; G84 =c1 ; A\E2;F.0E [email protected]@AC <+<[N/;1 :547/=O[< . 3E 7{68=1. 35? 4l [email protected] <[= N/a; 'M #G<+M Gf<>[email protected]=17 <ƒA\Embc6˜;FE J [email protected][email protected]Ä[email protected]<[email protected];< AKW< J [email protected]=?CN/N/; ;F<>E 7Q=H[68<= S
E<>;[email protected]/[email protected]?I;/7 W8O>a'3k4< =<>G =^d4; <>68a-? 3N’7 <[35N/43 @A HI? ==44a-=?\E AKN/SM?838<>7 ; <>=N <>E 68=cAC;<>a'<>=1<>=c<>=V;¢;/N/7 ?fO[AK<9J <>AK=VJ [email protected];/=7 NO[;F<£E <[=N/H[;%<È68<>=-;’H[AC<È<>7/H[;/<>?N\7/;/H N? E\;’H EGf; 6 S
4#168A\? E 7*<[.0 N/3 ? Gf6 =4 7 = <[N/È3 3k? 468 7 H[<>;/B; <2N J [email protected][email protected]=A¢N/W< ;FVIE ?C=N ; H[<2< ? 3kjB468=`7GfH[[email protected]<;+38bc6˜7 4J 68:8=hUA T>a'387 <-4:868UA =¡T>a':k<'4=¡E 38H[3<>7/E ;/7/N? ;/\?C<>H =cE ;;
P
!#"
$ "
JS>
[email protected] =V6 ;/7 d44IGf6868? [email protected]; <[ N¢7 <[3N/E3 7¢? UV=E4H = ’ ?6Gfa'A <[4N==G84N ;/?Ck/4k =NQ? RdG8A<'<[N/H[; <>H>7/A\;/E ?N\[email protected]’H Ebc; 6˜NQJ 6835=-468387m7 468:8=AUT>a'387 < 4:8L AUT><[a'N/; <#; 446s=cr/;2468O>;7 ON
X L <>; l 4/X L6? B=<BH[4=sr/<[H>;/687 <BH[O>AUT>:87 <+E 2'7/a'< bV6<ÈA\E°7 O[H>[email protected] 4IbV6< <[N/;ÄO>DVE AC<>a'<>=c;
Lc7FE ?C<-]
*5")f#0-. 2 l = 3 l ∩f* 3 l - 1. 1 - * 1 * - - - , * 1 *, - .0 $ . - . $ 1 . ./ - .0 - , "
Bi E 383kGE<>AC=4N =NÄbc6˜J 68? =B<B=`e 4=LMH><[;/H>?C; 4<>=1687°:k4c:k44IAC4O[AC<>O[=8<>== < # LE 7/?\E :8AC<[N{<[ N/;68$= <9eg4N/=? H>;/?C4= G8< ?
L 4687{; 468; <BLE 7/?\E :8AC< :k4c4ACO[<>=8=< N 687 S84=1O[H>7/[email protected];
I
S
>
<
{
;
4
ƒ
=
E
8
3
k
3
>
<
@
A
C
A
<
?
G:5844I<>=84; =ACO[O[<><B=8G8=H[4<[<a-N G8a'.< <;/71684=^-?CNÈ[email protected][email protected] ;/4I; BGfO>7F68=E [email protected]<ƒS6;V [email protected]:5=?54IN/A 4;FEACE'O[=<>bcH[=16<Y<[G8G8N/< ;/< ?CH>4A\=`E 6G8N < <[N Sc<[H N/W;^Ebc686=<[<+N/<ƒ;ÈH>e G8A\4E <m=6H>G8N ;/<BO[?C4H>O>?C=y;FG8E <>:5=c7 4I;ÄN/4A\?E2ACO[4<>N = =84a-=3k< <>a'68<;
NFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected] < ? Z ; <>LM< l 4c4 „E G8O>a'4=V;/7 Om68=YW< VI;/7FE47 Gf [email protected]=E [email protected] <m;/WO[4j7 T>a'<^]
{0, 1}n
{0, 1}
x
x
x
n
ξ ∈ {0, 1}n
f
{0, 1}
x := 1 − x
3
f
f (ξ) = 1
f
3
f
` *p +! 2 ' ,* * N ' ]
. - . $$ . . - - 3 .0 - 1 - 1. 1. 1- 1 - . $ 1 " . . B
j
¡
=
f
G
@
?
;
V
b
6
Q
<
C
A
<
8
3
7
4
8
:
UT>a'L< 3 <[N/; *, . ? L [email protected]°DMO>=O>7FE AC<>a'<>=c; S˜; 468;
A
38G87< 4X :8AUL T>S·a'[email protected]< <WΠVf?CN/G8; <¢<+68A\E =< H>A\ ENF N -<C*X <[ N/;9 Gf [email protected] ; / E *,6m 38.7 4:89 AUT>N a'?<35468? 79l HFJW<[EN/;bVM 6#G<°M [email protected] 7 <Ä4:8bcAU6T><¢a'3k< 4Π687
Π
#"
#"
#"
0
[email protected]=64<°a-38?\7 E 4A :[email protected]=VT>LMa'4I< bV6E =cG8;<C68X =<-L SN 446= N G8MK7 [email protected];9;/[email protected]=4<-68LMG84< [email protected]£7 O[e [email protected]/68=8;/[email protected]?C7£4=68=`G8<E [email protected]? 7/[email protected] ;/?%W8a'68=¡<m38<>=„7 4;:8<>AUa-T>a'3<N
=˜J E 383 E 7/; *<> =. E ? =V;{=Y3E38N 7F#mE ;/A\?CEbc6H><A\ES”NF35N <Y468X 79L a'3k4<>=c68;/7; <>>7°;/7 bV<B6˜7J 68O[[email protected];{7 4G8:8<9AUT>A\a'ENF<24<[7/N/; ;<ScX 4L=1M GfH[[email protected];Äa-bc386˜ACJ<>[email protected]”; <[4N/6 ;
X L M Gf3? 2^H>[email protected]<[email protected]”N/6 2';ÄG8<9N/68383k4N <>7’bc6˜J 4=^Gf?CN/3k4N <9GJ 68=1E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'< <>='; <>a-3N’354 M
[email protected][Hc4=a-4a'a-<?\E NA843k64N 68MK7 7¢4AC68<{;/[email protected]=O[N<m43564Gf687 <79S7 38O[68NF4?CN’6G8Gf<{7 <a'<>4= =V;;/7<><>a-7’3bcN96˜3kJ 44='[email protected]=<>468a-; ?\68E ;/[email protected]@68?CN= <>7¢38H[7 4<>;Ä:8AUE T>[email protected]'DM4<27/[email protected];/6˜W8a'J 4= <
N7jFT>E a'[email protected];m<G8G8O r < # l >4I;/74 < 5SfX egL4=M H[G4E a-; <>3868AC7B<>; G8S<H[A\4E-a-;/a'WO[< 47/?C<m G8<A\3E-E H[7m4W< a-V838<>a-ACW< [email protected]; < OQ? E [email protected]\4E 7/[email protected];/[email protected]; <'?CbVGf66´<S5;/4W=hO[4 E M
38A 7<È438687LM<>O£a-bV?C6<><£7£G8W< V8<{<>=a-438a2AC<+:87 <><>=#6SV ;/W38O[7 447/:8?C<°AUT>G8a'<[<[NNÄDG87FE<£38G8WO[<[H>N£?CN/Em?C4O>=^; O+N 4G8=c4; =8X =OL M 3H[E 47 a-l 384cAC<>4 ; 'N [email protected] 68LMN? [email protected] 7 >QSa'> < ?]
Π0
Π
#"
lDG*59,+ 2 -6
B=„D7FE 38W< G <>;£68=h<>=V;/?C<>7 k ?
!
Vf?CN/; <WKM ; [email protected]˜68=<H>[email protected]?Cbc6<G8< G G8<+;FE [email protected]@AC< k !
X L M H[4a-38AC<>; l 4I4 O/J ?
/ LI?CG8<>a-a'<>=V; SAKJ <WfV ?CN/; <>=H[< GJ 68=´E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<-<>= ; <>[email protected]=4a-?\E A 354687+7 OWM
NA 4J [email protected] =8<?C4=Y a^ EG/r <[4N/7/;[email protected];F68E [email protected] <<bc<[6N/;9<[N/bc;/6˜?C4J 68=„= eg4; =<>AGEE a'[email protected]<>4=V7/[email protected];F;/E W8ACa'<S”<ma^=˜E J ?C<WNÈVI?C<>N/=; H[<°4NT7 E <2=4N968G8LM4<>687/; ; < <°#-3EH[N< ]r 4687 ?
#
J/J
.
*$" /#0-6G 2 = l 6= 3 l . . $ 1 . ./-/ - ,
$* "$#0d"$# jB=„[email protected];9bV6˜J 68=ƒD7FE 38W< G H[4=V;/?C<>=c;968=ƒD7FE 38W< H N/? H <[N ;68=„N 46NiM
D7FE 38W<[email protected][email protected];ÈG8< G ?
;4".% [email protected];2bc6˜J 68=´D7FE 38W< G <[N/;mNFE =N :8?CGf68AC< ;/7 46˜SGf?\E a^E =V; [email protected][email protected]? +N J [email protected]Ä=<
H[4=V;/?C<>=V;°E 6H>68= :8?CGf68AC< ?
`6; ". B=<£H WEGCF =<È<[N/;%68=<£N/[email protected]; <£G8<£N 4a-a'<>; N GJ 68='D7FE 38W<{; <>[email protected]<£bc6<£H WEbc6<
NG4J Ea-68a';/7 <><[; N2 E NF7 E >6f; e<[NAC<9bcG86<>< 7/=8H[?C<><>[email protected]<[N°[email protected][;¢H[AC<[<9N NFN/E [email protected][email protected] L<[E N°=V3k; ?!4u687°E =NFEN¢;/AC?C<£N eKDE [email protected] <38WA\E1<[email protected]\35=8<>[email protected];/; ?C4-H =yE ]kLM4AC<[[email protected]
*, ?
`6! " È=`H W<>[email protected]= <[N/;968= D7FE 38W<QG84=V;BAC<[NBN 4a-a'<>; NÈ35<>68LM<>=c; >;/7 <247 G84=SM
=G8O[O[NÄN/[email protected]=<È<°a^AC<E =8HF?UW>T <>7 a-< #°[email protected]=he 4N/7/68a'7£<>AC<[7Äbc686=<><ÈAACH <[WN9EGCFN =4<a-NFa'E =<>;NÄN H[E4387 G83< E ?!7FEA ?CEN N =<>=V4;F; E G;/?CE 4== N£vAKJ 4−·7 Gf·7 ·−v
? ? ? S v ? l < D7FE 38W<+<[N/;68=ƒHFW<>[email protected]=„3E 7G8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=˜Sfa^E ?CN{a >a'<+N/?5AC<[N{N< 4va M S
a'<>? ; Z N ? v N<[4N/;=c;+68=ƒGE HF=WN<>a-68=`[email protected]=˜DS87FN/E ? 38W<>< ; G SN H[4<Q=c;{=˜G8J <[<[N/N{;+N 34Ea-N a'eg4<>7 ; H[N{O>G8a'< <>=V;Sf68E =¡AC47 HFN W<>[email protected]=´G8<
G
G8O[N/[email protected]=P<°AC<N 46NiM H W<>[email protected]=hG8< uP GJv<WVf;/7 O>[email protected]; O[N u <>; v ? P u−P −v
9
B=H)IH H>AC<„<[N ;Q68=<ƒN/[email protected]; <ƒG8<„N 4a-a'<>; N-GJ 68=D7FE 38W<ƒ; <>[email protected]<„bc6<ƒH WEbc6<
NAC<°4a-D7Fa'E 38<>;°W<[email protected][email protected]˜;+3kAC<2<>68N/; 68ƒ[email protected] =VLM;[email protected]È AC< GJ N/E [email protected];/L7 E <[=VN+;°E Gf7 >6¡; <[G8N<>7/]f=8AC?C<[<>N 7°*,O> ;FE =V1;° ? AC<Q387 <>a-?C<>7 ?,u E =N
G*$- B=h;/7 46¡<[N/; 68= D7FE 38W<-E[LM<[H'E 6`a'[email protected]=N k N 4a-a'<>; N°G84=c;+AC<[N NF4a-a'<>; N
35E 38<>6835LM<>[email protected]<>AC=c<°; ;/7>4;/76Y<'AC44=87 G8D'4;=84=68O[;9NQ;/G87 4< 6ha^E&E VH =8E ?U=V>T ; 7 < E 6„#1a'eg447/a'[email protected]=<>N 7Q 68N =´4a-H)fH a'H>AC<><-; N NF? E =N2H[47 G8< ? jB=
% "$#0 A <°387 OW\<8V < E =V;/? QG8O[N/[email protected]=<68=<°387 4387/?CO>; OQ46Y68=<2N/;/7/6H>;/687 <mGf6`H[4a-38ACOWM
a'<>=V;FE [email protected] < #Q68=<<WfV H[<>38;/?C4=Y387j[T N]8AC<[N£3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=N E =V;/?CNiIH a'O>;/7/?CbV6<[N ?
lDs %0 L E 7 eg4?CN´E 3835<>ACO OsL l (∆, ∆) Sm46 N ;/7 <>; H W<>7 ?DA <[N 387/?CN a'<[N¡N 4=V;G8<[N
D7FE 38W<[N¡4:8<>; =-<>=V7 6<>[email protected]?\E #r=V;Ä335E 47/68;/[email protected] 7¡; 4G868<; G8<>AC6S<[N’¶V N 4;/7/a-?\E a'=8D<>;AC<[N N¡Gf<>?CN ; r [email protected]=c3; EN 7¢{a68=',H aW<>,[email protected]= } <>; ?
{b , b , b }
A <[N9N <>68AC<[N9E 7 >; <[N9NF4=V;9H[<>[email protected]<[N9G8<[N£i HFW<>[email protected]=NÈ<>;£G8<[aN£;/7/?\E b=8DAC<[N ?<A <[N£NF4a-a'P<>; N
G8 7 <[<[N+N/3 ;/7/? ?\$E =8DAC<[N°N 4N/?=V;AC<[N¢E 38;/73k4<>?CACN’O[NBH WAC<><[[email protected]*,= N N -4=cGf;¢6`338E 7/[email protected]?CN/N a' 7 < <[? N/È3 ? =`[email protected]/3?CEN/a'[email protected] N < ? <[BN/;[email protected]; 7/?CN/a' <
<[J N/;¢ AC<°[email protected]; <>.368 A˜38Q7/N/?CN/?a'E 6-<°a'bc684?˜[email protected]==˜N J <[AKN/J 68;£=^3EG8N9<[N%AC4;/=87 4D^?CN¢<[N/HF; W<>[email protected]=? N’<[N/;¢G8<{AC4=8D6<>687E 6-a'[email protected]=N
-.;<%G _8sd%G A <[NhbV6EN/?NKM 387/?CN a'<[N N 4=V;`G8<[N„CD7FE 38W<[N`4:8; <>=V6N#3E 7/;/[email protected]<
G8<><>6S; ªV ;/7/3?\EE =87+D68AC<[=¡N-H GfW?C<>N a-/r [email protected][email protected]= =V; N {aG8<Q, c,AC4d}=8D6<><>; 687m{cE ,6`da', [email protected]}=N <>=> 7<><>;[email protected]?\ACE <[=VN+;'N 4AC<[a-N a'N 4<>a-; N a'<><>; N;
c
c
S
>/? RdA,1H E <>=„[email protected]£68= HFW<>[email protected]=
d 3E 7£68= H W<>[email protected]= S G8<+AC4=8D6<>687BE 6„a'[email protected]=N
1
n
1
n
i
1
1
2
3
i
i
2
3
i
6
0
0
0
S1
0
0
0
3
7 <>[email protected]?\E =V; 1# 68=N 4a-a'<>; <>;°68=H W<>[email protected]= 7 <>[email protected]?\E =c; 1# 68=N 4a-a'<>;
a0
4
a
S2
b0
6
6
J/O
? R A’=˜J H¡EhE 6H>68=<#E 68;/7 <1E 7 >; <^bc6<'H[<>[email protected]<[N2G8<[N2H W<>[email protected]=N <>;mG8<[Nm;/7/?\E =8DAC<[N
H>A ?N<[M G8N9<[HFN WN/<>6a-N [email protected]=A N <[N{N 4<>a-; a'<>; 3kN <>a68<>LM; <>=Vb; N >4;/=c7 ;£<E G838< 3kAC<>4AC=8O[ND6<> 68 7 1[S? $Z 1?°AKJGf686ƒ= bcG86< EN/?NMK38S 7/?CN/a'<[N/< ; ?
G8<+AC4=8D6<>687 E S6Ya'[email protected]=N > S4= [email protected];Èbc6<+AC<bc6EN/?NKM 387/?CN/a'<°<[N/; * S? S
l G;4 +6 L E 7 e 4?CN„E 383k<>ACO[< OsL l (∆, P ) ? A <[N#3IH 7FE a-?CG8<[NƒN 4=V;ƒG8<[N^D7FE 38W<[N
3k4H[<>:[email protected];68AC<><[7 =VN; 6G84N 68<[N#'; iHF3WACE <[<>7/N¢a-;/[email protected] [email protected]=a-GN2J a'68<>;= <>; GfNN 6¡4aa-;/<>7/a';?\E <>b=8; D3aAC<E <>?67’; L 68G='E J7268H =hWG8<>OW;/a-\7/=8?\[email protected] [email protected];/=8?CPD4AC=˜< ?/S˜A {b68<[=N¢,N N b<><>6868,ACA¢b<[N¢G8}<[E N<>7 >=hHF; W<[7 <>NÄ<>[email protected] ?\[email protected]==c=V;N;
<[E N/6`;ma'E 684; [email protected]=47/N ?CN JSO ?$#A <Q>;/N 7 4<'a-G8a'<-<>AC; 4=8D<[6N <>;+68E7 38> 3kS<>ACAC<[OmNmAC< E 68*,;/7 <[N2G8G8<[email protected]\LME'<>=V3!; cH 7F>E ;/a-7 <'?CG8G8< <-? ACA 4J [email protected]=cD; 6O><>7 68>;7
G8<[N£3!cH 7FE a-?CG8<[N <[N/;9bc6˜J <>[email protected]<[aN9H[4=V;/?C<>=8=<>=c;B; 46s/r 4687 N968=„;/7 46 [email protected] [email protected] ?
b
1
2
1
1
i
i
2
3
2
Y.
A <[N2D7FE 38W<[Nm3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N 4=V;2O>; O#[email protected]=V;/7 [email protected]; NQ3E 7 l A\E 6G8< 0{<>7/DM<#E 6G8O>:868;2G8<[N
Ea =8>=a'O[<[<’N G>&E E=/N[ 68=Q# E A\E„7/;/?CN/H>68AC<{[email protected]; E<#DG7 O J 68E =:8AC<H WE<>[email protected]=4<>68a'7 <>68=c=;'<ENiN IH N =V<);/h^W4H[[T 4N <Äa-H[384ACa-<WV838<^AU>T bc; 6˜<ÄJ [email protected]’<[N7FE7 H[<[4H =cW;<><^7 [email protected]<[?NNM
35N/G868<<>76l AC<[E ? N2=0{H>D<>?C7F<>7/E=DM38<WG8<><[< ; N2A 3?? E A 7l eK4·WVE [email protected]/g; g N2Nj;Fh E =A 4RS6>&> Nm[ S7 S868<>68=c==hLM4&44MH 68684LcLc=7F7FNE E DMDM# <ƒ<2bcH[H[[email protected] [email protected];/AC<[<[7 H>H><';/;/? ?e7 e%O 38eg38O>[email protected] 6:8<>NÈ[email protected]=?CO1H[7 O[<[NFH[Nƒ4<>6=V]˜;N268S=A\38Eh68E Gf:87/;/[email protected]@7?C?CH>Om<[ACH><^N ;/4?C6846== N
A\_ Eƒ? Gfl [email protected] WV<[6H>;/Gf?C=4=4 LfG8N < MH A S,?X i ? EiÈa 4:[email protected] <><)7/h ; N (B4=˜A e 4S =L6N ? @=Z <)<>IH ; a'0 4?687+iB<><[;+<[G i ? E*k W<>4;°a^68E=N E J/7/[ ;/?C?$H>ACu <-<27 O[a^H[<>E =c=8;2?U>T G87 <<
683=#E 7 3kegE <>[email protected]ƒ; N E 3=EE7HFW8A\7 EY4=8;/W?CbVO[64<7/?CS8<„4=1G8<#3k<>A\E`68;£H[4EGa-/r 43868AC7 <WGfV J [email protected]; 68O ?k? a'A <14;/[email protected] <>47{:8AUAK>TJ [email protected]'=V;/<„7 4IbVGf686?{H>;/=?C446=YN-G84I<[H[NH>D687F35E <138W<[<[N/N;
H[<>[email protected]?5G8<BA\EmH[4AC47FE ;/?C4=˜Sf7 < eg47/am68ACO+H>?NM G8<[N NF46NH[4a-a'< 68=1387 4:8AU>T a'<°G8<BG8O[H>?CN ?C4=`]
lDG*59 ,+ ] 2 8* *p;S#0 *5"
B=„D7FE 38W< G <>;£68=h<>=V;/?C<>7 k ?
!
fV ?CN/; <WKM ; KM [email protected]˜68=< kM H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=hG8< G !
X L M H[4a-38AC<>; E 7/3˜S /E ?
k [email protected] 68;°E 6
?
a'È=4<[email protected]=A38N <[[email protected]/;+N{H[4H>D68A\7FE ACE <>[email protected]=7 68G87bc<N˜63kH><[email protected]?CN/68bc?6768<mAC=`<¢E H[D3847F3ACE4E 387/7F?CWEG<><CF7 ;È?&GuG844H[==4H°H=VS[;/H[3k?C4<>4a-=c68;°a'7˜68;<=46868<2=„;H>[email protected]:5?C7Fbc4E 6= 38<2WH <’G8E =<24Gf=m;F?CE [email protected]@] AC;B<χ(G)
≥ ω(G)
5
3
4
8
6
7
>;/7 <+68=
?
H[G8<><>7/a^;/?NE \ =H G8E ;ƒ<>72GfN 6‘J [email protected] =H 4= EƒGf; 46r6s/r3847 6847:8NmAU>T O>a'DVE<¡[email protected][email protected]; O1<h<>A\=VE´;/7H[<^4ACAC4<-7FE =;/4?C4am= :87 Rd<1A H <[W8N 7 ;#4a^G84E =;/H`?Cbc6=<1E ;/<>68;7 <>A\A°E„G8;FE<[email protected]@N AC<<
GJ 68=] < [email protected]˜D7FE =G8<><Ä; H>[email protected]?CbV6< ? l <¢=˜?!JL <[N/[email protected];˜NÄ3EDMN˜O>=AC<’O>7FH E EACN<>a'<>;<>AC=c< ; [email protected]=˜[email protected]<>35;/[email protected];7/; H[< 4=cbc;/67 <><WAM <W;/7fV 4<>[email protected]<3<[E N/[email protected];
C χ(C ) = 3 ω(C ) = 2
\ < χ(H) = 3 <>; ω(H) = 2 ? (ÈA\E [email protected]=ˆP [email protected]\EGM t 4687/? Q/O EO>DVE AC<>a'<>=V;
H LMO>7/?N
7 <>a^E 7 bV6O+bc6<È<>=˜; J [email protected]/; <+bV6?<>u A˜E4=V=;/[email protected];/7AKJ4O>6„DVE [email protected]@[email protected]; 3O E [email protected] H E LM<[N/<[;’H eg2nE 6NF+N <91<>NF=14a-DMO>a'=O><>7F; ENÄAKLMSVO>a^7/?NE \ ?C<N
χ(H) = n + 1 ω(H) = n
4l =mA\E 3k6<>G868< ; 0N <¢<>7/G8DM<>< a^N E J =<[NG8; <>7%[email protected]=c3k; 4O>687 <[7N bcN O'6<>E AC6SN`V D7FDE 7F38E W38<[WN%<[<>N°[email protected]<’χO>G87/=<>?N”\ a'E ω<>=V68; 7 <<WV EH>; < ?04u6[T E NVH ACE <[=VN ;247/H[[email protected][email protected]=a'<[N < S
[email protected]%E =GfN9?CNTEH[<>[email protected];;/; <A\E17 <[:5N <>;/[email protected]/AC?C< H>;/38?C47 =˜438S7/=˜?CO>J [email protected]; a-O 3k°4357/; 4<m68bc7°6; <>4A˜6DN+7FACE <>3868W7 <N3kNF4<>668N ; KM D>χ7F;/E7 =<°38Wa2ω<[68N°[email protected]=?GfE 687/;/[email protected];?N\ N H>? ?C¢<>[email protected]=AC<>a'< k<<>>=c; ; S
J/Q
#
5
"
5
5
"
J
8GG8<#<[NQA\EhD7F:5E 38<>[email protected]<#<[N-38E7 4HV38E =c7/?C;QO>; A\O1EY3:kE <>[email protected]<'AKJ EG38r/7 446838; 7/?CGO>; J 68O1=7/<#?CN Dbc7F6E <#=G8G8<ƒ4=H>[email protected]?CbcG86<^<^N <#3E 7F7-E a'<WV8<><>=a-<>7 38AC#Y< ?6H[A<>[email protected]><1;/6G8G8<[<N
D7FE 38W<[N E HVE =V; bV6<>ACbc6<°3E 7/;968=<+D7FE =G8<2H>[email protected]?CbV6< ?
"8d#0d*$" ] U] 5 ! 75 & G 1-/.01 - */ *- - $ !- $$ G χ(G ) = ω(G ) L 4687A\EH>A\EN N <ÈG8<[N’D7FE 38W<[NÄ3E 7 egE [email protected]; N·SV4=#Gf?CN 354N <ÈGJ 68=^:k4=#H[<>7/;/?N\H E ;ÄGf6#=4=
<>G8;m<>a^E 6E N=N G8?<>Gf716N [email protected]È68? <WfV3k?C4N/68; <ƒ7+AC68<2=r38E7 [email protected]:84AU7/>T [email protected]';/W8<^a'G8<`<2<>A\=–EƒH[; 4<>ACa-47F3E N';/[email protected]? cH R =A%4<[a-N/;°?\E G8AÈ435=4H 68=7^E H[;/468AC7 4<>7/A’?C<>G87#< ACN<[<N
D7FE 38W<[NÈ3E 7 egE [email protected]; N ? l J <[N/;£:8?C<>= AC<H EN]
% ,7p*psd#0`6 ] ' ^ p% #&s`.. 6 * <%
s`.s $ U1 ?
B=„D7FE 38W<3E 7 eKE [email protected];
!
È=<°H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=`438;/[email protected]^GE AC<mG8< G ?
L [email protected] =4a-?\E AC< ?
!
4AKJ =c4;38Rd;//r A£[email protected] ?CONF68E 68;^;/=`?C=474=˜A; SkC<><mH[714H[a-bV<>6=ca'<„;/7F<2EAC<[A%A\N^E-G738E <[7=H 4NBWD<>AC7F<m7 E HFa-G8WO><[a^LMN <>E ACE;/4VH?C438E =¡3k=V<>;ƒN a'<>H[a-<>4=V=?NM;°GfG868G8OW\[email protected]<2; =8:8?C#7F< E AK= J lE H [email protected] DM? <[4N 7/E [email protected][email protected];/a-W8 a'3k? 4Rd<h7/A˜;FH>68E ?N;/=VM [email protected];[email protected]?C<[<[N N°NF<2N/G86A\E<N
a'<>=QO>7F;/WE ?C4IN G84<[= N%G8G8<’<[38N7 <>[email protected]@:[email protected]>T NFa'4KG<[8N <[GNJ [email protected]=68N/?I;FEÈE :8A\EÈ[email protected]@[email protected] ; O>O{38=c6868;FEa';/?CO>47/=?CbVG6J< >?s;/A7 <ÄEÈ;/7 7j<[[T H N%WGf<>?37 2^HFWH><[email protected]<GJ #£[email protected] [email protected]>4a'7/[email protected];/<>W8=Va'; <><7
3k7 <[<>N/7 ; e <m47/G8a^4E==cH; G4J E6‘H>;/H[64E [email protected][email protected][; <>O 38? ;/6<>[email protected]<>a'<>=c;hN/[email protected]<`3k46871H[4AC47/?C<>7„AC<[N1D7FE 38W<[Nƒ3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N
D7FE 38X W4<[6N#N#[email protected] LM34E =7 N'eg?6E [email protected] ; 6yN ? bcu 6<„4=ACH<[S¢N-G<;/[T7 4N^6bcN'6˜[email protected] a-68=–3E [email protected] EN#38<>W;'<hAC<[H[N#4=VE ;/=c?C<>;/[email protected];/;ƒ7 4AK6J 68N^[email protected]J3<>[email protected]V 7 N1S¢[email protected] AB4<[=cN/;^;[email protected]<[N ?
0
0
0
"
EG864=N N Hƒ?’A\[email protected]`[email protected] eKN-E [email protected]; 7FE =G8<[N2<„DH>7FA\EE38NFN W<„<[NQG8<1NFE D=7FNmE 38;/7W4<[6N^[email protected]=V;'E [email protected]=<>;Q3kNF<>E 68=;'N <[EN/3k=V;/O>[email protected] ;/<>7 7 46ªA\E`[email protected]<>37 E [email protected]<[7QH>;/N ?C44=c= ; ?
l <>A\E r 6N/;/?N\<+A\E-G8OW\[email protected];/?C4=`N/[email protected] =V; <']
"8d#0d*$" ] ! 1 G 1 1-/.01 $. *, - $ $ - (B6 G8O>:868;+G8<[N+E =8=O[<[N >&E /[ S l A\E 6G8< 0{<>7/DM< E^O>=4=H[O G8<>6SVhH[4=sr/<[H>;/687 <[N+H[OWM
AUGfT>?C:8O[7<1<[N3E e7-?4X8A68AEQM<>387 7 N <>4a-= ?U>T 7k<E SS%GfH[[email protected]; <1< bV*,68 ?{ AKJ Eh* -/H[4 [email protected]; . # A\Eh ;/WO[47/?C<ƒ1 G8<[N [email protected]>ST[GfE-7 O><[;N'O°E O>=c;/;/6S?NMM
:8G8ACO>4Ia'bV46=cE ;/=c7 ; O[N <2 <>bV= 6<#>&Ef=e4> 6]N =˜J O>LM4IbV6<>7 4=NQ3ENQ?CH>? ? X [email protected]=E AC<>a'<>=c; S A gNih[A A 4·LsgNjh#AKJ E
` !*p +! ] 1 ` !*p +! +8% 75G;<_`.!%a_6;<b ;4d#&% * <% '<= G 11 1-/.0 G 1 A E G8<>6SIV ?U>T a'<+H[4=s/r <[H>;/687 <°G8< l A\E 6G8< 0{<>7/DM<S .0 *, * - , 1 1 $ SfE°eKE [email protected];’AKJ 4:S/r <>;£G8<È=4a2:87 <>6N <[N{7 <[H W<>7 HFW<[N ’E < l WVL/g ;FE Ak7 <[H[<>=N < [email protected]
Ga^8< E ?Q/[/J/[[/[/E J 7/;/] ?CH>AC<[N°N/687+AC< N/6s/r <>; S”[email protected] J/Q E LE =c;GJ >;/7 < \ =E AC<>a'<>=V;mG8O>a'4=c;/7 O[<^<>=
.
` *p +! ] ` *5 +:bc*pG#a+6!% 7p;<_8`6% _6;<b ;4d#&%
`,-6+8"6* % *59 G#&%&*5" *5-6 `6*5;<% ] 2
Jfe
+ 1- . 1 $. 1 A
\
E
\=G8<^AKJ E =8=O[< J/[/[/J S˜A\E 387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] AC<#bc6<[N/;/?C4=ª468LM<>7/; <^N/687AC<[N2? lD7FE 38W<[N
3:8AUE T>7 a'egE <[email protected]; N E¡7 O><[; N/O ;FE \[email protected];'=E H[AC<><>[email protected]'AC<„<>G8=V;1<ƒ7AC<>O[68N [email protected] <[H[34E =871=_`E ?CNFE NF7/E ?\E=H[l <„Wc<>6=Gf=; <>4 a-LfN 3N-HMS{[email protected]>Hc7F=E 47 a-G ?\lE A 47/=V6<ƒO r/3847 AC4N M S
[email protected][email protected]=8D A [email protected]˜S L E 68A Z <)Hca'4687{<>; +7/?CN/;/[email protected]=E 6 M4·Lc? >&E S J/J S Ok ? (B6^H WE [email protected];/7 < S
=46N9G84=8=<>7 4=NÈbc6<>ACbV6<[NBG8O>;FE [email protected]/6879AC<>687 N9a'O>;/W4cG8<[N ?
X
@
?
=
E
C
A
>
<
'
a
>
<
V
=
;
k
S
C
A
[
<
N ! 1. 1^N/687BAC<[N D7FE 38W<[N+3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N 4S #^NTE[[email protected]
A\NFE´E =H[H[4<ƒ=sr/G8<[<[H>N ;/68D7 7F<hE 38e 4W7/<[; N <SÄ3EAC<Y7 [email protected] ; 4N :8S%AUNT>4a'=c<;^EG8s6 <hr 4A\E´687 H[G4J WcAC4687F?£E ;/7 ?CO[4N =)[email protected]<>N;ƒ?H[u <>[email protected]<168?+=4G8am<Y:8A\E´7 <>67 <[N H[<[4N#=8bV=6E <[?CNN MM
;/[email protected]=N^N97FG8E <>38a'?CG8<>< 687 bc<>6=V<h; H[H[<><>[email protected]<>? =G68E;/[email protected][email protected];B?CNFE4=V68;ƒLM<>A\7/E´; <[a'N S8O>AK;/J WW< Vf4c?CG8N/<; <>=G8H[<h<AKGJ O>J [email protected] [email protected][email protected]@3DM4N 47/[email protected];/8W8<`a'=<[4NB;FG8E a-<H[a'4<>AC4=V7F; E ? ;/?CjB4==
N:[email protected]=68EW; E [email protected][email protected]; 7 <><[7FN-E [email protected];-<[O>NmDVDE 7FAC<>E a'38W<><[=VN-;-G8G8< <[N-0{E <>[email protected]/DMDM4< 7/? [email protected];/jBW8a'=<[H[N-4=bVN/68?C?<G T>;/[email protected]<ƒ<>=VG8; 4=3HƒE 7/bV;/6?{<^G8<^A\E 387 7 <[4HF38W7/<>?CO>7 H; WO[N-< H[G4J a68= M
;/G8E [email protected] 4DM\=´4=87/[email protected][email protected];/;/68?CW84LMa'=„<>7/<e; 4< dH7/?[a'4X a2<>[email protected]:8AC; < [email protected]?==E Nm; [email protected] <<'#GA\E„8<^=4H[;/4?CAC44=7FE G;/?CJ 4E =ª[email protected]/<[[email protected];/W8Da'7FE < 38dHW[<[4Nmam3:8E [email protected]=egE E ; [email protected];[email protected] <<[^=N/;˜68J E =<#3EbVNm6<[G8N < M
XB46N9387 O[N <>=V; 4=N GE =NÈH[<HFWE [email protected];/7 <m? 68=hH[<>7/;FE [email protected]=Y=4am:87 <2G8<7 O[N/[email protected];FE ; NBN/687£AC<[N
D37FEE N138#ƒW<[AKN J <W3VfE W7 E eK6E [email protected]/; ;/N [email protected]Æ[email protected]; E O 7 ? e 4jB?CN%68;/E7 N <-N )< =h{4E ;/=7 <'H>?C<>[email protected]==N 47FXBE 4=;/H[7 <#<<>H W;°4=N? V24N<[N :k;<[N/N 684S:[email protected]=r/N<[H>N/;/3k? eO[<>H>;?N\=bV<Ä638<[N7 O>35; <>4=68G 7
A\E Em6´N/LI686´[email protected]; <+G8G8<'< A\E H[< 7 O[;/7FN E[[email protected] ;/[email protected]?C4Sc=ªAC<+G8H><[7/[email protected]; T>;/7 7 < 4?C7 N<>;38<>7 =V46 :8UA <[T>N a';<[H[N·<>S [email protected]<>?;2G8=< 4A\;FEE a-3k<>a'7/;/<>[email protected]=V=;-<>=G8H[<'<°A\G8E <[N387 7 <>O[68N/68LM<#[email protected];FE Gf; 6 N
;/WO[47jT>a'<+e 47/;BG8<[N£D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; N£3E 7 l Wc6Gf=4 LfN !H&. ?
ega'E [email protected]<>; =VNXB;FE 4]È[email protected] AC<[NQ<[N N a'? DA<>7F=cE¡E ;/38?C3k4W<>=8<[7 =NYeg4<[:8H>=;/[email protected]?C4E ?C=rH>7/?{;/?CG8ACN <[<[S9N-N'AC<[bVDNY67FE E [email protected][email protected];/=7W<ƒ<W<[MKN#DH>7FA\:8EE [email protected] 383N WE<[<[N7/N`;/[email protected]; <<[<[N/N ;^:[email protected];/37/E [email protected]"LI7/-;/?\?CE N ACSÈ< Y<>G8;h<><[email protected]<Y<>D687F7 7E O[NY38N/W68H[<[[email protected]; N a-< 3383E ACE OW7 7MM
W< Vf<>a-38AC<2Gf6hAC<>a-a'< >/[email protected]> ?pA E^3k<>7 e <[H>;/?C4= G8<[NBH[4a-38ACO>a'<>=c;FE [email protected] <[N°G8<m:[email protected] 7/;/?CN·SG8<[N
[email protected] [email protected][=N/W< [email protected]; 7F<>E =V38;ÈWG8<[<Nm;/G87 < 4?C:8N£[email protected];/3WE O[7/4;/7j?CNT>a'<>;<[NBG8<[G8N< H[ [email protected] ACO>a' LM<>[email protected] ;FE [email protected] > <[S N2Q/G8[ < S [email protected][email protected]> =S W< MKesDJ 7FE ?38W<[NQG8< :[email protected] 7/;/?CN
u E =N=4;/7 <Ä;/7FE[LE [email protected]·=46N E 687 4=N 3E 7 e 4?CN:k<[N [email protected]=2GJ [email protected]=feg47/a^E ;/?C4=N%N/687A\E9N/;/7/6WH M
;/6868=¡7 <;/WG8O[<[4N9j7 T>[email protected][email protected]'=<W<^MKDH 7FE E 7F38EWH>;<[O>N 7/?CG8NF<°E =c:8;[email protected]<[E N°7/;/[email protected][email protected] =? W< Z [email protected]=E E38ACW4<[=NQNB<>bc=¡6< DMO>A =4 O>7FE <>[email protected] 0{[email protected]Ä<>E [email protected]=2'< 7/Ma'< <'O bc6E <-38NF7 Eƒ468H LMGE O M
7FXBE<>H>[email protected]; AVO>iB7/?C4NF:5E ;/<>?C7/4; =¡NF43= E 7°? RdN =4G86O>N 35MKD<>7F=E G38E Wa-<[a'[email protected]<>==cGf;[email protected] ;[email protected]=V<; <>AK7 J [email protected]; ;/Nm7 <O>S ;FLE [email protected];[email protected]@<>[email protected]=`3835eK< E [email protected] ; <>G8WO 4r ;%#1<>H[;64XB=8?C=VH 6W<-4A\G8E<N
iÈ46N N 43k468AC4N£4=V; <>=N/[email protected]; <°G84=8=OAKJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<2N/[email protected] =V;m]
"
p*5d#0`8 ] ' `.*p# 'S' *$-.%0%&*p_ *$- *5% 2 -,2
B=„D7FE 38W< G ?
% ,7
J/R
? Z ?˜68=Y; <>AD7FE 38W<=˜J <WVf?CN/; <°3EN S
;
>
<
A
V
b
6
<
l 4AKa-J E [email protected]<WVf7/[email protected][email protected];/; W8O^a'] <7 <>; 4687/=< ? =˜J <[N/;93EN968=„[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W< ?
:[email protected]<)3H E XB7/>&;/68?C[fAN e ?=˜RdJ AEE22'HmN <>EB7/a2a'G8:8<<¢AC:kW<bcMK6˜4; =8MKJ <>[email protected]=A5= <[N NG84=87F<>EWDM?C4O N 74#N9=NGfN 356 #9O[H[H>H ?\<>EE A\N£[email protected]?C;/?N 7/<>È[email protected]=2?\H[E ;/<>A˜W;G8O[E 4<[email protected]\T>4EQa'7/[email protected]<£;/7/W8?!E a'k<=°H><°?C<><>E ;9=QS6 GfV'G86„< [email protected][email protected];/=t 7/W< ?\EMKE NFD=8N/7FACDE <>AC387 <WS <[G8N£W8<>[email protected]; V < M
D# 7FAKE J [email protected]<[4N97/[email protected];/W8!? Oa'>7<B<>G8=V<; NÈA 4<>=VW;£4;¢; 468s6 ='r/[email protected][email protected]=7 W<N£MKDG87F<[E N{[email protected][email protected]=<BW< G8MKD<{7F:8E [email protected] <[7/NÈ;/?GfGf!? O!? O>7><>7 =V<>=V; N;Ä?<Gfu 6-4;/=7/H°?\E N/=8?D4AC<=„ScG84='4=8<[=N/<;
H[G8<>< 7/;FA E <>[email protected]=W4bV;26N <'<'ACN<'35DO[7FH>E?\E [email protected]?CN < <^G8<-7 [email protected]<>68; N?4MK68a 7/=>a'O#<#N <>E 7FS6E V¡:[email protected][email protected][email protected]=E W< 7/MK;/D? 7F? E (B38W68;/<[7N <>a'G8<-<>=V:8;[email protected] [email protected]/; ;/S˜?CN AKSJ E <>[email protected];m4H[7/[email protected];/a-W8a'a'<<
[email protected]<WA’Vf<[?CN/N ; ;<'G8H[O <>r 3k#„<><>==¡GE ; =V<>;Qa-683=´[email protected];/[email protected]=O[O 4E [email protected]><a'S˜<[email protected]’N/<[68N 7;°A\[email protected]„a-N 35;/47/6N N H>[email protected];/:868AC7<'<#GG8J E <[a'NmO>[email protected][email protected]@=?C4<W7 MK<>D727FE NF38EƒWH[<[4NQa-G838<'ACW<[email protected]; 38O W? <[RdN A
:[email protected] 7/;/?CN2]
! È=YD7FE 38W<
R
G = L(R)
G
O(n + m)
R
` !*p +! ] ;<;< f# * ;4"8" U 1p1
$ G - + G - . $ & 1-/. 1 G 1 - X 46N'E[LM4=N#G8O r #h7 <>=H[4=c;/7 >&O EfesAC<[[ N 387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] 6SV;/WO[47jT>a'<[N'G8< A gNih[A A 4 L/gNihMS
G8G84<[N^=8=DO[7FNE 38E W6 <[N^G8O>3:8E 687 ;°eKE [email protected];<[N N+? E X =84=6O[<[N#N E LM4=N^Sk:k<>;B<[N e [email protected]==–G3kE a'468<>7^=c;FA\EE¡6SNV`[email protected]; 4< 68G87+< A\E^=H[44;/7a-<„38;/7 7FO>E WL<>E [email protected]+N ?C4G8= <
;/G8WO>O[;F4E [email protected]>T N{a'N/68<238G838<[ACN£O>a'D7F<>E =c38;FWE <[[email protected] N9<[N£3E N/768eK7ÄE [email protected] ; <[NÈNÄ<[;/N/7F;£E[LAC<E 6S. 1hV ]V 68=1 4 68 ;/[email protected] <[.N N *,<>=V ;/?C<>AG] E =NÄA\E°387 <>68LM<+Gf6
! ] = * <%
G - v ∈ V (G) $ G
. 1 - -/ - - - v " . 1. - . v .3 G 0
v 0
0
L 4687+G8O>a'4=V;/7 <>7 AC<°;/WO[47jT>a'<2G8<[NÈD7FE 38W<[NÈ3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N S A 4 L/gNihma'4=c;/7 <m<>= eKE [email protected];
ACG8<24=8;/W=O[O°4687j>T =a'<<2387N <>[email protected] <=cN/; [email protected][email protected]?N<[\ N O[;È<[email protected]<°6NÈH[<e 4;/7/W; O[? 4_h7j>T <>a'=c;/<'?C4] =8=4=N+bV6<-P ? PEN/3E 7/?\E = Q/J E
` !*p +! ] .2 - * <% 'S= G 1 1-/.0 - -/ - G G α(G )ω(G ) ≥ |V (G )| A 4 L/gNih+E2O>DVE AC<>a'<>=V;{[email protected]=c;/7 [email protected];{68=<B=4;/?C4=#[email protected]/;FE =V; < ? Z 4?C<>=V; α, ω ≥ 1 G8<[N
<a'>=c<>;/=c?C<>;#7 NQN/?£<>;3k4G687-68;=´468D;^7FE N384Wa-< ?a'jB<>; [email protected];2< bV6< S GAC<ƒ<[DN/7F; E 38(α,W< ω) 0 3k <> 68; >;/17 . <„„3N/?ÄE 7/<>;/;[email protected];/N ?C4<>68=8AC=<WO M
<>= $α. H>[email protected] ?Cbc 6<[ N2$G8 <';FE [email protected]@AC< 2ω; 4<>68;m;-<>Dv= 7FE ω38WN/G< ;FE bV:868AC<[?£Nm=˜G8J <[<^N ;-;FE [email protected]@EACG< N-α3\E? v7 jBegE =ª[email protected];#E <>38;-3k<>; <>[email protected]< bV 6 <„HFW EH>68= G8<1N <[N N 46N KM D7FE 38W<[[email protected][email protected]; N <[N/;Q3E 7 egE [email protected]; ? X 4; 4=NQbc6<#A\EYH[4=s/r <[H>;/687 <#e 47/; <1G8<[N
0
0
0
0
J/E
. D37FE E [email protected]<[N 4N-=V3;2E AC7 <[egNE [email protected]; <>N^68GfACN°[email protected];'D7FN/[email protected]<[AC<>N2a'a-<>[email protected]=8;^[email protected]^bc6E AC<1<>a'AC<[<>N-=V;/;Q7 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] ; [email protected] 7 ?.N'A <><';-;/ACW<[N'O[4E 7j=cT>a';/[email protected];/<^7 4N/668N'[email protected][email protected] a =V;M
<[N/;£68=<H[4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[email protected] <[H>; <Gf6 ;/WO[4j7 T>a'< [email protected]>&[ ]
` *p +! ] 252 * <% '<= G - $ .
.3 G 1 .0 A <[N-D7FE 38W<[N^3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=E :8AC<[N#4=c;'G8<„;/7jT[N-=4am:87 <>6NF<[N'387 4387/?CO>; O[N'[email protected]=c; O>7 <[N M
N3FE E =V7 ;egE<[[email protected] ; N [email protected][email protected]/7 62'E/O ;G8? <ÈX a'44; =V4;/=7 N#<>79bcbc66<Y<È3k; 4468687^;D387F7 E 43868WLM<<>713EAC<h7/;/;/[email protected];/W?CO[44=87j=>T E a':8<AC<°egH[447/=V;1;/?CG8<><[=cN#;£D687F=#E 38;/7W4<[6 N
[email protected] 4338E 7/[email protected]?C7'O>; 4O[6NG868<[=yN°E D=V7F;/E [email protected];/7W4<[6–N°[email protected] 7/3;/E [email protected];/[email protected]?C4? =8A =<ƒE :8;/ACW<[O[N 4? 7jXB>T a'4; < 4=N/[email protected] =V< ;-L a'EGf4:5=V<>;/7/7 D<YACE/<[N[ 38E[7/[email protected]=E H>[email protected];[email protected] O ACr<[# N
[email protected]>a'3E 47 =Veg;/E 7 [email protected]; N H[? <2;/WO[47j>T a'<-GE =N+AC<2H EN [email protected]+7 <[N/;/7 <>[email protected]=c;+G8<[N+D7FE 38W<[[email protected][email protected]^E AC<>a'<>=c;
` *p +! ] 2<] 5 ;4".+ -.;4" 7 G*p# #& .2 $ G - (α, ω) $ 1.0 ,* n = αω + 1 $ .0 G + *1 n *. #- $. . ω G + *1 n 1 1. $.$.0 α * /- G 1 ! *1 ω *. #- $. . ω /- G 1 ! *1 α 1. $. . α /- *. "- G $. . ω 1 *1 "- 1. $
.
.
G
α
/- 1 1.0 G $. . α 1 * 1 "- *. #- $
.
.
G
ω
-/+*1/- + v G $. - - #- *,.0 G \ v
,* ω *,-/.0- "
L E 7-;/WO[47jT>a'<„G8<1G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4=˜S%=46N-<>=V; <>=G84=N-?CH>?{; 468; 7 O[N/[email protected];FE ;^E 2'7 M
a^#+68E =V=;È<9bcN 466<+N 35M H>4A\68ENF7ÈN ;< 468;£4D6^7FE :838?C<>W= < G 3kG<>J 6868=; <>;/H[7 <><97/;FH E [email protected] =NF<2O H> G8A\EO[N H[N 4< a-C35S844NF6 O%:8G?C<>J 68= =G<9a^E 38E 3=8E?UT>7/7 ;/< ?C<>=V;
/ *2<>=´[email protected]/?C<>687 N Ca'47 H[< E 6SV G? È=; <>A¢7 O[N/[email protected];FE ;QN <>7FE GJ E 68;FE =c;[email protected][email protected]=V; O>7 <[N NTE =V;
LMbV<>67F< E jBA\EQG8='<BN 3k4:k<>6468N =8;’M =H>G8A\<[EO>N£N :NF38E < 7 ;/4;/C738<97/NF?CAC<>O>47F; =8E2O[DN N ;[email protected]<>H[a-a-438a-3ACN’< a'35<><;£4368bcE7’679NT< E[<WAKLMfV J 44<>[email protected]ÄO>38N7F?8EAC<+;/; ?C<>AK4AJ =E 4386'G83<+;E <>7/G8A; O[<>;/H[=W4EO[a-=47jH[3k>T < 4a'N/#[email protected]<B;/A\?CE<[4N/= H>;’A\384E6'NF7 NO[<=N <>4C7 = M ?
6838=7 438LM7/O>?C7/O>[email protected];;FO[E Nƒ:8ACE<ƒ[email protected];/4W7/O[[email protected];/7jW8T>a-a'?C<ƒbc6G8<[<ƒN G8 JO[H[[email protected]/r [email protected]=V35; 4S{N H>[email protected];/[email protected]?C?Cbc46= <h? l G<>J E 7/7/;F;/E [email protected]>=68N A\E 7 ;/O[?CN468= [email protected];FE? ?; N-? S{4=VG;-J E G868<^;/7 <[:kN14=835=<><[7 NM
a'<>=S<>\ ;/=Y; <>4=V=V;°;BG8AK<J E[a'LE 4=V=c;F;/E 7 DM<><m7°G8:5<m< E N 6J E H[[email protected] ?CbVG86<m<>7 ;/W#-O[G847j<[>T NÈa'H>A\<[EN N NF <[O>N9; [email protected]<°< DG7FJE E 387/W;/?C<[H>N968A\;/E 7j;/[T ?CNÈ4= A\E 7/SDMG<[NJ E 68 3;/7E <[7 NM
;/[email protected];/?C4=„E =c;/?CNiIH a'O>;/7/?CbV6<S8O>; [email protected]<+G8468:8AC< ? ? ? ? BX 46N£E LM4=N£H W4?CN/?A\E2N [email protected];/?C4= G8<ÈegEGM
0
0
H>[email protected]@[email protected]; OSVH[4=N/?CN/;FE =c; #+=<È3EN’<>=c;/7 <>7ÄGE =N’H[<BG8O>:E ;Ä<>;#°[email protected]=H>[email protected] <BGE =NÄH[<>;/; <ÈN <[H>;/?C4=
O/[
;3847 64:8N AUACT><[a'N <[7 NQO[N/[email protected];FLME <>; 7/N+; N =S˜4=64N+6N N2<>am<WVI:838A\[email protected] ?C=cbc;°6<>=7 O[4H[=<[N2N NF35E [email protected] 68<[7 N bc?64?’A\E#A\EƒN 3<[H>E ;/7/?C;/[email protected]=;/?C4JS=?KQ E H[=V4;/=?CNiNTHIEa'H>7 O>O[;/< 7/?CEbc6S6V <
=˜J E A 3ENÈG8<°:54=8=<[N9387 4387/?CO>; O[NBE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a-?Cbc6<[N ?
J
8
6
/
;
@
?
@
A
C
?
F
N
E
/
;
C
?
4
–
=
8
G
^
<
/
;
W
[
O
4
j7 T>a'<[N G8<1G8O[H[4a-354N [email protected];/?C4=ª3k4687QAKJ O>;/6G8<1G8<#H>A\EN N <[N G8<
DNFE 7FE H[38O>WUA T><[:8N 7 3<£E H[7 4eKs= E r/[email protected];<[NH>;/E^687 H[< 4a- LMa'[email protected]<>7 =EH[OQ<>E ; LE E/=cQ ;B3ka 4>68a'7 <Q68= bV6W8< ?CN/0{; 4<>7/7/?CDMbc<26<£E [email protected];BO>e;F4E 7/[email protected]@ACO£68G8ACO2<[N H>A\4E 7/[email protected][email protected] D<>[email protected]'=<[<>N =c ; ?
_A\E°E H[?C4N9=sH[r/<+<[H>=˜;/68J <[7 N/<£;Èegbc46˜7/; J <£#QG8A\E <[N¢\D=Y7FE G838<[WNÈ<[E N’=83=E O[7 <[egN E [email protected]>&; EfN’es3[ E 7¢bV6˜G8J <[<[N¢N ;È; <[E HF38W83=8E ?CbV7/6 6<[ACN<°G838<£7 4 G8r/O[<>H[;94G8a-<°353847 N [email protected];/68?CLM4=<>7 ?
A 47 N°G8< A\E1H[4=fegO>7 <>=H[<-<>= AKJ W4=8=<>687G8< l A\E 6G8< 0<>7/DM< bc68? N J <[N/;+; <>=V6< # L E 7/?CN
<>NFE':= H[r [email protected]@=AC<>E ; ?CN J/NF[/E [=k H[<mS ’Ee 47/a2< 68AClOmWVH[/L<g 38;FE7 4Ar/E <>;È7F<[EN/H[; 4=VZ ; 6O#< bV 6<^[email protected]\; Eƒ<[N/38?CG87 <><[a-N S8U? T>#-7 <^AKJ E 3k68<>; 7 4N a-4=8==< <1>&E EfHVe/E e=V?5; A #<
387<>a-. ?C<>7„7 O[N/G868<[[email protected];FN1E D;„7FGE 38E =WNƒ<[NƒH[<>G8;/<`; < _hGf)< [email protected] =8<[H>?C<>;/?CAB43= E 7e 680;168AKJ7/O>AC;/<>6;1G8<>< ;ƒG8X<Y4=8A\Eª[email protected];O[H[4>&a-Q 3k? 4ÈN/[email protected]=;/?C< 4= E 683;/E7 <7
O>4;F=cE ;ƒ3kH[<£[email protected]/4?C7/N„;FE bc=V6; <`<£eAC<[68N1; A\;/E+WO[H[44j7=fT>ega'O>7 <[<>N„=H[G8<È<`G8<G8O[L H[7/[email protected]=H[3k<>4; N/[email protected]=1;/?C4<>==)>&G8E/<[E/N1O SMa^4E ' ;/7/l ?CH[Wc<[LsN„g ;FO[E bcA68<>[email protected];Ä[email protected][email protected]:8iÈ7 <[O[<[<[G N
G8E LM< <[lH4AC<[=fN9eg4D7/7F;/E ?K38S Wl <[4NÈ7/=c36E 7O [email protected];N·N S ?4L E 683k?CN 4c4N 724=V<>;9; LM<>6=c6MNB4 GLI?J E'683k;/74<[68NÈL7E O[?C<>N/=V68;[email protected];FEE ;LMN [email protected]<+<[=NQ4E 6=N E E [email protected]?C=<[NN
W< VE a-A [email protected]=<>79?CH>? ?
J
W< Vf<>a-38AC<ÈAC<{[email protected]ÄE =H>?C<>u =^<>;¢AC<{? [email protected]ÄN/[email protected]<£GJ 68;/[email protected]@?CNFE ;/?C4=1G8<9G8O[H[4a-354N [email protected];/?C4=N
38=7<4·H[Lc4?C<>=c=c;/;?C<>G=V;J 68=2E 6;/H>W68O[= 47j;/T>7 a'46 <Ä? G8Z < ? [email protected]<[N/H ;£jB68=h=QDE 7F38E 3k38<>[email protected]<< S4=hE 38 3k <> [email protected] AC< *. -/#-. Ä ; 468;1D 7F E *38-/W.3 <’ bc 68?
G8E 38< 3k<>[email protected]; <2468E AC;°47<>N =N<>am,* :8 ACQ<-G8G< J E 7/;/?CACH><[68N£A\DE 7F;/?CE 438= W<[N G8< S5bc68?S [email protected]=? Gf? 68? S [email protected];°68=<QH>[email protected]?Cbc6< 4'G8< S? ?jB? =? S
N 4=c;9AC<[N9H[4a-3k4NFE =V; <[N H[4=8=W< Vf<[NÈG8< ?
"
G
G
K
G
Gk
` !*p +! ] 2 ' d ;< '
G
G[G1 ∪ K]
G\K
G
G1
G[Gk ∪ K]
$ G - -/. .3 - G 1 - *. #- &- G - *. #- *- .0 `!*p +! ] 2 ^ ; ;4 U1 - - - *. "- *- .0 . & * G G " .3 G 1 l <2G8<>7/=8?C<>7È;/WO[47jT>a'< E-3k4687ÈH[4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[email protected]'O[Gf?\E ; <Qbc6l<°AC<[N9D7FE 38W<[NBa-?NM
[email protected]^G84E =AC<>H^a'7 <><>=ca^;2E [email protected] a-bc63O1E 7 A\eKE E [email protected]; Nm<>7 =˜eg<[J 4H>=c;/?C;m4=ª3EG8N2<[G8NQ<'D7FH>E [email protected]?C38bVW6<[<#NQG;/J7/E ?\7/E ;/=8?CDH>6868A\ACEO[;/N ?CS%4bV= 6? <#AKA\JE 46=ªG8<35<>0{68<>;Q7/DM38< 7 46S M
LMD7F<>E7£383WE <ƒ7£;/687/=?\E <+=87 DO[68H>AC68O„7/7 =˜<>J=<[H[N <;QO>3LIE?CN G8<>68=V=; <ƒ<^H>][email protected]?C<[bcNÈ6H><[email protected]%[email protected]<[EYN£68N =4=c<„;9H>[email protected]?C<[bcN£6D<ƒ7FEG38J E W7/<[;/N£?CH>368EA\E 7 ;/[email protected];=–N ? 3Z E ?7-68AC= <
;/3WE O[7 4eKE j7 [email protected]>; a'3< E 7%[email protected]>&<{O ;/SMWN O[<[4N’7 38<>a'U? T[<H[<[JSN’[email protected]>)N 4k4=c?/;’u 3<>38E 768eK?CE N%[email protected]; AC<[<[N¢N¢E3=8E =7’O[!W <[HcN 3k>&4E;//4W [ T[SN <9G8<ÄG8=<È47 a2O[H>:8687 7/<>7 6S<>V-=H[;/<WScO[<>4;’7jT>[email protected]'<[<[N/N;
N/O>68;FE 7 =cAC; <[N+G8D<#7F;/E 7 384W68<[LMN+<>73E G87 <[eKNQE [email protected];G8N O[H[44=ca-;3kO>;4O N/[email protected];/G8?CO>4a'[email protected]=V;/7; O[<>N7 GfN/[email protected]; <[7+N-H[<QGE a'=NQ4c<G AC<[T>ACN2< D 7FLME [email protected] <[NQ>&[/a-O [email protected][email protected]^AKJ ?CE G8ACO[W< < M
a'D7F<>E =c38;°W<#[email protected] ? 7 3kegE [email protected]; jNN T[S5G84< 6 68a-=´?C<>NF6S4Vka-S5a'38<>7 O[;N LM<>7/&4 LHVE E =V=c;+;mA\; E^4635N<>7 ACeg<[<[N2H>;/E ?C684=;/7 ? <[jBNm=N 4Ea-38a'35<><>[email protected]; ACN2< Gf6 $D. 7FQE ;384W68< ; ?
A J O>; [email protected]<¡GJ E 7/;/?CH>68A\E ;/?C4= <[N/;ƒAKJ 68=<`G8<[N„G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4=N„AC<[[email protected]„H[4=8=c6<[N ? Z 4=
[email protected]=c; O>7 >;È387 4 LI?C<>=V; <>=V;/7 <QE 68;/7 <[N9Gf6 ;/WO[47jT>a'<mN [email protected] =c;]
OS>
. ` *p +! ] 2 1 ` S#&; ] - 1 1 1. *
- $.0 $ . $. *- .0 A J O>; [email protected]<'GJ E 7/;/?CH>68A\E ;/?C4=E135<>7/a-?CN2G8< 387 468LM<>7A\E135<>7 eg<[H>;/?C4=´G8< =4a2:87 <>6N <[N
H>bVA\68E?5N NN <[J <[NmN/;£G8<^E[LMDO>7F7 E O[38< [email protected]<[N 35? 4l 7/WV;FEL/=cg ;;F<E A 3E J7Äk A\E2EYN/68E [email protected]; N<QN/?’][email protected]=V=„;/7 E 4I38Gf3568<>[email protected]@;2AC< 68=<1 E 68 ;/ 7 <#G8O[H[ 4 a- 3k4 N/ [email protected]#;/-?C4= GJ 68; =´<>ACN-D7FbVE 638<W< G ; 4=˜68J ; <[<#N/; 33E 7/E;/N [email protected];/H[?C44=ª=8=G8<W<[V8NQ<1N <>4; a-a'<>; N =˜G8J< <[N/G;23<>E=N'G8E <>=c6S;/´V ?CH[4<>=8==N <><WamVf< :8? AC<[X N 4A; 4=<>N;
B
bVl 6˜WVJ L/68g =;F<ÄE AO>; [email protected][AC4<ÄG[A]
G=s/r J<[E H>7/;/;/68?CH>7 68OmA\bcE ;/6?C<°4=-AC<[<[N£N/;˜D7F68E =Q38WH E<[NNB3a-E G[B]
[email protected]/=8;/[email protected]?Ca^H>68E [email protected]?CAC<><>7%a'G8<><Ä=V;+3E [email protected]/;/[email protected];/E ?C47 eK= E [email protected] ; =cN9;/=˜?CNiJ cH 4a'=V;BO>;/37/E?CbcNÈ6G8< < ?
G8<+3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=`E =V;/?CNjcH a'O>;/7/?Cbc6<^]
*5
" )f#0-. ] 2 ` S#&; ] G - $. 1 $ .3 G " & 1 "- l <>;/; <{H[4=sl r <[H>;/687 <£N J <[N ; 7 O>LMO>ACO[<£Gf?32^H>[email protected]<S<>; G8<=4am:87 <>6S-V H EN 3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 N’4=V;
[email protected]>a-; O 3O>E ;/7 6egE [email protected]?C;%O[N=? <354<>7/68=c;%63O rE4N ACNÈH[4<>=c;{; iB<>=8<[[email protected]<[7’G GJ O/<>=Q N <>4am=c;£:8ACa'<£4G=VJ E ;/7/7 ;/O°?CH>bc686˜A\EJ 68;/=1?C4D=^[email protected] =38GfW68<+?CNFa-E [email protected]=8; [email protected]^= E DAC<>7Fa'E 38<>W=c<;
am 68-/[email protected];/ [email protected] 17/;/ ?f*,H[4 a-.38AC<>;%<[E N/LM;<[68H=QE 6D7Fa'E [email protected]=<{NG8G84<>=V6S;%mV AC<ÄH[4H[a-4a-3k384NFACO>E a'=V; <><[=cN%;FEE [email protected] ;/<È?CH[E£4=83k=4<W688V 7%<[H[N 4a-68=m354DNF7FE E =c38; W<[<N
H[bV46=8<9=H[<W<>fV 6S<[V^N G8G8<B<[NQXACH>[email protected]/?CbV?\E 6=#<[NiÈ ? 46_`NFN<><>=VA;/?C<>4; =8L [email protected]@[email protected]<[< NQi9;/7F68E[:8L?CE 426SVbV68G8?< 4=cl ;W <>@ 6#=8W G8<[t N’4338# 7 =84DAC4=8/DMO <>a'E <>[email protected]=c=; N/N ?
[email protected]=E ;/; <>=Gf6N [email protected]ÈHFWE [email protected];/7 < k +]
` *p +! ] 2 ' *5-6%&%& of# -698 * @=p= G - $. $ - #- (X, Y ) .3 -*- *, *, G[Y ] - 1. =<£E 68;/7 <9G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4='[email protected]/;FE =V; <È<[N/;%AC< G8OW\[email protected]; 3E 7ÄP ? l 47/=V6OWM
È
r 4ACN°<>; ? t ? l [email protected]=8D? WE a O/O ? X 4; 4=Nbc6<QA\EƒG8OW\[email protected];/?C4=387 O[H>?CN <-Gf6 J [email protected]/[email protected]=V;
LH>?CE N 7/O[?C<+< <>N =<>ACN/[email protected]; AC< <[? N{Z E [email protected];; <>687 N68=„X D47F6E N{38WG8< 4? =8jB=4=Y=EN{386835=<><[email protected]< OW\ [email protected];/?C 4Ä =„G838< 7 4·Lc?C; N [email protected] ; <<+Sf3bcE 687/?5;/[email protected];/<>?C7F4E= 38G87 <[OWNM
G
G
N 4a-a'<>; N'£G8LMO>< 7/?N\”E =V<>=r; H[G8<><>7/6S;[email protected]=<><[=NÈNF<>H[am4=:8GfAC<[[email protected];/N ?C4=NB3<>E ; 7/a-?˜AC<[; N9<>ACN/N^[email protected]˜E J [email protected]; <[<WN2VI?C] N ; <
>/? L 4687
S
JS? l WEbc6<N 4a-a'<>;ÈG8< [email protected];ÈH WEbc6<N 4a-a'<>;BG8< OS? l WEbc6<N 4a-a'<>;ÈG8< [email protected];ÈHFWEbV6<NF4a-a'<>;ÈG8< k4? RdA =˜J H E1E 6H>68=<'E 7 >; <-<>=c;/7 < <>; E 68;/7 <[Nbc6< H[<>[email protected]<[N°<>=V;/7 < <>;
QS? L 4687
S
/
N
?
>
<
;
/
N
?
[
<
N
m
;
8
6
=
H
W
>
<
a
@
?
=
r [email protected]=E =c;
AKG8J 68<+=8AC4?Cbc=86D<'6<>N 6847a-E a'6Y<>a';[email protected]< =N O #1AKJ 68=8?Cbc6<'N 4a-a'<>;2G8< S˜E AC47 NmH[<-HFW<>[email protected]=´<[N/;
S? L 4687
È
S
H
W
E
c
b
6
¡
<
[
H
4
a
5
3
4
F
N
E
c
=
;
<
[
H
4
8
=
=
W< V8<G8<
[
H
4
a
k
3
4
/
7
;
¡
<
8
G
[
<
N
N 4a-a'<>; NBG8< <>;9G8< G
X1
Ai , B i ⊆ X i
X2
i = 1, 2
i = 1, 2 Ai ∩ Bi = ∅
A1
A2
B1
B2
X1
X2
Ai
i = 1, 2
i = 1, 2
i = 1, 2
Ai
|Ai | = |Bi | = 1
Ai
G[Xi ]
Bi
G[Xi ]
Bi
Bi
O/J
e ? L 4687 i = 1, 2 SN/? |A | = |B | = 1 SÄE AC47 N G[X ] =˜J <[N/;^3EN^68=rH W<>[email protected]=
r [email protected]=E =c;ÈAKJ 68=8?Cbc6<N 4a-a'<>;ÈG8< A #QAKJ 68=8?CbV6<NF4a-a'<>;ÈG8< B RS? L 4687 i = 1, 2 [email protected]%<WVf?CN/; <268=H W<>[email protected]=G8< G[X ] E&HVE =V;68=< <WVf;/7 O>[email protected]; O-GE =N
<>;£68=<<WfV ;/7 O>[email protected]; OGE =N ES? AA <[NÈ<>=N <>a2:8AC<[N X <>; X NF4B=V;9G8<H E 7 [email protected]=E A E 6Ya'[email protected]=N OS?
u E =N^AC<[N#E 7/;/?CH>AC<[N^G8< l WV6Gf=cLM4 LfN !H .’GE =N JS> S AC<[N J [email protected] [email protected]=c; N^[email protected]<>=c;
N;F<>E [email protected] AC<<>Sca'H<>J <[=cN/;’;’LMH[O><>7/;/?N; \ <9<>7¢G8OWAC<[\ N’=8H[[email protected];/[email protected];/bV?C64<£=N =4> 6# N’S68? ;/[email protected]@?C=^N 4AK=J E N :?fN u <>=E H[=<9N’GAC<[J N’[email protected]=E Gf7/?C;/H ?CE H>;/AC<[?C4NÄ=G8N’< N l68384387/=VACO>6a'O /r <>4=SACNM
3k 468.A7ÈSf<[H G8N W<[EJ N{[email protected]/G864OW<°[email protected]\ =V;/=8; WNÈ[email protected];/O[NF?C4447j==V>T N£;9a'AC<><O>= DM? <>687 = <>a'H[<><>7/=c;F;9E [email protected]=`?!kON ><>7 =<>N{=c;[email protected]=V<[N9; <>N 7 [email protected];;{N 68G;/[email protected] [email protected]=?CN N£O[<[AC<[N·N£ScbcD67FE < 38=W4<[6NÈNÄ[email protected] =8O[[email protected]>a^?CNFE 4AC=<WNM
a'[email protected]<>[email protected];a^[email protected] 6S3V E 7# eKEA\E°[email protected]; H[N 4?S=sL /r [email protected]<[6H>N;/68387 7 <£O[H>eg?C4N 7/O>; a'<9<>G8=c<[; N [email protected]ÄE 38N 4W=c<[;{N’[email protected]=VE ; 7 <>eg7 E [email protected];[email protected]; N N£? BXGE 4=; 4N=AC<[NÄNÄbVH[64<È=cH[;/7<{<W;/M W<WfVO[4<>a-7j>T 38a'AC<<
<[N/;£LE A\E :8AC<°3k46879; 468; <[N£AC<[N9G8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=N Gf6 J [email protected]/r [email protected]=V; N ?
` !*p +! ] 2 *ps",- )*8 %a# -6"8"8 " 75`6;4 @'p' $ G - . 1 $ $ G - .0 G 1 - - $ $ ¢= J/[/[S> SP+O>7FE 7 G l 47/=c6O r 4ACN S8_h?CH W<>A\E =8DM<>AC4 l 4=feg47/;/?<>; +7/?CN/;/[email protected]=E 6 M4 LI?
[email protected]=c<[N£;{3EDe 477FeK7/E [email protected];W68N%<[ACO+NÈ=˜J6834=E=V<°7; egE3H[[email protected]; =sN%N2r G8<[] <H>;/368E 7 7/<°;/[email protected];/68?C4?K=^SfN/E ?k=VAK;/J 4?CNi=„IH a'EGfO>a';/7/<>?Cbc;96bc<6S< [email protected]<[38N{[email protected]?CDbV7F6E <38WA\E <[N£H[[email protected] =8<[[email protected]>a^;/68E 7 AC<<>a'eg4<>7/=V; <;
*$" /#0-6G ] 2 = *5"6b *pG#0 *5",
- 8* % - 5* . @' - G i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
1
2
1 0. - G 1 #- - . - - - G - & 1 #- G G
l <>;/; <-H[4=sr/<[H>;/687 <'E 383E 7FEGFC;mE 6sr/4687 GJ WV68?¢H[4a-a'< AKJ ?CG8O[Z <-G8O[H>?CN/[email protected]< H[4=Gf68?CNFE =c;
#ªA\E387 <>68LM<Gf6ˆ;/WO[47jT>a'< eg47/;„G8<[N„D7FE 38W<[N„3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N ? <[Nƒ;/7 4?CNYE 68; <>687 N 4=c;
38H[46r=H>A\[email protected]/G8?CO>4a'= ?$4=Vu ;/E 7 =<>7ƒN9ACG<°E ;/=WN1O[4G87j<[T>N^a'H <QEN'N/[email protected] E7/;/=V?C; H>[email protected]<[?C<>N 7 JN·SÄ[email protected]/[email protected]‘=V; <>N =yG847 <>[email protected]\EG<>V=VE;+=VN ;ƒ<>68bVAC6<>a'<>ACbc<>=V6;<„LM3kO><>7/6y?N\<>A\E 7
AC<[N9H[[email protected];/?C4=N > # k S e <>; RS?
` !*p +! ] ]- 5* "6b *pG#0 5* ",- *8 % -5* . N ' -
1 C .0 - G #- - G - G - G - $. *- .0 *, - * G 11 jB=1E 3835<>[email protected]< $.0 - 1. B; 468;¢D7FE 38W< G 7 O[[email protected]; #+68=#N 4a-a'<>;’46'3k4N N O[GE =c;
4
86G8=<[N<Y<WE VI7 ;/>7 ; O>< [email protected]; O[; N<>[email protected]< < bc?!6u<„E H =WN’EbcAC<£6<;/WN O[44a-7jT>a'a'<>< ;^N/[email protected]< LE =V; <[ScN/AC;^<[N EJ [email protected]/r/E4H[[email protected]=V<>=c; N; G8#¡[email protected] LM6–<>=Va';{N4<>[email protected]=68N'AC<>a'AKJ 68<>==V<;
LMO>7/?N\<>7BAC<[N9H[[email protected];/?C4=N > # k S e <>; ES?
e
G
e
` !*p +! ] ] 2 5* "6b *pG#0 5* ",- *8 % -5* . N ' 2
- $ $ .0 - G 1 "- - G - $.0 - 1. 1 *-/.3 G G
O/O
A <[N E =V;/[email protected];/7 46N%[email protected] [email protected] N GJ E 6Qa'[email protected]=N e N 4a-a'<>; N3k4N NjT[G8<>=c;%G8<[NO>; [email protected]<[N G8468:8AC<[N
GAC<>J a'E 7/<>;/=V?CH>;[email protected]\a-E ;/3?C4E = 7 eK? E [email protected];A{N-<[N=˜; J 4G8=V4;-=3H [email protected]'a-G35J 4O>;N 4N [email protected][email protected]:8AC<„AC<1G8G84<ƒ68:8a'AC<„4=cG;/J 7E <>7/7#;/?CH>bc686A\<1E ;/AC?C<[4N-= ?D7FjBE 38=W35<[N-468a-7/[email protected] [email protected][email protected];'a^<>EG= M
[email protected][Gf368E [email protected][email protected]{<È<[68N ;’=#; 354<>;F61E AC<>Lca'[email protected]; <><B=VbV;£[email protected]<È=c68AC<9;/[email protected];/AC<+WO[35447j68>T a'738<+7 G84<È68LMG8<>O[7{H[4AC<Èa-;/3kW4O[N/[email protected];/>T ?C4a'=„<BG8eg<[4NÄ7/;DG87FE <[38NWD<[7FNE 38NTEW=<[N’N{;/37 E 47 6 M
egH>E ?NM [email protected]; N <[? N Nl 4<>6A\N°E-<[=˜N/J ;+<[N/LI;£7F3E ?CE< N9) ; 468H;J <[#QN ;°eKE [email protected];9=<-<WV H[E4H>=;mN O[]8bV46=Y<>=NFEH[[email protected]<-;ÈGfE 6 6s/r ;/4W68O[7 4G7jJ >TWVa'68?< bVeg64<°7/;°A\E G8<[H[N°4=sD/r 7F<[E H>38;/W687<[<N
37FE E [email protected] ;£egE [email protected]=; N <m? E [email protected]; =<><È7/=38E 7 ;/<>[email protected]< <°# [email protected] E <[7/H>;/; ?C<H>AC<m G8G84<=c;£l =WV466GfN{==˜4·LIJ E[N LM4H„=<>N{;È3E EA N{? A\] E2a'[email protected]=Gf7 < ?CG8O[<’e 4687/=8?NM
*5
" )f#0-. ] ]5] G - . 1 $ .0 . - G
" . - 1.0 *- .0 G ;eF4E 7/=V;';¢4G8A\Em<[?CH>N^H[?84DH[=s7F4r/E a-<[38H>a'W;/68<[<>7N'=V<B;¢3H>4E ?NM=7 G8eKE a'<[[email protected]; 4N/N 6=V? NB;/X7 ]c<4N AC; 4<[email protected];=;/WN^O[4bc68j76T>=ƒ< a'H[<4=Ve 4<[;/7N/7/<W;^;%M G8<WG8V8<[< N<>a-0{D7F38<>E 7/AC38<+DMW< a-<[? N%[email protected] [email protected]^=7 HegE E [email protected];E N 61<><>;/;=-WO[E4Gf7ja'N T>4a'<>=c; <;M
Na-FE [email protected]==8N [email protected]^;/7 E 4A 6–? ([email protected]@[email protected]? 4u=NÄJ E AC38<Bj7 ;/T[WN'O[4AC<ƒj7 T>;/a'W<O[4JSj7 ?KT>JSa'> < # JS?KQ <>S ; ? <[N/Z ;^?AKE J 686=ƒN N ?G8< 68=rS H[4=V;/<[7 N <W;’M <W:V8E<>N/a-?Cbc386AC<< S
4J [email protected]=hr 4H[[email protected]=c=V; ;/S’7 4<[[email protected]; H[4A\E-=c;/3k7 <[<>Gf7 [email protected]<[;#H>;/AC<Y?C4=h;/WG8O[4<[NBj7 T>Da'7FE< [email protected]<[>&NÈR :’EG8N/4?Cbc=6H <[NN <>?; AKJ 68=h35G84< NFjN T[G8S <>=V;#35684=NFNj< T[G8O>;<°[email protected]= <
G8468:8AC<GJ E 7/;/?CH>68A\E ;/?C4=˜S”H[<°bc68?˜H[4=V;/7 <[[email protected];BA\E-H[4s= r/<[H>;/687 < JS?KJ/JS?
G
G
G
G
G
G
G G
G G
G
G
G
l WV6Gf=4·LIN !HMS/X <>[email protected]:5<>7/; NF4=˜S L E 68A Z <)Hca'4687 <>;%iÈ4:[email protected]= * W4a^EN N 4=V;
_
`
E
/
7
\
?
E
3H[4E =s7/rLM<[<>H>=V;/668N7 <[#°N 38JS7 [email protected]> 68 LM<><>; 7Ä[email protected]<[>&N’E SMLM38<>7 7 N/4?C684L=E NÄ=VAC;9O>DfE T>[email protected]=<>N/a'?”AC<><È=V;/;W38O[[email protected]¢T>a'eKE <È[email protected]:8egAC4<[7/N ;ÄSa^G8<[E NÄ?CNÄD7FN/E6382^WNF<[E NÄ=V3; <[E N·7 SVeKE [email protected]<[; NN
<>A ; <>687 O>7^3k384=7 <>G68E LM=V<h;#È<[N/AK;'J 68AC=4<Ä=8DG86<[<ND 7FACE<Y=38G87 <[<>N%a-bV?C6<><[7^N ;/a^?C4E ==cN64N 68H>7/[email protected]<>;17/; Gf<[?!N%k6G8<ÄN OA\SÄE9G;/WE O[; OY47/Gf?C<{6 G8<[J/NR D4c7FEH>;384W:8<[7 N < ?
J/[/[/J SVH[4a-3k47/; < >)kR 3E DM<[N <>;¢; <[HFW8=8?CbV6< ? X 46N’<>=#387 O[N <>=V; 4=NÄ;/j7 T[N’:87/U? T>LM<>a'<>=c;
ACN/<[6N£N H[O><>;F38E 35;/[email protected]<[:8N{AC<[38Nm7/[email protected]=<'H>[email protected]=34E 6AC<[NmN ? N <>X 7/[email protected]{3a'E <>7;/;A\E„4=N N£[email protected]; J E<H[SH[bc<>68=c?;È=N/68<^7{N AC4<[=cN{;7 3O[N/E68N°[email protected];FegE 4; 7 N£H[O>[email protected]'=c; <><>=V7/a';2ACO[<[GfN?\E [email protected]@6<[NN
[email protected]/;FE =c; NÈN <>AC4=YGJ E 68;/7 <[NBH>7/[email protected]; T>7 <[N ?
XB46? NZ E LM4=N:5<[[email protected]= G8< bc6<>ACbV6<[N=4;/?C4=NN/683838ACO>a'<>=c;FE [email protected] <[N ? Z [email protected]; 68=
D<[N/7F;9E 38H[W4<a-38AC?<>; # N/?˜H WEbcS864<m= N [email protected];9a'bc6<>;B<BG8AC<°< H[468LM384AC<[email protected];ÈHFWEbV6<m<[NN/4; a-*,a' <>.;ÈG8 < 46 ? jBbc6=Y< [email protected];
bVG86< < ? jB=ªE <[38N 35; <>[email protected]<+ * $ .0/N ?k, HFWEbV6<°; 4NF684; a-<^a'3<>E ;97/;/[email protected];/< ?C4=a^G8<[E Nm=NFbV46a-<+a'HFW<>E; N2bV6G8<< NF4a-<>a'= <> ;
<>=N <>am:8AC<[NÈ=4= Lc?CG8<[N
; <>ACN9bV6<^]
l WEbV6<„NF4a-a'<>; G8< Eh68=LM4?CN/[email protected]=<>; 68==4S= MKLM4?CN/? [email protected]=–GE =N ? l WEbc6<
A N 4<[a-NÈa'H[4<>68;È38G8AC<[< N EQ68=„S LM4?CN/[email protected]=Y<>S ;È68=„=4S S= MKLM4?CN/[email protected]=hN G4E =V=;ÈN H[4a-38AC<>; N ?
S S S N 4=c;ÈE =V;/?CH[4a-38AC<>; N ?
A <[NÈH[46838AC<[N
G
X, Y ⊂ V (G)
Y
X
(X, Y )
Y
(A, B, C, D, E, F )
(X, Y )
A
B
(C, A) (A, F ) (F, B) (B, D)
(D, A) (A, E) (E, B) (B, C)
X
Y
X
G
B
A
Ok
C3A <mE 7=X4l a 4Wc; Ls4G8g =< ;FNE A bc<>[email protected];r < 4Z [email protected]==c:84;È[email protected];/W873? <-E 7JG8 OWl \[email protected];/Gf?C?˜=444=´Lf=VG8;9N < a'H A\4E1=c&3;/7 .E [email protected]?7 AC< _<+W;/E W4?CNÈa'O[4bc47j6DfT><a'T>=A\<2<^E-N/<[=68N [email protected];+L;/?CE H[4=c<>= ;[email protected]<-E'] G8O>;[email protected]=VO[LM<^<>N=V4; 6O[<N
M
!
` !*p +! ] ] ' ` S#&; f# 98 `8 ] G - $+ .0 .3 G *, &$ / + a'G844=8=cX=;/47 4O[=6N2N£NY3<>E =1E [email protected] AC7 4O l=e N„O>WV7 6<>a^Gf==E H[[email protected]·< =cLI;ACN< <>==VMH E 68S=Va'iÈ;`O>4O>7 :k=4-<>47/Gf=; 61NH[4<>;/7=˜WS O[684Z =)7j<)T>HIH[a'a'<><°7/4;F68<>E ;[email protected]=)A\<>E; =34* E amDMW:8< 47a^#m<´EA\G8EN2bV< G6E;/<>[email protected][N <+447jJST>=1> a'35? <[<>NX 684;{G86OWAC<NM
;/E 7 =c4;/68?CNiLMcH <>a'7 O>G;/E 7/=?CbcN£6AC< <°a^E =V6NFH><[7/[email protected]/;B; GE ; $OYGf6 N/?J/; R 464IN H>; AC4<[:8N-7 H< WJ/<>[/a-[/[email protected]=? N^jBE&=YVH E [email protected];';9bVAC<>6˜68J 768N-=<<WfV 3;/E 7 7/O>;/[email protected];/[email protected]?C; 4O[= N
G;/?CE HF=WN<>[email protected]=<>N1;-E&ACVH <>E 68=V7';^(A,[email protected]=cAC<>; 68O>B)77/N#?C<>68<WIV7#;/G7 O>E a-=N [email protected]; O[AN#NG4E =c=;^N G8<„<>AC4;'=8ACD<>668<>7'[email protected]#=V;3O>E 7/[email protected]?C7 <>< 6871<>;^GEN/?£=N ; 46N-N AC4<[=cN#;^E G8=S< M
ACG84< =8Dl 6Wc<>Ls68g 7Ä;FE 3AE [email protected] 7H[< 4?=sAr <[<ÈH>;/;/68W7O[< 47jJS>T [email protected]'> <È+N/][email protected] =V;<[N/;¢A68=<£LM<>7 N/?C4=ƒE E [email protected]:[email protected]?C<ÈG8<9A\E°BH[4=s/r <[H>;/687 <
` !*p +! ] ] ],2 " + = _6; 75 2 G - $. . -/ ** & 3. 1 #- , " G X 46N°G8<>LM4=N+a^E [email protected]=V; <>=E =c;2G8OW\[email protected]°68=<Q=468LM<>[email protected]<-H>A\EN N < G8<QD7FE 38W<[N ? jB=E 3SM
3k<>=<>[email protected]<>< a2:8 AC*,<[,NhG8< ;F E [email protected]; [email protected]<´68;9E D6)7FE a'[email protected]< =GN J ; <>A] bc6< V (G) 35<>68S ;BN <+3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8S =<>7 <>=hbV6E ;/7 < S
{a , . . . , a } {b , . . . , b } {c , . . . , c }
{d , . . . , d } Sf; <>ACNÈbc6<-]
LL 46879; 468; 1 ≤ i ≤ m S a [email protected]; b <>;£354687£; 468; 1 ≤ j ≤ n S c a^E =bV6< d ?
H EE 6H>68=<¡E 7 >; < <>=V;/7 < {a , b } <>;
4687„; 468? ; L 1 ≤ i < i ≤ m SÄ[email protected]=˜J r
4
8
6
°
7
;
4
8
6
;
H E^; 468; <[N°AC<[N°E 7 >; <[N+354N N [email protected]:8AC<[N
{a , b }
1 ≤ j < j ≤ m S”[email protected]`
?
<>=V;/7 < {c , d } <>; {c , d }
L 4687B; 468; 1 ≤ i ≤ m <>;9; 468; 1 ≤ j ≤ n [email protected]ƒH E-<WV EH>; <>a'<>=V;+G8<>6S„V ? E 7 >; <[N
<>=V;/7 < {a , b } <>; {c , d } S<>;BH[<[N9G8<>6SV„E 7 >; <[NBN 4=V;È=4= [email protected]=H>?CG8<>=V; <[N
P 6<>ACN{N 4=c;{AC<[N’[email protected]<>;/[email protected]; N’:8?CH[4D7FE 38W<[N A <[[email protected]<>;/[email protected]; NÄ:8?CH[4D7FE 38W<[N£4=V; R
NA 4<ma-N a'4a-<>; a'Nm<>] ; a , aLM4, [email protected];9,68b=<2, cE 7 ,>c; <m, dG8<, dH[< ?A J S<>=<>;N <>am:8LMAC4< [email protected];9{cAKJ E ,7 c>; ,<2d 4,38d354}NFO[[email protected]=< Gf?468u [email protected]<°;968a = >a'C<S?
a
C
b
? ?CN 4a'47/38W8?CN/a'<#387j[T N S[email protected]’=˜J H
M
L
4
@
?
m
;
8
6
=
1
<
E
7
>
;
^
<
f
G
6
>
<
;
K
A
J
E
7
>
;
1
<
4
8
3
5
3
4
N
[
O
<
a
C
b
J
EƒE 7 G8>; 4<[=N{H'[email protected]=bcH>6?C<G8<>=c; H <[EN9N'Gf] 6 a S a?u ELM=4N?C<>AC=c<B;38A\7E1<>a-a ?C><>a'7£<^H EE N 7 Sf>4; =ƒ<'4Gf:86 ;/?CC<>=V;£4686 =„aG84S 68a:8AC<WLMM 4Gf?C?\<>E =Va^;QE G8=V<[; N S
<>;ÈGE =N9AC<G8<>6SVI?UT>a'<S CL(K \ e) ?pA <°;/WO[47jT>a'<mN [email protected] =c;È<[N/;{eKEH>[email protected]<']
` !*p +! ] ] 1 ],2 _6; 75 2 G - *, 1 .0 G $ A E¡387 <>68LM<`Gf6y;/WO[47j>T a'<`G8< N/;/7/6H>;/687 <`G8<[N'D7FE 38W<[NƒG8< 0{<>7/DM< 68;/[email protected]@?CN <Y68=<
; <[HFW8=8?CbV6<'H>A\ENFN/?CbV6<SGJ E [email protected]@AC<>687 NmG8O r #1a-?CN < <>= ? +68LI7 < 3E 7 l 4=fe 47/;/?KS l 47/=V6O /r 4ACN
1
1
1
m
1
m
n
n
i
i
j
j
0
i0
i
i
0
i0
j
j
j0
i
i
j
j
1
2
1
2
1
2
j0
1
2
1
1
4
2
4
1
2
1
2
4
1
2
2
4
1
2
4
3,3
<>; 6 M 4 LI? '3k4687387 468LM<>7mAC<'H EN2NFE =NH E 7/7 O jB=3E 7/;2GJ 68=D7FE 38W<#G8< {0 <>7/DM<
O/Q
>35H A\4ES˜N N <>N N T[;m< G84<m=´? A\jBE1N/68=^G838O[a'3kH[444Na-=c<';/3k7 bc<B46N/E <[email protected];/AC4?C47 =NH[bVN464=V<£68;/W?C; <>4E [email protected];Q; ;ÄO[68< AC<£=´? DjBH[7F<>= E 7/38;F7 WE <[[email protected]<ÈH[=ª4N·a-NJ 44a'7/6DV<>N E MK==8DH[?C7F<^N E <B38E EWAC468< 7 ; N468E[7LMG<[G8HQJ 68< =AC<[<^N+SMH[D<><>7F;Ä7/E ;F38bVE W6˜[email protected]=<[J [email protected]<N A
=E[LM<9<[H[H°4A\=VE ; <>N/=68E [email protected]; =c<m;{G8E <°6H>;/68W=1O[4N 7j4T>6a'N MK<[DNÈ7FH>E ?N38M G8W<[<ÈN G8NF4<96A\NE°]H>A\EN N < ? ? ? ¢4&HM4=NH[<>A\E°[email protected]Ä<>=^G8O>;FE [email protected]
G
G0
G
G0
C
C0
` *p +! ] U] ] 2 " = ' _8; 7p 1
$ G - 1 G
*, .0 . $ - - K .3 - . - G G - . 1 - G 1- *,, "- . - G G - - G - & 1 #- $ `*p +! ] U] ' ] 2 " 2.- _8; 7p ] G - 1 *, - *- . $ 1- 1 * - $ ".0 - G 11"- $ * K G$ " - G
- - G - & 1 #- " , `*p +! ] U] ] 2 " 2 ' ! _8; 7p - 1 1.
- G G *, . 1 - G K G
*, - 1 $ $ .0 " .0 "- . - G G - - G - 1 #- $ - G - $ /, 4
4
4
` *p +! ] U] = ] 2 " 2+ ' _8; 7p = ] G - 1 1.
- *, . 1 1- G.0 G ! G *, - - 1. + .0 +- . - K G
G - - G - & "- $, `*p +! ] ' - ] 2 " 2 ' ' 2 ' 2p2 _8; 7p $
G - 1 1. - *, . $ 1- 1 K G.0 G- - 1. .0 + - G - $ "- $, - G *, -*- -.0 "
- G *, "- *- - .3 / `*p +! ] ' 2 ] 2 " 2 ' ' 2 ' 2S] _8; 7p $
G - 1 - .0 . - +*, . - K 1 G.0 G- - 1. + ! .0 - $ "- $ &- G 11 - *. #- - G G 4
4
4
u <°H[<>;/; <[email protected]?CN/; <°G8<+;/WO[47jT>a'<[N S4=YG8O[[email protected];{eKEH>[email protected]<>a'<>=V;BAC<+;/WO[47jT>a'<G8<°G8O[H[4a M
354N/[email protected];/?C4= G8<[N9D7FE 38W<[NÈG8< {0 <>7/DM<']
O
` !*p +! ] ' ] G - 1 .0 - !
11 , #- - G 1 - *,, - . - G G - G - G - 1 #- , - G - $
/ + ¢ =^EGfa'<>;/;FE =V;¢; 46N AC<[N%;/WO[47jT>a'<[N’G8<H[<£HFWE [email protected];/7 <[email protected]<[N/;egEH>[email protected]<{G8<£G8O>a'4=c;/7 <>7
ACa-<ƒ[email protected]=8;/[email protected][4687jatT>a'E <ƒ6#eg;/4W7/O[;'4G87jT><[a'N <BD7Fe E4387/;W<[G8N'<[N’3DE 7F7 E [email protected]; N<[NÄ]%3N E 47 [email protected]; E [email protected]; N ? 68X =–4;H[44==cNÄ;/7 bc<W6M <W< Vf<>a-<[38N/AC;Ä<hG8G8<<ƒ0{;F<>E 7/[email protected]@AC< < ?
u J E 38j7 T[N+AC<Q;/WO[4j7 T>a'< JS?KQ S <[N ;+E 6N N ?68=¡H[4=c;/7 W< M <WVf<>a-38AC<'G8<2;FE [email protected]@AC< [email protected][email protected] ?
([email protected]?CbV64=N¢AC<£;/WO[4j7 T>a'< JS?KO/J # ? Z ? <[N/; :EN/?Cbc6<S4='H[4=V;/7 <[[email protected];’A\E 3k<>7 eg<[H>;/?C4=
G8N/? <[N{D47F6 E 38W<[35N£4:NFjNET[N G8?CbV<{668<[=N SfJ N/[email protected]? r [email protected]=c<[; N/SM;{468='=„H[4:8=V?CH[;/74<[[email protected] ;Ä38ACW<{<;/SW4O[=„4j7 H[T>4a'=V<;/7 JS<[[email protected]>&[email protected];ÈSMACN<+? ;/WO[35447jT>N Na'T[<G8<ÄJS68?KJ/=Q < S
3E =cE ;/[email protected] ?CNi<+HcWa'4O>a';/7/4?CfDbcT>6=<<[email protected]=„7 <H[S”44=V=Y;/7 H[<[[email protected];È;/7 AC<[<BGf;/[email protected];BO[AC4<°j7 ;/T>Wa'O[< 47jJST>?Ka'J/O < <>JS;£?KJN/k4? ?pu 3kE =4NNÈjN ;T[4G86<BN968AC=<[<BN9H3EE N·7/S;/[email protected];/=h?C4= E
68=<H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4= ?
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
' '/
A EÈ;/W4T[NF<G8<_ E 7/?\E l Wc6Gf=4 LfN H >0e <[N/;%H[4=NFEH>7 O[< #ÈA\EÈ387 <>68LM<{G8<A\EÈH[4=sr/<[HWM
;/38687 7<><a-JS?C<>[email protected]>&E 38387 47 :8438AU>T 7 a'<>a'< <>#1=V;+7 O[GfN [email protected]; 6<GfS7bc<'68?K<[S8N/=;+4;/; 7/[email protected]=?\N9E A9AC<]kS8; =˜4J 6<[NN°;9AC3<[N+EN9:8?CG8H[O>4a'D7F4E =V38;/W7 O[<[<QNmG4=cE =;N 68=JS< > 3?<E A 7 < M
;/O>[email protected]@;/[email protected]?C4=´[email protected]=<>E 79=c;/Gf?C6ƒNicH ;/a'WO[O>4;/7/7j?C>T bca'6<<°G8 3< EG8N O[egH[447 a-H[O>35a'4N/<>[email protected]=V;/;?C43= E [email protected];/7 W< O[S47j<>>T;°a'4<=¡JS3k?KO/<>68J ;° ? G8iB4<[=N/HQ; <BegEAKH>J O>[email protected]@[email protected]<>a-a'[email protected]<>==cE ;;/?CAC4<[= N
68;/G8W;/<[[email protected][[email protected]?CN37jO[>T E <[a'[email protected]°7 <[< GNQJSE W=?KJ/4N RSa'?A\E#4* Df384>T 687 =<>; <[68< N'egLM4< bc?CN968Gf?ÄAC6 <>N68;/<>7ÈWa2O[O>:[email protected][email protected]< >T a'[email protected]>=;/< E 7 ;/<1JS?C4?K68O/=`=J N ]5G8<>amO><>;[email protected]:8ACE <[[email protected]+<AKS=˜>38;/J E687 <°38?CN 368bVE =6˜7FJE <>[email protected] AC4N<[<>N:8=cAUN>T;4a'bV=c<6; <QGf;/7j?3G2^[T E N2H>[email protected]+AC< <>AC?6 <
A <[N<WfV [email protected]?CH E ;/?C4=N£G84=8=O[<[N?CH>?”387 4·Lc?C<>=8=<>=c;9G8<È=4; <[N3k<>7 N 4=8=<>[email protected]<[N387/?CN <[NAC47 N
G=8?CJ 68bc6= <¢<WbcIV 6˜3kJ 4<>[email protected]< G868<2;/[email protected]@_`?CN <E 7/=˜?\E J <[N/l ;WV7/6?C<>Gf==a'4·LI4N [email protected]!=$H Nbc# 6˜L J 68E =AC4< 7 (B<>A\[email protected]; 4^V E <>;/=Y?C4==m4·G8LM< <>amA\E{:8=7 4< ;/?CJ/4[/=m[/JSG8?$<¢A DE'7FE ;38<[WHF<ÈWSM ]
68N 4=¡6Ni;/M7/<>[email protected]=7FN E <>38amW:8< AC<[GN-Gf<[?CN N ;°/r [email protected]=¡=V; N;/7/[email protected]<#AC<>AK; J <>(V,=N <>Eam:8,ACE< ) ?,A ?8<[A NmJ <><>==NN <><>a2am:8:8ACAC<<[N E 7 <><>;387 EO[NF<>=VN 4; <1=c;AKJ G8<>=S<[NM
N <>a2 :8 AC<mG81.$<[.0N E ? 7 >L ; [email protected]<[6N N„ eg4. 7/0 a'<> [email protected]$<>,a' Q<>=VG8; < S G4=¶S;FEE =383kGf?C<>NÈ[email protected]<6< ,.E <[N/ ;9 AKJ <>E=G8N< <>a2:8AC; <m468G8;Y<[N DE 7F7E >38; W<[<N
G
?
G = (V, E) LMO>7/?N\”E =V; E ⊆ E ⊆ E ∪ E È=;/7/[email protected] 38W< <[N ;'[email protected]; N/G8?{< ; 0{468<>7/; DM<[<mN'35NF<[<>N 68; 7 O >E ;/[email protected] ?C<mNFE Lc;/6?C4=H[4N'a-N 4a'=c<m;'68G8=Y<[N ;/7/[email protected] 7F38E 38WW<[N'<2G8G8<< 0{0{<><>7/7/DMDM<< ? =BX <4H[; 44a-=3kN-4bc7/6˜;FE J 68=V=;°E D67FEH>13868 W= <<
El 7 Wc>6; <£Gf=4438Lf;/?CN 4!=8#H =G8<>[email protected]>ACa'<Sc4<>=V;;/=˜7 <°J E&E VH ACE 4=V7 ;N’G8684=#=;/H{W35O[447j68>T 7¢a'N <B<>68G8AC<<B7N/O;/7/E [email protected]?CH>NF;/E 68;/7?C4<B=#35bV4668<7Ä[email protected]<[N’?NKM a;/7/[email protected]>Da'7FE < 38? W_ <[N{E 7/G8?\E<
;D0{<>7F<>a'E 7/38DM<>W<=c<[S;QN{bVA\<[68EYN/?K;ÄS%H[438E [email protected] 38<[NÄ[email protected]>?CGf;/bV68?362^7 Oƒ< H>[email protected] JSAC6< [email protected]>&#°ESH E? 38N2X7 443687/E a'LM7/<>;/<>7{?CH>[email protected]<>[email protected]'?C<È<><>7-AC=V<9;GS%;/J 68WAC=ª<'O[4;/7jDW>T 7Fa'O[E 438< 7jWT>G8<ƒa'<ÈG8<ƒN/< ;/G87/0{6<#H><>N/;/7/;/68DM7/7<6< SH>;/G8G868<[47 NÄ=8<#=DG87F<1E <[<W38NmV W;/E<[7/HWN?NMM S
a^a'<>E ;m?CN G8S<#H[4Gfa-?CN/a'3k<4N [email protected]<>A7E G7/7/J [email protected] <3534E;/W47 eg[T 4NF?C<[N NmSG8GO>J [email protected]'=Gf46=c;/H>7;/<>?C47B=ªbc638<>[email protected]°6eg<m47/H ;W<[4N N S˜<<>G8;m<N J38E [email protected]>T NÈ7 <aGf?3\ 2^=H>E [email protected]<><a'3k<><>=c7 ;M
[email protected]ÄeKEH>[email protected]< ? (B61; 4;FE AKScA\E2387 <>68LM<+<>=ƒ3EN NFE =c;3E 7AC<[N;/7/[email protected] 38W<[N9<[N/;£E 6N N/?5AC4=8D6<
1
2
1
V
2
2
0
1
1
2
1
2
Ofe
4 83<>;[email protected][N{4e a-47/38;AC<W] V8<#bc6<1H[<>[email protected]<^3E 7QAC<[NQD7FE 38W<[N Sa^E ?CN <>[email protected]<1G84=8=<168=7 O[N/[email protected];FE ;Q68=ª35<>6
` *p +! ] '5' ,` -6+8"6* % 2 ' 2
.3 - G 1 #- - . - G - "- G
G G
- 1 - -
$
l 4a-a'<m4=hAKJ E'G8O r #'[email protected]; SG8<=4am:87 <>6N <[N+bc6<[N/;/?C4=NBH[4=H[<>7/=E =c;BAC<[NBD7FE 38W<[N
3GEJ 687 =#egE [email protected] ; [email protected]¢DM4NF47/[email protected]=V;/;ÄW8a'<>=<ÈH[4H[47 <Èa24:[email protected]=LM<>E 7/; ;4<[[email protected] <SMA\G8E+<£38H[[email protected]¢[email protected] ;/35?C44= 7/;F?E u =c;J E <B68O>;/;F7 E <[=cN’;¢bc356<><[68N/;/; ?CM 4>=;/7 NÄ<ÈE A\38E+37 E <[7FH EGWFC<>;/77 HF4W=c<;
E06<>7/\DMA9<mG8<[N/<„;9H[<><1=„;/687F=YE LNE <>[email protected]=A ? N9_ <>=E H[?CN47 AC<m<ƒ438687 LM4<>:87/AU; T>? a'< G8<1A\E G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4=yG8<[N D7FE 38W<[N'G8<
=¶< <>; S£4= E ;/; <>=G¶<>=ˆDMO>=O>7FE AQGJ 68=);/WO[4j7 T>a'<´G8<¡G8O[H[4a-3k4N/[email protected];/?C4=€bV6˜J [email protected]
357jT><>a'7/a'<[N <>;/JS; <1?KO/J G8<^<>; G8O>JSa'?KO/4O =c;/7 7 <><>a-7'[email protected]?C<[N NmNF<>;/=VW;^O[4AC7j<>T>68a'7-<[a-NQ?C3NFN/E ?C7Q4= [email protected]=? Gf_ 6H>E ;/?CN'?C4=4=y? ¢E =ª;/; <>H[=<#GyN <>E =6N N S˜N/?9AC<[bcNQ6;/<ƒWO[AC<[4NM
=G8Z O[EJ [email protected][=VA¢4;’=a-N/<-6835AK7%4J <[ACN/<{N/[email protected];/;a'?C43=4IEG<N2N·T>S˜egAC4<9468=N/7/[email protected]?CLN <>E N 7=V<>H =c;9W; ]<#4G868='<[=N-G8<'4E [email protected]=8DMO[=4H[<£7/[email protected];/W8=-35a'D4<[7FN [email protected];/38?C<>W4=ª=< ; bc<>68a-SM?¢43=-35NQ<>LM7/35O>a'47/[email protected] <>\HI;/<9=; <#4N a-J [email protected]?\< E<[N/A’dH; egE4:N =EN H>N/<>?C;/7 bc?C-A46S= C< < M ?
DL 7F4E 68387’WE <68S¢;F38E 68=c?C;’N^bV46˜=yJ 4='7 O NTE E38H [email protected]<?CbVS6AC<{<h;/AKWJ EO[[email protected]>7/a'[email protected];/< W8JSa'?KO/<YO 7 =O[<{H>683k7 <>N 7/[email protected]'<><>a'; <>3=VE;ƒN N/G868<{7'a'AC<[<>N ;/;/7 a'<£4<>=7 H[+< E 68S6 LcV 7 < ?
H7[O[<>N;/4; <m6GfN/7;/<°7FE AC; <+O>D38?C7 <24:8<>=YUA T>a'; <><ma-G83<+NBA\35E-47 @A HI<[H[=44=8a-=?\E E ?CA N ?5NFEL =4H[68<m7+G8N <[J <>N9=YDH[7FE438=VLWE <[[email protected]È=G8H>7< <0{Sk4<>7/=YDM<'LE-] <[N NF&E HM<>7BG8<
? R A¢<[N/;egEH>[email protected]<'G8<'; <[N/; <>7mN/? <[N/;:EN/?Cbc6< )
B
j
=
=
4
6
m
N
8
G
4
8
=
=
^
<
8
6
=
D
F
7
E
8
3
W
<
D35M<>=h447/N [email protected] ;/[email protected];/W8:[email protected]@a'AC?C<2NF< E <>=c=`JS;°? e; <><> =Va-? ;/7 Z3<-NJ [email protected]ÈE 3568=4;/<[email protected] HI<Q=AKJ AK4<[J a-EN/;^[email protected]?\E 34A%7/[email protected]·;/7S’W8a'4H[=y< <Q#^7G8<[<Q68HFW=7 <><[7H[E [email protected]=84< =7/E [email protected];/?C=NW8NTa'E J =<[email protected][4G8<[email protected]< =cG8;1l<[N G47/[email protected] [email protected]=c==6NW< O MKr D47FAC?E N°38l <>W;<><[A\N E´l 68g<[E =SN/NA ;MM
[email protected]<>=8S6 DV#Wa'E a 47 H[O/< O E S6 ? V Z J<>[email protected];£6A HƒAC<[N9E H 68W= 4NFJ <[[email protected] 4N [email protected]< =c; 3EN N <>=c;£:8S?C4<>= = 3 LME 7/[email protected] ?C<>=VO; k #3dHE 79EN W< N Vf<><>7 a-°A38C<°AC<D7F35E 43868W7£<2G8<><[= N
G8R A8O>W< ;FVfE [email protected]?CACN/N; <{? 35Z 4J [email protected]7¢=˜H[J H#<>A\E E2683=^EN£E [email protected]< 47/J [email protected]@;/r/W84a'[email protected]=V<È; S8<>4=-=ƒ; <>7 <[a-HF3WN<>7 35H [email protected]<°HI=68=4a-<+?\3E E A7/G ;/[email protected];/?C#4=Yl E ? =cG8;/<£[email protected]'D6O><>;/7/[email protected]?Cbc<[G8648< ?S
Z ? +AC<>[email protected]=˜S ? B4WE HVE E {E#<>; 0 ? iB<[<[G O ?
A J <>=N <>a2:8AC<
[
<
/
N
'
;
8
G
4
=
„
H
3
E
/
7
/
;
@
?
/
;
C
?
4
8
=
=
h
O
>
<
y
=
8
G
>
<
S6 V<>=? NF<>am:8AC<[N <>; S 4 '
35E =V4;/NF?CE H[=c4; =8=˜<=J <[H[<WN/4V8;+=8<-3=G8EW< <NV8<mH[4G8=8< =W< SkV8<><-;+<>4; =`<>;È3k44= N < 3k=˜4NJ <[< N ;°3ENE =V? ;/Rd?CH[A4?=˜=8jBJ =Hh=YW< EƒV8HF< WE 64jB?CH>N/[email protected];=H< WE 4S7 ?CH[N>[email protected]; ; a-<-35<>=c4S;/NFH[7 E 4< =ca ; < M
<>; H[4=cS;/a^?C<>E =8?C=N9<°; 46868=#; <[;/NB7 4AC6ƒ<[N [email protected] 7 3>;E <[[email protected]ÈNBE 3kAC44N7 N/N{[email protected]:8bcAC6<[<NÈ<>=c;/7 < S <>; S ? RdAN <3k<>68S;9;/j7 T[NB:8<>?C;<>=hbc6<
NG84<„=V;'7 <>G8A\E < =H[0{<><>7^7/DM7 <O[H>? 68u 7 N/[email protected]=LMH<>a'S%3k<>=c468;#7-AKJ 7E <[[email protected][44=87/[email protected]=;/W8EGFCa';/7 <`< N/AC68<[N-7 D7FE 38W<[N'G8< 0{<>7/DM?<S L [email protected] A971<[H[N ;[email protected];/=V7 68<;/S¢[email protected][email protected]< A
<[N/;meKEH>[email protected]<„G8<1LMS O>7/N? \<>7'bV6< <[N/<>;-; G8< 0{<>7/DM<„N/?<>;'N NF4<>=c68;ÈAC<>G8a'< <>0{=V;'<>7/N/DM? < ?4u 4=H4= 3k<>68; S
G
G
G
G
(X, Y )
"
V (G)
G[X]
X
G[Y ]
G[X]
G[Y ]
B
G
Y
A
B =X \A
C
D = Y \C
C
D
G[A] G[B] G[C] G[D] G[X]
A
G[Y ]
A, B, C, D, X, Y
G
G[A ∪ B ∪ D] G[A ∪ C ∪ D]
G[A ∪ B ∪ C]
G[B ∪ C ∪ D]
O/R
7AC< <>A\H E E=N{H[<><W7{VI;/AK7J E >[email protected]'DM4<+7/[email protected];/'1W8a';/7 < 4?C7 NO[G8H>68<[N{7 N/<>[email protected]=<>N a'<>a2<>=V:8;9AC<[N N 687ÄH[<[NbV6E ;/7 <BN 4D=c7F;E 38G8W<B<[;FN E ? [email protected]@X AC< [email protected]=> E ScAC<>4a'=1<>LM=c4;[email protected];£GbVE 6=<N
N/E ?%383k4=¡<>ACNmG847 =8O[H>=68< 7 N #^? e AKN2J E N/[email protected]/[email protected];/<[W8N2a'D< 7FE 6838= W<[DN27FE G838<^W;F<-E E[[email protected]@LMAC< <[H N 4a-? (Ba'6´<>; 38N [email protected] [email protected]<AS7/[email protected]?CA’N bV7/6?Cbc< 6G8<^<2GA\J E H´=H[E[<>LM7 [email protected]
l 4E a-3835a'<>AC<hN·S84H[=y<ACbV<„68?˜[email protected]; =8S¢=A\E <683=E <7/;/[email protected][;/4?Ca-4= 38ACE <W=cVI;/[email protected];?CiN OmHI<Wa'VIO>3k;/47/=?CbV<>6=V<Y;/?C<>=˜[email protected] <[< N/? ;'3EN'68=< LMO>7/[email protected];FE :8AC<
G8NFE O[=H[4H[<Èa-G83k<[4N N/[email protected];/7F?C4E 38=˜WS <[E N’6G8N < <>0{=Nm<>7/E [email protected]<£DM4; 7/[email protected];/W8;Äa-Gf6'?Cbca'6<^[email protected]<>=;°N ?f3kL 44686877ÄAC<-E 6838;F7 E 4=V:8;UA T>bVa'6<9<'=G84<-6A\N E„AC<97 <[NFH[E4HF=8W8=?C4E =?CNN M S
=cG868O[H[A 4=˜a-J E'3k4A\E-N/[email protected]';/?C44= [email protected]=GfG87<[<2N'?CDG87FO[E <238WE s6<[r/N1468G87$< G0{J WV<>687/?%DMG8<h<m&E H[HV<mE =Vbc;ƒ6<G8< 3k4:k6847/=87F=E [email protected]<[; N'>38;/77 <m438687/=Y?CO>;;/O[WNƒO[4E j7 [email protected]>DMa'47/< [email protected];/G8SW <M
a-?Cbc6<[N ?
A, B, C, D
n
n−1
3n−3
S _h<)HIXB=84?C<>6A N38R7 O[N ] <>=c; 4=N£?CH>?kA\E2=4;/?C4= G8<B3E [email protected] <+GJ E a-?CN£GJ 68=„D7FE 38W<[email protected]=c;/7 [email protected]; <+3E 7
"6d#0 *5" ' 2
1.$. +3E [email protected] <9GJ E a-?CN - -/ ,
$ . . - - . *11 . .0 - 1-/ ,
XB46N{LM<>7/7 4=NÈbV6<+AC<[N{3E [email protected] <[N9GJ E a-?CNÈN 4=V;968= 468;/[email protected]˜<12^H EH[<354687{387 468LM<>79A\E
35=4<>76egNB<[H>=˜;/J?C&E4HM=`4=G8N<QH[H[4<>7/=8;F=E E [email protected]=?CN <[NFN+E =H>H[A\E<-N NG<[J N+E 6G8H><68=D7F<-E 38H>A\WE<[NFN°N <2G8G8< <Q0{D<>7F7/E DM38<WS< :8?CG8<>4= =Vbc;°6˜A\E#J W8?C3kN/;<>47 e7/<[?CbVH>;/6?C<>4a'=<>E [email protected];;
G=<'J E :5eg44=V7 ;G 3O>E; OQN 38<WVf7 4H[68<>38LM;/O[?C< 4= 3E #Y7+A\ACE<[N+7j3T>DE [email protected]<17 <[38N°68G?CNJ E bca-6< ?CN ?,l A WV<[6N Gf=D7F4·E LI38N WH<[NG8 < .0{%<>=˜7/DMJ 68<Q;/[email protected]<>[email protected]?CN V<>MK=Va ; >3a'E<N
AC3<[E N°7 H[3<^E [email protected] <[6N2<-GAC<>J E68a-7m?C:8N·68S;Q35<>O>68;FE; [email protected];2>;/G87 <^<'338E7 [email protected]=<>N/726 2^A\E NTE H[=4H[s= <'r/<[G8H>;/<'68AK7 J < 468JS;/[email protected][email protected]>&AKESa^N/68E 7?CNA\E 3k<>N 68;/7/; 6M >H>;/;/7 68<#7 <^E 6G8N <[N/N ?
DG7FJ EE a-38W?CN<[?NQX G84<; 40{=<>N7/DM; 4< 68?; u < eE 4=?CN{NQbcH[6<>;/<È; <ƒA\Em4=384;/;/?C?Cbc46=„<SG8<È[email protected]{3=E <^7/;/[email protected] ;/[email protected]\4E = [email protected];QE 3=c;/E?CNQiN Hc7 a'<[H[O>4;/687/?C7/[email protected]^6<+E 6S3V´E [email protected]<ÈE [email protected] E <[[email protected];
;eE 4<>38=c7/35a'; <><[1AG8NQ4#=G8H1G8<1<[3k3N„<>E 68H[[email protected] 4; <[M =cN>;/;/7FG7 E <ƒJ [email protected] =V68a-; =<[?CNN-6G8G8NTE<1< DMN <#34E [email protected]/a-N [email protected];MK38DO¡[email protected]?CE G8H>[email protected]<; W<„<[H WNG8?<><1a-u A\[email protected] ==N·=NQS9468;/bV?C=ª64<=N <>AKG8=J 4<1N =ˆ3l [email protected]<>7668<1Gf;ƒ=Geg4 J 4ELf7/a-N am!?CHN68? AC<>_`7Y E .<>?C= N
r 6N bc6˜J #`387 O[N <>=c; SE 6H>68=yG8<YAC<>687 N'7 ? O[N/[email protected];FE ; N^=˜J E¡3k<>7/a-?CN^G8<„;/7 468LM<>7#68=< 3E [email protected] <
G>;/J 7E <°a-68?CN-=hG4E 68=;/[email protected]˜683k=468D7È7FEN/[email protected]<„[email protected]? G8\<<>7 0{H[<><>7/7/DM;F< E [email protected]=R <[ANÈ7 <[3N/E ; 7/<ƒ;/?CbV<[N6<#G8<°AC<[A\N E 338E 7 [email protected]<>7 68<[LMN-<QGGfJ E 6 a-;/?CWN O[3k4j7 4T>68a'7/7F<E ?Ce <>4=V7/;;
G8<[N£u D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; N ?
G8G8<È4=8D=7F<>E E 7 38=4WN¢=<[NBH[N£<£G8G8H <[4WNB=cE ;£7 38O[[email protected]\N/;/Em687 <[email protected];FSV<>E =7 ; eg4NÈ<[6H>N N;/68?C7È=4=14A\E-63kN¢G8<>H[O>684; ;{=V<[H>N; <È;/<>?C=c438; = 7 <>47 G8684<[=LMNÈ<>NÄ7£3G8DE <[email protected]'<[H[N<><°=VGE;/J?CS6 E 4V1a-=8=3?CN <>E 7Ä[email protected]<>7 ;9H[<[<>N£387/7;FGO[E J [email protected] =<>a-=V<[;NÄ?CN<>H>?7 A\4XBE=N 4NN 6<[# NN
[email protected][[email protected]<>=&E ;/W<H^; MK<-DN/7F684cE 7{H[38H ACWE<[<[NN/?CN 4D? =¡7FXBE 38684W=6<[N =N£a'4:868<>[email protected]=V<>E;/AÄ?C7/4;/E [email protected]=DME 4<>=77/N [email protected];/=W8G8Na'468=V<^;£=G8<268<-=H[4<+G8s= O>G8r/; O><[<[a'H>H>;/;/468?C4=7 =<N/;/G87FG8E <Q< ;/?Ci 34E=„? [email protected]*7 3k<[W4N468Ga^7/7FJ EEE a-N°[email protected];£?C<>N7 ;+<>Ga-X E ?38=A\_ N+EH[ACEÆ<[<>de 7NM
ACL <[68N ?CQ/N+[ =G84<>67/N°=8?Ua'T>7 4<[=VN ;/37 <>E 7 DM4<[=N NmG8AK<J [email protected]\=VEB; O>387 7 ><>;m68LMG8<{<[N+G8<3EA\[email protected] H[<[4Nm=sGr/<[J E H>a-;/68?C7 N+<35eg447/68; 7°<A\G8E1<[N%H[4DAC7F4E 7F38E W;/?C<[4N%=´3<>E =¡7 eKE [email protected] ; WO N M ?
N <>=V;FE =c;AC<[N°D7FE 38W<[N3E 7 eKE [email protected]; <>a'<>=V; H[4=V;/7FEH>;/[email protected]<[N ? X 46N°=46NH[4=H[<>=V;/7 <>7 4=NQN/687
"
G
G
x
y
{x, y}
O/E
k[
ACE <[6ƒN H7 WO[N E [email protected][email protected];F;/E 7 ; <+N N/AC68<[N7Ä38AC<[[email protected]Ä6N¢3EO[[email protected]>7 A\<[E [email protected]E =cJ E ; a-N’?C3kN{4Gf686#7 A\[email protected][email protected]/7 68< [email protected]; <£1G8 <£*H[<{a'O>a' [email protected] 38<È68<>:8; [email protected]?C=OB4NF64N¢67N’<>A\=VE2LMGf4&[email protected] 4<[=HWNM
;/DM?CO>4==O>7FG8E < AC< 0 7/a^6H[E <-?CN+iB68<[=`<[G¡35<><>6`;a'UM447/[email protected]=<-N+iB7 O[E H[a <>[email protected]; )<< h ? (BX A 4eg46=NÈN ;@= <>7/[email protected]=<>357 44=68N7°368E=7 <'G8jN <[HcN =c;/; 4W <>T[=VN ;F< E ;/[email protected]@6<[NN
G8<°DMO>=O>7FE [email protected]?CNTE ;/?C4=hG8<+A\E =4;/?C4=YG8<3E [email protected] <GJ E a-?CN ?
"
"
t <>=87/?_`<)Hc=8?C<>AE-387 468LMO°AC<+;/WO[47jT>a'<mN/[email protected] =V;2]
`!*p +! ' ] "8 . 1 $ $ A <[N£;/7 46N£[email protected] [email protected] N9=˜J 4=c;93EN9G8<+3E [email protected] <°GJ E a-?CN SAC<[N9E =V;/[email protected];/7 46N9AC4=8DMN9=4= [email protected]
DLI <>6?\=cE <>AC;/68<’7 7 <¡GfO6G8 ;/<>?W6SA O[V < 47j;/N >T W4a'a-O[4<’a'7jeg>T 4<>a';7/Nƒ;<°G8=G8<[4<BN=S_`DdM 7FE<)E GcH 38r =8EW?CH[<[<><>N Ak=V3<[; N/EN·;{7S£[email protected]°[email protected]; =<WN˜H°IV a^?CEN/E ;6s?C<hr N 4SÆ;68O>47 Lc6sG?C/r G8J 4Wc<>6868a-7 ?Nƒa'68=68<>=c=)<B; H[SÆH 4_`W=<>N <)a-O[cH [email protected]=8=)6?C<><>Ac=G8AK<`H[J <E[ACL;/4E 7/[email protected]?N;MM
3eK8E 7 [email protected]; 68N'LMG8OB< [email protected] 4·<[LsH>g; <>Nia'h <> =V;/W; ?O[4A 7j<9T>a';/W< O[4JS7j?K>T Q a'Q<B4=VG8;^<9_h354<)68IH 7^=8?CH[<>4A=<>NF;¢O[ACbV<96;/<>W=O[H[4< 7j>T Gfa'[email protected] <È<[H>G8; <[< N¢A\DE`7FE 3538<>W7 eg<[<[N’H>3;/?CE 47 = M
G8N/?£<[NB; 4H>68A\E;1N NN <[4NÈ6NG8KM <mD7FDE 7F38E W38<„W<[[email protected]È=GfN/[email protected][email protected];LE =V; <[G8NQ< ]4=`[email protected];È=ybV7 6˜O[GfJ [email protected]; D7F#¡E 3868W=y< N G4a-<[a'N/;È<>G8;^< H[4-=c;/?C <> =V ;168$=<
33EE [email protected]/7 ;/<'?CNQG<>J ;mE a-AC<[?CNQNmH[G84< a-H38ACO>4a'6¡<>68=V=;FE <[email protected] 3H<[E [email protected] G8<-<^G:8GJ [email protected] ?C7/N;/?CG8N2< N 4H=c;Q?,L G8E<[Nm72D<WfV7FE<>38a-W38<[ACN <SkG8AC<^<[N°bcD67FEE N/38?NKM W3<[E N7/[email protected]:8; O ?NM ?
jG8B< =„[email protected];9Gf?!bckO6˜>J 768<>=1=c;^D7FGE J3868W=<°<ƒ<[H>N [email protected];{?CbVG86< <„-H[4=c ;/ ?C <>=V;'$68 =<11 3 E *[email protected] °<„N/G?kJ; E 4a-68;£?CN-N 4G86< N KM D7F?8E L38WE 7'<[email protected]<W=8V Gf<>[email protected]; 38ACH<S
ACbc<[6N{EGDN/7F?NKM E 338E W7/<[[email protected];N£O:8N/[email protected];/37/E ?CH>7/;;/?C<mNÈ<[N N/4;£=V68;9= G8<[DN{7FE D387FWE 38<WG8<[<N9bcG86<°EbcN/6?NKM E3N/E ?N7/[email protected]; E O 7/? [email protected]; O°N/;/7/?CH>; < H? * 468;£D7FE 38W<G8<
D7FE 38jBW=Y< ?535u <>68E ;9= N 0<°?C<>G8=<>N/a^; 4IE H= G8<>EQ7Ba'N J [email protected]˜=c<[;/N/7 ;{OmeKbcE6H><°[email protected]<°H[<°G8<+387 ;/47 :8468AU>T LMa'<>7B<G8<[<[N/;ÈN{<>3=„E [email protected] <[O>NÈ=O>G7FJ E E A a-Gf?C?3NÈ2^GH>E [email protected]=<^N9] 68=
lD*p69 ,+!:' '
B=„D7FE 38W< G <>;9G8<>6SV N 4a-a'<>; N a <>; b G8< G ?
!
A E 3E [email protected] < {a, b} <[N/; M <>[email protected]<68=<+3E [email protected] <mGJ E a-?CN9G8< G l 4/X L M H[4a-38AC<>; 0?C<>=N/; 4cH 5S >&O ?
!
_
E
C
?
%
N
\
A
B
E
7
[
<
H
W
>
<
7
F
H
W
È
<
8
G
<
3
E
@
?
7
[
<
¢
N

G
J
E
a
C
?
%
N
k
3
>
<
8
6
>;/7 <Ä7 O E [email protected]?CNFO[<£<>=-; <>a-3N%[email protected] =4a-?\E A
;
N/NF?E =AKJ H[4<£=hG8N <[<mN%7 D<[7FN/E ;/387 <>[email protected]<[=VN ;°G8E < 6S0{V <>D7/7FDME < 38gWE <[[email protected]/<[email protected];/W80{a'<>7/< DM<SS? k DS 7 3EH[DM< < #->&AK[J E [email protected]]4N/7/[email protected];/W8a'<[N/< ;%G868<m= 7 D<[7FH[E 438=8W=<9E ?CG8N < M
G
0{<>7/DM< <>;N/? {a, b} <[N ;Ä68=<B3E [email protected] <BG8< N 4a-a'<>;£G8< G SIE AC47 N4=ƒH[4=N/;/7/[email protected];{AC<ÈD7FE 38W<
?
G 4:8; <>=V6<>=EGr/468;FE =V;1# G 68=¡N 4a-a'<>;°bV68?%=<[email protected];°bV6< a <>; b jB=¡H[4=N/;FE ; <
E AC47 N{bc6< {a, b} <[N/;68=<È3E [email protected] <+GJ E a-?CN£G8< G N/?”<>;£N <>68AC<>a'<>=c;£N/? G <[N/;G8< 0{<>7/DM< ?
3;FE E 7 7/[email protected] ; OG84S5<[6<>NmN¢;ÈH>E GA\[email protected] 4EN =N68<[N%;/Nm7 a^<[G8N E <[email protected]>=VA\D;E7F<>N E =N 38<[E WNÈ=c<[;’bcN2638G8<°7 O[<^AKN J <>bV4=c=`6; E<>N N/74?NKM 686833 =E ([<{7/[email protected]>; =8O#A\=EN<mN/N;/<{;7/?C<>G8H>[email protected]; <<[<^N D?H7FEEX [email protected]’<[N9N N 38J3E[7 ELfO[7 >T NFeg7 <>E <#[email protected]; ; bVN <>67 G84<'<{=; bcN 466838E;[email protected]/6<[?NNNM
0
0
. k4>
ACE <[6SNÈV1H>A\38E7 N 4N 38<[7/NB?CO>bV; 6O[<mNÈ[email protected]È7/a'?CH <>W=c<[;/N2?C4]f=8AC=<[N£<>7 D47F=E N°38WN <><[7N943=VE; 7 <>eKE= [email protected]; eK<>E a'[email protected];B<>H[=V4; =cH[; 4<>=V=V6;/7F<[EN°H>;/[email protected]<[=N N9? 68=<2H>A\EN N <
'/! & *'/ *
7 <>387 jBO[N = <>=V7F; E O238H>35?N<>M [email protected]<[< N N bc466<hNAC] <
-/,-)<[N/;ƒ68=
"!$#&% [email protected]> D7FE 38W<`3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7#´H>[email protected]=brN 4a-a'<>; N
A <°;FE 687 < E 6
’E
<
l WcLsg ;FE A8<>;X EGr [email protected]:E Z :[email protected]? J 4=V; G8O>a'4=c;/7 O£bV6<ÄAC<[ND7FE 38W<[N G8< 0{<>7/DM<
NeF7FE E&=H N{<>;F;°E 68j 7 <N HE E6Y7 N L 4=c47/;£; 34ƒE 47 =cegE ; [email protected]; a'N ?<4L =c;/E 7 79O A\EbV6N/<[email protected]; <[<NÈS Dl 7F<>E [email protected][email protected]=WE'<[N+G8G8<°< X [email protected]<>67/<>[email protected]<Q7 <[NFG8E 48=SNBX8;F7 E O[68G87 O>< 7/E ?CHm6¡_ N 4EÆ=Ved;M
G8G8<[<°NBbVD67FEE N/38?NMKW3<[E N°7/[email protected]; Om< H[bc46=8E=VN/6?NMK<3E #'7/[email protected][; <O r 4O/68E 7 ?? l J <[N/;+A\E^H>A\ENFN <QA\E'[email protected]+DMO>=O>7FE AC<-G8<QD7FE 38W<[N
07/6H[<ÈiÈ<[<[G1<>o
;
X+GE r [email protected]:E Z :[email protected]? Efe 4=V;{G84=8=OB68=ƒE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'? l <+<>=^; <>[email protected] HM
=7 <[4G8a-4°?\<>E ;%A835X47 O[68G87 O>7 7/<[?CH9H[4_`=8=E GEk7FCF;/E 7 H<ÈAC<[O/N%R D47FE=V38;¢WG8<[4N¢=8G8=< O£0{G8<[<>N¢7/DME <[email protected] 7/[email protected]%;/W8;Fa'E 68<[7 NÄ< <>E =-6 ; <>a-<>[email protected][email protected]=N E°3kG84<{[email protected][email protected]<>?\E N? MA
35AC447F68E 7;/?C74O[= N 4=64Gf;F7E <Ba-ACa'<[NÄ<>38=V;7 4?$:8A UA <>T>68a'7 <[NBN£E H>[email protected]\E4NF7/N/[email protected]?C;/bVW86a'<[<[NNÈG=˜J 4J 6838;/;/[email protected][email protected]@a-?CN ?C<>NF=VE ;B;/?C34=EN£N/AC68<[7{N9H[3<[E NÄ[email protected]<[7FNÈE 38GWJ E <[a-N SI?CA\N Em? H[4 M
. )+ & *'/ )+* ' "
Z ; <>38WE = t 468DVE 7 GSH fe E O>;/6Gf?CO#AC<[Nm3E [email protected] <[NQGJ E a-?CN GE =NmAC<[[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<[N
GAC8<ƒ< [email protected]:[email protected][email protected]<WMKE D7/7F;/E ?CN 38? WRd<YA’EƒGJ 68G8=–4=8D=7FO-E 3868W=<YE :[email protected][email protected]/E [email protected]/;/;/W8?9a'35<^4NF<>Nj=¡T[G8; <ƒ<>a-683=Nm<„3534E [email protected][email protected] <=4Ga-J E ?\a-E A¢?CN3k? 468A 7<„G8;/O[WH>O[?C4G87j<>T>72a'N/< ?
N/G868<[email protected] E [email protected];+<[a'NÈG4=VJ E ;/a-7 <'?CN bc? 6< G8<2=4a2:87 <>6SV¡[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<[NG8< :[email protected] 7/;/?CN+=< 354NFNjT[G8<>=V;+3EN
` *p +! ' ! 5* - 7p;<+
.3 L(R) L(R)
- *, " , R & '
D7FE 38tBW4<[68NÈDVG8E <°7 SG bcH 6EE¶N/?NMKO>3DVE E 7/[email protected]<>; a'O<><>=V;9;AC<[N£387 D47F3kE 438N WOy<[NBG8G8<[<°NªbVH[64Es= Nr ?N<[MKH>3;/E 687/7 [email protected]<[; NªOmN/3k;/47/?C68H>7; <-H ] E 7FEH>; O>7/?CN <>7ªAC<[N
*5")f#0-.:' 1 5* - 7p;<+
-/ - 1 - $ 1 * - 11 $. - . *. - * * 1 + 1
- - - - - - .0 " - . . - 1 & kJ
A E-H[4=sr <[H>;/687 <=<°387 O[H>?CN <+3EN9bc6<>ACN£[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<[N G8<+:[email protected] 7/;/?CNÈN 4=c;[email protected][email protected]^EGM
AC=<>4a'a2<>:8=c7 ;°<`=G84<h=H G8E<2N^bc36E E7/N/;/?N?CKM H>368E [email protected]/?C<>[email protected]; 7 O-NƒN/4;/=c7/?C;1H>; O>< ; ? OY 7 [email protected][AC<-N 4<[[email protected]/;+Nh<>]Ä=GH[4E 7=<-N^4AC68<hLMH <>E7/N#; <G8Sk<[a^N#E D?CN+7FE 6838=¡W<[H[N1<>7/NF;FE E [email protected]= N
;FNFEE 68=7N°< GfE 6„?\E a^3E E 7 =c;ml 3? G8E 7<°°[email protected])Dh 6GS<>H [email protected] <[<>;G848Z S8H[_`4:5E <[k7< FE es1H [ <>S; GL E 4=7/N; 4 AC<-O/H E EN°SfGG8E <[=N°N{DAC7F<+E 38H EWN{<[NG8<[NFN{E =DN°7FE D387/W?!<<[N
3_ E E 7 57A [email protected]&=8'H W<>E ;Ä7 <[iBN£<[<><[;{G _`esE R k7?FEt H 468esDVQ E 7SIGSG^H E =ENO>ACDV<BE H AC<>Ea'N{G8<>=c<[;{NÄ38D7F7 E43835W4<[N OÈN{38A\E°A\E H[=4E [email protected]/r 7 <[<[H>N;/6837E <B7 N/A [email protected][email protected]=8LWE E=V7 ; <[<QN S]
*$" /#0-6G ' *$- 75;<G+
5*$ $ G - - 11 "
- $ - 1 $+ . -/ . *. - * * 1 0. . - G G 11 - - - .0 . $ - '/ ! '/& A <[ND7FE 38W<[N :[email protected] 7/;/?CNFE =NN 4=V;G8OW\=8?CN˜[email protected]@?CH>[email protected]; <>a'<>=V; GE =N A\E{387 <>68LM<’Gf62;/WO[4M
7jG8T>< a'l <ÄWVeg64Gf7/;%=4·G8LI<[NN%DH 7FE 38 W.<[N%3J/E[ 7 ?eKE [email protected]; ='N E JS38> 3k<>[email protected]<>AC;<’<WDIV [email protected]?CWH>[email protected]< ; <>a' <>=c;’ GE -=N%; 4AK68J E ;%7/;/D?C7FH>E AC<£38WG8<Ä<ÄG8NjcH < =c0{;/W4<>7/[T DMN <<
NF<>E;9=NFN{E =38N 7/?CN a'<BAC4=8DSfNF? E È=N£=H[<°4H[a-4=s38/r AC<[O>a'H>;/68<>=c7 <;[email protected] <m7 4G835< 4NF38O[7/<+?CN/[email protected]'=G8< O>AC354<>=8=DGSfE NFa-E =a'N£<>G8=c4;È683:8EAC<W79M GfX8?\7 E O[a^G8O>E 7/=V?CH;
_N/;/[email protected] 385768FACE&<YHL(K
<bV>6; <ƒiÈAC<[4N^:8\[email protected]=e)7FE * 38WW<[4N'a^:[email protected] 3E #Y7/;/?CA\NFEhE =H[4N#=fN eg4O>=V7 <>;^=G8H[<ƒ<[N'G8D< 7FEL 38E WAC4<[M N^([email protected]; < 48S%bc6=E4 N/LM?N<>KM a23E :87/7 [email protected]<; O J/? [/[/J A\ E S
G38<>E 7/DM=8< ?U>T O/7 Q <'=NF<[<QH>NF;/4?C4=V=; 7/Gf?C6 <>= HFWGE J [email protected];/;/7 7 < < Q bcSk6˜=J 684= 6N+;/WLMO[<>47/7j7 >T4a'=N<QbcG86< <QG8ACO[<[H[N+4;/a-WO[3k447jN/>T [email protected]';/?C4<[=¡N JSG8?K<[O/N [ D<>7F; E 38JSW?KOS<[>N
:8a'[email protected]<>;/E ;/7/7F;/E [email protected];QE =G8N <-? B387 =4<968LM38<>7 7m<>68A\LME„<+H[G84<B=s/r AC<[<>H>68;/768bc7 <-6Eeg4N/?N7/KM ; 3<'E 7/[email protected]<[; ONmSfD<>7F;{E 38G8W4=<[NHB3G8<BE 7 ACeK<>E [email protected];7ÄNm3kNF<>E 7 =eg<[N°H>;/7 ?C<[4H[=˜4Sc683k7 N <>7 # M
H[(B<[61N-HFG8W<>E 6S38ªV [email protected];/;/7 W< O[ 4SV7j>T=a'46<[N{N S G8G844=8=V=;-<>7 A\4Eh=N{387 68<>= 68LME <„[email protected][7/[email protected]>;/68W835a'<1<+AC<[G8N < Q/7 <[[ H[4G8=8<>=7/=8E ?U?C>T N 7NF<[E N-=H[3<+E DMG8<[<[N-NDG87F< E 38JSW> <[N ?
:[email protected] 7/;/?CNFE =N gE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'< S?KJfe 3E DM< >&O/Q SH[4a-38AC<WIV [email protected]; O O(n ) ?
*$" /#0-6G ' ' ; ; # `6*5;<% G - "
3,3
9
.0 G - 0 X 4; 4=NÈbc6<+A\EQ7 O[H>[email protected] 4IbV6<G8<A\E-H[4=sr <[H>;/687 <m<[N/;{egE 6NFN <-]fAC<G8468:8AC<Gf?\E a^E =c;
=˜N 4J <[=cN/;Q;ƒG83<[ENQNƒD:87FE [email protected] W7/<[;/N ?CNFG8E =˜<1S£bV<>6;ƒEN/3k?NKM 4368E 7/7/;[email protected] ; =VO1; N/S£;/7/[email protected]°?CH><[; <N/;ƒS<>G8;Q< G8bV46=EH1N ?NG8KM 3<1E bV7/[email protected]; EO N/{?NKM AC3<[E Nƒ7/[email protected]; O7/?CSN/a'NFE < =N AC4>=8;/DM7 <N
:[email protected] 7/;/?CNFE =N ?
$& &/%) '/ # # '/
c68b 68=ˆ?”[email protected]>4DM; 64<[7/N H>[email protected]; ;/=< W84a'AC6<[N <hNÄ383bc7 E [email protected]?B7 <[4G8NÄN O[4GH>=?CJ EG8N a-< ?CH>?C?N/N{?ÈGGJ68EO>=r;=<>NÄ[email protected][email protected]=<[7 N’<W<È[email protected][email protected]=7F6E <W<>38MKACDWbc7F<6E <{38-W35<[<>1N£6-.0*,G8 AK<ÈJ!E -:[email protected][email protected]´7/E [email protected]/H[;/;/4W8?C=Va'N ;/? ?C<ÈX <>=VG84;ƒ< 6NtB68=G84<h468=8DV3=E E [email protected]=7 H <N
GDM4J E 7/[email protected];/W8?CN a'? <RdA JSN/? 6e 2'Sbc;+6835?%43568<>7°7/a'H[<><>A\;EƒG8G8< <Q7 7F<[EH[N 4N =<>a2N ;/:87/68AC<>[email protected] <-G8A\<>E#6SVh7FE7 H>O[[email protected]=N 68<[email protected];FGE J ;68N=¡[email protected] [email protected]=<)<Wh-MKDO>7FACE [email protected]=<O[SN'<>;+]5AK68J E =AN< M
. kO
VbE 386˜38J)([email protected]?C=H EGf;/7 ?Cg4N =#Z 3k<><>:6^H[a 4=8J E-=V6N/<[email protected]=<[E NÄACO[E <'[email protected]] 47/[email protected];/W8a'<[N{G8<9H[46838A\E DM< Gf6<#UVEH ¢Gfa'4=G8N·Sc<>;
% ,7p*5d#0`8:' +*$".+8%
b 2.- _8; 7p!%1 2 1 f# 1
B=„D7FE 38W< <>;ÈG8<>S6 V„N 4a-a'<>; N <>; G8< ?
! a-G8<[email protected]=8H [email protected]^GE FCE =ACB<-<2=E[G8<¢LM<+<[H ACHW4EG=8H[FC<[D=NÈ6<<>38G8687 < 7È43837/ESÆ?CO>[email protected] ; <¢< O[NAC?4)=8D6N/<>? 68687=3<mE ;[email protected] <><[email protected] <Q7 <>H [email protected]?\E GE =VFC=; < W< <>Vf; ?CN/; <>< ;? G8Z <’[email protected]=AC44=8=˜DS 63<>68E7N
?
!
XB4;/7 <£E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<È7 <>354N <£E 6N N ?fN 687AC<{AC<>a-a'<£N [email protected] =c;¢bV68?f;/[email protected];¢AKJ ?CG8O[<{:8?C<>=
H[G84<[=8N9=VH 6W< <>[email protected]=<£NBAC<[bVNÄ6H E W=EGG FC=4<[=YN3GEJ 68N =^N <DE 7F6„E [email protected][email protected]=<W< ScMKa D7F>E a'38W<È<^N/?”] <>[email protected]<[N’4=V;G8<[NÄH[47 G8<[N·SVG8<>LI?C<>=8=<>=V;
G
G
a
b
G
a
b
n3
! ' = $ R - G = L(R) F - 1 1. .0 . 11. , - *1/ R 1-/.0 R!- $ - F1* 1 G
Z ? <[N ;9AKJ <>=N <>am:8AC<QG8<[NBE 7 >; <[N GJ 68=<QH WEGFC=<mG8< SE AC47 N 4=Y=l 4; <
N
[
<
È
N
E
7
>; <[N SGE =N£AKJ 47 Gf7 <m4'Y<>[email protected]<[NBE 383E 7FE ?CN N <>=V; N/6879A\E HFWEGFC=< ? <[N
E687=><; <[H NÈWEGG8FC< =<2G8H[< 4=N/?;/[email protected] ;/6<><>;/;=c<2; H E W6EGN FCN =?˜<m68<[=N <;ÈN/NF68E [email protected]=; <2N9H[G84<7 G8N 4<2a-H a'E 79<>68; NÈ=<G8< O>LM<>=Vbc;/686?˜<>[email protected]<[AC<QN/;ÈH[H>4A\7 E [email protected]<m<>a'<>=c<>;/=c7 <;
G8<[NÄ<>; N 4a-Sa'N <>4; ?CN£<>=VG8;2< [email protected]=H>S ?CG8<>=V<>;; <[N2:8E ?CLM<>=´<[H bV6< =4=H[[email protected][H>[email protected]?C;/[email protected]<[<>N27FE [email protected];£E =bcN6<ÈA\E„AC<[H N{WE GE 7 FC>=; <<[S N£H[G8<-< bV68?S
<[N/;£[email protected]Èa-O[35H>[email protected] N/[email protected]:8bVAC6< <>? a'jB<>=h=c; EQS8a'N/? 4=V;/7 LcO26„bVH[64< a-a'[email protected]<°=Gf6868=„[email protected];9<>=:8N ?C<><>a2= :868AC= <HG8W<+<>[email protected]=`a'G8<>< ; N£G8? < ’[email protected][email protected];
[email protected]=N{E HF38W3<>[email protected] =´?CNFNG8<>< =V;ÈN S˜68E 7 AC47 N°?SA 4<[= N£=N 44;a-< a'<>; N S AC<[N°N 4a-a'<>Sf; N°N 4G8=V< ;ÈE 6SN GN ?5E =G8<[N+N9AKJE 47 7 >Gf; 7 <[<-N£4G8' <
? L 4687; 468;

S
@
?
A
[
<
/
N
;
>
H
\
A
E
@
?
7
c
b
6
<
C
A
[
<
N
E
7
>; <[NG8< S <>;
S
?
?
A3KN J4<WE=VVIN ;Q;/7 [email protected]>=a-H>[email protected];? O-<>Z =VJ [email protected]; A<<[W< N Vf?CjBN/; bV=< 68?%==˜4;J <[< N/;°3EN E[<>LM;°<[4H AC<>= 687-=4W< ; Vf< ;/7 O>E [email protected];7 <WO1N·VISM;/H[47 46^O>a-a-:[email protected]?C; <>68O^='[email protected]< 5A < H jBE2=ªE bV6'=684?%a'; =˜< 4J [email protected]<[=N/;N
;/G7 E 4=?CNN E 7 >;gE<[:N-N/G868< 7 G8< [email protected]=4H>6?CG8:8<>?C=V<>; = <[N'<>=ª68=a S><>a';2<[email protected]´4a-E a'68=ª<>; H)bcHI68H>?{AC<1G8G4E=8==N <>=V;-68 O>=DVE;/7/AC<>?\Ea'=8<>D=cAC<;
EGf:?CN/N/;/[email protected]=7 G8H>;< N ? ? (ÈjB68=ª;/7 LM<>4a'[email protected]; <>=cG8;È[email protected]#; S bc6<^35AC<><[68NQ; N >4;/a-7 < a'Lc<>6„; N H[4a-S a'<+AKJ <>=N <>a2:8S AC<°N 4G8=c<[;QN9G8E <>7 S6 >V; <[N£# GG8J 68<>S6 =V <
H WEGFC=<G8< ?
? Z 4=387/[email protected]=H>[email protected]<'<[N/;;/j7 T[N2N/[email protected]<SAKJ ?CG8O[<#O>;FE =V;2bc6<'N/?
¢4
C
?
>
H
¢
?
=
4
/
;
7
#
<
E
@
A
M
D
4
/
7
@
?
/
;
8
W
'
a
<
44='= NFNFEE [email protected][email protected];%;{egegE E [email protected][email protected] 7 <£<bcA\EQ6<>a ACbc>6a'<£<H WH 4WN4<ÈN <QE LME[<[LMH9<[HG8<[G8N¢<[HFNÈWH EGWFC<>=a-<[N’[email protected]=GN E =GN E =AC<[N£N ACD<[7FN£E [email protected][email protected]=WW< <[MKNÄD<>7FE=-38DMWO><[=N O>? 7FE AKSVE AC47 N
% ,7p*5d#0`8:' 2.B=„[email protected][email protected]=W< MKD7FE 38W< <>;9G8<>S6 V N 4a-a'<>; N <>; G8< ?
! B=1HFW<>[email protected]=YG8< AC4=8D6<>687£[email protected] [email protected] <+7 <>[email protected]?\E =V; <>; SfN J [email protected]<WVI?CN/; < 68=ƒ; <>A
?
H W<>[email protected]= Z [email protected]=4=˜S <[N/;£68=<°3E [email protected] <GJ E a-?CNBG8< ?
F
F
R
e1 , e 2 , . . . , e k
R
G
G
G ei
ei
ej
|i − j| > 1
R
ej
F
G
F
G
G
v1 , . . . v k
F
F
vi i = 1, . . . , k
i ∈ {1, . . . , k − 1}
ui ∈ V (R)
v1
u1
uk
0≤i<j≤k
u i = uj
R
u0 = uk
ui 0 ≤ i ≤ k
F
R
uk−1
P
R vi
vk
P
R
vi+1
u0
2
G
{a, b}
a
a
G
b
b
G
k/k
P
+
7
[
H
<
#„AKJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'< JS? e SH E ACH>68AC<>7Q68=´D7FE 38W<
? jB=Y3k<>68;[email protected] <>; H[4a-a'<QG8<[N+E 7 >; <[NBG8< ? jB; <>=YA’bc=64;< <
<35W<>VI; 4;/687 7 O>a-; [email protected]; <[O[; NmN¢G8G8<><{6SAKV´J E 7 <W>Vf; ;/< Sc7 O>4a-?=^P [email protected] ; 7 EO[ACNQH>H[68<G8AC<'#B<£AKAK68JJ [email protected]<£DM>4;HF<W7/[email protected];/FCW8=Sa'<È4<=G8<OS=?KR4S; <3k4687 ; 4<>;68; AC<[N2=G84<>; 6SO[<>V <;
; <>=G^SVG8a'<94I<[ACN/Gf4;È68=8AC68D4 =6J<°<>68 3? 7{E Z [email protected]?57 E <E [email protected]< H>J 68E<>=a-;’< 7 ?C<>NÈ[email protected]?\<BG8E < =cH[<[; NH ? WZ GE [email protected]# ==4<[=˜NS=˜H[J 4W< AKVf=J E?CN G8N/?C;G8Gf<O>[email protected];/7 ?CN<>4; 79=ƒ4AK38JG8<>35<[=<>NÄN 7{<>[email protected]<>=am;’Gf:8?C7 ACH[O>< <[3kN{4N=J G8Gf<>=S7<[<NM
E 7 ?>;Z <[; N¢438G83k<£<>AK7ÄJ 68<>=;¢<97 G8<>;<£4H[68<[7/N¢=HF<>W7GE ACFC<9=N <[4N 6SMNbcMK68D?7FE<[38N/;’WE<B6G8N < N/?868='[email protected]=<>[email protected]<>;’am3:8E AC7 <ÈG8<£NF4a-a'<>; N’G8< ?
?
!
Z ?¢AKJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<#GJ ¢Gfa'4=G8Nm;/7 468LM<'68=<'H WGE FC=< G8< AC4=8D6<>687
3N/68E 7 [email protected] <S E AC4? 7 jBN˜=y4===44; ; < <
N <[NE 7 ><>; <[; N·S GE =NAKJ 47 Gf7 <’4'2<>[email protected]<[NE 383? E 7Fl E 4?CNa-N <>a'=c<;
S
ACAK<[J <>N°=NN 4<>a2a-:8a'AC<+<>; G8Nm<[G8N{< E 7 >; <[N{NFG4=VJ 68;=H< WH 4W?CNEG?CFCN=<°GE G8=< N bc68?”H[4a-3k47/; < SkAKJ <>E =7 N ><>; am<[N :8?!ACu < J E 387j<[T[N/N;
ACG8<{< AC<>a-G8a'<£< AC4OS=8?KEDS6<>68<[7’N/[email protected];¢a-E 36E N [email protected] 7 ?8<£687 = <>[email protected]<>?\E==VNF;<>am:8# AC<9G8]<£AKJ EN [email protected]'7/[email protected];/<>W8; a'N G8<9< G84=8bV=68<£?fA\[email protected] =Gf:[email protected];¢=68<£=-7 O>H 35W4<>[email protected]< = ?
B
i
[
O
>
H
@
?
8
3
7
c
4
c
b
6
>
<
'
a
>
<
V
=
;
c
S
/
N
f
?
K
A
J
E
@
A
M
D
4
/
7
@
?
/
;
8
W
'
a
È
<

G
J ¢Gfa'4=G8N’=<£;/7 468LM<{3EN¢G8<£HFWGE FC=< S
EN/68AC4387 3kNƒ44N <1=‘<>L=E´LIa'64<1=VG;/7 J 68<>7„=<1bc6H[4< =c;/7FEGf?CH>;/<[?C4N/;1=–68AKJ=W< <YVf?CN/3; E <>[email protected]=7 <`H[<ƒGGJ E E a-=N ?CN„G8< GJ 68=?oL H W4<>68a-7„[email protected][= <>A\EfS4G8= <
ACAC4<[NB=8DN 64a-<>68a'7 <>[email protected]; a-NÈ3G8E < [email protected] <¡S<>=cG;/E 7 =< NÈAKJ 4<>7 ; Gf7 <m? 4 jB' = [email protected]=4E ; 38< 3E 7FE ?CN N <>=c;BS N/687S ? ? ? ?4S A <[NÈSN 4a-a'<>; N S
·
S
N
4
c
=
;
E
6
N
/
N
M
?
8
G
[
<
N
E
7
>; <[NG8< bc68?KS GJ E 38j7 T[NAC< AC<>a-a'< OS?KE S 3k<>68LM<>=V;
>;/7 <mLc6<[NBH[4a-a'<AC<[NBE 7 >; <[NBGJ 68=<mHFWEGFC=<2G8<°AC4=8D6<>687 3E [email protected] <mG8< ? _`E ?CN E AC47 N
[
<
/
N
m
;
K
A
J
>
<
=
N
>
<
2
a
8
:
C
A
ƒ
<
8
G
[
<
Q
N
E
7
>; <[N GJ 68=<1H WGE FC=<
8
G
'
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
3
E
@
?
7
<
?
bc6<+u AKJ E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<QE 687FE [email protected];BG G8O>; <[H>; <>72]f68=<H[4=c;/?7FEZ Gf?CH>;/?C4=
=O[<°34E =7BH H[<>[email protected] EAC<[email protected]<+7/[email protected];/JW8E a'[email protected]<°47/[email protected];/4W8=8a'=<< A\OSE?KRS:k? 4=8=<B7 O>354=N < E2H[4a-38ACW< [email protected]; O+<[N/;:8?C<>=„G84a-N? M
L(R)
ua,2
a
b
R
R
b
a
ub,1
ub,2
i ∈ {1, 2}
R \ {ua,i+1 , ua,j+1 }
j ∈ {1, 2}
Ci,j
ua,i
{a, b}
G=
ua,1
ub,j
G
P
G
Q = P ∪ {a, b}
G
n3
Ci,j
e1 , e2 , . . . , e2α
e0 = a e2α+1 = b
Ci,j
Q = {e0 , e1 , . . . , e2α+1 }
R \ {ua,i+1 , ua,j+1 }
R
2α + 2
G
Ci,j
Q
G
a
Q
b
Ci,j
{a, b}
G
G
a
b
v0 = a v1
P0
k = 0, . . . , 2α+1
v2α
P0
P0
v2α+1 = b
vk
R
R
{v1 , . . . , v2α }
Ci,j
2
F
;
E
V
=
Ä
;
8
G
4
8
=
=
[
O
N
8
G
>
<
SV-N 4a-a'<>; N GJ 68='D7FE 38W< SM4=^G8OW\[email protected];ÄAKJ 435O>7FE ;/?C4=1G8<
6
=<>*,; 4; O ? jB*=' <>= ;B^4;7 G8<<>[email protected]< ?CO #'<>; HFWACE<£] bV4D6=27F<QE <>38N=8W4AUa-<ÈT>LM4a'< :8<>; ;+<><>=cG8; 6 < ? jBG8< =^[email protected]Æ;’<>;bc64=< bcEG68r ?4LM68,4; <Ä[email protected]; 68 AK=2J 68 ==`4E686YLM< a'EG6 E [email protected] =N 4N+a-G8a'< <>;
=4; 4=N bc6<
7
>
<
8
3
7
[
O
N
>
<
c
=
;
ƒ
<
E
6
F
N
/
N
?
? R A<[N/;mH>A\E [email protected] bV6<^3546872; 468;mD7FE 38W< <>;
;O>4;FE68=c; <;m3G8E [email protected]=87 =<O[G8<-<Ä68N 4=a-< a'<>; N%=4=-M EH[4G ACr 4E7FH[E <>;/=V?C;4N =G8< S4=-SE 4=¡35<>68;+eKEH>[email protected]<>a'<>=V? ;Q 4=-:8<; k<<>=8>;[email protected] S
68=<>< ; S3868?CN’4M=^H[4G8AC44=87F=E ;/< ?C4# =„G8<>< ; A\]E4H[='4DV68E AC<>7 68G87Ä<9GfA\E°6'H[N 4468a-AC<>a'687Ä<>;G8H[<[4N’=VN ;/47Fa-EH>a'; O <>? ; NÄjBGf=#?!kO4>:87 ;/<>?C<>=c=V; ;{NÄG8G8<<
? l <[N’[email protected]=O>DVE [email protected][email protected]; O[N3k<>68LM<>=V; >;/7 <BN ;/7/?CH>; <[NB]IN/?
a >a'<BAKJ [email protected]=O>DVE [email protected][email protected]; O
/
x
y
x, y
x y
xy
y
G/xy
xy
x
V
V \ {x, y}
xy
x
y
χ(G/xy)
χ(G/xy)
y
G
G
x y
ω(G) ≤ ω(G/xy)
x
G/xy
G
{x, y}
χ(G) ≤ χ(G/xy)
G/xy
G
8 kQ
[<E N/AC4;˜7 68N =2HFW<>[email protected]='E[LM<><[; H’bc6E ;/7 <N 4a-;FE a'=<>Gf; ?CN NBS·bcN ? 6< <>; N 4=V;AC<[N<WVf<>;/;7 O>[email protected]; O[N%G8<’H[<’HFW? <>UMa-< [email protected] =˜= S
X7FE [email protected]<>38AC4; =<>N°;+A\E1UM< 38E 7 =S<>M 68L LM?C<-<>7/H>7 A\< ENFBN/?CW8bV7i6H <SkH R E 7°[email protected]=cA ;B=3847 64N°68LMNF<>O2amAC<:8AC;/<'WbcO[467j<QT>a'AKJ E < 7/DN/[email protected]'LE <>=V=V;+;2G8G4J O[=VHF; W=E =84DM6<N
:8W< VI?CH [email protected]; a^O°E G;/E ?Cbc=6N£<h68=68;/H[[email protected]@4?C=cNFO ; W< 3kVI;4<687^[email protected] N£4DM68O>LM=<>O>7^7FEA\E´A H[=44=6H>N£[email protected]=N/4?C46= N9W< gVfE38'[email protected]?CEbc6G8<><[7 N14=H NÈWE N/=68H[7£<[H[N1<°G3kJ 4>;/[email protected]=V7 <;
#QA\E N <[H>;/?C4= [email protected]> H[4=NFEH>7 O[<QE S6 V13E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=NÈ3E [email protected] <[N ?
x
χ(G) = 2
ω(G) = 2
"
` *p +! ' 252 $* " -6_.#7# `.
y
χ(G/xy) = 3
ω(G/xy) = 3
G - + {x, y} - $ G .0 . - * .3 . G - .0 1 *,-/.0- x
y G G/xy . 1 1 *1 #- * G G/xy *. "- -/ 1 .$.0 G 1 $ .0 G/xy Z [email protected]; 68=<-H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=438;/[email protected]^E AC<'G8< =<-G84=8=E =V;23EN°A\E1a >a'<
H[G84<[68NBACN<>468a-7 a'# <>; N<>; 7 468 DMGf<[?CN+N 4<>=; N{bc6AK< J <>=NF<[<>N/am;:87 AC4<-68DMG8<+<[N <>;N 4a-:8a'AC<><>6 ; N ? :8jBAC<>=„6EN ?5383kA <>J <>[email protected]=< N <>am:8AKJ AC<>< =N <>am:8AC<
[email protected]=6Gf68a [email protected];^>a'GE<„=H N ; OƒG868<1=rA\N E 46:8N [email protected] 7F7/E ;/[email protected];/W?C4<„= :[email protected] 7/;/?KSÄ? <>;'l <>AC<[A\E N'NN/[email protected]=8a'N? \<><ƒ; NbV6<#<>; ; 46N =AC<[< N N H 4W=V<>;^[email protected]=ENN
G38<E [email protected] < GJ E a-?CN£G87< <>[email protected]?\E S8=V4; =„H[4# =H>[email protected];£4=VbV; 6˜J [email protected]<^=˜ACJ 4W< =8VfD?CN/6; <><°68E 7 [email protected]>a-68=3E H [email protected] < <>[email protected]=„7 S 7 <>[email protected]?\E =c; O>;F# E =V; G68E ==<N
?$u 4=H <>; N 4=V;+GE =N+G8<>S6 VhH[4a-354NTE =V; <[N°H[4=8=W< V8<[N Gf?CN ;/[email protected]=H>; <[N G8<
?
5
S
>
<
;
G
E
=
+
N
[
H
>
<
@
A
C
A
Q
<
8
G
<
”
S
4
`
=
5
3
>
<
8
6
+
;
[
O
H
W
E
8
=
M
D
>
<
°
7
C
A
[
<
N
[
H
4
8
6
C
A
>
<
8
6
7
+
N
7
4
8
6
M
D
Q
<
>
<
B
;
8
:
C
A
>
<
6
<
jBl <[= H>?˜4:838;/7 ?C4<>68=cLM;m< E gACE47 N? 68=< M H[4AC47FE ;/?C4=G8< GE =NBA\Ebc6<>[email protected]< <>; N 4=V;+:8AC<>6N ?
L 4687{387 468LM<>7 : [email protected]/62';{G8<ÈLMO>7/?N\<>7
?SL 4687{H[<>A\[email protected]/62';
Z
GG884<2=8;/=7 4E 68=V;ƒLM<>A\7°E¡68a =< >a'<`H[4M 68H[AC4<>AC6847F7 E ;/# ?C4=ª<>G8; < SÄG84=c? ;#AK4J W<[email protected]; Vf?CN/; <>68==H[< <`<[N/;^DVM EH[7F4E AC4=c7F;/E ?C<h;/?C43=ªE 7 G8< gE ?
H[H[jB44=68a-AC4am<>:86868;/7 =?C<>G8<m=V<2;QG8; < E4AC64N 7 <>N°AC; <[egNBEH>? N [email protected]<>a-a'a'<><>=c; ;mN+68<>=;+< <>=`G84=8=H[E4=cAC4;m7FE E ;/6h?C4N =´4a-G8<a'<>;°H[4=c;/<>7F=´EH>H[; 4O2=A\N E#<>7/H[L4E 68=VAC;<>68A\E 7
L 4687#387 468LM<>7 H S [email protected]/6 2';#G8<„LMO>7/N? \<>7Y]
? L 46871H[<>A\EfS [email protected]
Z
?
H>N/[email protected]?C2'bV6;’<mG8=<£<m;/M 7H>H[[email protected]?C68bc=VLM;6<><><'7¢=EG68=cE =;+=< N 3ENÈ? ACZ<[email protected]=N 44a-=˜M H>Sa'[email protected]?CN bc<>46; [email protected]; <ÈH[4G=cE ;/=687FN E=H>< ; [email protected]? A<[N/;BH>MA\H>E [email protected][email protected]?C7+bVN 6bcjN T[6<^G8<G8<£H< 68J <[=N/< ; E 6NFH[N/4?=c68; =<W<MM
=35E4=VN N ;ÈT[ACG8<m<BN 684=Ya-=a'4<>S= ;ÈMKLMH[44?C=VN/;/[email protected]= EH>; OGE =N ?4A <°D7FE 38W< <>;ÈN/? 3k4N jN <[T[N/G8;9< 6868== <=H>[email protected]?CS= bcMK6LM<m4?CG8N/[email protected]< = ? GZ E ? =N
S E <[ACN/4;B7 N H W<>[email protected][email protected]; G8<<>AC;4=8D6LM<>[email protected];7 O 7 H <>E [email protected]?\E =c; <[N/#; 68=]f<„68H>[email protected]<2?CbVH[64<ƒ=V;/G87F< EGf?CH>;/?C4= ? ?$u A 4J 68== H
E 6Y35a'4N4N [email protected]=T[G8N+<+G8:8< ?C<>= <>68; =< [email protected]; <>=c;/U? T>M 7 H><>[email protected]'?CbV<>6=V< ; ?
GE =N S5H[<2bc68?a'4=c;/7 < bV6<
A
x
G
y
x
y
X
X ∪Y
Y
G
x
y
(X, Y )
G[X ∪ Y ]
x
G
x
G[X ∪ Y ]
G[X ∪ Y ]
{x, y}
y
x
x
χ(G)
x
G
G
ω(G) ≥ ω(G/xy)
G
G/xy
K
ω(G/xy)
K \ {xy}
a
K \ {xy}
y
x
b
y
a
K
x y
y
K \ {xy}
G
ω(G/xy)
xy
K \ {xy}
x−b−a−y
x
y
G
y
ω(G/xy)
ω(G/xy)
x
χ(G) ≥ χ(G/xy)
G/xy
A
χ(G)
x
y
χ(G)
G/xy
χ(G)
G
y
y
ω(G/xy)
G/xy
G
b
G/xy
x
k9
xy
x
y
L 4687/;FE =V; AC<+D7FE 38W< <[N/;
?
@
a
3
E
7
K
e
E
@
?
B
;
[
E
M
L
[
<
H
68=<°3E [email protected] <GJ E a-?CN
3E 7 eKE [email protected]; ?
"!$#&% OS?KJ V8<>a-38AC<G8<°H[4=V;/7FEH>;/?C4= GJ 68=<°3E [email protected] <GJ E a-?CN
L 4687387 468LM<>7 G [email protected] 6 2';’G8<97 <>a^E 7 bc6<>7Äbc6<{354687Ä; 468;’N 46N MKD7FE 38W<È[email protected][email protected];
G486 < =˜J E [email protected] A87/<W;/VI?C<>?C=VN/; ;<368E=-N N # 46N MKD7FE 38SMW4<{[email protected][email protected];; <9A\E°G8H[<4=cLM<>LM=VO>;/7/?C?N4\”=ƒE =c=;ÈE ;/] 687 <>[email protected]< N ?
? l 4a-a'<
<[N/;'3E 7 eKE [email protected];^3E 7#H[W<°HIbc35684?;/a'4W T[4N =V<;/S’7 [email protected]<mAÈA\7 E O[N/3k68<>[email protected] ; e <Y<[H>3;/?CE 47 =Y G8: < -<>; H ? bc6<´]
DAC<[7FN°E 38H[RdAW4=c<`egE;/[email protected];+H>3;/=?CE 447 ; =eK<>E N27°[email protected];1G8bV<Q6<>=‘<23E A\[email protected]=r<[H[N4D=V7FG;/E J 7F38E Ea-WH><`;/?C?CN43=´NFE 47 =VGeK;mE J [email protected];E =38<Q 3LM3E 4E7 [email protected]<>[email protected] a-< \a'DG68<>J E 7=Va-< ;2?COS68N+?K= J 3k a^<>? 68El ;B68<[;/LH>7FE ?+E ?C=Na'N 4eg4468=c7/;/;/a'[email protected] A <`<>3k7°bc468668= <7
7 <[H[4A =8=GE FC;/7 <mAC<[N£D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; N ?
7FGE J E;/?Ca-4=¡?C<#N 3k;/W4O[6847°j7 T>AC<[a'SN+H[<ƒD<^7FH>bVE N? M 6838G8?W<[<[38N N°N 7 6O[3HNmE T[73kG8eK<><^E 7/[email protected]';a'N <>?4;-=VZ ;/?G87 <#<^G8bc<[WO6˜N \J; #ƒ[email protected] E 7 687/eKE;/[email protected][email protected];E G[email protected]<>DM;°J 468N/7/[email protected]<^;/W8H[a'43kAC<„447FNN E [email protected];/T[?CG8438<2=AC<#684=G838<<1;/[email protected]^H[4E E [email protected] AC<< M
=H[G84<E a-=c; a'# <„N/S68<>[email protected];;„=´] G8;FA\O[EEƒGf=V68H[;'[email protected];Qbc686˜[email protected]<>a-J 684a'7Q=O[Gf;/Gf6´7 ?\4E 68N ; 4LM<>a-<„a'a'<>G=VE<>; =;mN 68H[=4AC<#=c<^;/DH[7F7FE4E H>AC438; 7FOWE < ;/?C4?=A 684=J 38E <[email protected];/[email protected]^47/E E [email protected][email protected];/7AC<^W8<ƒa'G8G<^< J E ea-4=?CN<>H>S=´;/?C44G8==84=S= A\E< M
H[G84<[=cNQ;/H[7FE4H>=V; ;/<7FE? H>jB;/?C=4=35N <>68N/6;-H[G8H[<[4N =N H„[email protected]<[N/[email protected]<>;Q7 <^H WA\EhEbc;/67FE<^H[N<„4a-G8<1a'; <>4; 68;-G8< N 4a-a'<[N/<>;; 7 <>38G87 O[< N <>=c; O^E 63E H[7Q468687 = N
68==8<^?Cbc3564<+N N NT[4G8a-<-a'3E<>Nm;9GG8E<^=3N{E [email protected]< 7 <^D7FGE J 38E Wa-<+?CN 7 O[S N/68<>;[email protected];FEAKJ =V4; =? jB<>=ª=„G8H[O[4GfAC4687/[email protected]?C;m<[email protected]< a'D7FO[E Gf38?\WE <+; <>7a'O[N/<>[email protected];-;FE 68=V=; <' bcH[684 M?
ACN 447F=#E ;/7 ?C<>438=‘7 O[GfN <>6–=V;FDE 7F=cE ;938WG< E =G8N’< AC<ÈG8DO>37FE E 387/;1W<È<>=–7 O[N [email protected]=8;FE ==VE ; =V? ; jB# =#H 3kW<>E68bc;6E <Y6NNF4N/?”a-G8a'OW\<>=8;'[email protected]{A\EN/68H[7’468AC<ÈAC<>a 687#>a'G8<<
a'GE 4I=<G N T>ACA\< Eh6838=ƒ7 <>E [email protected]<„47/[email protected];/6W8a';/W<°O[G84<Bj7 T>7 a'<[H < W<>G87 <ƒHFWX<°[email protected]<B68H>[email protected];'?Cbc<>6; < Èa^W8GE i7 [email protected]%a2<[68N/a;-bc?6A <ƒJ ?CG8N/O[? <S8bV68?kE <[38N 3;2E 7F68GE =FC<;
3E ACE [email protected] N2<14G=J E a-35<>?C68N-;2G8H < E ACH>68SAC<><>;Q7bc686=<1<'N/H>?Ä[email protected]?Cbc46=<-H[a^4=8GE =VIE [email protected][email protected]; 6868a =<#G8H>< [email protected]?Cbc6<^]˜N/a^? [email protected]=<'68a H[4=V;/?C<>G8=c<;23ENmAC< S
NAKJ468a-= a'G8<><[;'N+G8H[4<>=c6S;/Vh7FE<>H>=; N O <>am:8S AC<[E N AC47 N <[N/;-E 6N N/?{4686 =<ƒH>[email protected]?Cbc6<#a^GE [email protected][email protected]=aº[email protected]; < 68=<Q? H>Z [email protected][email protected]?C=bc46= <
a^GE Vfl [email protected] G8< ?
68G=J E <^a-3?C<[N#E N{[email protected]>E <';[email protected][email protected];'J7/E [email protected];/W8=–?Ca'N238<[G7 N{4E :83k=UA Nm4T>N a'68<>==V<Y;DGfG87F3? <>2^E 6S38H>V'[email protected]< 38< 7 4 jB38:87AU=T>4a':8E„UA <[T>G8N a'O ]Vr< ;#ƒ4OS68LI?KO6´; GS bcJ 6a^E :k<-E 4?CA\7N#EƒGbV7SI<[6H[H <ƒ4Wa-<>AC<>7 a'68HFW7#<><ƒ=VG8;{G8O>;/;<-7 <[43H>68;/E [email protected]<>= <7
B=„D7FE 38W<
G
G/xy
{x, y}
H0
H
G/xy
x
y
V (H 0 )
0
0
H
H
0
χ(H) = χ(H ) = ω(H 0 ) = ω(H)
H = H 0 /xy
H 0 /xy =
G
G/xy
G
{x, y}
G/xy
x
y
2
G
G
xy
G
v
G
G
{a, b}
K
G
G
ab
G
K
(K \ ab) ∪ {a}
K
G
(K \ ab) ∪ {b}
G/ab
8 k!e
38G 7E 4=:8NÈAUT>AC<[a'N <2D7F3kE 438N WO2<[3N+E G87+< AKJ 0{E [email protected]<>DM7/4DM7/<[email protected];/<[W8N/a';È<-7 O <[E N/[email protected];?CNTE<>=:8H[AC<Q47 <>< =`4; 68<>LMa-<>37/;'N ]535H[[email protected]=a'4a-<>=V?\;E A H[?$4A AC4<27/G8?C<><>7°6SVf<12^?UT>a'H EG< M
35H[<><>a'7/a'/ <>=V<>;;/;/687FE=^[email protected];ÈD7FG8E <m38H[W4< AC4G87/<?C<>0{79<>; 7/4DM68<È;9NTDE 7F=E N’383WE <°[email protected] 3<BE G7 eKJ E E [email protected];È?C<>N = ; iÈ<>a-O[NF34N£6Gf3k7 4<È[email protected][=<9438a-7 4?\E :8A AU? T>a'< 468LM<>7/;
<[N/35G8O>< 7 LI<>D7Ä?C7FG8E ; <>384a-amW<[a':kN°<><>eK7{=VE; 3H>S [email protected] AC#B7<[1NA\HFE+W#ƒN/E 68H[[email protected][; AC<<{47/G8N ?C68<£<>7’7 GfS [email protected]=1<>=¡7DN 7F35<[E <>N’3868H[W;4<B=VG8;/;/WO 7/7F\[email protected]=8H>?\[email protected];/E 72?C4A 4A\=#EƒN’H[H>4G8A\ACE<{4N 7/3N ?C<-E <>[email protected] 7G8?S<[<[L N N°4GD68J 7FE 7{E a-;384?CWN·68<[S; N 4< =-H>A\35E; <>N <>68N AC<;N
38DMbVO>6˜68=?CJ <>N O>N=h7F<°E 3AC3< E E 7/=˜7/;FLMJE DE <>=V=8;+r [email protected] 7 G8a^<#-E ?C68N°=h<>G8;D47F=8bVE =638O-<mW<2G83<QE G87È< 7 O[68N/=68? <[email protected];FN E 68;°[email protected]; [email protected]=V<m;/7; G8<2O>7<H[<[4H[NF4NF=8E=c==V;/E 7F; ?CES˜N H>NF<>E;/;°?C=4NH[= <><268G868A%<m=AC< <23E HE [email protected] N°<[38NB74 4I'GH J WE <-a-<[E?CN/N 6;+N4A\N/=E ?
H>A\EN N <°G8<[N9H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[NÈE-O>; O°N O>>&7/J ?C<>6NF<>a'<>=V;BO>;/6Gf?COmGE =N9A\[email protected][email protected];/; O>7FE ;/687 < ? ?
(È[email protected]=N ?M_`E 7 H
0{<>7/; N HFW8?
GE MK; [email protected] 4354NFO AC<[N˜G8WO \[email protected];/?C4=NN/[email protected] =c; <[N B=°D7FE 38W<
D687F=E <[<B38N/3;ÄWE<[[email protected]Ä[email protected] ; <+; <>*,G[email protected] ACJ<+E a-bc6?CN*< $. +N/? ; <[SI<>N/<>[email protected];¢;AC<°68bc=bc66<B<È< H>[email protected]?C4bV6867 <B46^N J [email protected]”W< Vf?CN/;SI<£<>;{68=bcSV6<BAC<B< N/[email protected];E < 38<[WN/< ;{68=<+3kH>[email protected] ?CNjbVT[6G8G8< << ?
A <ÈD7FE 38W< <[N/;{[email protected]; 1 * * $.0N/?”; 468;£N 46iN MKD7FE 38W<[email protected][email protected];£G8<
<[N/;9H[P 4=V;/7FEH>;/[email protected]< ?
G8A O<[r N #È38Lc7/66 ?C<>N/ACa'bcN 6<[N<ÄN [email protected]=V<[a-;N3;/AC7<[E [email protected] 6N¢[email protected] a-<>38683WLM<[E <>[email protected]=c7 ;ÄN =E[4<>;%LM=4AC<[[email protected]’N E G8E7 eg<[=VE N¢;/[email protected][email protected];3;/<>7 E a'[email protected]<><[N =cN¢;'ACG4=8H[J E 4DMa-=VN;/?C=˜7FN EJS4H>a^=V;/;[email protected] AC<[?C3N N-E3kN%[email protected]<=87 [email protected]^; E [email protected] S6 ;¢<[V N H WG4J EjB?NV'a-=G8?CN E< ?
egG8N E O[<[[email protected]£; 6=˜D<>7FJ=<[E H[N/38<;W3G8<[ENÈ< N =H[;/447/[email protected];/7F?\3E EE AKH>SÆ7 ;/egLM?CE [email protected]=˜[email protected]; 7 <>Sa'4e/=„<>e =cE ;B3k7/7/4H[[email protected]=V7 <°;/G87FE <[E6#N%H>;/[email protected]>ACE<[;FN·38E S”[email protected]< 4?=cA ;B<[4bcN=6838?k7/a'<[?CN N/4a';Ä=c68;/<[7N= <°[email protected] eKE=c3H>;/[email protected][email protected];/[email protected]<>77 a'4N%61N <>4=VAC=c4;B;=8bcDG86˜4J [email protected][AC<HN
[email protected]=V3;˜E [email protected] [email protected]=8N [email protected]^=cE;˜S6 AC<[V N˜? N <>=m68AC7 NO[DN/687FE a'38OWS[<[ACN<[N=4;/7 =436EN7 [email protected] [email protected]; E<>a'[email protected] N <>S[=VAC;%<[NH[4E =V=c;/;/[email protected];/E7 H>4;/[email protected]<[[email protected]=8N˜[email protected]<>a^;E AC<[S6 NV°38H[7/4?CN/=8a'=c6<[NN
# H[< r 4687 ?
;/7 7<>4=6YH[0< [email protected]/a-G86<H[3< EA\[email protected]È7 =S5<[4NF<[?NE G–V#=NG8E`<E 38=cP 7 ;/[email protected] ;/3k<>7 =44N46hO :8ACACG<4=8SfJ E =Dƒ3843k<>6;B<>N{ACNT<>38E7 7 =4NÈ3k3847/N ?C4N/=1a' N<m35 [email protected]&37{E ,[email protected] 47 ?;/ 7 l <1.07Fh3E [email protected]/<[=;£N'E G8=cD< 7F;+E ACA\<[38E'N9WH[E<[438N^=35NFH><>E 68AC=<>7 7NM
1 1 $ ? XB46N N/[email protected]=N+<>=Y7 <>LE =H W< H[<>;°E 68; <>687B3k4687°E 3835<>AC<>7
38A7/Eƒ1?CN/H[a'4s=< r? <[XH>;/468; 7 4<^=1N#N/[email protected] <„AC=c<[;N°; <4D68357F;1E <>3868DW;7FE<[NFNQ38<>WamNF<YE :8=ACGN°<>J)7°(B;/7 ;/7/47/; [email protected]>LIa-?\[email protected] a-?CACN#<^3<[EE N [email protected];^74S7 68N°NF=yE bV=6˜DN27FJ <>EE [email protected]=V<-W;/[email protected]<h<[;/N7 ;G46´J)<>(È= AC7/4; eg=8O>E D`[email protected];°?C<>N1<>;m=3NFH[EE [email protected] 7 <N ?
468LM<>7/; <']
C
G
G
C
C
"
G
G
G = G0
{xi , yi }
G
G0 , . . . , G k
Gi
i = 0, . . . , k − 1
Gi+1 = Gi /xi yi
Gk
G
C6
*5")f#0-.:' 2<] 5 f# #f# [email protected]=
G - 1 1 *, * $.0 1, - *. #- .3 G - $ &.0
*, * - 1 $ "* * $.0 t Eh <>A LM<>7 <>;/;°<>;07/6H[<QiÈ<[<[GY4=c;B387 43k4N O268=<2E 68;/7 <QH[4=sr <[H>;/687 <Q3k4687BH EGM
7FEH>; O>7/?CN <>79AC<[N£D7FE 38W<[NÈ3E 7 egE [email protected]; <>a'<>=c;BH[4=V;/7FEH>;/[email protected]<[N ]
*5")f#0-.:' 2 ' 5f# #f# [email protected]=
1 1 *, * $.0 1-/.01 $. 1 - 1 kR
B=<H[4=sr/<[H>;/687 <°[email protected]{eKE [email protected]:8AC<mE
O>DVE AC<>a'<>=V;+O>; O+387 43k4N O[<']
*$" /#0-6G ' 2 $f# ##7!+ @= - 1 1 .0 . 11 1 &*, * $. u <[N¢H EN¢3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 NÄG8<£H[<[N¢H[4=sr/<[H>;/687 <[N’4=c;ÄO>; O£G8O>a'4=c;/7 O[NB]GE =N AC<ÈH EN¢G8<[N
DNFE 7F=E 38NWD<[7/N’?!k<38¢A\E3=E E7 [email protected] 7 <[[email protected]=8N¢W3E E 7 7 <[NA [email protected]<>=8;W_ E 7 E <[57N·FSME&_`H E esk7Q FE <>-H ; <>G;¢E iB=N<[<[ACG<¢H esERNG8S<[GNE D=7FN E AC38<9WH <[EN N¢NFG8E =<[N¢ND;FE 7F68E 387 < WE <[6 N
3N/6E 2^7£G8NTE <°=VX; <[[email protected]%63k<>[email protected] <[7%G8bc486˜S8J _`68= E k7D7FFEE 381H W<><{; GL J)(È47/7/; ; 4 O>a-O/?CE N%3k? Rd47 N <>Nj=[T EQG8<Äi9686=N/<6 3#QE [email protected] 4<=8G=J EO°a-G8?C<[N N£H[>&4[/=J Gf? [email protected];/_ ?C4E =?CNN
AC3<QE 73EA N [email protected]=8NW<>E AC74<[= NÈ=<>;È46_ N°E G857O[FH>E&?CN/1H ? e/bcS568LM?˜<>74N+=V;BA\E138387 47 68<>68LMLMO°<-AC<+G8;/<QWA\O[E#47jH[>T 4a'=s/r <m<[H>N ;/[email protected] <E =cOS;[email protected]>)] k E1O>; OQe 7FE =HFW8?
` !*p +! ' 2 1 "6`6;<% # ; oG; ' $ G - 1 *,1 .0 G - $, X 46N'G8O>a'4=c;/7 <>7 4=N'A\E H[4=s/r <[H>;/687 < [email protected]>)k E 6–H WE [email protected];/7 < QS? X 4; 4=N'bc6<ƒ=46N
38a'7 <>4=c68;+LM<>Gf7 6`4=;/N-WO[34E 7j7Q>T a'A #G<2KM a e 4>7/a';+<ƒG8<[A\NBEYD357F<>E 7 38egW<[H><[;/NB?C43=E 7 G8eKE <[[email protected]; N D? 7FBX E 384W;/7<[<2N-38G7 J)<>(B687/LM; <QO>a-7 <[?CNN N [email protected]<>=a2G8:8O>AC3k< <>=##GH[E <>a [email protected]< M
GfiB6Y46H N EN NB<>A%NFE <>=;+N9iÈH 68E :87/7 ?C4+OS ) # AKLMJ <W4fV [email protected][7°<>H38W;/[email protected];/7=< 4;Fk4E ? :8 AC<[email protected]< <°G8AK4J 6=8=NFE <>DM7F<2E1G68J=68= E [email protected]<>4a-7/[email protected]';/W8<°a'eK<-E a'G8<>< 6SH[V 4ACG 47FEG# M
[email protected]>)k 3E DM< E ?
;/A ?CE^4=-H[4G8=s<[r N%<[DH>7F;/68E 387 <2W<[A\NE-G38J)[email protected](B6NÈ7/; egO>4a-7/; ?C<N G87 <[<N/H[; 4<a-bc386ACE <W=VVf; [email protected]; #'O O(mn
) gE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<
?
>
<
@
A
C
A
2
<
4
8
6
M
L
>
<
/
7
;
<
(B6YHFWE [email protected];/7 < SH[4=NFEGM
H>H[74O-=8=E E 6S?ChV N NT38E =7 4H[:8<^AU>T G8a'<[N<[NmD7FG8E <238W7 <[<[H[N24G=8=J)(ÈE 7/?CNF; NFO>Ea-=?CH[N <SgE [email protected]/N°[email protected];/G8W84a'=8=< <>S7 4?KJ=k N°368E =DM< E [email protected]>&DMO/4O7/[email protected];/W8H[4a'a-<-38G8AC<W<QfV [email protected];<WO M
O(n ) Sf<>;{68=ƒE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<°G8<B7 <[H[4=8=E ?CN NFE =H[<°G8<[ND7FE 38W<[N£GJ)(B7/; O>a-?CN{3E [email protected] N gE ANM
?
D7/[email protected];/7/[email protected]';/W8<+a'<>< =^S; <>?KJ/a-Q 33NE 3kDM4< [email protected] >&=O4k a-S’?\H[E 4Aa-G8384=8AC<W=VfE [email protected];=cO ;O(n
) X 46N^<>=rG8O[[email protected] 4=N168= E [email protected]
68=< H[4AC47FE ;/?C4= ,* $1 !
$.0 G8<[NQD7FE 38W<[N'GJ)(È7/; O>a-?CN 3E [email protected] N gE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'< S?KJ 3E DM< >&O/Q S H[4a-38AC<WfV [email protected]; O
? Z ?+AC<[NƒH[4=sr <[H>;/687 <[N„G8< iB<[<[G‘<>; LM<>7 <>;/; H[4=s/r <[H>;/687 <[N [email protected]>&O <>; [email protected]>&J O(n ) N 4=c ;+Lc.7FE ?C<[G8N <[SkNÈE DAC47F7 E N [email protected]<[NFNÈ<>G7FE^J)([email protected]/; O>a'a-O[?CGfN£?\E 3;°E [email protected] 6? <2H[<>;E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<-G84=8=<Q68=<QH[4AC47FE ;/?C4=
eK38E 7 [email protected]<>; 68<>X a'LM4<°<>6=VG8N£;£< E H[A\[email protected]=V=H[;/4N{7F=sEa^/r H><[;/E H>[email protected][email protected];/=V<[68N; 7 <>? < =* [email protected]>);9N{k 3H[<[E<[N NN’;{N D<>G87{7F4E =<>38=ƒH+W68<[7 <>N{=Lc<N 64E<[email protected];;bc<>6G87/<><[=ACNÄEbV;/[email protected]<[LME N{<+38H>3kWA\<[4EN{68N N 7{G<[N{38J)(È7 G847/<B; 68O>DLMa-7F<>E79?CN{38ACW<><>68;<[N{7{=334;/EE 7 77 < MM
eKHFE [email protected]; bV<-6H[<24=V35;/47FNFEN/H>[email protected];/:[email protected]@[email protected][email protected][email protected]@; [email protected] ; O2?6A H[4E=\ H[D<>7/68=7 E< =cOS;+?KJ AKJ E 338E 3DME < 7/;k<>E =EG8=4H[=8<'=<-E 6S68YV =¡H><WA\fVEN<>Na-<[N38ACN/<'[email protected]<QE =cD; 7F<[E N 38W] <-0{<>3k7/4DM68<7 S
eKbcE [email protected]:8EN/AC<>?NKM a'3E<>=V7/[email protected];B; O£;/7/N/?\;/E 7/=8?CH>D; 68<ACSO[bcNÈ6<>E;9N/?N3KM E37 E eK7/E [email protected][email protected]; ; O<>Sa'3<>E =V7 eK; E [email protected]; 7 <>G8a'4=8<>=V=;’E :8H[4AC<[=cN ;/? 7FEH>;/[email protected]<S9(B7/; O>a-?CN S_h<)IH =8?C<>AKS
"
"
2
9
20
23
'/ $" #
G8E 6s<r/AC44t 68=8<>7 D=8G67/J WV<>? 6868_`7’?£)<E N HI64=8=a'?C<>=4A [email protected]=a N G8? QOWRd\3kA=84EY?N A\NjG8E'T[O>G8a'H><>A\=cE4N;¢=VN ;/E <7 6QOƒG8a'<[bVNÈ[email protected]<#=7FN EH[<[38G8NmW<>6S<[DNÈV7FE G8H[3844W=V7 <[G8;BN <[; N N4? 46l =cN9;2<[ACN<[3NBDE 7F7H)E eKHI38E H>[email protected]; <[<[N NÈN [email protected]/a-Q47/3?6; E <>u [email protected]=c7 <;N
8 kE
& ' $%
"!#
XL8?? j *C? ?
P ? L8?
P ? L8? Z ?
l
?
]Å
X
E
@
?
8
:
C
A
>
<
'
a
>
<
c
=
È
;
/
;
/
7
\
?
E
8
=
D
8
6
C
A
O
L
]] P E 67 EegN/E N? [email protected]; 3<>Ea'7/[email protected]<>; =cO ; ? 47 G84=8=E :8AC< ?
P 6EN/N? MK3E 7/[email protected]; OmN/;/7/?CH>; < ?
]
L8? ? ] L E 7 egE [email protected]; <>a'<>=c; H[4=c;/7FEH>;/[email protected]< ?
"!$#&% OS?KO iÈ<>A\E ;/?C4=N¡GJ [email protected]=c; <>7 N <[H>;/?C4=Nª<>; GJ [email protected]=H>[email protected] ?C4=N¡354687¡[email protected];H>A\EN N <[N¡G8<
D7FE 38W<[N93E 7 eKE [email protected]; N
Q/[
OS? k B=YD7FE 38W<mG8<2_h<)HI=8?C<>A=<2H[4=V; <>=E =c;°E 6H>68=<23E [email protected] <mGJ E a-?CN G84=V; A\E
H[4=c;/7FEH>;/?C4h= 7 <[G84=8=<°68=YD7FE 38W<G8<_`<)Hc=8?C<>A ?
a^E 6E =8a ?UT>>7 a'<È<ƒ[email protected]=7 G8O[O>N/3568<>[email protected];F=E G; E ? =c_`; <<)S cH Z =8? ?C <>A9? _`E`E a'7 M44=cN/;/?\7 E O„=#bV<>6;’<ƒR ? (N <[?N DE 7F7FE E 383kW<><[;/N-?\E N = 4=cR;'k G8<[N N4=cD;¢7F3E 38E W7/LM<[<>N'=VG86<N
bcN/6867BEN/68?NKM= 33kE 7/<>[email protected];/; [email protected]+;ÈN/AC;/<>7/a-?CH>a'; < < R = 463N9E 7AC<68LM=<>< 7/7 3847 =<>N+68LME <°6hEHFN WN E<)[email protected]/;/[email protected] a-<238N AC68<[email protected]<>E ;9=cE;2N/;/]6AC<>H>a-?C<>6a'N <<+k4bc68?KQ ?”£7 bc<>3k6˜4J 4N = <
3k<>;Q<>68i9; 68LM:[email protected] 7ÄE AC6s<>/r a-468a'7 G< J [email protected]> ?CH[4X a-4;/a'7 <'<£6838='7 <>H68ELMN¢<13G8E <'7/;/A\?CEYH>68H[[email protected]?C4<>=s7’r <[GfH>6-;/68eKE7 <a'<>[email protected]>)QV k AC<> a-HFWa'E 38<£[email protected];/G87 <£< iBQ 4°6a'N N <><>; A
38<>_h= 7 ?C<>H +68WLM68<><QA Lc07G8<Q<268G87/_`AC<[<>N <);ÄIH ?C<>G8=8;ÄO[?C<>UV<[A <N+EN G8<>=#O7FrE#X#^4E [email protected] 687O[38NBN <>; 7F=VE ; >&38<[Q 3kN+<>G4ACO[=cE <2=;ÄN 35G844AC<Q=868=7BH [email protected]@N [email protected]=^N/<[;/;/NB7 W<>DO[7B7F4EAC7j<m38>T a'W38<[7 < N°4G835G8<94<QN G8_hO[ NH[<)<[4IH H>a-=8;/?C?C354<>4= A N ) [email protected];/??Ck 4A\= E ?
G8l <[W NÈ@=8DW 7FE tB38W43#<[NÈ=8D G8<S_`> <)EmcH =8G8?CO><>a'A bV4=V68;/?7 3kO+<>bc7/6˜a'J 68<>;È=#G8D<°7FE AC38<[NÈW<7 <[<[H[N/4;Ä=8G8=<BEGCF _h;/7 <)<mHI<>=8= ?C<>; A”<>N a-?”3<>;{NÈN 35<>[email protected] <>=a'4<>a-=V;{?\E N/A ??
[email protected][email protected]˜=Gf<[N/68;{[email protected]; eg47/; <>G8a'< <>=V;ÈS3H WE 7EegbcE [email protected]; <'S8HN 4J <[a-N/; a'M #G<>M ;[email protected] <m< N/?˜<>E;938N 3<>E687/AC<>;/?Ca'<>=V<>;=V;B#1N/68?=´354N/68;F7£E :8; AC4<-68;9bc68NF?467 <>N KM=DH[7F4E =V38;/W7 <<
; 468; <[NÈHAC<[N9H>[email protected]?CbVG6<[N9a^EGIV [email protected]^E AC<[NBG8< H ? H
t <>7/;ih Q/E EG8O>a'4=c;/7 Oªbc6<AC<[NYD7FE 38W<[N G8<´_`<)cH =8?C<>AmNF4=V;`3E 7 egE [email protected]; <>a'<>=c; ?
H[4=c;/7FEH>;/[email protected]<[N¢<>; <>=-EBG8O[[email protected];%68='E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<£G8<H[4AC47FE ;/?C4='G8<H[4a-38AC<WfV [email protected]; O 6<GE =N
B=<Gf?32^H>[email protected]; O2a'O>7/[email protected]; <mGJ >;/7 <a'<>=c;/?C4=8=O[<#] 0<>7/; NFH W8? >/> E 7 <>a^E 7 bc6OmbcO(nm)
68;/?C=24=^D7FG8E 438=8W=<Ä<9G868<Ä='_hD<)7FIHE =838?CW<><ÈAKS [email protected]<£=˜_`J <W<)fV Hc?CN/=8; ?C<’<>A 3ELMN4; [email protected] 6s\/r D468687 7 < N OSG8?<’k 368E =^[email protected] <W<’V8G<>J a-E a-38AC?C<9NG8G 4=V# ;ZA\E9E H[7 M44=cNF;/N/7F?\EE HW= M
a'G8< <>=c_`;/?C<)4cH =8=8=?CO<>AKGS5E AC<[=N N D9k 7FE 38 W? <[t N°<>7/G8;i< h bVEÈ6G8E4N/=?NM H’_`G8<)OWIH \ =8=8?C?V<>68A = LM<Ä4H>[email protected]\7 EN N 9k < [email protected] 6S5N<>;°A\E E#7/DMa'<Äbc46=c<;/7 ACO-<[NbVD67F<2E 38; 4W68<[N;
D687F=`E 38DW7FE <938G8W<£<2bcG86<2EN/bV?N6M _`EN <)?NMcH _h=8?C<)<>IH A”=8H[?C4<>=VA ?;/?Cl <>=V<>;Ä[email protected][email protected]=68E#=<{G83<2E [email protected] [email protected]<9D6G<>J [email protected] 7 a-<[G8?CN¢41G8<>4; =c+;¢7/A\E°?CN ;/H[[email protected]==VE ;/7FE6H>;/?CM44·=1Lc?G8 4=8k=[ <
4iB=c4;6G8N N4<>=8A¢=<>OÈ;68Rd=17 <>[email protected]„DM4i97/[email protected];/W8N/6 a'< >&[/bV[68?”47 <[=cH[;m4=8G8=4=8E [email protected]=;ÄO-AC<[68N’=D7FE E [email protected]/<[[email protected]Ä;/W8G8a'<B<#bV6G8E<-N/?NH[M 4_`a-<)38HIAC=8<W?CIV <>[email protected] ; ? O XAC47/?\E =
3k<>;1468X87-7 O[H[G84O>AC7/4?C7/Hh?C<>_7QACE <[k7NQFDE H7FE 38eGWk <[N-4G8=c<ƒ;1_`N [email protected]<)cH [email protected]?C?N<>\ A Oh6? * <>;'4683k; <>77 egO[<[H[H><>;/a-?C4a'=8=<>Oh=c; H[S<>0{;ƒ<>E [email protected]/r DME 4a-7/[email protected][email protected];/= W8a'A <hO>O(n
L3k[bc4668<)7
3E 7/LM<>[email protected] #Q68=hE [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<m<>=„; <>a-3NÈ[email protected][email protected]=O E [email protected] < ?
&!$#"%
"
"
"
"
"
"
2
8 QS>
'/! #% +&,& ' + *# ’E
<
l WVL/g ;FE A <>;BiYHVE = t+E H E 7 G Q/R 4=c;°G8OW\=8? A\E^=4;/?C4=`G8<2D7FE 38W<megE ?NM
:8H[4AC<>=Va';/?C<><>=V=V;£; ;/=87/??\E ;/=87 4D6h68ACACO 4? =8BD =# HDJ 7F<[E N/38; M W#G<°M Gf<[[email protected] 7 ; <QG8<1AC. 41=8 D 6<> 687+ E 6Ya'-/4. [email protected]=N/N ?Q<>;£N=8<>?68E AC<>=ca';/[email protected];/<>7 =V4;96hN ACJ [email protected]=8=D < ?
t E&H {E 7 G'EBG84=8=O{68=-;/WO[47jT>a'<ÈG8<G8O[H[[email protected]>&Q 3k4N/[email protected];/?C4=-3k4687 AC<[N%D7FE 38W<[N%eKE [email protected]:8AC<>a'<>=V;
;/7/?\E =8D68ACO[NÈbc68?KS#-H E 6N <°Gf6 ;/WO[47jT>a'< S<>=V;/7FEGFC=<mAC<>687£35<>7 eg<[H>;/?C4=´]
` *p +! ' 2 ; ;<+ U 1
1 1. 1 -/. & 1- . 1 -/ - - $ ! - H G G - H - *. #- H . * . $ - *, - .0 H - . 1 *-/.3 l W @=8W tB43# =8D'<>;£X87 O[G8O>7/?CHm_`E k7FE H /Q 4=V;£a'4=c;/7 ObV6<+AC<[N{D7FE 38W<[N£egE [email protected]:8AC<WM
a'AC<„<>;/=VW;9O[;/47/7j?\T>E a'=8D<h68G8ACO[<YN G8N 4O[=VH[4;Ba-G835<[N94N/[email protected];/E?C438= W<[H>NÈ?NM G8G8<m<[N bVN/66EN N/? ?NMKL 3E E 717/[email protected]\; E¡O2N/N/;/687/[email protected]?C; H><; So< ?4t A E&<>H 68{7ÈE 387 G7 <>S 68t LM<43# 68=8;/[email protected]@?CN<><;
_;/`?C4E =1k7F]E 4H¡= [email protected];%;2bc3867 < 468LMO'68=<[N/;/;W68O[4=7j< T>a'0<^38$,[email protected]£N°G8eg< 47/; SN/?c=; O[4H[68<[;N N/[email protected];FE <>=ca-;[email protected]=-68=7 <><'[email protected]?\=E 4=V68; LM<>[email protected]# AC<^G8<[OWN/\;=8G8?N< M
AegC4E=8H>[email protected]<[6N<>68#'7 G8JSO>?<; <[A H><[; N <>72J MK] 3E [email protected] <[NB4<[=VN/;9;£AK68J E =L< E =cJ ;FMKE3DME <[email protected] <23E G79J 687F=E 38D3k7F4E 7/38;ÈWE < S6 V13N/?˜E [email protected]<>7 ;È<[NBN <>G68J ACE <>a-a'?C<>N9=cG;BJ >N/;/? 7 <
?
<>(È; 7/? EN 4;/?=V<>;; GL E =E =N’GfG861<>S6 i V^E H[=84DVa-E = 3k4J NFE =V4;=V<[;ÄN{G8H[44=8=8==O9W< V868<[=#NÄE [email protected]?CDMN/4;/7/[email protected][email protected];/H>W8; a'<[N<BG8G8< <9H[4a-38ACW< [email protected]; O
S
J
b¢4V68?5?CH>38?˜7 AC<><+=;/GƒW<>O[=ƒ4j7 <>T>=ca';/<m7 O[G8<+C< 68t+=#E DH 7FE 38E W7 G <°<>;{ bc.68?k˜<>] =17 <>; 4687/=<+68=< MK3E [email protected] <+N J [email protected] H^<>=ƒE268=< ?
{x, y}
G
x
{x, y}
y
G
y
x
G[V \ N (x) ∩ N (y)]
O(nm)
` *p +! ' 2 ' ; ;<+ * 4" 7 ; ; U 1
1. 1 -/. 1-/.0 -/ - $ !- G G - *. #- - 0 , l <;/WO[47jT>a'< E-3k4687BH[4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[email protected]'O[Gf?\E ; <mA\E'3E 7 egE [email protected]; <QH[4=V;/7FEH>;/[email protected]@[email protected]; O G8<[N
DegE [email protected] :838AC<>Wa'<[N˜<>eK=cE ;[email protected]:8;/AC7/<>?\a'E =8<>D=V68;%AC;/O'7/?\7 E <[=8G8D468=8AC=O[<^N%H 68E =7A\DEÈ7FEH[438=VW;/<-7FEeKH>E ;/[email protected]:8?C4AC=-<>a'G<>J 68=V=;2< ;/7/J ?\MKE 3=8E [email protected]<ACO G? E l =NJ <[68N ;2=mED67FE N 38N/? W#<
=7 <[4H[;/47 =8<m=H[GE 4FC=8;/7=<¢E 68?CN =NF<¢E =H>H[A\E<2N NFAC<Q< G8N <>< 68DA7F;/E W38O[W4<[7jN˜T>a'3E <Q7 eKG8E <[email protected]; N;cHc? 3k<=2< 3k<E >[email protected]; 7 S <QZ G[email protected]=8a-7FE?CG2Nmb<>;c68Z ?7/[email protected];/W<>7/E a'7FE <>= ;/; <2>&[/G8Q <
4<>=h=V;¢7 7<><>[email protected]?\a^E =cE ; 7 bcAC6<[N+OÈG8bc<>66S<£VhN/?NF684a-='a'D7F<>E ; 38N WG8< <2A\E^3534NFE jN [email protected][7 <2G8<£<[N/68;B=eK< E [email protected]:8MK3AC<>E a'[email protected] <><=VSV;+E AC;/47/7 ?\N’E =8AC<£D68DAC7FO-E 38N/?W<È<>;+4:8N <>; 68<>=cAC<W6 M
a';/7/?\<>E =V=8;mDN/68? ACOSÆ[email protected]<[N/N 6;+2'egE ;%[email protected]:8G8AC4<>=a'HÄ<>G=cJ;Hm;/7 7/<[?\HE W=8<>D7 68H ACWO <>?.7 L 684=68< 7J 7 MK<[3H[E [email protected]=87 <=SGE <>FC;;/7 AC<'<H68E=´NDO[7FH WE 38O EW=V< ;¢egGE [email protected] :8<>= AC<>7a'<>[email protected]<>?C=c<>;7
ACLM<[<>N 79G868<>=6S<mV`H>[email protected]?C4bca-6a'< ? <>Z ; ?N S5#-386868=?CN+<mG8O><2;FE 7 3k<[<°H[[email protected]˜a-=˜a'J H <>=E H[<>37EN N 68G87B< ACJ<QMK3D7FE E [email protected]<WS< HJ4<[:8N/;; <>bV=V66 <r AC6<°N bcD6˜7FE J #'38W;/<m7 4G86S< M
G8O>E 37 EG7/S ;£Z =˜[email protected]>=8;F7FE [email protected]#;£3<>;EN{Z 7/[email protected];/[email protected]:8EAC<>7Fa'E = <>=cQf;£e ;/7/4?\E =c=8;’D38687 AC4O 3k? 4 N =„O{3k68=#<>7 eE <[[email protected]>DM;/4?C7/[email protected]=8;/W8=a'E =c<È;ÈG8H[<9<+7 38<[7/H[[email protected]==8H>[email protected] <?CN <S NFt E =&E H[H< M
GbV86˜<BJ H[[email protected]¢4a-W< Vf38?CN/ACW<; Vf<[email protected];68O =E [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'<-bc3k684?5687 7°<>357 4<[N H[< 4=8N/68=7{GE FCAK;/J 7 W< <'Vf?CACN/<[; N°<>=DH[7F<+E 38G8W< <[JN°MK3egE E [email protected][email protected]:87 AC<[<>N a'? Rd<>A”=ceg;mE 68;/7/;{?\E ==84D; S6<>7M
ACO[N Sa'[email protected]=N 35<>7 eg47/a^E =V; G8<„H[4a-38AC<[email protected]; O Sa^E ?CN-7 <>354NTE =V;-N/687-G8<[N ?CG8O[<[N
G
G
O(n + m2 )
O(n5 )
Q/J
=N/68E 7 gLMAC<[<[N„NQ] 38=7 44:86AUNQT>a'7FE <[38N'35G8<><[email protected]<>7 7 <[4H[=4N-=8=H[<>E ;'?CN NFE E [email protected]=4H[7/<[email protected];/W8NFa'46< N M #YN <[;/H>[email protected];/;/?C7 4<1= GSJ [email protected][email protected]@>/[email protected][email protected]> N ;/? 7FE A ;/<1?C4a'=y<>E [email protected]ª[email protected]<>HF68W7^E [email protected][email protected];/74< M
7/H[[email protected];/a-W8a'38AC< W< Vf#[email protected]; H[O o< r 46873k4687A\EQ t+H[4E ACH 47FEE ;/7 ?CG4S =YZ G838<[[email protected]=8N7FDE7FGYE 38<>W; <[Z N{7/[email protected];/E [email protected]:8E AC7F<>E a'= <>=VQf;£e ;/ 7/??\E =8D68ACO[NBEm3k4687
G8iÈ468=8:8¢=?C4<>=´7°=68AC<>4=a-6< N°a'LM7 <>< <[7 N/N/k4;/[email protected]><>= [email protected]? 38=l [email protected] 6<[=cN H>; ?{egE4=S67/4; V¡6< NQD 7FAC35<>E <>a-387/Wa'a'<[<><N;/;/egk4E7F? [email protected] :8BACG8<>Gf<1a'6 N/<>3keg=cE O[;2a'H>;/?\<>E7/S6 ?\[email protected]?CV`N =8<>DAC7 <>68a-=ACO[4a'N ;/S7<-<#=G8438<Q67 N°<>iB683k4LM46<ƒ68N N 7/G8<>7 <1A4=<>A\E N;
H=[44=s68r/LM<[<>H>[email protected];/AC68<27 38< 7 OS<>[email protected]>)LMk <2E Gf6#6`H ;/EWNO[G84<[j7 NÄT>a'D7F<QE 38GWJ W< <[VIN¢?CN/eK;E <>[email protected]:8=ACH[<><Qa'G<>J =V68;{=;/< 7/?\J E MK=83DE [email protected] AC<O[N SI;/H[W<ÈO[4bcj7 68T>?”a'G8< [email protected]>0<>e 7FEmS”68bc=68< ?
N <>7FEQ387 O[NF<>=V; O[<mNF<[H>;/?C4= QS? k4?
O(n + m2 )
'/ ' %& &.) ' )+ !#%
’E
F<
l WVL/g ;FE A J/O EG8OW\=8?BAC<[N^D7FE 38W<[N^3E 7 eKE [email protected]; <>a'<>=V;ƒ47 G84=8=E :8AC<[Nƒ<>;1E
G8G8O>4a'=8=4O2=c;/687 =YOBbcD6˜7FE J [email protected]¢W<QN 4bV=c6;¢<>3ACH[E 47 =egE [email protected]; N < [email protected]<>7 ;È68k=`<>3k=4N 68<>7¢am68:8=AC<Q<9NiG8HI<m=VH[;/4W468T[NFAC<><968N/7 68N 7 AC<9N/6sr/<>; ?S/ [email protected];FE <[=cN/;;
3k68=¡4N 4N/[email protected] :8GfAC7<< G8N/<Ä68H[7+4ACAC<[4N°7/?C<>N 47%a-AC<Äa'D7F<>E; N38S5W38<{68G8?C<ÄN+a^<>=¡E =8H[?U4T>AC7 4<7/?\DE AC=V4;68; AC4<[N+=8=N <4a-SHa'J <[N/<>;; N°#BGGfE [email protected]=<ÄN°<>H[=-<>;°G8OW4\7 =8Gf?C7 N <NFSE <>=c= ;
G688E <=^<'[NF4H><[7 ;FN+GfE 7=VLM<È; 4N/?C#BN/[email protected] 7=WNACE<[bcN¢G86O N r <4#ƒa-NF4H[a'a-4AC<>4a'; 7/NÄ?C<>O[;bVN 68A\? EÈ?L [email protected]=87mN=35<È=˜<>J E [email protected];/[email protected][email protected]=; 3k<N ?4H[687/4; =68<'<£AC<>bVH[68647<>AC4GfA 7F?CDNE 357F;/E?C4438=8=#[email protected]:8<4ACS38<{[email protected];/A¢<>[email protected]^=QW< VIE; ?C<>ACN <=; ScE<-<>=V;’G; JH H[E E [email protected]@a-H>AC<>683868AC;<>7 <N7
H[bc<>68;{?KSk477 <[GfN/7 ;/<È7 <><[[email protected]/=V;1; G8#14==˜mH J [email protected] L3kM4Gf7/;3? 2^<-H>[email protected]< <>? A¢_ N 4E 6?CN’N MKW<DVf7FE?CN/38; WW< MK< ; [email protected][email protected]=A”[email protected]; 47 Gf7 S5<BG8N 468=87’=AC< <[N68N=4<-a-H[a'4AC<>4;Ä7FE G8;/< ?C4=
438;/[email protected]^ E1AC< G8 < & Z ?; <>A%.0<[ N/? ;ÈAC<2H EN [email protected];+bV6<mAKJ 47 Gf7 <2<[N/; $9<>; bV6< <[N/;
4G87<[G8NÈ4RdDAV=87F=˜=E JE38W< :8WVfAC<[?C<'N/NÈ; ]f<’3_hE37 E?CeKG8NE [email protected]; <><¢<>=a'a'G84<>04 =V7 HMe;+<><>=Q4; 7 N G8L [email protected]=8<>38?!=k<AC<¢E >:83k7 AC4<[Rf68NBe 7 <[G8N 4;9O[=cH>68;9?CG8= G8<>O>387%a'7 N/4?M4:868=VUA =m;/T>7a'DO7F< bcE 386X W<ÈL <A\M E2Gf<[N/3? 7 2^; <[H[3H>[email protected]=87 < eg=? E E [email protected];?CN =<>NTa'E eK=E<>[email protected]=cH[; <; S
t 34 # =8D /J E#a'4=V;/7 O'bc6< H[< 387 4:8UA T>a'<-7 <[? N/; l < X L M Gf3? 2^H>[email protected] <Sa >a'<'J/N/O? 4= AC< 7 <[N M
;/687 =ƒ<>[email protected]'=c;2&4 HME <>6S= VhG8D<+7FE H[38<>W7/;/<[N? N+\<>eK7£E [email protected]:86˜AC<>J a'68=1<>=VD;°7FE ;/387/?\WE <°=8D<[68N ;ÄACO[3N E 7 eKE <>[email protected]; <><>a'=G<>E=V=c;9; 4S 7 G84WV=8L/=g ;FE E :8A AC<']c68=ƒE#D;/7F7 E43868WLM<O
E687= ><[; N <[;£NB3G8E < 7 egE [email protected]; G8<><°a'a^<>=cE ;B=8SÄ?U4NT>7 47 G8<m64N E=8MKH)D=Hf7FE EH>:[email protected]?CACWbV<6<„N/<?˜[email protected]=<><>;9Gf;968NFNT<>[email protected] ;'68=ACN9G8<><a'4:<>N/=V;/S¢;B7/6E[N·LMH>J [email protected]<[;/A˜?CH„4<[=˜N/AK;£J S8E 35687 >=4; NF< < N/[email protected] :8AC1<° 41G7/-J?C4* <>7/=c?C;<>O[=V¡<Y; <>O>G87B;F<E AC=c<[;N
LMG<>J E 7 [email protected] DM47/<>[email protected];{;/W8AKa'J E 7<ƒ>; <>< =´; <>a-47/3?C<>N2=V3k; O[4<°[email protected]=< 4a-?\LME <>AÄ7 N 35468? 7Ql < G8O[H>H>7/[email protected]; T><>7 7Q<+bc=6˜<+J 68G8=´4=8D=7F<+E 38O>WLI<#?CG8<[<>N/a-;ma'3<>E =V7 eK;9E [email protected]; E<WNM
a'H[4<>=c=cL;ÈE [email protected]=7 H>G87 4<{=87F=E E 38:8?CG8AC<<>Sa'a^<>=cE ?C; N£3GE E 7 =68N9=G8<<+N/[email protected]; a2<:8G87<¢<>egS6 4V ,7 ( HE EDMN£<[N 3? E l 7/;/J <[?CH>N/68; [email protected]?C<<>7 H N [email protected]353k468<>7/7a'AC<[<>N ;9DG87FE<°38N WJ <><[= N
=47/4?C=S<>MK=c3;FEE 7;/eK?C4E ='[email protected]; <>NFa'E =<>N =V;m4:4N 7 ;/G87/46=8H>;/=?CE4:8= AC<[ a^NmG8E ?C<mN A\E E7LM<[\HÄD683k7<>< 68; OSM ?K>JS;/?7 <{Z ?G8<[68N =`)H HfD7FH>EAC<[38N%W4< 7/?C<>=V;3kO[4N N NjT[E G8AC4<m7 N%684== <
G7/[email protected][email protected];/;ÈW8bca'6˜<9J [email protected]˜<£<[N/G8&; O>; <[H>;/?C4=#1G8 <[ N 3"E [email protected] <[ N¢G J E 1a-.0 ?C?N¢(BGE7/?=N E ;/AC<[?˜N%<>D; 7FL E <>38ACW<[<[G N’3> E 7 4eg=VE ;È[email protected]; <>G8a'4=8<>==cO;’4687/=h?C<>[email protected]; DMO[4 N M ?
`
_
)< HI=8?C<>A R E1G8O>a'4=V;/7 O^bV6<2AC<[? N+D7FE 38W<[N+3E 7 egE [email protected]; <>a'<>/=c[ ;m47 G84=8=E :8AC<[NN 4=c;
G8<[NÈD7FE 38W<[NÈG8<bc6EN/N? MK3E 7/[email protected]; ON/;/7/?CH>; < tB<>7/i; hm<>;BG8< <>7/7FE 4=YG8O>a'4=c;/7 O2bc6<
"
{1, 2, . . .}
G
G
H
H
G
"
G
G
P4 a − b − c − d
b
cd
G
d
ab
c
G
"
a
8 Q/O
l A\ENFN <
P0{+<>7F7/E DM38< W<[NÈbc6<>ACH[4=bV6<[N OO/kO >&>)kQR > [E/k/[k >&JBRBOR/k9Rfe Jf>&OeGk es/QR >&JBOB[/J[//QE J> /kR
P 6EN ?NMK3E 7/[email protected]; O
O/O >)kR E/[ RBR/R >&O esO/Q OBJ/R /[/[
P 6EN N? MK3E 7/[email protected]; OmN/;/7/?CH>; <
O/O >)k!e R/E R1/Rk >&OS> O/O OB[ Q/[k
L E 7 eKE [email protected]; <>a'<>=V;°H[4=V;/7FEH>;/[email protected]< O/O >)k!e R/E R1/R/O >&OS> O/O/O OB[/Q>/>&R
L E 7 eKE [email protected]; <>a'<>=V;°47 G84=8=E :8AC< O/O >)k!e R/E R1/R/J >&OS> J/E/E OB[/J esQ/Q
X”_`E )< [email protected]:8HIAC=8<>?Ca'<>A <>=V; ;/7/?\E =8D68ACO O/O/OJ >)>&k9O/[ R//RJ/J RCOBkR/R/O/OE >&JJ/R [/SJ/>)kE JBRJ/Q/R Rf/e [
% [email protected]> u O>=4a2:87 <>a'<>=V; NQ354687°H[<>7/;FE [email protected]=<[NH>A\ENFN <[N°G8< D7FE 38W<[N ?,u E =N°; 468; <[N
ACN <[4N¢a-H>a'A\E<>N ;N N<[SN k G84D=c7F;¢E [email protected]<[<[N/N ;¢#Qbc6;/7<[4N/?C;/N9?C4N =˜[email protected]<a'H-<>E; NÈ> <>D; 7F>/E 38> WD<7FE # 3868W='<[NN 4# a-bca'6E <>;/; 7 S <J N D47Fa-E 38a'W<><[; N N ? #+G8<>6SV
n=
5
6
7
8
9
10
AC=<[4N9; <>D7%7FE bc386W<<[AKN J <W3VIE ?CN7 ;egE<>[email protected]; H[<><a'G8<><=c;°A\EB437 [email protected] =8<{=GE J :8E a-AC<[N?CN¢NF<[4N/=V;%; G83O>a'E 7 4egE [email protected];/; 7 <>O[a'<9<><>=c= ;+38H[7 4O[=cN/;/687F38E3kH>;/[email protected]<[N=c? ;¢R H[A˜4eg=8E =V686 ;
68X = L 4M Gf7 Gf3? 2^7 <H>[email protected]<E Sc7 eK38E [email protected];¢?CN N/bc6867<ACSM<[H[N 4N a-4a-a'a'<È<>4; =#N AKG8J E+< LI6˜? SMjBG87¢O[H>H ?CE G8AC<>H>768ACN <>?87 6868=^= D; 7F<>E A8384W7 <ÈGf7<[<{N ;¢<[N/3; E NF7 EegE [email protected]%; <>G8a'468<>=c; <;
4G87:< G84t =8<>=7/i;E h`:8AC<><-;ƒ<[N/G8; < X L <>M 7/Gf7F?3E2^H>[email protected]<hAC< ?G84RdA6=8H`=<hE#3G8E4N1=HGJ G8E [email protected]<QDM4D7/[email protected] ;/=W8G8a'<[<¡N°H G8W<`E =H[H[4<[AC4N°7FbcE ;/6?C<Q4= A\E'<>a'=‘O>; ;/<>Wa-4IG83<N
[email protected] HIXB=44;/a-7 <2?\E E A [email protected]? DMl 47/<>[email protected]\;/E W8=˜a'J <[<QN/;£G8<m; 4H[684; AC<4eg7F4E ?C;/N9?C43=`EN9G8<[38NÈ7 4D687FLME O°38W7/[email protected]<[DMNB4G68J)7 (B<>67/;N O><>a-a'?C<>N =V;gE? [email protected]/[email protected];/W8a'< [email protected]>)k eG84<È=AKH>J ;/E [email protected]=84=7/[email protected]<Ä;/W8<>=ma'3<+E DM7/O>;/=?CH>O>[email protected] ?C<>A7%G8N/< 68H[7˜4ACAC<[4N˜7FDE 7F;/E?C438=ƒW<[G8N <[N3E D7 7FeKE E [email protected]; W<><[a'N{<>3=VE ;%7 eK4E 7 [email protected]; 4N=83=E E 7Ä:8A\ACEm<[N a'? ¢O>;/=2W4cG8G8<>W<+4G87 <N
AK<>J =„<>[email protected]@; [email protected]<>3a-N 43KGN98< 3k4gE @A [email protected]=447/[email protected];/?\W8E a'A˜3k< 4JS68?KO 79 H[S4HACJ 4<[7/N/?C; <>7È#BAC=<[4N9;/D7 <97FE H[384W=8<[=N9E 3?CNFE NF7E eK=E H[[email protected];<{<>ACa'<{<>38=V7 ;B<>a-47 ?CG8<>7Ä4=8E [email protected] 4:87/[email protected]<[;/NW8? a'<
G
'/!.+ )+ )+ -& L 4687o\[email protected] SMa'<>=c;/?C4=8=4=N£bV6< Z ; <>38WE =t 468DVE 7 GSH /R E°7 <[H[<>=N O >/>0e H>A\EN N <[N
ACG8E <{7/<°;/=?CD4H>7FACamE<^38:8ACW7<[<È<[N N G8G83<[O>N¢E=7 D4eg7FamE E [email protected]:8;38N 7WS<><[a'35N4<># 68=ck7 ; N^HN W4H[a-E4H>=a'68H[=<><>7/<Q; =N G8SE <[=ckN ;-bV=6AC<[<>1,[email protected]><[.A\NBE. [email protected] ,ANF10<[E-N2? 38O>X 6h;/64H 6GfE N’?CACO[H>E <[68LMN-AC4<>G=7 EN’3=<WE N Vf7B;/H[7F4<1E 7 [email protected] ;’[email protected]=G8E E <£38; [email protected]<>;/4687 = <7
[email protected]¢;FE :8AC< E 6 [email protected]> ? l <[H>?35<>7/a'<>;’G8<£NF<{egE [email protected] <{68=<9?CG8O[<9G8<£AKJ [email protected]/;FE =H[<Èbc6E =V;/[email protected];FEGM
;/[email protected] <38WG8<[<[NmNÈH>G8A\< EN [email protected]<[6N NmSf?CG8G8<^O[<Gf3k?NV <>68N ;4M a->;/a'7 <<>; ;/N 7 ?4a-Z <>3kAC4<>6=N <t 4G68J E [email protected]@AC7 <>GS68MH 7 S˜[email protected] 4¡H 687BE bVOB68[ ?/N·QJ [email protected]=V>/; >&O>R 7 <[DN 7FN E<238E W6S<[V N
3G8<'E 7 H[egE <>[email protected];/; ; <><-a';F<>E [email protected]@;’AC< H[? 4=VZ ;/<>7F68EACH><[;/[email protected]><[[email protected] =#b >&H>[ A\EN N 4N a-<[N a'S3<>;E N%7/a-3E ?’7/ACa-<[N ?8bVAC6<[N<>[email protected]<[NmJ /ACEB<[N J dbck 6DE7FN/E ?NKM 383WE <[7/N [email protected]; G8O<'<0{>;<>7/ACDM<[<N
dba'V<>6=VE;ÈN/?NH[KM 34=cE 7/;/[email protected]; EO H>;/N/[email protected];/AC7/<[?CNÈH>; 7 <O FSE [email protected]?CNFN 4<m=VG8;[email protected]°6N 68=h=4EamN N :8<)7 °h <>6:kN 4<[= N ?,N AH[4E#7 < H>A\#-ENFH[N <>< ;9G8O><[;/NB7FE D=87FDME <238WH[<[4N+=H[34E 687 7eKNE [email protected]; <WM
Z <>AC4= t 468DVE 7 GSMH [email protected]ªH E R R/Rfe D7FE 38W<[N-G8< 0{<>7/DM<1E LM<[H R N 4a-a'<>; N S 3E 7/a-?
AC35<[4N 68bV7¢6<>AC<[ACN bc6R <>R/AR [email protected] -H N 4E [email protected];¢;£68G8=<B<9bcGf6?!EON/>?NMK7 3<>=E 7/H[[email protected]< ; ? OjBS8<>=1; <>R =^<[G8N/;O[GfAC<[email protected];’[email protected]{<£35AC<><£;/[email protected]@;[email protected]==<W4KM Dam7F:8E 387 <°W<G8< G8<N 4a-a'<>; N
7 <>387 O[N <>=V; O \ D687 < OS?KJ <[N/;^AC<„[email protected]<>;/[email protected];'D7FE 38W<YG8< 0{<>7/DM<hbV68?£=<hN [email protected];-K3EN^\G8e<
3,3
Qk
cb 6ELN/?NMK3E 7/[email protected]; O ?
a'=4<>=¡=c; 3NQE E 7 G87 eK68< E [email protected]; <>7F4Ea'68?CN <>DV4=VE =8;m7 =GSH[<>HM4a'S=c4<>;/7F=´=cE;+H>a'N;/[email protected][email protected]<^[email protected];/A\<[7 E N/<#[email protected];+7 bc<mAC6< <><-;BAC<><'=h7 38<>[email protected];/[email protected]@O[?CNNF35<>E <>=V=V;/; ;[email protected];268\D=87FD?CE bc683867 W< <><^a'OSG8?K<>J =V<#S; <>bVAC;m6<[NBEE N/6G8?NMKNFO>3N/=?E 47/[email protected]; :8O1< 7 <><WA\E ;M
H[N 44a-=sr/a'<[H><>;/; 68N{7 <7 <>[email protected] >&O[O NF<><[=VN ;; O Lc\7FE D?C68<£7 3k< 4OS68?K7¢J AC<[<[N/N ;{DAC7F< E [email protected]<[NN 35# <>;/[email protected];£N 4Da-7FE a'38<>W; <+N G8 <°A <£bc638E7/?CN/N/N? a'MK3<9E 7/[email protected][email protected]; O+3N/E ;/[email protected]/?CH># ; R<
b\c68D68?f7=˜< J <[OSN/?K;%J 3<[EN N%;3AC<{E [email protected] [email protected]¢; <>35a'<>;/<>[email protected]=c; ;¢DH[7F4E =V38;/W7F<£EH>3;/[email protected] < eK?E [email protected]; <Ä<>a'387/<>?C=VN ;Äa'H[<Ä43=VE;/[email protected]># ;/[email protected] AC<ÈN 4bca-68?8a'=˜<>J <[; N%N/; 7 3<>38E7N¢O[GN <>J)(B=c; 7 O M
;38O>[email protected]+?CN 3k?!<>A ;/<£[email protected];°DD7F7FE E 3838WW< < # =R 4= N 43a-E a'7 eg<>E ; [email protected];NÄ<>G8a'<9<>A\=cE+;m34E 7 ;FG8E 4; =8< =dXE :8?3AC*C<'? <>£7;+<>338E 7 7 O[egEN <>[email protected]; =V<>; a'YO <>\=cD;m687H[< 4=VOS;/?K7FJ E<[H>N/;/;¢[email protected]<AC< ?
A <{[email protected]¢35<>;/[email protected]; D7FE 38W<9G8<£bc6EN/?NMK3E 7/[email protected]; O9N ;/7/?CH>; <£bV68?f=˜J <[N/; 3EN%eKE [email protected]:8AC<>a'<>=V;’;/7/?\E =8D68ACO
<[N 4N/;Äa-ACa'< <>; N°7 E <>LM38<[7 HQO[NFH[<><[=VN ; mO387 \4D38687/7?CO>< ; OSO[N?KJ ? Scu <>;4=4H2=#[email protected]<[[email protected]/;Ä; [email protected]<È3kH[4<BN N/[email protected]:8E AC38<QWG8<B<m<[7N <>;¢a-AC<B38NFA\E<>H[68<>A7°D7FAC<2E 38DW7FE< 38# W<
33kE<>;/7 [email protected];E ? [email protected]; A <>a'< 38<>[email protected];^N+4357 G8<>;/[email protected]=8;+=DE 7F:8E AC38< W#<-G8e < N 40{a-<>7/a'DM< <>; # N-Q G8<1N 4A\a-E:a'\D<>68; Nm7 < bV68OS?%?KJ =˜3J <[E N/7 ;+683=EN+DG87F<-E 38_hW<ƒ)< [email protected]?C6<>N A
<[N/;£A\E-a^E ?CN 4= 7 <>387 O[N <>=c; O[C< \D687 < OS?KJS?
X
@
?
=
E
C
A
>
<
'
a
>
<
c
=
;
S
@
?
A
=
<
7
[
<
N
;
'
<
V
b
6
<
/
;
7
4
C
?
m
N
D
F
7
E
8
3
W
[
<
m
N
/
N
8
6
°
7
\
A
E \D687 < OS?KJ G84=V;2=46N=<
3k38A\4E68H[LM< 4= ACN<[N°E 2'G8<>7/6Sa'V <>72D7FE[E LM38<[WH-<[N2H[<>E 7/LM;/[email protected]<[;/H 6G8>&<-R bcN 46˜a-J [email protected]'N°<>N ;4N ?C<>S˜=c<>;°;°ACAC<[<[email protected] 638N+W35<'<>G;/[email protected]);(BN+7/3k; O>4a-N N/[email protected]:8ACbc<[68N ? ##=˜ACJ <>E 683S7M
3AC<°E 7/38;/7 ?C4<>68=cLM; <>#„7È=E 6O[H[H><[68N =N/<'[email protected]; <>N 7F4E [email protected];ÈM H>G8A\<[ENÈN N LM< O>7/GN? \)J (ÈH E7/;;/O>?C4a-=?CNÈN N ? <>ACXB4=46=N°4H>67 NB04 HME4N =N )< Nmh°bc3k6˜O>J [email protected][email protected]°:8ACAC<[<-N N? 4=c; Sa^E ?CN
C6
C6
L 4687 bc64?%H[4=NTEH>7 <>7 68=<2N <[H>;/?C4= '# A\E'DMO>=O>7FE [email protected]?CNFE ;/?C4=¡G8<mA\E'=4;/?C4= G8<m3E [email protected] <
GH>68J E =a-<ƒ?CNNÄ<[;FH>E ;/=V?C4;Ä[email protected]=˜LcJ 7F<[E N/?”;-bVH[64<£=NF; 4E68H>7 ; O[<9< =#Y4;/A\?CEh4=#DM<[O>N/=;’<>7FN [email protected][?CNF<>E38;/;/[email protected]:8=–AC<ÈG8G8<1<£A\DMEYO>==O>47F;/E [email protected]?C=NFE ;/G8?C<4=ƒJ [email protected]<>r/;’[email protected]=V6˜; J S%E 6S=8M?
#ªH[<>[email protected]< G8<`3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=¶E =V;/?CNiHIa'O>;/7/?CbV6< 3E 7„<WV8<>a-38AC< A <[Nƒ7FE ?CN 4=N #H[<>A\EªN 4=c;
a2L E [email protected];/A [email protected] AC<)<[IH N a'? *46847°68;QAC4G7 NJ E :kG8<Q47 A\G´EƒH[N <><[;/N ; N/<#?C4bV=¡6G8<[<QN ;/?C3847 =´4:8<[AUN/>T ;2a'NF<[4Nm684LM68<>=VLM;m<>7/3k; N4N N O[68<7 SAC3<[E N7Q3<WE fV [email protected]<><[a-N°38GAC<^J E a-3E ?CN7
##A\E#H[4=fe O>7 <>=H[<-G8< L E AC4 (È[email protected]; 4ƒN/687 AC<[N D7FE 38W<[N°3E 7 egE [email protected]; N+<>= =4 LM<>a2:87 < J/[/[/J S46
3i9E j 7 ( Äu E =8¢= X +#?C( < <LI>[email protected] =S4#Q= A\E <>=QN/68a^[email protected]; E <°7 N GJ/J 68[/= [/OS<W?sfV A 35<4NFAC<[O°H>G8; <><°68X87¢7 N O[4G868O>W7/?CE [email protected]; _ <35E 57<>68F;E&M H >;/#Q7 <{A\E 68=H[4<=f7 egO>O>3k7 <>4==H[N <<
[email protected] H[4=VLE [email protected]=H E =V; < ?
3k;/?C<>H>768e [email protected]<[?CH>E'<>;/7m?C34G8E =ƒ<[[email protected]+<><2;{DG7FGEJ JE 38<>a-=VWLI<[?CN ?CN°NF<[E egNEDM;[email protected]<>:87£68AC<>=G8a'<m<[N<>==cE 4;[email protected];/DM?C;/447/7/= ?\[email protected] ;/bc=8W868Da'?˜68<[AC35N£O[<>N G87/S˜a'<B<>[email protected][<>AC4;+<2AC4N/[email protected];/687/[email protected];[email protected]= ;°E ?<=a uO>a'>E a'=<>=VNÄ< ;°AC68<ÈG8=´H <mEE [email protected];/447j68[T7/[email protected]Ä;/<>W837 a'E A\7 E< M
G38<E 7 7 eK<[E H[[email protected];4NÄ=8G8=4E =8?CN =NFEE =c=;H[< N ?<[email protected] [email protected];F79E =bcO>68a'?”7 <>>=VLM;{<+68G=#J 68E [email protected]< 4387/[email protected] ;/<>W868a'LM<°< GfG86#<È;/H[W4ACO[447F7jE >T ;/a'?C4< =˜egSc4A\7/E+;£3G8E <[[email protected] <BD7FGE J E38a-W<[?CNN
<3k[N/4;Q687-G84G8=<#H1=684=a24:8687 <>;/[email protected]{V 387D47Fa'E 38<>W;/;<[<>N-6837 ?E 7 _`egE E [email protected]; ?CNQN 4 H[=ª<>7/NT;FE E [email protected][email protected];[email protected][email protected]<^=<[AKJNi4KM 68D;/[email protected] AÄ38e W4<[=N^H>;/G8?C4<1=8:[email protected]<13E ;/7/7j;/[T ?CN2N a^3E E 7 A
<W8V <>a-38AC<{bc68?5=˜J 4=c;93EN9G8<+3E [email protected] <[N9GJ E a-?CN ? R A<[N/;9G84=H+=E ;/687 <>A G8<°N <+G8<>a^E =G8<>7
N/?68=<9=4;/?C4=^[email protected]’eKE [email protected]:8AC<93k<>7/a'<>;/;/7FE [email protected];ÄG8<9DVE 7 G8<>7ÄAKJ <[N N <>=c;/?C<>A5G8<[N’387 4387/?CO>; O[NÄ3k4687
Q/Q
; 46NBAC<[N D7FE 38W<[N°3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N ? XB46N+G84=8=4=N°?CH>?%G8<>6SVh38?CN ; <[NB3k4N N/[email protected]:8AC<[N CA <[N 3E 7/;/? ?NM
. ;/?C4=N£3E [email protected] <[NÈ<>;£AC<[N9H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[NÈ<>=8=<>a-?C<[N SE[LM<[H2bV6<>ACbc6<[N£AC<>a-a'<[NÈ<>=H[4687FE DM< E =c; N
' &/ &/%)+ %'/ A E1=4;/?C4=´G8<-3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=ªE =V;/?CNiHIa'O>;/7/?CbV6<^3E [email protected] <S˜G8O r #ƒG8OW\=8?C<-3E DM< Ok Sk=˜J <[N/;
3;/?CE4N£='NF<>E ==H[N£477F<£E [email protected]/;ÈDME[O>=LM<[O>H°7FE A\ACE2<9=G84OW\;/?C=84?C=Y<9G8G<+E =3N¢E A\[email protected] <°38G7 <>J E 68a-LM<9?CN Gf? 6-BX ;/4W6O[N{4387j>T 7 a'43k<£4egN 447/=;¢N£G8?C<[H>N ?D687F=E <+38W=<[4NM
3G8<>E 6S7 egYV E [email protected]<>; =N N <>JSam> :8]cAC<[N [email protected]=; 4G=`68Lc=^?CG8D<[7FN E? 38jBW= <+Gf<>;[email protected]; (A,bc6<mB)A\E'683=E <B7/;/[email protected];/?C7/4;/=¡[email protected];/?C<[4N/=1; G8<[N{ ,N -4a-N/?a'<>; <>; NFN<>68G8AC< <>a'V <><>=V= ;
N/?¢]
* 46N AC<[NÈHFW<>[email protected]=N°E VH E =V; AC<>? 687 N <WIV ;/7 O>[email protected]; O[N GE =N B <>;ÈAC<>[email protected]=V; O>7/?C<>687+GE =N
A NF4=V;ÈG8<+AC4=8D6<>687B3E [email protected] <
* 46N AC<[N-E =V;/?CHFW<>[email protected]=N^E VH E =c;-AC<>68? 7 N <WIV ;/7 O>[email protected]; O[N-GE =N A <>;QAC<>[email protected]=c; O>7/?C<>687
GE =N B N 4=V;9G8<AC4=8D6<>687È3E [email protected] <
Z [email protected]; G 68=yD7FE 38W<`bV6<>ACH[4=bc6< E[LM<[H¡E 6ya'[email protected]=N O NF4a-a'<>; N#<>; x S y G8<>6SV
NN 4<>68a-AC<>a'a'<><>; =VN;+=N/4? =EGr/EH[<>=c; N2G8< G ? (È<[AC4N/;97 N 68{x,
y} <[N/;68=<^3E [email protected] <^GJ E a-?CNmG8< G N/?’<>;
?
=
°
<
3
E
/
7
/
;
@
?
/
;
C
?
4
`
=
3
E
@
?
7
m
<
8
G
<
(V \ {x, y}, {x, y})
G =`H[<N <>=N S8A\E
3E 7/;/Z [email protected];/?C4= 3E [email protected] <<[N/;£:8?C<>= 68=<DMO>=O>7FE [email protected]??CNFE ;/?C4=hG8<°A\EQ=4;/?C4=hG8<°3E [email protected] <GJ E a-?CN ?
\ <^[email protected]'O[Gf?\E ; <>a'<>=c;^bV6˜J 68=<#3E 7 M
4
@
?
;
G <[N/;268=D7FE 38W<ƒG8< 0{<>7/DM< jB=ªLMO>7/?N
;/[email protected];/H[?C44=a-38(A,AC<>; B)# G8< <>;+N <[a^N+EN 4=a-bc6a'E <>=V; ;mN°<><[=cN/;/;+?U>T 37 E<>a'[email protected] < <>=VN/; ?%<>;+G8NF<>468=8AC=<>a'< <>##=V=;°4AK68J EGLM/r < 4E 686;+68G=¡J 68=D7FENF438a-W<-a'G8<><;
v
B
A
0<>7/DM< ? =hegE [email protected]; S3E 7BAC<mAC<>a-a'<2G8<27 O>[email protected]?CH E ;/?C4=¡G8< A 4·Lsg Nih AC<>a-a'< JS?KE S”4=h35<>68;
ACGfG8<[68<NÈ38N0{[email protected]?C<>bVa-7/6DMa'<>< 7Q?<>; H[A N+<^<hG8N <4AC<>a-Ka-a'a'#'<><`; ; [email protected]È<>L;2ACE <[=ca N ;#>N a'684a-;/<#[email protected]@a'?CEGN /r<>< 4; 68N H[;<>G8<>;/<7; <`B# H[S8G43k=4N/68;/68=7/7B6<^H><>H>;/[email protected]?C?CH[4bc4=ˆ67 <Q< 3k4K4:868; 7#<><>[email protected]>7B7 =<>68O>[email protected]?\7F=hE E [email protected]?C;QN7F<>E ; 7ƒ384W6A\E<N
H[bV46=<BH>H[[email protected]<9N/;/?CW4=O[47jgE>T a'{Gf<+6„E 2';/W7/O[a'47j< T>a'bc6<2<ÈG8N <°? [email protected]<[;BN/;’<>;68=B<BW837iHE [email protected] <;/WGO[J4E 7ja-T>a'?CNÄ< GOSJ [email protected]>/=1> D ?7FE iB38E W38<3kSI<>E ACAC44=7 NN
[email protected] J <[<WN/fV ; ?CM N/#G; M <[email protected] =<£<Q68=H[4<£ACH[447FEAC4;/7F?C4E =¡;/?C44=#38;/[email protected]<a^E {x,
AC< G84G8=cy}< ;¢GA\E bV;/7F68E?H[G8<94N/=868=7 <QA\E'a >G8a'4<Q=8=H[<{46868AC=<>68<97 H[4# AC4x7FE <>;/; ?C4y= S
{x, y}
438;/[email protected]^E AC<G8< G[{x, y}] ? G
! ' 2
G - $ (A, B) - 1 $ G 3. $ . - +*, .3 1 . *,.0 . G[B] - G &.0 * -/ B Bj =H[N 44=a-N/a';/7/68<>;[email protected];mN·S AC<-Gf?CDN r/7F4E [email protected]=VW; <ƒ< G8< <>=´? EGjBr =4687 ;F<>E [email protected]=c?C<#; ; # 46NQ68AC<[=N2<'N H>[email protected]?CbVa'6< <>; N G8E <#LM<[A\EH
H>[email protected]?CbV6< ?Gu J E E 386S7jVmT[N˜N 4AC<a-;/a'WO[<>4; 7jN T>G8a'< <¢e 4? 7/jB;=QG8<[4N:8D;/?C7F<>E =V38;W68<[=2N˜3DE7FE7 eK38E [email protected];<’N G8S·<4=20NF<>E 7/[email protected];<’bcLM6O>< 7/?N\”E =V<[;N/;3E 7 egE [email protected]; S
H;/[7F<mEbcH[<68?N [email protected] [email protected]?CbcG864<=8=<+68=<+H[4AC47FE ;/?C? [email protected];°38;/E [email protected]^47 E NÈAC<°68=G8<Q< H[4? AC4jB7FE=„;/?C684;/=`[email protected]@?C4NF38< ;/[email protected]^E AC< G8< ? Z E
H[468AC<>687 NB3k4687°H[4AC47/?C<>7 S”<>;+G84=H
H[468AC<>687 N+354687+H[4AC47/?C<>7 ? jB=
G0
χ(G) − χ(G[B])
K
ω(G)
G
K
G
ω(G0 ) =
B
G0
χ(G) =
χ(G0 )
G
G
K
χ(G[B])
G0
χ(G) − χ(G[B])
G[B]
Q
86E-=G8<4=H[4HmAC4:87F?CE<>;/= ?C4;/=`7 446838LM;/[email protected]^68=E AC<m<H[G84< AC47FE ;/?C4=`? 438;/[email protected]^E AC<2G8< G84=V;BA\E ;/7FEH[<mN 687 G84=8=<
A E¡387 <>68LM<YGf6yAC<>a-a'< 387 O[H[O[G8<>=V;ƒ3k<>68;';/7jT[N':8?C<>=r7 <>a-38A\EH[<>7^A\E 387 <>68LM<`G8<
A\G8Eª<>a-H[4a'=<>H>[email protected]; N/Sc?CH[4<>= ;/; <ÈgE =^4Gf686LM<>[email protected];/ACW<9O[3847 j7 <>T>68a'LM<¡<È<[G8N <`;¢=X<>4;/=8; [email protected]<>68a'38;<>=V<>;; a'[email protected]=7iN¢H [email protected]=c ;/; WO>7 O[<[4N 7jNFT>E a'=V;< <[email protected]>/?C> N bc?6˜/ J <>[email protected]?N< M
6838;/7 [email protected]@68?CN LM<Y<>7 AC<„68=Y;/W7O[O[4N/j7 68T>[email protected]';FE <Y; e [email protected]/6;1NBG8DM<[O>N'=O>D7F7FE E A 38? WX <[4N#63N E E 7 LMegE [email protected]=; NÈN ? ; <>Z =c4; =rO2NNT<>E 68=AÈNBa'N/6O>H[7/H [email protected];T[<YN G8<[N/<;1DVG8E 47 G8=<>HY7 G8A\E<
H[G84<[=N£H>[email protected] N/38?C4W=¡<[NÈDMO>3=E O>7 7FegEE [email protected];<'N ?; 468;<>=`=46N°G8O>:E 7/7FENFNFE =V;mGf6 7 <[H[4687 NmE 6 ;/WO[47jT>a'< eg47/;
A <[N3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=N2E =c;/?CiN HIa'O>;/7/?CbV6<[Nm3E [email protected] <[NmN 4=c;mG8<[NH EN°3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 N2G8<-3E 7/;/N? M
;/ ?C;/4W=O[N4j7 3T>Ea'[email protected] < <[NJS?$?KO/u J 4 S=4H=^S3NFEE [email protected];¢ACbc<m6;/<WH[O[<>47/7j;FT>E a'[email protected]=< NÄG8G8<m<[N G8DO[H[7FE438a-W3k<[4N’N/[email protected];/< ?C40{=¡<>7/G8DM<[<{N ACD<[7FN E [email protected]<[N’N+GfG83? 2^<1H>0{[email protected]<><[7/N DM#<
H38[4ACO>AC4a'7/?C<><>=c7 ;È.S G8#°< NFE[J [email protected][email protected]Ä[email protected]=cH[; <>ScS6 3kV-4NbcNj68T[?G8=<>=c<£;9N 4G8=c< ;’; 3<>[email protected] <[N{:E3N E ?C7/bV;/[email protected];/<[?CNÄ4=<>;¢N ? bVÈ68?==˜<BJ 3847=c<>;’68=8LM? <J E [email protected]/[email protected][email protected]=V7/;’[email protected];/=8W8?a-H[?C4bca 6< M
;FA\GfE2E [email protected]^=AC<>N%E a-D=87Fa'?UT>E 7<’38<+WH>N?G8<[M N <G83<[A\EmN E N/7 386eKE7N <>[email protected]; 68N 4LMS 68<+7 7/<>H>7F3kEA\[email protected];N NFN E G8?C=VbV4; 6=3k<H¢<>3kGf686ƒ<>; 68M ;/>; WM;/>7O[;/<£47 7jN/<T>68a'47 68< G8Lc<[OS7/[email protected][email protected]˜>/O[68>/H ?W=A<’E =8#238DM?C<>N/<[=;N’<¢H[:843k?C7 H4<W868SI7 7 =4H[4a^46EACN{4;/7/?C=˜bc?C<>J 6E 7LM<[H[4N <>9S=7 # NM
3EN9G8<7 O[N/[email protected];FE ; ?
G
B
G[B]
2
# * j
B
=
F
N
E
@
?
%
;
V
b
6
’
<
C
A
[
<
N
@
A
@
?
=
WMKD7FE 38W<[N G8<’:[email protected] 7/;/?CN%N 4=c;N 4OS68? kLM<>=c; NFE =N3E [email protected] <GJ E ? a-?CN ? l <
<
380W68O>7/=AC<>4;a7EÈT>G8=4< =<[H’N/HF;9W:8<>?C7 <>H = WOÄH[468a-=<¢38=7/?C4NB68DLM7 <>[email protected][<Ä<Q=E 46h;/?C;/4W=QO[E 4HV7jET>a'=c;%< LM4cH E S5;/G?C4= # #{7tB<>4a-6838DVA\E E7 H[GS<>H 7 A\E9_Y3?CHFE [email protected] <>< A
GGJJ 68E a-=?CDN 7FGE E38=WN9< ACG8<2<ƒH Ea'NÈ[email protected]=<[N9N^[email protected][email protected]=<#<WMK;/D7 7F4E ?CN^38WN <[4N+a-G8a'<m<>:8; N [email protected]%E AC<[7/;/N-?CN D? 7FjBE 38=`W<[[email protected];È:[email protected] <7/S;/?CNFN^E 6f4e¢=V;'H E; N946s;/7/r/[email protected]?\7E N A
G8E 38<[NÈj7 T[3NÄE [email protected] E<[N NÈNFE GDMJ <E a-E 6^?CN [email protected][email protected]=L W< 4MK68D7 7FbcE 6384W?< E AC4_h7 N9?CH =W<<>A 30E68N97/7 AC<><>DV;ÄE <[7 N/G8;{<>[email protected]=H[<°N/?bc36E <7/LMG8<><>=cLI6 ?C<>#°=V; A\E°H[<>=;/4; ;/<°?C43=ƒE [email protected] <<
H>E [email protected]@?CA\bcE 6=c;'<[N£G8<><^=8=AKJ <>68a-=< ?C<[N°#Y]cAK4J E =„68;/Gf7 [email protected]<1;£bc<>;Q6<Ba- [email protected]=8<>[email protected]^VƒE H>S6 [email protected]?CVbV63k<[4N£68N 7Q4=cAKJ; [email protected]= H>[email protected]/1?C4=– °E[LMN/<[?”H„; 4H[6<>N;/; AC<#<[N£38HF7 W438<>a-7/?CO>[email protected]=; ON
NG4J 68=c=;mG8D<-7FE AC384W=8< D6<>[email protected] 338E [email protected]<>7 [email protected]< AC?< L *[email protected] 38 7 O[H>?CNFO> a'<>=V&; ,S1.N/ ? <>; N 4=V; ;m468G8;+<>S6 HFVW<>H>[email protected][email protected]= 6<[N
&E HVE =V;968=<+W< Vf;/7 O>[email protected]; O GE =N ? SIAKJ E 68;/7 < W< Vf;/7 O>[email protected]; O°GE =N <>;{; <>AbV6<
HFbcW6<>< [email protected]=<>S6N V‘N 4H>7/;[email protected]?CE bc=V6; <[N N„E [email protected]<>A\=8E ==V;%<>a-G8<Ä?C<[AKN J 68 N ==4<=VeK#È;ƒE [email protected]; J E SE 687 G8;/<>7 G8S6<ÄWO VN\4=8H>[email protected]@;;/?CbV?CG846=)<’<[ACN'4Gf=8NF?CN 4Dr/=V64; <>[email protected]=V68; 7%<[N·[email protected]£13HEE [email protected] 7 < 68? =ˆN/jB?£=QO>; LM4=<>64=cN';;/<>6AC7F<[<>E N A
NjB4= a-G8a'OW<>\;[email protected][; 4a-G8<2ama 68=ª>a'H[<24=A\N/E';/[email protected]=;/46;/<>?C7F4E =¡[email protected]; G8#„< [email protected]*68. #?’-N <> 68+A¢68 =´ HFƒW<>][email protected]<>=6SVhN 4H>7/[email protected];F?CE bc=c6;2<[NBG8<-NF4AC=V4;+=8D6<> 68 7 [SN/??
; 46NÈAC<[N9H W<>[email protected]=NBN 47/;FE =V; N E [email protected]\E =V;BG8<+AKJ 68=< # AKJ E 68;/7 <N 4=c;ÈG8<+AC4=8D6<>687È3E [email protected] < ?
G
K1
V (G) \ (V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 ))
K1
K2
K1
K2
K2
V
(P ∗ )
P
⊆
-6% #0 8f;S#0 *$" +8$ ;".*p#0 *5" +8: -6%7"6"6! %
X 46N9E [email protected]=N£[email protected]< AC<[N£H>[email protected]?CbV6<[N£<>=8=<>a-?C<[Nr/46<>=V;9GE =N9AC<[N{[email protected][email protected]=<WMKD7FE 38W<[NÈG8< ?
:[email protected] 7/;/?CNÈ68=„7 AC<°N/[email protected][email protected]\E [email protected] <1# H[<>[email protected]?G8<[N£3E [email protected] <[NÈGJ E a-?CNÈGE =N£AC<[N{D7FE 38W<[NÈ:[email protected] 7/;/?CN
. Qfe
L 4687Q:8?C<>=´eKE [email protected] <S [email protected]Ä=46NmegE 68; G8<[[email protected]=fe 47/a^E ;/?C4=N 387 O[H>?CN <[NQN/6872A\EYN/;/7/6H>;/687 <1G8<[N
[email protected][email protected]>==<WO>KM D7FE7FE6S38¡V WG8<[N9< G80< <>[email protected]:[email protected]<3ME < 7/;/?CON ?S? A R <+A’ACE <>38a-3a'E 7/<+;/?CN/<>[email protected];QLE E =c6¡;9eg<[4N/A ;{IACG4E 7 =<SN{=˜AKJ J <[O>N/;F38E 7/[email protected]; ;£G8#1<[=N{4;/;/7F7 E[<^LE H[6S4V#=8=38E [email protected]?C6N NM
N7F<[E H[=4H[=8<^=38E 68?CN :[email protected] ?C=O#H[=V< [email protected]<[<[email protected][email protected] =7/<W; KM ? DX7FE 438; W4<[=NN2G8bc<26˜DJ [email protected]ÄE =38<1W<[G8N°4=8NFE ==<1N 3;/E7/?\N E =8GDJ E AC<[email protected]? 4 7/[email protected]=¡;/W8< a'k<><#; 7FS”E 35384?C68G87+<ƒ7 G8<W< M
[email protected][<>[email protected]=4==8N/O>[email protected] EG; [email protected] <D7 ;/< 7 ƒH <#3; G8E <[7<^N/; AK;<>J <>[email protected] 4<WD7/IV [email protected]?CE;/N/W838; a'<>W=<[<^H[N <2S [email protected]<GAÄJ A68<[N/=h<>;mW;/4387/;[email protected]?\6E 4=8Nm6 D7FACEiB<38S54?Cbc6G86N<1N<4G8G83k<^<4H 687 E AC<[4ACHFH>N W68<>ACg<>7E [email protected]\4<>Eƒ7°7/[email protected];/[email protected]>7a'[email protected]<[=H>< <1; <>JS<>a'? =´e <> =V;S5<>;°35a-4G8368<[N7N
D357/4?!68k<7+[N G8<>O>; a'G84<[=VN ;/7Gf<>?\7°E a^AC<QE =V;/W; N O[?4BX7j>T 4a'; 4< =G8N¢< E 6t N E N 7F?fE bc7i6YH <<>=;C4t;/7 4<[email protected][h <>a^a-E a'=8=<£<[ N/;/;%W68O[4=7j<£>T a'O>;F<E 35JS<?KR =9E N/;/686877 <>[email protected]<[AC<N
[email protected][email protected]=O>a'<WKM 4D=V7FE;/738O„W<[H[Nm<1G8AC<><-a-:8a'[email protected]<E S%7/;/a^?CN E ? ?CNR A¢a^<[N/E ;[email protected]<>468=7 H'<>638N 7 <>4a':<>E =V:8; ACS¢<'ACbV<>668<a7^+tE 7/E ;/7F?CH>E AC7i<1¡H <[<>N ;D;QBt ;/7j4[T [email protected] [h a^Gf?3E 2^=8H>[email protected]< =V# ;
NH <[email protected]@?C7<>4c=8H>=68<-7 <><>7 = S35>&Ef<>68eGk; M Sk>E;/7=8<m=O[3< E 7 bcH[68<?bVN 668<[email protected];B38AC68< :8H[[email protected]?C4O268G3¡E G=JN£/ AC;F<°E ;°387 Gf<>6ha-DM?C<>O>7B=O>=V7F68E a'A O>L 7 [email protected]^=4cGHFJ 68W=<>; <? 7 XB<>Lc466<N
387 468LM4=N \ =E AC<>a'<>=V; H[<°AC<>a-a'<°3k4687£=<°7/?C<>= A\E ?CN NF<>79GE =N£AKJ 4am:87 < ?
! ' 2 =
G - . 1 - 1 R . . - G = L(R) 1-/.01 G 11 + D3 7/E?!NÄk<G8<È<>;ÄD7/NF?!E k<=BNR =8AIGf?”<[?\N/EG8;a^< H>EGfA\E =V?\[email protected] ; 7%a^? bVjBE6=V=1<’; ACL? <¢EiÈ[email protected][email protected][O[=4H>W< [email protected]=MK38DN/7 ;/7F4I7/E [email protected] <><<a'G68<>=1J 68=V;=mDSf7FDE47F38=#E W38H[< W4=<N/NF?CNFEG<E =T>=N7 N’<B;/7/;/68?\7/E=1?\E=8D=8D7FDACE<ÄAC<38=W;<¢<<>3kA54bVN 6NFjN < ET[G8=<N
N [email protected];£?CN 4a'47/38W<1# ?
G
R
G
$
.0 +- - *. #- - (v)]
1- *, +*, G[N&(v)]
* - *, +*, G[N
*. "- L(R)
v ∈ V (G) Z 6838354N 4=N bc6<
? (ÈAC47 [email protected]{<WVI?CN ; <
˜
=
J
[
<
/
N
;
3
E
Q
N
8
6
=
1
<
>
H
@
A
C
?
c
b
6
<
>
<
;
Z
?
E AC4SI7 E N AC47 LMN [email protected];%;<W<>VACEN2H>bc; <>6a'< <>[email protected];’=a^GfAKJ 6868E [email protected]= =;ÄbcG8686<[=<N <ÈNFD47/a-?!k<a'È? <><>; ;ÄN N/<[? N/;m<>68;LM=ª[email protected]; N ? 4 a-='a'<><; <>k<;Q>; G8SVS<E N/AC? 47 N a^E =bc6< <>; S
[email protected]=Gf68<>[email protected]; ;Ä68=„GfE ?\LME <[a^H E =V; ?Su 4=H AC<[NLM4?CN/[email protected]=N{G8< N <ÈS 3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8? =jB<>=V=h;ÈLM<>4=ƒ[email protected];BG8<>bc6S6V#< <>=N <>[email protected]=Gf:868AC<[[email protected];N
68AKJ =<>=<9N H><>[email protected]?CbV:86AC<B< G8< H E 7’N/? [email protected]=GfH[[email protected];9;/?C68<>==c;£<+G8D<>7/!?6Sk<V-?<NF4u a-<+a'a <>>; a'N’=< 4=ƒ[email protected]=r/EGfH[68<>[email protected]=c;9; 68N =<°<>H>; [email protected]?CbV6SI< E ?<AC4u 7 <N
38 [email protected]=´6N < S5<[email protected]>A ; =˜SJ N/H`?¢Eƒ68=E <^6H>; 68<>[email protected]<'<^EE 77 >>;; <-<^<><W=VVf;/?CN/7 ;<-<'AC<[<>N°=c;/NF7 4<^a-68a'=<>N; 4Na-G8a'< <>; <>;+AC<[NN 4a-<>;ma'68<>=; N°N 4G8a-< a'<>; ?
? jB=
5
S
E
C
A
4
7
N
4
`
=
=
m
<
k
3
>
<
8
6
B
;
3
E
+
N
[
E
M
L
4
@
?
°
7
/
N
@
?
2
a
8
6
@
A
F
;
E
=
>
O
'
a
>
<
V
=
;
>
<
;
NH/68E 73835N/[email protected]=NF4<2= NFE =N+3k<>7/; < G8<QDMO>[email protected]==GfO>7F68E [email protected];[email protected][email protected]; 68O =Gf?\E a^E =V? ; jB? l=¡4H[a-4=a'N/<;FE ; <'E [email protected] ; N°bc6S< 4=´NTE [email protected];[email protected]; bV6<
?.u 4=H [email protected]; H E 7mN [email protected]=4=
? _ E ?CN
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
m
;
8
6
´
=
f
G
\
?
E
^
a
E
c
=
;
,
?
u
[email protected] =AC4Gf7 68N ?CN <>=V;9AC<[NÈG8<>6SV„H[[email protected][email protected]; E =c68;=`<[NÈGf?\H[E 4a^=8=E <W=cV8; <[]”NÈ68G8=< <QH[4=V;/7FEGf??CH>;/l ?C4<[= H>?˜387 44=68H LM< > <>? ;
u < > S4= G8O[[email protected];9eKEH>[email protected]<>a'<>=V; G8<>S6 V13k<>;/[email protected]; N9H[47 [email protected]\E [email protected] <[NB387FE ;/?CbV6<[N]
G[N (v)]
v1
v2 ∈ N (v)
u
v2
{v, u, v1 , v2 }
v2
u
v 1 v2
u
v1
v1 ∈ N (v)
N (v) \ {v1 , v2 }
u
v1
{v, u, v1 , v2 }
v2
v
K1
K2
Ki = {vi } ∪ (N (vi ) ∩ N (v)) i = 1, 2
K1
G
K1
u w
{v, u, w, v2 }
K2
K1
K2
u1 ∈ K 1
u2 ∈ K 2
u1 = v 1
u2 = v 2
u2 6= v2
u1
v2
{u1 , v, v2 , u2 }
u1
v2
u1 6= v1
v1
u2
{u2 , v, v1 , u1 }
{v1 , u1 , v2 , u2 }
K1
K2
G[N (v)]
Q/R
1- *. #- 1 * + . G 1 ,* - . - +- v - G ! .0 - v *1 - *. #- . G - v ! *1 1- *. "- + . G ?A <[N{N 4a-a'<>; N£G8< N 4=c;{G8< G8<>6SV
3
E
/
7
/
;
@
?
7
8
G
<
I
S
4
1
=
[
H
4
=
/
N
/
;
/
7
8
6
@
?
{
;
C
A
B
<
D
F
7
E
8
3
W
<
;cAC<[HcN£3kN<[4N'a-]a'AC<[<>N; NÈNF4G8a-<+a'; HI<>35; Nm< G8<- ;c Hc3k< {*bc. 68"-?kNF>4S=VbV;£68AC?¢<[N£NF4N =V4;a-ACa'<[N<>; H>[email protected]?CG8bc<6<[Na^=˜J EGE [email protected]^E 7/E ; AC<[<>Nm=E G8=c< ; bc6˜<>J # ;
68G8=< <'; HINF3k<>68< ACH><'[email protected]?CH>[email protected]?CbV<°6bc<'6a^E =EGG#[email protected]^<[N£E ACG8<#<>6SG8Vƒ< H>[email protected]?C?bV6jB<[=N£bcEG68r/4?k68AC<>; <-687968H[=4<^7/7 E <[7 N/>3k; 4<#=<>G8=V<>;/=V7 ;9<#GG8E <>=6SN V N 4N a-J [email protected]=ca'; <><>;7 NM
N7 <><[38H>; 7 <>O[=cN <>; =c? ;FjBE =ƒ=V; GE rAKJ46868=8; ?C<ÈbV668<2=< H>[email protected] ?CbV7 >6; <<Ba^<>=VGE ;/VI7 [email protected]<Ba^68E =#AC< N 4# a-A\Ea'bV<>6;<>[email protected]<<[email protected]; A HcE3k38<933kE <>7/=;/?CG<>E =V=V; ;{?$A<>;’<[NÈAC<BNF4N 4a-a-a'a'<><>; N;
G8N 4<+a-;cHca'3k<>< ;B35G8<><°=; GHIE 35=c<°;ÈG8N 4<m=VH>;£[email protected]?C3bVE679< ? H[4=N ;/7/6H>;/?C4=YG8<°G8<>D7 O > <>;£4=V;93k4687£N <>68ALM4?CN/[email protected]=„68=
.0
;c Hc=t3k<^< <H>[email protected]>?C;bcS26<^N ? N <>J ;[email protected][email protected]; AÄ<>3k7AC<>4N 68<[N H>jN72T[;FEG8H[=V4<r7/; 7 68<[G8=N/<>3kS6 4;/V 7/=?\G´#„E =8G8GD<>E AC<S6=V N ? Z J [email protected];/A7 4W< ?CVINQS'?CN/H>E; [email protected]<AC?C4bc76N<[NN <[a^NEGVfN [email protected]^a-E a'AC<[<>N2; NGf?CN N/4;/[email protected]=V=E;H>AC4; G8<[7 <NN
H[4=c;/?C<>=V;¢E 6m? Za'[email protected];[email protected]=E NAC;/47 7 4N ?CN H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[Na^GE [email protected]^E AC<[N SÆH[<’bc68?VH[4<>=V; ;/7 <[[email protected]; > ?0u 4=H ?
u J E 38j7 T[N > SMAKJ <>=N <>am:8AC< NF<{3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=<È<>=^G8<>S6 V-H>[email protected]?CbV6<[NÄbV68?NF4=V;¢AC<[N¢H[4a M
3k>;/47 NF< E bV=V6; <[< N H[4=8=W< V8<><[; NÈG8< <>;’AKJ E 7 ?>; l < <[NBG8<>a'S6 V4=VH[;/47 <+a-bc3564< NFE =c; <[N+H[4=8=<[NW< ;ÄVf<[H[NÈ4=8==<<W3kV8<2<>68]VLM68<>==V<;
H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4= E LM<[H > ? l <[H>?˜387 468LM< k ?
B
j
1
=
8
G
WO \[email protected];’68=<9e 4=H>;/?C4= G8< LM<>7 N ? Z ? <[N/;’68=#N 4a-a'<>;{E 383E 7 M
; <>=bcE 68=c?I; 7 <># [email protected]?CG8<È<>H[S6 <[VƒN¢G8H>[email protected]<>?C6SbcV6<[H>N{[email protected]?Ca^bc6GE <[VfN [email protected]?a^Z E ? AC<[NÈ=˜G8J E < 383E S7/E ;/AC?C4<>=V7 N9;Ä4bc=„6˜J [email protected]# 6868?=E<£N NFN 4c<>H>68?C<AC<9AKH>J [email protected]?C=8bc?C6bc<{6<a^E EG7 Vf>[email protected]; a^<E G8AC<<
G8<[N/< ;£:8?CS˜<>=hE AC4G87 WO N°\4=8=¡?C<°[email protected]?¢68E7ÈN N ; 4I4H>68?C;È<QN AK4J 68a-=8a'?CbV<>6;È<'G8E < 7 >; <-? G8< [email protected]=H>?CG8<>=c; < # ?,u J E 38j7 T[N O S
G
R
R
G
G
G
G
R
{a, b, c}
G
R
u ∈ K a ∩ Kb ∩ Kc
Ka , K b , K c
G[N (u)]
Ka ∩ K b ∩ K c = ∅
u ∈ K a ∩ Kb v ∈ K a ∩ Kc
N (u)
G[N (u)]
Kc \ u
Kb \ u
vw
f
R
w ∈ K b ∩ Kc
G[N (u)]
V (G)
G
E(R)
v
v
G
R
v
f
* . - -/ - , $
G f (u) ff(v) * # R - . 1 u v{u, v}
* $ G A EBeg4=H>;/?C4= f <[N/;%[email protected]=sr/<[H>;/[email protected]< ? ='< <>; S N ? u E 383E 7/;/?C<>=c;# G8<>6SVQH>[email protected]?Cbc6<[N%a^[email protected]^E AC<[N
G
* 8GG8<<>6SV H>E [email protected]?CACbc467 N„<[N G?4Ju E 3847j=T[H2N E 6J H> 68S= AC< E 68N 4;/7a-<ma'N 4<>a-; a'<><[;ÈN/G8;ƒ< AKJ 68=8=˜?CbVJ E668< 7FE-N 43ka-4a'6879<>; [email protected]^H[E 4DMa-< a268= ?#ªZ H[? <[N
=˜N 4J Ea-38a'3E <>7/;B;/?CG8<>< =c;+bc=˜6˜JJ E#-68687FE-=<23kN4<>68687£AC<[email protected]^H>[email protected] ?CDMbc<6<S”E AC4? 7 N
<>;BA #'<>=H[47 <SkE 6H>68=`E 68;/7 <
A EBe 4=H>;/?C4= <[N/; N/687 r <[H>;/[email protected]< ? ='< <>; SN [email protected]; 68=<£E 7 >; <£G8< ? Z ? <>; N 4=V;
G3k8G84<-<>==cc; ;'GHcE 3kAK=VJ <^[email protected]; a^S5H>[email protected] ?CDMACbc4<ƒ67 <N 3SE E7 AC4<[7 N/Nm;£<[NACAK<[m;J [email protected]^r 6G8E N/<>DM; S6 <m<>Va'G8H><<>[email protected]=c?CbV; 63<[E N 7 ? Z ?? <>; <[N/G8;'< G8<1;c4Hc=c3k;m<„68=´H>[email protected]?CNbV46a-<„a'<>; <>;QH[G84<ƒa-am; HI6835= <
G
u
G
f (u) = u
G
f (u)
f (u)
f
ab
a
f
ab
ab
b
b
a
f
R
a
G
b
b
u
Q/E
Z 6838354NF4=N u <>; v EGr EH[<>=V; N{GE =N G ? Z ? u E 383E 7/;/?C<>=V; #2G8<>6SV^H>[email protected]?CbV6<[Na^EGVf?NM
a^H[4E a-AC<[35N4G8NFE < =cG; <[N{=H[44; =8O[<[=N <WVfK<[N <>; K <>E ; AC47 N2GJ E ?38jB7jT[=ƒN N/ 68> 38+3k44=N <ÈNFE [email protected] ;=bcN’63k< <>7/G[N
(u)] E1354687
;E <ÈAC<ƒG8G8<B< DMO>=O>S 7FE E [email protected][email protected];7 ON
K \u K \u
Z
?
?
˜
=
J
E
8
3
3
E
/
7
/
;
C
?
>
<
c
=
^
;
c
b
˜
6
J
Y
#
8
6
=
ƒ
<
N
>
<
8
6
C
A
ƒ
<
>
H
@
A
C
?
c
b
6
1
<
^
a
G
E
V
I
@
?
^
a
v ∈ V (K )
H[<>;/; <;FE H>[email protected]?CbV?CNÈ6<mbc6<[N/<°; AKKJvE 7 >?p; <A J G8E <7 >; <mO>G8DV< E ACR< # O>DVE AC< # <[fN/;9(u)AKJ E 7 <[>N/; ;B<E 7 AC<>[email protected] ?\NÈE =VAKJ; E 7 >; <# 7 <>[email protected]?\? E l =cG;<[N9KG8<>6S<>V ;
K
EE 7AC4>7; N'<[NBGN J 4E =c38;È7jT[:8N ?C<> =`> [email protected] =AKH>J ?C68G8=<><„=V; G8<[RN<„? H[Z <[? N'vG8E<>6S38V3fE (v)H>7/[email protected];/?C?Cbc<>6=c;<[N'#^<[G8N/;<>6SYV H>[email protected]<>?CbV;'64<[=NBKa^=4EG; fV <ƒ[email protected]^vAKJ E E AC68<[;/N 7 <G8< G S?
A J E 7 >; <ÈG8< R O>DVE AC< # f (u) <[N ;ÄE AC47 N¢AKJ E 7 >; <È7 <>[email protected]?\E =V; KK <>; K ;FE =Gf?CN’bc6<£AKJ E 7K>; <
[email protected]=< H>?CRG8<>=VO>;DV<[E N AC?<Z # ? f (v)E 383E<[7/N/;/;'?C<>AK=VJ E ; 7 >#+; 68<„=7 < <>[email protected] ?\<>E 68=cAC; <ÈKH>[email protected]?Cbc6# <9Ka^EG? [email protected] a^<[EN'AC< G8<>G86S< yV E =7 >4; ; <[O[N^< NF4=V;'ScE :8AC4?C<>7 = N
4='=354<>; 68O[;Ä< N/683835 4N/[email protected]=<>47’=˜bVS86<>< = vO[=˜HFWJ E E 38=83DME < 7/E ;/=V?C<>;B=VAC;£<[N{E 67 AN N/C<[?”N9bV6˜G8<J #+68=<>;<BN <>S8684AC= <9H>N [email protected]< G?Cbc7F6E a7<£a^>T =EG< fV [email protected]#Qa^68E =„AC<ÈH G8E<N
G
G8# O r #Q;/S7F;FE E [email protected];=KOGf ?C? NB¢bc=„6< egE ?@; S8GJ <[E N 38;È7j[T AKNJ E 7 >J ; <mS KG8< = 7 K<>[email protected]?\E <>=V; ; fu(u)# v<[N/;£]”AKJ H[E <[7 NÈ>; G8<2<>6SG8hV< RE 7 >7 ;<><[[email protected]?\N E =VN 4; =Vu;
R
v K
:8?CK<>= [email protected]=H>?CG8<>=V; <[N ? f (v)
È
i
[
O
>
H
@
?
8
3
7
I
4
V
b
6
>
<
'
a
>
<
c
=
;
9
S
/
N
°
?
C
A
[
<
N
E
7
>; <[N f (u) <>; f (v) N 4=V;„[email protected]=H>?CG8<>=c; <[N SBE AC47 N„AC<>687
NG844a-=Ha'68<>=;^H[N 44a-a-a'am68<>;B=‘G8<[<2N/;-; IH =35O[<2H[<[H>N [email protected]?CbVE [email protected] <2<>a'H[4<>7/=c7 ;^<[N/683k=y4=NFG4E a-=Va'; #-<>;^68G8=<<QH>[email protected]<>?CDbV76OY<2E G86< a'4H[[email protected]==VN#; <>G8=<>E6S=ckV ; S
<u >; v Sbc68?˜N 4=c;ÈG84=H°:8?C<>=hEGr EH[<>=V; NBGE =N G ? l <[H>?˜387 468LM< Q ? G
A <[N2387 4387/?CO>; O[NQG8<#A\Eƒeg4=H>;/?C4= f a'4=V;/7 <>=V;-:8?C<>=ªbV6< G <[N/;m?CN 4a'47/38W<ƒE 6
[email protected][email protected]=<WKM D7FE 38W<mG8< R ?
2
A <{AC<>a-a'<9N/[email protected] =V;¢<[N ; # =4;/7 <ÈH[4=8=E ?CN NFE =H[<£47/[email protected][email protected]=E AKSa^E ?CN [email protected]=<£G8<>LI7FE [email protected]; 3EN
N/E 68a-7/?C38<[7 N9<>=<>;ÈGf7 <><=8=68<>=ha-AC<[?C<[H>NÈ; <>NF6847B=V;9WE3k:8<>[email protected]/;/;/[email protected]=O <>E=V6h; <[NBN/6sG/r <>E ; =? N9RdA˜AC<[a'N£[email protected][email protected]=V=;/<W7 KM <QD7FbcE 638<W<[AC<[N N9G8=<+4:8;/[email protected]=E N7/;/G8?CNm<m] H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[N
! ' ] G - .0 G 1 . 0
u
u
u
0
u
u
u
u
0
u
u
u
v
0
u
u
u
v
u
v
u
v
u
u
. 1 - . 1 "*. "- & $.01 -/". *. - 1- ,+ $ 1- 11. A B 1. - - -/1
*. #- $.01 K K G K ∈ A K ∈ A .3 K K & K ∈ B K ∈ B .3 K K K ∈ A K ∈ B .3 K K " 1 1
1
2
2
1
2
1
1
2
2
[email protected]>&ES?6u J E 387jT[N
j
B
ª
=
E
8
G
4
8
3
;
#
<
C
A
[
<
2
N
=
4
F
;
E
/
;
C
?
4
=
2
N
8
G
#
<
\
A
„
E
8
3
7
>
<
8
6
M
L
#
<
f
G
6
C
A
>
<
a
'
a
<
H35[<<>68AC<>;a-G8a'4=<HÈS N/6838<[3kN/;B4N ?C<>N 7Ä4a'bc6˜4J7/[email protected]<WVf< ?CN/E ; 6h<[email protected][email protected]==#<WDMKD7FE7FE3838WW<B< NTEG=J 68N¢=`;/7/D?\E 7F=8E 38DWAC< <2NFE ; =<>NBA”bc;/7/6?\<E =8DAC< ? jB= ?
RN A{4=VE ;È383G8E<[NÈ7FEGN FC4; a-Ga'E =<>NQ; N9A\EYG8< 387 <>68E LM38<ƒ3kGf<>AC6O[N9AC<>N a-4a-a'a'< <>OS; NÈ[email protected]>&G8E <+bV;c6Hc<#3k<AC<[H>N [email protected]?CH>[email protected]?CbV< 6? <[N2a^[email protected]^E AC<[N-G8<
Z ? <[N/;È:[email protected] 7/;/?KSE AC47 N l AC<[NBNF4a-a'<>; N G8<2; HI3k<2H>[email protected]?Cbc6<2G8< NF<m3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=<>=c;
<a^>[email protected]<>a^S6 V¡E AC<[N N#;FE G8:8< AC<[N ? Z <>4; [email protected]; ? <>;/; <-3<>E ; 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=ª<[N/;mG8E 6<>6SN N/V–? H>[email protected]=?CbV<'63<[N'E 7/a^;/[email protected];/[email protected]=a^G8E <[AC<[NN#H>[email protected]?C<bc6<[N ?
XB4; 4=NbV6< <>; NF4=V;{<>=^a >a'<B; <>a-3NÄG8<[NN 4a-a'<>; NG8< =4=ƒEG r/EH[<>=c; N ?
1
2
1
2
G
R
G = L(R)
G
R
R
R
R
A
B
G
K1 ∈ A
K1 K2
K2 ∈ A
G
R
/[
BHFj W=´<>a-NTE [email protected][email protected];mG8G8< 4=H^S˜bcG86<'< AC4=8D6<><>; 687m3E N [email protected] =c<;2S˜N G84<[7/Nm;FE H>[email protected]?C;2bc6<>;°<[Nm7 <>[email protected]?\?CNE r =c4; [email protected]=c; <[Nm<>G8; < ? S˜Z E J [email protected] <WN2VIG?CN J ;E <-387j68T[= N
ACa'<[email protected]<>=a-N a'J < NFOS4?K=VE ;SACAC<[<[NN2E N 7 4>a-; <[a'N{<>G8; <[email protected] [email protected]=V; ; O>O>7/7/?C?C<><>68687 7£N2GG8J <#68=H[<B<'HFH WWEG<>FCa-=<[email protected]= G8< bc68?’G8<[<BN/;mAC4G8=8<-D6AC<>468=87{[email protected]<>6837-E [email protected] 7 6 <
7; <>[email protected]?\EN£=cAC;<[NÈAC<ÄH WN 4<>a-a-a'[email protected]=<>N ; N 47/;FE E =V6-; NÈN 47 a-<>[email protected]'?\E <>=V; ; ? l<>; <[H>?fH[4N =V4;/=c7 ;È<[[email protected]<°; ACA\4EÈ=8:[email protected]<>E 687/;/[email protected];/[email protected]?Ca-4='3E [email protected]<7 <#] ?Gu 4=<>H;
N<>;4=c;<>=8NF4==V<>;£a-<>?C=8<[N =? <>jBa-=¡?C<[N G8? O>Za'44?C<>=V=c;/;£7 <-a^G8E < [email protected]=Va ; <>>=a'E =V< ; bc6<QN ? <>; <>; G8<>6SV„H>S[email protected]?CE bcAC64<[7 NN
a^7 <>[email protected] ?\VfE [email protected]=ca^; E AC<[N£<>G8; < ? SZ E J [email protected] W< N£VI3?CN E ; 7È<È6868==„7FH EW?C<>N [email protected]=„=<>G8a'< <>=V;+SIG8N/[email protected]< [email protected]\=8E [email protected] 6<<>S”6847= [email protected];/7 3468E [email protected] <°<Sf68N =4<7/;FHFE W=cGE ;9FC=<><;
G8H[4< =c;/7 <[G8Gf<[email protected];ÈAC4A\E=8D:[email protected]<>68E 77/;/[email protected];/E [email protected] =`<mG87 <>< [email protected]?\E =c];BAC<2N <>4; a-a'<>; N 4=V;ÈE E a-6h?CNF<[4N a-? a'<>; ?5A #'<>=H[47 <S54=
Z ? =˜Q J <[N/; 3EN :[email protected] 7/;/?KS¢E AC47 N 3k4? N jN T[G8<#68=;/7 46ª[email protected] [email protected] G8<^AC4=8D6<>687
GG8E 6–<°J 68G8=a'<>D4; <>[email protected]=A’O°N ;/E 7 6„46a' H G4E [email protected] 7 ==N NJ AKS8J<[4N/<>7 ;#;£Gf<[7NF<1N/E ;£=4 N'G8'´4;/[email protected]/AC?\H°DN E =8G8H´D< ACE <; 38HI 335E <+XB7FH>[email protected]?C; ?CNF4bcN =6<>N=V< ;?<? u l 4W=EH°bVHF6W<#EbVN 64a-<°NFa'4AC<>a-<[; N'a'G8NF<>4< ; a-a'<><[<[;N/N/N;;
<>H>=ƒ[email protected]?CbceK6E <[[email protected];£N68a^=GE <°VIH>[email protected]^[email protected]?CbVE 6AC<[<+N{a^<>=ƒ[email protected]<>a^S6 E V#AC<<>=G8N < <>am:8? ACZ <[?˜N 4=Y<>E ; 7/7/[email protected]<1H[4#Qa-3a'E 7/< ;/[email protected][email protected]=;/?CGf4?C=8bc=6<>OB7ÈGAKEJ <>==NN <>AC<BamAC:8<>ACa-<2a'G8<[<N S
[email protected] <>E68GfLMLI<>?C=V<>;Q=V;BG84bV=6H <>G8;/<>7 S6 <'V <>H>[email protected]=?Cbc<>6a-<[?CN9<[N H[S˜4=<>;N O[=H><68;/[email protected]<><[68N LM<>=V; <>; >;/7 <-; 4=68<; <[N N4=cAC<[;9N3G8E<>N96SGfV¡?CN Gr/4E [email protected]==VN ; <[N·S4=6 <
; 468<>; ; <[N%ACS8<[NH[<°G8<>bVS6 68V ?˜<[GN/E ;È[email protected] a-35?s4AN N <[[email protected] :8ACH><°[email protected]?CbcO>;F6E <[=VN ;[email protected]<>=VAC<>;¢68G8794==4H am>:8;/7 7 <£<°E [email protected]@; <>37/E [email protected] ;/? [email protected]<>a'<>=V;GE =N
K1
K2
G
K1
G
K2
R
K1
K2
K1
K2
K1
R
K2
K1
K1 ∈ B
K2 ∈ B
K1 ∈ A K 2 ∈ B
K2
K1
G
K2
G
R
K1
K2
R K1
K2
R
R
H
v1 , v2 , . . . v2k+1
R
H
vi
G
A
B
vi
vi+1
A
B
A
vi
B
2
$* " /#0-6G!%7f#7 %G- d#&;S#&% _8;<G#0d. %
Z ?AKJ 4=YEGfa'<>;9bc6<+AC<[N£H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[N£<>=8=<>a-?C<[NÈN 4=c;£AKJ <WVI; <>=N/?C4= G8<[N{3E [email protected] <[NÈGJ E a-?CN
;/E 686S7 Vƒ<[email protected][email protected]=68<[email protected] 7F=cE ; 38<'W] <[NÈG8<+:[email protected] 7/;/?CN S”E AC47 N£[email protected]˜<[N/;ÈEN N <)h+=E ;/687 <>AG8<+387 43k4N <>7£A\E H[4=sr/<[HWM
*$" /#0-6G ' ] 2 5 -6 d# ] - - 2 $ G - 1 - $!
- .3 - G - G - $ G - G - $ *. "- + 1 X 46N°=˜J E LM4=N3ENGJ ?CG8O[<-:8?C<>=´387 O[H>?CN <-3k4687°387 468LM<>7mH[<>;/; <'H[? 4=sr/<[H>;/687 < ? l <
bcO>DV68E ?”AC38<>a'7 O[<>H =c[T G8;°< 35a'46847B=c;;/74<°6NBbV6˜AC<[J <>[email protected]<+7FE <[38N/;W<[LcN+7FE G8?C<B<m3kbc6468E7ÄN/?NKMAC<[3NE 7/[email protected]; E O 38? WL <[4N{68:7 EACN/<[?CN bc6D<[7FNE 38W<[[email protected]+<+G8<[<1N/;Ä0{LI<>7F7/E DM?C<<
38:[email protected]<>67/N{; N DM4O>=„=<>O>;7FE * 6SWV 4S8a^AC< E;/N WO[ ;/4W7jO[>T 4a'7j>T<a'G8<<+JSG8?KO[O/H[J 4’a-=35< 4G8N [email protected];/=8?C4==Y<+G87/?C< <>=„l WVG86<BGfeK=EH>4 [email protected]<>N a'MH <>S =VZ ;9<)<WIH fV a'[email protected] ;FS8E :8iÈAC4< M ?
;[email protected]/r RdE 4A{[email protected] <[7 S8N/N{[email protected];-A68H><W=1A\VfE [email protected]/W7 ; <>< bca-;6˜[email protected] =ƒ<>6s=Vr 34;/E76<„[email protected]{7{G868NF<>4= 6S7/;FHFV EW=V<>H>;[email protected]?C? [email protected] =Y6=V<[N ;/NQ47 7/<°a^;FEG8EG=c<>fV 6S;[email protected]^1V G8E<BH>[email protected]<[AC?C4bVN-=86GD<[6JN68<>a^=687EG;/fV 7 [email protected]?a^6Z E [email protected]<AKJ 43G=YE J [email protected]= SGfa'[email protected]£=c<>;/<W;[email protected] ;/bc?C7 N/46; 6 <<
[email protected]<[N£3N E <>[email protected] NACNSD47F=YE 38H[4W=<[N/N£;[email protected] a-; <3EG87 4eK=E [email protected]; N£bc6a-<[email protected]=8A\E [email protected]^H[4E =s6S/r„V <[H>N ;/468=V7 ;{<mAC<[N/68N{[email protected];/L7 E 4=V6; N{<[email protected]<[a-N ;£3E [email protected] E N9?C<'<>;{] AC<[N£E =V;/[email protected];/7 46N
. *5")f#0-.:' ]5] 5a-. f# ]-8-,2
S>
&- + 1 . G $.
{K , K } 1. . - K i = 1, 2 , *. "- 1 1
- *. #- $. G
1
2
i
DH[<°7FE N 38jB<>W==y<[N NÈ? 3k34E 687 7/eK7FE E [email protected];[email protected];#N ? N XB4684W6ENÈ[email protected];38<>7 7#O[N 68<>==V;< 4=38N+7 <>?C68H>LM?<YbV6=˜<>J AC68bc;/[email protected]@<[?CNFNÈE 7 =VO[;1N [email protected];FEE N^; NÈAC< 3;/E W7/;/O[?C4<>j7 ACT>N°a'E <[email protected]\E eg=V4;+7/;^GEG8=<[NN

G
J
8
6
=
D
F
7
E
8
3
W
<
[
<
/
N
;
8
6
=
<
B
j
m
=
F
N
E
@
?
;
c
b
6
<
\
A
{
E
[
H
4
c
=
/
;
F
7
E
>
H
/
;
C
?
4
=

G
J
8
6
=
¢
<
3
E
@
?
7
’
<

G
J
E
a
C
?
N
?
P
4<>=835=O>7F<>Ea-;/?C?C4<[[email protected]=cA ; <[O>N’7 <[E N7 NF>E ; =V<[N; < [email protected]=H>?CG86<><>=cA9; <[N <>N 7F# E [email protected]; egAK4J 47/35a'O><>7F=VE ;Ä;/?C684=y=<£O[H>[email protected][email protected] < AC<>=V; <ƒG83k< 4687QAC<[ScN-<>;¢H>[email protected][?Cbc<>[email protected]<[<[NN
[email protected]=<[N%H>?CE G87 <>>=V; ;<[<[N%N [email protected]=# H>?CG8<>e 4=c7/; a'<[N <>#=c;9684=6 <°H>S [email protected]?C<>bc;6G8< 4=8=<£?<G8A 4<°=N H{4a-GE a'=N<>;ÈH[4=c;/7F68E=H><{; O H>[email protected]?CbV67<{< 4([:[email protected]; ;9<>=c; 4668<£; <><[= N
7<><>[email protected]=?\E <>=Va-;¢?CAC<[<[N N N 4a-<>a'; <>; N G8S%< 4=–G8#+WO \H[=8<>[email protected];'V G8G84< =HƒAKJ ?4u35O>E 7F=E N%;/?C684=-=–DH[7F4E =38N W?CN/< ;FE =V;E LM#h<[H97 G8<>[email protected]<>?C6S<>7'VQHH>[email protected]?CEbcbc66<[<N
N 4a-a'<>;? G8<X 46N #E [email protected]=bVNƒ6<+LM4N [email protected] a-bVa'6<<>;{H[G8<><;/; <¡4? 3kjBO>7F=ƒE ;/4?C:84;/=ˆ?C<>38=V;{7 O[68N <>=17/LM=<`468A\LMEª< E 3561<>7 Deg<[7FEH>;/38?CW4<= ? =4(È; 6 O
387 O E <>A\; E :8AC<ScG4='J 68=„LMO>D7/N?7F\E <38Wbc< 6<£AKJ =435<°O>3k7F<>E 68;/?C;94=1H>7 H[O[4<>7B=N/E ?C6N/;FH>E 68=c=; <2#+E 768<>;/[email protected] ?C<><°7DG87FE<>S6=V^G8<mH>[email protected]>[email protected]?C6bV6<[NÄ<°<>bc=86=<<>a-H[<>[email protected]<[AC<N
?<L [email protected]È387 O[H>?CN O>a'<>=V;Q]
[email protected][email protected]; <°3E 7
{x, y}
x
Ky
y
x
y
Kx
K1
K1
G
Kx
L(G)
xy
L(G)
Ky
G
K2
K2
GK1 ≡K2
K1
K2
G
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
! ' ] ' K K - *. #- 1+ 1 - - *. #- G 1- * 1-/. 1 K - *. "- G 1
2
K1 ≡K2
G K
V (K) ⊆ V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 ) Z ? =˜J <[N/;°3EN+68=<-H>[email protected]?Cbc6<-G8< SE AC47 N H[4=V;/?C<>=V; E 6 a'[email protected]=N°68Z =
N<>4=´a-4a'68;/<>7 ; < G8< =˜J <[<>N/; ;683=`[email protected]=a-H>a'[email protected]<>Nm; GE =G8N < bc68? =<QN 4=V; S3E EAC4N 7 7 N <>[email protected]?CO[N+H[G4=cE =;/?CN <>=V; ? 68= ?
NE 4AC4a-7 Na'S <>; bc68?˜=˜J <[<[N/N/;{;È68=8=?GH EW=<>a-N [email protected]=YN S84=87/?;FE G=cE ;È=G8N < SS8<>G8;È<+bcAC468=8?˜D<[6N/;9<>687 79<>[email protected]?CO1E [email protected]# 7 <Sf7 <><>[email protected]; ?\E =c; ? _`E ?C# N
SH[<°bc68?˜<[N/;ÈE :N/687 G8< ?
¢4?CH>?˜=4;/7 <°7 O[N/68A\E ;È387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] AN/6879AC<[N9H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[N9<>=8=<>a-?C<[N2]
K
v1
K1
V (K)
v
v1 −v−v2
G
v2
K1
K
K2
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
K2
G
G
K
v1
v2
K1
K2
2
` *p +! ' U] $ G - $ ,* 1- *. #- 1 1 K
K .3 G
. - - $ Z [email protected]; H 68=–N 46NiKM D7FE 38W<„G8< G ? jB=–H[4=N/?CG8O>7 < H AC<„N 46N M
D7FE 38W<h<>;G8< G bc68? E¡AC<[N#a [email protected]>=a'Gf68<[?CNƒN <>N =V4;ma-G8a'<[N2<>; H>[email protected]?CbVbV66< <[NmH<>=8? =Rd<>ABa-<[?CN<[;#NmH>G8A\< E [email protected]#bc<>6;m< bVV6< (K ) ∩
V (H)
V (K ) ∩ V (H)
?/u 4=HS3k4687¢3E 7/LM<>[email protected] #°=4N\=N [email protected]=46NÄN/62'H;’G8<£LMO>7/?N\<>H7ÄbV6=<
H
?4L 4687 H[<>A\EfS4=
) NFE =N£=46N9NF46H>?C<>7ÈG8<[N9N 46N KM D7FE 38W<[N
) = ω(G
χ(G
2
1
K1 ≡K2
0
K1 ≡K2
0
1
2
0
a'H[44AC4=V7F;/E 7 ;/<°?C4bc=h6˜J G8#m< 3E 7/;/[email protected]£GJ 68=E[LM<+<[H[H 4AC47FE ;/?C4=YG8< H[4E[68LMAC<[<>68H 7 N2] H[468AC<>687 N Sf4=ƒ;/7 468LM<+68=<
B
j
=
[
H
4
a
'
a
>
<
=
[
H
‘
<
3
E
7
[
H
4
C
A
4
/
7
C
?
>
<
7
C
A
[
<
N
N
4
a
'
a
>
<
;
N
c
b
8
6
^
?
=
‘
<
N
4
V
=
;
8
=
1
?
G
E
=
N
8
=
?
Z
?
S
O
K
?
/
J
O
GE =N ?
S’E AC47 N'4=–NTE [email protected];'GJ E 387jT[N-AC<ƒAC<>a-a'< bc6<
(K1 ∩H)≡(K2 ∩H)
K1 ≡K2
K1 ≡K2
G
GK1 ≡K2
ω(G)
ω(GK1 ≡K2 )
K1
K2
ω(GK1 ≡K2 ) > ω(G)
/J
? jB=)EªG84=H
?
@
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
„
;
K
A
J
8
6
8
=
C
?
V
b
6
<
>
H
@
A
C
?
c
b
6
`
<
^
a
[email protected] G8<
E
AC7/<-?C<>7Gf7 [email protected];
=
4
8
6
M
L
>
<
@
A
C
A
[
<
2
N
[
H
4
8
6
C
A
>
<
8
6
7
N
c
b
6
<
K
A
J
4
¡
=
8
6
/
;
@
?
@
A
C
?
N
'
<
5
3
4
8
6
7
[
H
4
C
A
M
4
?
a^AKJ E EG=VfH>[email protected]?Cam<>=868=a <£H[468AC<>68N 7%4Ga-E a'=N<>; N N¢4? Ga-jBE a'==QN <>3k; <>N{68bc;6N/<>68ACH[3843k=4bVN 6<>7<[N{bV6˜G8G8J< [email protected]=V<W;’VI?C4N =-; <’DV68E =7 G8N <94a-387 a'4 LI<>?CR; N A547 [email protected]<[<>N/G8a'; < <+<>E =V6 ;
<>4;:8; 68<>=1=c6„NF468a-=a'< <>; G8< M &EH[HV4EAC4=V7F;{E ;/A\E2?C4a= >G8a'< <BH[468AC<>687 <> ;GfA\?CEmN 4H[=4N=7H>[email protected]/DM?C<4Ä= H GfE 617N AC<>[email protected]=a-4a'=ƒ<+4=„<[N/E ;
NFGE E ;/=?CN/N egE [email protected]; < ?=8Rd?˜A<GH-E =E°N E AC47 N¢? 68jB== <ÈH[E 4==H>N/?C?C<><G =8T>=7 <9<H[AK4J <>68=ACN<><>68am7 :8 GfAC< ?CN 4=G8N <[:8N9AC<>N 64<a-¢a'bV68<>;?8N9=˜G8J <[< N/;’68;/[email protected]@?C?˜N O[N <£4=c=8; ?
73k4<>[email protected]< <[N946„A\EQ:8H[AC<>46a-N 3k?<4A NFJ E<>==V;N <<>amH[4:8=8AC< =<WV8<[email protected]=G8Gf< [email protected];£68G= E =N N£46H[N<+MKDN 7F4E 638N MKWD<°7FE :[email protected] < 7/? ;/Z ? ? G8< <>;£4S8=YE ACE 4S3 7 NM
683=„E [email protected] 38<[email protected] N9<>[email protected][?\E 4=V68; 7/;9HFW<><>a-; [email protected]=hG8? < l <mH W7 <><>[email protected]?\E [email protected]=V= ; <[N/;9# N 47/;FE <[=VN/; ;{H 68E = 79H [email protected]˜W<>=˜a-J H [email protected]=YE'G8E < 6H>68S8=YG8NF<+4a-AC4=8a'D<>6;B<>G868<7
H[<>=8468=AC<><>a-687°?C<[:8N SIAC<><>6;Ä<-4=ƒGE E°=a'N 4=c;/7 O bc6< <>; ? l =<[<ÈH>?¢N 4H[=c4;Ä=c;/37 E<[[email protected];E A\=E1NÄG8A\E°OW\a =8>[email protected];/a'?C4<È=´H[G84a-<[N°3kH>[email protected]?CbcE 6=c;<[<N
H[4=8=3kW< 4V868< 72E <?S[H>u ; 4<>7=H # [email protected]˜<[N/A\;{E„3kH[44N 68N/[email protected]:8<>68AC<+7G:8J ACO[<>H 6W<E S =8NFDME <>=7ÈNAC<[H N£WEH[=8468DM<>AC<>7Q68A\7 EƒN£7H[446868DMAC<><°68<>72;£Gf:86AC<>N64<°a-Ga'E =<>;N
? jB=7 <[H[4a-a'<>=H[<#H[<>;/; <1435O>7FE ;/?C4=;FE =V; bV6˜J [email protected]’7 <[N/; <^G8<[N2N 4a-a'<>; N2G8<^a >a'<
H[468AC<>687£G? E =N
3k4687 \=E AC<>a'<>=c;94:8; <>[email protected]{68=<
M H[4AC47FE ;/?C4= G8<
Z ? <>; NF4=V;BG8<>S6 VYNF46N M H>[email protected]?CbV6<[NBGf?CN r/[email protected]=V; <[N GJ 68=<2H>[email protected]?Cbc6< SE AC47 N <>[email protected]<[N
NAC<>4a-=c;'a'<><=8N=68<>[email protected] ?C<[=cN ;9? Lu E E G=E N'=NÈH[<ƒAC<°H NE<>N =S N94=–G8<°[email protected]<°;'H[bc46˜s= Jr/<><[[email protected]>AC<„;/68N 7 4< =VOS; ?KJ/ J ] .01 Q<>=8=<>a-?C<[N ? A <
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
# ω(G
K1 ≡K2 ) − ω(G)
ω(GK1 ≡K2 ) − ω(G)
ω(G)
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
G
v2
K2
ω(GK1 ≡K2 )
GK1 ≡K2
K1
K2
GK1 ≡K2
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
v1
C
G
G
v2 ∈ C 1
G
C
C1
v1
v1
C1
K1
K1
v2
K2
V (K1 ) ∪ V (K2 )
v1 v2
C1
C1
v2
v1
K1 ∪ K 2
ω(GK1 ≡K2 )
GK1 ≡K2
2
K1
K2
K
! ' U] 1 $ G - 1 $ $ + . K K 1- *. #- 1 1 + . 1 1 ω(G) G .0 1
2
|K1 |+|K2 | 6=
Z 68383k4N 4=N |K |+|K | = ω(G) ? iB<>a^E 7 bV64=N%GJ E :k47 G-bV6<GJ E 387j[T N
S
O
K
?
/
J
?
AC<’AC<>a-? a' < =S\ =˜S”O GS ω(G
) = ω(G) R AI<[N/;H>A\E [email protected]J E 68;/7 <’3E 7/;bV6< α(G
)≤
S
J
@
?
&
>
[
?
J
E
8
3
j
7
T
[
£
N
C
A
°
<
/
;
W
[
O
4
j
7
>
T
'
a
<
S
4
Y
=
E
α(G)
< |V (G)|
L E 7'G8OW\ [email protected];/?C4=˜S%; 46N AC<[N N 46N MKD7FE 38W<[N-G8< α(G)ω(G)
?u 4=HSGJ E 387jT[N
G N 4=V; 3E 7 eKE [email protected]; N
ACH[<Q4a-;/Wa'O[4< 7j>T a'<[< N/;{OS3?KJE k 7/S5;/[email protected]; ;/4?C64=8N+=AC<[E N°:8ACN <4S86<>N =ƒKM D7F7FE E ?C38N 4W=„<[N°G8G8<B< A\E G M H>[email protected]?Cbc6< NF4=V;+3E 7 egE [email protected] ; bVN 68?$?5L =˜4J 68<[N/7/;{;FE 3=VE; N S
638=ENÄ<£3H>[email protected] ?C7/bc;/[email protected];/<£?C4G8=8< =GE :8H ACE< 7?<LKE 7<>AC;<BK;/WO[4N 47j>T=Va'; =< 4JS='[email protected]>/;/> 7/[email protected]?\=#E AC<>ω<>=ƒa'G8<>=VO[;ÄGf68<>[email protected];K=bc<>6˜a-∪J [email protected]?CA”<[KN<[ N S ;’G3E 7 eKE [email protected]; ? _=˜J <[E N/?C;N
4H[4==c;/E 7 <[α(G
[email protected];ÈAC<°;/WO[4)ω(G
7j>T a'< [email protected]>&[S? ) ≤ α(G)ω(G) < |V (G)| = |V (G )| H[<'bc682?
u J E 387j[T N’AC<£AC<>a-a'<£387 O[H[O[G8<>=V; SIN/? K <>; K N 4=c;’G8<>6SV H>[email protected]?Cbc6<[N’<>=8=<>a-?C<[NÄGJ 68=
D7FE 38W<°[email protected][email protected]^E A [email protected] 7 egE [email protected]; G SE AC47 N9G8<>6SV H EN9N <+387 O[N <>=c; <>=V; ]
>/? |K | + |K | < ω(G)
u E =N H[<£H EN·S 4= 3k<>68;%7 <>a^E 7 bV6<>7¢bc6<AC<[N¢E 7 >; <[N bV6<AKJ 4=^EG/r 468; <<>= 7 <>[email protected]?\E =c;
1
2
K1 ≡K2
K1 ≡K2
K1 ≡K2
1
1
K1 ≡K2
2
K1 ≡K2
K1 ≡K2
K1 ≡K2
1
1
2
2
2
. /O
=
<
>
H
7
[
O
>
<
V
=
9
;
E
6
>
H
8
6
=
<
M H>[email protected]?CbV6< G? Jl E 387jT[N{AC<ÈAC<>a-a'< OS?KJ/OS?Su <[email protected] SIH[<[N
E 7 >; <[N9=<°G8O>;/Z 7/68?CNF<>=V; E 6H>68= M N/;FE :8AC< < egE [email protected];£a'O>7/[email protected]; <m68=<+387 <>68LM<^]
8
6
8
3
5
3
4
N
4
=
{
N
>
<
1
=
c
L
6
B
<

G
J
8
6
=
+
<
[
H
4
V
=
/
;
F
7
E
f
G
C
?
>
H
/
;
C
?
4
=
c
b
˜
6
J
4
1
=
8
G
>
O
/
;
/
7
8
6
@
?
{
;
8
6
=
M
?
N/;FE :8AC<ÄG8< bc68?˜<>N=m47=V<>;[email protected]?\GE E=V=; NÈ68= <>;H[<>7/;FE [email protected]= Ac<WVfM ?CN N/;F; E <Ä:8E AC<AC47 N?<G8u <>6SJ E Vm387jN T[4N£a-A\a'E <>H[;4N =H>[email protected]/?C4= <>e ;
Gf6ª;/WO[4j7 T>a'?/u < J [email protected]>&j7 J T[N’S [email protected]\AE+W< G8VfWO ?C\N/;=8<#[email protected];/?CG844=^=G8H^<[68N =D< 7FE 38M WH><[[email protected]?CN’bV36E< 7/;/[email protected];/?C4Gf=8?CN =r/4E [email protected]:8=VAC;<[<1N S G8< ? 35Z <>[email protected];;
>;/7 <3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=O <>= N/;FE :8AC<[N G8<;FE [email protected]@AC< ? (È6ha'[email protected]=NÈAKJ 68=`G8<mH[<[N N/;FE :8AC<[N
?
u =J 4E ; 384j7 =T[NNÈA\ACE^< H[4=2H><[[email protected]/; N/?C4Gf=?CN r/4< [email protected]£=V;-Gf6`G8< ;/WO[4Sj7 HT>Ea'7 < [email protected]>&J S”4H[=`4=cNF;/E [email protected]<>;B=V; bV6< N 4a-?pa'u <>4; =N H
4=-E9;/7 <>4=68LMG8O{4G=8E ==E N =c; # 68=QN 4<>a-; a'<>; A\E„;a <>Af>a'bc6˜<ƒJ 4H[=246838AC68<>?C68N 7NF<ÄS GfH[4?CNFAC44=7/?CN2<>7¢7 446838DM;/[email protected]< a^? E l AC<>4a'a-<>a'=c<;
S
@
?
’
A
W< VI?CN ; <-68=<'H[468AC<>687 Gf?CNF4=N:8AC<>6 +bc68?¢=˜J <[N/;3EN
?
L
68G8;/<[email protected]@A\?CEN O[38<+7 <>G68E LM=<ÈN Gf6#;/WO[4j7 T>a'<E 7{OS68?KJ=„k ScO[4H W=^E 3k=8<>DM68<+;’:8;/?C7 HF4W8687 LM4<>a^7E 68;/=?CbV<È6H[<4?CACG847F<>E=V;/;/?C?C4bc=ƒ6< G8<#QH[<>[email protected]?
bcO[H 68W?V4G864<=8S=7F< E A\38E£3kH[<>4AC468=AC<>N 687bV6˜7 4J 468=ªDM< ;/7# 468LM<><1;˜68A\E£=ªH[HF4W68<>AC<>[email protected] =:8NFAC<>467/;F< E # =V;-G8 <^N/?MAC684=8=D; 6<><>Ac68O[7H W3E E [email protected] <<
7G8<><>[email protected] ?\E V#=V;H[4AC47FE <>;/;?C4=N9GfH[!? O<1>bV7 <>68=V?{; <[<[N/N£;-G8H[< 4=V;/7FEGfSI?CH>H[;< [email protected] 68< ?k ?H[[email protected];/=7 E <[ACGf<>[email protected]';£<>A\EQ=c; H[S 44==H>[email protected]/?C;/47 = 468 LMD O Gf6„;/WO[47jT>a'< [email protected]>&JS?
u 4=HS”bc6E =G`4=h7 <>[email protected]?C< # S”4=hDVE 7 G8<268=`D7FE 38W<m3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=8=E :8AC<S<>;
4=„=<°[email protected];93ENBE 383E 7FEGFC;/7 <mG8<H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4= ?
K1 # K2
ω
α
α
G
K1
v1 ∈ K 1
K2
v2 ∈ K 2
α
S
ω
K
S
G\v
v ∈ V (K)
ω
S0
α
K\v
K
G
G\v
v1
|K1 | + |K2 | < ω(G)
K1 ∪ K 2
ω−1
S0 = S
v
v2
G\v
v1
K1
v2
K2
G\v
2
K1
K2
JS? |K | + |K | > ω(G)
u E =NÈH[<H EN·S<>= 7 <>[email protected]?\E =c; K # K 4=`4:8;/?C<>=V;B68=YD7FE 38W<2E LM<[H68=<2H>[email protected]?CbV6<
a^; 4EG6fV N£[email protected] <[68N£a N 4668Ni=8KM ?CDbV7F6E <#38W] <[KN9O>;F∪E =VK;£3? E l 7 eK<mE [email protected]; 7FN E [email protected]W<<[N/=˜;{J 3O>;FE E 7 =VegE ; [email protected]; 3?<Eu N9E 3=E N97/;/H[[email protected]<+;/?C4H =8EN£=E 4:8=„AC<3SkE <>7 ;M
LI=?C<°<>=VN <>;%a2G8:84=AC<H LM#[email protected] E 3838W3<£E 7FEEGN CFN ;/<)7 ’h < <W?Vf? ;/?7FE[LE DVE =V; SNTE =Nbc6˜J E 6H>68=<H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4=
A <°AC<>a-a'<2N/[email protected] =c;B<>;ÈNF4=YH[47 [email protected]\E [email protected] <ma'4=c;/7 <>=V;+bV6<mN/? K <>; K N 4=c;B<>=8=<WM
a-H W?CE <[=N2H[G< E G=N2J >;/687 =<„D<>=87FE =38<>Wa-<#?C< 3EG87/< ;/[email protected];/?C4=8? =X E 4:86AC<N-S =˜E JACE 4LM7 4NQ=68N-=3<^EN N-46;/7N 4M H>[email protected]?CbcO„6G<1J E G838< [email protected]?CH E ;/E„?C43k= <>6#`G8H[<<
35<>;/[email protected];{eKE [email protected]; S83k<>68; M >;/7 <°:54=$# H[K4=8=EGCF ;/7 <ma^E [email protected] O°; 468;m]
! ' ] K K 1- *. #- $+ .0 1
2
1
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
* - 1 G $ - - *. #- 1 * K K & 1 3. . G - $.0 *- .0 1
2
K10
1
K10
ZZ [email protected];
a^bV6EG< [email protected]^E AC< ? [email protected]; 68=1NF4<[a-N/;-a'68<><>=y;; bc<>6=<>N AC<>H[a24=:8bVAC< 6=<+G4JG8E=ˆ< 7/;/7 ?C<>H>[email protected]?CO[A\E N ;/?C [email protected]=ACN W< Vf?CG8N/;O[<>?[H =c4jB;=8=#S9=<[HLH>E E;F7 E a'=V4; =c;/7<[<><>N/;7;
? L 4687H[<>A\EfS4=`LMO>7/?N\<-bc6<Q; 468;°H W<>[email protected]= 7 <>[email protected]?\E =c; # NTE =N+3 EN N <>7 3E 7
H[4=V;/?C<>=V;B68= LM4?CN/[email protected]= G8< Gf?!kO>7 <>=c;BG8< ? =h< k<>;]
2
a ∈ K10
b ∈ K2
V (K1 ) \ V
c
{a} ∪ N (a) \ {c}
b
P
a
c
c
(K10 )
G
b
K2
c
K1
k
Z ? =<°H[4=c;/?C<>=V;+E 6H>68= lN 4a-a'<>;ÈG8< SE AC47 N <[N/;9G8<+AC4=8D6<>687È[email protected] [email protected] <
HGE E 7 =N+A\E#<>H; WEGFC=N<-4G8=c;<Q<>AC=84=8=D<>a-6<>?C68<[N7°? 3E [email protected]< a'< <>; SkN <>4;°=VH[; <><>;/=8; <=<>H[a-47 ?CG8<[N <QSÆ[email protected]!<>[email protected]?C<mE9eg684=7 H[<O>H[a'47<>G8=V<;
<>;9Z 68? = N 4a-H[4a'=c;/<>?C;È<>=VG8;#< 68=–SN H[4<°a-bVa'6˜<>J 4;^=YG8LM< 468A\E S¢[email protected];9E a'AC447 N'=V;/H[7 <„<>7 NF? 4a-a'<>;'<[N/;-=O[H[<[N NFE [email protected] <>a'<>=c;
ACAC<14=8LMD46?C<>N/[email protected]=–[email protected]< 3E [email protected] E<ƒ=H N E 7 S bV6<><1; AKJ 4=N=44=V; ;Q< <>=8? =jB<>a-=?C<[LMN [email protected];'u E 4AC=4H#7 N'A\E bV6HF<WEGFC=< <[N/;-G8<
<[N 4N/;°a-G8a'<Q<>AC;B4G8=8<D6<>687° H[3<>E ;/[email protected]; 7 <<SH[4<>;°7 G8<><°=3kH[4<>768< ;È68G=J E <[email protected]@e AC4<>68?CN 7 SkN 4>= ;/7 ;/< 7 468LM < ? 68=< H[47 G8<-G8< LM<>7 N+68=
P∗
K1
K2
K2
(a, c, . . . , b)
K2
P∗
a
P∗
K2
b
P
c−P −d
(a, c, . . . , d)
a
2
d
K1
K2
P∗
P
K10
ad
*5G* , ;4 :' ] ' K K 1- *. #- 1 . * - 1 G $ 1. $ K - - *. #- 1 * +! # K 0. K K 1 1 1
2
0
1
l A\E [email protected]ÈGJ E 387jT[NÈAC<+;/WO[47jT>a'< [email protected]>&Q
LI3k6`<>=G8jBN <><Q=-7ÄA\NE#3k68<>H[[email protected]; 7=s<Èr7 <[<>A\H>a^E°;/68aE 77 >bc< a'6OS<>< ?K7’JSG8>/bVO>?6a^<E =¡AC<{7 H < ACW<><<+a->;bVa'S56<£35<B4H>H[68?N<>M 7 [email protected]<B<[38N 7 bcN 466868N?5LME°=˜<>7J e <[4N/H[=;%<>H>;/3;/; E?C< 4N =8G8;/=<>7jOB7/T[=8N 3k?U<>T>4=7 68<H[7ÄS5468G847FO[= EH[DM43ka-< 4E 683k=V7/4;{7FNE <><>[email protected]= ;7
DACbc<[7F6N2E < 38DW7FE<Q38H[GW4J <[=c68N2;/=?C<2G8<>=V< N ;1680{:5G8<>Gf<[7/[email protected]<YH>?CN/[email protected]?C]?C4bc4=`6=ª<[:8N'H[[email protected]<>a-E=87/=a';/<>?C<2a-<>=G8?CH[<[< <^N ? 3jBE 7Q=?pu N/3k68J <>E3868383k;'j7 4T[NE N <>AC724AC<27 bcN'AC6<><[<a-N/3ka'O><7 H[<>4OS72=c?KJ/eK;/E [ ?C<>[email protected]”7 =V< [email protected]; A <[DN/7 ; [email protected]>N [email protected]/A\[email protected]< [email protected]
HH[[4<[N1=c;/H>[email protected][email protected]?C6bV<>67-<[N E [email protected] =6N/N ?ÄbcE[6˜LMJ #¡<[H';/AC7 <[4N68LM38<>7/71?CN/a'68=<[<YN S˜338E [email protected]?C7 N <`Sk68G8=<h< H>[email protected]?C4bc?C6N<[bVN16<><'=8AC=<[<>N°a-38?C7/<[?CN1N/a'G8<[< NmNF4? =VjB;m=rW< V83kH>[email protected]<>668N ; S
38a'4=–j7 4T[=cN <[;/N/7? ;'<1? ?bc bc6S6E<><^N/;[email protected]'H[4<>=´<>;/=c; <#35;'<>?C7F68G8E ;QO[a'<#<[O>N/7/=35?CNOO>bV7 6#<>7m<1G8;/G8<[7 N<'468D=LM7F<#<>E 7m383WE68<[Nm=N^<'e 4:[email protected] H>[email protected];/E 7 ?C7/<#4;/=8?CGNF=E J <>E =7 a-N S%?CH NgEE ?.7Q6SA [email protected]<'A G8ACH´<>4a-68E :8a'G8AC<W<^<[M N GfH>?\N?HFEM WG8a^E <[=ENF=VN/H[6<[; NNN
bcG86˜<[N£J 4D=#7FE 383868W?CNF<[N NÈ<È;/37 4E3YNÄeKN/E [email protected][email protected] < 38AC<[DN 7 4 NFH[N/<>[email protected]ƒCbc<[N{68?˜H>[email protected]?CbV=V6;B<[68N{=<><°=8O>=; <>[email protected]<?C<[NGSIJ E 47/6ƒ;/?CEH>AC684A\7 E N{;/?CN 4<>= 68 AC?<>a'<>=c;9GE =N
1
0
1
2
2
G
F
K4
F
G
u E =N 68=€E 7/;/?CH>AC<ªH[4=NFEH>7 OªE 6SV)3E 7/;/[email protected];/?C4=N`E =c;/?CNiHca'O>;/7/?Cbc6<[N E/E S9XAC47/?\E =
iÈ[email protected]=6< N ? N l <>A£<{<>AC<>; a-L a'W8<[email protected]@[email protected]'383k4<=c;/iÈ7 <È68bc:86?C4¡<£G4=VJ 68;'=^38H[7 <>O[7/N ;F<>E [email protected];=^O [email protected]=V;’AC<>G8a-<{a'LI6< <GSJACE <[38N¢3<>E=7 NF<><>=amH[:8<`AC<[EN{N N E <)=VhY;/?CEH[=4=S4MM
=G8<W<-fV ; <[<>N9a-G83<[NQN9DE 387FE 7j38[T N·WS˜<[NÈH[<'G8<AC<>a-0{<>a'7/DM<1<E N <°O>; H[O-4a-7 <[3kG84O[7/H[;4<>68=VLM; <>7/H[;[email protected]=a'G8O><m35G8<><=GN [email protected]'AC<[<>N9=c;N 43a-E a'7m<>AK;J O[N bc?468L [email protected]<>6 <
G;/8?C< N O L ACE <68A Z <)!IH a'4168- .7 . 1<>=ƒH[[email protected]\E <>:k=47F7FE E ;/?C?CN 44=Y=E[G8LM<[<[NmH E l 38E 387 [email protected] ?CH; <>E = ;/?C4* =WN24ama^[email protected] ;/N [email protected]<>38= AC<[ N2S8bcbV686˜?”J [email protected] [email protected] 68<>?¢:4E =V3S;M
;/387 684:[email protected]?CO-O[<[ACNÈ<>68G7E =38N£7 <>A\68EQLM38<^7 <>Gf686´LM<2AC<>a-Gf6„a';/<W O[? 4X 7j>T 4a'6<°N°eg=447/6;9NmG8O><[; N£<>D=7FGfE 7 384W=<[NmN9683=E 7 35eKE<>[email protected]; N N/68 [email protected]£Gf=˜?!kOJ 4>=c7 <>;9=c3; E<[NN
a^N/?C4E ==8N ?U>T 387 [email protected]<[6NÈN G8eg<°47/38; 7<[4N’68GfLM6#<>7+AC<>H[a-<°a'AC<><9a-3ka'468<°7’[email protected]<[3kN’4H>7/A\;FEE NF=VN ; <[? N BX 34E 67/;/NÈ?CH>O>[email protected]?U>T =7 H[<[<>N 7 4 D=7FN E 38<>=WN <[68NÄ[email protected]; <J)(BG87/<[; N9O>a-LM<>?C7N M S
DG87F<[E N938H[W4<[7 [email protected]\E <[email protected] _`<[NÈ<)bccH 68=8??C<>=AKS46DNÈ7FE N 38<>W7 4<[=cN2;[email protected];/:[email protected]<[<>NBa'E <>6=c;-HFW;/7/E ?\38E [email protected]=8;/D7 <m68ACN/O[[email protected] L? E BX =V;4? 6NQ; <>7/[email protected]=<>7 4=N 3E 7
"
Z ? <[N/;Ä68=1<>=N <>am:8AC<+G8< N 4a-a'<>; NGJ 68=#D7FE 38W< [email protected];{bV6˜J 68=1N 4a-a'<>;
<[E N/7 ;>; <2 G8*,4=c; .AC<[%N+N/G8? <>6SVhLM4<[email protected];%;/; 7 4O>6a-N%[email protected]; <[O[N N+N N 44a-=V;a'<>; M N H[4G8a-< 38AU?T>;jB<[='N ? E Rd38A 3k<[<>N/[email protected]; AC< ;/7/[email protected] ?\E ,A%bcÈ6G8<S”< GE =; 4N 6868; = <
DD7F6E <>3868W79<[email protected]<3E 0{[email protected] <>< 7/DMg<E S”6„N/a'? 684=`[email protected]=NFN 4O a- Sa'E <>AC;47 NBLMH[4<°[email protected]; N 4ACa-<[NBa'<WVf<>;È;/7 G8O>[email protected];[email protected]; LMO[[email protected]7ÈJ E686Y=`a'HFW4<>[email protected]=N£[email protected]= 68=YN G84a-<2ACa'4=S<>;M
G8 < ) . . B7FG8E < 383k<>ACAC<[4NÄ=NNQ4bV66N M< H W<>[email protected]=O[NN/[email protected]<=<'[email protected]=c4;=VO>;7/?CAC<><[68N’7-<WVfG8;/< 7 O>a-? [email protected]; O[N¢=´LMeg4E [email protected]<>; =VS; N/?’4<>;’=ªG8E 438=V3k;Ä<>[email protected]<[AC<N
NgE46'a-Na'<>=<>; N¢[email protected]<[=VN’; O>E 7/7 ?C><>; 68<[7 N N° Sa^bcE6=<{bcAC6<[N <>[email protected]=c; ; <>S57/L4E =¡[email protected]<[LMNÄ[email protected] ;+4=Vbc;’6<G8<{AC4N=8<2D63<>E 687/;/7Ä[email protected];/[email protected]=87 =<£<'46^<>= G8<{[email protected]=VAC; 4<>=87/DL6E [email protected]<>AC68<[N7
> Sc<>;G84=H bc6< 3k4N NjT[G8<968=1=4am:87 <[email protected] [email protected]{G8< MdE 7 >; <[N ?SA <BeKE a'<>6SV'AC<>a-a'<
383G8A\<E E7°H[iÈO-7F4E 6338NE 35NF7°4<>7/A68; =<>;È#1<>i9=A\E„68N <>:838am?C7 4#<>:868AC<[<1LMN/;9<'E 68=V4;/=7/[email protected]<mH[[email protected]==8O>E==ACW< O><^V87FE<[email protected]?CNF?¢E ? N ;/O>X?C434=`E 67FG8NE [email protected]<m;mG8H[4G8<°=8O =reKE#[email protected]=;mACN<[]8N68AC<mH=E< NFN438a-7 <>a'68<>LM; <^N/N/;[email protected]<[Ea-N/:8;938AC<[email protected] N?-<<>\a O[><;M
T
G
T
x
T
x
T
G
T
t
P∗
P
P∗
P
P
P
t
t
P
{t}
P
t
T
G[T ]
! "$#%&('*)
/Q
6 . =
4
´
=
N
F
;
E
8
:
C
A
?.A E 387 <>a-?UT>7 <^N/[email protected]@?N\H E ;/?C4=ª387 4 LI?C<>=V; GJ 68=<'7 < eg47/am68A\E ;/?C4=
<
G8<£3kA\E4N H[Nj4T[=G8H><[email protected]/=¡?C4=N 4a-: a'%Gf<>6#; AC<>Ma-H[4a'a-<38]AC<>A #°; 4'#=4iÈ64N°6O[N H>N 7/<>[email protected]<>4;Ä=N°i968AKJ :8EN?C4N <>O[7/H>;/7/[email protected]=¡E ?C38<>[email protected]=V6; N egA 4<97/; HF<ƒW<>] a-A [email protected]= <
H=˜FWJ E <>La-E [email protected][email protected]=;9O>LI?CG8H[<>4a-a-a'3k4<>7/=V; ;9<1368E=ªN{O[=HF4Wa2E 38:8357 <[email protected] a-6ƒ3DE 7 [email protected]'68G83k< < G8< MdE Z 7 )<>HI; <[a'N 4? 68l7 Sf<#357<><>7/=fa'eg4<>;£7 H[G8<><+a'Gf<>=V?CN/; 3kS¢4bcN 68<>7 ?
38G7J 68<>=68X LM<m4<9W6G8HIN+<£35384G87 ;/O>44W ;F3kT[E [email protected]<2N N¢4G8eg=E<NN ;/7 E ?CO[6GfH>N?C68<>N/7/6S? 7 VkG8<>=S<>=S6H[<m4Vh;Fe E=4a-47/a'68a'LM<><><>[email protected][email protected]<>;’<[a'N+3k<>384=c687 ;+<>7 6838ACLM<£[email protected]<[H NN£Eeg35N¢4447/68;' <7+SACH[< <H bcE=˜68N ?J <[G8N/; O>:3E E7/N¢7FN/EN/;F;FEN E NF:8:8<AC<ACA\< FSE ?
38( [email protected]/6E N„? N/[email protected] 3k384cAC<[4N 7 S #+=7/?C4N/;/;/7 [email protected]=<¡E E[LI?C6N„bcM4·6Lc<h? ƒA\E<>;^387 P <>68?\ELMH[< 4a'47/4 [email protected][email protected]=E a2AC< :5? <>[email protected] [email protected]? E38>&[/7 <>R a-S%U? H[T><ƒ7 <¡G8<[<>N/7/;„=8?C<>Gf7 6< a'#<
AKH[J 4&E a-HVE 38=V;F;-E DME <£[email protected]^3EE :87’ACA\<>E9a'eg4<>=V7/am;-68H[AC4<Èa-Gfam6'68H>=87/[email protected]?C:8bcAC6<9O[G< ?E =RdA’N¢E„G8<[G8N%O[:8H[[email protected]<>[email protected]/4;Q=AKN¢J E =7/4D=-68a'3868<>=V:8;[email protected]?CO[ENÄN/;/G86< H>?C<>S6E 35V´4IG84<7
<><>;; N J 6<[N/;2M4·7 Lc<>?=YGf6ªH[4H[=4H[a-<>7/38=; E <1=V;ƒbV6G8<1<[N H[<>7 ;-<[H E W7/<>D7 68H Wa'<[<>Nƒ=V;N/68357-4AC68<ƒ[email protected]<>;m;/; 38407 HV<[E NFDMbV<Y6<1G8<[NFEN-=;/NQ7 4H 6WN'E [email protected]<>3a'E <>[email protected] =VN ; S
NE J6E N 38N [email protected]=?Cbc46;/7<><+7Ä38E 6'7 4H 38E7 N <dN38/;F7 E<>:868ACLM< <°£GG8f<°6-H[AC<<>a-H Ea'N <9G8<£iB4N/6;FN E N :8<>ACA8<<>FS;¢fa'[email protected]:8=?CN94 ? N X35<[4H>6;FN%EH>38687 A\O[E N [email protected]<>7 =V<; S8<>a^7 4E =?CNN
bc68?E 3k<>68; M >;/7 <bV6<>ACbc6<[N£a'O>7/[email protected]; <[NBG84=V;9AC<°AC<[H>; <>687 r 68DM<>7FE ?
G[T ]
P
T
P
T
G[T ]
G[T ]
"
G[T ]
! + 2 *$-.%0%&of# -698 * @ =p=
G - 1 T
- 11. + $ G P - *1 G 1. - G[T ] 11 *, T 11 V (P ) . P T *, . .0 - 1 T , P .0 - 1-/ ,+ - 1, $ $ T 1 P .0 - 1-/ $ $ - *
. P 1 .0 - 1-/ $ , - 1 1- , - . .
0
.
1
1
$
* $
P = x−x −· · ·−y −y
T
u v 1. - N (u) ∩ V (P ) = {x, x , y} N (v) ∩ V (P ) = {x, y , y} P 1 .0 - 1-/ 3 1- $ 1 1-/ .01 1
- *11 .0 - 1-/ $ $ . 1 - 11 T 0
0
0
0
? Z ? <[N/; G8<
j
B
=
8
G
>
O
'
a
4
c
=
/
;
7
£
<
C
A
{
<
C
A
>
<
a
'
a
{
<
3
E
%
7
7
[
O
>
H
8
6
/
7
7
>
<
=
[
H
9
<
/
N
8
6
7
ACbc46=8<mD6AC<m<>68AC<>7 a-a'S < 4<[6 N/;ÈS[LIAK7FJ 68E =?<¢N ? G8<[N˜H[4=H>[email protected] ?C4=NgE? 5jB4=`6 35 : <>68;+<[N/G8;˜4NF=E ;/H2?CN N eK68E [email protected]; 35<4S NH[<><¢7 bcbV686?< a'4=V;/<[7N/<;
GG88<[<£N-AC4H[=84D=6H><>[email protected]/7£?C4E =6'N a' [email protected]=<>N ; ? G jBm=^==<ƒ4N; 4< [email protected];-NFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected]; < ? l <[N-H[4=?H>[email protected] 668N/38?C435=4N NF4==<ƒN’N bc<>6˜7 4J E =c6;-H>683=E<N
=7 O[4H>=687/387 [email protected]<>6=N'H[<NTS5E 4;/?C=hN egNFE E [email protected]; [email protected];<[N bV63k<468357-468687B=–; N 44686; N M <>=S”NFN <>4am6N:8M AC<>< =NG8<>< a2:8AC?<2u N/;/47/=?CH>H;BS%3<>; E 7-E =VW ;/HI?CH[3544=8;/=4W W<T[V8NF<< G8G8<<
SG8< [email protected] ?H jBE-=h68Gf=Y?CN/=;/[email protected]=8a2D:867<<2G8G8<>< S6 V„HMdEE7N>]; <[N GE =N bV68?E-a >a'<3E 7/[email protected]; OQbc6<A\E AC4=8D6<>687
.
*, .0 Z ? <[N/; G8<#AC4=8D6<>687
3AC4E [email protected]<6S£<>6847#=)[email protected]´a-3:8E ?C<>[email protected]=ˆ< ? A\E´jB=yH[4=GfH>?CN/[email protected];/[email protected]/=8?CD46= < gG8E <>?6SVu 4N =46H¡N M4H = EN^35bV<>6868;ƒ?9H[N/468=38Gf3k684?CN N <><>7„=c;^bV6; 4< 68;'G8<[<>N/6S;„V G8#<
G8<[N9H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4=N ]
|V (P )∪T |
0 1
P
2
3
|V (P ) ∪ T | ≤ 4
P = x−x0−· · ·−y 0−y
P
T
U
T
U
P
P
T
P∗
P
P
fe
6
y0
x0
y
x
u
v
T
y0
x0
y
x
T
y0
x0
y
x
T
CAXB<>a-4u 6a'EN =<E N9LMG8AC4<<°=iB38N„7 4<>7 6<>a-N 38N ?C7 <><>O[A˜7 N S”<><>;94=c=h; i9OE68;/:8A\7 E-?C44-?CH[NƒN·4J =EDH>[email protected]@N ?CW?CbV4<[6=N <'G8 ] H< £0{<>;È<>7/AC<°DM<¡D7F4 E 'ˆ38WAC<<
<>u =VE ;/=?C<>N7BAC<Ä<[N/G8;£<>68S6 =VfU? T>38a'7/?CN/<a'S4<°[email protected]ÈA\3EBE H[[email protected] 4=E[H>[email protected]<[6H N/?CR 4= NF4 a-G ˜a'<><>;%; ACN <Ä? D7FE 38W<
<>u =VE ;/=?C<>NY7BAC<[<N/;£;/687 4=h?CN/E U? T>=Va';/[email protected];/<ª7 4D6 7FE E[38LMW<[<H S+R 4=€N 4a-Era'N/[email protected]<>am; N 68? [email protected];FE =O>a'<>=c;A\E
H[<[4N/;£=H>[email protected]= 6N/?C4= ? H <>;{A\EQH[4=H>[email protected]/?C4= G ?<A < D7FE 38W<<>=c;/?C<>7
C6
&! #&% [email protected]> A <>a-a'<2G8<iÈ46N NF<>Ak<>;Bi968:8?C4„]8Gf?!O>7 <>=V; N H EN ?
/R
6 . T ! - &- 1 .0 ,1- /- ,1.$. jB=
a^ E 17 bc 6.<^$.0AC{<[N2; 4N 684;a-N 4a'6<>Ni; M NQH WG8<>< [email protected]=-bcG868< ?Ä4SÆ=cG8; <’E AC64=8a'D64<>[email protected]=7¢NmE 686Q=a'[email protected]?C=N/[email protected] => GS G8E =4=VN ;%TAC<[? NjB<WVI=ª;/7 E O>[email protected]<>; [email protected][AC<N
P
N<>4; =c;+N a^4=cE ;È7 bVa^6O[E <[7 N+bc6<>O[;°N G8S4AC<[=VNB;[email protected]=V<[; N+<>7/N L4E [email protected]'<[N+<>;G8N < [email protected]=V; O>e 7/4?C7/<>a'687 <>N=c;BNF468=V=; <m=34E =`7/;/a^[email protected];/E?C47 =`bc6G8O[< N ?$L 68gE?CN 6hbc6N <>< =N
G8<[NÈX E 7 4>6; N£<[N 38 7 ? O>; <>=G84=NBbV6<HFWEbV6<[email protected]=V; <>7/LE [email protected]<G8< <[N/;9G8<+AC4=8D6<>68793E [email protected] <m46YG8<
ACa'[email protected]=6N <>68O 7 =>/4? ; l O E 7 N/68383k4N 4=NBbc6˜J [email protected] LMHY<[H E [email protected];B68Gf=h6'[email protected] =c;; <>O£7/LG8E < [email protected]<Q<>G8; <2AC4=8GfD6'6H <>;687BO£[email protected]< 3E ? [email protected] Z < [email protected]; E 6
[email protected]== [email protected];?CN/[email protected]= =mG8;/7 < [email protected] 3=E N [email protected] ?Gu <>;4=H 68=QLM4?CN/? [email protected]=-Z ? G8< GE =E NAC47 N ? Z ? E AC47 N [email protected][email protected];68=
;/G87 <46NTE [email protected];/a-?CN 3egE E [email protected][email protected] 7 <+?pA\u E 4H[=4H =H>[email protected] ?C4= ?< Hu <°]8a68=><°a'H[<4S =c;/7FEGf?CH>;/??C4_`= ? E ?CNÈE AC47 N <>; 3k<>7/a'<>;/; <>=V;
L 68?CN bV6< <[N/;{G8<ÈAC4=8D6<>687£[email protected] [email protected] <[email protected]$A H#E68=1=4am:87 <[email protected] [email protected]£GJ [email protected]=c; <>7/LE [email protected]<[N
G84=c<2;ÄAC468=8=#DLM64<>?C68N/[email protected]=#H[?$4u a-<[email protected]=ƒN·GSE 3k=4N 687 ?HFWl EE H>768N/= [email protected]=G84<Q=˜H[SV<[[email protected][email protected]; =V; <>7/LE [email protected]<[LMN 4?CN/[email protected]=1G8< a^S E =bV<>6; E =c;
[email protected]=Gf%68<>[email protected];;°68= ;/7 46 S [email protected]?CN/[email protected]=–[email protected] G8?,< u 4=H a^E =bc6E =V?; u <2? a Z >? a'<S E AC4? 7 _ N E ?CNE AC47 N <>;
3k<>7/a'L 4<>;/68; 7 <>=V; ;468G8; <NFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected] =<+A\=E 4;H[<4=H>[email protected]/?CAK4J <>= =N H<>°a2]f:868AC<#=<G8<[H[N 4=V;/7FEMdGfE ?C7 H>>;/; ?C<[4N-= ?G8< ? jB==4; <
AC<[N°O>ACO><[a'N ;¢<>=VAC<£; Nm=4G8am< :87 <B? jBG[email protected]=VNT; E<>7/[email protected];+LE G[email protected] E<[NÄ38j7 G8T[<9NmACH[4<-=8DbV668<>?%68387 7 >O[H G8T[< G8<'bc? 6l < <£=4am:87 <
<[N/;£[email protected] [email protected] <>;£3E 79A\E2eg47/am68AC<mGf6 H>7/[email protected]:8AC<m4=hEƒ]
x
y
P
P
P
P 0 = x00−· · ·−y 00
x00
x y 00
y
u
00
00
0
x
T v
y
T
u=v
V (P )∪{u}
u 6= v
x00 6= x0
V (P 0 )∪{u, x, v}
x00 = x0
y 00 = y 0
u v
P
1
T
y 00
v ∈ T
y 00
x00
x00 = x0
t ∈T
t1 , t 2 , . . . , t α
f (t2 ) ∪ · · · ∪ f (tα )|
x00 −P −y 00 x00
y 00
00
u∈T
x
x00 6= x0
{x, u, x00 , y 00 , v}
y 00 = y 0
u
v
{t}
f (t)
T
|f (t1 ) ∪ f (t2 ) ∪ · · · ∪ f (tα )| =
P
|f (t1 ) ∪
P
X
|f (ti )|
i
−
??
X
|f (ti ) ∩ f (tj )|
i6=j
+(−1)(k+1)
??
X
| ∩i∈I f (ti )|
I⊂T,|I|=k
+(−1)(α+1) |f (t1 ) ∩ f (t2 ) ∩ · · · ∩ f (tα )|
L E 7^W!Hc3k4;/W4T[N < 8G <ƒ7 O[H>687/7 <>=H[<SÄ4=yNFE [email protected];'bc6<ƒ354687-; 468; I ( T AC<ƒ=4am:87 <
? u <ƒ[email protected] SAC<ƒ=4am:87 <„G8<ƒ; <>7/a'<[N^[email protected];/?C4=8=O[N^GE =N-AC<
| ∩ f (t )| <[N/; [email protected] [email protected]
a'=4<>=1a2Lc:8?C7 G8<¡<[N{GfG7 4J [email protected]; =ƒG8<><Y=N AK<>J amO>DV:8E [email protected]<[email protected]; EO¡LM<[H>H?NM G8<[N O>N AC6O>a'N„<><[=VN/;;1N O>?SDVuE A 4=# H 2AKJ O>DV−E [email protected][email protected]; O =H>?N4M a2G8<[:8NF7 N/<¡6N’G83k<h<>368E; 7/>;/;/?C<[7 <N
α
J
i∈I
i
7 O[O[H>7/[email protected]; <ma'4cGf68AC4 ]
α
|f (t1 ) ∪ f (t2 ) ∪ · · · ∪ f (tα )| = 2α − 2 + (−1)(α+1) |f (t1 ) ∩ f (t2 ) ∩ · · · ∩ f (tα )|
/E
6
u 4=H |f (t )∩f (t )∩· · · ∩f (t )| <[N ; [email protected] [email protected]’H[<£bV68?fLM<>68;’[email protected] <£bc6< P 3k4N NjT[G8<
68=^M H[=44a-am38:8AC<>7 ;m< ][email protected]=3<E [email protected][7{4G8=V< ;/7FTEGfdM E ?CH>7 ;/>?C; 4<[= N·SV? <>;{G84=HBbc6< P 354NFNjT[G8<BE 61a'[email protected]=N’68=ƒN 4a-a'<>;
T
T !- $ - 1. ,1- Z ? |T | = 1 SVE AC47 N T ∪ V (P ) [email protected][email protected];
68=1;/7 [email protected] [email protected] ?<u 4=H |T | ≥46 2 ? Z [email protected]; t 68= N 4a-a'<>;9G8< ? TX ? 4XB; 446=N9NQ38bV7 6O><; S<>=35G84468=72N9; bV4668<;
N (t) ∩ V (P ) = {x, x , y}
N (t) ∩ P = {x, y , y}
?
t ∈ T SAC<[NÄN 4a-a'<>; N T \ {t}M H[4a-38AC<>; N{G8< P a^E =bc6<>=V; t jB=1E 3835<>[email protected]< . . [email protected]=V< ; O>P7/?C<>; 684687 N+;Äa^NF4E 6=N MbcH 6W<><>=Va-; [email protected]=ƒ?5G8L < 68P?CN bcG864< =V;AC<><[; N’<WfV LM;/74O>?C<>[email protected]; ; O[N’S”LMAC<[4NÈ?C<>[email protected]=c=c;; <>t7/L<>E;’[email protected]<[4N°=V;G8< AC<[N’NFeg44a-7/a'a'<><>=V; ;N
6868==h<^=34a2E 7/:8;/[email protected] ;/<[email protected]=–a-3G8E< [email protected]°PG8<E t6N <>=N G8dM E<[7N-x>;E <[7 N°>; Gy<[NE ?8=Nu J E 68?$;/u t7 <#4=3H2E 7/[email protected]; hH =4E'668N-=`NFE [email protected]=VLM;4<>=7/NPLE [email protected]˜AC< J [email protected]< H´E
=bV64;< O r − P − sE 38bc368E ?’7FE 3k?C4N NN T<>Nj=c[T G8\;<-{t}
6G8E ==N =H[4<>am;+:8477 <1Gf7 [email protected]< a-N/3P68E 7 [email protected] G8? < X T4; \4={t}N+bVdM 6E 7< >; <[N ? Z 68383k<[4N/N ;+4G8=P<N
AC4M=8H[D46x,a-<>6838r,7ÈAC<>s,;QE 61yG8a'< [email protected]=?.N u 2 4H =E H79N/[email protected]=4=˜SIAKJ 68= E 6ƒa'[email protected][email protected]£=PG8Gf<[email protected];Q4686„=´G8;/< 7 4s6ªN <>37Fr−P
EE [email protected][email protected];£<>68; −s
=„N 4a-a'<>;
T
−s
<38[N/7 ;È4cHFG8W<°<mAC4G8=8< D6S<><>68; 7P 3E [email protected]<7 < 38? [email protected] [email protected]; (r7 r4IH−PACW<<mNFG8−s)
4<a-a'? ∪<>X ; {t}4T; 4\={t}
M H[4a-38AC<>;+G8< r−P −sr −P
C
A
°
<
8
3
[email protected]; 6<[NN
È
N
c
b
6
<
[
H
4
c
=
/
;
C
?
>
<
V
=
+
;
;
4
8
6
s
r −P −s
?<u 4=HS
AC3<[E N 7¢TWIH \35{t}4;/W4dM rE[T 7NF><È; G8<[sNÈ<£G87 O[< H>r−P
>
<
£
;
V
b
6
<
[
H
[
<
9
N
E
7
>
;
[
<
£
N
N
4
V
=
£
;
>
<
ƒ
=
=
4
m
a
8
:
7
+
<
@
?
a
3
E
@
?
7
−s
?
<[N/;’<>G8; <9AC4=8D6<>68<[7’N/;Ä[email protected]<9E [email protected] =8< D6jB<>=^687<>=^[email protected][E [email protected] <[email protected]; ?
bVjB6˜=J <WN/V68E38H>35; <>4a'NF<-<>=VG;J E AK:5J 684=#7 GG868<[bc7/N67 H<>< W=<>H[a-<S [email protected]=N −P−s
r−P −r
s −P −s
? =¡3E 7/;/?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 S
[
<
N
m
;
8
G
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
m
7
@
?
a
3
E
@
?
7
<
r −P −r
?
r 6= r <>; x 6= r
Z ? r a^E =bV6< y SVE AC47 N P = r −P −r−t−y <[N ;¢68=^H W<>[email protected]=ƒG8< G G8<9AC4=8D6<>687
[email protected] a-7 >3; E< [email protected]?.7 <Bu G84=4=cH;ÄS3AC<[E N72<WWIV IH;/7 35O>4a-;/[email protected]; [T O[NFN{<#N G84<^=c; 7 TO[H>\687/{t}7 <>=M H[H[4<a-SAK38J 68AU>T =; <1<[N G8? <[jBN27 H[P4=H>=˜[email protected] EN ?C34=ENÄN G8 H< T4\6 {t} G M
<LM[N/4;m?CN/[email protected]=#E ;/G?CN E eK=E [email protected] ; <-3k4687 ?Pu 4=<>; H T \G84{t}[email protected];’LM? 4_`[email protected] E ?CN2SMH[H[<B<>A\bVE 68<[?”N/[email protected];[email protected]@?C3kbV46N < N/[email protected]:8AC<^H E 7 t =˜<>J ; E„3EN2G8< ?
y
s =s=y r =y
Z ? r a^E =Tbc6\< {t}x SVE AC47 N Pr = r −P −r−t−x
[
<
/
N
’
;
8
6
1
=
H
W
>
<
a
[email protected]=„G8< G8<9AC4=8D6<>687
M H[4a-38AU>T ; <[N ? jB7 P =˜J E3GENÄG8< T \ {t}M
[email protected] a-7 >3; E< [email protected]?/7 u <B4G8=4H=cS;Ä3ACE<[7NW!<WIVcH ;/3k7 4O>;/[email protected][T ; N O[<£N{G8N <{4=c7 ;O[H>T687/\7 {t}
NLMFE 4;/?CN/?CN [email protected]=-eKE [email protected]; E <9=3kN 4687 P ?s<>u; T4=\H {t}G8? 4_`[email protected];%[email protected] H[<><>A\E2S=H[H[<[<{<N/SV;bVAK68<>J [email protected][a-<£47 38G8<[email protected]<[[email protected] a-6H[3k<4=4NH>N/[email protected][email protected]:8N/AC?C<4? =H jBN E 7=' HtEÈ=˜4G8J 64Em=3H{G E:8N{?C<[G8<>N/= <;
T \{t}
x
r=x
?u r
N (t) ∩ P = {x, x , y} <9a >a'<ScN/? s −P −s <[N/;G8<9AC4=8D6<>[email protected] [email protected] <SIE AC47 N4=
a'46 4=V;/7 < N (t) ∩ P = {x, y ? , y} ? jB=#E+:8?C<>=#a'4=V;/7 OBbV6< N (t) ∩ V (P ) = {x, x , y}
N (t) ∩ P = {x, y , y}
[email protected]=c; <>=E =V; S”3868?CN bc6< yS<>;%=˜38J <[68N/?C;9N bc36E<N T M =˜H[4J <[a-N ;383AC<>E; N [email protected] M „HH[4E a-6838=YAC<>;[email protected] a'EB<>68; =-uN ∈4a-Ta'; <><>; A
bV6< _`NE (u)∩P
= {x, x , y}
x
T
4
?
u
;
>
<
A
c
b
6
<
4
=
H
>
<
;
v∈T
N (v) ∩ P = {x, y , y}
u
v 35<>7/a'<>;/; <>=c; G8<mNFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected] <+A\E
?
H[4=H>[email protected]/?C4= H+]f68=<H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4=
!- $ - 1. ,1- - 1. - - 1- $ . , Z [email protected]; Q = u−· · ·−v [email protected] AC4=8D„E =V;/?CH W<>[email protected]=G8< G[T ] ? l 4a-a'< G[T ]
<[N/;BE =V;/?CH[4=8=<W8V <2E LM<[HQE 6Ya'[email protected]=N968=<2E 7 >; <S Q <[N/;ÈG8<mAC4=8D6<>687 E 6 a'[email protected]=N 2 ?4u <
1
2
α
∗
0
0
∗
∗
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
2
0
0
0
0
2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
es[
6 . 38NFE [email protected][email protected];{N Scbc36E< 7{AC<B3kHF4WN 4Nj?NT[V1G8<ÈG8< 68=#=S 4a2:87 < [email protected] <>[email protected]; 7{G8<
NMdE 47 =c>;£; <[E N£=c<>;/;Ä?CH[684=1=8==<W4Vfam<[N :8?<7 u< [email protected]=H+3E [email protected]= 7
G8G8<<+N 4a-a'<>Md;9E H[7 4>;a-<[a2N ? 68XB=Y4;H 4E =7{NÄ[email protected]$A bVH16˜J E 6868=7F< E [email protected];ÈE AC47 N{Md68E =ƒ7 >;NF<4a-<>;’a'68<>=; < M H[4a-38MdAC<>E ;97 >G; E< ==˜N J 4=c;Ä? 3 E= N
3E 7/;/Z ?CH>[email protected]?C<>7 SAC<[N MdE 7 >; <[NÄ<>;%AC<[N MdE 7 >; ? <[ZN’N 4=c;¢G8<>6SV # G8<>6SVQGf?CN/;/[email protected]=H>; <[N ?
8
6
8
3
k
3
4
N
4
=
#
N
V
b
6
<
N
4
@
?
'
;
8
G
„
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
^
7
3
E
@
?
7
<
4
@
?
;
8
6
=
<
MdE 7 >; <
G8< <>; 68=< E 383E 7FE ?CN N Md<>E =c7 ;>; G<`E G8=<N H[<>;+; 4<>[email protected]<[7 N'<QbcN/668<7 S NFE ? =Z N-? 3k<>7/;a^<„E G8=<ƒbV6DM< O>=O>7FE E [email protected][email protected]; 7ON S
?Z?
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
B
;
8
6
`
=
E
c
=
/
;
@
?
/
;
7
4
`
6
@
?
a
3
E
@
?
7
E
C
A
4
7
N
Z
?
[email protected][email protected]=a-Gf368E [email protected][email protected];7 ?!68u=14E ==cH ;/[email protected];/7 46#[email protected] [email protected] ? S<>; E AC47 N
[email protected]=#=GfE 68=V;/[email protected];’[email protected];/687 4=ƒ61E [email protected]=Va-;/[email protected];/7E [email protected] 6 ?
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
Ä
;
8
6
u 4=H <[N ;9G8<°AC4=8D6<>[email protected] [email protected] < gE 6„a'[email protected]=N ?
Z 68383k4N 4=N2bV6<
=
'
<
N
4
@
?
;
3
E
m
N
E
c
=
/
;
C
?
[
H
4
8
=
=
W< Vf< ?8L 68?CN bc6< <[N/;
E =c;/?CH[4=8=bc68W< Vf?<=S<[email protected][W<4VI=c?C;/N ?C; <><+=V;°68= 3EN N 4a-a'<><>;; ; <>A%GbcE 6=<N968=<LM4H[[email protected];+a-G35E =4NTN E =V; <mE 6hH[4a'=8=4W<[email protected]=V8N <°AKG8J 68< =¡G8<
<68>; = ;/? 7 4_`6YE [email protected]?Ca-N{E3ACE [email protected] 7mN ]f68=<H[4=V;/[email protected]?C=H>Gf;/[email protected]= ;£?$Gu E =4=N H 68=1H W<>[email protected]=„<[N/38;È[email protected] =VNÄ;/AC?C4H[=84D-=8=bVW< 6V8< < ? 46
X 46N^NTE[LM4=N1bV6˜J [email protected] H–E 68=r=4am:87 <[email protected] [email protected]#G8<
MdE 7 >; <[N„GE =N ?
[email protected] a-E E [email protected]„E [email protected]<>7-<AC4G8=< NbV6< 3kMdMdE4E 7N7 >jN>;T[; <[G8<[N N<£S ? 68bcu =#684?==4N H 4am=c:8;-7 <[email protected] >jN 37 T[<>E [email protected]< 7; <[G8E N <6rS%<>a';[email protected]=?ÄNƒ;Md68E47;F=>E < ;[email protected]?C<[NFN <>SI=V<>;-;’6868=ª=#==44MdamamE 7 :8:8>;77 <<<
c
b
8
6
¢
?
˜
=
J
[
<
/
N
;
8
=
?
8
6
=
<
MdE 7 >; <#=8? 68=<
MdE 7 >; < ? jB=´N 6838354N <-NTE =N
3k<>7/; <G8<?<DMu O>4==O>7FH E [email protected][email protected]; O2a^bVE 6=< bV6< 46 S83E 38E 7B3E W< 7FVfE <>?Ca-N N 38<>=cAC< ;BG? E (È=N AC4H[7 <>N ;È47 GfLM74<[email protected]; N/687S8H E 7B<>N/;È[email protected]=bc46= <
[email protected]<>7F3E [email protected];%[email protected] 68f=<>< ; [email protected]=Gf68MdE [email protected] H E>E [email protected]; 7{; < N/[email protected]<>==h; 4E = =V;/[email protected];/47 [email protected]; 6`[email protected]Æa-H E37 E [email protected]/7 [email protected]=4<>= ; [email protected]=Gfa^68E [email protected]=7FE [email protected];{< 68=ƒ[email protected]=SE GfH =c68E ;/[email protected][email protected];/NE7 [email protected][email protected]=;¢614E =˜[email protected]=Va-S ;/[email protected];/7E [email protected] 6 S
<>E ;-=c;/G8?CH <#W<>a a->[email protected]'=< G8< AC4=8D6<>?868u [email protected]=H 3E [email protected] <'G8< ]kA\EƒH[4=H>[email protected]<>N/?C; 4= G °<[N/;°NFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected]; <[<N/Sk; 6868== <
H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4= ?
. - *, . Z [email protected]; 68=; <>A£N 4a-a'<>; ? L E 7
W!Hc? 3kZ 4?Ä;/4W 4T[=´N <`4:8G8;/<Y?C<>=V7 O[;2H>A\68E„7/7 H[<>4==H[H><[email protected]{6N/4?C=‘4= E 38 G [email protected]?CSbcE 6AC<h47 ACN <YAC<>a-a'< E 6r<[N/;mHFWG8<><'[email protected]= =8D6<>[email protected] <>[email protected]; 7 <# S
E<>;6ªa'[email protected]=N O; <>S ACN-4=ªbc6AC<'< =4; <
<>;[email protected]<>W<; VI?CN/; <1G8<>S6 VN 4a-a'<>; N ?
? Z ?’4=4:8;/?C<>=c;mA\E
_H[4=E ?CH>[email protected] N/AC?C447 = N H ¢E AC47 N
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
m
;
8
6
¡
=
/
;
7
4
6
@
?
a
3
E
@
?
7
[
<
/
N
’
;
8
G
9
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
>
<
’
;
F
N
[
<
’
N
8
G
>
<
S6 V'N 4a-a'<>; N¢[email protected]=c; O>7/?C<>687 N ?
N_ 4=cE ?C;„NÈACE <[ACN„47 W< N VI;/7 O>[email protected]; O[N„GJ [email protected]=¶=GfE [email protected];/;£?CH68W=h<>a-E [email protected]=;/[email protected];/7 46 [email protected]< a-3E [email protected] 4?4=Vu ;„4=AKJ [email protected]=V4; O>= 7/?C4<>:868;/7h?C<><[=cN/;9;„AKJG68E ==<N G8<[N
H[G84< =H>[email protected]/?C4=N gN E 4’=c4; 6 G8<2 : a Sc><>a';<2AC<È3=E 47/[email protected]; O :8? 7 <+jBG8= < 4:8Md;/E?C<>7 =V>;+; <[68N{=G<QE =H[4N =H>[email protected]/?C4=¡N/<>[email protected];a-A\E°[email protected]\E [email protected] =8<QD3564<>686877
? (B6h; 4;FE AKS5AC<2=4am:87 < G8< MdE 7 >; <[N°GE =N <>; A\E'AC4=8D6<>687°G8< NF4=V;
G8<°a >a'<3E 7/[email protected]; O<>;£AKJ 68=<G8<[NÈH[4=H>[email protected] ?C4=N gE 46 : {<[N ;9NFE ;/?CN eKE [email protected]; < ?
Q G[T \ {u}]
G[T \ {v}]
T \ {u}
T \ {u}
P
T \ {v}
T \{u}
Q
0
P
y v yv
T \ {v}
x, xu , x0u , yv0 , yv , y
{x0u , yv0 } ∪ V (Q)
T \ {v}
T
P∗
T \{v}
xu x0u
T \ {u}
P
P
x0u
yv0
x 6= xu
{xu , yv0 } ∪ V (Q)
0
yv 6= y
{xu , yv } ∪ V (Q)
P = xu−x0u−yv0 −yv
V (P ) ∪ V (Q)
Q
3
G[T \ {u, v}]
G[T ]
w
G[T \
{u, v}]
Q∗
w
G
u
v
V (Q) ∪ {w}
G[T ]
Q
G[T \ {u, v}]
T \ {u, v}
P
P
T \ {u}
T \ {v}
T \ {u, v}
P
T \ {u, v}
x00 y 00
T \ {u}
T \ {v}
x, x00 , y 00 , y
P
00
∗
00
00
y ∈P
y
u
v
v
y
u
V (Q) ∪ {y 00 }
x00
u
x00 y 00
T \{v}
x00
v
V (Q)∪{x00 }
00
0
00
00
x =x
V (Q) ∪ {x , y , x}
y 00 = y 0
P = x − x00 − y 00 − y
V (Q) ∪ {x00 , y 00 }
G
T
P∗
z
x−P −z
T
x−P −z
x − x0 − P − z 0 − z
u ∈ T
0
v ∈ T
N (u) ∩ V (P ) = {x, x , z}
N (v) ∩ V (P ) = {x, z 0 , z}
0
0
V (x −P −z ) ∪ {u, v, y}
x−P−z
3
Q
G
T
V (Q) ∪ {y}
T
x−P −z
x−P −z
z −P −y
T
P
P
2
e>
6
?
B
X
4
6
’
N
8
G
4
8
=
=
4
=
¢
N
^
a
E
@
?
V
=
;
>
<
=
E
c
=
;
8
G
>
<
S
6
V
L
E
/
7
\
?
E
V
=
;
[
<
N
f
G
6
C
A
>
<
a
'
a
9
<
8
G
9
<
È
i
4
6
F
N
N
>
<
A
>
<
¢
;
9
i
8
6
8
:
C
?
4
A E-387 <>a-?U>T 7 <S5bV68? =˜J EfS #-=4;/7 <2H[4=8=E ?CN NTE =H[<S5E 6H>68=< E [email protected]?CH E ;/?C4=˜S5a'4=V;/7 <QbV6<
N/? T <[N ;9N/;FE :8AC<E AC47 N94=„3k<>68;{O>; <>=Gf7 <AC<+AC<>a-a'<mE 6S#V D7FE 38W<[NBNFE =N{;/7 46„[email protected] [email protected]
<>;ÈE :E =G84=8=<>7ÈA\E-H[4=H>[email protected]/?C4= G +]
! ] G - 1 - $ T - 1 1. $ G P - *11 G 1. - G[T ] &1 .0 T 11 V (P ) . 1 P T *, . 1 .0 - P 11 .3 /- - $ - 1, $ T , P 11 .3 /- - $, - 1, T , * . P .3 /- - $ $ 1- 1-/- .0 P = x−x −· · ·−y −y .3 $. T 1- $ * $
u v . - N (u) ∩ V (P ) = {x, x , y} N (v) ∩ V (P ) = {x, y , y} D=E =V;BE 6YH EN RdA˜TN/6'2N/;FE;È:8G8AC<< 7? <>387 <>=Gf7 <mA\E 387 <>68LM<mGf6 AC<>a-a'<387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] A<>=YN <+7 <>;/7 <>2?NM
0
0
0
0
A E¡G8<>6SVf?UT>a'<„LE 7/?\E =V; <Ybc6<„=46N^387 O[N <>=V; 4=N#H>?NM G8<[N N 46N^<[N ;^H[<>[email protected]< G8<„AKJ E 7 M
;/;F?CE H>DMAC<1<„4G7/J >[email protected];/[email protected] =< E 38A ? [email protected]¢N'[email protected]<1IH G8a'4O>=8;/=7/?C<1bc668<„=<ƒ<>;^H[4G8=<ƒH>[email protected]:86?CN/<>?C=–4=a'a'4=V4;/[email protected]=7 <>NQ7#egA\4E 7/; N/<[email protected]^[email protected]@E [email protected]?C;/N26G838<7 O[bcNF<>68=V?9; <ƒ=<„AKJ E[NFLE 68E =S; < M
3E[LME4N+=E N{6S7 V <[H MH W<><>6S7 hV HFW<>O=VG8;/7 <[< N{ACLM<[<>N°7 N/H[?C44==H>N£[email protected]<>N=?CH[44=7 N < [email protected]È6N£<>; NiIH Ga'BO>;/G87/<2?CbVA\6E^<[LMN{<>Gf7 6ƒN ?C4AC<>=`a-38a'7/[email protected]<=S8H><>[email protected]=„E <[AC< N ?NFE&BX VH 4E 6=V;N
3l E J <[7’N/<W;fV NT<>E a-=38NÄACG8<B4G868<£; <B7 <>35a-438NFN/A\[email protected]:8H[AC<>< 7E AC61<9H 38W7/<>?N^Va-G[email protected]= J E P7/;/?N3\ E H[7’<[N£68Gf=#[email protected]<>=<>7 N N{<>ambV68:8?5AC< =˜H[J 44=V=8; =)Å<WfV <È=bV466<>NACH[NF4<>am=bc:86AC<W< M ?
; [email protected] ) 3EN9G8<°a'<>[email protected]@AC<>687 <[NÈa'4;/[email protected] ;/?C4=NBbV6<+AC<H>[email protected]; <mG8<+A\E-NiHIa'O>;/7/?C< ?
! ' *5-6%&%& #7 -698 * @=p=
G - 1 T
- .0 + $ G P - *1 G 1. - G[T ] 1 *, T 1 V (P ) . 1$ P T *, . .3 - P 11 .3 /- - $ - 1, $ T , $, - 1, T , P 11 .3 /- - * . 1 - *1
.3 - 1- , - .0 $ 1 T . 1 1- 11 V (P ) . - *11
.3 /- - , - . 1 $ V (P ) . 1 1-/ T l <>;/; <°LM<>7 N/?C4=`<[N/;£68=<H[4=N O[bc6<>=H[<[email protected] <[H>; <2G8<°A\E LM<>7 N/?C4= 387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] AC< ? iÈO[H>?NM
38H[47 =84cbc=V66<><°a'A\E <>=VLM; <>Sf7 [email protected] A˜?C4<[=YN/;9H>E?NM N G8NF<[<)NhÈN/eK6EN H>? [email protected]<°G8< 387 468LM<>79A\E2LM<>7 N/?C4=„387/[email protected]=H>[email protected] AC<°<>= N/68383k4NFE =V;
esJ
6 . A <'AC<>a-a'<'G8<#iÈ46N N <>A¢<>;2i968:8?C4„7 <[N/; <^O>Lc?CG8<>a-a'<>=c;2LI7FE ?¢GE =N; 468; <#N 46N M
HLM>A\<>E7 N N/NF?C4<9=-G8<[38N¢[email protected]/W; <[< NÄ? X G8< 460{N <><W7/8VDM<E SMa-a^[email protected]=E <>?CN’7 4G=E N =ACNÄ<[N¢H[<>D7/7F;FE E [email protected]=W<[<[NÄN GGJJ)<>(È=c7/;/; 7 O><Ba-<>[email protected] AC<[3N·[email protected] =^N·S4AC<[:8N%;/?CD<>7F=VE ;Ä3868W=<[<N
GAC8<><£a-_`a'<)<[cH N%=8H>?C?N<>M A8G8<><[;%N N AC4<[N%6N%D7FN E<>387 4W=c<[; N%68eKE;/[email protected][email protected]@:8?CNFAC<>O[a'N 3k<>=V4;¢687%;/7/G8?\EO>=8a'D468=VAC;/O[7 N <>? 7%(ÈAK6-J <WIV H W?CN E ; 38<>[email protected];/H[7 <<ÈG8N/<’[email protected] E [email protected]=c7 ;<[SN%ACG<[N%J E ;/a-7 4?CN?CN ?
! +!
G - 1 1 $ P - *11 G T ⊂
- . 1 V (G) V (P ) 1. - G[T ] 1 *,
P T * . .0 .0 1, T , P + $ - .3
.0 - 1-/ P 1 *-/. 1 P .0 - 1-/ $ $ .0 P *, - + - T *, . Bj [email protected]=E [email protected];„[email protected]?Cbc686= <138AC<17/?CACN/<>a'a-<`a'[email protected]<[email protected] >/[email protected]?8S{u 68E = =N NF4 A\E`6NiH[MKD47F=E H>[email protected]/<[email protected]= =c; <>H7 [email protected]; AK?J <>=u N E <>=a2Nƒ:8A\ACE<
H[<>;+4=G8H>[email protected]=V;+N/?C4AC<[= N <WG VI ;/S7 O>N a-?’[email protected]; =´O[N+=N 44; =c< ;BAC<[N+AKJ EG8=V<>;/6S?CVhHFWN <>[email protected]=a'<>G8; < [email protected]=V; G8O>7/4?C=V<>;Q687 AKNmJ [email protected]=VG8; < O>7/?C<>Sk68E 7 AC4<[7 N/N ;2GE =N
S˜<>=H[47 <'68=´N 46N MKD7FE 38W<
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
;
8
6
=
E
c
=
/
;
@
?
/
;
7
4
6
8
G
<
8
G
'
<
F
;
E
@
?
@
A
C
A
^
<
E
6
'
a
4
@
?
=
N
?
u
[email protected]=cE ; ;/<>?CN/7 egGfE [email protected][email protected]; ; <[N ? 4=HSMH[4a-a'<9E =8=4=H[OSVNF<>68AC<[N AC<[N H[4=H>[email protected]/?C4=N gE <>; : 35<>68LM<>=c; >;/7 <
A <AC<>a-a'<mN [email protected] =c;BO>;FE [email protected];BG8O r #-H[4=8=c6hG8<m_`)< HI=8?C<>AN 46N968=<387 O[N <>=V;FE ;/?C4= 68=
3kAKJ W!<>6ªHc3kGf4!? ;/OW4>T[7 N <><Q=V; G< J ?E =VRdAÄ;/?CH[a'44=8=c=;/<W7 Vf<ƒ[email protected]; bVOQ6G8<1< GE =; Nm468AC<[;BNQ<>D=`7FE G8384W=8<[=N E =VG8; <168_h=<m)< HIH[=84?C=<>AH>[email protected]=ªN/?C43k=`<>68:k;2< E 7 6<>A\H[GE 4V868<>3 7
[email protected] 47/; <-]
V (P ) ∪ {u, v}
Q
G
P
V (Q)
T
V (P ) ∪
G
2
T
! + 1
"6 . 51
G - 1. P - *1 G .3 - 1- $ , T ⊂ V (G) V (P ) . - .0 1 P T *, . 1 .0 -/ P T *, . Z [email protected]; t 68=N 4a-a'<>;2G8< T ? jB=´E 3835<>[email protected]< 1 .$. 'G8< P ; 468;N 46NiM
^aHFG8W< E <>[email protected]=)4<>7/=VG8a'; < <>=c? ;Èl 68G84=a-4<m=ca';13<mEAC<[7/ACN„;/<[[email protected];/W< ?C<WVf4VI;/=h7;/O>7 G8O>a-< [email protected]; [email protected][; O[NƒE NB6YLMG84N< ?C<><>==VNB; LMG84<[?CNB<><>;ƒ=cE ; 7 G8>4; S8=c<[4N;„=Y?5ACu <[NFNƒE <[email protected];È[email protected]Èa'<+; AC<>4<[;68N9Nƒ;[email protected][email protected][email protected]=V=c; ; ;<>O><>7/7/L7/?CLE <>E [email protected]@<[7AC<NN
> 46¡G8< AC4=8D6<>6873E [email protected] <S˜NTE =N°bV64?
[
<
/
N
°
;
8
G
<
C
A
4
8
=
D
6
>
<
8
6
7
[email protected]=c= ; <>;/7/7 L4E 6„[email protected]<'[email protected]<QE [email protected]?5=8uD64<>=68H7 S >/? O>Z ;F? E =V;Ba^G8E <+=bcAC46=8<2D686=¡<>[email protected]'3E<>[email protected];7 <G8S8< [email protected]˜H[S4=VE ;/AC4?C<>7 =cN+;[email protected] E 6„<WVfa'[email protected]/=;4Gf< [email protected][email protected]È7FE [email protected]= ;N
G4=83k<[<>[email protected];=V;/; 7<>47/L68E [email protected]<>AC<[7QN'N/68G87 <1AC4=8G8D<[6N<>N6847-a-3a'E [email protected]<>7 ; <ƒN <>; G8<[[email protected]=cO>; 7/<>N? \”7/LE E [email protected]; AC<[N'G8<1AC4<[=8N/D;°668<>=´687 [email protected]=V>/; ?8<>7/u [email protected]=AC<H
G8<„AC4=8D6<>687 > <>; [email protected][email protected];Ä68=^)H HI<[H>N/;-AC<[email protected]=–[email protected]=cE ;[email protected]<>7/E[LLME <[[email protected]ÈAC<Y68G8=<„<9N AC<>468=8ACD<96H[<>4687 7'G8<3SVE [email protected] =^< ? N 4_ 6NE MK?CDN^7FEE 38AC4W7 <N
[email protected]=c; <>7 [email protected]; ?pu 4=H [email protected];È; 46N£AC<[N9N 4a-a'<>; NBG8< ?
A <hAC<>a-a'< G8<`iÈ46N NF<>A <>;ƒi968:8?C435<>68;ƒO>DVE AC<>a'<>=V; >;/7 <`7 <>=feg47 H[O`3546871AC<[N
D7FE 38W<[N#eKE [email protected]:8AC<>a'<>=V;1;/7/?\E =8D68ACO[N ? l <>;/; <Yeg4?CN S¢4=y3k<>68;^7 <>A\GE V8<>7^AKJ !W Hc3k4;/4W T[N <[NƒG8<
P
t
t
P
P
t
P
P0
V (P 0 ) ∪ {t}
P
t
P
P
P
y−P −z
V (x−P−z) ∪ {t}
t
x, y, z
P
x−y
2
esO
3E 7/[email protected]; OG8< ?
!
P
$
- 1. 1 & /- . -
*11 G .3 G - 1- - T ⊂ V (G) P = x−·
V·(P·−y) 1. G[T ] 11& *, &1. - .0 P T *, . .0 . - 1-/ P - " T *, . i
B
>
<
^
a
E
7
V
b
6
4
=
+
N

G
J
E
k
:
4
7
`
G
c
b
˜
6
J
E
6
>
H
8
6
¡
=
N
4
a
'
a
>
<
;
=
2
<
^
a
E
=
c
b
6
2
<
8
G
>
<
SV
6
a68'N [email protected]^=a'N EG<>VIQ ; [email protected]¢S8a268H[684= a=N N 4O[G86H><#68N MK;/DN ? eg47FN¢Ea-38G8a'W< <<>; [email protected]=VH; G8<>E < 77¢GfN/[email protected][email protected]; =? ? 4jBZ =˜4=´S [email protected]; 3kE <>AC684;m7 N N/6838683k= 4H[N 4N <>4=c7ma-;/?Cbc<>a'6˜=V<>;J [email protected];ÈAÄ68G8<W=-Vf< ;/?CN/7 ;4<-6^68G8=ª<{;FNbcE [email protected]@?AC<ÈLMa'4E <>[email protected] ;;
Z 4?C<>=V;E AC47 N <>H ; E 7„N/[email protected]<[=NB4=˜LM4S ?CN [email protected]=3kN <>7/G8a'< <>;„N/G868< 7 NFE S”;/?CHFN [email protected]?C7 N/<h?CN+A\G8Eª<2H[N 44=7/H>; [email protected]< 6N/bc?C64<=ˆGf6 AC<>a-a'< ?
E 383<>E ; 7FE ?CN ? N <>P =V68;{[email protected];/G; E $< =N{# H[O[<>H ;ÄW4E 7=8GfDM7 <>< 7#N/AC68<[7 N-7 A? C(È<[N'AC4G87 <N·SVGJ E <>38; 7jT[NS A\4E°=7 <>3ka^<>68E ;'7 bcN/668<È[email protected][email protected];/<>?\E 7 AC<S [email protected]; ?
u J E 38j7 T[NmAC<^HFW4N? V´G8< S˜3868?CN bc6< [email protected]; <>;a^E =bV6< S˜[email protected]’W< Vf?CN/; <-68=ªN 4a-a'<>;
?,L 68?CN bc6< <[N/;E =V;/?CH[4=8=<WV8<S˜[email protected] <WVf?CN/; <
V
b
8
6
?
M
L
4
@
?
;
>
<
°
;
c
b
8
6
?
^
a
E
=
V
b
6
<
68a-=ª[email protected]=8E [email protected]=V;/?C?CN HF<>W7-<>a-A\[email protected]= AC4=8D6G8<>< 687^G8<ƒH[7 <><>;[email protected]?\EE =V=c;;/?CH W<><>a-; [email protected]= S?o<>u ;2J 4E =38j7 HT[WN'4A\N/[email protected]; 7 <>a^<>E ; 7 bc6G8<ƒ<#[email protected]=8a^[email protected];/E ?\E=8ACU? <T>S%7 < AC<[# N
NG84< a-a'S<>AC;<[N°[email protected] =V4; a-O>7/a'?C<><>68; 7 NBN [email protected]=V; O>LM7/4?C<>?C68<>=c7 N+;mG8H W< EH>68LM=4AK?C<>J 68=V=´; ;G84< 6N 46<>; G8< ? Z S? <>;Ga^J E E 38=7jbcT[6Nm< AC<'H E WAC44?N7 V N
?4u 4=H [email protected]; ? Z ?
@
?
=
f
G
8
6
@
?
È
;
8
6
`
=
E
V
=
/
;
@
?
/
;
7
4
6
8
G
<
F
;
E
@
?
@
A
C
A
2
<
E
Y
6
'
a
4
@
?
=
N
au 4^=E H =bV6LM< [email protected]; S5E <>AC4; 7 N ? _ E ?CN£E AC47 N [email protected][email protected]; 68=hE =V;/[email protected];/7 46¡[email protected]=<°Gf68;[email protected] ;{[email protected]@68AC< =ƒE E 6 =c;/a'[email protected];/47 [email protected]=6 N G8QS< ?
;FE [email protected]@AC<mE 6„a'[email protected]=N Q ]f68=<H[4=c;/7FEGf?CH>;/?C4= ?
ACN <><>a-7FE a'[email protected];È4<E6G8N N#N<{<)A\iBh°E ?C4N/N 668N 4N7/N38=<>7NƒA8<><>=4; 68E =ci9LM;B<>687/H:8; E<h?C479A\354E´=„4bc68=67%<°<[ACN/<[H[;/N4?C4D=8=7F=E E 38N/[email protected];[email protected]<[3LN EE 3N£=VE; G8<7 <°eKE ]’H [email protected];E W< <>7FVfa'E?CN/H><>;; =VW<O>MK;’7/; [email protected] A+G8;/?C6844=8==`=<YG8E LM:8<[<>N£AC7<[DNN ?C7F4E =‘38l W<>Gf<[A\6E N
3E 7 egE [email protected]; <>a'<>=c;B47 G84=8=E :8AC<[NB3E 79N 46N MKD7FE 38W<[[email protected][email protected]; NÈ[email protected]=V; <>7 [email protected]; N ?
t∈T
V (P ) ∪ {t}
z
P
V (P ∗ )
T
u ∈ T \ N (z)
x0
z
y0
z
x, x0 , z, y 0 , y
u
x0 6= x
P
P
x0
y0
x
z
v∈T
z
Q
u
x0
u
G[T ]
y
x0
z
G[T ]
v
u
v
x0
x0
Q
z
Q
Q
z
x0
V (Q) ∪ {x, x0 , z}
5
z
y
V (Q) ∪ {z, x0 , y}
z
y y = y0
V (Q) ∪ {x, x0 , z, y}
x
x0
x
2
Xu
T
"!# $ %&'!() ,-)*+*-.0/1
T
23/04)65 !
(
0
. <# 1 =?>@ 4< AB)*+*-C:)5 DE#E(62 ?,A
$ F/.
DA*+ G!($) H99$I!# &J)*+*-KI +*- %$LD$)
\
!
*+)*-%
$*+
#
M
*F4 +$)
.$I 0!(
DNO $*F)
0)'!(1
'
#
?
2 $P<$*-6 +
L> %!(Q5 $
G - & {a, b, c} - /.0 G - - "
,
*
- *1/- G \ {a, b, c}
G \ {a, b, c} $"-. - - {a, b, c} - *1/- {a, b, c} *1 - G \ {a, b, c} .3 G - 1 - - " . {a, b, c} '
?
$*+)
) %7)8$1 9:2 $;$!# %
?
eGk
!( )$
X
P
*+*J )
c#
%
?X wH
? V
{a, b, c}
L *+*-
u v
6 . T
<#
?
%.A!( )$
G5 P
Q
V
F
*+
V ?
Q1) E# !( G \ {a, b, c}
$
P
1
)$%92 9 *+ P$ ). )5 M!( )$
u
a
:
Q
. !( )$ ' %=,)$$ ; 1:2 5 D *+*-1
w
0A *+*-.
G \ {a, b, c}
!(BJ $)
15 M) E# C*+*J )G!(-C $)
v
b
G \ {a, b}
A: *+
H
? ) )=$ )PI: *+ w
w0
P
w0 −
,)I%0 = I *+)6= 0
0
w−Q−c w −P −u−a w −P −v−b
0P$$ E#)
w0
{a, b, c}
# L *-%K
!( ) 9 %
$
3 ) w
w0 , w00
P
$<#I 5% 2
I
)
I
%
B
A
A
,
$
u, w0 , w00 , v
P
$ )DI: *+ ,)%+
w − Q − c w0 − P − u − a
w00 − P − v − b
8
5
$)$*-0'$$ E#)
!( {a, b, c} {w, w 0 , w00 } w 6= c
c
*-.A *+*-1
G \ {a, b, c} # *- L
!( ) K $
) w
P
)
7
(
!
)
$
9
$
)
Q
:
0
#
)
&
I
:
<)
w0
w
P
u
w00
'$ )0I: *+ v
w−Q−c w−w 0 −P −u−a w−w 00 −P −v−b
,)%P M I *+)+M PD$$ E#)
C5% w
{a, b, c} !( . *-%.B *+*-.
w 6= c
c
G \ {a, b, c} 2
?
T V
V
T
?<A
!
V
r
?
V
H
?A
r
?
V
G - 11 "$ $ H - - G T ⊂
1
.
1 - *, - 1- V (G)
$ T *, V (H)
.0$ * $ T.0 H H - 1, T , + *+*-
x
T
M
y
H
$6
CM*
T
M
$
#
y
V
M r
TM
V
H
H
?.u
k4? k
T
JS? u
T
H
*+*-'
2 ?)6
*--2 $
*-Q,)
I )L5% G)
$*-)*-%
x
? V
F %CE%
2 .
N
)%
M$) #"
%1
: *+ D
#"?>@ - 0 >/[email protected]>/?KJ
6)M)*+*-
I \
C
C
)C
<#
V
*+)0
M4)
$*+
$
E#
k4?KJ ?
*C4
\
2
)
! + = G - 1 S - - 0 1 G 1$1 a b T ⊂ V (G) - 1 1.0 & $ G V (S)
1. - G[T ] *, a, b T * .0$ .3 *1/- /.0 - 1- $ T * .0$ S $.
,)5 6$'
\
D)= *+*-P=)=: *+ 6,
E#
/- k4?KJS?
t∈T
M
52 $ $)$*-
$ - 1- $ - /.0
?
*C4D
MME#I : M2 $$))J
!( ;
H
S
*+*-
{a0 , c, d}
c
S3
esQ
c0
a0
b0
S1
S2
0
S4
d
d
a
$')6I: *+A %
S1
S2
S3
S4
$')6I: *+A %
"!$#&% k4?KJ ?
{a , c, d}
<# X
0
$')P: *+
$3)=I: *+
%
M
?
?
a0
b0
I
c0
I
d0
2 I 2 72 I72 I $) .< ')052 $ $)$*-1?> V
5> D
a
b
c
d
b
)$
*J 5 T
*+*-
%$
)
H
t ∈ T
*-%
%
V
d
c
?
?
$*+
B
k4? e
$$ E#)
a
b
!( )$
$
t
{a0 , c, d}
a = a0
)
9
)
5
A
)
B
)
+
*
*
#
E
I
: B ,
N (t) ∩ {a0 , c, d} = {a}
2 9 )5 F!( )
=)D$$ E#)
" V (S) ∪ {t}
t
v
{a0 , c, d}
> )5 0!( )$G
Q8 K )5% .)')*+*-
v0
v
S \ {a0 , c, d}
E#I : F ,=2 1
)
=
1
)
;
:
$
:
P
,
(V (S) ∪ {t}) \ {v 0 }
)*+*-7I %4)M $) N E# ' M$$ E#)
#?>
%$I ,)$) {a0 , c, d}
?
?u
(
&+E#I : 0?>
$*+)8 ' %$)3$)$*- 2
M GM
V
V
<#I 0*J %2 P5% P)6)*+*-C 'N
V
H
V
'
I *+)
H
?
V
T
k4? e
>?
!(
< .)P$$ E#)
{a0 , c, d}
#> $ # ,35> , )$3
*+*-
+
*
*
α, β ∈ {a0 , c, d}
u, v ∈
)F5 *J 5 *J 5 >@ !( !( T
u
α
v
β
u
β
v
α
)5 $D $) #
$): *+
?> $*+
G[T ]
Q
u
v
<1 B<=: )$
6*J # ,
$" $=5% G[T ]
u
v
Q
!( )% <#4) F%$I =5% .)3I *+*-7
) ) Q∗
α β
,&J $$ J
# %$I ,)$) ' +*- &
V (Q)∪{α, b, β}
G
1 *+*-
+
*
)
$
I
D
C
J
*
*-6N >@ $
a0 , c
d
T
$$ E#)6,A52 $ $)$*-
2
L
?
F
H
T >
T
?
V
?
?!u
?
? M
M
V
?6u
V
(
! .2 - G - 11 H - - G P - *11
G 1 x y T ⊂ V (G) 1. - T V (H) V (P ) 1- 1- $ G[T ] *, ab cd - 1 1. - . 1 1. 1+, 11 by} c d x
H T *, .0$ ".0 - . - a P b H1 T *, {ay,
.0 :2 E(
P1
?> N V
c
d
V
?b V
$*+
"7
*J 5% b
V
$IM $'
25 )$-
\
E#
k4?KO
2 E(
esRS? ?
H
$ ##,5%$
2 I )%; 11 ,C$
#
)
a, c, d, b
( %G ,
).: *+
a c
V (H) \ {b, d}
P2
%L # 75% .)0)*+*-; V (H) \ {a, c}
*+*-
5%7*J 5% F *+*-
5%
u ∈ T
a
v ∈ T
$*+
d
L
)0I: *+9?> ?
e
u b # 5% y
v a y
?
C F!( )$D 6 . T
*J 5 7%$ *-%
{a, b, y}
u
)F$$ E#)
? ) = )5 x=y
N (u) ∩ {a, b, y} = {y}
)1)*+*-
GE#I : . ,72 69)5% V (P ) ∪ V (H) ∪ {u}
u
!( )$
G
)
B
$
$
#
E
)
'
>
)
5
B
(
!
)
u0
{a, b, y}
u00
u0
2' A )5 P);)*+*-
KE#I : P ,'2 (V (P ) ∪ V (H)) \ {a, b, y}
F
)
M
F
)
D
:
$: M, )*+*-
(V (P ) ∪ V (H) ∪ {u}) \ {u00 }
84)GI $) N E# 1 J$$ E#)
?>
1 %$I ,)$) L 8
{a, b, y}
u
{a, b, y}
k4? e
?u
E#I : 6?>
L
)5% ?
p? u
G[T ]
G[T ]
. $): *+
b
H
$*+)0 C %$)%1$)$*-P?
v
?
(
*+*-
%$$
V
$P %$) I:
)$
u
V
# V
'
T
H
?
I *+)
)$F
K*J v
k4? e
?
T
%$): *+
#
*J 5 w ∈ {y, c, d}
?
5
x = y ac ∈ E(G), bd ∈ E(G)
$$ BP) E# 1 A*- ,
7
a
b
$*+
!( )%'
Q
V (Q) ∪ {a, b, w}
) C %$I ,)$) )J ) V
?> Q
u
*+*+)-B) E# J
;)'!(%$ )1 *+*-'$)0
P) E# = B*- >?
!(
?
?u
C a
,
; !( ,-
V (Q) ∪ {a, b, c, d, x}
6 %$I ,)$) 2
! + 52 2 $ G - 1 H - - G P - *11 G 1$ x y T ⊂ V (G) . - T 11 V (P ) ∪ V (H)
11 *, . " $. 1 1- $ *, .0$
G[H ∪ P ] *,
* $ u, v ∈ V (H) x .0 T- $. 1- P T- . - u v - . - T *, . V (H) \
{u, v, x} H
P
r
,)
?
V
)=)*+*-P 7N
?
k4? k4? X
V (P ) ⊂ V (H)
MV
\
$IM $0
N E#
' $) 0
%$
)K: *+H ,+2 ?
05> L P$ #=2 $6*
*-J<#4)
*+)F!(
# C5 |H ∪ P |
)9I: *+
*+*J ,M2 ?
Hu
V (H) \ {v}
Hv
V (H) \ {u}
)P *+*-0
)= Q: P
%0K!( )$ x0
P
x
H
)
M
(
!
)
$
$
)
F
=
Q
:
+
)
D
(
!
)
$
$
)
u0
x0
Hu
u
v0
x0
Hv
.I: 6
v
*+*- NO $*- - %$ *+)# 0
H P
T
u 6= u v 0 6= v
x∈H
) 6?>@ 6)M)*+*-
# D *C4+2 6
P6 H
T # 9H *+*-
*+)-
9NO $*-D2 M
H \ {u, v, x}
T
H, P, T
$ *+)
J <D$ #
J53$I x∈
/ H
V (x−P −
0
x ) ∩ V (H) = ∅
# > F": *+ u0 = v 0
x−P−x0−u0−Hu−u x−P−x0−v 0−Hv−v
MV
?
T
k4?KR
M
?uT
?
?u
?&A
$3') E# 8*+2 ?!u
T
>@ T
N
$*-%32 9 $
L
H ?
?
MV
*+)
M
MV
3)')*+*-
T (V (x − P − x0 ) ∪ V (H)) \ {u, v, x}
*+2 G
?
H
M
k4? k
H*- -
?
M GM
M
(0: *+9<#I
*+*-
$- x00
Q#> $ # ,.$
T
T
F
'-
*+)
& ) x00
*F4
H
H P
T
00
0
x ∈ V (x−P−x ) \ {x}
9)BI: *+
) J)B$
N
$*-%G
?
H
x00 − P − x0
, 6 $I ,)$) |V (H) ∪ V (x00 −P −x0 )| < |H ∪ P |
<#I <P )5
u0 6= v 0
u0 v 0 ∈ E(G)
$
= A: *+
2
*
1> B
H
x−P −x0
u0 , v 0
%$I ,)$) ?
<#I G
\
?
e/e
?
?
\
MV
%$
M
*+)
;)F)*+*-
$
T
3$
[email protected]>&[
*+)
!(
,K2 u0 6= v 0
u0 v 0 ∈
/ E
H0
)
N $*-%=
(
V (u−Hu −u0 ) ∪ V (v −Hv −v 0 ) ∪ {x0 }
H 0 x−P −x0
T
%$ *+)G
)*+*-9!(
|V (H 0 ) ∪ V (x−P −x0 )| < |V (H) ∪ V (P )|
P %$I ,)$) 2
MV
?
esR
x
P
6 . y
a
b
H
c
&!$#&% k4?KO A
*+*-
x
[email protected]>&[S?4A
P
d
1 *+*-
) 0 C(T )
y
H
u
&!$#&% k4? k A
*+*-
[email protected]>/>/?4A
v
1 *+*-
) 0 C(T )
FI:2 $M$1 I --!(DC9 $$
?>.$*+)P$=2 N *-%C $I $)
)*+*-
/1
6A/.4)'> $)F
> $ =2 "!:2 .
-1
> $) $D!(+ M
E#I : 3?>1$*+)./-1
$# I&%G,
GE#I
;E#I : I 4)+D>
)BI B
$$%.
E( $$:*--M *+)Q
I E(+,
B : 0I ' $')(*$+,
O(n2 m)
P ) $)P)
$1!(0C3 I $$
3$< )I 8
PE#I : 1?>1$*+).1-;
0!($ 15% 6< 1)'E#I : 1
!(L<32$L! L *+*-A LE( I )I $) L
%Q) !(A )5% L
> Q)$ P?> 62 6?>@ *+).54 0)'E#I : 'N 4)*-%.$$ E#) !(1 1 0
8!($ 75 0)0$: : *[email protected]<
$: : *-CC *+<#$$) *+*-C
$
!()=*- $$I $) L0> ,)$ ;?> 06$72 8 $: 97
: *-;<(=/>= 36$?:;$) 2$P!
$
'2 .?>@ *+).
! 0I 1F6:2
XYZ[EH\9] ^_ZHSWZa`0bc'Ad69+,
'E#I : .?>1$*+).B-1
! &Q)$ %$ $: : *-& *+ #$$) NO )3< $)) $D %=6 *+)=
a0
t
DCFEGFHIBJKLENM3O EPRQSTIBJUVEHSWJK
b
a
H
e"fTgihBj0k3l1LE#I
"!#
: C?>1$*+)0I 0 $
%;C$; 1);I ) 2
%J ,n
!(
%7, ipo$)
; ;
J) 8 $)K
m B1);5%
49L*-J$I!#
$# I&%q/4 7$ !(3 .2 1?>@ *+)7 3JE#I : #
(r
d
!#"%$&'!(*)'+-,!.0/1!)'.%(32#4"%+"5#)6#78'.5/1!#"909"%! H +902#+ .%!:0:5+9%. u, v
2;(3.9<,=)'/1+ 6 .#" H > /[email protected]+1.%9 7 $7 2;(8"%+AB!(3.(8)'.02C? #)D.%!:0:5+9 t 2#+ H E / AF(32#+:0:5+)&9 >
: 2 :5+G2',=)'.H#)'+G/7I,!.%.%+J,='.%.(C"%+1.9"%+(8)K9%+L$K'+M73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.H2C? "9%4:0(3.H.P,=)'./Q,=""%4 >
/1+99%+(32#41+R)'+TSU!)'/9(3!)#)'+-,!.V(8:0:5412;(I,=9%+:5+)K9 > /1!:0:5+73+:5!)&9"%+R73+N"<,=#O'+
"%+#"%41.%+)K9%4XW'N#"%+ jY {a, b} )[email protected]+1.9M-,!.#)'+X-,=(8"%+02C?[,=:0(3.
/Q,='.%+\2;].%!:0:5+9
( : :5+^.%!:0:5+9X2C? #)
`_ ++)'2',=)&9 !)a+#9
&
$
#(
1
+
%
.
G
9
3
7
5
+
#
2
+
%
"
+
8
7
I
(
=
,
&
)
9
+
9
0
a
P4
a
b
>
734N(89(8:5+:5+)K9\.<+5#7I,=(8)'2;"%+^2C?[,QAB!(8"\:^,=)'$&'4b2#+^/%O-,=)'/1+ Y .(,=78(3+c2#+ H )'!'.
,QAK(3!)'./%O'!(3.( /1!:0:5+G#78'. /1!#"9H9"%!d73+G9"%! H 0 !e#9%+)KR+)d"%+:0#7I, m ,=)&9 > 2',=)'.
Y
H > a -,=" a0 > ,=73!"%. > 7f? (32#41+G,=#"<,=(89SU!)'/9(3!)#)'4 {a0 , b} +1.%9ge#(3+)T#)'+-,=(8"%+h2C?[,=:0(3.
2#+ G ;i )V/1+.%+)'. > a0 +1.9jk:5+(87873+#"ml$K'+ a F> ,=)'.g73+ /Q,!.g2#+1.gN"<,=#O'+1.*.<,=)'.g/Q,=""%4 >
! (8)#O-,="%+1.J+9hnR, # "<, % !)&9G:5!)K9"%[email protected]+)oSU,=(89M73+\AB!(3.(8)-,=NB+02#+ /1!:0!"9%+52#+ t
/78(3$K'+1. A +9 B > A 49<,=)K9 #)R+)'.%+:Le#73+X2#+G.%!:0:5+9%.jkp!#A,=)&9"%+:0#7I,!/1+" al > +9
Kr
8
B 49<,=)&9#)^+)'.%+:Le#73+ 2#+.%!:0:5+9%.qjkp!#A,=)&9"%+:0#7I,!/1+" B l #" A +9,='.%.(-.%#"
= !)Tp+#9,=73!"%.*2#4sW')#(8"#)'+"%+7I,=9(3!)[email protected]!"%2;"%+M-,="9(3+7 8 /1!""%+1.!)'2',=)&9 7f? (32#41+
B >
2#4 4ABK$K'41+h2#+M.%!:0:5+9jk:5+(87873+#"mlh$&Z? #)d,=#9"%+ = l )T4734:5+)&9 :^, (8:^,=7Z2#+ A
+9h#)4734:5+)K9L:^, (8:^,=72#+ B 8 7I,^jk:5+(87873+#"%+sl0-,=(8"%+ = SU!":5+)&9J,=73!"%.G#)'+\-,=(8"%+
2C?[,=:0(3. 2#+ G > ,=)'.`)'!9"%+#"%+#AB+ 73+.%!:0:5+9 +1.%9Z"%+:0#7I,!/14-,="`#)J+)'.%+:Je#73+g,=)K9(3/1!)#)'+ +
>
t
9> ,=)'.`[email protected]+1.%#"(89t2;X73+:0:5+2#+uH!'.%.%+7F+9qu#e#(3 73+1. +)'.<+:Le#73+1.
T
A +9 B .%!)K9t2#+1.
>
+)'.%+:Je#73+1.H2#+h.%!:0:5+9%. T 7 /1!:0#73+9%. 5! +1..%!:0:5+9%.H2#+ V (H) \ {a, t, b} .%!)&9*73+1.
.%!:0:5+9%.q2C? #)5/<O'+:0(8)^,=#p+734 Z 2#!)K9q#)'++ 9"%4:0(89%4*+1.9 A7 /1!:0#7 : 9%+ > +9t7f?[,=#9"%+
7
: A,=)&9M7I,b#"%+#AB+\#"%!#"%+:5+)&9J2;(89%+ 7I,^.%+1/9(3!).%#(8A!,=)K9%+J(8)K9"%K2;#(89
B /1!:0#7 9%+
>
$K'+73$&'+1.)'!9(3!)'.#"%478(8:0(8)-,=(8"%+1. vMwPx
yzH{|p}q~€VkzH‚ƒ{%~~'„Vq†`{<z‡%}q~
r !(89
‰ )D)'!9%+
7
G #)ˆN"<,=#O'+
C(T ) [email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+R2#+1.^.%!:0:5+9%. T /1!:0#73+9%.
2#+ V (G) uH+:^,="%$K'!)'.h$&'+J-,="G2#4sW')#(89(3!) > T +9 C(T ) .%!)K9G2;(3. !(8)&9%. Z‰ )]2;(89
$KZ? #)R+)'.<+:Le#73+J)'!)AF(32#+ T ⊆ V (G) +1.9 S I UkŠH[Za`a`JIBU .( G[T ] +1.9,=)K9(3/1!)#)'+ +
+9.( G[C(T )] )Z? (8)'2;#(89 -,!.H#)'+L/78(3$K'+ 8 /1+L$K#(‹(8:0#78(3$K'+X2C?[,=(87873+#"%. |C(T )| ≥ 2
##(3.%$K'+h73+hN"<,=#O'+LAK(32#+h+9H73+hN"<,=#O'+G"%412;#(89
#)d.%!:0:5+9H.%!)K9 2#+1./78(3$K'+1. ='Π7
:
.%+M+#99" .*e#(3+)$&Z? #)TN"<,=#O'+ G )Z?[,=(89 ,='/#)d+)'.%+:Je#73+G(8)&9%4"%+1.<.<,=)&9 B> ,=)'. /1+
/Q,!. > !#" 9%!#9h.%!:0:5+9 v > [email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ N (v) (8)'2;#(89M#)'+J/78(3$K'+ 8 .<,=)'.M$&'!( {v}
.%+"<,=(89h#)]+)'.%+:Je#73+0(8)&9%4"%+1.<.<,=)&9 =t_ +7I,V(8:0#78(3$&'+02#!)'/0$K'+ G +1.9M#)'+\"%4#)#(3!)
2;(3. !(8)&9%+L2#+G/78(3$&'+1.H.<,=)'.H,='/#)'+L,=" 2 9%+G+)K9"%+L+7873+1.  HS `aPRZa` !)&9g49%4*2#4sW')#(3. .<+1/9(3!) A6 l )'+-,=(8"%+
u,=#p+73!)'.$&'+73+1. G5J9`aSŽ8B
f
`
'

Š‘ SWJKZ .(
7
2C?[,=:0(3. {a, b} 2#+ G +1.9q2;(89%+
G )'+*/1!)&9(3+)K9,=)'/#)5$K-,!.( #"(3.:5+*.9"(3/9
[email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. a +9 b 8 AB!(8"bW'N#"%+ jA6q= ! ? (8)K9%4" 2 9T2#+1.^-,=(8"%+1.2C?[,=:0(3..41/(I,=73+1.
#"%’AK(3+)K9 2C? #)73+:0:5+MSf,!/(873+G$K'+MAB!(87 TY
“”K•a•a”R–C—˜6™PšL›%—œž Ÿ#¡£¢^_ESTU
G/Id¤HNJs YZ ZU
G/I ZHJSTH Z0¥‹¦ JPS `J¥ Z
G
{x, y}
G§
¨ KEHa` EI JT©
ª Js« ^ S
G
I Z‘ EI U SVZI UgJ`T¥ Z U HNEG S P JSTHa]@JKEHa`
G/xy
I_Z‘ EIBU SWZIBUgJ9`¥ Z
H
tD
g d
a0
b0
a
b
‰ 5
) ,H"%+#"%41.<+)&9%4*#)\N"<,=#O'+*2C?[,="9%4:0(3. G ! , -,=(8"%+ {a, b}
+1.9M#)'+X-,=(8"%+X2C?[,=:0(3.L2#+ G $K#(`)[email protected]+1.%9-,!.h.%p41/(I,=73+\+9M7I,
-,=(8"%+ {a0 , b0 } +1.9*#)'+h-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3. .41/(I,=73+h2#+ G e"f g"hBjA6 k34 ,=(8"%+1. 2C?[,=:0(3. .p41/(I,=73+1.H+9*)'!)d.41/(I,=73+1. U H[EG STPH5JS H
§
ªQ« ^ S
I Z\‘ EI U SVZI U‹J9`X¥`¦ JIBU STU H[EGF` ]iJKEHa` ]
I Z\‘ EI U SWZI U JG;‘&GFI J I U S Ž
G
G/xy
U H[EG¥S ŠH ZI U*¥ Z
C6 §
ª ‘£« ^ S
I Z‘ EI U SVZI UI1SFBHS `P Z`"I S  GJ`aSŽ8BHS `PRZa`H¥‹¦ ZU HŠP S UkŠa`
ZU ] JK EHa` ]
G
x y
I_L
Z ‘ EI U SWZI UiJG;‘G/IVBHS `PRZ
§
G/xy
ª ¥«D^ S
Za`t
U ¥‹¦ ¨ HkU ŠPS ` Z&U `S
Za`UGFI_Zt5JS H ZM¥‹¦ JPS `i`f'Š‘SWJKZM¥FZ ] JK EHa`
G
{x, y}
G
Z`
U ¥‹¦ ¨ HkU ŠPS `
§
G/xy
- !9"%+M9O'41!" : :5+L#"(8)'/(8-,=7`+1.9*73+h.#(8A,=)&9 Y
`JI Ug¥ Z
+K•a”R–C— ^ ES U
G/Id¤HNJs YZ0¥‹¦ ¨ HUkŠPS ` ^ S
Za`U G/I ZI5`&ZP QKZ STI UkŠH Za`sŽ
§
G
T
JKEHa`
‘ E I U SVZI U GFI Z*JS H ZX¥‹¦ JP S 0
` `f#Š‘&S JK?Z0¥ Z
G
C(T )
G§
i ),!2;:5+99<,=)&9/1+M9O'41!" : :5+ 7I,0/1!) +1/9#"%+G2#+Gu +1+12T+9 i AB+"%+99H+1.%99" : ..(8:0#73+
>
2#4:5!)&9"%+" Y
”–C—#" X EG/UG¤H[JP Y5Z¥‹¦ ¨ HUkŠP S `R¥S ŠH ZI UV¥‹¦ G/I Z]‘&K S  G1ZbE9`a`%$¥FZG/I Z
JSTH[ZX¥‹¦ JPS ` `k#Š‘SWJK?Z XBEGU`¤H[JP YZ\¥`¦ ¨ HUkŠPS `pZa`UCJH M&JS U,ZPRZI U‘ EI U H[JB‘&U STKZ
§
§
r (
& ')( *,+(./78(3$K'+1.5,=73!"%. >
G +1.9\#)'+"%4#)#(3!)D2;(3. !(8)K9%+T2C?[,=6:5!(8)'.52#+
9%!#9%+5-,=(8"%+ {x, y} 2#+b.%!:0:5+9%.J)'!) ,!2 ,!/1+)&9%.\+1.9G#)'+b-,=(8"%+^2C?[,=:0(3.X.41/(I,=73+
2#+ G -r ( G )[email protected]+1.9-,!.#)'+"%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)K9%+h2#+/78(3$K'+1.*,=73!"%.(87C+ (3.9%+M,=:5!(8)'.
#)R+)'.%+:Je#73+X(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9 > +92#!)'/ > 2C?[,=#" : .73+L9O'41!" : :5+ jA6 > #)'+L-,=(8"%+\2C?[,=:0(3.
.p41/(I,=73+ {x, y} /> ,=)'.9%!'.73+1./Q,!. > !)b!e#9(3+)K9#)'+-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(p.41/(I,=73+ {x, y} > ?[,=#" : .J73+573+:0:5+ j
> G/xy +1.9L2C? "9%4:0(3.\+9L-,="L#)'+^"%41/#""%+)'/1+4AK(32#+)K9%+ >
!)TAB!(89H$&'+ G +1.9*-,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K9 /1!)K9"<,!/9(873+ 2
š
vMw0/
!
y6|}2143}
517698J2:*|,;‚ƒ}
vMw0/
r !(89
G #)dN"<,=#O'+X2C? "9%4:0(3.+9 T #)+)'.%+:Je#73+J(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K92#+ G !9%!)'.
,=73!"%.*$&'+ G )[email protected]+1.9-,!.#)'+ "%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)K9%+2#+M/78(3$K'+1. '‰ )T2#4:5!)&9"%+h73+9O'41 7
" : :5+L-,=""%41/#""%+)'/1+0.#" |V (G)| _! ,b#78'. +9(89%+JA!,=73+#"p.<.(8e#73+L!#" |V (G)|
d6
.%!:0:5+9%. N"<,=#O'+^!#"
1+ .9 > /1!""%+!)'2',=)&90,=a/Q,!.L G +1.9G#) /%O'+:0(8)
>
73+1$K'+7C73+M9O'41!" : :5+h+1.9*AF"<,=( #‰ ).%##p.%+M2#!)'/ |V (G)| ≥ 4 > +9!).##.%+M$&'+
73+X9O'41!" : :5+0+1.9AK"<,=( !#"9%!'.M73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.h2#+X9<,=(87873+\.9"(3/9%+:5+)&9h(8);SU4"(3+#"%+
|V (G)|
u +:^,="%$&'!)'. 9%!#9 2C?[,=e!"%2d$KZ? (87‹.592#+G2#4:5!)&9"%+"73+G9O'41!" : :5+J!#"73+1.
+)'.%+:Je#73+1.*(8)&9%4"%+1.<.<,=)&9%.*:^, (8:^,= !#"7f? (8)'/78'.(3!) -_ ,="*.( T +1.9#)+)'.%+:Le#73+
(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)&952#+ G > ,=73!"%.L9%!#90+)'.%+:Je#73+b(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9 T 0 ,1AB+1/ T ⊂ T 0 AB4"(žW-+"<,
>
C(T 0 ) ⊆ C(T ) !)'/X#)'+X-,=(8"%+02C?[,=:0(3.h.41/(I,=73+J2#+ G 2',=)'. C(T 0 ) .<+"<,V,='.<.(
2',=)'. C(T )
r !(89t2#!)'/
T #)J+)'.<+:Le#73+(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9t:^, (8:^,=7 uH+:^,="%$K'!)'.t$&'+p!#"`9%!#9
.%!:0:5+9 z ∈ V (G)\(T ∪C(T )) > [email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+ N (z)∩C(T ) (8)'2;#(89Z#)'+/78(3$K'+2#+ G >
/Q,=".(8)'!) > T ∪{z} .<+"<,=(89q#)5+)'.%+:Le#73+(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)&9#78'.qN"<,=)'2 i )5+ # +9 > T ∪{z}
.%+"<,=(89 ,=)&9(3/1!)#)'+ + 8 ##(3.%$K'+ T [email protected]+1.%9‹+9 z 6∈ C(T ) = +9 C(T ∪{z}) = C(T )∩N (z) #+73!)'. ‘ Y5ZPS In`&EHUVJI U 9%!#9g/<O'+:0(8)
7
P "%+78(I,=)&92#+ .%!:0:5+9%.)'!),!2 ,
/1+)K9%. 2#+ C(T ) +9H2#!)&9 73+1.H.%!:0:5+9%.H(8)&9%4"(3+#"%..%!)&92',=)'. V (G) \ (T ∪ C(T )) > ?[,=#" : .73+*73+:0:5+ 1 (87-)Z? % ,M-,!.2#+ /%O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)&9g2#+73!)#N'+#"(8:0-,=(8"%+ F> +
>
#78'. > .( P +1.9H#)d/%O'+:0(8)o.%!"9<,=)&92#+G73!)#N'+#" -,=(8"%+ > ,=73!"%.H.P,\73!)#N'+#"+1.%9 ,=
:5!(8)'. 4 i )R+ # +9 7f? #)#(3$&'+J.%!:0:5+9(8)&9%4"(3+#" z 2C? #)o4AB+)&9'+7t/%O'+:0(8)].%!"9<,=)K9
2#+g73!)#N'+#" 6 .%+"<,=(89t9%+7;$K'+ N (z)∩C(T ) )Z? (8)'2;#(89q-,!. #)'+/78(3$K'+ > /1!)K9"%+12;(3.<,=)&9
7I,\:^, (8:^,=78(89%4G2#+ T -‰ )2;(3.%9(8)#N'+G:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K92#+ /Q,!. Y
š ˜ a K I¦ \RJ3JG#‘ G/Ia‘ YZPSTI `&EHUVJI U
§
r !(89
#)
'
o
+
=
,
8
(
%
"
]
+
C
2
[
?
=
,
0
:
3
(
.
.
1
4
/
I
(
=
,
3
7
]
+
2;N"<,=#O'+ G[C(T )] u ,=#+73!)'.$K'+
{a, b}
G[C(T )] )[email protected]+1.9\-,!.\#)'+/78(3$&'+/1+V$&#((8:0#78(3$K'[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+2C? #)'+9%+7873+V-,=(8"%+ >
-,="JO % p!9O : .%+b2#+5"%41/#""%+)'/1+V.( G[C(T )] )[email protected]+1.9L-,!.L#)'+5"%4#)#(3!)c2;(3. !(8)K9%+b2#+
/78(3$K'+1. > 9"(8AF(I,=73+:5+)&9.( G[C(T )] +1.9*#)'+h"%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)K9%+G2#+G/78(3$K'+1. r !(89
qr
P #) /%O'+:0(8)D2#+ G [email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. a +9 b ( P /1!)K9(3+)&90#) .%!:0:5+9
qr
t ∈ T ,=73!"%. P = a − t − b > +9 P +1.9J2#+^73!)#N'+#" 2 ( V (P ) ∩ T = ∅ > ,=73!"%.
> !)'/
V (P ) ⊂ C(T ) > /Q,=" .%(8)'!) > P /1!)&9(3+)'2;"<,=(89h#)o/%O'+:0(8)].%!"9<,=)&9
P +1.9M2#+
73!)#N'+#"0-,=(8"%++9 {a, b} +1.%9X#)'+b-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3.02#+ G L> +b#78'. > .Q? (87+ (3.%9%+b#)
$K-,!.( 7 #"(3.:5+T.9"(3/9 S [email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. a +9 b 2',=)'. G > ,=73!"%. V (S) ⊂ C(T ) /Q,="
.(8)'!) > 9%!'.H73+1. .%!:0:5+9%.2#+ S .%+G9"%!#A!,=)K9.#"H#)/%O'+:0(8)R"%+78(I,=)&9 a +9 b > (87 +)
"%41.#789%+"<,=(89$&'+ S /1!)&9(3+)K9 #)d/<O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)K9 no,=(3.H/1+7I,0/1!)K9"%+12;(89$K'+ {a, b}
+1.9\#)'+-,=(8"%+T2C?[,=:0(3.5.%p41/(I,=73+2#+ G[C(T )] o (8)-,=73+:5+)&9 > {a, b} +1.%9Xe#(3+) #)'+
-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3. .41/(I,=73+h2#+ G š aK Z S `U,ZpGFI‘Y5ZPS I `EHUVJI U
§
r !(89
#)
T
#
8
7
'.
1
/
!
#"
9
/<O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)K9 r ,X73!)#N'+#"H+1.9 n + 1 α−z −· · ·−z −β
- !9%!)'.5$K1'+T2C?[,=#" : n.^/1+T$K#(*#"%41/ : 2#+
‰ )D)'!9%+
Z =
> n +1.%90(8:0-,=(8"^+9 n ≥ 3
-‰ )d2#4sW')#(89 Y
z −· · ·−z
1
n
A = {v ∈ C(T ) | vz1 ∈ E(G), vzi 6∈ E(G) (i = 2, . . . , n)},
B = {v ∈ C(T ) | vzn ∈ E(G), vzi 6∈ E(G) (i = 1, . . . , n − 1)}.
- !9%!)'.G$K'+
A +1.9h)'!)]AF(32#+ > /Q,=" α ∈ A > +9G$K'+ A (8)'2;#(89L#)'+0/78(3$&'+ > /Q,="
H
tD
g d
1>
2
14 ,="2#4sW')#(89(3!)
A ⊆ N (z1 ) ∩ C(T ) +G: :5+ > B (8)'2;#(89#)'+G/78(3$&'+L)'!)dAF(32#+
>
> +b#78'. (87g)Z? % ,d-,!.X2C?[,=" 2 9%+
Q
,
B
A
1
+
/
Q
/
=
,
\
"
=
,
3
7
!
%
"
.
>
A∩B = ∅
uv
u ∈ A, v ∈ B >
{u, z1 , . . . , zn , v} (8)'2;#(8"<,=(89H#)T9"%!d(8:0-,=(8"
- !'. ,=7873!)'.‹:^,=(8)K9%+)-,=)&9t:5!)&9"%+" -,="‹73+1.‹73+:0:5+1. j jAd $K'+2#+1.`.%!:0:5+9%.
B -,="9(8"
a ∈ A > b ∈ B e#(3+)]/<O'!(3.(3. S !":5+)K9#)'+J-,=(8"%+\2C?[,=:0(3.M.p41/(I,=73+X2#+ G
2C? (3/( > 73+1.t"<,=(3.<!)#)'+:5+)&9%..%!)K9,!.%.%+ g#"%K/<O'+1.2#+g7I,#"%+#AB+*2;0/Q,!.q.<,=)'.t/Q,=""%4 ')(*$+,
“”K•c•”o–—8
C(T ) ∩ N (Z) ⊆ A ∪ B ∪ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) §
r
& ')( *,+(
!(89 w ∈ C(T ) ∩ N (Z) &Œ 7p+ (3.9%+H2#!)'/#)'+M,=" 2 9%+ z w ,QAB+1/ z ∈ Z
j
j
8
=r ##.%!)'.
Y
1 ≤ j ≤ n
w ∈
/ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) (87 + (3.9%+2#!)'/d#)ˆ.%!:0:5+9
gr
u ∈ A ∪ B ,1AB+1/ uw 6∈ E(G) ,=)'.^p+"9%+T2#+NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > !)D+#95.##.%+"
Fr
F
u ∈ A !(89 i 73+*#78'.p+9(89g+)&9(3+" i 9%+7-$K'+ zi w ∈ E(G) 73!"%. u−z1−· · ·−zi−w
+1.9t#)5/%O'+:0(8)^.%!"9<,=)K92#+73!)#N'+#" i+1 > 2#!)'/*!)52#!(89,QAB!(8" i = n > +9 w ∈ B 2
GFIR‘ YZPSTI¥ Z0KEIK¤G1ZG/H S P JSTH [email protected]‘
P = u−u0 −· · ·−v 0 −v
¨ K EH ` 0
ZU
EG 0
u ∈ A v ∈ B§
u ∈A
v ∈ B§
- !9%!)'.J$&'+
& ')( *,+(
1
+
.
L
9
#
2
^
+
73!)#N'+#"X,=a:5!(8)'. 3 /Q,="J(87)Z? % ,,='/#)'+
P
2
L
>
,=" 9%+T+)&9"%+ A +9 B
+#78'. P )'+T/1!)&9(3+)K9V,='/#) .<!:0:5+952#+ T )#(H,='/#)
.%!:0:5+9H2#+ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) 8 .%(8)'!) > P .%+"<,=(892#+h73!)#N'+#" 6q=pr ##p.%!)'.H$&'+M73+
_73+:0:5+ jAj .%!(89MSf,= 6Y u0 ∈
/ A +9 v 0 ∈
/ B !'.L,=7873!)'.hAB!(8"L$K'+0/1+7I,T+)K9"<, 3)'+
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
8P« Za`@`.ZGFK?Za` JHU,Za`ZI U H Z
Z&U
`EI U
ZU
Z
P ∩ C(T )
z 1 u zn v §
i )c+ # +9 .%(
2
zw +1.9L#)'+V,=" 9%+V,QAB+1/ z ∈ Z +9 w ∈ P ∩ C(T ) > ,=73!"%. > ##(3.%$K'+
>
"%+:^,="%$K'4 +92C?[,=#" : .*73+M73+:0:5+ j !)
>
>
w∈
/ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) /1!:0:5+G!)T7f?[,\2#4
Y
B
4
, w ∈ A ∪ B #(3.<$&'+ A +1.9M#)'+X/78(3$K'+ > 73+\/Q,!. w ∈ A +)K9"<, 3)'+ w = u 8 +9
2#!)'/ zw = z u /1!:0:5+0.%!#O-,=(89%4 = ! w = u0 8 +9G2#!)'/ u0 ∈ A > /Q,!.h+ /78o-,="
1
O % p!9O : .%+ = ! +G/Q,!. w ∈ B +1.9.%(8:0(87I,=(8"%+ R_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
‰ )G:^,="%$K'+73+1.Z.%!:0:5+9%. 2#+
+)G-,="9(3/#78(3+"`73+1.
P $K#(&!)K9Z#)LAB!(3.(8)J2',=)'. Z
S
B
I
,
U
Z
H
9
J
K
?
K
Z
.%!:0:5+9%.2#+ V (P ) ∩ V (Z) .%!)K9:^,="%$K'41.
#p+73!)'.
2#+ P 9%!#9g.%!'. 7
/%O'+:0(8)2#+ P > 2#+h73!)#N'+#",=:5!(8)'. 1 > 2#!)&9 73+1.+ 9"%4:0(89%41. .%!)K9:^,="%$K'41+1.H+9
2#!)&973+1..%!:0:5+9%.(8)K9%4"(3+#"%.)'+73+.%!)&9-,!. q> ?[,=#" : . 8N<= > 73+1..%!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$K'41.
2#+ V (P )\{u, v} .%!)K9t9%!'. 2',=)'. V (P )\C(T ) 94 #(3.%$K'+ u +9 v .%!)&9t:^,="%$K'41. > 73+1.
(8)&9%+"A,=7873+1.2#+ P SU!":5+)&9*#)'+M-,="9(89(3!)2#+ P ,=T.%+)'.2#+1.,=" 2 9%+1. uH+:^,="%$K'!)'.
$&Z?[,=R:5!(8)'.H#)o.%!:0:5+9M(8)&9%4"(3+#"h2#+ P 2#!(89 2 9"%+L:^,="%$K'4 > /Q,=".%(8)'!) V (Z) ∩
> !)'/
 E9` ` $¥ Z;JG P ESTI5`
5
V (P ) = ∅ +9 V (Z)∪V (P ) (8)'2;#(8"<,=(89t#)X9"%!J(8:0-,=(8"
P
¥ ZG STI U,ZH $JKTKZ`> +H#78'. -,="73+ 73+:0:5+h2#+ u !'.%.%+7+9uH#e#(3 8 73+:0:5+ 1 F= !)
>
>
 E9`a`%$¥ ZGFI IBEPRQH ZpS P  JSTHL¥ Z
NŽ JH&U,Za` > !)'/ Y
.<,=(89$&'+ P T
§
81« a K"ZS `U,ZTq¥ JI1`
GFI STI U,ZH $JKTKZ
G/S‘ EIBU SWZIBU GFI IBEP QH[Z STP  JSTHV¥ Z Ž
P
Q 
T
JH&U,Za`
§
- !9%!)'.M$K'+\/1!:0:5+
:
P .%. 2#+\,=o:5!(8)'.h2#+ (8)&9%+"A,=7873+1. > Q )'+\/1!)&9(3+)K9
#
r
#r
-,!. 7I,MSU!(3. u +9 v ,=)'.+"9%+2#+HNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > !).##p.<+ v ∈
/ V (Q) !(3+)&9 w
“”K•c•”o–—I–
^ ESTU
d9
+9 x 73+1.q+ 9"%4:0(89%41.2#+ Q #+73!)'. w0 8 "%+1. x0 = > 73+*.%!:0:5+9q2#+ Q ,=#-,="9%+)-,=)&9
8
='‰ )T+#9.%##p.%+"
C(T ) +9*/%O'!(3.(‹,='.<.(#"%K/<O'+h$&'+.%.(8e#73+M2#+ w "%+1. x
$K'+ u > w > w0 > x0 > x > +9 v ,=#-,="<,=(3.%.%+)K9X2',=)'.X/1+9J!"%2;"%+b.#" P ‰ )6, w0 6= x0
/Q,=" Q /1!)&9(3+)K9J,=o:5!(8)'.M#)'+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+ _4 !#"G$K'+X9%!#9G.%!(89e#(3+)/7I,=(8" > )'!9%!)'.
$K'+ V (Q) ∩ V (Z) = ∅ /Q,="J.(q#)a.%!:0:5+9 Q 49<,=(89L2',=)'. Z (87.%+"<,=(89 > 78#(g,=(8)'.%(
$K'+o.%+1.VAB!(3.(8)'.T2',=)'. Q > :^,="%$&'4 > !)'/o!)€,=#"<,=(89 Q = wx = w0 x0 no,=(3.
,=73!"%. > 7f? #) 2#+ w0 , x0 .%+"<,=(89
7I,dSU!(3.02',=)'. Z +902',=)'. C(T ) > 2#+ +)'.<+:Le#73+1.
-,="^2#4sW')#(89(3!) 2;(3. !(8)&9%.
!9%!)'.b,='.%.%($&'+T.( w0 = w > ,=73!"%.^/1+T.%!:0:5+9b+1.9
2',=)'. P ∩ C(T ) ∩ N (Z) +9^2#!)'/ > 2C?[,=#" : . 8N<= > w 0 = w = u > ?[,=#9"%+-,="9 >
: 8N<=
x0 = x +1.9(8:0p.%.%(8e#73+H/Q,=" x .%+"<,=(89,=73!"%.2',=)'. N (Z) ∩ C(T ) > /1+ $&#(p2C?[,=#" .
Y
Z
Œ
+)K9"<, 3)'+"<,=(89 v = x #)'+J/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
7 [email protected]+)'.#(89$&'+ Q +1.9 2#+J73!)#N'+#"G,=
:5!(8)'. 2 > ?[,=#" : .h7I,V2#4sW')#(89(3!)a2#+1.h.<!:0:5+9%.M:^,="%$&'41. (87q+ (3.9%+X#).%!'. 7 /<O'+:0(8)
Z0
>
2#+ Z [email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. z +9 z > 9%+7$K'+ z w +9 z x .%!)&9G2#+1.G,=" 2 9%+1. 8 i < j > i = j
i
j
i
j
! i > j .%!)&9Xp.<.(8e#73+ =t‰ )6/%O'!(3.%(89 Z 0 :0(8)#(8:^,=7,QAB+1/b/1+1.X#"%!#"(349%41. > /1+b$K#(
Sf,=(89$&'+h.<+1.*4AB+)&9'+73.H.<!:0:5+9%.*(8)&9%4"(3+#"%.H:^,=)'$&'+)K9 w +9 x /4 ,="H/1!)'.%41$K'+)&9 >
- !9%!)'.$KZ? (87C)Z? % ,X-,!.
H = G[V (Q) ∪ V (Z 0 )] +1.9*#)T9"%! > 4AF(32#+:0:5+)&9H-,=(8"
2#+.%!:0:5+9%.g2#+ C(T ) 2',=)'. V (H) \ V (w 0 −Q−x0) > -,="2#4sW')#(89(3!)T2#+ w0 +9 x0 +9
-,="%/1+*$K'+ Z ⊆ V (G)\(T ∪C(T )) i )\Sf,=(89 > 73+1. T 7 ,=" 2 9%+1.2#+ H .%!)K9+ ,!/9%+:5+)K9
73+1. T 7 ,=" 2 9%+1. 2#+ Q r ( 0 +9 0 )'+5.<!)&9G-,!.G2#+1.J.%!:0:5+9%.L/1!)'.<41/#9(žS .J2#+
:
w
x
P > ,=73!"%. H p.<. 2#+
:
2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.)'!)V,!2 ,!/1+)K9%.2#+ C(T ) +9q.%. 2#+!#"9<,=)&9#)0)'!:Le#"%+(8:0-,=(8"
2#+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+1. Y #)'+/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)d,=V73+:0:5+ 1AdF> !)'/ w0 +9 x0 .%!)&9*/1!)'.%41/#9(žSU.
.#" P - !9%!)'.
8
=C‰ )]2#4sW')#(89h#)]/%O'+:0(8)
k = max{i, j} k ≥ 1
Y +)R.<,=)K9 Y =
q
zk+1−Z−zn−v .%( k < n +9 Y = v .( k = n !9%!)'.$K'+ H ∪ Y +1.9/1!)#)'+ +/Q,="
1
!'.#"%49%+)'2#!)'.$&'+h/<O-,!$&'+G.<!:0:5+9
zk +1.9*#).%!:0:5+92#+ H ,!2 ,!/1+)&9
Y
#
i
#
2 :5+h:^,=)'$K'+G/1+1.2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.H/Q,="
^
:
=
,
'
)
K
$
'+
+
9
d
)
+
+
9
8
7
#(
Z
:
> v
z∈Y
w0
x0
w0 , x0 > x > v .%!)K9J$K-,=9"%+^.%!:0:5+9%.X2;(3.9(8)'/9%.\,=#-,="<,=(3.%.<,=)K9X2',=)'.X/1+9J!"%2;"%+b.#"
5> +
P +9*.( z ∈ V (zk+1 −Z−zn ) > ,=73!"%. z :^,=)'$K'+ x0 /Q,=" x0 )[email protected]+1.9-,!.:^,="%$&'4
#78'. > .( z AB!(89 w0 > ,=73!"%. w0 +1.9h:^,="%$K'45+9 w0 = w > +9G2#!)'/ w0 ∈ P ∩ C(T ) no,=(3.L,=73!"%. > /1!:0:5+ z 6= z +9 w0 6= v > 7f?[,=" 2 9%+ zw0 /1!)&9"%+12;(89 8N<=> !)'/5(87+1.9
1
e#(3+)TAF"<,=(C$&'+ z :^,=)'$&'+ w0 +9 x0 o (8)-,=73+:5+)&9 > 73+M9"(8#73+9SU!":54M2;9"%! H > 2;
/<O'+:0(8) Y +9 2#[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ T /1!)K9"%+12;(89 73+L73+:0:5+ 1 ##(3.%$KZ? (87‹)Z? % ,0-,!.2#+
.%!:0:5+9 2#+ C(T ) 2',=)'. H \ {w 0 , x0 } 2
4 !#"%.#(8AB!)'.g7I,#"%+#AB+H2;^9O'41!" : :5+ jA6K‰ )^2#4sW')#(89#)'+*"%+7I,=9(3!)
<A .#" A
+).<,=)K9 u < u0 .(Z+9.%+#73+:5+)K9 .Q? (87Z+ (3.9%+h#)/<O'+:0(8)2#+h73!)#N'+#" (8:0-,=(8"%+
A
2#+ u AB+"%.#)d.%!:0:5+9H2#+ B 9%+7‹$K'+ u0 +1.9*73+h2#+ ( : :5+G.%!:0:5+9H2#+h/1+h/<O'+:0(8) - !'.H,=7873!)'.:5!)K9"%+" $K'+
8
=
< +1.%9*#)'+h"%+7I,=9(3!)[email protected]!"%2;"%+ -,="9(3+7
A
Za`UiJIBU S `\9P^Š U HS  G5Z
<A
§
r ##p.%!)'. +)dAF'+L2C? #)'+J/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)$KZ? (87‹+ (3.%9%+L2#+1.H.<!:0:5+9%.
& ')(*,+(
_>
u, v ∈ A 9%+73.h$K'+ u <A v +9 v <A u !)'/\(87t+ (3.9%+X#)/%O'+:0(8)c2#+J73!)#N'+#"
“”K•a•a”R–C—8Ÿ
J3H ZK JqU S EI
H
g tD
dj
(8:0-,=(8"%+ P = u −· · ·−u ,1AB+1/ u = u > v = u > u ∈ B > p ≥ 3 > p (8:0-,=(8" > +9(87
u
0
p
0
1
p
+ (3.9%+M#)/%O'+:0(8)2#+G73!)#N'+#"H(8:0-,=(8"%+ P = v −· · ·−v ,QAB+1/ v = v > u = v >
v
0
q
0
1
p‰ )d+#9 ,QAB!(8"
vq ∈ B > q ≥ 3 > q (8:0-,=(8"
up = vq > +9 .(8)'!) up AB!(89 vq ##(3.<$&'+
B +1.9*#)'+G/78(3$K'+
8P« ¨ G;‘ G/I `EPPRZUg¥ Z
I¦ Za`Ugq¥ JI5`
V (Pu ) ∪ V (Pv ) \ {u, v}
A§
i )+ # +9 #)d.<!:0:5+92#+
^
:
=
,
'
)
K
$
'+
X
=
,
:5!(8)'.7f? #)o2#+ u
>
V (Pu ) ∪ V (Pv ) \ {u, v}
_
2
+9 v > +9*)'+h+#92#!)'/ 9"%+G2',=)'. A $K#(Z+1.9*#)'+G/78(3$K'+
+1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
81« ¨ G;‘G/I `EPPRZUg¥ Z
IC¦ Z`U¥ JI5`
V (Pu ) ∪ V (Pv ) \ {up , vq }
B§
i )+ # +9 ##(3.%$&'+
1
+
.
h
9
#)
'
5
+
/
8
7
3
(
K
$
'+
#)
%
.
!
0
:
5
:
+
L
9
#
2
+
B
(Pu ∪ Pv \ {up , vq }) ∩ B
>
>
no,=(3. .%(
)'+G+#9 $KZ? 2 9"%+ u
! v
=
,
3
7
!
"%. u −P −u
+1.9H#)
>
up−1 ∈ B
p−1
q−1
1
u
p−1
/%O'+:0(8)]2#+L73!)#N'+#"M(8:0-,=(8"%+\2#+ A AB+"%. B > +9 73+L73+:0:5+ jAj (8:0#78(3$K'+X!Re#(3+)
8
8N<=[= !e#(3+)
8
u2 ∈ A /1+X$&#( /1!)&9"%+12;(89
up−2 ∈ B /1+J$K#(`/1!)K9"%+12;(89h$&'+ B +1.9
_
=
1
!
+1.9 .(8:0(87I,=(8"%+
+1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8W6q=
#)'+h/78(3$&'+
+G/Q,!. v
q−1 ∈ B
r !(89
r 73+h#78'.+9(89H+)&9(3+" 9%+7‹$K'+ ur ∈ V (Pu ) \ {u0 , u1 } ,\#)AB!(3.%(8)d2',=)'.
2
Pv > +9h.%!(89 s 73+L#78'.+9(89M+)K9(3+"h9%+7 $K'+ ur vs +1.9M#)'+X,=" 9%+ > ,1AB+1/ 2 ≤ s ≤ q
> +9%+73.+)&9(3+"%.+ (3.%9%+)&9##(3.<$&'+
7 2
vq 78#( : :5+ ,h#)^AB!(3.(8)^2',=)'. Pu !9%!)'.$&'+
73+1..<!:0:5+9%. u , . . . , u , v , . . . , v (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9h#)9"%! H > +9M$&'+ r +9 s !)&9h2#+
1
r 1
s
/1+SU,=(89*: 2 :5+L-,="(89%4 8«iI^5
 ZGU `aG’B
 E9`.ZH  G1ZEG QSWZIa©
ª J«
ªQ«
r=p
]
ZU
s=q
r<p s<q
Z&U
]
ur+1 −Pu −up = vs+1 −Pv −vq §
r !(89 73+h#78'.*N"<,=)'2d+)&9(3+"H9%+7`$&'+
t
ur vt ∈ E(G) > ,1AB+1/ 2 ≤ s ≤ t ≤ q
r (
t − s +1.9-,=(8"H,=73!"%. u1 −Pu −ur −vt −Pv −vq +1.9#)/%O'+:0(8)2#+M73!)#N'+#"
(8:0-,=(8"%+2#+ A AB+"%. B !r !)X2#+")#(3+"t.%!:0:5+9t+1.9 u > +9 .%!)0,1A,=)&9 7 2#+")#(3+".%!:0:5+9
8
=
8
= > ?[,=#" : 2.h73+\73+:0:5+ jAj ,=##78(3$K'4
/1+
w +1.9 vq−1 .%( t < q ! ur .( t = q
>
/%O'+:0(8) > )'!'.,1AB!)'.*!e#(3+) u ∈ A 8 :^,=(3.*/1+7I,X/1!)&9"%+12;(89 8N<=[= !e#(3+) w ∈ B > ?[,=#" : . 8W6q= /1+h2#+")#(3+"/Q,!.*)[email protected]+1.29*.%.(8e#73+M$&'+h.%(
8
=
w = ur = up +92#!)'/ t = q
> ,=)'.h/1+0/Q,!.
> v −Pv −vs −up +1.%9h#)/%O'+:0(8)a2#+\73!)#N'+#"G(8:0-,=(8"%+^2#+ A AB+"%.
: .L731+^73+:0
+
J
9
C
2
[
?
=
,
#
"
:5+ jAj > !) 2#!(89X,QAB!(8" v ∈ A 8 :^,=(3.L/1+7I,d/1!)&9"%+12;(89 8N<=[=
B>
2
_
! v ∈ B +\2#+")#(3+"M/Q,!.M)[email protected]+1.%9 .%.(8e#73+X$&'+\.( v = v +97I,b/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 , =
s
s
q
2#+ 8Wq= +1.9*e#(3+)d.<,=9(3.SU,=(89%+ r (
t − s +1.%90(8:0-,=(8"b,1AB+1/ t ≥ s + 3 ,=73!"%. v1 − Pv − vs − ur − vt − Pv − vq
+1.9H#)o/%O'+:0(8)2#+J73!)#N'+#"M(8:0-,=(8"%+X2#+ A AB+"%. B pr !)o2#+ ( : :5+\.%!:0:5+9M+1.9
7
8
=
8
=
v2 > +9V.%!) ,1A,=)&9 2#+")#(3+".%!:0:5+9 w +1.9 vq−1 .%( t < q ! ur .( t = q
> ?[,=#" : . 73+h73+:0:5+ jAj ,=##78(3$K'4
8
/1+L/%O'+:0(8) > !)2#!(89M,1AB!(8" v ∈ A :^,=(3./1+7I,
2
/1!)&9"%+12;(89 8N<=[= ! w ∈ B > ?[,=#" : . 8W6q= /1+2#+")#(3+"b/Q,!.0)[email protected]+1.%95p.<.(8e#73+$K'+.(
8
= > !)'/
w = ur = up +9M2#!)'/ r = p +9 t = q
r +9 t .%!)K9(8:0-,=(8"%. > /1+X$K#( +1.9
(8:0p.%.%(8e#73+h/Q,=" t − s +1.9(8:0-,=(8"H+9 r − s +1.9*-,=(8" ! +.<+#7K/Q,!.`"%+1.9<,=)&9t+1.9
t = s+1 > /1+$K#(&+)K9"<, 3)'+g$K'+ u0−Pu−ur−vs+1−Pv−vq
+1.9#)/<O'+:0(8)R2#+L73!)#N'+#" (8:0-,=(8"%+ > $K#(‹+#9 !'+" 73+G" !73+J2#+ P _ +99%+LS !(3. >
u
d*
7I,0/1!)'/78'.%(3!) 8 e = 2#+ 8Wq= +1.9.P,=9(3.mSU,=(89%+ R_ +1/(C#"%!#AB+ 8Wq=
‰ ) =, #p+7873+ STI U,ZH $ JKTK?Z 9%!#9J/%O'+:0(8)c2#+
H > 2#+073!)#N'+#"J,=a:5!(8)'. 1 > 2#!)K9
73+1.+ 9"%4:0(89%41.AB!(3+)K9 z +92#!)&9H73+1.H.%!:0:5+9%.*(8)&9%4"(3+#"%. :^,=)'$K'+)&9 z 1
1
8!« Za`S I U,ZH $JK K?Za`^¥ Z
`&EI U JGIBEPRQH Zb¥FZ
JGP ESTI5` Z&U STK)`"MEHaPRZI U GFI Z
H
JHU S U S EIo¥ Z
JG `.ZI5`L¥ Za` JHU,Z`
§
H
r !(89
YFr ( 7I,G/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 , = 2#+ 8Wq= +1.9g.<,=9(3.mSf,=(89%+
#)
%
/
'
O
+
0
:
8
(
)
#
2
s
4
'
W
#
)
p
(
#
2
H
+
I
7
G
,
%
.
!
"
%
9
+
P
>
K
r
!)bp.%+ P = z −Z−z
(-7I,L/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 e = 2#+ 8Wq= +1.9.P,=9(3.mSU,=(89%+ > !)b2#4sW')#(89 P
2
n
/1!:0:5+ 49<,=)&9#)V/%O'+:0(8)[email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. z +9 u
> /1!)&9%+)K2',=)'. {z2 , . . . , zn } ∪
8 + (3.%9%+J/Q,="[email protected]+)'.%2+:Je#73r+1
5
+
].
%+1.M.%!:0:5+9%.h.%!)&9M9%+)K'.G2#+
{ur+1 , ur+2 , . . . , up } P
=
'
‰
.%+H9"%!#AB+"*+1.9/1!)#)'+ +
)b"%+:^,="%$K'+ $K'+ 73+73+:0:5+ 1 +#9.’?[,=##78(3$&'+",=
9"(8#73+9 H, P, {z } Y H +1.9M#)]9"%! > P +1.%9h#)o/<O'+:0(8) > {z } (8)'2;#(89h#)]N"<,=#O'+
1
1
,=)K9(3/1!)#)'+ + 2;(3. !(8)K92#+ H ∪ P > G[H ∪ P ] +1.9/1!)#)'+ + > 9%!#9.%!:0:5+9 z ∈ V (P )
:^,=)'$K'+ u +9 v 8 .( z ∈ Z[z , z ] -,="%/1+L$K'+ u, v ∈ A > .( z ∈ V (u
2 n
r+1 −Pu −up )
-,="%/1+X$&'+ P +9 P .%!)K92#+1.M/%O'+:0(8)'.M+9 r, s ≥ 2 = > +9+);W') u, v, z .%!)&9M2',=)'.
2
> !u)'/73+v73+:0:5+ 1 :5!)&9"%+d$&Z? #)D.%!:0:5+952#+
C({z1 })
V (H) \ {u, v} +1.%9
2',=)'. C({z }) = N (z ) > !)'/ z p.<. : 2#+0,=]:5!(8)'. 3 AB!(3.(8)'.G2',=)'. H D_ +1/(
1
1
1
#"%!#AB+ 8TF=
8s«
 E` `%$%¥ Z GFI IBEPRQH ZJSTHL¥ Z
ŽNJH&U,Za`
§
H
T
u,=#p+73!)'. $&'+ u +9 v .%!)&9 2',=)'. C(T ) !r (&7I,H/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 , = 2#+ 8Wq= +1.9`.P,=9(3.mSU,=(89%+ >
,=73!"%. u +9 v .<!)&9*2',=)'. C(T ) 'r ( 7I,X/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 e = 2#+ 8Wq= +1.9.<,=9(3.mSf,=(89%+ > ,=73!"%.
r
s
!)^,=##78(3$K'+73+73+:0:5+ 1Q ,=09"%! H > ,=5/<O'+:0(8) u −P −u +9 [email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+
u
p
_ /Q,='.%+\2#+1.h,=" 2 9%+1.
1Q (8r+1
:0#78(3$K'+X$KZ?[,=o:5!(8)'.M7f? #)
T
uv +9 ur vs > 73+X73+:0:5+
2#+ u +9 v +1.%9L2',=)'. C(T ) > !)'/ > $K'+07I,T/1!)'/78'.(3!)62#+ 8Wq= .<!(89 8 , = ! 8 e = >
r
s
!)6+#9\, 5":5+"5$K'+ H /1!)&9(3+)&9^,=6:5!(8)'.\9"%!(3.\.%!:0:5+9%.02#+ C(T ) 4 ,="073+
73+:0:5+ 1Ad > !)d!e#9(3+)&9 7I,\/1!)'/78'.(3!).%!#O-,=(89%41+ R_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8Wjq=
,="9(8"2C? (3/( > !)p+#9/1!)'.#789%+" 7I,\W'N#"%+ jA uH+:^,="%$K'!)'. $K'+ u−v +1.%9
#)(8)&9%+"A,=7873+X$K#(‹/1!)K9(3+)&9M#)'+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+ B> !)'/ > 2C?[,=#" : . 8TF= +9 8Wjq= > (87 + (3.9%+L#)
(8)K9%+"A!,=7873+ Q 2#+ H > 2;( # 4"%+)&9X2#+ u−v > $K#(/1!)&9(3+)K9L#)])'!:Je#"%+5(8:0-,=(8"L2#+ T 7
,=" 2 9%+1. -‰ )d,=#+7873+ x +9 y 73+1.+ 9"%4:0(89%41.H2#+ Q > +9*!)d,=#p+7873+ x0 73+h.%!:0:5+9H2#+
Q ∩ C(T ) 73+#78'.g#"%K/<O'+h2#+ x +9 y 0 73+ .%!:0:5+9*2#+ Q ∩ C(T ) 73+#78'.#"%F/%O'+h2#+
:
4
y > 2#+:^,=)#( "%+$K'+ u, x, x0 , y 0 , y, v ,=#-,="<,=(3.%.%+)K9g2',=)'.g/1+9g!"%2;"%+.#" H #(3.<$&'+
H /1!)&9(3+)&9M,=:5!(8)'.*9"%!(3.*(8)&9%+"A,=7873+1. > !)T+#9.##.%+"*$&Z?[,=T:5!(8)'.7f? #)d2#+
#
x +9 y > -,=" + +:0#73+L+9H.P,=)'.+"9%+L2#+GNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 y > +1.9H2;( 4"%+)&9M2#+ u +92#+ v
4 ,=" /1!)'.%41$K'+)&9
> y :^,=)'$K'+h7f? #)d2#+ u +9 v
r (
1
+
.
*
9
#
2
+
3
7
!)#N'+#" 1 > !), Q = x−y = x0 −y 0 > +9 y ∈ N (z ) ∩ C(T ) /! +
Q
1
j
73+:0:5+
(8:0#78(3$K'+ y ∈ A ∪ B ∪ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) no,=(3. y ∈ A ∪ C(T ∪ A ∪ B)
+1.9^(8:0p.%.%(8e#73+T/Q,=" y :^,=)'$K'+7f? #) 2#+ u +9 v > +9 y ∈ B +1.95(8:0.%.(8e#73+T/Q,="
=1> !)'/
y ∈ N (z1
Q +1.92#+G73!)#N'+#" ,=:5!(8)'. 2 > V (Q) ∪ {z1 } (8)'2;#(89H#)T9"%!
7 2
1Ad ,=##78(3$&'4
7I,
H1 /1!)&9%+)-,=)K9G#)o)'!:Le#"%+\(8:0-,=(8"h2#+ T ,=" 9%+1. > +9 73+X73+:0:5+
-,=(8"%+ H , T (8:0#78(3$K'+G$K'+ x0 −Q−y 0 +1.92#+M73!)#N'+#" 1 5> !)'/ x0 +9 y 0 .%!)K9*73+1.
1
.%+#73.H.%!:0:5+9%.H2#+ C(T ) 2',=)'. H 1
H
g tD
dq(
Z
z2
z1
zn
vs
ur+1 = vs+1
y
y0
x
ur
0
x
v = v0 = u1
up = vq
u = u0 = v1
eifTg"hqjA k ! + :0:5+ jA* .%!:0:5+9%.
!
x > x0 > y 0 + 9 y +1..%!:0:5+9%. jk#73+(8)'.l.%!)K92',=)'.
>
C(T )
Z
z1
z2
zn
vs = y 0
ur
y
v = v0 = u1
u = u0 = v1 = x = x0
up = vq
eifTg"hj ;[email protected]! +:0:5+ jA* W')02#+g7I,H#"%+#AB+ ! +1.t.%!:0:5+9%.`jk#73+(8)'.mlg.<!)&9q2',=)'.
>
C(T )
dd
r ##.%!)'.
5!
1 ,=##78(3$K'4L,=9"%!
x 6= u +M73+:0:5+
H1 > ,=/<O'+:0(8)"%412;#(89
+
9
f
7
@
?
+
'
)
%
.
+
J
:
#
e
3
7
+
5
:
!
&
)
9
%
"
M
+
K
$
'+
#
2
!
8
(
9
B
A
!
8
(
"
1
/
+
K
$
#(
8
(
:0#78(3$K'+ x = x0 = v u
T
u
x0 >
2
‰ )o,^,=73!"%.
j 1 > !)'/
x ∈ N (Z) ∩ C(T ) > /1+J$&#(‹/1!)K9"%+12;(89M73+G73+:0:5+
x = u +9
/1!:0:5+ x +1.92',=)'. C(T ) > x0 = x = u ;‰ )T,=##78(3$&'+:^,=(8)K9%+)-,=)&9*73+ 73+:0:5+ 1
,=9"%! H > ,=/<O'+:0(8) u −z −Z −z > +9
[email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+ T _ +1/(‹:5!)K9"%+J$KZ? (87
p
n
2
+ (3.9%+b#) 1.%!:0:5+9\2#+
q_
up − zn − Z − z2 $K#(AB!(89X7f? #) 2#+ x0 +9 y 0 +V.%!:0:5+9
)'+\+#9h-,!. 2 9"%+\#) z , (i = 2, . . . , n = > /Q,="G/1+1. z :^,=)'$K'+)&9 x0 = x = u -,="
i
i
2#4sW')#(89(3!)a2#+ Z +9h:^,=)'$K'+)&9 y 0 /Q,='.%+02;]73+:0:5+ j 1‹_ +0.%!:0:5+9G)'+\+#9
2#!)'/ 2 9"%+M$K'+ u > /1+$K#(C+)&9"<, 3)'+ s = 2 +9 u AB!(89 v #_ +7I,X)[email protected]+1.9p.%.%(8e#73+$K'+
p
p
s
.( s = q − 1 ! s = q nR,=(3. s = q +1.9 (8:0p.%.%(8e#73+L/Q,=" !)o,=#"<,=(89M,=73!"%. x0 ∈ A >
2
Y
y 0 ∈ B +9 x0 y 0 .%+"<,=(89 #)'+,=" 9%++)K9"%+#)\.%!:0:5+9t2#+ A +9 #)\.%!:0:5+9 2#+ B #)'+
/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) F> !)'/ s = q −1 -,="9(8"2#+:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)&9 > 7I,M.(89-,=9(3!)5"%+1.<.%+:Le#73+
#78#9!9 /1+7873+"%+#"%41.%+)K9%41+W'N#"%+ j 1<! +/<O'+:0(8) u−z −y−P −u +1.9`2#+73!)#N'+#"
1
u
r
-,=(8"%+J/Q,=" H +1.9#)9"%!d-,=(8" 1> !)'/h73+G/%O'+:0(8) u−z −y−P −u −u +1.9#)
1
1
u
r
p
/<O'+:0(8)52#+73!)#N'+#"t(8:0-,=(8"%+ > "%+78(I,=)&9q2#+ .<!:0:5+9%.q2#+ C(T ) +9 )'+/1!:0!"9<,=)&9
,='/#)'+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+ Y #)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)],=73+:0:5+ 1 1
2
“”K•a•a”R–C—
J3H ZK JqU S EI
Za`U U H[JI5`STU S 9Z
§
r
& ')(*,+(
! (3+)K9 u, v, w 9"%!(3.q.%!:0:5+9%.q2#+ A 9%+73.q$&'+ u < v < w 4 #(3.%$K'+
A
A
v <A w > (87-+ (3.9%+#)V/%O'+:0(8) P = v0−v1−· · ·−vq ,QAB+1/ v0 = v > v1 = w > vq ∈ B >
q +1.9*(8:0-,=(8" > q ≥ 3
r ( )Z?[,G-,!.2#+AB!(3.%(8)V.#"
u
v2 −P −vq ,=73!"%. u−v1 −P −v1 −vq +1.9#)V/<O'+:0(8)
2#+X73!)#N'+#"h(8:0-,=(8"%+02#+ u AB+"%. v $K#( :5!)K9"%+0$&'+ u < w /1!:0:5+0.<!#O-,=(89%4 q
A
‰ )0+#92#!)'/.##.%+"q$&'+
:
u p.%. 2#+#)0AB!(3.%(8) vi .#" v2−P−vq > +9!)5/<O'!(3.(89
8
=‹‰ )a,
i 73+X#78'.hN"<,=)'2o.%.(8e#73+0,1AB+1/^/1+99%+\#"%!#"(349%4 2 ≤ i ≤ q
i < q /Q,="h(87
%
2
)Z? ,\-,!.2C?[,=" 9%+1. +)&9"%+ A +9 B
=
r ( +1.9*(8:0-,=(8" 8
i
3 ≤ i ≤ q − 2 > ,=73!"%. u−vi −P −vq +1.9*#)d/%O'+:0(8)(8:0-,=(8"
>
:
j
2#+ A AB+"%. B
?[,=#" .G73+\73+:0:5+ Aj > )'!'.J,QAB!)'.J,=73!"%. v ∈ A ! v
i
q−1 ∈ B
! +G#"%+:0(3+" 2#+G/1+1. /Q,!.H+1.9*(8:0.%.(8e#73+G/Q,="
A +1.9H#)'+G/78(3$&'+L+9H2#!)'/ vq−1 ∈ B
no,=(3.,=73!"%. > v −u−v −P −v
+1.9#)/%O'+:0(8)2#+ 73!)#N'+#"H(8:0-,=(8"%+h2#+ v AB+"%.
0
i
q−1
%
8
jA*q=
B > $&#(C:5!)K9"%+ v <A u > /1!)&9"%+12;(3.<,=)K9 7f?[,=)K9(3. :549"(3+L2#+ <A 73+:0:5+
r ( +1.9L-,=(8" 8
=
i
2 ≤ i ≤ q − 1 ,=73!"%. v − u − vi − P − vq +1.%9J#)6/%O'+:0(8) 2#+
73!)#N'+#"(8:0-,=(8"%+2#+ v AB+"%.#)V.%!:0:5+92#+ B $K#(-:5!)K9"%+ v < u /1!)K9"%+12;(3.<,=)&9
A
)'!#AB+Q,=7f?[,=)&9(3. % :549"(3+L2#+ < 8 73+:0:5+ jA*q=
2
A
<A
! +1.R2#+ 73+:0:5+1.#"%41/1412#+)K9%.o:5!)&9"%+)K9]e#(3+) $K'+
<A +1.%9#)'+c"%+7I,=9(3!)
[email protected]!"%2;"%+ 8 -,="9(3+7 =H‰ ) 2#4sW')#(892#+d: 2 :5+o#)'+"%+7I,=9(3!) .#" B Y .( u, u0 ∈ B >
!)Vp.<+ u < u0 .(p+9.%+#73+:5+)K9*.Q? (87 + (3.9%+#)V/%O'+:0(8)T2#+ 73!)#N'+#"(8:0-,=(8"%+M2#+
B
:
5! +1.
u AB+"%.g#)V.<!:0:5+9g2#+ A 9%+7$&'+ u0 +1.973+2#+ ( :5+M.%!:0:5+92#+/1+ /<O'+:0(8)
+)'.%+:Je#73+1. A +9 B !-,=)K9G2#+1.M"!73+1.h. % :549"(3$&'+1. > !)]AB!(89G$K'+X7I,^"%+7I,=9(3!) <
B
+1.9,='.%.(C#)'+h"%+7I,=9(3!)[email protected]!"%2;"%+ - !9%!)'.H$K'+ A +9 B 49<,=)K9 2#+1.H+)'.<+:Le#73+1.HW')#(3. >
!)d.P,=(89$&Z? (87Z+ (3.9%+G2',=)'.
+9H2',=)'.
2#+1.4734:5+)K9%.H:^, (8:^,= _
A
B
H
tD
g dr
ZU GFI`&EPPRZU_P J STPJK
“”K•c•”o–— ^ ESTU G/I`&EPP Z&UBP J S P JK#¥ Z
a
(A, <A ) b
¨ K EHa`
¥ Z
Z`U GFI Z*JS H ZX¥‹¦ JP S ` `f#Š%‘S JKZ\¥ Z
(B, <B ) §
{a, b}
G§
r
& ')( *,+(
##.%!)'.$KZ? (87G+ (3.9%+R#)€/%O'+:0(8)€2#+o73!)#N'+#"d(8:0-,=(8"%+ Q =
_
/Q,="(87Z)Z? % ,5,='/#)'+
a−a0 −· · ·−b0 −b +G/<O'+:0(8)+1.92#+h73!)#N'+#"M,=:5!(8)'.
2
L
!
j
A
j
,=" 9%++)&9"%+ A +9 B +T73+:0:5+
:5!)K9"%+d$K'+ a0 ∈ A 8 +952#!)'/ a < a0 =
A
! b0 ∈ B 8 +9G2#!)'/ b < b0 = > 2',=)'.h9%!'.L73+1.h/Q,!.G!)c,V#)'+0/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
7I,
B
1
>
:^, (8:^,=78(89%4G2#+ a +9 b !)'/ {a, b} +1.9*e#(3+)#)'+G-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3.H2#+ G
r ##p.<!)'.$&'+
7 $7 2;(8"%+a$KZ? (87L+ (3.%9%+o#)
{a, b} )'+].%!(89-,!..%p41/(I,=73+ > /[email protected]+1.%9
$&-,!.( 7 #"(3.%:5+V.%9"(3/9 S [email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. a +9 b 8 !)6)'!9%+V73+1.X.<!:0:5+9%.0+9X73+1.\/<O'+ 7
:0(8)'.*2;$&-,!.( 7 #"(3.%:5+h/1!:0:5+M(8)'2;(3$&'4W'N#"%+ 1A6q=-‰ )T!#""<,\.%+"%+p!"9%+"
7I,
W'N#"%+ jAj -,=NB+ r $&#(q"%+#"%41.<+)&9%+5/1+"9<,=(8)'.J2#+1.h.%!:0:5+9%.L$K'+X)'!'.G2#4sW')#(8"%!)'.
,=d73!)#N2#+L7I,^#"%+#AB+J$K#(`.%#(89 B4 ,="h. % :549"(3+J!)+#9M.##p.<+" $K'+ S +1.9 2#+
1
73!)#N'+#"J,=]:5!(8)'. 1 > +9G!)a,=#+7873+ a 73+\AB!(3.%(8)2#+ a0 .#" S 4 #(3.%$KZ?[,='/#)
1
1
.%!:0:5+9q2#+ S )'+gAB!(89 7I,HSU!(3. a +9 b > ,='/#)0.%!:0:5+9q2#+ S )[email protected]+1.%9 2',=)'. T 9- !9%!)'.
$&'+ a−S −a0 −c−S −c0 −b0 −S −b +9 a−S −a0 −d−S −d0 −b0 −S −b .<!)&9
1
3
2
1
4
2
2#+1./<O'+:0(8)'.G2#+X73!)#N'+#"h-,=(8"%+0/Q,=" {a, b} +1.9M#)'+X-,=(8"%+02C?[,=:0(3. _ #p+73!)'. H
73+M9"%!(8)'2;#(89-,=" V (S ) ∪ V (S ) 3
4
8P« ¨ G;‘ G/I `EPPRZUg¥ Z
IC¦ Z`Uq¥ JI5`
S \ {a, b}
N (Z) ∩ C(T ) §
r ##p.%!)'.b$&Z? (87+ (3.%9%+#)ˆ.<!:0:5+9
u ∈ V (S) \ {a, b} 2',=)'. N (Z) ∩ C(T )
> ?[,=#" : .g73+H73+:0:5+ j > u ∈ A ∪ B ∪ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) no,=(3. u ∈ C(T ∪ A ∪ B) +1.%9
7I,XS !(3. a +9 b 5> !)'/ u ∈ A ∪ B (8:0p.%.%(8e#73+h/Q,=" ,='/#)d.%!:0:5+9H2#+ S )'+MAB!(89
r (
2
8
= > !)'/
u ∈ A > u 2#!(89 9"%+X73+\AB!(3.(8)]2#+ a .#" S1 /Q,=" A (8)'2;#(89h#)'+0/78(3$&'+
(V (S1 ) \ {a}) ∪ V (S3 ) ∪ V (S2 ) (8)'2;#(89#)/%O'+:0(8)R2#+M73!)#N'+#"H(8:0-,=(8"%+ Pu 2#+
8
= 4 #(3.%$&'+73+*AB!(3.(8)^2#+
u ∈ A AB+"%. b "<,=#p+73!)'.g$K'+ {a, b} +1.9q#)'+*-,=(8"%+ 2C?[,=:0(3.
8
=
jAj (8:0#78(3$K'+
u .#" Pu )[email protected]+1.9 -,!.2',=)'. A /Q,=" A (8)'2;#(89#)'+X/78(3$&'+ > 73+L73+:0:5+
$&'+X73+\AB!(3.(8)a2#+ b .#" P +1.9G2',=)'. B nR,=(3.G/1+7I,/1!)K9"%+12;(89L7I,V:^, (8:^,=78(89%452#+
u
Zr
2
8
b !#"[email protected]!"%2;"%+ <B ( u ∈ B > u 2#!(89 9"%+\73+\AB!(3.%(8)o2#+ b .#" S2 .( S2 +1.9h2#+
73!)#N'+#"J,=:5!(8)'. 1 = !7f? #)c2#+ c0 , d0 8 .( S +1.9L2#+\73!)#N'+#" 0 = > :^,=(3.G2',=)'.
2
7f? #)!7f?[,=#9"%+h2#+1.*/Q,!. > #),="N#:5+)&9H.%(8:0(87I,=(8"%+
7I,X.(89-,=9(3!) u ∈ A /1!)'2;#(89
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) _ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
> ?[,=#" : .*73+h73+:0:5+ 1Ar ,=##78(3$K'4
Y
S +9 T > !).<,=(89H$K'+
81« ¨ G P ESTI5`F¥ ZG ¥ Za` `EP PRZUT` 0
ZUL¥ ZG ¥ Za`n`EPPRZUT` 0 0 0 `EI U
a , c, d
b ,c ,d
¥qJI5`
C(T ) §
4 #(3.%$K'+
8
=
8N<= +9 8W6q= !)
a 6= a0 .%!#AB+)'!)'.*)'!'.*$K'+ b = b0 +1.9p.<.(8e#73+ > 2#+
Y
p+#92#412;#(8"%+h73+1. 2#+ Sf,=(89.#(8A,=)&9%.
8« ^ S;K¦ GFI F¥ Z 0
Za`UM¥ JI5`
] JKEH `3S K Za`UGq¥ JI5`
ZU K?Za`
a , c, d
N (Z)
N (Z) \ C(T )
¥ ZG JG/U H Za` `&EI U¥ JI5`
C(T ) \ N (Z) §
8!«p^ S K¦ G/I¥ Z 0 0 Za`Uq¥ JI5`
] JK EHa`;STK Za`U¥ JI5`
] K%¦ JG/U H ZpZa`U
c ,d
N (Z)
N (Z) \ C(T )
¥qJI5`
]iZU 0
C(T ) \ N (Z)
b ∈ C(T ) §
- !9%!)'.H$&'+ 0
a ∈
/ Z /Q,=".(8)'!)d7f? #)d2#+ c, d .%+"<,=(89H2',=)'. N (Z) ∩ C(T )
r
‰ ) 2#4sW')#(89#) /<O'+:0(8)
Y .<!(89 00 73+.<!:0:5+92#+
P /1!:0:5+o.#(89
a
N (Z) 73+
#78'.#"%F/%O'+o2#+ a .#" a − S − a > +9.%!(89 b00 73+o.%!:0:5+9T2#+ N (Z) 73+#78'.
1
1
1
#"%F/%O'+G2#+ b0 .#" S 8 73+1.H.%!:0:5+9%. a00 +9 b00 + (3.%9%+)&9
/Q,='.%+L2#+ a +9 b =-r !(3+)&9
2
zi ∈ V (Z) ∩ N (a00 ) +9 zj ∈ V (Z) ∩ N (b00 ) 9%+73.$K'+ zi −Z −zj +1.9H,='.<.(Z/1!#"9
$K'+L.%.(8e#73+ 8 )'!9%!)'.M$&'+ i < j > i = j ! i > j .%!)K9 .%.(8e#73+1. = 4 .%!)'. P =
‰
a1−S1−a00−zi−Z−zj−b00−S2−b0 )GAB4"(žW-+$K'+ P +1.9Z#)G/<O'+:0(8)J2#+ G [email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41.
q>
:
1 ,=##78(3$K'4
a1 +9 b0 ?[,=#" .g73+73+:0:5+
H > P +9 {a0 } > (87p+ (3.%9%+#)b.<!:0:5+9
z 2#+ P $K#(#AB!(897f? #)b2#+ c ! d > +9!)^/<O'!(3.(89#)59%+7 z ,='.%.('#"%F/%O'+H$&'+*.%.(8e#73+
2#+ a .#" P #(899%+ 41/%O-,=)#NB+" S +9 S > !)X.##p.<+$K'+ z AB!(89 c 9! ,H2#4sW')#(89(3!)
1
3
4
2#+1.`$&-,!.( 7 #"(3.%:5+1.`+)K9"<, 3)'+ z 6∈ V (a −S −a00 )∪V (S ) > +9‹2#!)'/ z ∈ V (z −Z−z ) 1
1
2
i
j
/>
> ?[,=#" : . 8Wq= !)V,
c ∈ N (z) \ C(T ) +9 a0 , d ∈ C(T ) \ N (Z) !)'/ a0 )Z?[,h-,!.g2#+
>
AB!(3.(8)'.2',=)'. V (P ) \ {a } > /Q,="#)^9%+7'AB!(3.(8)^2#+AF"<,=(89!e#78(8N&,=9%!(8"%+:5+)K9g.%+9"%!#AB+"
1
2',=)'. z −Z −z .%!'.h+(8)'+02#+5/1!)K9"%+12;(8"%+57I,2#4sW')#(89(3!)c2#+1.L$&-,!.( 7 #"(3.%:5+1. > /1+
i
j
$K#(Z+)&9"<, 3)'+"<,=(89 a0 ∈ N (Z) Y #)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) B #9"%+:5+)&92;(89 Y
8s«
Za`U GFI]‘ YZP STI¥ Z
a0 −a1 −P −b0
G§
8
=
‰ )o)'!9%+
2
b 73+JAB!(3.%(8)o2#+ b0 .%#" P b1 p+#9 9"%+ zj !o#)].%!:0:5+9h2#+ S2
> ?[,=#" : .73+L73+:01:5+ 1 ,=##78(3$&'4
H > b1 −P −z +9 {b0 } > (87t+ (3.9%+L#)R.<!:0:5+9
;
2
D/
%
'
O
+
0
:
8
(
)
K
$
#(
*
B
A
!
8
(
0
9
f
7
? #) 2#+ c0 , d0 r !'.5+(8)'+T2#+T/1!)&9"%+12;(8"%+7I,
y
b1 − P − z
7
2#4sW')#(89(3!)2#+1.$K-,!.( #"(3.:5+1. > !)V, y ∈ z−P −z = z−Z−z > !)'/ > 2C?[,=#" : . 8TF= >
j
j
!)d.P,=(89$&'+ Y
8P«2
JB&‘ U,ZPRZI U K%¦ G/IoF
¥ Z 0 0 Za`Uq
¥ JI5`
] K%¦ JGU H Z Z`U¥ JI5`
c ,d
C(T ) \ N (Z)
N (Z) \
]iZ&U 0
C(T )
b ∈ C(T ) §
> +M#78'. Y
8m«
cc0 ∈
/ E(G) §
r ##.%!)'.
-r
cc0 ∈ E(G) ( c0 ∈ C(T ) ,=73!"%. a0 −c−c0 +1.9#)T/%O'+:0(8)d.%!"9<,=)K9H2#+
\
6
Y
73!)#N'+#"
#)'+*/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) #r ( c0 6∈ C(T ) > ,=73!"%.2C?[,=#" : . 8W*q= > a0−c−c0−b0 +1.9
#)V/%O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)&9g2#+73!)#N'+#"(8:0-,=(8"%+ Y #)'+ /1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) ^_ +1/(-#"%!#AB+ 8V(=
#+73!)'.
%
:
H1 37 +5/ /73+0(8)'2;#(89J-,=" V (a1 −P −z) ∪ {a0 , c} > $&#(.%. 2#+b,=
:5!(8)'. 4 .%!:0:5+9%. B> ?[,=#" : . 8Wjq= +92C?[,=#" : .7I,52#4sW')#(89(3!)]2#+ z > H +1.9 #)9"%! 1
‰ ).%+ 0
0
0
S4 = d−S4 −d −c
8 « aK IC¦ \RJG;‘G/I ZJHU,ZZIBU H[Z
Z&U
a1 −P −z
S40 §
r ##.%!)'.g$&Z? (87p+ (3.9%+H#)'+ ,=" 2 9%+
;‰
xw ,1AB+1/ x ∈ V (a1 −P −z) +9 w ∈ V (S40 ) )
, w 6= d /Q,=" d ∈
/ N (Z) +9 d :^,=)'$&'+9%!'.73+1.*.%!:0:5+92#+ V (S1 ) \ {a0 } '/#)
.%!:0:5+9M2#+ V (S 0 ) \ {d} )[email protected]+1.9M,!2 ,!/1+)K9
a0 ! c /Q,='.%+L2#+L7I,52#4sW')#(89(3!)o2#+1.
4
$K-,!.( 7 #"(3.:5+1.+92#+ 8V(= no,=(3.,=73!"%.*73+73+:0:5+ 1 ,=##78(3$K'4
H1 > S40 \ {d} +9
_
W
8
q
d
=
+1/(C#"%!#AB+
{d} +)&9"<,3)'+G#)'+h/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
‰ ).P,=(89$&Z? (87C+ (3.9%+M#)T.%!:0:5+9 0 2#+
z
z−P −z $&#(‹,J#)TAB!(3.(8) δ ∈ V (S40 )
8W /Q,='.<+L2#+ = ‰ )d/%O'!(3.%(89 0 ,='.<.(C#"%K/<O'+J$K'+Mj.%.(8e#73+G2#+
y
z
z .#" z −Z −zj +9
!)R/%O'!(3.(89 δ ∈ V (S 0 ) ∩ N (z 0 ) ,='.%.(`#"%K/<O'+J$K'+h.%.(8e#73+L2#+ d .#" S 0 B4 ,="M/1+1.
4
4
/<O'!( > z −Z −z 0 −δ −S 0 −d +1.9h#)/%O'+:0(8) 2#+ G ‹‰ )c, δ 6= d /Q,=" z 0 ∈ Z +9
4
H
tD
g r
F_
%
d∈
/ N (Z) !)'.(32#4"%!)'.73+ / /73+ H2 (8)'2;#(89g-,=" V (a1 −P −z 0 −δ−S40 −d) ∪ {a0 } >
$&#(.%. : 2#+h,=:5!(8)'. 4 .<!:0:5+9%. -r ##p.<!)'.*$&'+ H .%. : 2#+#)'+h/1!"%2#+ 5! +1.
2
2#4sW')#(89(3!)'.G2#+ S, P, z 0 , δ +9M73+JSf,=(89M$K'+ a0 −a −P −b0 +9 z −P −z 0 −δ −S 0 −d
1
4
.%!(3+)&92#+1. /<O'+:0(8)'.2#+ G (8:0#78(3$K'+)&9M$K'+G73+1..%+#73+1. /1!"%2#+1. .%.(8e#73+1.H2',=)'. H
2
.%!)&9X2#+1.X,=" 2 9%+1.X2#+59 % + wx ,QAB+1/ w ∈ V (S ) +9 x ∈ V (z −Z −z) nR,=(3.J2#+
4
i
9%+7873+1.,=" 2 9%+1..%!)K9q(8)&9%+"%2;(89%+1.2C?[,=#" : . 8Wdq=q> !)'/ H +1.%9q#)09"%!0-,=(8" ! +.%!:0:5+9
2
:
8
= > !)'
/ > 2C?[,=#" : .L73+073+:0:5+ 1Ad > H
c .%. 2#+\9"%!(3.hAB!(3.%(8)'.G.#" H2 a0 > d +9 z
2
:
7
2
p.%. 2#+ #)T)'!:Je#"%+h-,=(8"2#+ c ,=" 9%+1. > 7f? #)'[email protected]+7873+h49<,=)&9 a0 d no,=)#(žS +1.9%+:5+)K9 > (87
)Z? % ,X-,!.2#+ c7 ,=" 2 9%+L.%#" d−S 0 −δ 1> +M#78'. > δz 0 )'+M+#9-,!. 2 9"%+M#)'+ c7 ,=" 2 9%+ >
4
/Q,="g/1+7I,J(8:0#78(3$K'+"<,=(89 δ = c0 +9 cc0 ∈ E(G) Y #)'+M/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!),1AB+1/ 8V(=> !)'/
73+1. c7 ,=" 2 9%+1.52#+ H 2;( # 4"%+)K9%+1.52#+ a0 d 8 +9\(87 % +) ,#)6)'!:Le#"%+(8:0-,=(8" = .<!)&9
2
2',=)'. z−P −z 0 5 #p+73!)'. z 00 73+MAB!(3.(8)2#+ c 73+M#78'.*#"%F/%O'+L2#+ z 0 .#" z−P −z 0 >
2#+.<!"9%+$K'+73+1. c7 ,=" 2 9%+1.H2#+ H 2;( # 4"%+)&9%+1. 2#+ a0 d .%+ 9"%!#AB+)&9H2',=)'. z−P −z 00 > ?[,=#" : .73+h73+:0:5+ 1 ,=##78(3$K'4 2
Y
z−P −z 00 +9 {c} > !)!e#9(3+)K9
8«
Za`U¥ Z K EIF¤G5ZGFH S P JSTH Z
z−P −z 00
§
> ?[,=#" : .T73+]73+:0:5+ 1Ad 73+])'!:Je#"%+2#+
7 2
>
T ,=" 9%+1.2#+ H1 +1.9T-,=(8"!€4N&,=7
> ,=)'.J/1+02#+")#(3+"L/Q,!. 73+1.G.%!:0:5+9%.
1
V (H ) ∩ C(T ) .%!)K9 a0 +9 a1 ##(3.<$&'+
>
> ?[,=#" : .q73+73+:0:5+ 1 ,=##78(3$K'4 1
c∈
/ C(T )
H1 > (b0−P−z)\{z} +9 T > /1+"9<,=(8)'.
.%!:0:5+9%.2#+ (b0 −P −z) \ {z} AB!(3+)K97f? #)d2#+ a0 +9 a nR,=(3.*/1+7I,\/1!)K9"%+12;(89 8Wjq=
1
> !)'/ Y
8P«
H1
E` `%$%¥ Z G/I IBEP QH[Z*JSTHJ¥ Z
z 00
z
zi
T
ŽNJH&U,Za`
§
z0
y
zj
z1
zn
H1
c
c0
a0
b0
a1
a00
b1
d
δ
δ
0
0
d
b00
a
b
eifTg"hjAj0k! +:0:5+ jAd 2',=)'.73+H/Q,!. 0
!
d ∈ C(T ) +1..%!:0:5+9%.jk#73+(8)'.ml .<!)&92',=)'.
C(T )
> ?[,=#" : . 8W*q= 7f? #)62#+ 0 0 1+ .%9X2',=)'.
Y
t‰ ) 2#4sW')#(89\#)
>
c ,d
C(T ) !) 73+^)'!9%+ γ 0
B
r
8
=
/%O'+:0(8) S 00 /1!:0:5+*.#(89 ( δ = c0 1/ +*$&#(#+)K9"<,3)'+ γ 0 = d0 > !)0
.%+ S 00 = c0−d0
4
4
r6
+9 δ 0 = c0 r ( δ ∈ S ,=73!"%..%!(89 δ 0 73+LAB!(3.(8)d2#+ z 0 .%#" S $K#(‹+1.973+h#78'.H#"%K/<O'+
4
4
2 + d0 B‰ )5.%+*,=73!"%. S 00 = δ 0−S 0 −γ 0 &‰ )0.%+ Q = a0−c−z 00−P−z 0−δ 0−S 00−γ 0
#
1
4
4
4
+9 Q = a0 −a −P −z 0 −δ 0 −S 00 −γ 0 -_ +1.*/%O'+:0(8)'..<!)&9*e#(3+)2#+1.*/%O'+:0(8)'. 2#+ G
2
1
4
2 ?[,=#" : . 8Wjq= > 8V(= > 8Wdq= +9g2C?[,=#" : .g73+1.2#4sW')#(89(3!)'.2#+ z 0 > z 00 +9 δ 0 ! +#"%.g+ 9"%4:0(89%41.
C
.%!)K9 a0 +9 γ 0 > $&#(C.%!)K9g9%!'.73+1.g2#+ 2',=)'. C(T ) 4 #(3.%$K'+ H +1.9#)T9"%!-,=(8"
1
+9 ##(3.%$&'+ z −P −z 00 +1.%9 2#+G73!)#N'+#"(8:0-,=(8"%+ > 73+1.H/%O'+:0(8)'. Q +9 Q !)&9M2#+1.
1
2
73!)#N'+#"%.*2#+ -,="(89%41.2;( # 4"%+)K9%+1. ! +)'!:Le#"%+M2#+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+1.2#+ Q +9g/1+78#(C2#+ Q
1
2
.%!)K92#+: 2 :5+M-,="(89%4 > /Q,=" H .%. : 2#+ #)T)'!:Le#"%+M-,=(8"2#+ T 7 ,=" 2 9%+1.2#!)K9 cz +9
1
8
=
a0 c )'+0S !)K9L-,!.G-,="9(3+ /Q,=" c ∈
/ C(T ) > +9X/Q,=" z −P −z 00 )'+5/1!)&9(3+)K9J-,!.X2#+
7 2
8
=> !)'/7f? #)52#+1.q/%O'+:0(8)'.
T ,=" 9%+1. /Q,=" Z )'+/1!)&9(3+)&9-,!.q2#+.%!:0:5+9%.2#+ C(T )
1
1
Q +9 Q /1!)&9"%+12;(89 73+M73+:0:5+
2
1
2
! ,5/1!)'/78'.(3!)d2;73+:0:5+ jAd :5!)&9"%+Ge#(3+)$&'+M73+M9O'41!" : :5+ jA6 +1.9*AF"<,=( vMw
X~-
:
X}J† }q~z‡:*|p{ 68X‚ƒ{
1
1X}q~
- ! '.\,=7873!)'.X2#!)#)'+"X(3/(g#)'+b.%4"(3+b2C?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.XS !)'2#41.X.#"X7I,T#"%+#AB+2;
9O'41!" : :5+ jA65! +M2#+")#(3+"[email protected]+)K9"%+h+ +":5+99"<,\2#+/1!73!"(3+"*73+1.gN"<,=#O'+1.2C? " 7
9%4:0(3.+)^9%+:0'.qp!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 Y O(n2 m) - !9"%+AB+"%.(3!)5!"(8N(8)-,=73+H2#+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
,QA!,=(89Jp!#"L/1!:0#73+ (89%4 O(n6 ) > :^,=(3. g"'/1+buH+1+12a,"%+:^,="%$K'4^2#+5)'!:Le#"%+'.%+1.
,=:5478(3!"<,=9(3!)'. @- !'.78#(X2#+AB!)'.R)'!9<,=:0:5+)&9]7f?[,=)-,=7 % .%+j£,=:5!"9(3+sl 2#+c7f?[,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ > /[email protected]+1.9 7 $7 2;(8"%+7f? (32#41+V2#+T/1!:0#9<,=e#(878(3.<+"0N73!e-,=73+:5+)&9^9%!'.\73+1.5,=#+73.X"%4 7
/#"%.(žSU. 5- !'.*"<,=#+73!)'.H$K'+M)'!'.H2#!)#)'+"%!)'.H4N&,=73+:5+)K9H#),=78NB!"(89O#:5+J2#+M"%+ 7
/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+H2#+1.qN"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3.,=5/%O-,=#(89"%+ *&_ +9,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ )Z? #9(878(3.%+"<,
-,[email protected]+ (3.%9%+)'/1+2C? #)'+-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3.V:^,=(3.V2#49%+1/9%+"<, 2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)&9T73+1.b#"(3.:5+1.
2',=)'.H73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.H2#+ +"NB+ •a”–—
' (
' f (
l )TN"<,=#O'+ G
l ) +)'.%+:Le#73+V(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)&90:^, (8:^,=72#+
G > !c#)'+b-,=(8"%+b2C?[,=:0(3.
.p41/(I,=73+h2#+
!Vj
+1.9*#)'+h/78(3$K'+sl
!#"%$
*
"
G>
G
4 O-,!.%+ 0Y "%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+X2C? #)d.%!:0:5+9 )'!)d.(8:0#78(3/(I,=7 t
r (
G )[email protected]+1.9*-,!.*/1!)#)'+ + > .9%!#+"+9*"%+9%!#")'+"#)'+M-,=(8"%+ {a, b} ,QAB+1/ a
r (
+9 b 2',=)'. 6 /1!:0.<,=)&9%+1.g/1!)#)'+ +1.g2;(3.%9(8)'/9%+1.2#+ G ;
G +1.9g/1!)#)'+ + >
*
r
/Q,=73/#73+"^73+2#+N"%42#+/<O-,!$&'+R.%!:0:5+9
(9%!'.b73+1.^.%!:0:5+9%.V.%!)&92#+
2#+N"%4 n−1 > .9%!#p+"t+9 "%+9%!#")'+"‹j G +1.9‹#)'+/78(3$K'+sl ! r (8)'!) > /1!)'.(32#4"%+"
#)].%!:0:5+9 u 2#+\2#+N"%40.9"(3/9%+:5+)&9L(8);S 4"(3+#"
n − 1 no,="%$&'+"h9%!'.
4
73+1.gAB!(3.(8)'.2#+ u ,=":0(‹73+1.g.<!:0:5+9%.*:^,="%$&'41. > "%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+" #).<!:0:5+9
, % ,=)K9H#)TAB!(3.(8))'!)d:^,="%$&'4 1- !:0:5+" t #)T9%+7‹.%!:0:5+9 4 O-,!.%+ 6 Y#Œ )#(89(I,=78(3.<,=9(3!)2#+1.:^,="%$&'+1. > !)#)'+"
t 7I,:^,="%$K'+j T l > 2#!)#)'+",= AB!(3.(8)'.q2#+ t 7I, :^,="%$&'+j C(T )l
_ !)'.(32#4"%+"9%!'.*73+1.,=#9"%+1..%!:0:5+9%. /1!:0:5+h)'!) 7 :^,="%$&'41. 4 O-,!.%+ Y "%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+X2#[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+L(8)&9%4"%+1.%.P,=)&9H:^, (8:^,=7 T
M
` gH1 R
5
5
r
* ,=)K9 $KZ? (87Z+ (3.%9%+h#).%!:0:5+9 )'!)d:^,="%$&'4MSf,=(8"%+ Y
u
r
r (
( N (u) ∩ C(T ) +1.%90#)'+T/78(3$&'+ > 2#!)#)'+"
u 7I,R:^,="%$&'+bj /78(3$K'+sl
4
!#"
N (u) ∩ C(T ) )[email protected]+1.9-,!.H#)'+X/78(3$K'+ > 2#!)#)'+"
u 7I,^:^,="%$&'+Gj T l
/%O-,!$K'+G)'!) 7 AB!(3.%(8)2#+ u :^,="%$&'4hj _ 8 * = l > + # ,!/1+"H7I,\:^,="%$K'+Mj _ 8 * = lG+9
/1!)'.(32#4"%+" u /1!:0:5+h)'!) 7 :^,="%$K'4 o (8)2;jfSf,=(8"%+sl r 9%!#+"H+9"%+9%!#")'+"[email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+L2#+1..<!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$K'41.j l T
f & " (
1
+
%
.
L
9
3
7
5
+
'
)
!
J
:
#
e
"%+2#+^.%!: 7
O(max(n + m, m(n − k)))
k
8
:5+9%. 2#+ C(T ) !#"[email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+ T "%+9%!#")'4 .( ,='/#)R+)'.%+:Le#73+ T )[email protected]+1.%9
"%+9%!#")'4 > !)ˆ,!2#!#9%+d7I,a/1!)&AB+)K9(3!) k = n +9b7I,/1!:0#73+ (89%4+1.9V,=73!"%.
O(n + m)
=
!
C(T )
T
eifTg"hjA* k 78NB!"(89O#:5+ jArbY /%O-,=)#NB+:5+)K9%.2#+:^,="%$K'+1.gp.<.(8e#73+1.!#"73+1.g.%!: 7
:5+9%.*73!"%.2#+h7f?[,=#N:5+)K9<,=9(3!)R2#+
T
Œ 7-+1.9/7I,=(8"$K'+)'!9"%+M,=78NB!"(89O#:5++1.%9/1!);S !":5+M,= .41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'. uH+1.9%+
,=)-,=7 % .%+".<,\/1!:0#73+ (89%4 ! ,H#O-,!.%+ )'41/1+1.%.%(89%+g,=X#(8"%+
!
6
n+m 49<,=p+1.t2#+g/Q,=73/#7 , #O-,!.%+ 4N&,=73+:5+)&9
4 !#"X7I,T#O-,!.%+ /<O-,!$&'+b(89%4"<,=9(3!) 2#+57I,Te!'/73+5)'41/1+1.<.(89%+b,= #78'.
m -,!.X2#+
>
/Q,=73/#73. i ) + # +9 > 2#41/(32#+"V.( N (u) ∩ C(T ) +1.95#)'+/78(3$K'+T)'41/1+1.%.%(89%+d,=D#78'.
8
2
:
7 2 =
m -,!. /[email protected]+1.9G#)c#"%K/1+1.%.<.'.G$K#(.Q?[,=" 9%+52 .J$&[email protected]!)"%+)'/1!)K9"%+^#)'+^)'!) ,=" 9%+
! [email protected]+ # , m ,=NB+ 2#+1.:^,="%$K'+1.tj
:
C(T )l*.%+*#"%!e#7 :5+2',=)'.7I,h:5+1.%#"%+H^!)b9"<,1A,=(87873+
7
2
.#"2#+1.)'!) ,=" 9%+1. no,=(3.!)^+#9"%+:^,="%$K'+"g$K'+*73+*)'!:Je#"%+ 2#+-,!.+1.9:^, !"%4
-,="73+h2#+N"%4G2;d.%!:0:5+9 t (8)#(89(I,=7`/Q,="[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ C(T ) )'+MSf,=(89$&'+h2#41/"% 39"%+
-,="9(8"H2#+h.<,XA,=73+#"(8)#(89(I,=73+ N (t) > !)'/ /%O-,!$K'+(89%4"<,=9(3!)Ljk9<,=)&9 $&'+slt)'41/1+1.%.(89%+g,=G#78'.
.! ,W'N#"%+ jA*
m 49<,=+1.
>
:5!)&9"%+
7f?[,=(32#+R2##
+ " : /<O'+1.b7I,]SU, m !) 2#!)&973+1.V.%!:0:5+9%.^+#AB+)&9/%O-,=)#NB+"T2#+
Œ
:^,="%$&'+ 7',=#-,="<, 39$&Z? #)5.<!:0:5+9qp+#9 2 9"%+,=\#78'.q#)'+gSU!(3.t)'!)0:^,="%$&'4 > +
&
')(
*,+(
-
r9
78'. > 73+1. k .%!:0:5+9%."%+1.%9<,=)&9 7I,MW')V2',=)'. C(T ) )'+H.%!)K9
#
,='/#)b:5!:5+)K9)'!) 7
:^,="%$K'41. > +9 )[email protected]!)&9M2#+L/1+GSU,=(89 ,=:^,=(3./1!:0#9%4L!#"H#)'+L(89%4"<,=9(3!)R2#+L7I,0e!'/73+ > !)'/ 7I,Ve!'/73+\)'41/1+1.%.(89%+\e#(3+)a,=]#(8"%+
> [email protected]]7I,/1!:0#73+ (89%4
n − k (89%4"<,=9(3!)'.
>
,=)#)'!)'/141+
2
•a”–— ˜
' (
G
l )VN"<,=#O'+L/1!)#)'+ +
G +9 T > +)'.%+:Je#73+M(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9:^, (8:^,=7‹2#+
:
7
f ( r (
C(T ) .%. 2#+\#)/%O'+:0(8) %. !"9<,=)&9 > jk(87+ (3.%9%+\#)/%O'+:0(8)c.<!"
9<,=)&9ml > .%(8)'!)Vjk-,!.2#+G/%O'+:0(8)R.%!"9<,=)&9ml
!#"%$ * " 4 !#" /<O-,!$&'+L.%!:0:5+9
Y
u 2#+ G \ (T ∪ C(T )) Sf,=(8"%+
-,="9(8"q2#+ +9q2',=)'.
u
G\T > :^,="%$K'+"t73+1.q.%!:0:5+9%. 7f?[,=(32#+g2C? #)\-,="%/1!#"%.
r ([email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+J2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.*:^,="%$K'41.H2#+
+)T7I,="NB+#"H2C?[,=ep!"%2 p
C(T ) )[email protected]+1.%9
-,!.#)'+L/78(3$K'+ > .%9%!#p+"H+9 "%+9%!#")'+"jk(87`+ (3.9%+G#)/%O'+:0(8)o.%!"9<,=)K9ml Bo (8)
2;jfSU,=(8"%+sl '
r ( ,='/#)c.%!:0:5+9 u )Z?[,+":0(3.L2#+^.9%!#p+" > .9%!#+"L+9G"%+9%!#")'+"Ljk-,!.
2#+h/%O'+:0(8).<!"9<,=)&9ml
f & " (
O(m(n − k)) k +1.%9*73+h)'!:Le#"%+J2#+h.%!:0:5+9%.H2#+ C(T )
Œ 7p+1.9/7I,=(8"g$&'+H)'!9"%+,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M+1.9g/1!);S !":5+M,= .41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'. ')(*,+(
_ ! )'.(32#4"%+"*9%!'.73+1..%!:0:5+9%.
u 2#+ G \ (T ∪ C(T )) )'41/1+1.%.(89%+h,=#(8"%+ O(n − k)
49<,=+1. q! +-,="%/1!#"%.+)57I,="NB+#"2C?[,=ep!"%2^)'41/1+1.%.(89%+H,=5#(8"%+ O(m) 49<,=p+1. +1.9%+"
.([email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+V2#+1.L.%!:0:5+9%.J:^,="%$K'41.J2#+ C(T ) )[email protected]+1.9L-,!.L#)'+^/78(3$K'+0)'41/1+1.%.(89%+
,=#(8"%+ O(m) 49<,=p+1. 5> [email protected],5/1!:0#73+ (89%4L,=)#)'!)'/141+ 2
&
•a”–— ˜ ˜
l )DN"<,=#O'+
G +9 T > +)'.%+:Le#73+d(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9^:^, (8:^,=7 2#+ G 9%+7
$&Z? (87Z+ 3( .9%+h#)/<O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)K9p!#" C(T )
' f ( l )T#78'. /1!#"9H/%O'+:0(8)R.%!"9<,=)&9 !#"%$ * " 4 !#"9%!#9.%!:0:5+9
u ∈ C(T ) > !)5/Q,=73/#73+H2',=)'. G \ (T ∪ (N (u) ∩
-,="9(8"\2#+ u +9J2#!)&9J7f?[,=#9"%+b+ 9"%4:0(89%4
C(T ))) #)#78'.X/1!#"9J/<O'+:0(8)
8
=Z
‰ )"%+9%!#")'+\#)o/%O'+:0(8)2#+
v +1.%92',=)'. C(T ) .( #)9%+7q/%O'+:0(8)]+ (3.9%+
73!)#N'+#"H:0(8)#(8:^,=73+h-,=":0(‹/1+1. /%O'+:0(8)'.
f & " (
' (
O(nm)
Œ 7C+1.9*/7I,=(8"$K'+ )'!9"%+G,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L+1.9/1!);S !":5+G,= .41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'.
')(*,+(
8 )'!9%!)'.$K'+-,="*O % p!9O : <. + (87Z+ (3.9%+#)T/%O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)&9 = _ !)'.%(32#4"%+"9%!'.73+1.
>
.%!:0:5+9%.2#+ C(T ) )'41/1+1.%.(89%+h,=b#(8"%+ n 49<,=+1. /! +/Q,=73/#72;V#78'.*/1!#"9/%O'+:0(8)
)'41/1+1.%.%(89%+L,=T#(8"%+
49<,=+1. [email protected],\/1!:0#73+ (89%4J,=)#)'!)'/141+ &
O(m)
•a”–— ˜
>
2
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G 2C? "9%4:0(3. > T > +)'.%+:Le#73+L(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9:^, (8:^,=7‹2#+
G +9 Z /%O'+:0(8).<!"9<,=)&9H2#+h73!)#N'+#"H:0(8)#(8:^,=73+G!#" C(T )
l )'+M-,=(8"%+L2C?[,=:0(3.H.41/(I,=73+G2#+ ' f (
' (
G
` gH1 R
M
5
rj
‰ €
) )'!9%+ z 7f? #)'+c2#+1.+ 9"%4:0(89%41.2; /%O'+:0(8) .%!"9<,=)&9 > +9 z
1
k
7f?[,=#9"%+0+ 9"%4:0(89%4 Z‰ )]/Q,=73/#73+X73+1.M+)'.%+:Le#73+1. A +9 B Y A [email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+
2#+1.H.%!:0:5+9%.H2#+ C(T ) $K#(Z2#+ Z )'+hAB!(89 $&'+ z > B $&'+ z 1
k
4 !#"L9%!#9M.<!:0:5+9
a 2#+ A /Q,=73/#73+"h#)o#78'.h/1!#"9G/%O'+:0(8)2#+ a AB+"%. B
2',=)'. G \ (T ∪ (N (a) \ A)) -r ( #)9%+7C/%O'+:0(8)T)[email protected]+ (3.9%+ -,!. > "%+9%+)#(8"j a +1.%9
:^, (8:^,=7žl B> +G: 2 :5+ > !#"H9%!#9H.<!:0:5+9 b 2#+ B /Q,=73/#73+"H#)#78'./1!#"9
/%O'+:0(8)62#+ B \ b AB+"%. A 2',=)'. G \ (T ∪ (N (b) \ B)) r (#)9%+7/%O'+:0(8)
)[email protected]+ (3.%9%+L-,!. > "%+9%+)#(8"Hj b +1.9:^, (8:^,=7žl ‰ )R"%+9%!#")'+X#)'+L-,=(8"%+ {a, b} a +1.%9*#)4734:5+)&9H:^, (8:^,=7‹2#+ A > +9 b 2#+ B
#" $
5
"
*
"
&
(
f
O(nm)
> ?[,=#" : .Z7I,*#"%+#AB+2;G9O'41!" : :5+ j A6 #)L4734:5+)&9
>
a ∈ A +1.9C:^, (8:^,=7
p!#"7I,h"%+7I,=9(3!) < .( +9g.%+#73+:5+)&9*.Q? (87')[email protected]+ (3.9%+ -,!.2#+ /%O'+:0(8) P 2#+ a AB+"%. B
A
i )o+ # +9 2C?[,=#" : .73+G73+:0:5+ jAj #)R9%+7 /<O'+:0(8)
p
2',=)'.
&
')(
*,+(
-
G \ (T ∪ (N (a) \ A))
P
>
>
%/ O'!(3.(;2#+73!)#N'+#" :0(8)#(8:^,=73++1.9`2#+73!)#N'+#" (8:0-,=(8"%+ > +9t.%!)L#)#(3$K'+.%!:0:5+9 a0
AB % ,=)&9 a AB4"(žW-+ a0 > a > !)'/ > .%( a +1.9g:^, (8:^,=7 > #)9%+7C/%O'+:0(8)T)[email protected]+ (3.9%+-,!. >
A
+9"%41/(8#"%F$&'+:5+)K9 > .(#)V9%+7/<O'+:0(8))[email protected]+ (3.9%+H-,!. > a +1.9:^, (8:^,=7 5- !9%!)'.g$K'+
2C?[,=#" : .M7I,^#"%+#AB+02;]9O'41!" : :5+ jA6 > (87q+ (3.9%+Xe#(3+)o#)4734:5+)&9h:^, (8:^,=7qp!#"
B> +L: 2 :5+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+\2#49%+1/9%+"<,
>
<A > $K'+G7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+\2#49%+1/9%+"<,5S !"%/14:5+)K9
e#(3+)5#)b.%!:0:5+9 b :^, (8:^,=7-!#" < Bi 92C?[,=#" : .73+*73+:0:5+ jAd > {a, b} +1.9e#(3+)
B
.%+1.
#)'+5-,=(8"%+V2C?[,=:0(3.X.%p41/(I,=73+V2#+ G > !)'/5)'!9"%+,=78NB!"(89O#:5+V+1.%9J/1!);SU!":5+
.p41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'. _ ,=73/#73+"M73+1.+)'.<+:Le#73+1.
! +J/Q,=73/#7
A +9 B )'41/1+1.%.(89%+\,=R#78'. O(m) 49<,=+1.
2#+1.#78'./1!#"9%./%O'+:0(8)'.g#"%+)'2078#(,='.%.( ,=5#78'. m 49<,=p+1. > +9,=^#(8"%+H/1+/Q,=73/#7
+1.9
SU,=(8"%+ n SU!(3. 5! ,0/1!:0#73+ (89%4G+1.9 2#!)'/he#(3+) O(nm) 2
•”–C— ˜
"
(
l )TN"<,=#O'+G2C? "9%4:0(3.
G
f
l
'
(
) +M-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3.H.%p41/(I,=73+h2#+ G !Tj G +1.%9*#)'+G/78(3$&'+sl '
#" $ * " ‰ )T(8)&ABF$&'+G7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ jAr-r ? (87Z"%+9%!#")'+j
G +1.9*#)'+G/78(3$K'+sl >
2
H
r
!)"%+9%!#")'+o7I, : :5+]/%O'.%+
? (87M"%+9%!#")'+]#)'+o-,=(8"%+o2C?[,=:0(3..%p41/(I,=73+
r ? (87`"%+9%!#")'+J#)+)'.%+:Je#73+X(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9
2#+ G > !)d7I,^"%+9%!#")'+J4N&,=73+:5+)K9 Z
:^, (8:^,=7 T > ,=73!"%.V!) (8)&ABF$K'+d7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ jQ r ? (87 "%4!)'2Dj 4 ,!.2#+
/%O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)K9ml ,=73!"%.M!)R(8)&ABF$&'+J"%41/#"%.(8AB+:5+)K9h7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. .#"
' >
73+5N"<,=#O'+ G[C(T )] > $K#()'!'.J"%+9%!#")'+"<,d#)'+5-,=(8"%+V2C?[,=:0(3.J.41/(I,=73+^2#+
pr ? (87‹"%+9%!#")'+Gjk(87‹+ (3.9%+h#)R/%O'+:0(8)o.%!"9<,=)&9ml
G[C(T )] $K'[email protected]!)"%+9%!#")'+
>
,=73!"%.H!)(8)&ABF$&'+h7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j $K#(Z)'!'.*SU!#")#(89H#)/%O'+:0(8).<!"9<,=)&9
2#+73!)#N'+#"b:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > ##(3.^7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j.6 $K#()'!'.^"%+9%!#")'+d#)'+
-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3.H.%p41/(I,=73+G2#+ G > $&'[email protected]!)"%+9%!#")'+ "
&
(
f
O(nm)
> ,=)'.X7I,T#"%+#AB+2; 9 O'41!" : :5+ jA6 !) ,T:5!)K9"%4T$&'+b.Q? (87 % , #)
>
+)'.%+:Le#73+J(8)&9%4"%+1.%.P,=)&9M:^, (8:^,=7 T + 9 -,!. 2#+J/%O'+:0(8)o.%!"9<,=)&9p!#" C(T ) > ,=37 !"%.
&
')(
*,+(
-
#)'+-,=(8"%+*2C?[,=:0(3..41/(I,=73+*2#+ G[C(T )] +1.9q4N&,=73+:5+)&9#)'+-,=(8"%+*2C?[,=:0(3..p41/(I,=73+
r*
2#+ G 5> !)'/h)'!9"%+J,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L+1.9*e#(3+)d/1!);SU!":5+
.<+1.*.p41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'. ‰ )]A,b:5!)&9"%+"J-,="(8)'2;'/9(3!)c.#"
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. )'4 7
n $KZ? #)a,=#+7
t
r
/1+1.%.%(89%+b,=a#(8"%+ O(nm) 49<,=+1.J2#+b/Q,=73/#7
##.%!)'.X$&'+b/1+7I,d.%!(89JAK"<,=(p!#"
9%!'.X73+1.XN"<,=#O'+1.0,1AB+1/T,=c#78'. n − 1 .<!:0:5+9%. ‰ )6,=#+7873+^7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+T.%#"
#)RN"<,=#O'+0,1AB+1/ n .%!:0:5+9%. Cr ( 73+LN"<,=#O'+\+1.9 #)'+X/78(3$K'+ > !R.Q? (87t,5#)o/%O'+:0(8)
.%!"9<,=)K9 > ,=73!"%.L(87)Z? % ,-,!.X2C?[,=#p+7g"%41/#"%.(žS > +9X7f?[,=#p+7,= ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1. j
+9 j.6 )'41/1+1.%.(89%+*,=\#(8"%+ O(nm) 49<,=+1. Br ? (87F)Z? % ,-,!.q2#+/<O'+:0(8)5.%!"9<,=)&9 > ,=73!"%.
!))'!9%+ k 7I,L9<,=(87873+h2#+ C(T ) /! ?[,=#p+7Z,= ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1. jAr +9 jQ )'41/1+1.%.%(89%+M,=
#(8"%+ O((n − k)m) 49<,=p+1. > +95-,="^O % !9O : .%+d2C? (8)'2;'/9(3!) > 7f?[,=#+7"%41/#"%.(žS
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. )'41/1+1.%.%(89%+ ,=^#(8"%+ O(km) 49<,=p+1. > /1+H$K#('9%!9<,=78(3.%+He#(3+) O(nm)
49<,=+1. 2
•a”–— ˜F
' (
' f (
2#+ G
!#"%$
&
*
"
l )TN"<,=#O'+L2C? "9%4:0(3. G
l )'+M/1!73!"<,=9(3!)!#9(8:^,=73+M2#+
G +9#)'+M/78(3$K'+2#+9<,=(87873+:^, (8:^,=73+
_ !73!"<,=9(3!) Y !)0(8)&ABF$&'+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j.&r ('/1+78#( 7 /('"%4!)'2Xj
G +1.9t#)'+
‹
r
/78(3$&'+sl > !)/1!73!"%+ G 9"(8AF(I,=73+:5+)&9
(8)'!) > 9<,=)&9M$&[email protected]!))[email protected]!e#9(3+)&9M-,!. #)'+
/78(3$&'+ > !)T/1!)&9"<,!/9%+h7I,J-,=(8"%+M2C?[,=:0(3."%+9%!#")'41+M-,="*7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. > +9
!)V,=#+7873+
)'!#AB+Q,=V7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. .#"73+HN"<,=#O'+M/1!)&9"<,!/9%4 -,=)'2
/%O-,!$K'+L.<!:0:5+9 2#+ G 7I,
!),=""(8AB+
#)'+J/78(3$&'+L2#+h9<,=(87873+ ω > !)d2#!)#)'+
/1!#73+#"H2#+G.%!)T"%+#"%41.%+)K9<,=)&9M2',=)'.*7I,0/78(3$K'+ _ 78(3$&'+0:^, (8:^,=73+ Y !):^,="%$&'+^9%!'.G73+1.J.%!:0:5+9%.L2#+07I,/78(3$&'+ ##(3.L!)
>
"%+12#41/1!)&9"<,!/9%+d/<O-,!$&'+-,=(8"%+T2C?[,=:0(3. {a, b} > +) )'+7I,=(3.<.<,=)&90:^,="%$K'4T$&'+
/1+78#(2#+1.X2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.0$K#(g,QAB+1/V73+1.\,=#9"%+1.\.%!:0:5+9%.\:^,="%$K'41.X(8)'2;#(89
#)'+ /78(3$K'+9<,=(87873+ ω l )'+*SU!(3.9%!#9%+1.g73+1.-,=(8"%+1.2#41/1!)K9"<,!/9%41. > !)^"%+9%!#")'+
[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+J2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$K'41. ')(*,+(
"
&
-
(
f
O(n2 m)
> ?[,=#" : .h73+1.M#"%!#"(349%41.L2#+1.h-,=(8"%+1.L2C?[,=:0(3.G.41/(I,=73+1. 8 73+:0:5+ j<=
>
73+1.R/1!)&9"<,!/9(3!)'.o2#+-,=(8"%+1.R2C?[,=:0(3.R.p41/(I,=73+1./1!)'2;#(3.%+)&9oe#(3+)
#)'+a/78(3$K'+ > ?[,=#" : .\73+1.0+ #78(3/Q,=9(3!)'.52#+V7I,.<+1/9(3!)62C? (8)K9"%K2;'/9(3!) ,= N"<,=#O'+1.0-,="mSf,=(89%+ 7
:5+)K9 /1!)&9"<,!/9(873+1. 8 .%+1/9(3!) A6q= > 73+h9O'41!" : :5+J2#+ o !)#78##9+9 l O#" % )'!9<,=:0:5+)K9
8 9O'41!" : :5+ <= 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+V/1!)'2;#(89Le#(3+)
#)'+^/1!73!"<,=9(3!)c!#9(8:^,=73+^2#+ G
>
+9
#)'+0/78(3$K'+02#+\9<,=(87873+\:^, (8:^,=73+52#+ G ! [email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+52#+1.L.%!:0:5+9%.h:^,="%$K'41.
"%+9%!#")'41.
7I,TW') 2#[email protected]+ 41/#9(3!)6(8)'2;#(89\e#(3+)6#)'+b/78(3$K'+2#+^9<,=(87873+V:^, (8:^,=73+
2#+ G R#(8"%+ (87`Sf,=#9
#)'+
>
O(n) /1!)&9"<,!/9(3!)'.G2#+J-,=(8"%+1.M2C?[,=:0(3.Mp!#"-,="AB+)#(8"
/78(3$K'+ > [email protected],\/1!:0#73+ (89%4J,=)#)'!)'/141+ 2
- !'.,QAB!)'.2#!)'/He#(3+)5#)b,=78NB!"(89O#:5+2#+/1!73!"<,=9(3!)b2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3.
‰ )op+#9 Sf,!/(873+:5+)&9h:5F2;(žW-+"M/1+9h,=78NB!"(89O#:5+02#+J:^, 7
2#+\/1!:0#734 (89%4 O(n2 m) C
:
)#( "%+
78#(ZSf,=(8"%+L,!/1/1+#9%+")Z? (8:0p!"9%+J$&'+7`N"<,=#O'+L+)R+)&9"%41+ ! +L.%+#7‹#"%!e#7 : :5+
M
` 5
M)5q Z
M#FgT R
`
5
rq(
+1.9X$K'+.#"\#)6N"<,=#O'+T$&#(g)[email protected]+1.9\-,!.02C? "9%4:0(3. > (87g"(3.<$&'+V2#+V)'+-,!.X+ (3.9%+"
[email protected]:5+)&9G:^, (8:^,=7qp!#"h73+1.h!"%2;"%+1. < +9 < no,=(3.G,=73!"%.G!)op+#9h9%! !#"%.
A
B
"%+9%!#")'+"J#)'+b-,=(8"%+^$K'+73/1!)'$&'+V2#+^.<!:0:5+9%. 8 9<,=)K9J:0(3+ .%(/[email protected]+1.9J#)'+^-,=(8"%+
2C?[,=:0(3. =! ,G#O-,!.<+HW')-,=73+M2#+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M"(3.%$K'+,=73!"%.2#+M/1!)&9"<,!/9%+"2#+1.g-,=(8"%+1.
$&#()'+M.%!)&9-,!.*2#+1.-,=(8"%+1.2C?[,=:0(3. > /1+h$K#(Z,=#"<,Jp!#"*/1!)'.%41$K'+)'/1+h$&'+7I,\/1!73 7
"<,=9(3!)bW')-,=73+M)'+M.%+"<,J-,!.gSU!"%/14:5+)&9H!#9(8:^,=73+ > +9*$K'[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+h"%+9%!#")'4
7I,
W')X)'+.%+"<, -,!.`SU!"%/14:5+)&9#)'+/78(3$K'+ no,=(3.t(87#.%+p+#9t9" : .te#(3+)0$&'+g:^,=78N"%49%!#9
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+0"%+9%!#")'+\#)'+\/1!73!"<,=9(3!)c,1AB+1/ ω /1!#73+#"%.h+9h#)'+\/78(3$&'+\2#+\9<,=(87873+
ω > ,='$&'+7‹/Q,!. !),=#"<,07I,5/1+"9(89'2#+J$K'+G/[email protected]+1.9e#(3+)#)'+G/1!73!"<,=9(3!)o!#9(8:^,=73+L+9
#)'+#78'.N"<,=)'2#+ /78(3$&'+ 8 .<,=)'. 2 9"%+ . #"$K'+*73+HN"<,=#O'+H2#+H2#4-,="9g+1.92C? "9%4:0(3. =
- !9"%+T,=78NB!"(89O#:5+T+1.902#!)'/V"%!e#'.9%+ Y !6e#(3+) (87*2#!)#)'+#)'+/1!73!"<,=9(3!) !#9( 7
:^,=73++9g#)'+M/78(3$&'+M2#+ 9<,=(87873+:^, (8:^,=73+ > !Ve#(3+)(872#!)#)'+(872#!)#)'+h,=#9"%+/<O'.%+ >
+95!) ,d7I,o/1+"9(89'2#+d$&'+73+N"<,=#O'+2#!)#)'4T+)D+)K9"%41+T)[email protected]<,=(895-,!.52C? "9%4:0(3. > ,=)'.*/1+h2#+")#(3+"/Q,!. #)'+M9"<,!/1+h/1!:0#7 : 9%+G2#[email protected]+ 41/#9(3!)+1.9#)!e +92#+M9<,=(87873+
>
p!7 % )'!:0(I,=73+\$&#(t/1+"9(žW-+\$&'+J73+XN"<,=#O'+X+)o+)&9"%41+\)[email protected]<,=(89M-,!.M2C? "9%4:0(3. _l )'+
$&'+1.9(3!)a(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9%+.%+"<,=(89L2#+^.P,1AB!(8"J.%(
-,="9(8"\2#+5/1+9J!e +9J/1!:0#73+ + > !)
p+#9g"%+9"%!#AB+"gSU,!/(873+:5+)K9g#)V9"%!(8:0-,=(8" > #),=)K9(89"%!!V#)V#"(3.:5+ 8 +)b9%!#9
/Q,!./1+7I,\+#9 2 9"%+MSU,=(892;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)K9 N" !/1+J,= ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.2;/%O-,=#(89"%+ *q=
vMw
:
J~ 1X}X†`}q~„
:
J|€J}q~€~: X
1
~&† ‡%z~-~ }q~V
1
|6 ‚ƒ{<~
- !'.h,=)-,=7 % .%!)'.(3/(t)'!9"%+J#"%+#AB+\2',=)'.73+\/Q,!2;"%+X"%+1.9"%+(8)&9h2#+1.9"%!(3.h/7I,!.%.%+1.
2#+MN"<,=#O'+1.-,="mSf,=(89%+:5+)&9M/1!)&9"<,!/9(873+1.2#4sW')#(3+1.-,=NB+1. d j6
!#" $
- !9"%+#"%+#AB+2;G9O'41!" : :5+ jA6 "%+1.%.%+:Le#73+ep+Q,='/1!# I7 ,#"%+#AB+/7I,!.%.%(3$&'+q2#+
f7 [email protected]+ 3( .9%+)'/1+L2C? #)'+h-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3.H2',=)'.H73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.H2#+Ln+ % #
) (3+7 1- !'.*"%+12#!)#)'!)'.
/1+99%+h#"%+#AB+L,1AB+1/G)'.)'!9<,=9(3!)'. GFI^¤HNJPBYZG¥ Z/. Z\I1SVZK ^ S
I¦ Za`U
™(' ” )+* ” -, œ #
Ÿ ¡£¢^ ES U
&% •a”R–C—˜#–
§
G
G
E` %` $%¥ Z F
G I_Z5JS H ZX¥‹¦ JPS `
J9`@GFI_ZJ‘&K S  G1Za]"JKEHa`
G
§
‰ )#"%F/ : 2#+0-,="h"%41/#""%+)'/1+ tr (
G ,V:5!(8)'.G2#+09"%!(3.G.<!:0:5+9%. > .(
!(8)K9%+2#+V/78(3$K'+1. 73+b73+:0:5+V+1.%9X9"(8AF(I,=7 1
+
.
\
9
#)
'
V
+
/
8
7
3
(
&
$
'+
!
6
#)
'
V
+
%
"
4
#)
#
3
(
!
)
;
2
3
(
.
>
G
r (8)'!) .%!(89
4
%
:
>
T #)6+)'.%+:Le#73+V(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)&90$K'+73/1!)'$&'+V2#+ G ,="XO p!9O .%+V2#+
:
"%41/#""%+)'/1+ > (87-+ (3.9%+*#)'+-,=(8"%+H2C?[,=:0(3.g2#+ G[C(T )] no,=(3.2C?[,=#" .73+73+:0:5+ 1Aj >
/1+99%+h-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3.+1.9,='.%.(C#)'+M-,=(8"%+G2C?[,=:0(3. 2#+ G 2
&
')(
*,+(
-
- !9%!)'.H$&'+G.%(Z!)+ 41/#9%+h7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. .#"#)TN"<,=#O'+J2#+hn+ % )#(3+7 7I,
>
/1!)&9"<,!/9(3!)o2#+h7I,X-,=(8"%+L2C?[,=:0(3.H"%+9%!#")'41+G)'+h"%+12#!)#)'+L-,!.*9%! !#"%.H#)N"<,=#O'+
2#+RnR+ % )#(3+7 8 AB!(8"VW'N#"%+ F="4 !#"T73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.T2#+R$K-,!.( 7 nR+ % )#(3+7 > )'!'.)'+
.<,1AB!)'.*-,!. /1+h$&Z? (87`+)+1.9 rd
#
"$ !
#$
" !
r (Z!).%p41/(I,=78(3.%+)'!9"%+h#"%+#AB+G,= N"<,=#O'+1.Sf,=(8e#73+:5+)&99"(I,=)#N#7341. =, 73!"%.!)
>
!e#9(3+)K9H#)'+h)'!#AB+7873+h#"%+#AB+J2C? #),=)'/(3+)"%41.#789<,=9 Y [email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+L2C? #)'+ $6 7 ,=(8"%+ ™ ) , * , ' ) , œ3–'Ÿ;¡£¢^_ESTU
G/I ¤H[PJ  YZ
4 &% •”o–— ˜FŸ
G
M&JSVQKZP ZI U U HSWJIK¤G/K8Š  G/S IC¦ Za`UJ` G/I ZX‘K S  5
G Z ¨ K EH `
E9` ` $¥ Z G/I Z Ž8JS H Z
G
2
§
§
r
& ')(*,+(
( G +1.%9X#)'+V"%4#)#(3!)D2;(3. !(8)&9%+T2C?[,= :5!(8)'.02#+
/78(3$&'+1. > ,=73!"%.
9%!#9%+*-,=(8"%+H2#+.%!:0:5+9%.)'!)^,!2 ,!/1+)&9%.SU!":5+#)'+ 27 -,=(8"%+ Fr (8)'!) > !)^/1!)'.%(32 : "%+
#) +)'.%+:Le#73+V(8)&9%4"%+1.<.<,=)&9X:^, (8:^,=7 T > ?[,=#" : .J73+573+:0:5+ 1A* > (87)Z? % ,T-,!.X2#+
/<O'+:0(8) .%!"9<,=)K9L!#" C(T ) 4 ,="XO % p!9O : .%+^2#+5"%41/#""%+)'/1+ > !)c9"%!#AB+5#)'+ 27
-,=(8"%+ {u, v} 2#+ G[C(T )] nR,=(3. {u, v} +1.9g,='.%.(##)'+ 6$7 -,=(8"%+ 2#+ G > ##(3.%$K'+*9%!#9
/<O'+:0(8)a+)&9"%+ u +9 v -,!.%.<,=)&9h-,=" T +1.9G2#+X73!)#N'+#" 6 +9M##(3.%$KZ? (87q)Z? % ,V-,!.
2#+G/<O'+:0(8).%!"9<,=)K9!#"
C(T )
2
! ,€#"%+#AB+ 2; 9O'41!" : :5+/( 7 2#+1.%.'. :5!)K9"%+$&'+ .(!) ,=##78(3$K'+ 7f?[,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ j.p #)0N"<,=#O'+Sf,=(8e#73+:5+)&99"(I,=)#N#734 > ,=73!"%.7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ 2#+"%+1/%O'+"%/%O'+
2#+1.G4734:5+)K9%.G:^, (8:^,= !#"h73+1.G+)'.%+:Je#73+1. A +9 B 8 ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j.6q= )[email protected]+1.9
,=:^,=(3.b,=#+734##(3.%$KZ? (87)Z? % ,]-,!.b2#+/%O'+:0(8) .%!"9<,=)K9 Π7H+1.9^+) Sf,=(895(8)K#9(873+
2C?[,=#+73+"h73+1.L,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.G2#+\"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+^2#+\/<O'+:0(8)a.%!"9<,=)&9 8 ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1. jQ
‰ )6+1.%9J2#!)'/!e#78(8NB4$&'!($&Z? (87*,=""(8AB+2C?[,=#p+73+"\"%41/#"%.(8AB+:5+)K907f?[,=7 7
+9 j<=
NB!"(89O#:5+ j.i /%O-,!$K'+dSU!(3. > !)ˆ2#!(89V"%+1/%O'+"%/%O'+"T#) +)'.%+:Je#73+(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9
:^, (8:^,=7 8 ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ jArq=q> !)'/7I,h/1!:0#73+ (89%49%!9<,=73+H2#+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j. +1.9
‰ )V)' 7
(8)'/<O-,=)#NB41+M: 2 :5+.%(p!)V73+"%+1.9"%+(8)&9,= N"<,=#O'+1.gSf,=(8e#73+:5+)&9*9"(I,=)#N#7341. '
$
6
7
9%+"<,*/1++)'2',=)&9t$K'+q7I,-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3.‹"%+9%!#")'41++1.9C9%! !#"%.Z#)'+
-,=(8"%+ > ##(3.%$K'+
9%!#9%+h-,=(8"%+L2#+G.%!:0:5+9%.*)'!) 7 ,!2 ,!/1+)&9%.2C? #)'+h"%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)K9%+G2#+G/78(3$K'+1.+1.9
#)'+2#+ F7 -,=(8"%+ u ,=#+73!)'.`4N&,=73+:5+)K9 9(89"%+2#+/1!:0-,="<,=(3.%!)\$&'+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
73+J#78'.Mp+"mSU!":^,=)&9
/1+ !#"Mp!#"M/1!73!"(3+"M73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.SU,=(8e#73+:5+)K9h9"(I,=)#N#7341.
% ,="%2 r #(8)#"<,!2+9 r "(89O-,="<,=) 'Ajq(<+T=
,X!#"H/1!:0#73+ (89%4
2 8 , >
O(n + m )
#
"
!
!#!$ - !9"%+g#"%+#AB+2#+7I,H-,="mSU,=(89%+/1!)K9"<,!/9(878(89%42#+1. N"<,=#O'+1.q2C? "9%4:0(3.t2#!)#)'+g#)'+
#"%+#AB+L9%!9<,=73+:5+)&9)'!#AB+7873+G!#"73+G/Q,!.*-,="9(3/#78(3+"M2#+1.*N"<,=#O'+1. -,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K9
!"%2#!)#)-,=e#73+1. )'!9"%+L/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+ > /1+99%+G#"%+#AB+L)'+hNB4)'4"<,=78(3.%+J,='/#)o,=)'/(3+)
"%41.#789<,=9 - !9%!)'.$K'+*.(#)'!'.,=##78(3$K'!)'.7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j.
#)0N"<,=#O'+*-,="mSf,=( 7
9%+:5+)K9g!"%2#!)#)-,=e#73+ > ,=73!"%.)'!'.)'+p!#AB!)'.-,!.N&,="<,=)&9(8"$K'+7I,h/1!)&9"<,!/9(3!)T2#+
7I,H-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3. "%+9%!#")'41+2#!)#)'+#)J)'!#AB+Q,=\N"<,=#O'+-,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K9!"%2#!)#)-,=e#73+ vMwmv
X2:*|,;‚ƒ}q~J}
8
Xq†:H‚
„ :
~-{ 6 { :
}
6
„Xz{%|p}q~
fz ‚ƒ{%~
- !'.V2#!)#)'!)'.b(3/(2#+1.V9O'41!" : :5+1.V2#+2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!) !#"^73+1.V/7I,!.%.%+1.V2#+
_ +1.9O'41!" : :5+1.*.%!)K9
N"<,=#O'+1.(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)&9%+1.H2;V!(8)&9*2#+AF'+2#+1.g-,=(8"%+1.*2C?[,=:0(3. '
9%!'.G4)'!)'/141.G#"%+1.%$&'+0+ #78(3/(89%+:5+)&9 8 +9Me#(3+)a.#"h2#4:5!)&9"%41. = 2',=)'.h7I,V#"%+#AB+
a
gRM
g
*F1 rr
2 9O'41!" : :5+hSU!"9H2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1. -,="mSf,=(89%. 'A6+ > +9H)'!'.)'+G!#AB!)'.H2#!)'/L-,!.*73+1.
;
"%+AB+)'2;(3$&'+"p!#") !9"%+1. - !'.M,1AB!)'.9%!#9M2C?[,=ep!"%2e+1.%!(8)R2C? #)R+9(89H73+:0:5+
9%+1/%O#)#(3$K'+ Y
¨ K EHa`
^ ES U
KZ K STI ZsŽ¤HNJPBYZ0¥‹¦ [email protected]`G5Q%¥S <S `S EI QS[JHU SVZ\¥ Z
G
K4 §
E G QSVZI
Za`U
ZU
‘ EI U SVZI U G/I^ HaS `aPRZ ª «$] EG QSVZI
‘ EI U SVZ I U
G
L(K3,3 \ e)
G
C6
G
GFI^BHS `P Z K EIK¤
“”K•c•”o–— ˜
§
7
‰ )c.%##p.%+^$&'+
G +1.9G73+^78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+2C? #)aN"<,=#O'+ R +9J$K'+ R
+1.9*#)'+G.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)e#(8-,="9(3+L2C? #) K 2#!)&9 !))'!9%+G73+1..<!:0:5+9%. a, b, c, d ‰ )
4
/%O'!(3.(89h#)'+0,=" 2 9%+02; K .#e2;(8AK(3.<41+X+)o#)/<O'+:0(8)2#+\73!)#N'+#"h:^, (8:^,=73+
4
.<,=)'.gp+"9%+M2#+MNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > !)T.##.%+M$&'+ ab +1.9*/%O'!(3.%(3+ 5! ?[,=" 2 9%+ ab 2; K +1.9
4
2#!)'/G.#e2;(8AK(3.%41+L+)#)d/%O'+:0(8)o2#+h73!)#N'+#"h,=:5!(8)'. 6 > ,=)'. R > (87‹+ (3.9%+h#)
#)#(3$&'+/%O'+:0(8)b2#+ a AB+"%. b $K#(;)'+-,!.<.%+g-,!.t-,=" c, d Y !)\)'!9%[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+H2#+g.<+1.
,=" 2 9%+ E 'Œ 7‹+ (3.9%+h#)#)#(3$K'+G/<O'+:0(8)R2#+ a AB+"%. b $K#(Z-,!.%.<+h-,=" c .<,=)'.*-,!.<.%+"
0
-,=" d Y !)T)'!9%[email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+G2#+M.%+1.,=" 2 9%+1. E #i );W')!)T)'!9%+ E [email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+G2#+1.
c
d
,=" 2 9%+1.G2#+X7f? #)#(3$&'+5/<O'+:0(8)a2#+ R -,!.<.<,=)&9G-,=" d .<,=)'.M-,!.%.%+"h-,=" c Z‰ )]AB4"(žW-+
$&'+ E ∪ E ∪ E > $&#(t+#9 2 9"%+XAFR/1!:0:5+\#)o+)'.%+:Le#73+02#+\.%!:0:5+9%.M2#+ G >
0
c
d
(8)'2;#(89#)V#"(3.:5+M2#+ G 'r (/1+H#"(3.:5+ )[email protected]+1.9g-,!. C > !).<,=9(3.mSf,=(89#)'+/1!)'/78'.(3!)
6
2;T73+:0:5+ r (‹/1+M#"(3.:5+G+1.%9 C > ,=73!"%.73+1..%+#73+1.H,=" 2 9%+G.%#ep2;(8AF(3.%41+1.2; K .%!)&9
6
4
2
:
ab +9 cd > 7f?[,=" 9%+ ab )[email protected]+1.9^.#e2;(8AF(3.%41+T$&Z? #)'+d.%+#73+SU!(3. > +9 > 2C?[,=#" .573+d/%O'!(
2
L
>
(8)#(89(I,=72#+ ab > 7f?[,=" 9%+ cd )[email protected]+1.%9\+7873+,='.<.(g.%#ep2;(8AF(3.%41+$&Z? #)'+T.<+#73+^SU!(3.
!)'/ >
+
9
!
d
)
<
.
=
,
9
3
(
m
.
f
S
=
,
8
(
*
9
f
7
[
?
=
,
#9
%
"
G
+
1
/
!
'
)
/
8
7
'.
3
(
!
d
)
;
2
d7
3
+
0
:
5
:
+
R = K \ e>
2
&
')(
*,+(
-
3,3
!(3/(Z#)T9O'41!" : :5+L$K#(C"%41.#:5+h73+1.#"%!#"(349%41. 2#+1.*N"<,=#O'+1. 2C? "9%4:0(3. Y
•a”R–C—˜
^ ESTU
G/I ¤HNJs YZ Za`  G5JU H ZdBH[EPBHSUŠ&UkŠa``aG/S 9JI U,Za``&EI U
G
§
Š /
G S $JKZIBU,Za`0©
ª J«
Za`Ug¥‹¦ ¨ HUkŠPS `
G
§
ªQ«
I ZL‘ EI U SVZI U I1S U HNEG S P JS Ha] I1S JI U S U HNEG K EIK¤9] I1SpBHS `aPRZ
G
§
ª ‘£«
EG/HUVEG/Ui`&EGF`PŽ¤ HNJPBYZSTI ¥G/S U 0 ¥FZ ]‹5EGFHUVEGU ZI5`.ZPRQK?Z
JI U SU‘ EI-Ž
G
G
T
I Z FZ¥ Z 0 ]@EG QSWZI
Za`U GFI Zd‘K S  G1Za]pEG QSVZI STK"Z S `U,Z GFI_ZLJSTH[Z
G
C(T )
¥‹¦ JPS `0`f'Š‘ SWJKZ5¥ Z
¥
q
J
1
I
`
G0
C(T ) §
ª ¥«
EG/H UVEGU`EGF`PŽ ¤ HNJs YZ0STI ¥ G/STU 0 F¥ Z ]LEG QSVZI 0 5E9` ` $¥ Z0G/I ZqJHU STU SWEI
G
G
G
JI U S `a\P^Š U HS  G5Z
 JSTH[Z] EG QSVZI
Za`U QS[ JHU S ] EG QSVZI 0 Za`U GFI ZJ‘K S  G5Z
0
G
G
§
&%
! +1.b#"%!#"(349%41. 8 , = +9 8 e = %. !)&9V41$&#(8A,=73+)&9%+1.V-,="^2#4sW')#(89(3!) "! ,
#"%!#"(349%4 8 e = (8:0#78(3$&'+g7I,H#"%!#"(349%4 8 / = 2C[? ,=#" : .t73+9O'41!" : :5+ jA69! , "%41/(8#"%F$&'+
&
')(
*,+(
-
+1.9J#78'.XSf,!/(873+ Y 73+1.5,=)&9(89"%!'.073!)#NB.0+9\73+1.X9"%!'.\(8:0-,=(8"%.0)[email protected]!)&90-,!.02#+V-,=(8"%+
2C?[,=:0(3. $&-,=)K9H,= #"(3.%:5+1. > (873.p+#AB+)K9H+)d,1AB!(8" > :^,=(3.*73+MAB!(3.(8)-,=NB+h2C? #)d/1!(8)
)[email protected]+)d/1!)&9(3+)K9 ,=:^,=(3. - !9%!)'.q$KZ? #)0N"<,=#O'+2C? "9%4:0(3.q)'+*/1!)&9(3+)K9 ,=:^,=(3.q2#+78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+2#+*.#e 7
2;(8AK(3.(3!)e#(8-,="9(3+G2#+ K 8 2C?[,=#" : .73+ 73+:0:5+ j<( > (873.*/1!)&9(3+)#)'+)&92#+1.#"(3.:5+1. = >
4
)#( 2#+\2#!#e#73+02;(I,=:^,=)&9 8 $K#(q/1!)&9(3+)K9G#) C =_> !)'/X73+X9O'41!" : :5+ 6A -,=NB+ j
6
Q
:5!)K9"%+$K'+ 7I,h#"%!#"(349%4 8 e = (8:0#78(3$K'+ 7I,G#"%!#"(349%4 8 2 =F! ,G"%41/(8#"%F$&'++1.9g#78'.
2;(8"%+1/9%+ Y !)AB4"(žW-+SU,!/(873+:5+)K9$&'+73+1.,=)K9(89"%!'.*73!)#NB. > 73+1.g9"%!'.(8:0-,=(8"%.+973+1.
#"(3.:5+1.t)'+.%!)K9q-,!.te#(8-,="9(3. > )'+.%!)&9q-,!.q2#+1.t/78(3$K'+1. > +9 )[email protected]!)K9-,!.t2#+g-,="9(89(3!)
,=)K9(3. % :549"(3$K'+G-,=(8"%+ 2
! +b9O'41!" : :5+T/( 7 2#+1.<.'.0.#NN : "%+$&'+ 2#+^SU,=(89 73+1.X-,=(8"%+1.02C?[,=:0(3.0.Q? O'4"(89%+)K9
>
>
2C? #)'+R/1+"9<,=(8)'+R:^,=)#( : "%+-,="V-,="9(89(3!) ,=&
) 9(3. % :549"(3$K'+-,=(8"%+ > e#(3+) $&'+)'!'.
Π7J.%+"<,=(89R2#!)'/a(8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9
)Z?[,=""(8AF(3!)'.R-,!.
.<,1AB!(8"Rp!#"%$K'!(\+9/1!:0:5+)&9 M
2C?[,QAB!(8"#)'+o#"%+#AB+2#[email protected]+ (3.%9%+)'/1+2#+R-,=(8"%+]2C?[,=:0(3.2',=)'.T73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.d2C? " 7
r ? (87`+1.9*e#(3+)AF"<,=(Z$&'+h73+1.-,="9(89(3!)'.
9%4:0(3.H-,="73+M9O'41!" : :5+L2#+h2#41/1!:0.(89(3!) p
%
,=)K9(3. :549"(3$K'+1.-,=(8"%+1.#"%41.<+"AB+)&9H73+1.-,=(8"%+1.H2C?[,=:0(3. ,=73!"%.73+M9O'41!" : :5+G2#+M2#4 7
/1!:0.(89(3!)ˆ.%#(8A!,=)K9b+1.95#) + )'/1!#"<,=NB+:5+)&9
2',=)'.H73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.e#(8-,="9(3.<,=)'. Y
4
&%
•”o–— ˜
$JKZIBU,Za`\©
ª Js«
G
^ ES U
Za`U"QS[JHU S `JI
G
G/I^¤H[JP YZ
§
>
"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+"T2#+1.5-,=(8"%+1.b2C?[,=:0(3.
Za`;U H[ES `qBH[EPBHSUŠUkŠ`;`GFS $JI U,Z` `EIBUqŠ  GFSŽ
§
ZU
I Z*‘ EI U SVZI1I ZIBU_I1SBU H[EGS P JS Ha] I1S
] I1Sp¥qEG5QK?ZsŽm¥S JPJI UT]
G G
L(K3,3 \e)
I1SpBHS `P Z KEIK¤
§
ª £‘ «
EG/H;UVEGU `&EGF`PŽ¤HNJPBYZ0STI ¥G/STU 0 ¥ Z ] EGnQSWZI 0 E` `%$%¥ Z;GFI_Zt5JHU S U SWEI
G
G
G
JI U S `a\^
P ŠU HaS  G1Z*JSTH[Za] EG QSWZI
Za`U"QS JHU S ] EG QSWZI
Za`Ug‘ EP BK3ŠPRZI'Ž
G
G
UVJS H X
Z ¥ ZQS JHU S
ªQ«
§
! +1.b#"%!#"(349%41. 8 , = +9 8 e = .%!)K9b41$K#(8A!,=73+)K9%+1.b-,="2#4sW')#(89(3!) i! +
73+:0:5+ j<( :5!)K9"%+ $K'+73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.ge#(8-,="9(3.<,=)'.g.%!)&9.<,=)'.78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+ 2#+.#e 7
2;(8AF(3.(3!) e#(8-,="9(3+R2#+ K ! +1.b9O'41!" : :5+ 6A +9 6A :5!)&9"%+)K9T,=73!"%.V$K'+7I,
4
#"%!#"(349%4 8 e = (8:0#78(3$K'+^7I,T#"%!#"(349%4 8 / = ! ,T"%41/(8#"%F$K'+^+1.9J#78'.L2;(8"%+1/9%+ Y !)
&
')(*,+(
-
AB4"(žW-+5SU,!/(873+:5+)K9J$K'+\73+1.h9"%!'.G(8:0-,=(8"%. > 73+1.G#"(3.:5+1.h73!)#NB. > L(K \ e) +9L73+
3,3
2#!#e#73+2;(I,=:^,=)&9t)'+.%!)K9‹-,!.Ze#(8-,="9(3. > )'+.<!)&9‹-,!.`/1!:0#734:5+)&9<,=(8"%+1.q2#+e#(8-,="9(3. >
+9)[email protected]!)K9-,!.2#+h-,="9(89(3!)o,=)&9(3. % :549"(3$K'+h-,=(8"%+ 2
4 ! #"073+1.\N"<,=#O'+1.02C? "9%4:0(3.0-,=(8"%. 7I,R.(89-,=9(3!) +1.9\#) +6#78'.0/1!:0#78( 7
>
Œ 7M+1.9^Sf,!/(873+R2#+dAB4"(žW-+"T$K'+/1+1.VN"<,=#O'+1.V)'+/1!)K9(3+)#)'+)&9-,!.2#+78(8)'+ 7
$K'41+ N"<,=#O'+\2#+L.%#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)Re#(8-,="9(89%+J2#+ K Y 2#+L9%+73..<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1.M/1!)&9(3+)#)'+X9%! 7
!#"%.M#)o#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8" 8 /1+XSU,=(89Me#(3+)]/14!)#)&+1.9h2#4:5!)K9"%40#)op+o#78'.M73!(8) Y
73+:0:5+ * -,=NB+ <(=! +1.t9O'41!" : :5+1.2#+2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!)^2#+1.tN"<,=#O'+1.2#+ +"NB+
8 9O'41!" : :5+1. 6A6q( +9 6A<= (8)'2;(3$&'+)K9g,=73!"%.$K'+73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3.-,=(8"%..%!)K9
.%!(89 e#(8-,="9(3. > .%!(89t2#+1.`/78(3$K'+1. > .%!(89`#)X#"(3.:5+-,=(8"t,QAB+1/ r .%!:0:5+9%. > .%!(89t!)&9 #)'+
-,="9(89(3!)a,=)K9(3. % :549"(3$K'+X-,=(8"%+ > !e#(3+)]!)&9M#)o2#+ F7 !(8)&9 !#9%+sS !(3. > (87t2#!(89
% ,1AB!(8" #)T9O'41!" : :5+G#)T+#78'.SU!"9$&#(C)'41/1+1.%.%(89%+h#)'+h)'!#AB+7873+G2#4sW')#(89(3!) r !(89
6$7 !(8)&92C? #) N"<,=#O'+
8
7
(X1 , X2 ) #)
G !) "%+#"%+)'2D73+1.b)'!9<,=9(3!)'.bO-,
$
6
7
<
=
‰
‘
Y
Z
P
T
S
I
&
`
E
H
V
U
J
I
U
e#(89'+7873+1.0!#"\73+1.
!(8)K9%. > AB!(8"\-,=NB+
) ,=#+7873+
!#"
73+ 6$7 !(8)K9b9%!#9V/%O'+:0(8)2#+ G[X ] , % ,=)&9V#)'+d+ 9"%4:0(89%42',=)'. A > 7f?[,=#9"%++ /7
i
i
8
= ‰ )a2;(89
9"%4:0(89%4b2',=)'.
9%!'.G73+1.J,=#9"%+1.J.%!:0:5+9%.GO'!"%.J2#+
Bi >
Ai , Bi i = 1, 2
a
gRM
g
*F1 Q
 JS H 8 "%+1.% STP  JSTH= .(‹9%!'.M.%+1./%O'+:0(8)'.h.%!"9<,=)K9%.h.%!)&9-,=(8"%.
$&Z? #) 6$7 !(8)K9+1.%9 8 "%+1. (8:0-,=(8"%. =ZΠ7+1.9G/7I,=(8"X$&Z? #) 6$7 !(8)K9
(X1 , X2 ) 2C? #)N"<,=#O'+b2#+ +"NB+ G
+1.9*9%! !#"%.-,=(8"H!(8:0-,=(8" > .<,=)'.H$&'!( G /1!)K9(3+)&9#)T9"%!(8:0-,=(8" Œ 72#!(89 2 9"%+Vp.<.(8e#73+2#+b:5!)K9"%+"5$&Z? #)6N"<,=#O'+T2C? "9%4:0(3.0-,=(8"0$&[email protected]!)6)'+
p+#952#41/1!:0.%+"^$K'+-,=" 6$7 !(8)&95+#909%! !#"%.b.%+T2#41/1!:0.%+"5-,=" 6$7 !(8)&9
-,=(8" 'i )d+ # +9 > 73+1. 6$7 !(8)&9%.H-,=(8"%. ,=#-,="<,=(3.%.%+)K9H)-,=9#"%+7873+:5+)K92',=)'.H73+1.*#"(3.:5+1.
-,=(8"%. > .9"'/9#"%+
-,="9(8"2#+7I,!$&'+7873+!)0+#92#41/1!:0.%+"73+N"<,=#O'+*9%!#9+)&9(3+"
2',=)'.M7I,^#"%+#AB+^2;R9O'41!" : :5+0S !"9h2#+1.MN"<,=#O'+1.h-,="mSf,=(89%. 8 AB!(8"h9O'41!" : :5+ 6A6q(=
4 !#"h2#!)#)'+"M#)9O'41!" : :5+\2#+X2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!)o2#+1. N"<,=#O'+1.h2C? "9%4:0(3. -,=(8"%. (87
>
2#+AK"<,=(89g2#!)'/ .5"%+ 2#+"%+1/1!#(3+"73+H/<O-,=#(89"%+ 2#+ 7I,h#"%+#AB+2;^9O'41!" : :5+HSU!"92#+1.
N"<,=#O'+1.t-,="mSU,=(89%.q/1!)'.<,!/"%4,=\#"(3.:5+g-,=(8" > +)\"%+:0#7I, m ,=)&9-,="9%!#9 j 6$7 !(8)K9mlg-,="
j 6$7 !(8)K9q-,=(8"ml _ +g9"<,QA!,=(87#)[email protected]+1.9t+#9 7,2 9"%+-,!.t(8)'.#":5!)&9<,=e#73+ > :^,=(3.t)Z?[, 2C? (8)K9%4" 2 9
$&'+h.(Z!)T-,="AF(3+)&9
#9(878(3.%+"73+h9O'41!" : :5+L2#+G2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!)d!e#9%+)& D
u +1/1!)#)-,39"%+0#)'+^/7I,!.%.%+02#+\N"<,=#O'+1. > /[email protected]+1.%9L2#!)#)'+"G#)c,=78NB!"(89O#:5+^p+":5+9 7
H
9<,=)&9\2#+b2#41/(32#+"\.(#) N"<,=#O'+,=#-,="9(3+)&90!c)'!)
7I,/7I,!.%.%+ `Π7g+1.9L9%! !#"%.
i
(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9b2#+2;(3.%p.%+"52#+d/1+NB+)#"%+d2C?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
) + # +9 > +1.9 7 (87AF"<,=(8:5+)&9
#9(873+2#+2;(3..%+"^2C?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.V+"mS !":^,=)K9%.^2#+d/1!73!"<,=9(3!)ˆp!#"^#)'+/7I,!.%.%+
.([email protected]!)+1.9h: 2 :5+0-,!.h/Q,=-,=e#73+52#+02#41/(32#+"L.%( 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+5S !)'/9(3!)#)'+5p!#"h#)
N"<,=#O'+G2#!)#)'4 E
- !'.]2#4e##9%+"%!)'.a/1+ /%O-,=#(89"%+ -,="]#)
49<,=92#+ 7f?[,="9+) "<,=#+7I,=)&99%!#9
2 ?[,=ep!"%2
C
9(89"%+2C? (87878'.9"<,=9(3!) #) ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ )-, SR2#+ "%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.<.<,=)'/1+ 2#+1.
N"<,=#O'+1.‹Sf,=(8e#73+:5+)&9q9"(I,=)#N#7341.q+9t+)\2#!)#)-,=)&92#+1. (8)'2;(3/Q,=9(3!)'.t9" : .t.'/1/(8)&9%+1.t.#"
7I,M"%41.%!78#9(3!)^"%41/1+)K9%+H2;5#"%!e#7 : :5+2#+*7I,M"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.<.<,=)'/1+H2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.2#+ +"NB+ - !'.h2#!)#)'+"%!)'.G+)'.%#(89%+1.G2#+1.G,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.L+)]9%+:0'.h!7 % )'!:0(I,=7qp!#"h2#49%+1/ 7
9%+"J/1+"9<,=(8)'.X9 % p+1.X2#+^.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1.X(8)'2;#(89%. 8 #"(3.%:5+1. > #"(3.:5+1.X-,=(8"%. > #"(3.:5+1.
(8:0-,=(8"%. > 78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.*2#+.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)b2#+ K = /%O-,!$K'+SU!(3. > )'!'..%+"%!)'.!e#78( 7
4
NB41.h2#+J"%+1.%9"%+(8)'2;"%+073+\/%O-,=:0'.L2C?[,=##78(3/Q,=9(3!)c2#+J)'.J,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.
2#+1.h/7I,!.%.%+1.
2#+N"<,=#O'+1.^-,="9(3/#78(3+"%. 8 N"<,=#O'+1.b.<,=)'.5 % "<,=:0(32#+d!D.<,=)'.^9"%!D(8:0-,=(8"^.%+73!)
73+1.J/Q,!. = - !'. '.9(žW-+"%!)'.\/1+99%+b"%+1.9"(3/9(3!) +)c#"%!#A,=)&90$K'+^)'.J#"%!e#7 : :5+1.
2#+J2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+AF(3+)#)'+)&9 -04L7 /1!:0#73+9%.M73!"%.%[email protected]!)]+1.%.<, % +\2#+J73+1."%41.%!'2;"%+Xp!#"
9%!#9N"<,=#O'+ #i )T/1!)'/78'.(3!) > )'!'.-,="AF(3+)'2;"%!)'.
"%+1/1!)#)-, 39"%+h+)9%+:0'.!7 % 7
Y
)'!:0(I,=7C73+1.*/7I,!.%.%+1.*2#+N"<,=#O'+1..#(8A,=)&9%+1. N"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3. > 2C? "9%4:0(3.*-,=(8"%.
+9He#(8-,="9(3.<,=)'. - !'.2#!)#)'+"%!)'.#)],=78NB!"(89O#:5+\2#+L/1!73!"<,=9(3!)]+)9%+:0'.!7 % 7
)'!:0(I,=7Zp!#"*73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3.H-,=(8"%. > 2#!)&9H)'!'.*)'+G.%!:0:5+1.*-,!.-,="AB+)&
#"%!#AB+"[email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%4 !#9%+sSU!(3. > )'!'.:5!)&9"%!)'.h$KZ? (87 2#!)#)'+Je#(3+)#)'+\/1!73 7
"<,=9(3!)!#9(8:^,=73+ > /1!)'2;(89(3!)R$K'+h7I,0/1!) +1/9#"%+J2#+ i AB+"%+99+9 uH+1+12.%!(89HAK"<,=(3+
8 /1!) +1/9#"%+ .q=
.
!
! +1."%41.#789<,=9%.2#+M/1+M/%O-,=#(89"%+L!)&949%4h.%!#:0(3.,= ^ ¨
JUTYZP JU SU‘` 'Ad9+,
Q
.
#"
CFEGFHIBJKENM
S `1‘H ZU,Z
Q9
GwPx pz €
6
J}
6
RTMˆH #F ‡’kz*|6
_ =, 73/#73+"J2#+1.h#78'.G/1!#"9%.G/<O'+:0(8)'.G!#"h9"%!#AB+"L2#+1.G.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1.G(8)'2;#(89%.
-,="<,39 ,!.<.%+G)-, Sq+)#"%+:0( : "%+J,=)-,=7 % .%+ 54 ,=" + +:0#73+ > .(Z!)d/<O'+"%/%O'+J#)T#"(3.:5+
2',=)'.\#)6N"<,=#O'+ > .(*!) /1!)#)-,=(89073+1.\2#+ 9"(I,=)#N73+1. {a , a , a } +9 {b , b , b }
 1HSWE2HaS p3!#"q$K'+*12#+1.t2 #783'.
2C? #)0#"(3.:5+*2;\N"<,=#O'+ > ,=73!"%.t(87;)Z? % ,h,='/#)'+"<,=(3.%!) JgB
/1!#"9%.g/%O'+:0(8)'. P "%+78(I,=)K9 a b SU!":5+)&9#)5#"(3.:5+ F4 !#"9<,=)K9 > #)V,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
i
i
i
e#(3+) /1!)#)&ˆ2#+"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+R2#+1.5N"<,=#O'+1.^SU,=(8e#73+:5+)K9^9"(I,=)#N#7341.^S !)K9(3!)#)'+
.#"g/1+H#"(8)'/(8+ nR,="(I, _ O&'2;)'’AF. % +9 4 ,=#7 r + % :5!#"g!)K9:5!)&9"%4M$&'+ /1+H9 % +
2#+J9%+1/%O#)#(3$K'+1.Mp+#9h,=(32#+"
"%+1/1!)#)-, 39"%+X73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.M2#+ +"NB+ > :5 % +)#)-,=)K9L2#+
:J#789(8#73+1.H#"%41/Q,=#9(3!)'.
!
"
$ !
" !
$
! +T73+:0:5++907f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+/( 7 2#+1.%.<!'.5.%!)&95SU,!/(873+1.5+90e#(3+)D/1!)#)K'. Π73.0)'+
.%!)K9##e#78(341.T)K#7873+]-,="9Tp!#"d,=#9<,=)K9$K'+o)'!'.d, % !)'.#73+oAB4"(žW-+" > +9d!)
Π73.0.%!)&95)'4Q,=)#:5!(8)'.5#9(873+1.
+#95/1!)'.(32#4"%+"^$KZ? (873.^,=#-,="9(3+)#)'+)&9,=6S !7 F73!"%+ q
+9L2#!)#)'+)K9L#)'+^ep!)#)'+0(32#41+^2#+5/1+5$K#(qA!,T.%#(8AK"%+ 4 !#"J/<O-,!$&'+59 % p+52#+^.%!'. 7
N"<,=#O'+
2#49%+1/9%+" > )'!'.L2#!)#)'+"%!)'.h#)]73+:0:5+5, 5":^,=)&9X$&[email protected]+)]/Q,=73/#7I,=)&9X2#+1.
#78'.`/1!#"9%.`/<O'+:0(8)'.`+)K9"%+2#+1.‹.<!:0:5+9%.‹2C? #)J.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+2#!)#)'42#+/1+q9 % + 8 #)
#"(3.:5+J-,=" + +:0#73+ = > !)R!e#9(3+)K9
)'!#AB+Q,=R#)R.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+J(8)'2;#(892#+L: 2 :5+
%9 + F_ +*73+:0:5+Hp+":5+99"<,G7I,M:0(3.%+ +) M#AK"%+ 2C? #)b,=78NB!"(89O#:5+$&#(;j 2#+AF(8)'+sl#)
)'!:Je#"%+HW 4H2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.2;b.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+H##(3.$K#( +)^"%+9"%!#AB+73+H"%+1.9%+-,="2#+1.
/Q,=73/#73. 2#+h#78'./1!#"9%.H/<O'+:0(8)'. ‰ )d"<,=#p+7873+h$KZ? #) K EIK¤ U HNEG 2',=)'.#)TN"<,=#O'+G+1.9*#)/ % /73+M(8)'2;#(89H2#+M9<,=(87873+
,=:5!(8)'. j
G/I¤H[JP YZ ZU
GFI K EIK¤ U H[EG¥ Z
¥FZUVJSTK K?Z PSTI1S P J K?Z
“”K•a•a”ŸZ—˜c^ E S U
G
H
G
§
^ ESTU
G/Ic‘Y5ZPS I6¥ Z
^ ESTU
G/IBK G `5‘ EG/HUH‘YZPSTI ¥ Z
ZH `
I Z
a−u−b
H§
P
a
b
I1S $ES `aSTIV‘ EP PG/I¥FZ ZU ¨ KEHa`
S I ¥GFS U
‘ EI U,ZIBJIBU I1S $ES `aSTIVF
¥ Z
u
a b§
{u}∪V (P )
G/I K EIFR
¤ U H[EG¥ Z
¥ Z UVJSTK [email protected]
G
§
_
& ')(*,+(
7I,=(8"
2
•a”dŸC— l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
r (
:
G .%. 2#+#)73!)#N\9"%! > =, 73!"%.7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+h"%+9%!#")'+M#)73!)#N
9"%!d2#+ G 2#+h9<,=(87873+h:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ pr (8)'!) > 8( 7C"%+9%!#")'+Mj 4 ,!.H2#+M73!)#N^9"%!;l ' (
' f (
!#"%$
*
"
k_ !)'.(32#4"%+"q9%!'.t73+1.t9"(8#73+9%.
4
(a, u, b) 2#+ G !#"/%O-,!/#)[email protected]+ /Q,=73/#73+"
-,="G7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ Aj #)#78'.L/1!#"9X/%O'+:0(8) P 2#+ a AB+"%. b -,=":0(73+1.
r (
.%!:0:5+9%.52#+ V \(N (u) ∪ (N (a) ∩ N (b))) {u} ∪ V (P ) (8)'2;#(895#)
9"%! 2#+ G > 2#+9<,=(87873+(8);S 4"(3+#"%+
#) 4AB+)&9'+7M9"%! 2#4 [ "%+)'/1!)&9"%4 >
,=73!"%..9%F/ B+"H/1+M9"%!+):54:5!(8"%+ ')(
Qj
*
k l )'+gS !(3. 9%!'.q73+1.t9"(8#73+9%.4)K#:54"%41. "%+9%!#")'+"[email protected]+AB+)K9'+7-9"%!52#+9<,=(87873+
>
r ? (87‹)Z? % +)d,\-,!. "%+9%!#")'+"lf-,!.2#+h9"%!;l :0(8)#(8:^,=73+ p
>
f & " (
5 &
#H
O(n )
*,+(
-
_ 7I,=(8" 2
! ?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A6 p+#9 2 9"%+h#9(878(3.<4
2 +1.W')'.*:L#789(8#73+1. 4 ,="H+ +:0#73+Gp!#"
#
"%+1/1!)#)-,39"%+73+1.ZN"<,=#O'+1.‹Sf,=(8e#73+:5+)&9 9"(I,=)#N#7341. Y (87K.59‹2#[email protected]+ 41/#9%+"`.#" G ##(3.
, % ,="%2
.#" G i )XSU,=(89 > !)5,M2#4 AF\-,=NB+ j $&Z? (87#+ (3.9%+g#)^,=78NB!"(89O#:5+2
>
r #(8)#"<,!2+9 r "(89O-,="<,=) 'Ajq($+ !#"*"%+1/1!)#)-, 39"%+h73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.SU,=(8e#73+:5+)K99"(I,=)#N#7341.
+) O(n+m2 ) <- !9%!)'.‹$K'+/1+9 ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+)'+2#49%+1/9%+-,!.‹2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)K9 73+1.‹9"%!'. uH41/1+:0:5+)&9 > r - ( B!73!!#73.L+9 ! 4 ,=7878(3. 'Adr$+ !)&9J2#!)#)'40#)a,=78NB!"(89O#:5+^2#+
/1!:0#73+ (89%4 O(n + m2 ) $&#(Z2#49%+1/9%+L2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)&973+1.*9"%!'. +!
!
" &
!
#
#
_ ! :0:5+*!)\7f?[, 2;(89t#78'.tO-,=#9 73+g#"%!e#7 : :5+2#+g7I, "%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+*2#+1.tN"<,=#O'+1.
>
-,="mSU,=(89%.M+1.9 "%+1.9%4J!#AB+"9 '.%[email protected]+) 66 4 #(3. > no,="(I, _ OK'2;)'QA;. % > 4 ,=#7 r + % 7
:5!#" > 4"<,="%2 _ !")&'4 !73. > (8)#:0(8)#N ! (8+9 M"(3.9(8)-,
BQAF(J!)K9.%(8:L#789<,=)'4 7
:5+)&9h#"%!.%4\2#+ ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.G2#+\"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+02#+1.MN"<,=#O'+1.h2#+ g+"NB+\+)
9%+:0'.!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 '.r > 66 > 9+,K_ +*#"%!e#7 : :5+.%+:Je#73+H,=#" : ./1!#b:5!(8)'.2;( ^/(873+
$&'+H7I,G#"%+#AB+M2#+ 7I,L/1!) +1/9#"%+ S !"9%+ 2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.g-,="mSf,=(89%. > +9(87C,G!#"9<,=)&9*49%4
"%41.%!78d.9%4"(3+#"%+:5+)&9h+9M.<,=)'.H$K'+G73+L9O'41!" : :5+\2#+L.9"'/9#"%+X2#+1.HN"<,=#O'+1.M2#+
g+"NB+)Z?[,=#!"9%+h,='/#)'+G,=(32#+ 8 AB!(8".<+1/9(3!) 6Aj !#"g2#+1.*2#49<,=(873.*.%#"g/1+!(8)&9 =
Œ 7 SU,=#9)'!9%+"*$K'+ 73+1.2#+ ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.*"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.%+)K9*73+1.N"<,=#O'+1. ¥ Z b0ZHU¤ Z +9
>
)'+"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.%+)&92#!)'/*73+1.tN"<,=#O'+1.-,="mSf,=(89%.$K'+*2',=)'.t7I,:5+1.#"%+073+9O'41!" : :5+
S !"9g2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.g-,="mSf,=(89%.+1.9AF"<,=( &Π7 SU,=#9g4N&,=73+:5+)&9*)'!9%+"*$&'+H73+H#"%!e#7 : :5+M2#+
7I,X"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+L2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.H.<,=)'.*9"%!d(8:0-,=(8"H+1.9+)'/1!"%+G!#AB+"9 4 !#"SU!#")#(8" #)],=+" m R2#+1. :549O'K2#+1.M+:0#73 % 41+1. (87`)'!'.HSU,=#9M2#+ 2#4sW 7
>
)#(89(3!)'. r !(3+)K9 G #)RN"<,=#O'+J+9 C #)9"%!o2#+ G C‰ )R2;(89M$KZ? #).%!:0:5+9 v 2#+
P J&ZGFH .%#"
G +1.9
C .([email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+h2#+.%+1.AB!(3.(8)'..#" C )[email protected]+1.9(8)'/78T2',=)'.,='/#)
‰
) ,=#+7873+ H[J  G1ZUWU,Z p!#" C #)ˆ.<!:0:5+9^:^, +#"b.#" C $&#( AB!(89
P3 2#+ C
+ ,!/9%+:5+)K9J9"%!(3.X.%!:0:5+9%.X2#+
`‰ ) "%+:^,="%$K'+"<,d$K'+5.( +1.%9G#)'+5"<,!$K'+99%+
C
v
p!#"g#)9"%!V(8:0-,=(8" C 2#+ G 2#+ 9<,=(87873+:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > ,=73!"%[email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+ V (C) ∪ {v}
(8)'2;#(89#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+ ! +1.2#+ ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1."%+.%+)&9 .#"*#)'+M#"%+:0( : "%+h#O-,!.%+G/1!:0:J#)'+L2;(89%+h2#+
I ZUWUVE\qJQ¤ Z 2;]N"<,=#O'+ '.r$+,Z_ +99%+\#"%+:0( : "%+0#O-,!.%+Xp+":5+9h.%!(89h2#+0/1!)'/78#"%+0+)
9%+:0'.*p!7 % )'!:0(I,=7Z$K'+M73+MN"<,=#O'+h)[email protected]+1.9*-,!.2#+ +"NB+ > .%!(89*2#+SU!#")#(8"#)'+M78(3.9%+
2C?[,=^#78'. O(n8 ) .%!'. 7 +)'.%+:Je#73+1.2#+ V (G) ,1AB+1/H7I,h#"%!#"(349%4.#(8A!,=)K9%+ Y .( C +1.%9
#)T9"%!d(8:0-,=(8"H2#+h9<,=(87873+G:0(8)#(8:^,=73+L2#+ G > +9.%( C +1.9H.P,=)'.*"<,!$&'+99%+ > ,=73!"%.7f? #)
2#+1.H+)'.%+:Je#73+1. +1.9 2;(3. !(8)K9 2#+ C +9H/1!)K9(3+)&9M9%!'.73+1. .%!:0:5+9%.H:^, +#"%.H2#+ C ‰ )b2;(89*,=73!"%.g$K'+73+ 9"%!
I ZUWUVE\&
Š 8 2#+.%+1.AB!(3.(8)'.:^, +#"%. = +9g!)2;(89$K'+
C +1.9
>
I
&
Z
W
U
V
U
E
&
\
Š
73+MN"<,=#O'+ G +1.9
! ,o#O-,!.%+d2#+)'+99% % ,=NB+p+":5+9^2#!)'/d2#+T"<,=:5+)'+"^7I,R"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+d2#+1.
N"<,=#O'+1.2#+ g+"NB+
2#+ #"%!e#7 : :5+1.#78'.*.(8:0#73+1. Y 7I,\2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+1.9"%!'.*(8: 7
Q*
RTMˆH #F -,=(8"%.p.<. : 2',=)&9#)'+*"<,!$&'+99%+ > ##(3.7I,G2#49%+1/9(3!)V2#+1.9"%!'.(8:0-,=(8"%.)'+99% % 41.2#+
9<,=(87873+h:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ C_ +1.*#"%!e#7 : :5+1.!)&9H49%4G"%41.%!78'.H2#+h2#+ :^,=)#( : "%+1.2;( # 4"%+)K9%+1. > ? #)'+h-,="9 _ OK'2;)'. % +9 r + % :5!#"H!)&9H#"%!p.%4M#)d,=78NB!"(89O#:5+J2;(8"%+1/92#+M"%+ 7
>
/<O'+"%/%O'+X2#+G % "<,=:0(32#+1.2',=)'.#)N"<,=#O'+X$&'+73/1!)'$K'+ > ##(3.2#+h9"%!d(8:0-,=(8"2',=)'.
#)5N"<,=#O'+H)'+99% % 4 'A66$+,K_ +9g,="9(3/73+,M49%4)'!9"%+.<!#"%/1+H2C? (8)'.#(8"<,=9(3!)b#"(8)'/(8-,=73+
!#"/1+M/%O-,=#(89"%+ 1> ?[,=#9"%+M-,="9 > _ !")&'4 !73. > ! (8+9 BQAF( 'A9+ !)&9#"%!.%4
#)],=78NB!"(89O#:5+02#+L"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.<.<,=)'/1+JS !)'2#4\.#"73+#" 9O'41!" : :5+\2#+X2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!)
2#+1.HN"<,=#O'+1.H.<,=)'.H9"%!(8:0-,=(8" 8 9O'41!" : :5+ 6A6 -,=NB+ 6q=1- !'. ,QAB!)'. ,='.%.%(‹+1. 7
.<, % 4T2C?[,!2',=#9%+"5/1+99%+2#+ ( : :5+:549O'F2#+
2#+1.\#"%!e#7 : :5+1.\)'!) "%41.%!78'.\:^,=(3.
/1+99%+MSU!(3..<,=)'.H.'/1/ : . - !'.`:5+)&9(3!)#)'!)'.t!#"‹:54:5!(8"%+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+g.%#(8A!,=)K9 $K#(B#9(878(3.%+g2#+1.‹9%+1/<O 7
)#(3$K'+1.2#+h#78'./1!#"9%. /%O'+:0(8)'. •a”dŸC—"ˆ™Pš
6” ” ‹• *
)
)
œ#¡m— ¢
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
r (
%
4
%
7
G +1.9g.P,=)'. "<,=:0(32#+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+h"%+9%!#")'+j ,!.*2#+M "<,=:0(
2#+sl r (8)'!) > (87C%" +9%!#")'+G#)'+G % "<,=:0(32#+G2#+ G 2#+M9<,=(87873+h:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ f & " (
O(n9 )
' (
' f (
i );W'))'!'. /(89%!)'.H73+h#"(8)'/(8-,=7 "%41.#789<,=9.#"7I,\"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+J2#+1.HN"<,=#O'+1.
2#+ +"NB+ Y
•a”dŸC—8
™Pš
*
Gw
/
"
š
*
9 ,
“
¢
#,
r (
G +1.%92#+ +"NB+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+0"%+9%!#")'+
f
(
,
#¡ ¢
”)‹•
,
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
9%!#")'+
&
)
' (
' f (
™œ ˜
p}q†
6
{
6
(
g
'
(
O(n9 )
X}
:
('
g
(
‹r (8)'!) (87 "%+ 7
>
~: X
1
~%*|z*„58X}q~
- !'.,=7873!)'.t:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K9AB!(8"q#)'+.%4"(3+2C?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.2#+2#49%+1/9(3!)52#+.%!'. 7
N"<,=#O'+1. - !'.q#9(878(3.<+"%!)'.(8)&9%+)'.%(8AB+:5+)&97I,9%+1/%O#)#(3$K'+H2#+1.q#78'./1!#"9%./<O'+:0(8)'.
:0(3.%+*+) M#AK"%+-,=" _ OK'2;)'QA;. % +9 r + % :5!#"!#"7I,M2#49%+1/9(3!)b2#+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1. r (8N)-,=73!)'.\,='.%.($K'+573+1.X,="9(3/73+1.J2#+ _ !);S !"9( _ !")&'4 !73.J+9 BQAF(^.%#"G73+1.
>
N"<,=#O'+1.G2#+ +"NB+0.<,=)'.h/Q,=""%4\+9h7I,V2#41/1!:0p.%(89(3!)2#+1.MN"<,=#O'+1.G.<,=)'.M9"%!o(8: 7
+ /1!)K9(3+)#)'+)&9H2#+ )'!:Le#"%+ "%41.#789<,=9%.*.#"7I,L:^,=)#( : "%+M2#!)&9#)T.%!: 7
-,=(8" 'A
>
:5+9h+#9hAB!(8"h#)]#"(3.:5+ ! +1.M73+:0:5+1.G$K#(.#(8AB+)K9h#9(878(3.%+)&9L2#+1.G"%41.#789<,=9%.G2;
: 2 :5+h9 % + :^,=(3.*e+Q,='/1!##78'. .(8:0#73+1. >
"-
" #
- !'.M2#!)#)'!)'.M(3/(q2#+ ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.h2#+\2#49%+1/9(3!)o2#+1.M#"(3.%:5+1.!o2#+1. %F7
"<,=:0(32#+1. F ##78(3$K'41. 2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.g.<,=)'.q % "<,=:0(32#+ > /1+1.,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.g2#+AK(3+)#)'+)K9
.(8:0#73+:5+)K92#+1.*,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.2#+ 2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+ #"(3.:5+1. ! +#"%+:0(3+"*[email protected]+)&9"%+h+ T
%
M
Qq(
)5t% Q. ? (8)'.#(8"%+T2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)&9V2#+1.\9%+1/%O#)#(3$K'+1.5#9(878(3.%41+1.5-,=" _ O&'2;)'QA;. % +9 r + % :5!#"
p!#"q7I,h2#49%+1/9(3!)b2#+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1. > :^,=(3.p.<. : 2#+#)'+*/1!:0#73+ (89%4He#(3+)5:5+(87873+#"%+
/Q,="*73!"%.%$&'[email protected]!)/<O'+"%/%O'+X.(8:L#789<,=)'4:5+)K9H#)#"(3.%:5+h!T#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+G2',=)'.*#)
N"<,=#O'+ > 7I,X9%+1/%O#)#(3$K'+G2#+1.#78'./1!#"9%./<O'+:0(8)'.H.%+M.(8:0#78(žW-+ 5! +h2#+ ( : :5+L,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+5+1.9h#)]+]#78'.hp+"mSU!":^,=)&9J+9G)'+\"%+p.<+\#78'.L,='.%.(2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)K9J.#"
73+1.*#78'./1!#"9%.H/<O'+:0(8)'. EP U STPJK .(g.%!))'!:Je#"%+b2#+b.%!:0:5+9%.
‰ )c2;(89X$&Z? #)a.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+b2#+
G +1.9
+1.9(8);SU4"(3+#"!b4N&,=7p,=^)'!:Le#"%+2#+H.<!:0:5+9%.2#+9%!#9#"(3.:5+H2#+ G > +9(8);SU4"(3+#"
!4N&,=7`,=)'!:Le#"%+L2#+G.%!:0:5+9%.H2#+M9%!#9%+G % "<,=:0(32#+L2#+ G “”K•c•”RŸC—I– ^ ESTU
G/IV¤H[JP Y5Z  G1ZK8‘ EI  G5Z ^ ESVZI U
]
]
] U HNES `h‘YZPSTI5`
G
P 1 P2 P3
§
¥ Z
M&EHaP JIBU G/I ZB\HNJPSU¥ ZEP_U S P JK?Z
¥ Z U HaSWJIK¤K?Z
"IIBEU,Z
G
F
{b , b , b } §
a
KZh‘ ES IR¥ Z
ZU EI `aG’BE9`.Z  G1Z5EGFH
]
J 5EGF1H Z 2U H%3ŠPS UkŠa`
ZU 1
F
i = 1, 2, 3 Pi
a
b §
^ ES U 0 G/IBK G `5‘ EG/HUH‘YZPSTI ¥ Z
9ZH `
¥qEI U"K?Za`p`&EPPRZUT` STI Uk1ŠHSWZGFHai`
P1
a1
b1
¨ KEH `pEG QSWZI©
PJI  G1ZI U
ZU
b2
b3 §
ª J« L¦ ZI5`.ZPRQK?Z
S Ip¥ GFS U G/ITBHS `aPRZ EP_U S P JK¥ Zb‘ ESTI
V (P 0 ) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 )
ZUg¥ Z U HaSWJIK¤ K?Z 1
a1
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
ª Q « Z`\‘ YZP STI5`
]0
]
M&EHaPRZIBU"GFI Z B
 \HNJPSU¥ ZEP_
 U S P JK?Z0¥ Z0‘ ES I
ZU
P1 P2 P3
a1
¥ Z U HS JIF¤ KZ
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
"I JRGFI H%a
Š `aG/K UVJU `S PSTK JS H Zg5
 EGFH
ZU
P2
P3 §
r (
Z‰ ).##.%+\2#!)'/
& ')( *,+(
a AB!(89 b > 73+J73+:0:5+0+1.%9h9"(8AK(I,=7
a1 b1 ∈
/ E
- !9%!)'.$&Z?[,=73!"%. 1 0 +1.91 2#+L73!)#N'+#"G,=d:5!(8)'. 6‰ ))'!9%+
(P1 )
H 73+G9"%!R(8)'2;#(89
-,=" V (P ) ∪ V (P ) t‰ ) )'!9%+ c 73+V.%!:0:5+902#+ P 0 ∗ > 73+^#78'.X#"%K/<O'+V2#+ b > +9
2
3
1
1
, % ,=)&9X#)AB!(3.(8) 2',=)'. H - !9%!)'.X$K'+ c + (3.%9%+5/Q,=" a ∈ V (H) +9L/Q,=" P 0 +1.9
1
1
2#+b73!)#N'+#"V,= :5!(8)'. 6 u +1.9%+)&9
+ ,=:0(8)'+"^$K-,=9"%+V/Q,!.^/1!)'2;#(3.<,=)&9
#)'+
/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)o!
/1+G$&Z?[,QA!,=)'/1+G73+h73+:0:5+ Y
k r ( )'+MAB!(89H2#+
%
7
c
H $K'+ a1 > ,=73!"%. P10 > P2 > P3 SU!":5+)&9 #)'+M "<,=:0(32#+L!#9(
:^,=73+G2#+G/1!(8) a +9H2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } 1 2 3
k r ( )'+gAB!(892#+ 1 $K'+
c
H
a1 +9t#)\AB!(3.(8)52#+ a1 > ,=73!"%. V (P10 )∪V (P2 )∪V (P3 )
(8)'2;#(89H#)T#"(3.:5+L!#9(8:^,=7‹2#+G/1!(8) a +9H2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } 1
1 2 3
k r ( :^,=)'$K'+
c
a1 ,=73!"%.\73+VN"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(890-,=" V (H) ∪ V (b1 − P10 − c)
+973+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } .<,=9(3.mSU!)&9H9%!#9%+1.73+1.*O % !9O : .%+1.H2;d73+:0:5+ 1)( >
1 2 3
/1+\$&#( :5!)&9"%+0$K'+ F 0 /1!)&9(3+)K9G#)#"(3.%:5+X!R#)'+X % "<,=:0(32#+ nR,=(3.M/1+7I,
/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%452#+ F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | 8 (87q:^,=)'$&'+\73+1.h.<!:0:5+9%.h2#+
=
P10 +)K9"%+ c +9 a1
k r ( AB!(89
7
7
c
a1 +9 ,=X:5!(8)'.`#)L)'!) AB!(3.(8)02#+ a1 .#" H > ,=73!"%.`(87F+ (3.%9%+#)J/<O'+
6
:0(8) Q 2#+ H 2#+73!)#N'+#"q,=L:5!(8)'. > +9`2#!)K9‹73+1.`+ 9"%4:0(89%41.t.%!)K9 a +9‹#)
1
AB!(3.(8)b2#+ c nR,=(3.g,=73!"%.73+*N"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(89-,=" (V (H) ∪ V (P 0 )) \ V (Q∗ )
1
+973+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } .<,=9(3.mSU!)&9H9%!#9%+1.73+1.*O % !9O : .%+1.H2;d73+:0:5+ 1)( >
1 2 3
/1+\$&#( :5!)&9"%+0$K'+ F 0 /1!)&9(3+)K9G#)#"(3.%:5+X!R#)'+X % "<,=:0(32#+ nR,=(3.M/1+7I,
/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%452#+ F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | 8 (87q:^,=)'$&'+\73+1.h.<!:0:5+9%.h2#+
=
Q∗
Qd
RTMˆH #F r (
c AB!(8952#+ H #) ,=#9"%+T.<!:0:5+9^$&'+ a1 ,=73!"%.073+N"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(890-,="
%
:
V (H) ∪ V (P10 ) \ {a1 } +9g73+H9"(I,=)#N73+ {b1 , b2 , b3 } .<,=9(3.S !)K99%!#9%+1.g73+1.gO p!9O .<+1.
1
)
(
%
2;c73+:0:5+
> /1+b$&#(:5!)&9"%+V$&'+ F 0 /1!)&9(3+)&9X#)a#"(3.%:5+^!#)'+^ "<,=:0(32#+
Y
no,=(3.b/1+7I,a/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%4o2#+ F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | (87:^,=)'$&'+
F 0 73+
>
.%!:0:5+9 a
!)'/ > c )'+bAB!(89J2#+ H $&'+^73+^.%!:0:5+9 a > + ,!/9%+:5+)&90/1+^[email protected]!)
1
1
AB!#7I,=(89 :5!)&9"%+" 2
“”K•a•a”ŸZ—8Ÿ ^ ES U
G/Ib¤H[JP YZ  G1ZKž‘ EI  G1Z ^_ESWZI U
]
]
]LU H[ES `h‘YZPS I1`
G
§
P 1 P2 P3
¥ Z
M&EHP JI U;GFIRBHS `aPRZnEP U STP JK
¥ ZnU HSWJIK¤K?Za`
ZU
G
F
{a1 , a2 , a3 }
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
"I `aG’B
 E9`.ZEG/H
G5Z
JM5EGFHZ U H%ŠPSTUkŠa`
Z&U

i = 1, 2, 3
Pi
ai
bi §
^_ESWZI Ug©
G/Ia K GF`R‘ EG/HU5‘ YZPSTI¥FZ
9ZHa`
¥ EI U KZa` `EPPRZUT` STI UkŠHSWZG/Ha`
P10
a1
b1
P JI  G1ZI U
ZU
b2
b3 §
/
G
a
I

K
F
G
R
`
‘
E
G/HU5
‘ YZPSTIF¥ Z
9ZHa`
¥ EI U KZa` `EPPRZUT` STI UkŠHSWZG/Ha`
P20
a1
b2
P JI  G1ZI U
ZU
b1
b3 §
/
G
a
I

K
F
G
R
`
‘
E
G/HU5
‘ YZPSTIF¥ Z
9ZHa`
¥ EI U KZa` `EPPRZUT` STI UkŠ HSWZG/Ha`
0
P3
a1
b3
P JI  G1ZI U
ZU
b1
b2 §
¨ KEHa`J©
ª Js« Za`L‘YZP STI5` 0 ]
]
M&EHP ZI ULGFI5BHS `P ZpEP U STP JKZ¥ Z
¥ ZL‘ ES I
ZU
P1 P2 P3
G
a1
¥ Z U HaSWJIK¤K?Z
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
ª Q « iG QSWZI
STI ¥G/STU GFIBHaS `aPRZEs U S P JK¥ Z^‘ ESTI
V (P ) ∪ V (P20 ) ∪ V (P3 )
a
ZUXF¥ Z U HS JIK¤ K?Z 1
] EG QSWZI
]
]
M&[email protected]_Z\ \9H[JPSU¥ 1Z
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
P1 P20 P3
ZUgF¥ ZpU HSWJIK¤ K?Z
EP U STPJKZX¥ ZX‘ ESTI
a1
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
ª ‘£« iG QSWZI
STI ¥ G/STU GFIB
 HaS `aPRZEs U S P JK¥ Z^‘ ESTI
0
V (P ) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 )
a
ZUXF¥ Z U HS JIK¤ K?Z 1
] EG QSWZI
]
] 0 M&[email protected]_Z\ \9H[JPSU¥ 1Z
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
P 1 P2 P3
¥ ZL‘ ES I
Z&Ug¥ ZpU HS JIF¤ KZ
EP U STPJKZX¥ Z
G
a1
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
‰
& ')(*,+(
)T#9(878(3.<+"<,\.<,=)'.:5+)&9(3!)+ #78(3/(89%+M73+SU,=(89*$K'+ (P ) +1.9,=V:5!(8)'.
i
,='.%.%(C73!)#N^$&'+ (P 0 ) i
‰ ) /1!:0:5+)'/1+T
-,="\#"%!#AB+"07I,R/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 , =‰ )6)'!9%+ H 73+V9"%! 2#+ G
(8)'2;#(89-,=" V (P ) ∪ V (P ) r ( 73+1. .<!:0:5+9%. (8)K9%4"(3+#"%.h2#+ P 0 :^,=)'$K'+)&9h+)K9( :7
2
3
1
"%+:5+)K9 H > ,=73!"%. P 0 > P > P SU!":5+)&9#)d#"(3.%:5+L!#9(8:^,=7t2#+ G > !)'/J!)d+#9
2
3
1
.##.%+"[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+2C? #).%!:0:5+9(8)K9%4"(3+#" c 2#+ P 0 $K#(-AB!(89 H +9/<O'!(3.(,='.<.(
1
#"%F/%O'+0$K'+Xp.%.%(8e#73+J2#+ b nR!)&9"%!)'.L$&'[email protected]+ (3.%9%+)'/1+02#+X/1+\.%!:0:5+9h+)K9"<, 3)'+
1
#)'+/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) Y 73+N"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(89-,=" V (H) ∪ V (P 0 ) \ {a } +9q73+9"(I,=)#N73+
%
:
1)1( /1+X1$&#( :5!)&9"%+\$K'+
{b1 , b2 , b3 } .<,=9(3.mSU!)&99%!#9%+1.73+1.O p!9O .%+1.M2;R73+:0:5+
>
% "<,=:0(32#+ no,=(3. /1+7I,^/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%4\2#+
1
/
!
&
)
9
3
(
+
&
)
M
9
#)
#
"
3
(
.
5
:
J
+
!
R
#)
'
G
+
0
F
p_
8 =
F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | +1/(Z#"%!#AB+h7I,0/1!)'/78'.(3!) ,
4 "%!#AB!)'.H7I,0/1!)'/78'.%(3!) 8 e =p‰ )d)'!9%+
H 73+G9"%!2#+ G (8)'2;#(89H-,=" V (P1 ) ∪
B_ !:0:5+
:
^
:
=
,
'
)
&
$
'+
!
\
)
P
.
=
,
8
(
t
9
K
$
'+
V (P3 )
a1
b2 >
P20 .%. 2#+g2#+1.q.%!:0:5+9%.t(8)&9%4"(3+#"%.
r !(89
c 73+0.%!:0:5+9G(8)K9%4"(3+#"J2#+ P20 $K#(qAB!(89 V (H) > +9G/%O'!(3.(,='.<.(q#"%K/<O'+5$K'+
.%.(8e#73+\2#+ b - !9%!)'.h$K'+ c + (3.%9%+X/Q,=" a ∈ H uH+1.9%+)K9
+ ,=:0(8)'+"G$K-,=9"%+
2
1
/Q,!./1!)'2;#(3.P,=)&9
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)o!
/1+G$KZ?[,1A,=)'/1+h73+h73+:0:5+ Y
T
%
M
Qr
)5t% %
7
k r ( )'+MAB!(89H2#+
c
H $K'+ a1 > ,=73!"%. P1 > P20 > P3 SU!":5+)&9 #)'+M "<,=:0(32#+L!#9(
:^,=73+G2#+G/1!(8)
+9H2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+
a
{b , b , b }
1 2 3
k r ( )'+gAB!(892#+ 1 $K'+
c
H
a1 +9t#)\AB!(3.(8)52#+ a1 > ,=73!"%. V (P1 )∪V (P20 )∪V (P3 )
(8)'2;#(89H#)T#"(3.:5+L!#9(8:^,=7‹2#+G/1!(8)
+9H2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+
a
{b , b , b }
1
1 2 3
k r ( :^,=)'$K'+
c
a1 ,=73!"%.\73+VN"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(890-,=" V (H) ∪ V (b2 − P20 − c)
+973+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } .<,=9(3.mSU!)&9H9%!#9%+1.73+1.*O % !9O : %. +1.H2;d73+:0:5+ 1)( >
1 2 3
/1+\$&#( :5!)&9"%+0$K'+ F 0 /1!)&9(3+)K9G#)#"(3.%:5+X!R#)'+X % "<,=:0(32#+ nR,=(3.M/1+7I,
/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%452#+ F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | 8 (87q:^,=)'$&'+\73+1.h.<!:0:5+9%.h2#+
=
P20 +)K9"%+ c +9 a1
7
k r ( AB!(89
7
c
a1 +9 ,=X:5!(8)'.`#)L)'!) AB!(3.(8)02#+ a1 .#" H > ,=73!"%.`(87F+ (3.%9%+#)J/<O'+
6
:0(8) Q 2#+ H 2#+73!)#N'+#"q,=L:5!(8)'. > +9`2#!)K9‹73+1.`+ 9"%4:0(89%41.t.%!)K9 a +9‹#)
1
AB!(3.(8)b2#+ c nR,=(3.g,=73!"%.73+*N"<,=#O'+ F 0 (8)'2;#(89-,=" (V (H) ∪ V (P 0 )) \ V (Q∗ )
2
+973+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } .<,=9(3.mSU!)&9H9%!#9%+1.73+1.*O % !9O : .%+1.H2;d73+:0:5+ 1)( >
1 2 3
/1+\$&#( :5!)&9"%+0$K'+ F 0 /1!)&9(3+)K9G#)#"(3.%:5+X!R#)'+X % "<,=:0(32#+ nR,=(3.M/1+7I,
/1!)&9"%+12;([email protected]!#9(8:^,=78(89%452#+ F /Q,=" |F 0 | < |F | 8 (87q:^,=)'$&'+\73+1.h.<!:0:5+9%.h2#+
=
Q∗
_ +1/(B#"%!#AB+7I,H/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 e =<! ,*#"%+#AB+2#+q7I,*/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 / = +1.9‹.<+:Le#7I,=e#73+
/1+7873+G2#+M7I,0/1!)'/78'.(3!) 8 e =
2
- !'.V2#!)#)'!)'.V#)ˆ73+:0:5+R$K#(+1.9b#)'+dA,="(I,=)&9%+R2; #"%41/1412#+)&9 :^,=(3.V$&#(
>
/1!)'/1+")'+d/1+99%+SU!(3.073+1.0#"(3.:5+1.^73!)#NB. 8 /[email protected]+1.9 7 $7 2;(8"%+d73+1.5#"(3.:5+1.^2;( # 4"%+)K9%.b2#+
=Bl )#"(3.:5+G73!)#N PS I S P JK 2',=)'.H#)N"<,=#O'+
+1.9H#)#"(3.:5+J73!)#Nb2#!)&973+
C6
)'!:Le#"%+52#+5.<!:0:5+9%.G+1.9h(8);SU4"(3+#"J!4N&,=7
2;TN"<,=#O'+ G
/1+78#(2#+\9%!#9X,=#9"%+0#"(3.:5+073!)#N
“”K•c•”RŸC— c^ ESTU
G/I¤H[JP [email protected]`&JI5`gB\H[JPS ¥ Z ^ ESVZI U
]
]
] U HNES `L‘YZŽ
G
§
P 1 P2 P3
M&EHaP JIBU GFIo HaS `aPRZ KEIK¤ PSTI1STPJK
¥ Z U HaSWJIK¤KZa`
ZU
P STI5`VF¥ Z
G
F
{a , a , a }
"I3`GQ&E9`&Z5EGFH
JEG/H Z qU HŠPS UkŠa` 1 ZU 2 3 ^_ESTU
G 5Z
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
i = 1, 2, 3
P
a
bi §
^ ES U 0 GFIB
 K GF`V‘ EG/HUh‘Y5ZPS IDi¥ Z
9ZH `
¥ EI U;KZai`R`EP
PRZUT`
i ∈ {1, 2, 3} §
Pi
a
b
1
i
ª K%¦ JB¥&¥ STU SWEIo¥ Za` STI ¥SU‘ Za`@`#¦ ZI U,ZI ¥ P EQ¥GFKE «
S I UkŠ HaSVZG/H `@P JI  G1ZI U
ZU
§
bi+1
bi+2
¨ K EHa` ] K%¦ ZI5`&ZPRQK?Z
STI ¥G/STU G/I^BHaS `aPRZ K EIK¤nEP U STPJK
V (Pi0 ) ∪ V (Pi+1 ) ∪ V (Pi+2 )
¥ ZX‘ ESTI
ZUg¥ Z U HaSWJIK¤ K?Z
¥ Z
G
a1
{b1 , b2 , b3 } §
! ,X#"%+#AB+L+1.9+)9%!#9*!(8)&9H.(8:0(87I,=(8"%+ I7 ,X#"%+#AB+G2;73+:0:5+ *A*
- !9%!)'.$&Z? (3/( 73+N"<,=#O'+
%
:
%
G +1.9-,="O p!9O .<+H.<,=)'. <" ,=:0(32#+ /1+ $&#(#Sf,=([email protected]!)
>
%
)'+Mp+#9 ,=:^,=(3.*9"%!#AB+"H2#+G "<,=:0(32#+
&
')(
*,+(
-
2
- !'.#"%!.%!)'.M7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+0.#(8A,=)&9M!#"M2#49%+1/9%+"h73+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1.G!R73+1.
#"(3.:5+1. Y
•”dŸZ—
(
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
f
r
'
(
( 73+GN"<,=#O'+X+1.9H.<,=)'. % "<,=:0(32#+J+9.<,=)'. #
`
"(3.:5+ Y j - (`#"(3.:5+ > #
) (
r (8)'!) Y #)^#"(3.:5+ ! #9(8:^,=7p!V#)'+ % <" ,=:0(32#+!#9(8:^,=73+M2#+ % "<,=:0(32#+sl '
G
' #" $
*
"
Q
RTMˆH #F k_ !)'.(32#4"%+"H.'/1/1+1.<.(8AB+:5+)&9 9%!'.*73+1.$K-,!2;"##73+9%.
(a1 , b1 , b2 , b3 ) ∈ V 4
_ =, 73/#73+"‹!#"
i = 1, 2, 3 #)J#78'.‹/1!#"9 /%O'+:0(8) Pi 2#+ a1 AB+"%. bi 2#!)&9`73+1.
.%!:0:5+9%.h(8)K9%4"(3+#"%.G:^,=)'$K'+)&9G73+\"%+1.9%+\2;$K-,!2;"##73+9 `r ([email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+
%
V (P1 ) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 ) (8)'2;#(89#)R#"(3.:5+L!R#)'+G "<,=:0(32#+ > ,=73!"%.73+
.9%F/ B+"+):54:5!(8"%+ kr (g,='/#)6$&-,!2;"##73+9X)Z?[,2#!)#)'4V2#+5#"(3.%:5+b! 2#+5 % "<,=:0(32#+ "%+9%!#" 7
>
)'+"0j - ( #"(3.%:5+ > )#( % "<,=:0(32#+sl Hr (8)'!) > "%+9%!#")'+"#) #"(3.:5+!ˆ#)'+
% "<,=:0(32#+G2#+h9<,=(87873+h:0(8)#(8:^,=73+L-,=":0(‹/1+ .9%K/ B41.H+)T:54:5!(8"%+ f
"
&
(
O(n4 m)
%
r (
G +1.9b.<,=)'.^#"(3.:5+d+9V.<,=)'.b "<,=:0(32#+ > ,=73!"%.b(87 +1.9b/7I,=(8"V$K'+
%
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L"%4p!)'2Vj (C#"(3.:5+ > )#(‹ "<,=:0(32#+sl r (
:
%
:
G .%. 2#+T#)'+T "<,=:0(32#+R!D#)ˆ#"(3.:5+ > ,=73!"%. G .%. 2#+T#)D#"(3.%:5+
!#9(8:^,=7!o#)'+\ % "<,=:0(32#+0!#9(8:^,=73+ > $K'[email protected]!)])'!9%+ F _ #)'+0/1+"9<,=(8)'+049<,=+ >
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+/1!)'.(32 : "%+*#)^$K-,!2;"##73+9 (a , b , b , b ) > 9%+7'$K'+ {b , b , b } +1.%9#)
1 1 2 3
1 2 3
9"(I,=)#N73+M2#+ F +9 a ∈
+1.%9#)/1!(8)V2#+ F /! ?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+h/Q,=73/#73+h,=73!"%.
1 / {b1 , b2 , b3 }
2#+1.*#78'. /1!#"9%./%O'+:0(8)'. P 2#+ a AB+"%. b 54 ,=" 9"%!(3.H,=##78(3/Q,=9(3!)'. /1!)'.<41/#9(8AB+1.
i
1
i
2#+1.*73+:0:5+1. *Aj +9 *A* > !)TAB!(89H$K'+ V (P ) ∪ V (P ) ∪ V (P ) (8)'2;#(89#)T#"(3.%:5+
1
2
3
!R#)'+G % "<,=:0(32#+\!#9(8:^,=73+X2#+ G > 2#+L/1!(8) a +92#+L9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } B> !)'/
1
¥ 1 Y/EQ2‘ 2#3 +T: 2 :5+
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+"%+9%!#")'+d/1+.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+ > ! #) .%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+ JBD
9<,=(87873+ > ,=)'. 73+L#(8"%+J2#+1.M/Q,!. 9%+1.9%+" 9%!'.H73+1.$K-,!2;"##73+9%.M)'41/1+1.%.(89%+
O(n4 ) 49<,=+1.
>
_ ,=73/#73+"73+1.#78'.H/1!#"9%.*/%O'+:0(8)'.H+9*AB4"(žW-+"$K'+73+h.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+h!e#9%+)Kd+1.9*#)
#"(3.:5+J!d#)'+L % "<,=:0(32#+G)'41/1+1.%.(89%+ O(m) 49<,=+1. 1> !)'/ > ,=#(8"%+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
.%+M9%+":0(8)'+J+) O(n4 m) 49<,=+1. 2
&
')(*,+(
-
i )X"%+:0#7I, m ,=)K9-,="9%!#92',=)'[email protected])'!)'/14*/(;2#+1.%.'.‹jk#"(3.:5+sl-,="`jk#"(3.:5+73!)#N!l
+9h+)R(8)&ABF$&-,=)K9h73+J73+:0:5+ *)(
7I,^#7I,!/1+\2;R73+:0:5+ *A* > !),=""(8AB+
2#49%+1/9%+"
73+1.*#"(3.%:5+1.73!)#NB.2',=)'.H73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.H.<,=)'. % "<,=:0(32#+ Y
•a”dŸC—
%
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G .<,=)'.* "<,=:0(32#+
' (
' f (
r #
( 73+N"<,=#O'++1.9q.<,=)'.q#"(3.%:5+73!)#N Y j 4 ,!.2#+#"(3.%:5+*73!)#N!l &r (8)'!) Y
#)#"(3.:5+M73!)#N5:0(8)#(8:^,=7 2#+ G #"%$ * " r (8:0(87I,=(8"%+
!
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+G#"%41/1412#+)K9 &
"
(
f
O(n6 )
!(3/(C:^,=(8)K9%+)-,=)&9 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M73+ #78'."<,=#(32#+h$K'+)'!'., % !)'.*9"%!#AB4M!#"
2#49%+1/9%+"*73+1.#"(3.:5+1.H!V73+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1. 5- !9%!)'.*$K'+7f? '.<,=NB+h2;73+:0:5+h.#NNB4"%4
-,=" g"'/1+Ru +1+12 8 73+:0:5+ 1)(= ,+":0(3.2#+d"<,!/1/1!#"%/(8"T9" : ..%+)'.%(8e#73+:5+)&9T.<,
#"%+#AB+ •a”dŸC— ˜
' (
' f (
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
r (t73+JN"<,=#O'+0+1.%9M.P,=)'.M % "<,=:0(32#+0+9M.P,=)'.M#"(3.:5+ Y j - (t#"(3.:5+\)#(
% "<,=:0(32#+sl pr (8)'!) j Π7 % ,X#)d#"(3.:5+G!T#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+sl >
T
%
#" $
"
*
M
)5t% Y
4 !#" 9%!'.73+1.*9"(I,=)#N73+1.
T = {b1 , b2 , b3 } 2#+ G SU,=(8"%+
H_ ,=73/#73+"
$ #(oAB!(3+)&9 b +9
X1 > +)'.%+:Le#73+ 2#+1.€.%!:0:5+9%.2#+ G &
1
_
2
!
_
:^,=)'$&'+)K9 b , b
,=73/#73+"2#+g: :5+ X , X
,=73/#73+" X [email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+
2 3
2
3
_ ,=73/#73+"g73+1.
2#+1..<!:0:5+9%.g2#+ G $K#(')'+ AB!(3+)&9*,='/#)V.<!:0:5+9g2#+ T F
/1!:0p.P,=)&9%+1./1!)#)'+ +1.2#+ X H
r (H!#"
!
AB % ,=)&9
7I,
(87H+ (3.%9%+T#)ˆ.%!:0:5+9V2#+
i = 1> 2
3>
Xi
S ! (3.b#)ˆ.<!:0:5+9V2#+ X
+9^#) .%!:0:5+9b2#+ X > ,=73!"%.b.%9%!#p+"
i+1
i+2
+9H"%+9%!#")'+"Hj Π7 % ,5#)d#"(3.:5+J!d#)'+L % "<,=:0(32#+sl 8 ! ?[,!2#2;(89(3!)o2#+1.
(8)'2;(3/[email protected]+)K9%+)'2:5F2;#73 )=
6H‰ )]:^,="%$&'+5,=(8)'.%(/1!:0p.<,=)K9%+1.L/1!)#)'+ +1.G2#+
> !)#)'+"
/%O-,!$K'+
X
/1!:0p.P,=)&9%+ H 7I,R:^,="%$&'+ i .Q? (87+ (3.9%+#)D.%!:0:5+9^2#+ H AB % ,=)&9
#).%!:0:5+92#+ X r (Z#)'+J/1!:0p.<,=)K9%+ H "%+ m !(89H73+1.H9"%!(3.:^,="%$K'+1.
i
Π%
%
1, 2, 3 > .9%!#+"+9"%+9%!#")'+"*j 7 ,\#)T#"(3.%:5+G!#)'+M "<,=:0(32#+sl
4 !#"V9%!#9
(i, j) ∈ {1, 2, 3}2 > !#"5/%O-,!$K'+d/1!:0.<,=)&9%+ H 2#+ X
p.<. : 2',=)&973+1. 2#+ :^,="%$&'+1. i, j +9 !#" /<O-,!$&'+X.%!:0:5+9 x 2#+ X
i
_4
p.<. : 2',=)&9M#)oAB!(3.(8)o2',=)'. H > 2#!)#)'+"
x 7I,^:^,="%$&'+ j !#"h9%!#9
%
i ∈ {1, 2, 3} > +9q!#"/%O-,!$K'+.%!:0:5+9 x 2#+ Xi , ,=)&9#)5AB!(3.(8)52',=)'.
r
&
Xj (i 6= j) > 2#!)#)'+" x 7I, :^,="%$K'+ j (;#)\.<!:0:5+92#+ X1 ∪X2 ∪X3
:
#
p.<. 2#+G2#+ :^,="%$K'+1. 2;( 4"%+)&9%+1. > .9%!#+" +9"%4!)'2;"%+hj Π7 % ,\#)
#"(3.:5+G!#)'+G % "<,=:0(32#+sl &
')(
r F
( ,='/#)X9"(I,=)#N73+)Z?[,p+":0(3. 2#+.%9%!#p+"`p!#"`"%+9%!#")'+"‹j Œ 7 % ,#)L#"(3.:5+
!#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+sl > .9%!#p+"+9H"%+9%!#")'+"j - (‹#"(3.:5+M)#(Z % <" ,=:0(32#+sl *,+(
"
&
-
(
f
O(n3 (n + m))
nR!)&9"%!)'.2C?[,=ep!"%2 Y
8P«^ S
E9` ` $¥ Z G/IbBHS `P Z EG GFI_Z \9H[JPSU¥ Z
] JKEHa` K¦ [email protected]¤qEHSTUTY PRZ H ZUVEG/HaI_Z
G
F
aK \3JRGFIbBHS `aPRZpEG GFI_Z \9H[JPSU¥ Z
§
r ! (89
#
‰
)V)'!9%+ c 73+AB!(3.(8)V2#+ b 2',=)'. F \ {b , b }
{b1 , b2 , b3 } #)V9"(I,=)#N73+h2#+ F
1
1
2 3
+9g!)2#4sW')#(89*2#+ : 2 :5+ c > c /4 !#" i = 1, 2, 3 > )'!9%!)'.$K'+H7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M:5+9 c
2 3
i
2',=)'. X i
r (
* .<!:0:5+9%. ,=73!"%.G!)]/1!)'.9<,=9%+0$&'+J7f? #)2#+
F )Z?[,V$K'+
c1 , c2 , c3 AB!(89M73+1.
>
i
>
2#+
,=#9"%+1.
!)'/R7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+o.9%!#+
[email protected]<,=+ +9V"%+9%!#")'+j Œ 7 % ,#)
#"(3.:5+h!#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+sl r (
* .%!:0:5+9%. +9 .(
%
:
F ,5#78'.H2#+
F )[email protected]+1.9 -,!.H#)'+L "<,=:0(32#+L.%. 2',=)K9H#)
>
/%O'+:0(8)]2#+L73!)#N'+#" > ,=73!"%. !)o/1!)'.9<,=9%+\$K'+ F \ {b , b , b , c , c , c } +1.%9H#)
1 2 3 1 2 3
N"<,=#O'+G/1!)#)'+ +h$K#(CAB!(89 X , X , X 5> !)'/ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+G:5+9H73+1..%!:0:5+9%.2#+
1
2
3
m
F \ {b1 , b2 , b3 , c1 , c2 , c3 } 2',=)'.g#)'+ /1!:0.<,=)K9%+2#+ X $K#( "%+ !(8973+1. :^,="%$K'+1. >
##(3..9%!#+
[email protected]<,=p+ 6 +9*"%+9%!#")'+Mj Œ 7 % ,X#)#"(3.%:5+h!#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+sl r (
* .%!:0:5+9%.G+9G.(
%
F ,V#78'.G2#+
F +1.%9#)'+5 "<,=:0(32#+^,1AB+1/0#)/<O'+:0(8)a2#+
73!)#N'+#" > ,=73!"%.5!) .##p.<+
#)'+T. % :549"(3+#" : .0$K'+ c +1.%9X73+/1!(8)D2#+7I,
1
% "<,=:0(32#+ gr (
Y 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
c c ∈ E +9 c c ∈ E ,=73!"%. F ,].( .%!:0:5+9%.
2 1
3 1
.6
RTMˆH #F =, #"<,=(89d2#4 .9%!#+" H‰ ) +#9d2#!)'/.##.%+"
#)'+. % :549"(3+]#" : .d$&'+ c
2
:^,=)'$K'+ c /> !)'/ > 2',=)'.g73+/%O'+:0(8)T2#+H7I,G % "<,=:0(32#+M"%+78(I,=)&9 b
c1 > (87 + (3.9%+2#+1.
1
2
.%!:0:5+9%.+)&9"%+ c +9 c > $&#(t,=#-,="9(3+)#)'+)&9
#)'+X/1!:0.<,=)&9%+X/1!)#)'+ + H 2#+
2
1
!
X "%+1/1+A,=)&9073+1.J:^,="%$&'+1. 1 +9 2 +V.%!:0:5+9 c1 +1.%9X,=73!"%.X#) .%!:0:5+9X2#+ X1
"%+1/1+A,=)&9g7I,h:^,="%$K'+ 2 8 /Q,="(87,h#)^AB!(3.%(8)b2',=)'. H =;r ( c AB!(89 c > ,=73!"%. c "%+ m !(89
1
3
1
7I,d:^,="%$&'+ qr (8)'!) > (87+ (3.%9%+b2#+1.X.%!:0:5+9%.\.#"X73+^/%O'+:0(8) 2#+ F "%+78(I,=)K9 b
3
#)'+X/1!:0.<,=)&9%+0/1!)#)'+ +
c1 > $&#(t.%!)&9h+)K9"%+ c3 +9 c1 > +9h$&#(q,=#-,="9(3+)#)'+)&9
m
>
H 0 2#+ X "%+1/1+A!,=)K9L73+1.J:^,="%$&'+1. 1 +9 3 !)'/ > c1 "%+ !(89J+)'/1!"%+b7I,:^,="%$&'+
o (8)-,=73+:5+)&9
m
> c1 "%+ !(8973+1.q:^,="%$K'+1. 2 +9 3 > 2#!)'/7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+H.9%!#+ [email protected]<,=+
+9"%+9%!#")'+Mj Π7 % ,X#)#"(3.:5+G!T#)'+G % "<,=:0(32#+sl R_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
8 1« ^ S %K ¦ JK ¤qEHaS UTY PRZ H ZUVEG/HI Z aK \DJDGFIBHaS `aPRZ EG G/I ZX \9H[JPSU¥ Z] JK EHa`
G
E` `%$%¥ Z F
G IbBHS `aPRZpEG GFI_ZgB\H[JPS ¥FZ
§
[email protected]'2#+J2;'$&'+7‹7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L.9%!#+ r !(89
T = {b1 , b2 , b3 } 73+h9"(I,=)#N73+
r ( 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+\.9%!#+
[email protected]<,=p+ > ,=73!"%. (87t+ (3.9%+
#)'+X. % :549"(3+L#" : .#)
.%!:0:5+9 c 2#+ X > $&#(`AB!(89 2#+ .%!:0:5+9%. c ∈ X +9 c ∈ X pr ( c AB!(89 c >
1
1
2
2
3
3
2
3
,=73!"%[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ {c , c , c , b , b , b } (8)'2;#(89#)5#"(3.:5+ Fr ( c :^,=)'$K'+ c > ,=73!"%.
1 2 3 1 2 3
2
3
[email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+ {c , c , c , b , b , b } (8)'2;#(89#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+ 1 2 3 1 2 3
r (;7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+.%9%!#p+ [email protected]<,=p+ 6 ,=73!"%[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+
:
7
>
X p.%. 2#+#)'+/1!:0
.<,=)K9%+H/1!)#)'+ + H /1!:0#"%+)-,=)&92#+1..%!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$&'41. 1 > 2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$K'41.
#Œ 2 +9H2C?[,=#9"%+1.*:^,="%$K'41. 3 7Z+ (3.9%+h2',=)'. G 9"%!(3..%!:0:5+9%. c1 ∈ X1 > c2 ∈ X2 +9
'‰
c3 ∈ X3 > 9%+7C$&'+M!#" i = 1, 2, 3 > ci AB!(89*#).%!:0:5+9*2#+ H )d,=##78(3$K'+G,=73!"%.
73+73+:0:5+ 1)( ,= N"<,=#O'+(8)'2;#(890-,=" {b , b , b , c , c , c } ∪ H +90,= 9"(I,=)#N73+
-‰
: 1 2 3 1 2 3
%
{b1 , b2 , b3 } )/1!)'.9<,=9%+G$K'+ G .%. 2#+Me#(3+)#)T#"(3.:5+L!#)'+h "<,=:0(32#+
r (7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+G.%9%!#p+
[email protected]<,=p+ > ,=73!"%. > #)'+M. % :549"(3+#" : . > (87+ (3.9%+#)
.%!:0:5+9 c 2#+ X $&#(', 2#+1. AB!(3.(8)'. :^,="%$&'41. 2 +9 3 - !9%!)'.t$&Z? (87#+1.9 (8:0p.<.(8e#73+
1
1
$K'+ c ,=(892#+1.HAB!(3.%(8)'.2',=)'. X +9 X > /Q,="M,=73!"%. 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+0,=#"<,=(89M.9%!#4
1
2
3
[email protected]<,=+ -‰ ).##.%+M2#!)'/h.<,=)'.p+"9%+h2#+MNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4L$&'+ c )Z?[,X-,!.2#+AB!(3.(8)
1
2',=)'. X B> !)'/ > c ,0"%+ m R7I,^:^,="%$&'+ 6 +)"<,=(3.%!)o2C? #)'+J/1!:0.<,=)&9%+\/1!)#)'+ +
2
1
H 2#+ X /1!:0#"%+)-,=)K9V2#+1.5.<!:0:5+9%.5:^,="%$K'41. 1 +952#+1.5.%!:0:5+9%.^:^,="%$&'41. 2
- !9%!)'.M$&Z? (87 )Z? % ,b,='/#)'+\,=" 2 9%+\+)&9"%+
m
H +9 X3 > /Q,="M.(8)'!) H ,=#"<,=(89M"%+ R73+1.
:^,="%$K'+1.0+907f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+d,=#"<,=(89^.9%!#4
[email protected]<,=p+ 6r !(89^,=73!"%.0#) /<O'+:0(8)
%
P 2#+ H "%+78(I,=)&9h#)oAB!(3.(8) d1 2#+ c1 #)].%!:0:5+9 d2 , ,=)K9h#)RAB!(3.%(8) c2 2',=)'.
r (
m 7I,d:^,="%$K'+
X2 > 2#+^73!)#N'+#"\:0(8)#(8:^,=7,1AB+1//1+1.X#"%!#"(349%41.
c1 ,d"%+
3 +)
2
"<,=(3.%!)c2C? #)'+^,=" 9%+5+)&9"%+ c +9G#).%!:0:5+9 c 2#+ X > ,=73!"%.L73+1.h9"%!(3.L/<O'+:0(8)'.
1
3
3
%
b1 − c1 > b2 − c2 − d2 − P − d1 − c1 +9 b3 − c3 − c1 S !":5+)K9#)'+o "<,=:0(32#+2#+
9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } +9V2#+/1!(8) c r (8)'!) > c ,]"%+ m ˆ7I,o:^,="%$K'+ +) "<,=(3.%!)
1 2 3
1
1
2C? #)'+G/1!:0.<,=)K9%+L/1!)#)'+ + H 0 2#+ X /1!:0#"%+)-,=)&9M2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.H:^,="%$&'41. 1 +9
2#+1..<!:0:5+9%.:^,="%$K'41. 3 5- !9%!)'.$KZ? (87Z)Z? % ,0,='/#)'+L,=" 2 9%+G+)K9"%+ H +9 H 0 > /Q,="
/1+.<!)&9b2#+1.^/1!:0p.<,=)K9%+1.b/1!)#)'+ +1.^2#+ X > )#(H+)K9"%+ H 0 +9 X /Q,="b.%(8)'!) H 0
2
,=#"<,=(8973+1. :^,="%$&'+1.+9H7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+0,=#"<,=(89M.9%!#4
[email protected]<,=+ 6r !(89,=73!"%.#)
/<O'+:0(8) Q 2#+ H 0 "%+78(I,=)K9h#)AB!(3.%(8) e 2#+ c
#)o.%!:0:5+9 e , % ,=)K9G#)RAB!(3.(8)
1
1
73!"%.g3 73+1.9"%!(3.*/<O'+:0(8)'.
c 2',=)'. X > 2#+73!)#N'+#"g:0(8)#(8:^,=7Z,QAB+1//1+1.g#"%!#"(349%41.
3
3
T
%
.
)5t% M
%
b1 −c1 > b2 −c2 −d2 −P −d1 −c1 +9 b3 −c3 −e3 −Q−e1 −c1 SU!":5+)&9#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+
2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } +92#+G/1!(8) c d_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8W6q=
1 2 3
1
> ?[,=#" : . 8N<= +9 8W6q= 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M+1.9/1!);S !":5+ .%+1..41/(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'. )K#:54 7
>
"%+" 9%!'.73+1.t9"(I,=)#N73+1.2#+ G )'41/1+1.%.(89%+,=0#(8"%+ O(n3 ) 49<,=+1. uH+1.%9%+ AB4"(žW-+"$K'+
/%O-,!/#)'+52#+1.L,=#9"%+1.L49<,=p+1.M+#9 2 9"%+\"%4Q,=78(3.%41+\-,="h#)]-,="%/1!#"%.L2#+\[email protected]+)'.<+:Le#73+
2#+1.g,=" 2 9%+1.2#+ G F4 !#"[email protected]<,=p+ > (87.59gp!#"g/%O-,!$K'+M,=" 2 9%+2#+ AB4"(žW-+"g.(p7f? #)'+
2#+1.`+ 9"%4:0(89%4+1.9 b > +9t2#+:^,="%$&'+"t7f?[,=#9"%++ 9"%4:0(89%4j X l 9! +1.t.%!:0:5+9%.q, % ,=)K9
i
i
#)'++9#)'+ .%+#73+*:^,="%$K'+j X l.%+"%!)K973+1.4734:5+)K9g2#+ X ! +1..<!:0:5+9%.)Z?[, % ,=)K9
i
i
"%+ m T,='/#)'+M:^,="%$K'+M.%+"%!)&9*73+1.4734:5+)K9%.2#+ X 8 !)T"(3.%$&'+2#+M2#+AB!(8"*-,="%/1!#"(8"
=_4 !#"h73+1.49<,=+1. +9 6 #)R-,="%/1!#"%.M2#+1.
>
V (G) p!#"73+1. #"%+)'2;"%+X+)o/1!:0#9%+
2
5
,=" 9%+1.*.59
!9%!)'.*[email protected]!)p+#9AB4"(žW-+" ,=VS #"*+9
:5+1.#"%+h2#+1.:^,="%$K-,=NB+1..(
#)'+ /1!:0.<,=)&9%+ H ,h9"%!(3.g:^,="%$K'+1. > .<,=)'.$KZ? (87 % ,=(89e+1.%!(8)b2#+ 73+1."%+-,="%/1!#"(8"
,=#" : .0/1!# 4 !#"[email protected]<,=+ > (87*.590!#"5/%O-,!$K'+,=" 2 9%+ xy ,QAB+1/ x ∈ X +9
i
‰ ) AB4"(žW-+V,=aS#"X+9
:5+1.%#"%+b.(g.%!:0:5+9 x .%. : 2#+
y ∈ H 2#+b:^,="%$K'+" xi
2#+ :^,="%$K'+1. > !)'/ 2',=)'.g73+ #(8"%+ 2#+1./Q,!. 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M)'41/1+1.%.(89%+
>
>
O(n3 (n + m)) 49<,=+1. 2
‰ V
) /1!)'.%9<,=9%+$K'+73+1.2#+ ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1./( 7 2#+1.%.'..%!)K9"%+7I,=9(8AB+:5+)&9*+"mS !" 7
:^,=)&9%.5/1!:0-,="%41.
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A_ +T2#+")#(3+"^.%+:Je#73+2C?[,=(87873+#"%.52;( ^/(873+
,=:5478(3!"%+"
" #
" - !'.2#!)#)'!)'.M(3/( #)o,=78NB!"(89O#:5+02#+X2#49%+1/9(3!)]2#+1. #"(3.%:5+1. -,=(8"%.M2',=)'.73+1.
N"<,=#O'+1.h.<,=)'.M9"%!](8:0-,=(8" - !'.M)Z?[,QAB!)'.h-,!.M9"%!#AB402C? #9(878(3.<,=9(3!)
/1+9L,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ > :^,=(3.*(87‹+1.9*!9%+)&9(3+7873+:5+)K9 (8)K9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9H!#"H,=:5!(8)'.H2#+ "<,=(3.%!)'. Y
73+1.G#"(3.:5+1.L-,=(8"%. !'+)&9X#)"!73+5(8:0!"9<,=)&9X2',=)'.L7I,#"%+#AB+b2#+57I,T/1!) +1/9#"%+
S !"9%+2#+1.bN"<,=#O'+1.V-,="mSf,=(89%.
AB!(8"V73+d9O'41!" : :5+ 6A6q(/"> +d#78'. > (87H+#9 2 9"%+
(8)&9%4"%+1.%.<,=)K9 > +) AF'+T2C?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.5S #9#"%. > 2#+T.<,QAB!(8"^2#49%+1/9%+"^73+1.^.%+#73.5.%!'. 7
N"<,=#O'+1.
7I,LSU!(3.,=#9%!"(3.<41.g2',=)'.73+1.gN"<,=#O'+1.*2C? "9%4:0(3.-,=(8"%.*+9(8)K9%+"%2;(89%.2',=)'.
73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.H2C? "9%4:0(3. ‰ d
) +#9H(3/( +)'/1!"%+X,=##78(3$K'+" 73+1.H:549O'K2#+1.M2#+L#78'. /1!#"9%./%O'+:0(8)'. > :^,=(3.
/1+99%+S !(3. > 73+M/%O'+:0(8)'+:5+)K9+1.%9g:5!(8)'.*2;(8"%+1/9 p‰ )2#!(89/1!)'.%(32#4"%+"H2#+1.*.%!:0:5+9%.
j£,=c:0(878(3+ 2#+1.X/%O'+:0(8)'.ml > !#"X2#+1.J"<,=(3.%!)'.\$K#(,=#-,="<,39"%!)K952',=)'.J7I,d#"%+#AB+
2;V73+:0:5+ *5! ?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+G2#+ _ O&'2;)'QA;. % +9 r + % :5!#" 'A669+ p!#"7I,X2#49%+1/ 7
9(3!)2#+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1.#9(878(3.%+M/1+99%+ : 2 :5+M"'.<+2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.j£,=V:0(878(3+;l > $K#(!)&9
p!#"G/1!)'.%41$K'+)'/1+XS !/%O'+'.%+0:^,=(3.L.<,=)'.h2#!#9%+0(8)'4AF(89<,=e#73+02#+\:L#789(8#78(3+"L-,=" n3
7I,\/1!:0#73+ (89%4J2#+M)'!9"%+L,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ r !(89
`‰
P #) /%O'+:0(8)c2#+^73!)#N'+#"L-,=(8"%[email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. a +9 b ) ,=#+7873+
P STK SWZG 2#+
r
P 7f? #)#(3$&'+.%!:0:5+9 m 2#+ P AB4"(žW ,=)&9 lg(a−P−m) = lg(m−P−b) !(89
F #)L#"(3.:5+-,=(8"ZSU!":54-,="`73+1.‹/%O'+:0(8)'. P1 > P2 > P3 > +9`2#+9"(I,=)#N73+1. {a1 , a2 , a3 } >
{b1 , b2 , b3 } > 2#+h.%!"9%+M$&'+!#" i = 1, 2, 3 > 73+M/%O'+:0(8) Pi .%!(89*[email protected]+ 9"%4:0(89%41. ai +9
`r
`‰ )a2;(89X,=73!"%.L$K'+073+ 7 ##73+9
bi !(89 mi 73+5.<!:0:5+9J,=a:0(878(3+a2; /%O'+:0(8) Pi
9
U
N
H
J
R
P
Z
1
+
.
*
9
I
7
,
#
2
+
(a , a , a , b , b , b , m , m , m )
F
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
3
“”K•a•a”ŸZ—˜ ˜ ^ ESTU
/G I ¤ H[JP YZ
G
BHS `aPRZ 5
 JS H ¥ Z VU JSTKTKZ P TS I1STP J KZ€¥ Z
RTMˆH #F U H[EG S P JSTH Z&U `ES U
G/I
F
^ GQ&E9`EI5`  G5Z
`ES Ua¥ ZcU HNJP Z
G§
F
Z&U M&EHP5Š\JH KZa
` ‘YZPS I1`
]
]
J9Z‘
(a1 , a2 , a3 , b1 , b2 , b3ª , m1 , m2 , m3 )
P P P
« ^_ESTU
G/Ic‘YZPSTc
I ¥ Z
¥‹¦ Z U H%1ŠPST2UkŠa` 3
]
ai , mi , bi ∈ V (Pi ) i = 1, 2, 3 §
R
G
a 1 , m1
¥qEI U K?Za` `&EPPRZUT` STI UkŠHSWZGFHa` P JI  G5ZI U
ZU ] ZH
U ¥ Z KEKI ¤G1ZG/HP STI1SŽ
a2 , a 3 , b 2
b3
P JK?Z J9Z‘0‘ Z`*BH[EPBHSUŠkU Š`
§
¨ KEHa` ]
G1Z K ¦ EI IBEU,Z
Za`U GF]
I ‘YZP ST]
I ¥ Z
]iZU
]
]
a −R−m1 −P1 −b1
G 
R1
R1 P2
M&EHP 1ZI U G/b
I BHaS `aPR
Z JSTL
H ¥ Z
¥FZpUVJS KTKZ PS I S P JK?Z
P3
`JI1`
§
G
%
: - !9%!)'.
r !(89
k 7I,T73!)#N'+#"X2#+ P1 > $K#(+1.9G-,=(8"%+^-,="LO !9O .%+
$K'+ |E(R)| ≤ k/2 ‰ )a)'!9%+ H 73+59"%!62#+ G (8)'2;#(89X-,=" V (P ) ∪ V (P ) qr (
2
3
73+1..<!:0:5+9%.*(8)&9%4"(3+#"%. 2#+ R :^,=)'$K'+)&9 +)&9( : "%+:5+)&9 H > ,=73!"%..%!(89 R #)T#78'.
1
/1!#"9/<O'+:0(8)€2#+ a AB+"%. b /1!)&9%+)& 2',=)'. V (R) ∪ V (m − P − b ) H‰ )€,
1
1
1
1
1
|E(R1 )| ≤ k +9*73+1.H/%O'+:0(8)'. R1 > P2 > P3 SU!":5+)&9#)T#"(3.%:5+ F 0 ,QAB+1/ |V (F 0 )| ≤
8
4
|V (F )| #(3.<$&'+ G +1.9b.<,=)'.^9"%! (8:0-,=(8" > R1 +1.%9b2#+73!)#N'+#"-,=(8"%+ .(8)'!)
=
V (R1 ) ∪ V (P2 ) (8)'2;#(8"<,=(89#)T9"%!(8:0-,=(8" > +9 F 0 +1.9*#)T#"(3.%:5+M-,=(8"*:0(8)#(8:^,=7
! ? (8)'4N&,=78(89%4d/( 7 2#+1.%.'.0+1.902#!)'/V#)'+T4N&,=78(89%4 /1+$&#(:5!)&9"%[email protected]+)6Sf,=(89
>
R1 +1.9
Y
4N&,=7 a −R−m −P −b 7I,\/1!)'/78'.(3!)2;T73+:0:5+L+1.9H.<,=9(3.mSf,=(89%+
1
1
1
‰ )bp1+#92#!)'/H
.##.%+"$KZ? (87-+ (3.9%+*#)b.<!:0:5+9(8)&9%4"(3+#" c 2#+ R , % ,=)&92#+1.
AB!(3.(8)'.M2',=)'. H - !'.,=7873!)'.:5!)&9"%+"G$K'[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+\2#+X/1+J.%!:0:5+9M+)&9"<, 3)'+
#)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) ‰ )/%O'!(3.(89 c ,='.%.%(Z#"%K/<O'+G$K'+hp.<.(8e#73+h2#+ m -‰ )A,XAB!(8"
1
$K'[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+h2#+ c +)&9"<,=(8)'+h#)'+h/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) pr !(89 S #)#78'.*/1!#"9/%O'+:0(8)
2#+ c AB+"%. b /1!)&9%+)&2',=)'. V (c−R−m ) ∪ V (m −P −b ) K‰ )b, |E(S)| < k /Q,="
1
> ?[,=#" : .H7I,^2#14sW')#(89(3!)R1 2#+ 1 ,=1'/#).%!:0:5+9M2#+
|E(R)| ≤ k/2 +9 c 6= a1
c>
S \ b1
)Z?[,2#+\AB!(3.(8)2',=)'. H ‹‰ )2#4sW')#(89L2#+ .%!'. 7 /<O'+:0(8)'.L2#+ H Y H = H\a +9
2
3
4
H3 = H\a2 !#" i = 2, 3 > !))'!9%+ ci 73+5.%!:0:5+9L2#+ Hi AB!(3.(8)c2#+ c 73+5#78'.
#"%F/%O'+G2#+ a i
8P« "I^5
 ZGU `GQ&
 E9`&ZH  G1Z
Za`U GFI_Z JHU,Z\F¥ Z
c2 c3
P2 §
r (
%
c2 = c3 ,=73!"%. V (S) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 ) (8)'2;#(89#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+]2#+R9"(I,=)#N73+
Y
> !)'/
-r
{b1 , b2 , b3 } +9 2#+h/1!(8) c2 #)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
c2 6= c3 ( c2 :^,=)'$K'+ c3 >
%
,=73!"%. V (S) ∪ V (P ) ∪ V (P ) /1!)&9(3+)K9#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+h2#+9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } +9
2
3
1 2 3
2#+X/1!(8) c Y #)'+X/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/ c c +1.9e#(3+)o#)'+X,=" 2 9%+\2#+ G > +9 > $K#(899%+
2 3
41/<O-,=)#NB+" P +9 P > !)]+#9G.##.%+"G$&'+ c c +1.9h#)'+^,=" 2 9%+02#+ P _ +1/(
2
3
2 3
2
#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
&
')(*,+(
-
> !)'/
V (S) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 ) (8)'2;#(89*#)T#"(3.%:5+ F 0 2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+1. {b1 , b2 , b3 }
+ 9 {c, c , c } ,QAB+1/ |V (F 0 )| < |V (F )| ##(3.%$K'+ |E(S)| < k > !)'/ F 0 1+ .95#)
2
3
#"(3.:5+b(8:0-,=(8" > /1+b$K#((8:0#78(3$K'+b$K'+ c − P − b +1.9J#)c/%O'+:0(8) 2#+^73!)#N'+#"
3
2
2
(8:0-,=(8"%+ > +9L2#!)'/ a −P −c #)a/<O'+:0(8)c2#+\73!)#N'+#"L-,=(8"%+ tr !(89 R0 #)#78'.
2
2
2
/1!#"9H/<O'+:0(8)d2#+ c AB+"%. a /1!)K9%+)&2',=)'. V (c−R−m ) ∪ V (m −P −a ) -‰ )
1
1
1
1
1
, |E(R0 )| < k /Q,=" |E(R)| ≤ k/2 > ?[,=#" : .h7I,2#4sW')#(89(3!)a2#+ c > ,='/#).%!:0:5+9
2#+ R0 \ a )Z?[,2#+0AB!(3.%(8)c2',=)'. H > !)'/ R0 +1.9L2#+573!)#N'+#"J-,=(8"%+b/Q,="J.(8)'!) >
1
> !)'/
V (R0 ) ∪ V (a2−P2−c2 ) (8)'2;#(8"<,=(89#)^9"%!^(8:0-,=(8"
V (R0 ) ∪ V (P2 ) ∪ V (P3 )
(8)'2;#(89 #)L#"(3.:5+ F 00 2#+9"(I,=)#N73+1. {a , a , a } +9 {c, c , c } > +9 F 00 +1.9‹#)J#"(3.:5+
1
2
3
2
3
T
%
M
.j
)5t% -,=(8"‹AB4"(žW ,=)&9 |V (F 00 )| < |V (F )| /Q,=" |E(R0 )| < k ! _ 1+ /(F+1.9`#)'+/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) 2
‰ ) +#9o:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K9a2#!)#)'+"o#) ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ #
2 + 2#49%+1/9(3!) 2#+1.R#"(3.:5+1.
-,=(8"%. Y
•”dŸZ— ˜
' (
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G .P,=)'.*9"%!(8:0-,=(8"
f ( r ('73+HN"<,=#O'+H+1.9.<,=)'.#"(3.:5+H-,=(8" Y j 4 ,!.g2#+*#"(3.:5+-,=(8"ml ;r (8)'!) Y
#)#"(3.:5+h-,=(8"H:0(8)#(8:^,=7‹2#+
'
#" $
"
*
G
k_ !)'.(32#4"%+"^.%'/1/1+1.%.(8AB+:5+)&9^9%!'.073+1. r$7 ##73+9%.
(a1 > a2 > a3 > b1 > b2 > b3 >
9
m1 > m2 > m3 ) ∈ V (G)
_ ,=73/#73+"p!#"
i = 1, 2, 3 #) #78'./1!#"9/<O'+:0(8) Ri 2#+ ai AB+"%. mi
2#!)&9g73+1.g.%!:0:5+9%.(8)K9%4"(3+#"%.g:^,=)'$&'+)K973+H"%+1.9%+H2; r$7 ##73+9 > +9#)^#78'.
/1!#"9/%O'+:0(8) S 2#+ m AB+"%. b 2#!)K973+1..%!:0:5+9%.(8)&9%4"(3+#"%.:^,=)'$K'+)&9
i
i
i
73+J"%+1.9%+\2; r$7 ##73+9 Zr ( [email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ ∪
(8)'2;#(89M#)
i=1,2,3 (V (Ri ) ∪ V (Si ))
#"(3.:5+h-,=(8" > 73+h.9%K/ B+"H+):54:5!(8"%+
kr (,='/#) r$7 ##73+9b)Z?[,a2#!)#)'42#+d#"(3.:5+-,=(8" j 4 ,!.V2#+#"(3.%:5+-,=(8"ml >
r (8)'!) "%+9%!#")'+"`#)G#"(3.:5+t-,=(8"‹2#+q9<,=(87873+:0(8)#(8:^,=73+-,=":0(&/1+ .9%F/ B41.
>
+):54:5!(8"%+ &
')(
"
&
*,+(
-
(
f
O(n11 )
r (
G +1.9T.<,=)'.V#"(3.:5+R-,=(8" > ,=73!"%.(87M+1.9T/7I,=(8"$K'+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
"%4p!)'2bj 4 !, . 2#+M#"(3.%:5+h-,=(8"ml r (
:
:
G .%. 2#+5#)a#"(3.:5+^-,=(8" > ,=73!"%. G .%. 2#+0#)c#"(3.:5+5-,=(8"J:0(8)#(8:^,=7 >
$&'[email protected]!) )'!9%+ F i #)'+R/1+"9<,=(8)'+o49<,=+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+o/1!)'.(32 : "%+R#) r$7 ##73+9
.!
(a1 , a2 , a3 , b1 , b2 , b3 , m1 , m2 , m3 ) ∈ V (G)9 $&#(K+1.9‹7I,9"<,=:5+2#+ F ?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
/Q,=73/#73+,=73!"%.2#+1.t#78'./1!#"9%.q/%O'+:0(8)'. R , S 4 ,=".( ,=##78(3/Q,=9(3!)'./1!)'.%41/#9(8AB+1.
i
i
2;]73+:0:5+ * > !)]AB!(89L$K'+ ∪
(8)'2;#(89L#)]#"(3.:5+0-,=(8" i=1,2,3 (V (Ri ) ∪ V (Si ))
> !)'/R7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+o"%+9%!#")'+]/1+o.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+ ! #).%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+ BJ ¥ Y/QE ‘ 2#+
>
: 2 :5+h9<,=(87873+ > ,=)'.73+#(8"%+M2#+1./Q,!. 9%+1.9%+"g9%!'.73+1. r$7 ##73+9%.)'41/1+1.<.(89%+
_ ,=7 7
'
O(n9 ) 49<,=+1.
>
/#73+"573+1.5#78'.5/1!#"9%.b/%O'+:0(8)'.V+95AB4"(žW-+"b$K'+T73+.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+!e#9%+)& +1.95#)
#"(3.:5+h!T#)'+h % "<,=:0(32#+h)'41/1+1.%.%(89%+ O(n2 ) 49<,=p+1. 5> !)'/ > ,=d#(8"%+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
.%+M9%+":0(8)'+G+)
11 49<,=+1. O(n )
"-!
#
2
#"
"-
"+!
K4
! +1.t78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.2#+.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)'.`e#(8-,="9(3+1.2#+
K4 !'+)&9t#)\"!73+(8:0!"9<,=)&9
:
2',=)'.7I, #"%+#AB+]2;9O'41!" :5+2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.T-,="mSf,=(89%.
AB!(8"T-,="+ +:0#73+o73+
9O'41!" : :5+ 6A6*> 49%+1/9%+"\/1+09 % +^2#+5.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+5+#9J2#!)'/ 2 9"%+^(8)&9%4"%+1.%.P,=)&9
i )'.#(89%+ +9h/1+7I,bS#9M)'!9"%+\:5!9(8A,=9(3!)](8)#(89(I,=73+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+52#!)#)'40/( 7
+)o.<!( p
>
>
2 +1.%.%!'.+1.9 +1.%.<+)&9(3+7tp!#"7I,52#49%+1/9(3!)2#+1. #"(3.:5+1.(8:0-,=(8"%. > +92#!)'/J!#" 7I,
#
"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+G2#+1.HN"<,=#O'+1.H2C? "9%4:0(3.*-,=(8"%. .*
vad
RTMˆH vda
#F vac
vab
Pad
Pac
vca
Pab
Pdc
vcd
vdc
vdb
vcb
Pbd
Pcb
vba
vbd
vbc
e"f g"hB*0k3! (8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+J2C? #)'+L.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)Te#(8-,="9(3+G2#+
K4
4 !#"*/1+H$K#( .#(89 !)^!#""<,L/1!)'.%#789%+"7I,GW'N#"%+ *#r (
7
>
F +1.%973+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+
2 ? #)'+0.#e2;(8AF(3.(3!)]e#(8-,="9(3+ R 2#+ K > ,=73!"%.G!)/1!)&AF(3+)&9J2#+\)'!9%+" a > b > c +9 d
C
4
73+1.$K-,=9"%+.<!:0:5+9%.g2; K /1!""%+1.!)'2',=)&9 -‰ )T!"%2#!)#)'+h,="e#(89"<,=(8"%+:5+)&9 a > b > c
4
+9 d Y a < b < c < d _ /%O-,!$K'+0,=" 2 9%+ ij > i < j > 2#+ K > /1!""%+1.%p!)'2o2#!)'/\#)
4
/<O'+:0(8)V2#+ F $&[email protected]!)5)'!9%+ P K‰ )^)'!9%+ v +9 v 73+1.+ 9"%4:0(89%41.2#+ P > 2#+ .%!"9%+
ij
ij
ji
ij
$K'+Mp!#" i = a, b, c, d [email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+ T = {v ; j ∈ {a, b, c, d} > j 6= i} (8)'2;#(3.%+h#)
i
ij
9"(I,=)#N73+ _o (8)-,=73+:5+)&9 > !)!e#9(3+)K9h$&'+L73+1. .( /<O'+:0(8)'. P > P > P > P > P >
ac
ab
ad
bc
bd
Pcd > +9 73+1.2#! Q+L.%!:0:5+9%. vab > vac > vad > vba > vbc > vbd > vca > vcb > vcd > vda > vdb +9
Y
v AB4"(žW-+)K9
dc
k ! +1./%O'+:0(8)'.
Pab > Pac > Pad > Pbc > Pbd > Pcd .%!)K9H2;(3. !(8)&9%.
k
F =P
∪P
∪P
∪P ∪P
∪P
ac
ad
bc
bd
cd
k 4 !#" ab
7
i ∈ {a, b, c, d} > j ∈ {a, b, c, d} > i < j > 73+X/%O'+:0(8) Pij ,0!#" + 9"%4
:0(89%41. v +9 v
ij
ji
k ! +1. +)'
.<+:Le#73+1.
{vab , vac , vad } > {vba , vbc , vbd } > {vca , vcb , vcd } +9
{v , vdb , vdc } .%!)K92#+1.9"(I,=)#N73+1. 2#+ F
k ! +1da
2
..%+#73+1.g,=" 9%+1.2#+ F .%!)K9/1+7873+1.2#+1./%O'+:0(8)'.+99"(I,=)#N73+1.#"%41/1412#+:5+)&9
2#41/"(89%. ‰ ) "%+:^,="%$K'+"<,\$&'+M/1+"9<,=(8)'.*2#+1.*/<O'+:0(8)'.*p+#AB+)K9 2 9"%+h2#+H73!)#N'+#"*)K#7873+ >
/1+M$K#(p/1!""%+1.!)'2
#)'+h,=" 2 9%+M2#+ K )'!)V.%#ep2;(8AF(3.%41+ /4 ,="+ +:0#73+ > P !#" 7
4
ab
"<,=(89 2 9"%+H2#+*73!)#N'+#")K#7873+ > ,='$&'+7 /Q,!.73+1..%!:0:5+9%. v +9 v .<+"<,=(3+)&9/1!);SU!) 7
ab
ba
2;'. nF2;#73G73+/<O'!( (8)#(89(I,=7 2#+*[email protected]!"%2;"%+.#" {a, b, c, d} > 73+1..%!:0:5+9%.+9/<O'+:0(8)'.
T
%
M
<(
)5t% / ( 7 2#+1.%.'..%!)&9*2#4sW')#(3.*.<,=)'.*,=:Je#(8N U9%4 1! +1.*.%!:0:5+9%. v .%!)&9,=#+7341.73+1. ‘ ESTI5`
ij
2#+ F ! +1. /<O'+:0(8)'. P .%!)&9M,=#p+7341. ‘Y5ZPS I5`J¥FZ Q[J9`.Z 2#+ F _ O-,!$&'+X.%!:0:5+9
ij
'‰ )T,=#+7873+h/1+1.g9"(I,=)#N73+ U HaSWJIK¤KZa`L¥ Z Q[J9`.Z
i 2; K4 2#!)#)'+M#)9"(I,=)#N73+ Ti 2#+ F
&
Œ
2#+ F 7#Sf,=#9)'!9%+"g$K'+ F p+#9p.%.<412#+"2C?[,=#9"%+1.g9"(I,=)#N73+1. > 73!"%.%$K'+H2#+1.g,=" 2 9%+1.
2; K 2#+G2#4-,="9)'+h.<!)&9-,!..%#ep2;(8AF(3.%41+1. ! +14. 9"%!(3.t73+:0:5+1. .#(8AK"%+g.%!)K9 e#(3+)0/1!)#)K'.q:^,=(3. )'+g.<!)&9t##e#78(341.t)&#7873+-,="9
.%!'.7I,0SU!":5+\+ ,!/9%+\2#!)&9M)'!'.G,QAB!)'.Mep+1.%!(8) Z_ [email protected]+1.9!#"%$&'!(t)'!'.h2#!)#)'!)'.
73+#"#"%+#AB+\!#"M)'+\"(3+)o7I,=(3.%.%+"h2',=)'[email protected]!:Le#"%+ ! +\73+:0:5+0.#(8A!,=)K9M:5!)&9"%+5+)
$&'!( 7I,V2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+1.M78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.G2#+\.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)oe#(8-,="9(3+02#+ K p+#9G,=(32#+"
4
2#49%+1/9%+" 2#+1.*#"(3.:5+1.(8:0-,=(8"%. ¨ K EHa`
“”K•c•”RŸC— ˜ " ^ ES U
KZ K STI ZsŽ¤HNJPBYZ0¥‹¦ [email protected]`G5Q%¥S <S `S EI QS[JHU SVZ\¥ Z
G
K4 §
‘ EIBU SWZIBU G/IbBHaS `aPRZ S P JS H
§
G
‰ )J.%##p.%+.<,=)'.`p+"9%+g2#+NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4$K'+ +9 .%!)&9t2;J: 2 :5+g/ !9%4
& ')( *,+(
a b
2#+M7I,\e#(8-,="9(89(3!)2; K 1> !)'/h7f?[,=" 2 9%+ ab 2; K +1.9 .#ep2;(8AF(3.%41+h+)#)/%O'+:0(8)
4
4
7
2#+ 73!)#N'+#"H-,=(8"%+ 1! +1.H,=" 2 9%+1.*(8)'/(32#+)K9%+
a +9 b 2#!)#)'+)&9 > 2',=)'.*73+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+
G > 73+1.q2#+ 9"(I,=)#N73+1.q2C? #)0#"(3.:5+ > +9t73+g/<O'+:0(8)^2#+ a AB+"%. b 2',=)'.t7I,.#e2;(8AF(3.(3!)
2#+ K 2#!)#)'+ > 2',=)'.h73+X78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+ > #)/<O'+:0(8)a2#+X73!)#N'+#"G(8:0-,=(8"%+ `_ !:0:5+
4
G +1.92#+ +"NB+ > !).<,=(89H$K'+ F +1.9*#)d#"(3.:5+h(8:0-,=(8"
2
! +h73+:0:5+G.%#(8A!,=)K9)'!'.+":5+99"<,\-,="7I,\.#(89%+L2#+h:5!)&9"%+"$&'+M73+1..%#ep2;( 7
‰ )
AK(3.(3!)'.H2#+ K $K'+h)'!'. 2#49%+1/9%+"%!)'. .%!)K9He#(3+)R2#+1.H.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)'. QS JHU SWZa`p
4
U
a
H
S
.
W
S
J
?
K
Z
!
7
2;(89L$&Z? #)'+^.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!) R 2#+ K +1.9
.%( R = K
+578(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+b2#+
4
4
+1.9"%+#"%41.%+)K9%4MW'N#"%+ Ar -,=NB+ <(/
K4
¨ KEHa` EIDJnK%¦ G/I ZU
G/I Z `aG1Q¥ S .S `aSWEI  G1ZK8‘ EI  G1ZV¥ Z
“”K•c•”RŸC— ˜K ^ E S U
R
K4 §
K¦ GFI `&ZGFK?ZPRZI U¥ aZ `J‘ J`@`aG/S $JI UT`X©
Za`U U HS .S JKZa]‘ ¦ Za`U Ž!Žm¥STH[Z
R
R = K4 §
‘ EI U SVZI U GFI U H[EG STPH5JS H
L(R)
§
Za`U G/I Z `aG1Q¥ S .S `aSWEIDQS  JHU SWZX¥ Z
R
K4 §
r
& ')( *,+(
( R +1.9T9"(8AK(I,=73+ > ,=73!"%. R = K +9V(87G+1.%9/7I,=(8"$K'+ L(R) )'+
4
/1!)&9(3+)&9J-,!.G2#+\9"%!](8:0-,=(8"L+9G$K'+ R )[email protected]+1.%9G-,!.Me#(8-,="9( `‰ )+#9G2#!)'/0.# 7
p.%+" R 6= K Π7 +1.9 /7I,=(8"M4N&,=73+:5+)&9h$K'+G73+1.2#+ 2#+")#( : "%+1.M.##p.%(89(3!)'.H)'+
4
p+#AB+)K9 2 9"%+T.P,=9(3.mSU,=(89%+1.\.(8:J#789<,=)'4:5+)&9 > /Q,="\73+1.\78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.52#+VN"<,=#O'+1.\e#( 7
-,="9(3..%!)K92#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.g2#+ g+"NB+ FΠ7'"%+1.9%+ '.9%+
#"%!#AB+"[email protected]!)5)'+Hp+#9,1AB!(8"
.(8:L#789<,=)'4:5+)K9 L(R) .<,=)'.9"%!T(8:0-,=(8"H+9 R )'!)Te#(8-,="9( -r ##p.%!)'.H2#!)'/ > +)
AK'+h2C? #)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > $KZ? (87Z+)d.%!(89H,=(8)'.%( #+73!)'.
a > b > c +9 d 73+1.`$K-,=9"%+.<!:0:5+9%. 2; K4 > +9 p!#" i < j ∈ {a, b, c, d}
)'!9%!)'. C 7I,.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)L2#+7f?[,=" 2 9%+ ij <4 #(3.%$K'+ L(R) +1.9‹.<,=)'.‹9"%!L(8:0-,=(8"`+9 R
ij
)'!)^e#(8-,="9( > ,=73!"%. R /1!)&9(3+)K9#)b/ % /73+(8:0-,=(8" 8 )'!)^)'41/1+1.%.<,=(8"%+:5+)K9(8)'2;#(89 =#r (
/1+/ % /73+(8:0-,=(8"‹)[email protected]+1.9Z-,!.‹#)G9"(I,=)#N73+ > ,=73!"%.‹(87&2#!)#)'+2',=)'. L(R) #)G9"%!G(8:0-,=(8" Y
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) Cr (Z/[email protected]+1.9#)T9"(I,=)#N73+ > ,=73!"%. !)Tp+#9.##.%+".<,=)'.p+"9%+h2#+
NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4L$K'+h/1+M9"(I,=)#N73+L+1.9 {a, b, c} _ !:0:5+ R 6= K > !)d.<,=(89$KZ?[,=:5!(8)'.
4
.d
RTMˆH #F #)'+,=" 2 9%+2; K +1.9 .#e2;(8AK(3.%41+ > -,="t+ +:0#73+ ad .P,=)'.‹+"9%+2#+gNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 no,=(3.
4
,=73!"%.q7f? #)b2#+1.+)'.%+:Le#73+1. E(C ) ∪ {cd} ∪ E(C ) +9 E(C ) ∪ {bd} ∪ {bc} ∪ C
ad
cd
ad
cd
[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+M2#+1.,=" 2 9%+1.2C? #)/ % /73+H(8:0-,=(8"2#+ R 2#+H73!)#N'+#",=^:5!(8)'. j > $K#(
2#!)#)'+G2',=)'. L(R) #)9"%!(8:0-,=(8" > +)'/1!"%+G#)'+G/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) 2
i )d/1!:Le#(8)-,=)K9 73+1.2#+ 73+:0:5+1.H#"%41/1412#+)&9%. !)!e#9(3+)&9 Y
>
¨ KEH `pEG QSWZI]©
^ ESTU
[email protected]`G5Q%¥S <S `S EI  G1ZK8‘ E I  G5Z0¥FZ
R
K4 §
Za`U U HS .SWJK?Za]g‘-¦ Za`U Ž!Žm¥S H Z
R
R = K4 §
‘ EI U SWZI U G/IU HNEG S P JS H
L(R)
§
‘ EI U SWZI U G/b
I BHS `P Z STH
P 5JS H
“”K•a•a”ŸZ—˜#–
§
L(R)
4 !#"2#+1.g"<,=(3.%!)'.*$K#(,=#-,="<,39"%!)K9H2',=)'.7I,G#"%+#AB+h2;V#"%F/%O-,=(8)T73+:0:5+ !)
>
, ep+1.%!(8)2#+G#"%+)'2;"%+X+)/1!:0#9%+J73+1.H.%!:0:5+9%.M,=d:0(878(3+R2#+1. /<O'+:0(8)'.2#+1.H78(8)'+ 7
5
N"<,=#O'+1. -‰ "*/1+1.*/<O'+:0(8)'.*p+#AB+)K9 2 9"%+h2#+73!)#N'+#"*(8:0-,=(8"%+ > +9g)Z?[,QAB!(8"-,!.*2#+
/1+MSf,=(892#+h.%!:0:5+9H/1+)K9"<,=7 p‰ )d+1.%92#!)'/L,=:5+)'4
7I,\2#4sW')#(89(3!)R.#(8A!,=)K9%+ Y
r !(89
7
7
F 73+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+*2C? #)'+g.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)\2#+ K4 ,1AB+1/g73+1.‹)'!9<,=9(3!)'.q/( 2#+1.<.'.
r !(3+)K9
*
r
mab > mac > mad > mbc > mbd +9 mcd .( .<!:0:5+9%.T2#+ F ( !#"V9%!#9
3
7
i < j > +\.%!:0:5+9 mij +1.9M2',=)'. Pij +9AB4"(žW-+ dPij (vij , mij ) − dPij (vji , mij ) ∈
.d$7 ##73+9
{−1, 0, 1} > ,=73!"%.!)T2;(89$K'+ 73+
(vab , vac , . . . , vcd , mab , . . . , mcd ) ∈ V 18
U
N
H
J
R
P
Z
B
!
+1.9#)'+
2#+ F +1..%( .%!:0:5+9%. m > m > m > m > m +9 m .Q? (8) 7
ac
ab
ad
bc
bd
cd
9%+"#" : 9%+)K9M/1!:0:5+X2#+1..%!:0:5+9%.Hjk#"%K/<O'+1.2#+1.H:0(878(3+ 2#+1./%O'+:0(8)'.ml P > P >
ac
ab
!(3/(Z:^,=(8)K9%+)-,=)&973+M73+:0:5+h#"(8)'/(8-,=7 Y
P > P > P +9 P
ad
bc
bd
cd
“”K•a•a”ŸZ—˜;Ÿ ^ ESTU
G/IL¤H[JP YZ `JI1`CB\HNJP SU¥ Z ^ ES U
G/I`EGF`PŽ ¤H[JP YZ S I ¥GFS U
G
F
§
¥ Z
"I `GQ&E9`&Z
¥FZ UVJS KTK?Z
G /SZ`U FG I_Z `aG1Q¥S .S `aSWEI IBEI U HS .SWJK?Zo¥ Z
G
K4 §
F
PSTI1S P JK?ZRZ&U ¥ ZRU HNJP Z
^ ES U
GFIdBK G `^‘ EG/HU
(vab , vac , . . . , vcd , mab , . . . , mcd ) §
P
‘ Y5ZPS ID¥ Z
9ZHa`
¥qEI U;KZ``EPPRZUT`S IBUkŠHaSVZG/H ` P JI  G5ZI U;UVEG ` K?Za`
v
m
vij
JGU H Za`  G1Z ab ¨ K EH `J© ab
vab §
J¦ ZI1`&ZPRQK?Z
STI ¥ G/STUiG/IDK S I ZŽ¤ H[JP YZb¥‹¦ GFI_Z `aG1Q¥S .S `aSWEIIBEI
(F \vab Pab mab ) ∪ P
U HS <S JK?ZX¥ Z
¥ Z UVJS [email protected] P JK?Z
K
§
"I J G/I H
Š `aG/4 K UVJU0`S PSTK JS H ZG
 EG/H3K?Za`T‘ S I  JGU H[Za`T‘ EG’B
 K?Za`
Z&U;K?Za`3`aS#
(vij , mij )
‘ EGQB
 K?Za`
(vji , mij ) §
‰ )0p!#""<,M/1!)'.#789%+"q7I, W'N#"%+ *A6 -,=NB+ .r&‰ )0)'!9%+ 0
& ')(*,+(
F = F \Pab
r (
vab = mab > !\.( vab AB!(89 mab > ,=73!"%. 7I,H/1!)'/78'.(3!)02;J73+:0:5+g+1.9 9"(8AK(I,=73+:5+)K9
.<,=9(3.SU,=(89%+ '‰ )Vp+#9*2#!)'/M.##.%+"g$K'+ v +9 m .%!)K9*2#+1.g.<!:0:5+9%.g2;(3.%9(8)'/9%.
ab
ab
+9)'!)d,!2 ,!/1+)&9%. > /1+h$K#(C(8:0#78(3$&'+J+)!#9"%+ m 6= v ab
ba
8PR
« ^ S K?Za` `EP PRZUT` STI UkŠ HSVZGFHa`X¥ Z
P JI  G5ZIBU ZI U S $H[ZPRZIBU 0 ] K JT‘ EI ‘ K G `S EI
P
F
¥G KZPPRZZa`U `JU S ` M&JS U,Z
§
r !(89
%
u 73+J.%!:0:5+9 2#+ vab −P −mab 73+G#78'. #"%K/<O'+J2#+ vab +9M, ,=)&9M2#+1. AB!(3.(8)'.
&
r
2',=)'. m −P −v
!(89 u0 73+AB!(3.(8)^2#+ u 2',=)'. m −P −v 73+#78'.#"%K/<O'+2#+
ab
ab
ba
73!ab"%. ab ba
> vab−P −u−u0−Pab−vba +1.9#)V/%O'+:0(8).<,=)'./1!"%2#+$&'+*[email protected]!)b)'!9%+ P 0
vba
‰ )R/1!)'.9<,=9%+L$K'+
7
V (P 0 ) ∪ V (F 0 ) (8)'2;#(89H73+L78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+J2C? #)'+J.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)d)'!)
T
%
M
.r
)5t% vad
vac
vab
c2
Pad
c3
e1
Pac
e2
vda
vca
c1
Pab
P
vcd
d1
vdc
e3
vdb
vcb
e4
mab
Pcd
Pbd
d2
d3
Pab
vba
Pbc
vbd
vbc
eifTg"hq*A6;k
8
*.*q=q! 1+ ./<O'+:0(8)'.+)0N"<,!.+9q73+1.q9"(I,=)#N73+1.N"(3.%41.
F +9 P #"%+#AB+H2#+
7
/1!)'.9(89'+)&9 73+h.%!'. N"<,=#O'+h(8)'2;#(89
2#4sW')#(`,1A,=)&9 8V(=
E
.6
RTMˆH #F 9"(8AF(I,=73+2#+ K > !)'/ V (P 0 ) ∪ V (F 0 ) ,M#)'+9<,=(87873+.#4"(3+#"%+H!54N&,=73+
/1+7873+ 2#+
4
1
/
G
+
K
$
#(
Z
1
+
.
9
%
.
.
8
(
#
e
3
7
h
+
%
.
+
#7
3
+
5
:
+
K
)
9
.
(
Q
/
=
,
"
1
+
%
.
*
9
#)
T
#
8
7
'.
1
/
!
#"
H
9
%
/
O'+:0(8) F>
u = mab
P
7
no,=(3.J2',=)'.\/1+b/Q,!. > (V (F ) \ V (v − P − m ) ∪ V (P ) (8)'2;#(89J73+b78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+
ab
ab
ab
2C? #)'+J.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!))'!)9"(8AK(I,=73+L2#+ K 2#+h9<,=(87873+G:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > +97I,0/1!)'/78'.(3!)o2;
4
73+:0:5+G+1.%9e#(3+).<,=9(3.mSf,=(89%+ _ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
‰ o
) +#9h2#!)'/0.##p.<+" [email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+02C? #)].%!:0:5+9 c 2#+ P , % ,=)K9L2#+1.AB!( 7
1
.(8)'.H2',=)'. F 0 > +9/%O'!(3.(t,='.%.(#"%F/%O'+L$K'+M.%.(8e#73+h2#+ v ‰ )2#4sW')#(89 2#+h: 2 :5+
ab
%
7
d1 > .%!:0:5+9M2#+ P , ,=)K9G2#+1.HAB!(3.%(8)'.2',=)'. F 0 > +9/<O'!(3.(,='.%.(‹#"%F/%O'+\$K'+G.
.(8e#73+02#+ m - !'.J,=7873!)'.hAB!(8"L$K'+\[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+02#+0/1+1.L.%!:0:5+9%.L+)K9"<, 3)'+0#)'+
ab
/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) 81«
Za`U [email protected],ZLF¥ Z 0 ZU
Za`U [email protected],ZL¥FZ 0
N (c1 ) ∩ V (F 0 )
F
N (d1 ) ∩ V (F 0 )
F
‰ )T.%+
'‰ )T.##p.<+2C?[,=e!"%2T$K'+ 73+M.%!:0:5+9
H = Pac ∪ Pbc ∪ Pbd ∪ Pad
c1 ,
2#+1.*AB!(3.%(8)'.H2',=)'.*73+h9"%! H ‰ )62#4sW')#(89\2#+ /%O'+:0(8)'.02#+
Y
t‰ )
H Hac = H \ vad +9 Had = H \ vac
p
‰
2#4sW')#(89 c 73+L.%!:0:5+9H2#+ H 73+M#78'.#"%F/%O'+J2#+ v +9AB!(3.(8)2#+ c
)d2#4sW')#(89
2
ac
ac
*1r (
3
7
]
+
%
.
!
0
:
5
:
+
9
#
2
+
3
7
o
+
#
8
7
'.
T
#
%
"
F
%
/
'
O
+
#
2
+
+
T
9
B
A
!
3
(
.
8
(
)
#
2
+
c3
Had
vad
c1
c2 = c 3 >
,=73!"%.^[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ V (H) ∪ V (c − c − P − v ) (8)'2;#(89b#)'+T % "<,=:0(32#+2#+d/1!(8)
2
1
ab
Y
;> !)'/
Hr
c2 +92#+o9"(I,=)#N73+ {vab , vac , vad } #)'+]/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
c2 6= c3 ( c2
:^,=)'$K'+ c > ,=73!"%.G!).##.%+\.<,=)'.Mp+"9%+02#+\NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4^$&'+ v > c > c +9 v
3
ac
2
3
ad
,=#-,="<,=(3.%.<+)&92',=)'.t/1+9q!"%2;"%+g.%#" H i 9t!)\AB!(89 $K'+73+1.`9"%!(3.q/<O'+:0(8)'. c −P−v >
1
ab
%
c1 −c2 −Hac −vac +9 c1 −c3 −Had −vad (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9g#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+M2#+ /1!(8) c1 +92#+
9"(I,=)#N73+ {v , v , v } Y #)'+0/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/\73+0.%!:0:5+9 c ,b!#"G.%+#73.
1
ab ac ad
AB!(3.(8)'.J2',=)'. H 73+1.L2#+ .%!:0:5+9%. c +9 c $K#(.%!)&9J+)c!#9"%+^,!2 ,!/1+)&9%. t‰ )
2
3
.##.%+h.<,=)'.p+"9%+G2#+MNB4)'4"<,=78(89%4J$&'+ c c +1.9*#)'+L,=" 2 9%+L2#+ P ∪ P 2 3
ac
bc
r ( .%. : 2#+ +)]#78'.G2#+0.%+1.MAB!(3.(8)'.L.#"
c
H > 2#+1.MAB!(3.(8)'.L.#" Pcd > ,=73!"%.G!)
>
)'!9%+ c 73+ AB!(3.%(8)2#+ c .#" P 73+#78'.#"%K/<O'+h2#+ v ;‰ )AB!(89*$&'+73+1.*/<O'+:0(8)'.
4
1
cd
dc
%
c1 −P −vab > c1 −c4 −Pcd ∪ Pad +9 c1 −c2 −Hac −vac (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9G#)'+X "<,=:0(32#+
2#+G/1!(8) c +92#+G9"(I,=)#N73+ {v , v , v } Y #)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) B> !)'/ c :^,=)'$K'+
Pcd
1
ab
ac
1
ad
o (8)-,=73+:5+)K9 .(
>
c1 AB!(89\2#+1.X.%!:0:5+9%.\2#+ H ,=73!"%.J(87)'+^AB!(89X2#+ F 0 $KZ? #)'+
2
=, " %9 + > ,=(8)'.(*$K'+V73+b#"%4AB!(89 8W6q=‰ )6+#9\2#!)'/.##.%+"0$K'+ c :^,=)'$&'+ H 1
> ,=)'./1+G/Q,!. 2C?[,=#" : . 8N<= !)T+#9H.##.%+"$K'+
,\2#+1.HAB!(3.(8)'.2',=)'. ∗ c1
Pcd
>
>
r (
Z
)
[
?
]
,
K
$
Z?
#)
ˆ
%
.
+
#7
B
A
!
3
(
%
.
8
(
)
=
,
3
7
!
%
"
5
.
3
7
1
+
V
.
%
/
'
O
+
0
:
8
(
'
)
.
c1
c ∈ Pcd >
c − c1 − P − vab >
%
c−Pcd −vcd ∪ Pac +9 c−Pcd −vdc ∪ Pad (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9*#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+M2#+M/1!(8) c +9*2#+
9"(I,=)#N73+ {v , v , v } Y #)'+\/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/ c ,b#78'.(3+#"%.AB!(3.(8)'.h2',=)'.
1
ab ac ad
∗ B‰ )0)'!9%+ c 73+AB!(3.(8)52#+ c 2',=)'. P ∗ 73+#78'.t#"%F/%O'+2#+ v +9 c 73+AB!(3.(8)52#+
Pcd
2
1
3
cd
cd
∗ 73+M#78'.#"%F/%O'+L2#+ v -r ( c +9 c )'+h.%!)K9-,!.H,!2 ,!/1+)&9%. > ,=73!"%.*73+1.
c1 2',=)'. Pcd
2
3
dc
/<O'+:0(8)'. c −P−v > c −c −P −v ∪P +9 c −c −P −v ∪P (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9q#)'+
1
ac
1 3
ab 1 2
cd
cd
cd
dc
ad
% "<,=:0(32#+b2#+0/1!(8) c +9J2#+\9"(I,=)#N73+ {v , v , v } Y #)'+0/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/
1
ab ac ad
73+1..%!:0:5+9%. c +9 c .%+/1!:0!"9%+)&9+)'/1!"%+ ,=(8)'.(-$K'+7f?[,=)#)'!)'/1+ 8W6q= ! ,G#"%+#AB+
2
3
!#" d +1.9 .(8:0(87I,=(8"%+ _ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8W6q=
1
‰ )L)'!9%+2#!)'/
c , c 73+1.‹2#+ AB!(3.(8)'.`2#+ c 2',=)'. F 0 > +9 d , d 73+1.`2#+ AB!(3.(8)'.
2
3
1
2
3
T
%
M
.6
)5t% 2 + d 2',=)'. F 0 A!,=)K92#+Lp!#"%.#(8AF"%+ > (87‹Sf,=#9HAB4"(žW-+"h$K'+G73+1. 78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.h$&'+
#
1
)'!'.H,=7873!)'.9"%!#AB+")'+L2#4NB4) : "%+)&9H-,!.H+) L(K ) Y
4
8«^ ES U
G/I &` EGF`PŽ¤HNJPBYZ\¥ Z 0
GFS"Za`U K ZpK S I ZŽ¤H[JP Y Z\¥`¦ G/I Z a` G1Q¥S .S `aSWEI
J
F ∪P 
¥
Z
^
0
S
%
K
¦
/
G
ˆ
I
¥
a
Z
n
`
U
a
H
W
S
J
K
I
¤
K
Za`¥ Z
‘ EIBU SWZIBU
] JKEHa`
Za`U IBEI
$&'+73/1!)'$K'+
K4 §
J
c1
J
U HaS .SWJK
§
i 6
) NB4)'4"<,=7 > !#"XAB4"(žW-+"5$&Z? #) 78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+ J 2C? #)'+.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!) 2#+ K +1.9
4
)'!)R9"(8AF(I,=7 > (87q.59h2#+JAB4"(žW-+"G$K'+ J .%. : 2#+X#)]/1!(8)o$K#(t)Z?[,=#-,="9(3+)&9L$KZ?
#)a.%+#79"(I,=)#N73+V2#+5e-,!.<+52#+ J _ [email protected]+1.9Je#(3+)a73+b/Q,!.G(3/( Y J )'+5+#9L-,!. 2 9"%+573+
78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+ 2#+ K /Q,=" c )'++#9g,=#-,="9%+)#(8"$&Z? #)b.%+#7-9"(I,=)#N73+ 2#+ J 5_ +1/(
4
1
#"%!#AB+ 8Wq=
8!« i
Ic5ZG/U `aG’BE`&ZH  G5Z
Z`U GFI Z JHU,Zo¥FZ
ZU
G/I Z JHU,Zo¥ Z
c2 c3
Pac
d2 d3
Pcb ∪ Pbd §
2
r (
c2 c3 +1.9`#)'+g,=" 9%+g2#+ Pcd > ,=73!"%. [email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ V (c1−P−vab )∪V (Pac )∪V (Pad )∪
7
7
V (Pcd ) (8)'2;#(89*73+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+G2C? #)'+M.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)e#(8-,="9(3+h2#+ K4 2#+9<,=(87873+h.9"(3/
7
:
W
8
q
h
=
Y
7
9%+:5+)&9(8);S 4"(3+#"%+
/1+7873+X2#+ F > $&#( +1.9)'!) 9"(8AF(I,=73+X2C?[,=#" .
#)'+J/1!)K9"<,
2;(3/9(3!) -r ( c c +1.9#)'+M,=" 2 9%+h2#+ P > ,=73!"%.*[email protected]+)'.%+:Le#73+ V (c −P −v ) ∪ V (F 0 )
2 3
1
bc
ab
(8)'2;#(89h73+\78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+^2C? #)'+5.#e2;(8AF(3.(3!)oe#(8-,="9(3+52#+ K 2#+\9<,=(87873+0.9"(3/9%+:5+)K9
4
(8);S 4"(3+#"%+
/1+7873+L2#+ F > $&#(Z+1.%9*)'!) 7 9"(8AK(I,=73+J2C?[,=#" : . 8Wq=MY #)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/
2
‰
2
c2 c3 +1.9#)'+\,=" 9%+L2#+ Pac ∪ Pad )d:5!)K9"%+J2#+L: :5+J$K'+ d2 d3 +1.9
2
4
%
#)'+,=" 9%+2#+ P ∪ P
,="b. :549"(3+T+95.<,=)'.0+"9%+2#+NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > !) p+#9
bc
bd
.##p.<+"$&'+ c c +1.9*#)'+L,=" 2 9%+G2#+ P d_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8TF=
2 3
ac
‰ )a.##.%+0.<,=)'.h+"9%+52#+0NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4b$&'+
vac > c2 > c3 +9 vad =, #-,="<,=(3.%.<+)&9
‰
2',=)'.H/1+9 !"%2;"%+J.#" H ).%##p.%+L4N&,=73+:5+)&9h$&'+ d > d + 9 v =, #-,="<,=(3.%.<+)&9
2
3
ad
2',=)'./1+9H!"%2;"%+G.#" H 8s«
`&EI Ug¥ Za`@`EP PRZUT`L¥S `U STI ‘&UT`pZU IBEIJB¥&JB‘ ZIBUT`
d1
§
`
r
4 ,=" 8W6q= +9 8TF= !) .<,=(89G$&'+
( c AB!(89 d > ,=73!"%[email protected]+) 7
>
c1 +9 d1 .%!)K9J2;(3.9(8)'/9%.
1
1
.%+:Le#73+ {c , d } ∪ V (H 0 ) (8)'2;#(89 #)d78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+L2C? #)'+J.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)de#(8-,="9(3+L2#+
1 1
7
: 8Wq=Y #)'+
K4 2#+M9<,=(87873+h.9"(3/9%+:5+)&9(8);SU4"(3+#"%+
F > $&#(C+1.9)'!) 9"(8AF(I,=73+G2C?[,=#" .
C
‰
_
W
8
q
j
=
/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
).<,=(89H2#!)'/G$K'+ c :^,=)'$&'+ d
+1/(Z#"%!#AB+
c1
ZU
1
1
‰ )T)'!9%+G,=73!"%.
%
e1 73+h.<!:0:5+92#+ c1 −P −vab , ,=)&9H2#+1.*AB!(3.%(8)'.2',=)'. (mab −
‰
Pab −vab )∗ > +9M/%O'!(3.(,='.%.(`#"%K/<O'+\$&'+Jp.<.(8e#73+L2#+ c1 )R)'!9%+ e4 73+X.%!:0:5+9
%
2#+ d −P −m , ,=)K9g2#+1.AB!(3.(8)'.2',=)'. (m −P −v )∗ > +9/<O'!(3.(p,='.<.('#"%F/%O'+
1
ab
ab
ab
ab
$&'+Lp.%.%(8e#73+J2#+ d C‰ )R/<O'!(3.(89M,=73!"%. e 2',=)'. (m −P −v )∗ > AB!(3.(8)R2#+ e >
1
2
1
ab
ab
ab
+9 e 2',=)'. (m −P −v )∗ > AB!(3.(8)2#+ d 5! +1.H.%!:0:5+9%. e +9 e .%!)&9H/<O'!(3.(3.
3
1
2
3
ab
ab
ab
,='.%.(C#"%F/%O'+1.H$K'+M.%.(8e#73+M7f? #)d2#+M7f?[,=#9"%+ 8P«
e1 =
6 vab §
r (8)'!) 37 +1.M/<O'+:0(8)'.
vab −P −c1 > vab −vac −Pac −c2 +9 vab −Pab −e3 −e4 −P −
>
S
!
"
:5+)K9*#)'+ % "<,=0
: (32#+h2#+/1!(8) v +92#+9"(I,=)#N73+ {c , c , c } d1 −d2 −Hac −c3
1 2 3
ab
_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8W*q=
.66
RTMˆH #F ! +1. / "(89 : "%+1. p!#"H73+G/%O'!( 2#+1. .%!:0:5+9%. /( 7 =, #" : . (8:0#78(3$K'41. 37 +1.H#"%!#"(349%41.
>
8Wjq= +9 8W*q= +973+*Sf,=(89 .(8N)-,=734+)^2#4e##9g2#+#"%+#AB+ K$ '+
+
9
>
>
m
v .<! )&92;(3.%9(8)'/9%. >
ab
ba
:5!)K9"%+)&9M$&'+ c −P −e −e −P −e −e −P −d +1.%9#)d/%O'+:0(8)R2#+ G 2#!)K9
1
1
2
3
4
1
ab
73+1..%!:0:5+9%.(8)K9%4"(3+#"%.:^,=)'$K'+)&9 F 0 K‰ )^)'!9%+/1+H/%O'+:0(8) P 0 F‰ )^/1!)'.9<,=9%+H$K'+
[email protected]+)'.%+:Je#73+ E = V (P 0 ) ∪ V (F 0 ) (8)'2;#(89G73+078(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+b2C? #)'+5.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)])'!)
9"(8AF(I,=73+G2#+ K 8 )'!)d9"(8AK(I,=73+h-,=" 8Wq=[=
4
8m« JRUVJS KTKZJ¥ Z
Za`U `U HS .‘ U,ZPRZI U S I.MQŠ HSWZGFH Z RKJ3UVJS KTK?ZL¥ Z
E
F§
Œ 7‹.592#+G:5!)&9"%+"M$K'+G73+1.H.%( /<O'+:0(8)'.M2#+he-,!.%+L2#+
!
K
)
9
.
9"(3/9%+:5+)K9 :5!(8)'.
E
2
‰
2C?[,=" 9%+1. $&'+h73+1.H.( /<O'+:0(8)'. 2#+Ge-,!.%+h2#+ F
)T)'!9%+ α 73+h)'!:Je#"%+L2C?[,=" 2 9%+1.2;
‰
/<O'+:0(8) v −P −m
)d)'!9%+ β 73+G)'!:Je#"%+J2C?[,=" 2 9%+1.2#+ v −P −m ‰ )
ab
ab
ab
ba
ab
ab
)'!9%+ δ 73+M)'!:Le#"%+J2#+1. ,=" 2 9%+1. e 2#+ F 0 ,=#-,="9%+)-,=)K9
2#+1./<O'+:0(8)'. 2#+Me-,!.<+ F ! +G)'!:Le#"%+J2C?[,=" 2 9%+1. 2#+1. /%O'+:0(8)'.2#+
E +1.%9(8);S 4"(3+#" !d4N&,=7 δ + 2α − 3
_ +99%+Xe!")'+X/1!""%+1.%p!)'2],=o#(8"%+\2#+1./Q,!. /1+78#(q
>
e4 +9 mab .%!)&9h/1!);SU!)'2;'. >
5(87p+ (3.%9%+*#)5#)#(3$K'+.%!:0:5+92#+ P +)&9"%+ c +9 d > e AB!(89 v > e AB!(89
1
1
ab
2
> ,=1)'./1+/Q,!ab. 73+)'!2:Je#"%+
vab +9g P +9 vab −Pab −mab .%!)&92#+ : :5+H73!)#N'+#"
>
2C?[,=" 2 9%+1. 2;d/%O'+:0(8)R2#+ E ,=787I,=)&9 2#+ c
1
+
.
*
9
#
e
3
(
+
)
4
&
N
=
,
7
d1
2α − 3
! +)'!:Le#"%+*2C?[,=" 2 9%+1.q2#+1.q/%O'+:0(8)'.2#1+
F +1.9t4N&,=7 α+β +δ = 2α−ε+δ ,1AB+1/
'i
:
ε ∈ {0, 1} /Q,=" > 2C?[,=#" .H7I,^2#4sW')#(89(3!)2#+ mab > (87`+ (3.9%+ ε 9%+7 $&'+ α = β + ε 9
2
2#!)'/H73+)'!:Le#"%+2C?[,=" 9%+1.g2#+1./<O'+:0(8)'.2#+He-,!.%+2#+ E +1.9.%9"(3/9%+:5+)&9g(8);S 4"(3+#"
/1+78#(p2#+1./%O'+:0(8)'.g2#+*e-,!.%+H2#+ F q> !)'/*7I,M9<,=(87873+ 2#+ E +1.%9.9"(3/9%+:5+)&9g(8);SU4"(3+#"%+
/1+7873+G2#+ F d_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8V(=
- !'.H,=""(8AB!)'. 2#!)'/
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) 2
‰ )+#9:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)&92#!)#)'+"*#),=78NB!"(89O#:5+h2#+2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+1.78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.
2#+.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!) )'!) 9"(8AF(I,=73+2#+ K 2',=)'.\73+1.\N"<,=#O'+1.0.<,=)'.\ % "<,=:0(32#+ qΠ7Sf,=#9
4
)'!9%+"h$K'+X/1+99%+X"%+1.9"(3/9(3!)a,= .#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)'. IBEI U HaS .SWJKZ` )[email protected]+1.9h,='/#)'+:5+)&9
(8)'2;(3.+)'.<,=e#73+o!#"T$&'+R7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+oSU!)'/9(3!)#)'+]/1!""%+1/9%+:5+)&9 ;- !'.,QAB!)'.
/<O'!(3.(g/1+b!(8)&9\2#+5AF'+5"%+1.9"(3/9(žSH!#"L!#AB!(8"JSU,!/(873+:5+)K9X9"<,=(89%+"\+)'.#(89%+b73+1.
 JHU SVZ 2#+
8
78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.2#+h.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!) QS[
K4 "<,=#p+73!)'.H$&'+ K4 +1.9*#)TN"<,=#O'+
$K'+73$&'+Gp+T-,=9O'!73!N(3$K'+ > +)/1+h$&Z? (87‹+1.%9*7I,0.%+#73+G.'2;(8AF(3.(3!))'!)de#(8-,="9(3+L2#+
7
Ar -,=NB+ <(=
K 2#!)&973+h78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+J+1.92#+ +"NB+ > AB!(8"W'N#"%+
4
•a”dŸC— ˜
l )TN"<,=#O'+
%
G .<,=)'.* "<,=:0(32#+
r ( 73+ N"<,=#O'+M+1.9.P,=)'.78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+M2#+.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)V)'!)V9"(8AK(I,=73+M2#+
Y 4
! r/- l Zr (8)'!) 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L"%+9%!#")'+X#)78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+
K4 j ,!.M2#+ >
2#+h.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!))'!)T9"(8AF(I,=73+G2#+ K ' (
' f (
!#"%$
*
"
4
k_ !)'.(32#4"%+"*.'/1/1+1.%.(8AB+:5+)K9*9%!'.g73+1. .d$7 ##73+9%.
(vab > vac > . . . > vcd > mab >
18 . . . > mcd ) ∈ V
_ ,=73/#73+"p!#"9%!#9
i ∈ {a, b, c, d} +9g9%!#9 j ∈ {a, b, c, d} 9%+7p$K'+ i < j
#)^#78'./1!#"9g/<O'+:0(8) P 2#+ v AB+"%. m 2#!)&9g73+1..%!:0:5+9%.(8)&9%4"(3+#"%.
ij
ij
ij
:^,=)'$&'+)K9L73+0"%+1.%9%+52; .d$7 ##73+9 > +9L#)#78'.L/1!#"9L/<O'+:0(8) Q 2#+ v
ij
ji
T
%
M
AB+"%. m 2#!)&9*73+1.*.%!:0:5+9%.(8)K9%4"(3+#"%.:^,=)'$K'+)&9*73+M"%+1.9%+M2; .d$7 ##73+9 ij
r (
7
∪i,j (V (Pij ) ∪ V (Qij )) (8)'2;#(89*73+ 78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+L2C? #)'+h.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!))'!)
7
9"(8AF(I,=73+2#+ K > ,=73!"%..%9%K/ B+"/1+*.%!'. N"<,=#O'++)0:54:5!(8"%+ +9/1!)'.(32#4"%+"
4
73+1. .d$7 ##73+9%. .#(8A!,=)K9%. uH+9%!#")'+"7f? #)^2#+1..<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1..9%F/ B41.2#+*9<,=(87873+:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ ;r ( ,='/#)
.d$7 ##73+9)Z?[,G2#!)#)'42#+H78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+M2#+ .#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)V)'!)^9"(8AF(I,=73+ 2#+
K4 >
r - l "%+9%!#")'+"*j 4 ,!.H2#+ ! /
k
.6
)5t% f
"
&
(
O(n20 )
r (
7
G +1.%9V.<,=)'.b78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+o2#+.%#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!) )'!) 9"(8AF(I,=73+2#+ K4 >
,=73!"%.G(87+1.%9L/7I,=(8"J$K'+57f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+b)[email protected]+)a9"%!#AB+^-,!.J+9L$KZ? (87"%+9%!#")'+5j 4 ,!.J2#+
! r/- l r (
7
7
G /1!)&9(3+)&9M#)78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+\2C? #)'+J.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!))'!) 9"(8AK(I,=73+X2#+ K4 > ,=73!"%.
G +)d/1!)&9(3+)K9H#)d2#+M9<,=(87873+L:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > $&'[email protected]!)T)'!9%+ F
#)'+b/1+"9<,=(8)'+V49<,=p+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+/1!)'.(32 : "%+b#) .d$7 ##73+9
(v > vac > . . . >
>
L- !9%!)'.\$K'+ab^73+1.X
&
$
#(
1
+
.
X
9
#)
'
^
+
9
<
"
=
,
5
:
+
#
2
+
2#! Q+
18
vcd > mab > . . . > mcd ) ∈ V >
F
/
4
#78'.*/1!#"9%.*/%O'+:0(8)'.*"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'41.-,="7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+G+ (3.9%+)K9
,="2#! Q+G,=##78(3/Q, 7
9(3!)'. /1!)'.%41/#9(8AB+1.h2;73+:0:5+ *.* > !)RAB!(89$K'+ ∪ (V (P ) ∪ V (Q )) +1.%9H#)
i,j
ij
ij
78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+T2C? #)'+V.%#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)6)'!)69"(8AK(I,=73+2#+ K 2#+^9<,=(87873+:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > !)'/
4
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+\"%+9%!#")'+0/1+X.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+ > !op+#9 7,2 9"%+\#),=#9"%+\.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+02#+
: 2 :5+h9<,=(87873+G+9H, % ,=)K9H73+1.*: 2 :5+1. /1!(8)'. &
')(
*,+(
-
> ,=)'.\73+^#(8"%+T2#+1.\/Q,!. 9%+1.9%+"\9%!'.\73+1. .d$7 ##73+9%.0)'41/1+1.%.%(89%+
>
O(n18 ) 49<,=+1.
_ =, 73/#73+" 73+1. #78'.M/1!#"9%./<O'+:0(8)'.M+9 AB4"(žW-+"M$&'+L73+J.<!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+J!e#9%+)K]+1.9H73+
78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+2#+*.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)\e#(8-,="9(3+2#+ K #"%+)'2 O(n2 ) 49<,=+1. > !)'/ > ,=0#(8"%+ >
4
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+L.%+M9%+":0(8)'+G+) O(n20 ) 49<,=p+1. 2
- !'.Dp!#AB!)'. :^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)&9 #
2 !)#)'+" #) ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+€2#49%+1/9<,=)&9ˆ73+1.D78(8)'+ 7
N"<,=#O'+1.H2#+h.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!) Q[S 5JHU SVZ 2#+ K 2',=)'.H73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.H.<,=)'.9"%!'.*(8:0-,=(8"%. 4
•”dŸZ— ˜
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G .P,=)'.*9"%!(8:0-,=(8"
r M
7
( 73+RN"<,=#O'+]+1.9T.<,=)'.V78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+2#+o.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!) e#(8-,="9(3+]2#+
Y j 4 ,!.2#+ ! r
l Fr (8)'!) 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+"%+9%!#")'+H#)b78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+ 2#+
K4
>
.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)de#(8-,="9(3+G2#+ K 2#+h9<,=(87873+G:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ 4
#" $ * " L
i 41/#9%+"7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *<(/
' ( ' f (
"
&
(
f
O(n20 )
> ?[,=#" : .M73+X73+:0:5+ * !)].<,=(89h$&'+ 2',=)'.
7
G > 73+1.M78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+1.G2#+
>
B
I
E
'
I
Ž
U
H
S
<
S
J
?
K
a
Z
`
7
.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)
2#+ K .%!)K9L+ ,!/9%+:5+)K9J73+1.G78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+1.J2#+5.%#ep2;( 7
4
AK(3.(3!) QS[JHU SVZ 2#+ K ‹_ +1.J2#+")#( : "%+1.J/1!);W'N#"<,=9(3!)'.\.%!)K9L2#!)'/^/1!""%+1/9%+:5+)K9
4
2#49%+1/9%41+1.-,="7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *<(/
&
')(
*,+(
-
2
.69
"-
"
#
" RTMˆH #F - !'.`p!#AB!)'.t2#41.%!":^,=(3.‹S !#")#(8" #)0,=78NB!"(89O#:5+g+)J9%+:0'. p!7 % )'!:0(I,=7K!#"
2#49%+1/9%+"X73+1.G#"(3.:5+1.L(8:0-,=(8"%. ‹Œ 7qSf,=#9L.%+0:5!)K9"%+"J#"'2#+)K9X/Q,="X2',=)'.L/1+b/Q,!.G7I,
9%+1/<O#)#(3$&'+J2#+1.*#78'.H/1!#"9%./<O'+:0(8)'.SU!)'/9(3!)#)'+h:^,=7 Y
P1
m1
P
a1
P1
P2
a2
a3
b1
b2
b3
P3
e"fTg"h *A k
"<,=#O'+G/1!)&9%+)-,=)K9.( #"(3.:5+1.*(8:0-,=(8"%.
*A /1!:0p!"9%+ j /78(3$&'+1.:^, (8:^,=73+1.2#+H9<,=(87873+
! +HN"<,=#O'+
G "%+#"%41.<+)&9%4 W'N#"%+
‰
,=6:5!(8)'.09"%!(3.
)6AB4"(žW-+T$K'+b73+1.0$K-,=9"%+/78(3$&'+1.\N"(3.<41+1.0.%!)&952#+ 2#+ +)#)'+:0(3+1. 8 AB!(8"L.%!'. 7 .%+1/9(3!) AA6 -,=NB+ j* p!#"G2#+\#78'.J,=:0#73+1.L+ #78(3/Q,=9(3!)'.
.#"\73+1.0/78(3$K'+1.0+)#)'+:0(3+1. = !'.\73+1.0/%O'+:0(8)'.^.<!"9<,=)&9%.\73+1.\"%+78(I,=)&9
7I,R/78(3$K'+
‰ ) +)D2#412;#(89^$K'+
)'!)DN"(3.<41+T.%!)&9^2#+73!)#N'+#"b-,=(8"%+ 1
+
.
0
9
3
7
+
8
7
8
(
'
)
+ 7 N"<,=#O'+
G
8
2C? #) N"<,=#O'+de#(8-,="9( > +9b$KZ? (87 +1.%9^2#+ +"NB+ p!#"[email protected]+)ˆ/1!)KA!,=(8)'/"%+ > !) +#9
6 $&#(;,=#"<,*W')-,=73+:5+)K9.%+"AF( $K'+73$K'+/<O'.%+ =$4 !#"t9%!#9%+
#9(878(3.%+" 73+73+:0:5+ A
>
-,=(8"%+52#+^/78(3$&'+1.hN"(3.<41+1. > (87+ (3.9%+0#)]#)#(3$K'+0#"(3.:5+0(8:0-,=(8"X2#+ G $&#(,=(89J/1+1.
‰ )5/1!)'.9<,=9%+H$&'+73+1./<O'+:0(8)'.
/78(3$K'+1.q!#"9"(I,=)#N73+1. K
P1 > P2 +9 P3 (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9#)
#"(3.:5+g(8:0-,=(8"q2#+ G 2#+g9<,=(87873+g:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ 4 !#"9<,=)&9 > .(;!)\"%+:0#7I,!/1+ P > !\: 2 :5+
1
.(8:0#73+:5+)K9 73+L.%!'. 7 /%O'+:0(8) a −P −m -,="H#)#78'. /1!#"9 /<O'+:0(8) P > !)d)Z?[,
1
1
1
-,!. 7I,HN&,="<,=)&9(3+*[email protected]!e#9%+)#(8" )'!#AB+Q,=\#)\#"(3.:5+(8:0-,=(8" l )0,=78NB!"(89O#:5+g)-, S--,="
#78'.t/1!#"9%.t/%O'+:0(8)'.t"(3.%$K'+g2#!)'/[email protected]/<O'!'+" i )LSf,=(89 #)J9%+7#,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ 8 /Q,=73/#73+"
73+1.^#78'.b/1!#"9%.V/%O'+:0(8)'.V!#"^/%O-,!$K'+.<+ 9##73+9 (a , a , a , b , b , b ) ∈ V 6 =
1 2 3 1 2 3
+ +1/#9%40.#" G W')#(8"<,=(89he#(3+)]-,="G2#49%+1/9%+"G#)]#"(3.:5+\(8:0-,=(8" Y /1+78#(/1!)K9%+)-,=)&9
73+1.*2#+ 9"(I,=)#N73+1.73+1.#78'.g+)O-,=#9.#"g73+M2#+1.%.(8) no,=(3.(87)'+9"%!#AB+"<,=(89*-,!.#)
!
#"(3.:5+\2#+X9<,=(87873+\:0(8)#(8:^,=73+02#+ G > /1+X$K#(`SU,=([email protected]!)R)'+XAB!(89h/1!:0:5+)&9L#"%!#AB+"
$KZ? (87CSU!)'/9(3!)#)'+ 8 .Q? (87SU!)'/9(3!)#)'+ =
‰ )^p+#9/1++)'2',=)&9"%+:^,="%$&'+"g$&'+
7
7
G /1!)&9(3+)&9g73+*78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+ 2C? #)'+H.#e2;(
Y
7
AF(3.(3!)\e#(8-,="9(3+*2#+ K 73+*.%!'. N"<,=#O'+(8)'2;#(89+)0!#e#78(I,=)&973+1.q.<!:0:5+9%.`jk#73+(8)'.ml r (C/1+9 % p+M2#+M/1!);W'N#"4 <,=9(3!)d+1.9g(8)&9%+"%2;(89%+ (87 % ,J2#!)'/M+)'/1!"%+M#)T+1.!(8"g$K'+73+1.
>
9%+1/<O#)#(3$&'+1.02#+b#78'.\/1!#"9%.X/<O'+:0(8)'.XS !)'/9(3!)#)'+)K9 ! +b73+:0:5+V.%#(8A!,=)K9J:5!)K9"%+
$K'+h/1+9*+1.p!(8"+1.%9SU!)'2#4 -‰ )T"%+:^,="%$K'+"<,\$&Z? (87C)[email protected]+1.9*: 2 :5+M#78'.)'41/1+1.%.<,=(8"%+h2#+
-,="9(8"‹2C? #)L#"(3.:5+2#+q9<,=(87873+q:0(8)#(8:^,=73+ > )#(B2#+q#78'.Z/1!#"9%.`/%O'+:0(8)'. > /1+$&#(:5!)K9"%+
T
%
M
.6j
)5t% $ '+07f? (8)K9%+"%2;(3/9(3!) 2#+1.L78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.\2#+5.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)c2#+ K +1.9L#)'+^/1!)&9"<,=(8)K9%+
&
4
9" : .SU!"9%+M2#!)&9*!),L2#4 +#)'+H(87878'.9"<,=9(3!)2',=)'.7I,L#"%+#AB+h2;V9O'41!" : :5+S !"9
2#+1.*N"<,=#O'+1.-,="mSf,=(89%. 8 AB!(8"73+1.*9O'41!" : :5+1. 6A6q(6A<=
“”K•c•”RŸC— ˜ ^ ES U
G/I¤HNJs YZD`JI5`U HNEGcS P JSTH ZU `JI5`K S I_ZsŽ¤H[JP Y5Z6¥ Z
G
`aG1Q¥ S .S `S EI Q S JHU SVZc¥FZ
^ ES U
GFI BHS `P Zc¥ Z U HS JIF¤KZ`
ZU
K4 §
F
{a
,
a
,
a
}
1
2
3
ª
ZULMEHaP^ŠL
 JH U H[ES `‘YZP STI5`
«DJ\qJIBU5EGFH Z qU HŠPSŽ
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
P i = 1, 2, 3
UkaŠ `
ZU
^ ESTU
GFI‘YZP STI¥ Z
9ZiHa`
¥qEI [email protected]?Za`n`EP PRZUT` STI UkŠHSWZGFHa`
a
b §
P
a1
b1
¨ KEH `J©
PJI  iG1ZI U i ] ]
ZU
a2 a3 b2
b3 §
]
]
P P 2 P3
M&EHaPRZIBU G/I5BHS `aPRZL¥FZ
G
¥ ZpP PRZ*JHSTUkŠ  G1Z
F§
‰ )dp.%+
-r
: 7
H = P2 ∪ P3 (Z73+1..%!:0:5+9%. 2#+ P ∗ :^,=)'$K'+)&9+)&9( "%+
8
:5+)&973+M9"%! H > ,=73!"%. P > P > P S !":5+)K9H#)T#"(3.:5+h(8:0-,=(8" 2#+ G (8:0-,=(8"H/Q,="
=‹‰ 2)Rp+3#9h2#!)'/\.##.%+"$KZ? (87q+ (3.%9%+L#)].%!:0:5+9h2#+
G +1.9h.<,=)'.9"%!o(8:0-,=(8"
P ∗ $&#(‹,02#+1.AB!(3.(8)'.2',=)'. H
‰ ) )'!9%+
%
c1 73+.%!:0:5+952#+ P ∗ , ,=)&9^2#+1.\AB!(3.%(8)'.52',=)'. H +90/%O'!(3.%( ,='.%.(
`
‰
)a2#4sW')#(89L73+1.L/%O'+:0(8)'. H = H \ {b } +9 H =
#"%K/<O'+^$K'+\p.%.%(8e#73+52#+ a
1
2
3
3
F4 !#"
!
b
)
'
)
!
%
9
+ c 73+.%!:0:5+9g2#+ H > AB!(3.(8)V2#+ c > /%O'!(3.(Z,='.%.(
H \ {b2 }
i = 2, 3 >
i
i
1
#"%K/<O'+G$&'+M.%.(8e#73+h2#+ b i
8P
« iI^5
 ZGU `aG’B
 E9`.ZH  G1Z
Za`U G/I Z JH&U,Z\¥ Z ∗
c2 c3
P2 §
r (
c2 = c3 > ,=73!"%.J73+1.L9"%!(3.\/%O'+:0(8)'. c2 − c1 − P − a1 > c2 − P2 − a2 +9 c2 − P2 −
%
Y
b2 −b3 −P3 −a3 S !":5+)K9H#)'+h "<,=:0(32#+J2#+G/1!(8) c2 +92#+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {a1 , a2 , a3 }
q
‰
‹
r
#)'+5/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
)+#9G2#!)'/5.##.%+" c 6= c
( c +9 c )'+0.%!)K9G-,!.
2
3
2
3
,!2 ,!/1+)K9%. > ,=73!"%.73+1.9"%!(3./%O'+:0(8)'. c −P −a > c −c −P −a +9 c −c −P −
1
1 1
2
2
2
1
3
2
%
Y
b2 −b3 −P3 −a3 S !":5+)K9H#)'+h "<,=:0(32#+J2#+G/1!(8) c1 +92#+h9"(I,=)#N73+ {a1 , a2 , a3 }
_
N
8
<
=
#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
+1/(Z#"%!#AB+
&
')(
*,+(
-
81«
P JI  G1Z
c1
b1 §
r (8)'!) 73+1.J9"%!(3.L/%O'+:0(8)'.
c1 −b1 > c1 −c3 −P2 −b2 +9 c1 −P −a1 −a3 −P3 −b3
>
%
S !":5+)K9g#)'+ "<,=:0(32#+h2#+M/1!(8) c +9*2#+9"(I,=)#N73+ {b , b , b } V_ +1/(#"%!#AB+ 8W6q=
1
1 2 3
‰ )6)'!9%+ 0 73+AB!(3.(8) 2#+
‰ )D2#4sW')#(89^,=73!"%.
'
2
=
,
'
)
.
a1
a1
P1
d1 73+.%!:0:5+952#+
t‰ )
%
a01 − P − c1 73+b#78'.\#"%F/%O'+Vp.<.(8e#73+b2#+ c1 +9\, ,=)&952#+1.\AB!(3.(8)'.\2',=)'. P1
2#4sW')#(89 d ∈ P > AB!(3.(8)D2#+ d ,='.%.(#"%K/<O'+$K'+p.%.%(8e#73+V2#+ a +9 d ∈ P >
2
1
1
1
3
1
AB!(3.(8)2#+ d ,='.<.(C#"%K/<O'+G$K'+Mp.%.%(8e#73+h2#+ b 1
1
8«
Za`U GFI_Z JHU,Z\F¥ Z
d2 d3
P1 §
r (
d2 = d3 > ,=73!"%.M73+1.9"%!(3.h/<O'+:0(8)'. d2 −d1 −P −c1 > d2 −P1 −a1 −a2 −P2 −c2
+9 d −P −b −b −P −c S !":5+)K9h#)'+\ % "<,=:0(32#+52#+0/1!(8) d +9h2#+\9"(I,=)#N73+
2
1
2
3
2
Y 1 2
F‰ )\p+#9t2#!)'/*.##.%+"
Br
{c1 , c2 , c3 } #)'+/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
d2 6= d3 ( d2 +9 d3 )'+
.%!)&9Z-,!.`,!2 ,!/1+)K9%. > ,=73!"%.Z73+1.Z9"%!(3.Z/%O'+:0(8)'. d −d −P −a > d −d −P −b −b −P −a
1 2
1 1 1 3
1 1 3
3 3
+9 d −P −c −c −P −a S !":5+)K9L#)'+0 % "<,=:0(32#+b2#+5/1!(8) d +9L2#+09"(I,=)#N73+
1
2
2
1
Y1 2
o_ +1/(‹#"%!#AB+ 8Wq=
{a , a , a } #)'+G/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)
1
2
3
.6*
RTMˆH #F ‰ )0"%+:^,="%$K'+g:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K9$K'+73+1.q$K-,=9"%+g9"(I,=)#N73+1.
{a1 , a2 , a3 } > {b1 , b2 , b3 } >
/<O'+:0(8)'.
+
t
9
3
7
1
+
q
.
.
(
{c1 , c2 , c3 } > {d1 , d2 , d3 }
P > a −P −c > a −P −d > b −P −c >
7 3 2 2 2 1 1 2 G12ZK8‘ E2I  G13Z
b1 −P1 −d3 > c1 −P −d1 (8)'2;#(3.%+)K9H73+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+L2C? #)'+L.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)
2#+ K $&#( )[email protected]+1.9V-,!.b73+78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+]2#+ K > /Q,=" a 6= b i> !)'/ > 2C?[,=#" : .73+
4
4
3
3
 JHU SVZ 2#+
73+:0:5+ * > G /1!)&9(3+)&9X73+\78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+^2C? #)'+^.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!) QS K4 > /1+
$K#(Z+1.9/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9%!(8"%+
2
!(3/(g:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K90#)6,=78NB!"(89O#:5+2#+b2#49%+1/9(3!)62#+1.J#"(3.:5+1.X(8:0-,=(8"%.\2',=)'.
73+1.*N"<,=#O'+1. .<,=)'.*9"%!(8:0-,=(8" •a”dŸC— l )TN"<,=#O'+
G .<,=)'.*9"%!d(8:0-,=(8"
r (
Y
4
‹r (8)'!) Y
G +1.9h.<,=)'.#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8" j !, .h2#+X#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8"ml
j Π7 % ,X#)#"(3.:5+h(8:0-,=(8"ml
' (
' f (
!#"%$
"
*
k f7 ?[,=(32#+J2#+J7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *<( > 9%+1.9%+".%( G p.<. : 2#+G#)R78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+02#+
.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!))'!)T9"(8AF(I,=73+M2#+ K 'r (9%+7Z+1.973+h/Q,!. > .9%!#p+"*+9*"%4!)'2;"%+
4
j Π7 % ,\#)T#"(3.:5+h(8:0-,=(8"ml r (8)'!)!#"%.#(8AK"%+ k_ !)'.(32#4"%+"*.'/1/1+1.%.(8AB+:5+)K99%!'.73+1..%+ 9##73+9%.
(a1 , a2 , a3 , b1 , b2 , b3 ) ∈
‹_ ,=73/#73+"G!#"
#)
]
#
8
7
'.
G
1
/
!
#"
G
9
%
/
'
O
+:0(8) P 2#+ a AB+"%. b
6
V
i = 1, 2, 3
i
i
8 73+1. i
2#!)&9X73+1.\.%!:0:5+9%.X(8)&9%4"(3+#"%.\:^,=)'$K'+)&9 a > a > b
+9 b
i+1
i+2
i+1
i+2
(8)'2;(3/1+1.^.%!)K9^/Q,=73/#7341.b:5K2;#73 q=r ( P > P > P SU!":5+)&9^#) #"(3.:5+
1
2
3
(8:0-,=(8" > ,=73!"%.H.%9%!#p+"7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+J+9"%4!)'2;"%+j Π7 % ,X#)#"(3.%:5+h(8: 7
-,=(8"ml kr (,='/#)D.%+ 9##73+90)Z?[,R2#!)#)'4T2#+#"(3.:5+ "%4!)'2;"%+bj 4 ,!.52#+V#"(3.:5+
>
(8:0-,=(8"ml "
&
(
f
O(n20 )
r (
7
G +1.9t.<,=)'.t#"(3.:5+g(8:0-,=(8" > ,=73!"%. G )'++#9 -,!.t/1!)K9%+)#(8"2#+g78(8)'+
N"<,=#O'+b2C? #)'+5.#e2;(8AK(3.(3!)])'!)a9"(8AK(I,=73+52#+ K /Q,="L2C?[,=#" : .G73+\73+:0:5+ *.j > #)
4
9%+778(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+h.%+"<,=(899"(8AF(I,=7 > !T/1!)K9(3+)'2;"<,=(89#)9"%!V(8:0-,=(8" > !/1!)&9(3+)'2;"<,=(89
#) #"(3.:5+b(8:0-,=(8" Y 2',=)'.X9%!'.X73+1.J/Q,!.X#)'+V/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) > !)'/b7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
2#!)#)'+h7I,0ep!)#)'+M"%4!)'.%+ Y j 4 ,!.H2#+h#"(3.%:5+h(8:0-,=(8"ml r (
:
7
G .%. 2#+J#)#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8"G+9#)o78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+02C? #)'+X.%#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)R)'!)
9"(8AF(I,=73+2#+ K > ,=73!"%.^/1+7I,o+1.952#49%+1/9%4
7I,o2#+ ( : :5+49<,=p+ > +907f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
4
"%+9%!#")'+hj Π7 % ,X#)#"(3.:5+M(8:0-,=(8"mlG/1!:0:5+G(87Z.<+h2#!(89 r (
:
:
7
7
G p.%. 2#+G#)R#"(3.:5+L(8:0-,=(8"M+9)'+G.%. 2#+J,='/#)o78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+\2#+X.#e
2;(8AF(3.(3!) IBEI U HS .SWJK?Z 2#+ K > ,=73!"%. > +)]-,="9(3/#78(3+" > G )'+5p.%. : 2#+\,='/#)a78(8)'+ 7
 J4HU SVZ 2#+
*.r
N"<,=#O'+b2#+^.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!) QS[5
K4 > +9L!)a+#9J,=##78(3$K'+"L73+073+:0:5+
r !(89G,=73!"%.
F #)o#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8"h$K'+73/1!)'$&'+\2#+ G > 2#+L9"(I,=)#N73+1. {a1 , a2 , a3 } +9
#)'+5/1+"9<,=(8)'+549<,=+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+b/1!)'.(32 : "%+073+5.%+ 9##73+9MSU!":54
{b1 , b2 , b3 }
>
-,="0/1+1.0.( .<!:0:5+9%.0+9\/Q,=73/#73+!#" i = 1, 2, 3 73+1.X#78'.0/1!#"9%.0/<O'+:0(8)'. P
8 $K#(H+ (3.9%+)&9 = 4 ,="^9"%!(3.V,=##78(3/Q,=9(3!)'.b/1!)'.<41/#9(8AB+1.^2;D73+:0:5+ *.r !) AB!(89 i
>
$K'+ P ∪ P ∪ P (8)'2;#(89 #)R#"(3.:5+G(8:0-,=(8" > $K#(`.%+"<,b2#!)'/Ge#(3+)o2#49%+1/9%4 Y 7f?[,=7 7
&
')(*,+(
1
-
2
3
TM .6q(
R# # g Z q
NB!"(89O#:5+h"%+9%!#")'+Mj Π7 % ,X#)d#"(3.:5+h(8:0-,=(8"ml Gw
}q~ „J| \‡ ‚ƒ}q~ y B† H‚ „\‡%}
,:
;
:
6
2
~
- !'.G,QAB!)'.h"%41.%!78]2',=)'.G/1+\/%O-,=#(89"%+5#)o/1+"9<,=(8)a)'!:Le#"%+02#+\#"%!e#7 : :5+1.G2#+
2#49%+1/9(3!) 2#+V.%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1.X(8)'2;#(89%.\2',=)'.L73+1.XN"<,=#O'+1.\.<,=)'.J % "<,=:0(32#+!c2',=)'.
73+1.N"<,=#O'+1..<,=)'.9"%!(8:0-,=(8" B- !'. ,=7873!)'. AB!(8" 2',=)'./1+99%+L.%+1/9(3!)R$&'+J.([email protected]!)
/%O'+"%/%O'+
73+1.b49%+)'2;"%+o,= N"<,=#O'+1.$&'+73/1!)'$K'+1. > /1+1.b#"%!e#7 : :5+1.T2#+AF(3+)#)'+)&9
-;4L7 /1!:0#73+9%. - !'.:5!)&9"%+"%!)'.$K'+h73+1.#"%!e#7 : :5+1.2#+G2#49%+1/9(3!)2#+1.H#"(3.:5+1.
>
2#+1.*#"(3.:5+1.-,=(8"%. > 2#+1.#"(3.:5+1.H(8:0-,=(8"%.H+9H2#+1.78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.2#+L.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)2#+
-04L7 /1!:0#73+9%. K4 .%!)&9H9%!'.
- !9"%+G#"%+#AB+G.Q? (8)'.#(8"%+G2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)K92#+M7I,5/1!)'.9"'/9(3!)2#+ g(3+)'.9%F/ T2',=)'.
.%!)\,="9(3/73+.#" 7I, -;4L7 /1!:0#7349'2#+H2#+7I,H"%+1/%O'+"%/<O'+2#+1. -,=(8"%+1.q2C?[,=:0(3. > ,=)'. '.$+ >
(3+)'.%9%K/ L-,="AF(3+)&9 "%412;#(8"%+73+g#"%!e#7 : :5+ $7 7I,"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+2#+g-,=(8"%+*2C?[,=:0(3.
;
Œ
$
2',=)'.#)VN"<,=#O'+ 7 -,="AK(3+)K9*4N&,=73+:5+)&9
"%412;#(8"%+ 7 ,=V#"%!e#7 : :5+.%#(8A!,=)K9 Y
*
•”dŸZ—C˜c™
%
(
$
f
&
"
(
(
Π0
¢
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G +9H2#+ .%!:0:5+9%. a +9 b 2#+ G
, 7 9 7 (87‹#)T9"%!d2#+ G -,!.%.P,=)&9*-,=" a +9 b E
f -;4 7 /1!:0#73+9 8 g(3+)'.9%F/ '.$+T=
>
>
i ^
) ,!2',=#9<,=)&97I,H#"%+#AB+*2#+ g(3+)'.9%F/ > )'!'.,=7873!)'.t:5!)&9"%+"$&'+g73+#"%!e#7 : :5+
-;4 7 /1!:0#73+9X: 2 :5+b.([email protected]!) .%+5"%+1.%9"%+(8)&90,=c/Q,!.X2#+1.LN"<,=#O'+1.\.<,=)'.
Π0 2#+:5+#"%+
9"(I,=)#N73+ 4 !#",=78734NB+")'!9"%+#"%!p. > (87-,=#"<,=(8949%4#"%4sSU4"<,=e#73+*2C? #9(878(3.%+"73+1. H%Ša`aG/K Ž
UVJUT` 2#
+ g(3+)'.9%F/ 0#78#9!9$&'+H2C?[,!2',=#9%+".P,M#"%+#AB+ > :^,=(3.)'!'.)Z? % .<!:0:5+1.-,!.
-,="AB+)&'. - !9%!)'.h$&'+X)'!9"%+\/1!)'.9"'/9(3!)a+1.%9 #78'.h.(8:0#73+\$K'+\/1+7873+02#+ g(3+) 7
.9%K/ J/Q,="/1+*2#+")#(3+"#"%!#A,=(892#+1.q#"%!#"(349%41.#78'.q2;( ^/(873+1. 8 -04L7 /1!:0#7349'2#+H2#+
 HS EHS (87)Z? % ,J-,!.*2#+M"<,=#p!"9
7I,L"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+J2#+ -,=(8"%+1.H2C?[,=:0(3. =-‰ )T)'!9%+"<,\$&Z? JMB
2;(8"%+1/9%+J+)K9"%+L7I,5"%+1/%O'+"%/%O'+02#+L#"(3.:5+1.+9 7I,5"%+1/%O'+"%/%O'+\2#+J-,=(8"%+1. 2C?[,=:0(3. Œ 7‹+1.9
2#!)'/G"%+:^,="%$K-,=e#73+X$K'+L/1+1.2#+ .9"'/9#"%+1..%!(3+)K978(341.
7I,0S !(3. -,=" 2#+1.9O'41 7
:" :5+1. 8 -,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3.q2',=)'. 73+1. N"<,=#O'+1.q2C? "9%4:0(3. \73+1. #"(3.:5+1.t.%!)K9 (8)K9%+"%2;(89%. =
>
+9*-,="7I,X#"%+#AB+L2#+ -04L7 /1!:0#7349'2#+
.#(8AK"%+ •”dŸZ— ™
%
Π
¢
1> + .%!:0:5+9%. +9 2#+
(
l )N"<,=#O'+
G .P,=)'.9"(I,=)#N73+
a b
G > )'!)
6
!, 2 ,!/1+)K9%. +92#+L2#+N"%4
* ( f , 7 9 7 (87‹#)T9"%!d2#+ G -,!.%.P,=)&9*-,=" a +9 b E
"
f
&
(
-;4 7 /1!:0#73+9 $
4 !#"J#) "<,=#+7g2#+^7I,2#4sW')#(89(3!) ;2 c#"%!e#7 : :5+ $7 AB!(8" A6A6
>
6
&
Œ
r ! (89 #)'+(8)'.%9<,=)'/1+H2#+ -,=NB+
7 +1.9/7I,=(8"g$&'+ Π +1.9#)^#"%!e#7 : :5+ -04 ;
'
f
3
>
/1!)'.(3.9<,=)&9J+) m /7I,='.<+1. C , . . . , C .#" n A!,="(I,=e#73+1. x , . . . , x - !'.L,=7873!)'.
1
m
1
n
/1!)'.9"#(8"%+d#)ˆN"<,=#O'+d.<,=)'.b9"(I,=)#N73+
2#!)K9b7I,9<,=(87873+.%+"<,]:^, !"%41+-,="^#)
&
')(
*,+(
Gf
.6d
RTMˆH #F !7 % ) !:5+\+)o7I,b9<,=(87873+\2#+ f +9M/1!)K9%+)-,=)&9L2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.h2;(3.9(8)#N'41. a +9 b 2#+
2#+N"%4 2#+ > 9%+73.$K'+ G /1!)K9(3+)&9g#)^9"%!5-,!.<.<,=)&9-,=" a +9 b .(-+9.<+#73+:5+)&9.(
-_ +1/f(Z#"%!#AB+"<,073+M9O'41!" : :5+ ! +1.49<,=+1.2#+M7I,\/1!)'.9"'/9(3!)
f +1.9.<,=9(3.mSf,=(3.<,=e#73+
2#+ G .%!)&9H"%+#"%41.%+)&9%41+1.W'N#"%+ * 1
f
ti
ai
G(xi )
Y
bi
fi
t0i
a0i
b0i
fi0
vj1
G(Cj )
Y
cj
G(xi ) +9 G(Cj )
8 /Q,!. p
=
uj = x i
Y
dj
vj3
ti
ai
vj2
bi
fi
vj1
t0i
a0i
b0i
cj
fi0
Gf
Y
vj2
vj3
a
e"fTg"h * k
dj
b
9<,=p+1. 2#+M7I,0/1!)'.9"'/9(3!)2#+ G
f
k 4 !#"/<O-,!$&'+MA,="(I,=e#73+
8
=
xi i = 1, . . . , n > !)T2#4sW')#(89*73+N"<,=#O'+ G(xi ) ,QAB+1/
O&#(89.%!:0:5+9%. a > b > t > f > a0 > b0 > t0 > f 0 +9g2;( ,=" 2 9%+1. a t > a f > b t > b f >
i i i
i
i i
i i i i i i
i i i
i
a0i t0i > a0i fi0 > b0i t0i > b0i fi0 > ti fi0 > t0i fi
k 4 !#"q/%O-,!$K'+g/7I,='.%+
8
=
C j = 1, . . . , m > ,1AB+1/ Cj = u1j ∨u2j ∨u3j > \/%O-,!$K'+
= +1.%9#)j 78(899%4"<,=7C2#+
p 8
uj p = 1, 2, 3
{x1 , . . . , xn , x1 , . . . , xn } > !)T2#4sW')#(89*#)
N"<,=#O'+ G(C ) ,QAB+1/h/(8)'$b.%!:0:5+9%. c , d , v 1 , v 2 , v 3 +9.( ,=" 2 9%+1.2#+h.%!"9%+
j
j j j j j
$&'+h/<O-,!$&'+ c , d AB!(89H/%O-,!$K'+ v 1 , v 2 , v 3 j j
j j j
k 4 !#"
2
r
p = 1, 2, 3 > .%( upj = xi ,=73!"%.*!)d, !#9%+h2#+ ,=" 9%+1. vjp fi +9 vjp fi0 (
2
,=/1!)&9"<,=(8"%+ p
,=73!"%.!)R, !#9%+G2#+ ,=" 9%+1. p +9 p 0
uj = x i
! +5N"<,=#O'+
Gf +1.9X!e#9%+)&
vj ti
vj ti
-,="9(8"\2#+57f? #)#(3!)c2;(3. !(8)K9%+b2#+1. G(x ) +9X2#+1.
i
TM .6r
R# # g Z q
:
4 !#"
2
G(Cj ) 2#+V7I,:^,=)#( "%+T.#(8A,=)&9%+
i = 1, . . . , n − 1 > !)6, !#9%+V73+1.5,=" 9%+1.
`‰ )]"<, !#9%+07f?[,=" 2 9%+ 0 4 !#"
bi ai+1 +9 b0i a0i+1
bn c1
j = 1, . . . , m − 1 > !)c, !#9%+
2
=
‰
7f?[,=" 9%+ d c
)J(8)&9"%F2;#(89`73+1.`2#+ .%!:0:5+9%.‹2;(3.%9(8)#N'41. a +9 b > ##(3. !)X, !#9%+
j j+1
2
73+1. ,=" 9%+1. aa > aa0 > bd > bb 1! ,59<,=(87873+L2#+ G +1.9H#)p!7 % ) !:5+L+)7I,\9<,=(87873+ f
m
n
8 +)dSf,=(89H7I,^9<,=1(87873+J2#1+
=C‰ )R/1f!)'.%9<,=9%+J$K'+
Gf +1.9 O(n + m)
Gf )'+J/1!)K9(3+)&9M-,!.
2#+M9"(I,=)#N73+ > +9$K'+ a +9 b .%!)K9H2#+G2#+N"%4 6
‰ )A,X:5!)&9"%+" $K'+G.([email protected]!)2;(3.p.<+h2C? #),=78NB!"(89O#:5+J+)d9%+:0'.!7 % )'!:0(I,=7
p!#"t"%41.%!'2;"%+ Π > ,=73!"%.q!)52;(3..%+2C? #)b,=78NB!"(89O#:5++)09%+:0'.q!7 % )'!:0(I,=7#!#"
"%41.%!'2;"%+ $7 /4 !#"g/1+*Sf,=(8"%+ > (87-.59g2#+:5!)K9"%+"g$KZ? #)'+(8)'.9<,=)'/1+ f 2#+ $7 +1.9g.P,=9(3.mSU,=(3.P,=e#73+ .(+9.%+#73+:5+)&9.( 73+N"<,=#O'+ G /1!)K9(3+)&9*#)V9"%!-,!.%.<,=)&9-,="
f
a +9 b
8P
« ^ S
Za`U `JqU S `TMJS `JFQKZ] JK EH `
‘ EIBU SWZIBU G/IU HNEG0
 J9` `&JI UC
 JH
ZU
f
Gf
a b§
r !(89
‰ )d9"%!#AB+J#)d9"%!o2',=)'.
ξ ∈ {0, 1}n #)dAB+1/9%+#"epF!7341+)$K#(`.<,=9(3.SU,=(89 f
‰
)ˆ.%473+1/9(3!)#)'+ a +9 b 4 !#"
G +)ˆ.%473+1/9(3!)#)-,=)K973+1.^.%!:0:5+9%.V/1!:0:5+d.#(89
i = 1, . . . , n > !)a.<473+1/9(3!)#)'+ ai > bi > a0i > b0i 2#+0#78'. > .( ξi = 1 > !)c.%473+1/9(3!)#)'+
/4
ti , t0i > 9<,=)'2;(3.*$&'+.( ξi = 0 > !)T.%473+1/9(3!)#)'+ fi , fi0 !#" j = 1, . . . , m > ##(3.%$K'+ ξ
.<,=9(3.mSf,=(89 f > ,=b:5!(8)'.7f? #)b2#+1.9"%!(3.78(899%4"<,= 2#+ C +1.9g4N&,=7 1 F> !)'/H(87 + (3.9%+
j
‰
tŒ
p ∈ {1, 2, 3} 9%+7*$&'+ upj = 1 )6.<473+1/9(3!)#)'+,=73!"%. cj > dj +9 vjp 7g+1.90/7I,=(8"
%
$&'+H73+1.g.<!:0:5+9%.g.<473+1/9(3!)#)'41.,=#-,="9(3+)#)'+)&9
#)/ /73+ Z $&#(p/1!)&9(3+)&9 a +9 b ‰ )dAB4"(žW-+L$K'+
B
!
+L.<+#7‹!(8)&9 2#478(3/Q,=9M+1.9$&'+ Z )'+J/1!)&9(3+)K9
Z +1.9 .<,=)'. /1!"%2#+
,='/#)'+b/1!"%2#+V+)&9"%+b#)c.%!:0:5+9\2#+ G(C ) +9J#) .<!:0:5+9X2#+ G(x ) > /Q,="X#)'+
j
i
9%+7873+L/1!"%2#+L.<+"<,=(89 !e#(3+)#)'+J,=" 2 9%+ t v p 8 ! t0 v p = ,QAB+1/ up = x +9 ξ = 1 > !
i j
i
i
i j
j
e#(3+) > . % :549"(3$K'+:5+)&9 > #)'+G,=" 2 9%+ f v p 8 ! f 0 v p = ,1AB+1/ up = x +9 ξ = 0 > ,=)'.
i j
i
i
i j
j
9%!'.73+1./Q,!. > !)d,=#"<,=(89#)'+h/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!)o,1AB+1/h7I,J:549O'F2#+G2#+h.%473+1/9(3!) d_ +1/(
#"%!#AB+ 8N<=
uH41/(8#"%F$&'+:5+)K9 > .##.%!)'.$K'+ G /1!)&9(3+)#)'+c#)9"%! Z ,1AB+1/ a, b ∈
f
B
V (Z) 73!"%. Z /1!)&9(3+)K9 a1 +9 a01 ##(3.%$K'+J/1+X.%!)K973+1.M.%+#73.AB!(3.(8)'.M2#+ a 2'=, )'.
Gf
]
‘ EIBU SWZIBU Z JB&‘ U,ZPRZI U0`S `&EPP Z&UT`5F
¥ Z
© G5JU H Z
81«
EGFH
i = 1, . . . , n Z
Gi 
¥‹¦ ZI U H[ZZG `&EI U
]
Z
i
U
K
Z
X
`
¥
Z
G
J
G
U
[
H
Z
p
`
`
E
I
i
U
E
G
Q
V
S
Z
I
Z
U
i
]
EG QSVZI
ai , a0i , bi , b0i
ti
t0i
ZU 0
fi
fi §
q4
‰ )^49'2;(3+ 2C?[,=e!"%2573+H/Q,!.
7
i = 1 #(3.%$&'+ a, a1 ∈ Z +9$&'+ a1 )Z?[,L$&'+9"%!(3.AB!(
.(8)'. a, t , f > + ,!/9%+:5+)K9g7f? #)2#+ t , f +1.9g2',=)'. Z > +H: 2 :5+ + ,!/9%+:5+)&97f? #)
1 1
1 1
2#+ t0 , f 0 +1.92',=)'. Z ;r ( t +9 f 0 .<!)&92',=)'. Z > ,=73!"%.73+1..%!:0:5+9%. a, a , a0 , t , f 0
1
1 1 1 1
1 1
1
.%!)&9 9%!'.t2',=)'. Z +9 (873.`(8)'2;#(3.%+)&9q#)X9"%!X$K#(F)'+/1!)K9(3+)&9q-,!. b Y #)'+/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/ 7
9(3!) $> +: 2 :5+!)X)Z?[, -,!.`.(8:J#789<,=)'4:5+)&9 t0 +9 f 2',=)'. Z <> !)'/ > -,=" . % :549"(3+ >
1
1
!)b+#9g.%##p.%+"g$&'+ t , t0 .%!)&92',=)'. Z 9<,=)'2;(3.g$K'+ f +9 f 0 )Z? % .%!)K9-,!. ;r ? (87
1 1
1
1
+ (3.9%+ #)T.%!:0:5+9 up ∈ G(C ) 8 ,1AB+1/ 1 ≤ j ≤ m > 1 ≤ p ≤ 3 = 2',=)'. Z +9$K'+M/1+
j
j
.%!:0:5+9q+1.9,!2 ,!/1+)K9 t > ,=73!"%. > ##(3.%$&'+g/1+.%!:0:5+9 up +1.9,='.%.(#,!2 ,!/1+)&9 t0 >
1
1
j
!)dAB!(89M$&'+L73+1. .%!:0:5+9%. a, a , a0 , t , t0 , up .%!)&99%!'.2',=)'. Z +9 (8)'2;#(3.%+)&9M#)
1 1 1 1 j
9"%!V$K#( )'+ /1!)&9(3+)K9*-,!. b Y #)'+/1!)&9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) 1> !)'/ 73+HAB!(3.(8)2#+ t .#" Z $K#(
1
+1.92;( # 4"%+)&9*2#+ a )[email protected]+1.9-,!.2',=)'.7f? #)V2#+1. G(C ) 8 1 ≤ j ≤ m = > 2#!)'//1+HAB!(3.%(8)
1
j
.
RTMˆH #F +1.9 b > +L: 2 :5+ > b0 ∈ Z p‰ )R,02#!)'/L#"%!#AB4 8W6q= p!#" i = 1 B4 #(3.%$K'+ b ∈ Z
1
1
1
[email protected]+ ,!/9%+:5+)K9h7f? #)R2#+ t +9 f +1.9M2',=)'. Z > ##(3.%$K'+ b +1.9M2#+X2#+N"%4 3 > !)
1
1
1
/1!)'/78#9\$&'+ a +1.9J2',=)'. Z > +5: 2 :5+ > !)c/1!)'/78#9\$&'+ b +1.9J2',=)'. Z 4 !#"
2
2
i = 2 > 7I,X#"%+#AB+h+1.9*+1.%.<+)&9(3+7873+:5+)&9 (32#+)&9(3$K'+L,=T/Q,!. i = 1 > +9-,="*"%41/#""%+)'/1+
d_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8W6q=
!)-,="AF(3+)&9
i=n
8«
EG/H
]
j = 1, . . . , m Z
‘ EIBU SWZIBU
]
c j dj
Z&U;G/I `EP PRZU Z JB‘&U,ZPRZI UJHP S
vj1 , vj2 , vj3 §
‰ )\49'2;(3+2C?[,=e!"%2J73+/Q,!.
$>
: 8W6q= 0
j = 1 ?[,=#" .
> bn ∈ Z +9‹#)\.%!:0:5+9 + ,!/9%+:5+)&9
F
>
-,=":0( t0 , f 0 +1.9*2',=)'. Z !)'/ > ##(3.%$K'+ b0 +1.9*2#+M2#+N"%4 3 > c +1.92',=)'. Z 4 ,="
1
n n
n
/1!)'.%41$K'+)&9 > + ,!/9%+:5+)K9#)0.%!:0:5+9-,=":0( v 1 , v 2 , v 3 +1.%9t2',=)'. Z > -,="+ +:0#73+ >
1 1 1
.<,=)'.Gp+"9%+52#+5NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > v 1 ! +0AB!(3.(8)a2#+ v 1 2',=)'. Z $&#(+1.9J2;( # 4"%+)K9L2#+ c
1
1
1
)'+Lp+#9 -,!. 2 9"%+L#).%!:0:5+9M2#+ G(x ) 8 1 ≤ i ≤ n = > /Q,=" /1+L.<+"<,=(89M,=73!"%. t 8 !
i
=t‰ " !)c.P,=(89X2C?[,=#" : . 8W6q= $&'+^73+1.Xi2#+ AB!(3.(8)'.J2#+
8
=
fi
ti ! fi 2',=)'. Z .%!)K9
>
2#+1.h.%!:0:5+9%.h2#+ G(x ) _! +\.%!:0:5+9 t 8 ! f = ,=#"<,=(89L,=73!"%.M9"%!(3.MAB!(3.(8)'.h2',=)'.
i
i
Y
o i (8)-,=73+:5+)K9 7f?[,=#9"%+^AB!(3.(8)62#+ 1
Z #)'+b/1!)K9"<,!2;(3/9(3!) ,1AB+1/[email protected]<,=9\2#+^9"%!
u1
>
2',=)'. Z +1.%9 d > +9h!)],V2#4:5!)&9"%4 8Wq= p!#" j = 1 4 #(3.%$&'+ d +1.%9M2#+X2#+N"%4 4
1
1
[email protected]+ ,!/9%+:5+)K9G7f? #)2#+ v 1 , v 2 , v 3 +1.9h2',=)'. Z > !)]/1!)'.9<,=9%+0$K'+ c +1.9h2',=)'.
2
1 1 1
1!
Z ,5#"%+#AB+L+1.9H+1.<.%+)&9(3+7873+:5+)K9(32#+)K9(3$&'+Lp!#" j = 2 > +9H-,="H"%41/#""%+)'/1+X!)
d_ +1/(Z#"%!#AB+ 8Wq=
-,="AF(3+)&9
j=m
,="9(8"2#+ Z > !)5/1!)'.9"#(89:^,=(8)&9%+)-,=)K9#)0AB+1/9%+#"eF!7341+) ξ /1!:0:5+H.#(89 4 !#"
i = 1, . . . , n > .( Z /1!)K9(3+)&9 ti +9 t0i > !)R.%+ ξi = 1 .( Z /1!)&9(3+)&9 fi +9
!
T
)
p.<+ ξ = 0 1> ?[,=#" : . 8W6q= > /1+7I,5,Xe#(3+)#).%+)'. 0
fi
i
r !(89
8
=
i> ?[,=#" : . 8Wq= +9T.<,=)'.V+"9%+R2#+
Cj 1 ≤ j ≤ m #)'+o/7I,='.%+o2#+ f
r ( 1
NB4)'4"<,=78(89%4 > !)Vp+#9g.##p.<+"$K'+ v 1 +1.9g2',=)'. Z F
uj = xi ,1AB+1/ i ∈ {1, .., n} >
j
,=73!"%.h7I,/1!)'.%9"'/9(3!)c2#+ G +)K9"<,3)'+^$K'+\)#( f )#( f 0 )'+0.<!)&9L2',=)'. Z _> !)'/ >
i
f
i
B>
ti +9 t0i .<!)&9h2',=)'. Z > +92#!)'/ ξi = 1 +9M7I,b/7I,='.%+ Cj +1.%9.<,=9(3.SU,=(89%+J-,=" xi +
: 2 :5+ > .( u1 = x ,QAB+1/ i ∈ {1, .., n} > ,=73!"%.7I,J/1!)'.9"'/9(3!)2#+ G +)&9"<,3)'+h$K'+
i
f
j
)#( t )#( t0 )'+H.%!)&9g2',=)'. Z > !)'/ > f +9 f 0 .%!)&9g2',=)'. Z > 2#!)'/ ξ = 0 +97I,h/7I,='.<+
i
i
i
i
i
5o (8)-,=73+:5+)&9
+1.9.<,=9(3.mSf,=(89%+M-,="
.P,=9(3.mSU,=(89 Cj
> ξ
xi
f
2
! , 0
- 4L7 /1!:0#7349'2#+62#+
7
Π +)K9"<,3)'+ 2;(8"%+1/9%+:5+)K9]/1+7873+c2#+c#78'.(3+#"%.#"%
e#7 : :5+1. 5- !'.!#""(3!)'.p+#9 7,2 9"%+h41/"(8"%+M#)#"%!e#7 : :5+hNB4)'4"(3$K'+h2#+M2#49%+1/9(3!)
2#+ .%!'. 7 N"<,=#O'+1.g(8)'2;#(89%.S !":541.g2#+H/78(3$K'+1.+9g2#+H/<O'+:0(8)'.73+1."%+78(I,=)&9 > :^,=(3.g/1+7I,
.%+"<,=(892C? #)5SU!":^,=78(3.:5+ #)b+^73!#"%2 /- !'.#"%4sSU4"%!)'.)'!'."%+1.9"%+(8)'2;"%+ (3/(,= #"%!e#7 : :5+1.+"9(8)'+)&9%.p!#")'!9"%+L49'2#+ - !'. +1.4"%!)'./1!)&A,=(8)'/"%+J73+L73+1/9%+#"
"%412;#(8"%+
2;(8AB+"%.
$K'+ > p!#"*2#+1.'.<,=NB+1.S #9#"%. > 73+ #"%!e#7 : :5+ Π +1.9,!.<.%+SU,!/(873+
#"%!e#7 : :5+1. 4
•”RŸC— &%
§
§
*
(
$
(
_f $
(
I  BH[E QK$PRZa`p`GFS $JIBUT`0`&EI U gŽm‘ EP B
 K?ZUT`\©
I¤H[PJ  Y5Z
‘ EI U,ZIBJIBUiZ qJ&‘&U,ZPRZI U¥ Z G U HS JIF¤KZ`
G
§
‘ EI U SWZI U Ž,STK G/I^ HaS `aPRZ
Za`J‘&S
"
G
I¤H[JP Y5Z
G
‘ EI U,ZIBJIBUiZ qJ&‘&U,ZPRZI U¥ ZG
U HS JIF¤KZ`
§
TM *
*
*
*
(
K4
$
f
(
f
(
$
(
f
§
(
f
$
§
§
(
(
.
R# # g Z q
U Ž S K G/I^BHaS `aPRZ S P JS H
‘ EI U,ZIBJI U"ZqJB‘&U,ZPRZIBU¥FZG nU HSWJIK¤K?Za`
G
§
U Ž S K G/^
I BHaS `aPR
Z JSTH ‘ EI U,ZIBJI U"Z qJB‘&U,ZPRZIBU  GJU H Z U HS JIF¤KZ`
G
§
U Ž S K K?Z K STI sZ Ž ¤HNsJ  Y0
Z ¥‹¦ G/I Z `G5%Q ¥S <S `S EI¥ Z
K4
‘ EI U,ZIBJI U"Z qJB‘&U,ZPRZIBU  GJU H Z U HS JF
I ¤KZ`
§
G
U Ž,STKLKZ K STI sZ Ž¤HNPJ BY^
Z ¥`¦ G/I Z `G5%Q ¥S <S `S EI QS JHU SWZ^¥ Z
‘ EI U SVZI
G
I¤HNJPBYZ
‘ EI U SVZI
G
I¤ HNJPB YZ
‘ EI U SVZI
G
I¤ HNJPB YZ
‘ EI U SWZI
G
4 !#"/<O-,!/#)52#+1.q/(8)'$h#"%!e#7 : 5
: +1. > !)\A!,.##.%+"t$&'[email protected]!)0/1!)#)-,39
#)V,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M2#+ 2#41/(3.%(3!)V+)V9%+:0'.gp!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 F4 #(3. > !)bA!,L+)b"%412;#(8"%+!7 % 7
)'!:0(I,=73+:5+)&9H73+M#"%!e#7 : :5+J/1!)'.(32#4"%4L,=T#"%!e#7 : :5+ Π > /1+h$K#(C#"%!#AB+"<,\73+h9O'41 7
‰ )o"<,=#p+7873+\$K'+J-,="
" : :5+ Cr !(89h2#!)'/ (G, a, b) #)'+X(8)'.9<,=)'/1+\2;o#"%!e#7 : :5+ Π C
2#4sW')#(89(3!)
+1.9.<,=)'.9"(I,=)#N73+ $K'+
+9
.%!)K9)'!)d,!2 ,!/1+)K9%. +92#+L2#+N"%4 6
&
')(
*,+(
-
>
G
a2
b
G
a4
a1
a
a0
a
a3
eifTg"h *Aj k
a5
b4
b0
b2
b1
b
a00
b00
G +9 G0 > "%412;'/9(3!)2#+ Π
b5
b3
7I,\"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+L2#+G#"(3.:5+1.
,="9(8"52#+ G > !)D/1!)'.9"#(89073+VN"<,=#O'+ G0 ,=(8)'.( 8 AB!(8"\W'N#"%+ *Ajq=VY !)
"%+:0#7I,!/1+G73+J.%!:0:5+9 a -,="73+LN"<,=#O'+J,1AB+1/J/(8)'$.%!:0:5+9%. a > a > a > a >
3
4
2
`‰ )a"%+78(3+ 1 2 7f? #)c
2#+1.
a5 +9L/(8)'$,=" 9%+1. a1 a2 > a1 a3 > a2 a3 > a2 a4 > a3 a5
a4
AB!(3.(8)'.t2#+ a +9 a 7f?[,=#9"%+gAB!(3.(8)\2#+ a !‰ )X"%+:0#7I,!/1+*2#+: 2 :5+g73+g.%!:0:5+9
5
2
b -,="*73+MN"<,=#O'+J,1AB+1/h/(8)'$V.%!:0:5+9%. b1 > b2 > b3 > b4 > b5 +9/(8)'$V,=" 9%+1. b1 b2 >
p‰
b1 b3 > b2 b3 > b2 b4 > b3 b5 )d"%+78(3+ b4 7f? #)2#+1.AB!(3.%(8)'. 2#+ b +9 b5 7f?[,=#9"%+
p
‰
AB!(3.(8)R2#+ b )d"%+78(3+ a +9 b _ !:0:5+ G +1.9.<,=)'.*9"(I,=)#N73+ > !)dAB!(89H$K'+
1
1
:
:
G0 .%. 2#+H#)b#"(3.%:5+ .(p+9g.<+#73+:5+)&9*.( G .%. 2#+#)V9"%!V-,!.%.<,=)&9g-,="
‹Œ
:
a +9 b 7+1.9X+)c!#9"%+^4AF(32#+)&9\$K'+ G0 )'+^p.<. 2#+5$K'+52#+ 9"(I,=)#N73+1.
> !)'/ .(;[email protected]!)^.<,=(89q2#49%+1/9%+"#)0#"(3.:5+*+)09%+:0'.p!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 ,=73!"%.q!)5.<,=(89
>
>
"%41.%!'2;"%+ P i +)9%+:0'.!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 6 ,="9(8"b2#+ G > !) /1!)'.9"#(89V73+TN"<,=#O'+ G0 /1!:0:5+R/( 7 2#+1.%.'. 4 #(3.b!)
/1!)'.9"#(89*OK#(89N"<,=#O'+1.H,= (878(I,=(8"%+1. G(i, j, k) ,QAB+1/ (i, j, k) ∈ {0, 1}3 2#+M7I,
:^,=)#( : "%+H.%#(8A!,=)K9%+ Y .%+73!)^$K'+ i = 1 ! i = 0 > !)^.%#ep2;(8AF(3.%+*!5)'!)57f?[,=" 2 9%+
> +J: 2 :5+ .%+73!)R$K'+
a a +)78#(q, !#9<,=)K9h#)R.<!:0:5+9
j = 1 ! j = 0
>
2 4
.6
RTMˆH #F p!#"\7f?[,=" 2 9%+ a a > +V: 2 :5+ > .%+73!) $&'+ k = 1 ! k = 0 p!#"\7f?[,=" 2 9%+
‰ ) /1!)'.39<,=9%5+V,=73!"%.X$K'+
:
a1 b1
G .%. 2#+5#)a9"%!a-,!.<.<,=)&9X-,=" a +9 b .%(
73+^N"<,=#O'+!e#9%+)& -,="X"%4#)#(3!)62;(3. !(8)K9%+b2#+1. G
p.%.<. : 2#+5#)c#"(3.:5+
i,j,k
(8:0-,=(8"
,="9(8"q2#+ G > !)\/1!)'.9"#(89t73+1. &
O #(89qN"<,=#O'+1.,= (878(I,=(8"%+1. G(i, j, k) /1!:0:5+
7
B
‰
/( 2#+1.%.'.
)\B
A 4"(žW-+*,=73!"%.q$&'+ G p
.<. : 2#+#)\9"%!\-,!.%.<,=)K9t-,=" a +9 b .(#+9
.%+#73+:5+)&9H.%( 73+N"<,=#O'+M!e#9%+)&T-,=""%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)&9%+h2#+1. G
p.<.%. : 2#+
i,j,k
#)#"(3.:5+h-,=(8"
vab
vad
a0
vac
a
a00
b00 G
b0
b
vda
vdb
vca
vdc
vcd
vbd
vcb
vbc
vba
e"fTgih_*A*k uH412;'/9(3!)o2#+
Π
7I,^"%+1/%O'+"%/<O'+\2#+L78(8)'+ 7 N"<,=#O'+1.h2#+J.#ep2;(8AF(3.(3!)o2#+
K4
1 -,="9(8"2#+
2 +h7I,\:^,=)#( : "%+G.%#(8A!,=)K9%+ 8 AB!(8"
G > ! )/1!)'.9"#(89H#)TN"<,=#O'+ G0 #
= Y !) + )#7 : AB+R73+1.b.%!:0:5+9%.
7
W'N#"%+ *A*q
a +9 b +9b!), !#9%+2#! Q+o.%!:
p
‰
), !#9%+
:5+9%. v > v > v > v > v > v > v > v > v > v > v +9 v
ac
ca
ab
ad
ba
bc
bd
cb
cd
da
db
dc
2#+1.G,=" 2 9%+1.G2#+\.%!"9%+\$&'+\/%O-,!$K'+0+)'.%+:Je#73+ {v , v , v } > {v , v , v } >
ab ac ad
ba bc bd
‰ ), !#9%+
*
73+1.V,=" 2 9%+1.
{vca , vcb , vcd } +9 {vda , vdb , vdc } .%!(89V#)ˆ9"(I,=)#N73+
#
‰
vab vba > vdc vcd > vbd vdb +9 vbc vcb )b"%+78(3+ vad 7f? #)T2#+1.gAB!(3.(8)'.2#+ a 2',=)'.
‰
K
G > +9 vac 7f?[,=#9"%+HAB!(3.(8)b2#+ a 2',=)'. G )b"%+78(3+ vda 7f? #)V2#+1.AB!(3.(8)'.g2#+
‰
:
b 2',=)'. G +9 vca 7f?[,=#9"%+hAB!(3.%(8)2#+ b 2',=)'. G )TAB4"(žW-+G$K'+ G p.%. 2#+
7
#)T9"%!T-,!.%.<,=)&9*-,=" a +9 b .(C+9*.%+#73+:5+)&9 .( G0 /1!)&9(3+)&9 73+78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+
2C? #)'+L.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)Te#(8-,="9(3+G2#+
K4
,="9(8"52#+ G > !) /1!)'.9"#(89\#)6N"<,=#O'+ G0 /1!:0:5+V/( 7 2#+1.<.'. L4 #(3.0!)
/1!)'.9"#(89X$K-,=9"%+5N"<,=#O'+1.\,= (878(I,=(8"%+1. G(i, j) ,QAB+1/ (i, j) ∈ {0, 1}2 2#+57I,
:^,=)#( : "%+H.#(8A,=)&9%+ Y .%+73!)^$K'+ i = 1 ! i = 0 > !)^.#e2;(8AK(3.<+!5)'!)57f?[,=" 2 9%+
_> +J: 2 :5+0.%+73!)R$K'+
vad a0 +)o78#(t, !#9<,=)&9h#)].%!:0:5+9
j = 1 ! j = 0
2
‰
:
p!#"J7f?[,=" 9%+ v a00
)a/1!)'.9<,=9%+b,=73!"%.X$K'+ G .%. 2#+0#)9"%!c-,!.%.<,=)K9
j ac
TH #F D .
gHH %
-,=" a +9 b .(+9*.%+#73+:5+)&9.(p73+N"<,=#O'+M!e#9%+)&T-,=""%4#)#(3!)2;(3. !(8)&9%+M2#+1.
:
7
Gi,j .%.%. 2#+ #)d78(8)'+ N"<,=#O'+L2#+h.#e2;(8AK(3.%(3!)e#(8-,="9(3+G2#+ K4
2
Gw
}q†
:
Xz{%~
~-zX† }
}
† :
‡:*|z
6
{
6
:
- !'.J!#AB!)'.L"%41.#:5+"X73+1.G"%41.%#789<,=9%.X2#+b/1+^/<O-,=#(89"%+V2',=)'.J73+b9<,=e#73+Q,= *
_ O ,!$&'+J78(8N)'+\/1!""%+1.p!)'2
#)#"%!e#7 : :5+\2#+X2#49%+1/9(3!)$&'[email protected]!)],=)-,=7 % .%+X2',=)'.
#)'+/7I,!.%.%+T2#+TN"<,=#O'+1.V/1!""%+1.!)'2',=)&9
#)'+/1!73!)#)'+ 4 !#"^9"%!(3.^#"%!e#7 : :5+1.
%
2#+]2#49%+1/9(3!)€2',=)'.73+1.N"<,=#O'+1..<,=)'.T "<,=:0(32#+ 8 .(8N)-,=7341.d-,="Vj E l = > )'!'.T)'+
.%!:0:5+1.L-,!.J-,="AB+)&'.
2#49%+":0(8)'+"\2#+b/1!:0#73+ (89%4 r ()'!'.J2#+AF(3!)'.L"(3.<$&'+"
#)'+h/1!) +1/9#"%+ > )'!'.H2;(8"(3!)'.H$K'+h/1+1.#"%!e#7 : :5+1.H!)&9H7I,X: 2 :5+G/1!:0#73+ (89%4L$&'+
73+M#"%!e#7 : :5+L2#+M7I,02#49%+1/9(3!)R2#+1.*9"%!'.*(8:0-,=(8"%. 8 /1!) +1/9#"%+G+d,1AB+)K9#"%+'.%+ =
"<,=#O'+1.
NB4)'4"<,= 4 "(3.:5+G! 4 % "<,=:0(32#+
4 % "<,=:0(32#+
n9
r
h *0k_
"<,=#O'+1.H.<,=)'.
9"%!(8:0-,=(8"
n5
1
n5
n20
E
E
E
'A669+
-04_
-0
4 _
-0
4 _
-0
4 _
-0
4 _
K4
K
4 "(3.:5+h(84:0-,=(8"
4 "(3.:5+h-,=(8"
"<,=#O'+1.H.P,=)'.
% "<,=:0(32#+
n5
4 "(3.:5+
! r/- !
n5
1
n5
n20
n20
n20
n11
!:0#73+ (89%4L2#+L2;(8AB+"%.*#"%!e#7 : :5+1. 2#+h2#49%+1/9(3!)
" !/1+
)'.b,=78NB!"(89O#:5+1.2#+2#49%+1/9(3!) > )'!'.^!#AB!)'.^2#!)#)'+"V2#+1.V,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+1.2#+M"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+h!#"*73+1./7I,!.%.<+1.*2#+hN"<,=#O'+1.49'2;(341+1.H2',=)'.73+1.*/%O-, 7
#(89"%+1.*#"%41/1412#+)&9%. Y
•”dŸZ— #
' '
f ( r (C73+hN"<,=#O'+L+1.92C? "9%4:0(3. Y
#" $
"
*
k
l )TN"<,=#O'+ G
(
*
f,-r (8)'!) >
L
4 "(žW-+"d$&'+ G )'+p.%. : 2#+-,!.d2C?[,=)&9(89"%!€73!)#N
f7 ?[,=(32#+2#+o7f?[,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ *A6 + 41/#9%4G.#" G k
* 1
4"(žW-+"H$&'+ G +1.92#+ +"NB+
7f?[,=(32#+G2#+M7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ k
%
4"(žW-+"L$&'+ G +1.9L.<,=)'.G#"(3.:5+5+9L.<,=)'.L "<,=:0(32#+
f7 ?[,=(32#+^2#+07f?[,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ *Ad
kr ( 9%!#9%+1. 73+1. AB4"(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'.h!)&9M2#!)#)'4 * f "%+9%!#")'+" * f,Cr (8)'!) "%+ 7
>
>
9%!#")'+" L
&
"
(
f
O(n9 )
.9
RTMˆH #F Œ'
-,!.%(8:5+)&94AK(32#+)K9%+ K
7 Sf,=#9 '.9%+)'!9%+"g$&'+H73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.g2#+ +"NB+
)[email protected]!)K9-,!.2#+o % "<,=:0(32#+ > !)'/ > .( G +1.92#+ +"NB+ > 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *Ad AB4" (žW-+
.(8:0#73+:5+)K9 $K'+ G +1.9.<,=)'.#"(3.:5+ 2
&
')(*,+(
-
! ?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+2#+H"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.<,=)'/1+2#+1.N"<,=#O'+1.2C? "9%4:0(3.+":5+94N&,=73+:5+)K9
2#+\/1!73!"(3+"h73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.G2C? "9%4:0(3.h+)R9%+:0'.M!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 C‰ )]4)K#: : "%+\9%!#9%+1.
73+1.‹-,=(8"%+1.`2C?[,=:0(3. 2#+ G > $&'[email protected]!)X/1!)&9"<,!/9%+ 8 "<,=#p+73!)'[email protected]!)L.<,=(89`AB4"(žW-+"`$KZ? #)'+
-,=(8"%+X2#+G.%!:0:5+9%.2C? #)N"<,=#O'+J2#+ +"NB+L+1.%9H#)'+G-,=(8"%+J2C?[,=:0(3. = 4 !#"M/%O-,!$K'+
-,=(8"%+ > !)XAB4"(žW-+g$K'+73+N"<,=#O'+!e#9%+)&0+1.9 e#(3+)02C? "9%4:0(3. 8 N"!/1+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+
r (G/[email protected]+1.973+R/Q,!. !) "%+1/1!:0:5+)'/1+.%#"V73+RN"<,=#O'+]/1!)K9"<,!/9%4 '$KZ?
/( 7 2#+1.%.%'. =
>
!e#9%+)#(8"\#)'+V/78(3$&'+ 4 ,="X73+b9O'41!" : :5+ jA6 > !)6.<,=(89J$K'+b/1+7I,SU!)'/9(3!)#)'+"<, #(8"%+ > (87SU,='2;"<,,=#+73+" n3 SU!(3.07f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A69 Y /Q,="^2',=)'.5#) N"<,=#O'+
n
.%!:0:5+9%. > (87 % ,d,= #(8"%+ O(n2 ) -,=(8"%+1.
9%+1.9%+" > +9X,= #(8"%+ > (87SU,='2;"<,SU,=(8"%+ n
/1!)K9"<,!/9(3!)'.H,1A,=)&[email protected]!e#9%+)#(8"#)'+M/78(3$&'+ /! ,X/1!:0#73+ (89%42#+M/1+9*,=78NB!"(89O#:5+h+1.9
W')-,=73+:5+)K9 O(n12 ) > /1+ $K#(p+1.%9*,!.<.%+ :5412;(3F/"%+-,=""<,=#p!"9
7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ j
$K#(Z+1.92#+G/1!:0#73+ (89%4
2
O(n m)
•a”dŸC— –
l )TN"<,=#O'+
G
r (Z73+MN"<,=#O'+G+1.9 2C? "9%+:0(3.*-,=(8" Y
' (
' f (
!#"%$
*
"
*
f, r (8)'!) >
L
k 7f?[,=(32#+h2#+7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A69 AB+"(žW-+"$K'+
-r (9%+7C+1.9
G +1.9*2C? "9%4:0(3.
>
L
73+h/Q,!.*!#"%.#(8AK"%+ > .(8)'!).9%!#+"H+9*"%4p!)'2;"%+ k 7f?[,=(32#+\2#+J7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A6 AB4"(žW-+"h$K'+
G +1.9M.<,=)'.#"(3.:5+X(8:0-,=(8"
r (C9%+7‹+1.9*73+h/Q,!. "%+9%!#")'+" * f .(8)'!) .9%!#+"+9"%4!)'2;"%+ L
>
>
f & " (
20 O(n )
Œ'
7 Sf,=#9g.(8:0#73+:5+)K9*"%+:^,="%$&'+"*$K'+H73+1.gN"<,=#O'+1.*2C? " 9%4:0(3.g)'+H. 7
. : 2#+)K9\-,!.X2#+b9"%!6(8:0-,=(8" > /1!)'2;(89(3!) "%+1$K#(3.%+bp!#"X!#AB!(8"\+ 14 /#9%+"\7f?[,=78NB 7
"(89O#:5+ *A6
2
r (q73+1.h/1!) +1/9#"%+1.G2#+ i AB+"%+99L+9hu +1+12 8 /1!) +1/9#"%+ .6 +9 . -,=NB+ F(=
>
2#+A,=(3+)&9 2 9"%+#"%!#AB41+1. > ,=73!"%. /1+7I,(8:0#78(3$K'+"<,=(89`[email protected]+ (3.9%+)'/1+2C? #)\,=78NB!"(89O#:5+-,="
/1!)K9"<,!/9(3!)2#+M-,=(8"%+1.H2C?[,=:0(3.p!#"/1!73!"(3+"73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.*-,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K9 /1!)K9"<,!/ 7
9(873+1. ;Œ 7pSU,=#9e#(3+)T)'!9%+"$K'+/1+ Sf,=(89 > /1+"9%+1.#7I,='.(8e#73+ > )Z?[,X"(3+)[email protected](32#+)K9: 2 :5+
#)'+HS !(3.g/1!)#)&7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+M2#+"%+1/<O'+"%/%O'+h2C? #)'+ -,=(8"%+M2C?[,=:0(3.2',=)'.g73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.
2#+ g+"NB+ tr (7I,d/1!) +1/9#"%+ . +1.9JAK"<,=(3+ > ,=73!"%.L73+1.LN"<,=#O'+1.J2C? "9%4:0(3.X-,=(8"%.
.%!)K9d+ ,!/9%+:5+)&9d73+1.N"<,=#O'+1.-,="mSf,=(89%+:5+)&9/1!)K9"<,!/9(873+1. > ,=)'./1+]/Q,!. > 9%!#9
N"<,=#O'+*2C? "9%4:0(3.q-,=(8"2;( # 4"%+)&92C? #)'+*/78(3$K'+p.%. : 2#+#)'+-,=(8"%+*2C?[,=:0(3.q2#!)K97I,
/1!)K9"<,!/9(3!)X"%+12#!)#)'+#)LN"<,=#O'+2C? "9%4:0(3.`-,=(8" 8 2C?[,=#" : .`7I,/1!) +1/9#"%+ .6q=$! +
#"(8)'/(8+2#+*7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ +1.92#!)'/.(8:0#73+ Y !#"9%!#9%+*-,=(8"%+2C?[,=:0(3.2;5N"<,=#O'+ >
AB4"(žW-+"g$&'+.P,h/1!)&9"<,!/9(3!)2#!)#)'+
)'!#AB+Q,=V#)5N"<,=#O'+H-,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K9g/1!)K9"<,!/ 7
‹
r
i
9(873+
(q73+1.h/1!) +1/9#"%+1.G2#+\uH+1+12o+9 AB+"%+99L.<!)&9hAF"<,=(3+1. > /1+99%+\AB4"(žW-/Q,=9(3!)a+1.9
.%.(8e#73+N" !/1+ 7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *A6j9l )'+S !(3. 7I,H-,=(8"%+g9"%!#AB41+ > "%+1/1!:0:5+)'/1+".#"
73+N"<,=#O'+/1!)K9"<,!/9%4 '.<$&Z? !e#9%+)#(8"`#)'+g/78(3$&'+ 9 J#(8"%+ > (87BSf,=#9 O(n3 )×O(n20 )
&
')(*,+(
-
`gC h
5
5
.j
49<,=p+1. > /1+L$&#(Z2#!)#)'+h#)'+L/1!:0#73+ (89%4G2#+ O(n23 ) 'i )"%41.#:54 Y
•”dŸZ— 'Ÿ
(
l )TN"<,=#O'+G2C? " 9%4:0(3.-,=(8" G f
l
'
(
) +^/1!73!"<,=9(3!) 2#+ G > $K#(+1.9X!#9(8:^,=73+V.%(73+1.X/1!) +1/9#"%+1. .6
'
+9 . .%!)K
9 AF"<,=(3+1. #" $ * " !(8"/( 7 2#+1.%.'. "
f
&
(
23 ' O(n )
!(87 #)'+ :5!9(8A,=9(3!) .###734:5+)&9<,=(8"%+ˆp!#" /%O'+"%/<O'+"c#)'+ #"%+#AB+
7I,
1/ !) +1/9#"%+R2#+ i AB+"%+99T+9VuH+1+12 > /Q,="$K'+7873+$K'+d.%!(89V/1+99%+d#"%+#AB+ > ,=78NB!"(89O 7
:0(3$&'+! )'!) > !) .<,=(8952#4 [email protected]+7873+Tp+":5+99"<,a2#+/1!73!"(3+"59%!'.^73+1.5N"<,=#O'+1.
-,="mSU,=(89%+:5+)K95/1!)&9"<,!/9(873+1.5+)69%+:0'.Xp!7 % )'!:0(I,=7 ‰ )6p+#9X9%!#9%+sS !(3.0+1.%p4"%+" >
/1!:0:5+^!#"J73+1.JN"<,=#O'+1.\2C? "9%4:0(3. > #)'+b#"%+#AB+2#!)#)-,=)&9\#)6,=78NB!"(89O#:5+2#+
/1!73!"<,=9(3!)d#78'.+ ^/Q,!/1+ ‰ )+#9X,='.%.(2#!)#)'+"L#) ,=78NB!"(89O#:5+V2#+0"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+b2#+1.LN"<,=#O'+1.Le#( 7
-,="9(3.<,=)'. Y
•”dŸZ— ' '
f ( r (C73+hN"<,=#O'+L+1.9*e#(8-,="9(3.<,=) Y #" $
&
')(
Gw£v
"
*
k
l )TN"<,=#O'+ G
(
fV-r (8)'!) >
*
L
4"(žW-+"H$&'+ G +1.92#+ +"NB+
7f?[,=(32#+G2#+M7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ * 1
k
4"(žW-+"H$&'+ G +1.9.<,=)'.*#"(3.:5+G73!)#N
7f?[,=(32#+G2#+h7f?[,=78NB!"(89O#:5+ *Ar
k
:
4"(žW-+"‹$&'+ G )'+q.%. 2#+t)#(B2#!#e#73+2;(I,=:^,=)K9‹)#( L(K \e) +)G49'2;(I,=)&9
3,3
. % .9%4:^,=9(3$K'+:5+)&9H9%!'.73+1. d$7 ##73+9%.H2#+G.<!:0:5+9%.2#+ G kr ( 9%!#9%+1. 73+1. AB4"(žW-/Q,=9(3!)'.h!)&9M2#!)#)'4 * f "%+9%!#")'+" * f,Cr (8)'!) "%+ 7
>
>
9%!#")'+" L
"
*,+(
&
O(n9 )
_ 7I,=(8" -
f
(
X}q~
1
{
6
2
J~
:
:
}t|6 }q~
13
! ,b$&'+1.9(3!)o!#AB+"9%+X7I,5#78'.4AF(32#+)&9%+ 8 )'!)o-,!. "%41.%!'2;"%+ :^,=(3. .%+Lp 7
>
=
.%+" 1+ .9/1+7873+G2#+h7I,X"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.<.<,=)'/1+L2#+1.*N"<,=#O'+1..<,=)'.*9"%!T(8:0-,=(8" B- !9%!)'.H$&'+
_ !);S !"9( _ !")K'4 !73. G,=pF!"+9 BQAF(h!)&9H"%41.%!78T#)T#"%!e#7 : :5+G.(8:0(87I,=(8"%+ Y
>
>
7I,"%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+R2#+1.VN"<,=#O'+1.T.<,=)'.V9"%! -,=(8" 'A6d > 6r9+, no,=(3.b2#+R)'!:Le#"%+ ,=#9"%+1.*#"%!e#7 : :5+1. 2#+:5+#"%+)K9 +!#!#"-
!
" #
#
"-
! +1.d.<+1/9(3!)'.d#"%41/1412#+)K9%+1.R.<+:Le#73+)&9R(8)'2;(3$K'+"$K'+]7I, "%+1/1!)#)-,=(3.%.P,=)'/1+a2#+1.
N"<,=#O'+1.a2C? "9%4:0(3.a+1.9#78'.SU,!/(873+ $&'+ /1+7873+ˆ2#+1.]N"<,=#O'+1.c2#+ g+"NB+ !#9
.*
RTMˆH #F 2C?[,=e!"%2 > 7f? (8)&9%+"%2;(3/9(3!).(8:J#789<,=)'41+02#+1.H#"(3.:5+1.M+9M2#+1. % "<,=:0(32#+1.SU,!/(878(89%+J73+#"
2#49%+1/9(3!) ! ,V.%+1/9(3!)2#+J7f?[,="9(3/73+02